For readers of Jason Stanley and Timothy Snyder comes an urgent and rigorous comparison of our current political climate to that of Germany's during Hitler’s first year in power.
Since a new wave of far right-wing sentiment entered American political life a decade ago, political scientists and pundits have chided people for what they see as overly facile comparisons between today’s Republican leadership and Nazism. Are these comparisons just scare-mongering? Or could they tell us something useful about the state of American democracy?
Using the writings of German thinkers like Thomas Mann, Victor Klemperer, Hannah Arendt, and other meticulous diarists of the era, Project 1933 retells the story of the first year of the Third Reich month-by-month, pausing to draw connections between Germany’s past and America’s present. Adrian Daub deftly explores the truths of living under fascism—the grim uncertainty (and even grimmer certainty) of early days, the existential scramble to cleave to institutions that define us even as they are bent to the will of a despot, the creation of bystanders and collaborators, the shifting cultural conversations, and the day-to-day banalities.
While some parallels are downright terrifying, Project 1933 aims to remind readers of the choices that are available to us, and that fascism’s key magic trick is to convince us of its own inevitability. Project 1933 shows readers a path toward a more hopeful, moral imagination and the possibility of radical change.
Many people compare the current political climate in the United States to Nazi Germany and ho boy do people get offended when you do that. “It’s nothing alike.” they say. “We’re nothing like them.” they say. The author of this says that while there are differences, there are also similarities, and the best way to see these is to look at the first year of rule by the Nazi party, 1933. When you compare the politics of 2025-2026 and those of 1933 Germany there are striking and obvious similarities.
I absolutely loved this book. It can be an incredibly difficult read because it doesn’t shy away from detailing the atrocities of the Nazis but I still loved this.
This book goes over in great detail how Nazi power consolidated and evolved in the year 1933. It makes the point that the Nazis in general weren’t as organized and powerful as we think in current times and watching the process of them pulling themselves together was both interesting and horrifying.
The book focuses a great deal on the thoughts and feelings of normal people in Germany at the rise of Nazi power. I haven’t seen much literature like that and reading from their point of view was something else. There is a great deal of information pulled from personal letters and diaries that I didn’t know about that was especially enlightening.
Overall I greatly liked this book. Like I said earlier, it can be a very hard read at points but m glad I read it. Highly recommend this for people that can handle the content.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!
There’s an alarming comparison often made between the Nazi regime and Trump’s America, and, for the most part, it ends up getting pooh-poohed. I think there’s a perception of the age-old ‘It can’t happen here!’ about it all in the U.S., which is a dangerous perception for myriad reasons.
This book, helpfully, draws a strong comparison between the two governments and demonstrates exactly why the canary in the coal mine should be chirping by now (or rather, why it should have stopped chirping a suspicious while ago).
It’s a worrying thing to see compared, but the intervention of ICE and the subsequent deaths that have been caused, as well as numerous other abuses of power at all levels are deeply concerning. This book draws a strong academic comparison between the rise of Hitler’s regime and the approach of the current U.S. government, and gives contemporaneous reports from both time periods to illustrate the point.
The most powerful evidence is the diary extracts, which make for compulsive reading, and also show that the general sentiment that silence was not complicity. Of course, we know how 1933 ended. The question of how the human rights abuses in the U.S. end is a different matter.
I did think that some of the segments about the modern era could have been a little stronger. As a whole though, this book serves as a warning- it can absolutely happen here, and we need to make sure that we do all we can to prevent it from doing so, regardless of which stage it may be at in all our respective countries.
Project 1933 is a masterful historical comparison that feels urgent for today's political climate. I loved the focus on the actual diaries of thinkers like Hannah Arendt and Thomas Mann, it grounds the heavy theory in real human experience. It’s an eye-opening look at how easily societies slip into authoritarianism, but it ultimately offers a hopeful path forward.