Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Cut Him Out in Little Stars

Rate this book
Heartbroken after the death of her fighter pilot fiancé, Juliet is sent to stay with her sister at Samphire House. But when she discovers the body of a local girl washed up on the beach, past mysteries come flooding back.

Under the darkening skies of wartime England, Juliet is thrown together with a handsome stranger.

Can she find the courage to confront her deepest fears, put right a terrible injustice, and - even as the world burns around her - risk falling in love once more?

334 pages, Paperback

Published August 27, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Lucy Strange

17 books450 followers
Lucy Strange worked as an actor, singer and storyteller before becoming a secondary school English teacher. She now lives and writes in the heart of the Kent countryside with her partner James, their baby boy and a tortoiseshell cat known as Moo.

Our Castle by the Sea is Lucy’s second novel for children, following her critically acclaimed debut, The Secret of Nightingale Wood.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
60 (35%)
4 stars
70 (41%)
3 stars
33 (19%)
2 stars
5 (2%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
Profile Image for A N N A.
251 reviews3 followers
September 2, 2026
3.5. Would have been 4 stars if not for the melodramatics at the start about a man she hardly bloody knew.
Profile Image for Olga.
947 reviews41 followers
October 27, 2026
Now this is what I call excellent historical fiction for younger readers. Beautifully written, wonderfully atmospheric, full of historical detail and, perhaps most importantly, intelligent enough not to treat its intended audience as though they require everything explained to them three times.

I absolutely loved it.

Set on the Kent coast during the Second World War, Cut Him Out in Little Stars follows Juliet, a young woman grieving the death of her fighter pilot fiancé, who arrives at her sister's home and gradually becomes entangled in a mystery. There is romance, poetry, family drama, secrets and a wonderfully evocative sense of wartime Britain, all woven together with considerable skill.

What struck me immediately was the writing. Lucy Strange has a beautiful command of language, particularly when describing the sea and the coastal landscape. You can practically smell the salt in the air and feel the wind coming off the Channel. The setting feels wonderfully alive, but never in that irritatingly overwritten way where an author spends three pages describing a cloud because apparently we must all appreciate how literary they are being. Strange knows when to linger over a description and when to move the story along.

I also loved the historical context. There is a tremendous amount of information about wartime Britain incorporated into the narrative, yet it never feels like a history textbook masquerading as a novel. We see the war through the experiences of ordinary people, particularly young people whose lives have been interrupted by events entirely beyond their control. The danger, uncertainty, grief and restrictions of the period are portrayed realistically, without resorting to gratuitous violence or unnecessarily graphic descriptions. The war is never romanticised, but neither is the reader subjected to relentless misery.

As a school librarian, I kept thinking how suitable this would be for our library. I would happily recommend it to confident readers from Year 7 upwards, depending on maturity, although I suspect older teenagers might appreciate some of its emotional complexities more fully. It is exactly the sort of book that can make history feel real to young people, and perhaps even encourage them to explore the period further. And I love that it manages to do this while remaining genuinely entertaining.

Now, Juliet herself. Goodness gracious, that girl tested my patience.

She is rather an airhead at times, isn't she? A romantic little creature whose imagination frequently appears to have galloped several miles ahead of her common sense. I occasionally wanted to reach into the book and give her a good shake. But, to be fair, she is young, grieving and attempting to navigate a world that has suddenly become frighteningly uncertain. More importantly, she actually grows throughout the story. Her experiences force her to question her assumptions, develop some discernment and become considerably less exasperating. I appreciated that Strange allowed her heroine to be genuinely immature rather than presenting us with yet another implausibly wise teenager who possesses the emotional intelligence of a forty-year-old therapist.

One of my favourite aspects was Juliet's love of literature. Shakespeare, poetry and particularly Romeo and Juliet are woven beautifully into the narrative, and I thought the literary references added real depth rather than simply functioning as decorative quotations. There is something especially lovely about a young character who interprets the world through books, even if, in Juliet's case, her romantic imagination occasionally gets her into trouble. The title itself is taken from Shakespeare, and its significance becomes increasingly poignant as the story unfolds.

The romance is also handled remarkably well. Given the premise and the abundance of poetry, this could quite easily have become unbearably saccharine, but thankfully it never does. There is tenderness and youthful longing, certainly, but also grief, disappointment, difficult choices and a fair amount of emotional messiness. In other words, something rather closer to actual human relationships than the usual collection of beautiful people gazing meaningfully at one another.

I also appreciated the inclusion of LGBT characters and the way their circumstances were presented within the social realities of the 1940s. One of my pet hates in historical fiction is when characters behave like twenty-first-century people who have somehow wandered into the past wearing period costumes. Strange avoids that trap. The attitudes and restrictions of the era matter, and the characters must negotiate them accordingly. It is handled sensitively without sacrificing historical credibility, which I thought was particularly important.

And then there is the final ten per cent.

Goodness gracious.

After spending much of the novel building atmosphere, relationships and mystery, Strange suddenly accelerates the narrative, and everything becomes extraordinarily intense. I was completely absorbed, and the emotional impact took me rather by surprise. It is a genuinely moving conclusion, made all the more effective because we have spent enough time with these characters to care about what happens to them. I do love an author who understands that emotional devastation is considerably more effective when it has actually been earned.

4.5 stars.

This is an excellent example of historical fiction that works equally well for younger readers and adults. It has beautiful prose, convincing historical detail, strong character development, a wonderfully realised coastal setting and enough mystery and romance to keep things interesting without overwhelming the story.

If anything, the book reminded me how much I appreciate children's and young adult authors who take their craft seriously. Writing for younger readers should never mean writing down to them, and Strange clearly understands that.

I would be delighted to have this on our school library shelves, and I would recommend it just as enthusiastically to adults who enjoy thoughtful historical fiction.

And Juliet, bless her, does eventually acquire some common sense. Which, considering how things began, is almost a miracle in itself.
Profile Image for Hannah Rials Jensen.
Author 7 books54 followers
September 2, 2026
Stunning! Romantic, mysterious, mystical, fast paced and great characters. What more could you want?
Profile Image for Jordan.
19 reviews
September 2, 2026
A truly swoony historical coming of age story!!!

This book had the best bits of everything - romance, history, mystery and just a touch of the supernatural.

Juliet was a beautifully written, relatable protagonist and I loved her character development/ growth throughout the book.

I don’t often read historical romances but I’m glad I read this one!!!
Profile Image for Nic.
336 reviews5 followers
September 19, 2026
I listened to Cut him out in Little Stars on my commute this week & finished last night.

At the start of the book, 18 year old Juliet falls head over heels in love with a fighter pilot, who is soon after killed in action over France. (I’ve seen a review complaining of her melodramatic reaction to such a short affair- R& J is one of the inspirations behind this book after all & … Rosaline?!)

Grieving what she had just found, and all she has lost, she moves to Samphire House, a cottage on the south east coast, to live with her sister, Frances.

When the body of a young woman washes up on the beach, ghosts of the family’s past reappear, but will Juliet be strong enough to confront her history as well as her present? The discovery of the body sparks Juliet into life when she determines the death was not an accident. She is also, quite literally, flung together with another handsome, somewhat enigmatic man… but it’s all too soon, isn’t it?

I really enjoyed this audiobook, which is wonderfully read by the author herself. My review might feel a little vague as it’s difficult not to give away spoilers, & I want everyone to encounter the details as I did. The various mysteries are very well worked and keep you guessing, and caring, until the end.

The story begins as action is hotting up in the skies spanning the English Channel and the period is evoked in detail. I’ve read a fair few Blitz books, but it felt different in this intimate little coastal community.

The main female characters are great: Juliet is a really interesting character, who grows a lot over the course of the novel. She is observant, diligent and brave. Her sister’s situation is difficult too. She has internalised 1940’s society’s bigotry and is struggling to come to terms with who she is. Another frequent character, Anne, is a treasure & is courageously, consistently, her authentic self.

The male characters are also very interesting and you spend much of the novel trying to discern who can be trusted and who is a villain- or perhaps somewhere in between.

The romance elements are suitably swoon- worthy and teenage me would’ve had my head in the clouds for days! It’s also chock-full of literary references (lines of poetry, poets, authors, the title itself, which is woven into the book so beautifully too.)

12+. CW: racism, homophobia, death
Profile Image for Opbo :D.
16 reviews3 followers
October 23, 2026
Really good!! Picked it up the second time I saw it on a recommended books table (at two different bookshops), and thought it was really sweet! Loved the world of the village and the feminist side of it, plus of course the side character queer acceptance :D read it in a day and a bit, good book, solid 8/10!
Profile Image for Faye.
103 reviews1 follower
September 15, 2026
I’m terrible at audiobooks, so if I managed to finish it, it must be good. Read as it is the Waterstones pick of the month and glad I did.
Author 2 books53 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
July 20, 2026
I received a review copy from the publisher in preparation for a UKYASpotlight interview. It has not affected my opinions.

CUT HIM OUT IN LITTLE STARS is a stunning historical romance and mystery set on the Kentish coast around the Battle of Britain.

This book is part mystery, part romance. It's hard to pick which one is the bigger storyline (so I've decided to add it as a historical in my spreadsheet!) It's about grief and finding the strength to love again. It is just a gorgeous book that balances the mystery of what happened to the dead girl with a romance you fear is doomed because of the war.

There's such a rollercoaster of emotions throughout the book, that overwhelming feeling as a teen that means every emotion lands with such a punch. Then add in the existential dread of being in a war right in the place that will be the first place an army would land. All of this translates so well onto the page, sinking its claws into you.

As you might have guessed from the title, it takes some inspiration from Romeo and Juliet, but here Romeo may not be the person he claimed to be, and Juliet isn't dead either. It's more a stepping off point than anything else, and certainly not a retelling.

This is far from the only literary allusion in the book. It's full of poetry from the 18th and 19th centuries. Juliet finds great comfort in the emotions expressed by others as she goes through her own crises. I'm sure there was a lot of references I missed (if it wasn't explicit, I wasn't going to pick it up as I'm really not familiar with poetry!)

The book is set in a fictional place along the Kentish coast. This is the coast I know the best and I loved seeing it brought to life here. For me, Kent is one of the most magical places as I spent so much time there as a child (and still visit regularly) - particularly its historic places. This book manages to capture that history and magic, which made the "ghosts" of the house feel possible without breaking the realism of the setting.
Profile Image for Liane Collins.
139 reviews3 followers
August 30, 2026
Cut Him Out In Little Stars by @thelucystrange

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

This was the first historical romance I’ve read and it was absolutely captivating and I couldn’t put it down.

Synopsis: The story takes place in war time Britain in 1940 and follows 18 year old Juliet who has had her heart broken falling the death of her fiancé, with whom she had a very whirlwind romance.

Her father sends her to stay with her sister Frances by the coast at their childhood home, which also happens to be where an RAF base has been established.

Soon after murder and mysteries enter into Juliet’s world and no longer can her brain focus on heartache when there is puzzles to be solved and a handsome, young pilot who captures her eyes and heart 💜.

My thoughts: Overall, I adored this book. I throughly enjoyed being transported into 1940s Britain and all the descriptions about what life was like at that time. The simplicity of a man asking a woman to a dance and the chivalry was everything 🥹. No exchanging Instagram handles and waiting on WhatsApp blue ticks in their day (genuinely love and life seem simpler back then). The murder and mystery was excellent, I did figure out who the villain at just over half way, but how it all played out was page-turning, gripping and I couldn’t put it down till the very end. There was a lot of character development in Juliet which I liked and I really enjoyed how Lucy emphasised her and other women’s roles played in the war— a very important historical detail I think many forget. I would have just loved one extra chapter between the final chapter and the epilogue, purely for my romantic heart to feel the yearning, chemistry and love between them even more than I already did, but that’s a tiny thing and simply my heart going all mushy for love 🥹. I absolutely loved it and would highly recommend for anyone. The perfect young adult romance suitable for age 12+.

✨Thank you Lucy for gifting me your book. ✨
💜Please note whilst this book was gifted all opinions and thoughts on this book are my own.
Profile Image for Faith Richmond.
20 reviews1 follower
August 2, 2026
Set against the backdrop of wartime coastal Britain, Cut Him Out in Little Stars follows Juliet as she navigates love, loss, and a dark mystery following a sudden tragedy in her small seaside town. Highly recommended for fans of Elizabeth Wein’s WWII novels, as Lucy Strange writes with similar emotional depth, rich historical atmosphere, and compelling literary references.

I am always a sucker for a solid historical romance, and this one absolutely fit the bill. It strikes such a great balance between history, romance, and a tight mystery, while handling heavy themes like grief with a lot of care.

I would advise looking past the quick romance/insta love at the start. It serves as the main spark for the plot, and as things unravel, it completely makes sense, setting up some fantastic character growth as Juliet matures and comes into her own. The story does get a bit sappy in places, but it is YA, and the second half becomes very fast paced. I found myself listening to the audiobook every chance I got.

Lucy Strange thrives at creating an authentic setting, with a supporting cast that makes Fairlight Bay feel fully alive and immersive. I also loved the poetry excerpts woven throughout. Sparingly and wisely used, they add so much depth.

As for the audiobook, I would've never guessed the author narrated it herself! It was exceptionally well-delivered and beautifully performed from start to finish.
Thanks so much to the publisher for the ALC in exchange for an honest review!
Profile Image for The Reading Raccoon.
1,178 reviews137 followers
September 18, 2026
Cut Him Out in Little Stars is a young adult historical mystery novel about a young woman who flees to the coast of England in the height of World War 2. But instead of finding a place to heal her broken heart, she stumbles on the mysterious death of a local young woman.

Juliet is heartbroken after a whirlwind romance ends with the death of her fighter pilot fiancé while flying for the Allies in France. Escaping to her childhood home to see her sister seems like the perfect escape, but a nearby RAF base puts her in proximity to more fighter pilots, and then the body of a young woman washes up on shore. Juliet thinks her death wasn’t an accident and immediately starts an investigation of her own.

Cut Him Out in Little Stars has a historical detail, a mystery, and a sweet romance. I really enjoyed the audiobook, which is narrated by the author herself.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Disclosure: An advanced listening copy of Cut Him Out in Little Stars was provided by LibroFM for review purposes. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Rebecca R.
1,544 reviews33 followers
November 13, 2026
In the summer of 1940, 18-year-old Juliet is sent away to the coast to stay at Samphire House with her sister to recover from the heartbreak of losing her fighter-pilot fiance. But soon after she arrives, she discovers the body of a young woman washed up on the shore. Juliet still suffers from nightmares about the sea, triggered by her mother’s death-by-drowning when she was six, but when she realises that this was not an accident, her curiosity outweighs her fear and she is determined to investigate. Can Juliet overcome her fear of the sea, solve a murder and possibly even fall in love again?

I have enjoyed Lucy Strange’s middle grade historical mysteries in the past, but I was utterly swept away by this story. (A colleague had to call my name three times to get my attention in the staffroom at lunchtime while I was reading.) This is a captivating coming-of-age story full of intrigue, drama and swoon-worthy romance, perfect for fans of Laura Wood and ‘I Capture the Castle’.
Profile Image for Sophie.
91 reviews
October 5, 2026
THIS WAS AMAZING!!

i got recommended this by someone who worked in Waterstones and i thought id give it a go and im so glad i did!! i love it so so much it was so heartwarming ❤️😭

i love her and bertie together, and im glad that she made up with xander

also i absolutely loved the murder mystery plot too, even though i knew who it was from the start 😉

i kept predicting what would happen every so often, like stan being the secret lover, juliet nearly dying, and then her going out on the lifeboat to save bertie. i know that makes the author sound predictable but i actually enjoy guessing what’s about to happen, and i love getting it right

i nearly cried at the ending like always! i really loved this though, im so sad it’s over!! definitely a favourite ❤️
Profile Image for Zayna✨️.
58 reviews2 followers
October 25, 2026
Because it's set during WW2 it's really tense and emotional, but what brought the hopefulness into the book was the bond between the characters. Especially the sister bond between Frances and Juliet, and the love between Bertie and Juliet, he was an amazing love interest.

Alex was another character that was amazing she was such a good character and friend to both sisters.

The pacing was great too, it never felt slow or dragged out and I really enjoyed the mystery in the book. I was able to figure it out beforehand but that didn't ruin it for me at all, the book still had me hooked.

Overall such a lovely, emotional read. I'd definitely recommend it if you love historical fiction with a mystery and a bit of romance.
Profile Image for Emma.
485 reviews2 followers
September 19, 2026
This was such a lovely little read.

The research that must have gone into writing this book must have been so in-depth, especially because of the nature of the story. I really enjoyed reading about the war heroes and the families they left behind.

I’m not going to lie, before I finished the book I actually had to check with someone who had already read it, just so I could prepare myself in case there was a sad ending! 😂

I really enjoyed this book, but there was just something I couldn’t quite put my finger on that stopped me from giving it the full 5 stars.

Still, a really lovely and touching read. ❤️📚
Profile Image for Nicole Sweeney.
710 reviews21 followers
September 4, 2026
Cut Him Out in Little Stars is a beautifully told gothic historical fiction tale that follows a young woman named Juliet during the events of World War two. When her fighter pilot fiancé is killed in action, Juliet goes to stay with her sister at the remote Samphire House, hoping there she will find the space to grieve. Shortly after she arrives, the body of a local village girl washes up on the shore. Juliet soon becomes entangled in the mystery of what happened to the poor girl, but with the threat of war ever looming, can Juliet solve the mystery in time?

This was a really atmospheric and compelling read that I raced through in just a few sittings. I loved the gothic house setting with just a dash of the supernatural. The story is inspired by Romeo and Juliet, and blends historical fiction, mystery, and romance really well. The story feels well researched, and the sights and sounds of a coastal town really come to life in Strange's writing.

The story has some great characters, and I really liked both Juliet and Bertie. There's a great supporting cast, and I really liked that the story explored subjects like relationships, grief, and loss. The romance is well developed, and the mystery kept me guessing till nearly the end.

Overall, Cut Him Out in Little Stars is a richly detailed, captivating historical mystery, so if you're looking for a YA story to keep you hooked right to the very last chapter, this is one you definitely need to pick up.
Profile Image for Ruja.
253 reviews
September 29, 2026
I bought this book from a bookstore in London not realizing it was a YA book. I don’t generally love YA, but this is beautifully written and has a lot of depth.

It’s a historical mystery set during WWII in England with a sweet romantic storyline as well. The back cover perfectly sums it up with three words: wartime, mystery and romance.

I love that the title comes from Romeo and Juliet and the FMC’s name is Juliet.
Profile Image for Charley.
93 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
August 20, 2026
Wow wow wow what doesn't this book have? Gorgeous historical setting of wartime Britain, a divine romance between our sweet lead Juliet and charming, scarred Bertie, and a mystery that kept me guessing throughout! What a delightful book, utterly readable and a perfect choice for any YA readers that want something a bit different!
Profile Image for Jodie.
162 reviews
September 19, 2026
It was good I just wasn't blown away by it. Also, the epilogue contained a detail that seemed extremely unbelievable having followed Juliet's "investigative" thought process throughout the mystery portion of the book. I would love a multi-pov continuation slice of life novel though.
Profile Image for Rosie Hayward.
228 reviews
September 27, 2026
Any book that can make me cry like this gets 5 stars. Immediately. I’m in love with Flight Lieutenant Bertie Campbell. He’s wizard.

Poor Juliet did spend a good 70% of this book in bed sobbing her heart out bless her. Glad everything worked out in the end.
Profile Image for ThatBookGal.
758 reviews104 followers
October 4, 2026
This was cute, and lots about it left warm fuzzies. I thought the ‘mystery’ element of the book was fairly obvious and most of the twists were not particularly surprising. Overall a sweet story and the sisters blossoming relationship with each other, was just lovely!
Profile Image for Chrissie.
2 reviews
October 14, 2026
I bought this book as it was Waterstones' YA book of the month for September and it looked really interesting. I enjoyed the fact that it blended historical fiction, with a crime plot and a romance. The characters were engaging and it was an easy and enjoyable read with a satisfying conclusion.
Profile Image for Laura Garcia Moreno.
90 reviews
October 27, 2026
Teens will EAT this up!!!!! But it wasn’t for me, it was Laura Wood adjacent (characters were so charming) but a bit too melodramatic at times for my taste. Fast paced and it reads so quickly - it has barely taken me two evenings.
Profile Image for Erin.
240 reviews3 followers
November 5, 2026
Thanks to Libro.fm for this free audiobook!

This was such an atmospheric book and each character felt solid. Truly lovely to listen too. The mystery was good but the characters and the love felt in family, friends, and romance really made this for me.
Profile Image for Sophie ꔫ.
65 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Book of the Month
August 13, 2026
YA book of the month next month, sped through it on my cover shift with nieve! lowkey absolutely fantastic icl
Profile Image for Dara Tinius.
606 reviews45 followers
August 27, 2026
I love Lucy Strange's gothic middle grade books. I am not sure this was as successful for a YA audience.
4 reviews
September 10, 2026
The sweetest coming of age story! The fmcs love for poems resonated with me so much. The ending was so cute and perfect loved this book !
3 reviews
September 13, 2026
Was expecting to really enjoy this but it ended up being rather disappointing.
the ending felt rushed and it didn't seem as if the author respects first loves.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews