Homesteading the harsh, unforgiving landscape of a remote island might not be for everyone, but a group of twelve is ready for the challenge of a lifetime.
One island.
They think they’re miles away from anyone but each other. So when the group discover the body of a stranger, they begin to wonder who else is on the island.
How many will survive?
Discovering there’s a killer in their midst and no way to call for help, everyone is desperate to find a way home. But what are they willing to do to get there?
Thank you to Avon books for an advanced copy of this book.
Right! The premise is great, one of those survival programmes where a group is sent to the wilderness and basically has to survive. Absolutely loved it.
The writing is quick paced, and I loved how it shifted at pace, so you weren't bored hearing about people struggling.
The problem I had with this book is the characters,
Ava suffers from MS and is struggling to work in a school, yet is well enough to go to an abandoned Arctic Island for a year, even I had to work had to believe that plot point, this paired with her only symptom for the whole book being migraines, left me not really believing this character could be real.
Then the rest of the characters all just appeared a bit clichéd, and sadly, when deaths occurred, you didn't care as they felt unreal (YES, I know it's fiction).
Cast Away by Sarah Goodwin. Thanks to avonbooks for the gifted arc ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Twelve strangers head to a remote island for the challenge of a lifetime. As the challenge deepens, so does mistrust. Their island is isolated and abandoned; or so they thought until a stranger ends up dead. When they abandon post, it becomes man vs. nature, in an unforgiving environment.
Looking for a good survival thriller for the upcoming cold, winter season? Here you go! When we think of “cast away” and abandoned on islands, you typically think of a tropical, warm environment. Not with this story. Get ready to bundle up because you’ll feel the chill coming off the pages. The atmosphere really sticks out, as well as the fear, terror, but also bravery of some of the main characters. We get the perspective from one main character, and she is perfectly done. She has a back story of a medical condition that is only going to progress with time. The addition of a reality tv show filming adds a fun component while you wait for things to go wrong… and they will! Things get worse, worse, and worse again. I did love the ending!
“I imagined this was what it had felt like in a fox hole - the shock and horror of bloodshed coupled with the fear that we might not make it. There was no way out of this but through.”
Read if you like: -Reality TV or competition tropes -Pioneer or old time living -Survival and nature thrillers -Cold environment vs. man
Ava, along with her brother and sister in law, join a few groups of other contestants in a survival style tv show, set to be the challenge of a lifetime. They are flown to a secluded island and think they are miles from any civilisation. But when they discover the body of stranger, they begin to wonder who else is on the island.
I have enjoyed a lot of Sarah Godwin’s books, with my favourites being her survival thrillers Stranded and The Private Jet, so I was excited to see that this one would have a similar theme. This one ended up not disappointing, being up there with my other favourites by her. When I first started I was intrigued by the idea behind the challenge and how it would play out, however I found that I wasn’t completely gripped. But that all changed as the story progressed and by the halfway point I was completely captivated and raced all the way through the shocking scenes to the conclusion.
Even though the story felt a bit far fetched at times, there was still a layer of realism and it was entertaining to read. Some parts of the story I found myself on tenterhooks, the author did a great job at building the tension and suspense. The author was also successful creating a bleak, isolated atmosphere, where the reader can vividly picture the cold and character’s plights. Although I didn’t fully like many of the characters and their actions were at times questionable, they still felt authentic and were well developed. I also enjoyed that as well as building fear in the reader, there were also thought provoking, emotional moments.
Overall this was a fun, addictive, gripping thriller with plenty of interesting turns and one that I will continue to think about. I hope the author writes more stories like this one. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this copy in return for an honest review.
I'm a big fan of Sarah Goodwin's thrillers, but I was a little disappointed with Cast Away. One of the things I've enjoyed about her earlier books is the realistic psychology of characters stranded in awful situations, as in Stranded, The Private Jet, The Resort and The Alpine Retreat.Cast Away sees several families choose to live a pioneer lifestyle on a remote island for a year as part of a reality TV show, building their own homes and stocking up food stores for the winter. The early part of the novel is slow-paced - not a problem for me - as the characters develop rivalries and our protagonist, Ava, struggles with her relationship with sister-in-law Claire. But then the group make a decision that I found frankly unbelievable, and which sets the course of the rest of the plot. I struggled to engage with the remainder of the book, although it was well-written, because I just couldn't understand why they would do this. I also found Ava a bit bland and idealised compared to Goodwin's usual satisfyingly flawed protagonists. A shame, but I'd recommend pretty much anything else by Goodwin.
I received a free copy of this novel from the publisher for review.
Sarah Goodwin writes some very good stories about people being stuck in one place, so when I was looking for something a little different for my *Trapped in Place* theme week, this seemed like a good choice.
Twelve contestants, a remote island just below the Arctic Circle, and a year to survive on what they can grow or earn through challenges set by the production company. What could possibly go wrong?
Quite a lot, as it turns out.
### POST-READING
The blurb gives us a story about a group discovering a body, suspecting there's a killer among them and desperately trying to get home. That's not quite the story I read.
After a terrible storm, the contestants discover a stranger sabotaging them. A struggle follows, and the stranger ends up dead. Panicking, underfed and not thinking particularly clearly, they decide that the sensible thing to do is disappear into the wilderness for a while. Surely, when they're eventually found, everyone will just be relieved they're alive and won't ask too many questions about the death?
Yes. Well.
This is a much heavier book than the blurb suggests. Several of the twelve contestants die, and the story doesn't shy away from the physical consequences of trying to survive in such an unforgiving environment. Exposure and illness take their toll; people who have been starved for too long can suffer terribly when they finally have access to food; and one character develops frostbite which leads to a particularly unpleasant deterioration of their extremities.
It's tough reading in places, and I'd give readers a heads-up that this is considerably more graphic and bleak than the premise might suggest.
Having said that, I really enjoyed it. The pacing is excellent, and the practical details of survival seemed to make sense as I was reading. I'm guessing Sarah has done her research, because the consequences of the characters' decisions feel convincing rather than conveniently arranged to move the plot along.
One character is experiencing the early stages of MS, and the symptoms and attacks felt consistent with that, too. It's an important part of their experience without feeling as though the condition has simply been added for dramatic effect.
I don't want to spoil the story by saying too much more, but this is an effective, fast-moving survival novel. Just be aware that the book you're getting is not quite the one the blurb appears to promise!
### RECOMMENDATIONS
For another story about people taking part in a survival reality show, try *The Last One* by Alexandra Oliva. For television, *The Wilds* brings together young people stranded in an unforgiving environment, with secrets and complications lurking beneath the surface.
### MUSIC PAIRING
“Ship to Wreck” — Florence + The Machine. A rather fitting soundtrack for people whose attempts to survive seem to involve making things considerably worse for themselves.
### VIBE CHECK
- **Colour palette:** Ice grey, storm-cloud blue, dark sea green and the stark white of snow. - **Soundtrack:** Howling wind, crashing waves, the creak of shelter and the constant sound of something being battered by the weather. - **Season:** Deep winter, when daylight is scarce and the cold is relentless. - **Mood:** Isolated, tense, bleak and determined. - **Scent:** Salt water, damp clothes, smoke and the earthy smell of things growing in difficult conditions. - **Texture:** Wet wool, rough timber, frozen ground, stiff fingers and the unforgiving bite of ice.
### TAROT CARD PULLED — FIVE OF PENTACLES
The Five of Pentacles is a card of hardship, deprivation and vulnerability. It speaks of what happens when the things we need to keep ourselves safe and well are suddenly out of reach.
For the contestants, survival isn't just about finding food and shelter. It's about the physical and emotional consequences of prolonged hardship, and the way people can become increasingly vulnerable when their basic needs aren't being met.
It's also a reminder that survival is not always a matter of willpower. Sometimes the conditions are simply too harsh, and determination alone can't protect you from everything.
*Cast Away* publishes on 3 December 2026. I received a free copy and am giving an honest review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Having previously read Stranded by Sarah Goodwin and absolutely loved it, I was really intrigued to see how Cast Away would compare. After all, both books have a survival element, and I wondered whether this one would feel a little too similar. I needn't have worried! This was a very different story, but every bit as gripping, intense and brilliantly written. In fact, I would go as far as to say that this is one of the best books I've read this year! This was such a harrowing read, and the atmosphere was so brilliantly portrayed that I could practically feel the cold seeping through the pages. The isolation, desperation, and sheer struggle to survive were so vividly described that I felt completely immersed in what was happening. There were moments when I genuinely wondered how things could possibly get any worse, only for the author to prove that they absolutely could! I did find myself questioning some of the pioneers' rather crazy decisions. There were definitely times when I wanted to shout at them and ask what on earth they were thinking! However, I suppose if everyone had made sensible, rational decisions, there wouldn't have been much of a book! Their choices certainly added to the tension, even if they did leave me shaking my head in disbelief on more than one occasion. The pacing was excellent, and I loved how the tension kept building. Just when I thought I could relax, something else would happen and pull me straight back into the story. It kept me on the edge of my seat throughout, and I found myself constantly turning the pages, desperate to know what would happen next. It really was one of those books that I struggled to put down, and I love it when a book has that effect on me. One aspect I particularly appreciated was the inclusion of chronic illness and how the author explored people's attitudes toward conditions they cannot see. I thought this was such an important element to include, particularly the ignorance, lack of understanding and dismissive attitudes that people with invisible illnesses can face. It really resonated with me, and I was pleased to see it represented in the story rather than simply overlooked. It added another layer to an already compelling read and made certain moments all the more thought-provoking. What impressed me most was how completely absorbed I became in the story. I wasn't simply reading about the characters' experiences; I felt as though I was right there with them, experiencing the freezing conditions, the fear, the frustration and the uncertainty. Sarah Goodwin has a wonderful ability to create an atmosphere that really gets under your skin, and she certainly achieved that here. Overall, this was an absolutely brilliant read and another fantastic book from Sarah Goodwin. It delivered everything I could possibly want from a survival thriller: tension, atmosphere, difficult decisions, desperation and that overwhelming need to read just one more chapter. Having now thoroughly enjoyed both Stranded and Cast Away, I'll definitely be looking out for more of her books. Without a doubt, one of my favourite reads of the year and a very easy, very well-deserved five stars from me!
Sarah Goodwin's earlier books used to frustrate me. There was usually a solid premise and the novels would start strongly and pique my interest. Then, sadly, there was a tendency for the storylines to tail off in the second half. Thankfully, those earlier traits now seem to have been addressed by the author and her more recent offerings have built on the positive aspects of her earlier works, but now deliver captivating reads throughout.
This latest offering, "Cast Away" has some echoes of her previous two novels. There is the "survival against the odds" element that was also evident in "The Private Jet" and there is the isolated snowbound backdrop that was similar to the setting used in "The Alpine Retreat". In spite of the resonance of these previously used themes "Cast Away" is, nonetheless, a very different story.
Due to long-term health issues, Ava has left her career as a school teacher and joins her brother and sister-in-law as contestants in a year-long reality tv show. In a similar way to the original "Big Brother", the show's format is designed as something of a social experiment, but with the focus being on how a family unit can survive on a basic homestead in the very challenging, isolated surroundings of Devon Island.
Sarah Goodwin does a fine job of creating a tangible atmosphere that not only reflects the frozen background setting, but also the fraught relations between the show's participants who are, after all, competing for a very large sum of money. This is due, in no small part, to the strength of Ava as the central character. The skills gleaned from her day job and her personal health challenges come to the fore as the narrative develops and the tension mounts.
"Cast Away" provides further evidence of how accomplished and more rounded Sarah Goodwin's fictional writing has become. This is another gripping and filmic novel that could easily find itself being adapted for the screen and I look forward to reading more from her.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for supplying an ARC in return for an honest review.
Ava joins her brother and his wife on a reality game show to earn a piece of the prize money that she needs for future health care. The show is all about surviving on a polar desert island for one year and includes building their shelter and growing their food. The contestants are barely allowed any provisions and have been chosen for their particular knowledge and skills that might help them succeed.
There are twelve contestants, divided into four competing families. Everything goes pretty well for the first few months, until they discover someone else on the island. Someone who is now dead. Anything else would probably be a spoiler, but let’s just say some hasty decisions are made that change the course of the show.
The story’s pretty realistic and shows the struggles no one tends to consider, like not being able to see inside their cabins after dark unless they happened to bring candle-making supplies with their provisions. If a family runs out of one thing, they can trade with another, but no one really gives anything for free. They’re trying to win $750,000, after all. The weakest part for me was the first and worst of the bad decisions they make, which I just didn’t buy.
But the author did include information about refeeding syndrome, which I’ve never heard of in all the mysteries and thrillers I’ve read. And there were plenty of them where one or more characters were kidnapped or lost and ended up severely malnourished. It’s like other authors just brush this very real condition aside as the vague ‘medical attention’ when characters are rescued. I appreciate the authenticity of this author in each of her survival stories that I’m now hooked on!
My thanks to NetGalley and Avon Books UK for the free advance reading copy of this book.
I have read several books by the author and i couldn't wait to get right into Cast Away.
Ava along with her brother and sister in law join a survival programme where they have to adapt to the cold climate and survive 12 months living a pioneer lifestyle alongside 3 other families, in total 12 contestants. I did find the beginning a bit of a slow pace but once months had passed for the families tension started brewing and that is when the pace become more faster. I did enjoy the description of the characters, there was not one same person and mostly felt real especially the tension i kept feeling between Ava and her sister in law Claire, i was wondering how the survival element was going to play once everything went wrong and it didn't disappoint.
When the group are put into a tough decision they decide to really become survivors and leave everything behind which will have consequences which i was blown away with the decisions they made and wondered how they could decide on doing something when you could clearly imagine it's like walking to your death. The description of the location was really well written and i just imagining it i knew i wouldn't be able to handle it and would of wanted to go home right away but the decisions the contestants makes leads to fear and for some death.
This book was full of suspense, survival and moments that'll have you shaking your head, i couldn't put it down and would recommend.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher Avon Books UK for the copy of this arc in exchange for my full honest review.
Thank you to NetGalley and Avon Books UK for an advanced copy of this title. I enjoy a deserted-island thriller, especially when a familiar setup takes an unexpected turn. Cast Away starts with contestants heading to a remote island to compete on a game show, but a shocking twist around the halfway point completely changes the direction of the story. I found that reveal genuinely interesting and enjoyed seeing how it shifted my understanding of what was happening. The story is told entirely from Ava’s POV in the present, with medium-length chapters that kept things moving. Ava was a character I could root for, even though she was a bit meek at times. I liked seeing her gradually find her footing as she faced the challenges of her situation, and it was satisfying to see her become more capable as the story progressed. There were a few moments when I had to suspend my disbelief because some of the decisions characters made didn’t feel realistic given their circumstances. While the explanation of what actually happened fell short of my expectations, I was fine with how the story wrapped up overall. Despite a few frustrations, I found this an entertaining read. If you like deserted-island thrillers, reality TV gone wrong, and shocking mid-story twists, then you will enjoy this book. #NetGalley #CastAway
Spoilers drop on release day at www.spoiltheplot.com. Until then, explore the site to find your next great thriller!
From the synopsis I was eager to read this book. I found the beginning to be quite slow, but once the pace picked up I was completely invested. Twelve people travel to a remote island to take part in a reality show with a large prize fund. It’s set mainly against a frozen wasteland where the ‘families’ compete, completing tasks in return for prizes. Not everyone gets on, there’s call of sabotage, and then there’s ’the body’. Is there a killer on the island? With no one to call for help, do they take drastic action to try and survive until help can arrive? This is a great thriller that had me eagerly turning the pages. I liked the strength of Ava’s character and how the other families interacted with each other. A solid 4 stars. Thank you to NetGalley, Avon Books UK and the author for the chance to review.
A group of strangers travel to a very remote island to take part in a reality TV survival show. But when things go horribly wrong their dream adventure turns into a terrifying fight for survival. Cut off from civilisation paranoia takes hold as they discover that the greatest danger might not be the island itself but each other.
😬 The isolated setting was absolutely perfect always love an isolated setting. 🌫️ Was so atmospheric and at times I actually felt the cold. 🥶Loved the survival element from the initial game to what came after. 📖 I was completely hooked from start to finish.
Thank you to Netgalley, Avon Books UK and Sarah Goodwin for an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
There seems to have been a glut of books with reality show plots, and I have to admit I find them just as addictive as real reality shows - if not more so. As the title suggests the show in this book is based upon the concept of Castaway (the show from 2000 which led Ben Fogle to fame). 12 stranger spending a year building a society on a deserted island.
I really enjoyed the first half of the book, however the big decision made when things started to go wrong just seemed completely illogical. I found it very hard to believe that anyone would do it in real life, and the subsequent decisions after that, so that ruined the 2nd part of the book for me.
Finding the body of an unknown person on a remote island where you think you know everyone is never a good sign. It's even worse when you are already part of a social experiment of sorts, with only a dozen people participating.
Because that means that there is either another stranger -who is a killer - somewhere on the island. Or,,, someone in your little community is the killer. Neither prospect is particularly reassuring.
Goodwin has a gift for claustrophobic, locked room style mysteries, and this book is no exception. A very enjoyable thriller read.
I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
I'd like to think people making reality TV would do a bit more research on people going into the wilderness for a year. Not just accept an add on either. Surely enough people apply your not desperate. Ok, first off, I didnt like Ava. Sorry she's ill and all, but it seemed very much a come and go thing. Like I can't chop wood, I have to lie in bed all day with a migraine but I can carry someone up a mountain and survive harsh conditions no problem.
I'm not sure on the logic of running away either. I mean a dead body is still a dead body in a few weeks or months.
It took a long while to get going, and when it did, I read it pretty quickly. I was interested to see where it went. I think I like it more if I don't think about it too much. 😂
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.