ARC REVIEW
FIRST IMPRESSIONS ( Started as a 6 Star )
Before it was even mentioned, I got Runaway Bride energy from this and I was all the way here for it. First of all, I’ve been in love with Robbi Renee’s writing since Somebody’s Wife so thank you to the publisher for letting me get my hands on her newest work! Let’s gooo.
Right out the gate: chaos. Beautiful chaos. And a beautiful man too, whew. But Summer? She’s in that unsure phase of life and it feels real.
Here’s what I’m loving so far (without spoiling too much):
- The description of the first male character... I think I actually drooled a little 👀
- That conversation around women choosing “safe” over “meant to be,” and how we know when someone isn’t the one. Whew.
- Learning why it’s called Summer’s Echo so early in the book
- Finding out who Echo is and the nickname he has for her? When that man said “baby-girl,”—I promise I actually heard it
- The setting is where I live so it’s giving extra fun energy for the summer
- Female friendship! Summer has a girl group and y’all know I love seeing that in books. Loooooove a good, layered friendship dynamic in books—it always makes the story feel fuller.
It’s already giving grown, sexy, and emotionally complex. Robbi knows how to write that kind of story, and I know this one is going to be a hit. I’m so ready to see how it all unfolds!— Cannot wait to report back.
UPDATE :
⭐️⭐️⭐️ (3–3.5 stars)
Started off feeling like a 6-star read… update: it’s not. 😅
So here’s the thing…
When I first started this, I really thought I had a new fave on my hands. But somewhere along the way, my investment started slipping. The first half had me kind of checked out… like, them being stuck in the same spot for that long? It was blowing me. I just didn’t care enough yet.
BUT—once they moved?? Baby. It picked up QUICK.
I flew through the last 50% and finished it expeditiously. I am glad I stuck with it.
What I loved:
- His nicknames for her were cute
- The setting had such a cozy, nostalgic vibe
- And there were a few emotional beats that hit home for me personally
Why it dropped to a 3–3.5:
- The past/present timeline… was distracting.
It just didn’t feel clean. I love a dual timeline when it’s done right, but this one had me frustrated and honestly, I think it only really mattered for one part of the plot. A simple “15 years ago” vs. “Now” would’ve done wonders. I summarize each chapter as I read, and this format made the experience choppy.
- The second chance half
Lowkey underdeveloped.
I needed a clearer reason for why they couldn’t reconnect as adults. I kept waiting for that “aha” moment, and it never came. The fact that he was about to show up at her wedding to another man but somehow they never reached out before??? Be for real. 😭 It felt childish and that knocked the emotional payoff down big time for me.
- The pacing around her “running away” situation.
If we got to that part sooner or even teased it more effectively, I genuinely think this would’ve been an easy 4-star read.
Final thoughts:
If you’re looking for a second chance romance without the usual toxicity, something a lil campy, cozy, and layered with just enough drama to keep you going? This one might be perfect for you.