Jade Anderson has learned the hard way that love is not a promise, it’s a risk. Years ago, she believed in forever with the one person who made her feel chosen… until he didn’t. Since then, she’s built her life on independence, control, and the quiet safety of lowered expectations.
Evan Ballard is everything she swore she’d never let back in. He’s history. Heartbreak. A chapter she closed to survive.
When their lives collide again, the past refuses to stay buried. Old feelings resurface. Boundaries blur. And the fragile balance Jade has fought so hard to maintain begins to crack.
Because some connections don’t fade with time.
They deepen.
They wait.
And sometimes, the most dangerous question isn’t what happened then—
it’s what could happen now.
Forever, Maybe? is an emotional, slow-burn second-chance romance about unfinished love, timing, and the terrifying hope that some stories aren’t over… even when they hurt the most.
Mom of two, wife, and unapologetic Michigan native—born and raised with the Great Lakes in my veins. I’m proud to call the Upper Peninsula home, where the air is crisp, the people wave from their porches, and every season feels like its own adventure.
“Today she stopped surviving; today she started living.”
This was a really wonderful novel that explores the messy and realistic complications of relationships as an adult. I found it very sweet that even as time has passed, the love the two people (Jade and Evan) have for each other continued to wait patiently for the right time to flourish. I didn’t quite feel as pulled toward this book because of the pregnancy trope, so if a reader is into that then this is right up their alley. Again, I did like the plot thought of two characters who are so in love and who explore that indomitable love and heal from old wounds.
Thank you Isla Quinn for the digital ARC of this book.
If I could rate this story on just Jade's character, 5 stars.
I loved her story and how real it felt. She struggled with her feelings for Evan even though she knew that they shouldn't be together. I found her character so real and relatable. I also wanted to hug her. She has worked so hard for everything she had and was doing so well. She deserved everything good in life.
I struggled to like Evan in this story. I almost wanted them not to be together. I don't know that I really ever believed him in the end. It still didn't feel like he chose her, and that's all she wanted. She wanted to be someone's first choice. I found it difficult to trust anything he told Jade.
Overall, Jade was my favorite and such a great character. I just adored her.
I had the opportunity to read an advanced copy of Forever… Maybe? by Isla R. Quinn. I gave this book 4 stars. Normally I don’t love second chance romances, but Isla did a great job with this one. The redemption arc for the MMC was realistic and well written. If you like second chance romances, real world issues, and the single father, and surprise pregnancy tropes, I would highly recommend giving this book a read.
Forever… Maybe? is one of those emotional second-chance romances where the love never really died - it just got buried under years of heartbreak, regret, grief, and bad timing.
Jade and Evan were supposed to run away together after high school, but when Evan chooses his future over their relationship, Jade leaves anyway and spends the next 12 years rebuilding herself from nothing. By the time they meet again, she’s strong, guarded, and determined never to let him hurt her again.
Unfortunately for her… chemistry apparently doesn’t care about emotional trauma 😅
This story was messy in the best way. There’s grief, pregnancy complications, custody drama, betrayal, unresolved feelings, and enough emotional tension to make me want to shake both characters repeatedly.
Jade was such a strong FMC, and I loved that despite everything she went through, she still built a life for herself. Evan drove me insane sometimes, but his POV chapters added so much context to his behavior. Once you understand how much guilt and grief he’s carrying, his emotional walls make a lot more sense.
And listen… a broken pediatric doctor who shows up devastated after losing a patient and ends up emotionally spiraling into his ex-girlfriend’s bed? I was DONE FOR 🖤
This book definitely leans heavily into emotional drama, so if you prefer quieter romances this may not be for you. But if you love:
emotional slow burns second chances longing and regret complicated relationships high emotional stakes “I never stopped loving you” vibes
…you’ll probably eat this up like I did.
The ending felt earned, emotional, and hopeful after everything these two survived.
Definitely a whirlwind of feelings from beginning to end.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Received as an ARC from the author, this is my honest review.
Forever, Maybe is an emotional, second-chance romance about unfinished love, timing, and the terrifying hope that some stories aren’t over… even when they hurt the most.
What I enjoyed most about this book was that the story felt real, and raw.
The FMC being a foster child who experienced a disconnect from being part of a family, then experienced what was to her, abandonment from someone who promised her the world and was strong enough to make a solid life for herself… was uplifting.
Overall, it was a quick read that reminds you that you never know how your past will affect your future.
Favorite Quote: Forever didn’t feel like a fairy tale, it simply felt like coming home.
Why this wasn’t 5 stars for me: (spoiler alert)
These may be more personal preferences, but I could not stand the MMC’s blatant and sometimes what felt like manipulative disregard for the MMC. In the end, he does redeem himself, but his character was extremely aggravating to me. Maybe that was intentional?
The instant hook-up right after 12 years of not seeing each other did feel a bit rushed as one of the tropes said slow burn, so this was a bit confusing.
Their emotional connection was a bit all over the place for me, I wanted a bit more of that to really bring home their choices at the end of book.
Forever…Maybe had a good story with a comprehensive plot. I think I liked the FMC (Jade) more than the MMC (Evan). Whether he was scared and young or not, he should have understood how his words and actions would affect her because they had been close for a long time and her knew her situation. This is obviously a second chance romance and Evan is one lucky guy since Jade should not even be talking to him. I enjoyed the build up to Jade making her final decision as well as the emotional depth that Evan showed at times. This was a good read and I am thankful to have received this book from the author to read and review.
This is a deeply emotional second-chance contemporary romance, with heartbreaking and heartwarming moments woven throughout.
Jade and Evan have a messy, imperfect love. They each go through their own struggles while finding their way with one another. There’s a lot of depth in the writing, which drew me into the story, and I really liked how it showcased their romance and their growth at a slow, gradual pace.
If you enjoy an emotionally charged romance that’s complicated in all the best ways, this may be a good read for you.
This book was given to me as an ARC here is my honest and voluntarily review. This book hooked me from the first chapter . He made a promise She believed him waited for him to leave together and start their new life and He breaks her heart ❤️. The tension, heart felt hesitation, and the lingering “what ifs” kept me hooked the entire time. I loved the story, second chance romance ❤️🔥 loved every minute of it .
I read this book so quickly. I’m glad I requested this book because Isla really pulls you into the story and describes mental health issues, how people protect themselves and what fear can do to your wellbeing so well.
Evan and Jade reconnected after a chance encounter and their trauma from past hurts brings them back together. This is a beautifully written story full of pain, longing, love and found family.
Thank you Isla for the opportunity to read this eARC early!
This book definitely was an emotional roller coaster. And definitely made me mad the characters with just yelling at them just say how you actually feel and stop being stubborn. Jade has a lot of trauma and trust issues. Where Evan is a man going through so much in such a short amount of time. This book had so many heartfelt moments. Their relationship is something at moments wanted to fail and other moments were rooting for them.
I enjoyed this book. Jade had gone through so much from a young age. Evan the love of her life made plans with her after graduation to have a life together. After graduation her world crumbled. Evan her the love of her life, the one she trusted broke her heart and trust. Many years later, they reconnect unexpected and well you have to read this book to see what happens.
A soft, introspective romance that leans into the “what ifs” of love rather than perfect endings. Isla R. Quinn captures the quiet, messy reality of feelings and timing, with characters who feel real even when they’re frustrating. Not the fastest paced, but emotionally honest and relatable.
Evan & Jade's story is heartbreaking and healing. They get their second chance at love when they meet 12 years after they had last seen each other. They have been through so much and now they have to learn each other and heal from the past!
I got this as a arc read and it was an amazing g read read it in one day! Beautiful storyline full of emotions wrapped around trauma young love forbidden then reunited it was a heartfelt story
This was a 3.5 star read for me. I really enjoyed it, it was a good read that left me wanting to know what was going to happen next. I loved how everything turned out in the end 🥰
First, I received this book as an ARC. This book made me feel overwhelming happiness as well as sadness throughout different parts of it. Very well written, Isla Quinn!! I loved the whole story! It was very relatable even though I’ve never been in that situation. I could definitely feel all of the emotions that were very well described!
I had an opportunity to receive an ARC read of Forever…Maybe? A Love Story by Isla R. Quinn. This book was filled with past trauma and how to cope with your past being a part of your future. The story had me connected with the characters and invested in both their past and their future!
Jade was born from nothing and her upbringing was rough and filled with heartbreak at every turn as she was a child of the system which shaped her adult years and forced independence because that’s all she knew.
Evan had it all from the start. The perfect life, parents that would pay for his future, but he faced a dilemma in his young adulthood that further tore Jade to pieces and forced her to begin her adult life the way she lived her childhood: alone.
As adults, their reconnection is relatable and emotional. The story left you guessing if the damage was too far gone for it to all work out in the end.