What do you think?
Rate this book
Scrupulosity: Gospel Peace for Moral Obsession
While most people may be familiar with Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD), there is another category of obsessions and compulsions that has been known to burden many believers. It is known by many names including scrupulosity, religious OCD, moral obsession, among others. Counselees struggling with obsessions and so-called compulsions surrounding their spiritual life may be diligent with checking off every spiritual box, but still lack assurance, peace, and joy. This booklet aims to help biblical counselors address wayward postures of the heart that promote scrupulous fear with a gospel-focused remedy.
- GenresCounselling
34 pages, Paperback
Published January 23, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
October 19, 2026
Lucid brevity at its best. Helpful primer. Clear overview. Incisive unpacking. Practical tips. Great stuff.
Some Takeaways and Quotes
- When you give into compulsions, you are giving into a demand of your heart that is ungodly.
- What areas of life are you neglecting to carry out what you think is demanded by your compulsion?
- A review of 2 Corinthians 4:1-4 and the sermon Self-forgetfulness by Keller could be a great homework assignment
- Scrupulosity involves misdirected trust, misdirected love, and selectivity
- The scrupulous person must learn to distrust his ability to see himself clearly
- When compulsion hits, pray and then move on to do the next thing.
- The scrupulous person is trusting herself to provide the way of escape from her fear.
- Scrupulous strugglers need to know that the rules they make for themselves (i.e., compulsions) have no real strength to combat the sin within. This is evidenced by the fact that in her self-made religion, Emily is sinning in order to address her fear that she will sin in another way that she finds repugnant.
- -(Colossians 2:20-23) Did you notice that Paul says these regulations promote “self-made religion”? This is, essentially, what a scrupulous person has done in giving herself a law to obey so she can escape her fear.
- For the scrupulous person, then, trusting the Lord often looks like doing the opposite of what feels right.
- A child learning to ride his bike feels like it’s best to stop peddling when he feels the slightest wobble, but he actually needs to peddle faster to obtain balance. Likewise, Emily needs to be counseled to attend church, though it feels unsafe to her. This puts her in a position to trust God by doing what He says is right, instead of what she feels is right.
- Another heart problem at the root of scrupulosity is misdirected love. That is, love of self. It may seem strange to associate love of self with scrupulosity, since we don’t typically think of fear as being proud. But John Street describes OCD as “a fear-driven set of excessive thoughts and behaviors that is fueled by presumptions of self-importance and self-righteousness.” This is why uncovering what the scrupulous person fears will help you see that he not only needs to be directed outside of himself in what he trusts, but also in what he desires.
- As a counselor, it your duty to draw out the heart behind their intrusive thoughts and demand for certainty.
- What is it that you want when you are meticulously working through your safety checklist?” or “What is it that you fear losing that leads you to adhere to your checking?
- me- we need to help people take back their mind at the level of compulsion with the Word or a mantra based on the word of God.
- There is a final heart problem for the scrupulous person that is considered unreasonable: it is a selective outlook that keeps her from experiencing God’s peace. In her mental angst, she has tunnel vision, which restricts her thinking to those questions, indictments, and compulsions related to her fear. This selectivity often shows itself in what she detects in her own heart – her sins are highlighted, while evidence of the Spirit’s work is forgotte.
- Why would we not focus heavily on all the good the Spirit brings internally and externally?
- Without excusing her sin, Cassie needs to see that in her fear she has functionally cut off access to her source of confidence in salvation. By staring at her sin, she is isolating her spiritual sight from Jesus Christ, the one “who loved [her] and gave Himself for [her]” (Galatians 2:20). If you are counseling Cassie, then helping her focus on her Savior instead of her sin is a high priority. Sinclair Ferguson is right when he says that “faith gets a man out of himself and into Christ.” Her selective outlook has kept her anxious because she is looking within to find something that is not there: hope.
- "Self-knowledge,” says David Powlison, “is only a doorway of grace.” So, Cassie needs to heed John Piper’s counsel on this matter: “Only look within to see what you need to look to Jesus for.” This means that when Cassie recognizes jealousy in her heart, instead of only recalling 1 John 3:6, that “no one who abides in Him keeps on sinning,” she needs to remember 1 John 2:1, “If anyone does sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous.” And in her mind, when she begins to rehearse an angry rant against her mom, instead of only recalling 2 Corinthians 5:17, thinking that she is not acting like a “new creation,” she needs to remember Romans 8:1, “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.”
- teach her to read God’s Word in context and refrain from fearfully cherry-picking verses that disconnect her sin from the gospel. Where there is a Romans 3:23 (“for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God”), there is also a Romans 3:24 (“and are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus”).
- -Take Psalm 40, for instance. In verse 12, it’s true that David writes, “For evils have encompassed me beyond number; my iniquities have overtaken me, and I cannot see; they are more than the hairs of my head; my heart fails me.” But that verse is preceded by the hope of verse 11: “As for you, O Lord, you will not restrain your mercy from me; your steadfast love and your faithfulness will ever preserve me!”
Some Takeaways and Quotes
- When you give into compulsions, you are giving into a demand of your heart that is ungodly.
- What areas of life are you neglecting to carry out what you think is demanded by your compulsion?
- A review of 2 Corinthians 4:1-4 and the sermon Self-forgetfulness by Keller could be a great homework assignment
- Scrupulosity involves misdirected trust, misdirected love, and selectivity
- The scrupulous person must learn to distrust his ability to see himself clearly
- When compulsion hits, pray and then move on to do the next thing.
- The scrupulous person is trusting herself to provide the way of escape from her fear.
- Scrupulous strugglers need to know that the rules they make for themselves (i.e., compulsions) have no real strength to combat the sin within. This is evidenced by the fact that in her self-made religion, Emily is sinning in order to address her fear that she will sin in another way that she finds repugnant.
- -(Colossians 2:20-23) Did you notice that Paul says these regulations promote “self-made religion”? This is, essentially, what a scrupulous person has done in giving herself a law to obey so she can escape her fear.
- For the scrupulous person, then, trusting the Lord often looks like doing the opposite of what feels right.
- A child learning to ride his bike feels like it’s best to stop peddling when he feels the slightest wobble, but he actually needs to peddle faster to obtain balance. Likewise, Emily needs to be counseled to attend church, though it feels unsafe to her. This puts her in a position to trust God by doing what He says is right, instead of what she feels is right.
- Another heart problem at the root of scrupulosity is misdirected love. That is, love of self. It may seem strange to associate love of self with scrupulosity, since we don’t typically think of fear as being proud. But John Street describes OCD as “a fear-driven set of excessive thoughts and behaviors that is fueled by presumptions of self-importance and self-righteousness.” This is why uncovering what the scrupulous person fears will help you see that he not only needs to be directed outside of himself in what he trusts, but also in what he desires.
- As a counselor, it your duty to draw out the heart behind their intrusive thoughts and demand for certainty.
- What is it that you want when you are meticulously working through your safety checklist?” or “What is it that you fear losing that leads you to adhere to your checking?
- me- we need to help people take back their mind at the level of compulsion with the Word or a mantra based on the word of God.
- There is a final heart problem for the scrupulous person that is considered unreasonable: it is a selective outlook that keeps her from experiencing God’s peace. In her mental angst, she has tunnel vision, which restricts her thinking to those questions, indictments, and compulsions related to her fear. This selectivity often shows itself in what she detects in her own heart – her sins are highlighted, while evidence of the Spirit’s work is forgotte.
- Why would we not focus heavily on all the good the Spirit brings internally and externally?
- Without excusing her sin, Cassie needs to see that in her fear she has functionally cut off access to her source of confidence in salvation. By staring at her sin, she is isolating her spiritual sight from Jesus Christ, the one “who loved [her] and gave Himself for [her]” (Galatians 2:20). If you are counseling Cassie, then helping her focus on her Savior instead of her sin is a high priority. Sinclair Ferguson is right when he says that “faith gets a man out of himself and into Christ.” Her selective outlook has kept her anxious because she is looking within to find something that is not there: hope.
- "Self-knowledge,” says David Powlison, “is only a doorway of grace.” So, Cassie needs to heed John Piper’s counsel on this matter: “Only look within to see what you need to look to Jesus for.” This means that when Cassie recognizes jealousy in her heart, instead of only recalling 1 John 3:6, that “no one who abides in Him keeps on sinning,” she needs to remember 1 John 2:1, “If anyone does sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous.” And in her mind, when she begins to rehearse an angry rant against her mom, instead of only recalling 2 Corinthians 5:17, thinking that she is not acting like a “new creation,” she needs to remember Romans 8:1, “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.”
- teach her to read God’s Word in context and refrain from fearfully cherry-picking verses that disconnect her sin from the gospel. Where there is a Romans 3:23 (“for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God”), there is also a Romans 3:24 (“and are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus”).
- -Take Psalm 40, for instance. In verse 12, it’s true that David writes, “For evils have encompassed me beyond number; my iniquities have overtaken me, and I cannot see; they are more than the hairs of my head; my heart fails me.” But that verse is preceded by the hope of verse 11: “As for you, O Lord, you will not restrain your mercy from me; your steadfast love and your faithfulness will ever preserve me!”
January 9, 2026
It's a short book with nothing I disagree with and some helpful advice, but I struggled with his case studies. Having worked with some people who struggle with religious OCD, I found some of the counsel a little superficial.
August 22, 2025
Great little book for an often ignored sinful pattern.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews