What do you think?
Enchanting Confections
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries
A dab of pumpkin, a dusting of cinders, and a drizzle of midnight baking that could change everything.
Celine Blackthorne is the secret ingredient behind the kingdom’s most fashionable bakery. While her stepmother and stepsisters bask in the dining room spotlight, Celine bakes and cleans in the basement kitchen. When a Royal Patisserie Competition threatens to expose her family’s lack of coin and lack of talent, Celine must take matters into her own flour-dusted hands and save the family business.
With the help of the cobbler’s apprentice next door, Celine risks her anonymity to save the people who take her for granted. But when the contest requires her to leave the bakery for the ballroom, Celine’s secret participation may not stay secret for long. As heat rises in the royal kitchen, Celine must decide if she’s baking for her family’s approval or for a love that’s as sweet as it is unexpected.
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries, a retelling of Cinderella with nods to the Great British Bakeoff, is a standalone novella, complete with tropes such as friends to lovers, found family, and royal competition. It is part of The Enchanting Confections series, a collection of clean and cozy stories guaranteed to delight your sweet tooth.
Celine Blackthorne is the secret ingredient behind the kingdom’s most fashionable bakery. While her stepmother and stepsisters bask in the dining room spotlight, Celine bakes and cleans in the basement kitchen. When a Royal Patisserie Competition threatens to expose her family’s lack of coin and lack of talent, Celine must take matters into her own flour-dusted hands and save the family business.
With the help of the cobbler’s apprentice next door, Celine risks her anonymity to save the people who take her for granted. But when the contest requires her to leave the bakery for the ballroom, Celine’s secret participation may not stay secret for long. As heat rises in the royal kitchen, Celine must decide if she’s baking for her family’s approval or for a love that’s as sweet as it is unexpected.
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries, a retelling of Cinderella with nods to the Great British Bakeoff, is a standalone novella, complete with tropes such as friends to lovers, found family, and royal competition. It is part of The Enchanting Confections series, a collection of clean and cozy stories guaranteed to delight your sweet tooth.
238 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 29, 2026
About the author
A.G. Marshall
25 books327 followersA.G. Marshall grew up in libraries and has been writing since she could hold a pencil. She loves fairy tales, witty banter, and heroines who aren’t afraid to save themselves. When she’s not writing or teaching piano lessons, she enjoys dancing and traveling the world.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 91 reviews
June 26, 2026
4.5 stars ⭐️ Clean Fiction - Fairytale Retelling (no magic)
“Thank you all so much for helping me. I couldn’t have done this without you.”
“You could have, but I don’t think you would have.”
(This part perfectly describes our Cinderella and her love interest 🥹)
This was adorable, I have tears in my eyes at the happiness of that ending. Which is exactly how I want to feel after reading a wonderful fairytale retelling. I’m literally this emoji: 🥹🥹🥹🥹
I didn’t want to put the book down to make notes, that’s how you know I was fully invested into the story and didn’t want to stop reading. “Sleep? Who needs sleep? Not me.” says the girl who finished this book at three am. Whoops. But it was just too cute and completely distracted me from everything. Currently sitting at a 4.5 star rating 🌟
- Cinderella retelling
- no magic
- lots of baking
- single POV with a bonus in the love interest's POV
- sweetest Cinderella that has to learn to stand up for herself
- green flag love interest
- step-mother and stepsisters were awful but not eye-twitching awful
- super clean
- very much reminiscing of The Great British Bake-Off
- precious overall and a 4.5 star rating from me
Jacque was great. Arthur was great. Shadow was great. Mouse was especially great. 🥰 I hope we can have spin-off books set in this world with Jacque and the princess’ stories.
The stepmother was subtly awful, but not absolutely horrible hold-me-back-or-I’m-gonna-pull-her-hair-out level. The stepsisters were decent and not evil—perhaps overstepping and not realizing that their wishes were sacrifices for Celine, but not super evil—so that was nice. My eye didn’t twitch at all with these three unlike other Cinderella retellings I’ve read, which is often my gauge for that.
Did I know where the Cinderella plot was going? Yes. Did I care? Absolutely not. This was a fantastic version of Cinderella and even as someone who would take a potato in any form rather than a slice of cake, I greatly enjoyed this fall-themed, dessert-themed retelling of it.
Make sure you read the bonus story that is in Mouse’s POV. It was precious and solidified my opinion that he was such a green flag love interest because of wanting to help Celine stand up for herself without berating her or being frustrated with her like other male leads might be; he truly cared for her and her well-being.
This was my first book by this author and while I’m an easy sell on Cinderella retellings, I cannot wait to read more of her books now because after reading this book, I’m giddy at the thought of potentially finding a new fairytale retelling author to read.
Last note, but if you loved “The Reluctant Godfather” by Allison Tebo &/or “Callie and the Pumpkin Seed” by Sarah Beran: you have great taste, but also you would probably really enjoy this book as well! Those are more humorous and while this book had moments of that, it was still super sweet and enjoyable with a ton of baking.
Main Content-
Spiritual-
A few mentions of magic and fairy godmothers (which are implied not to be real); A mention of fate denying a woman her husband (due to his early death).
Language-
No language stronger than ‘blast it all’ (used twice in the bonus short story); A mention of someone swearing (not written out).
Negative-
While Celine’s step-family are not incredibly cruel/evil, they do have ways of manipulating her and due to it, she’s come to believe that if she puts her needs or wants before theirs, it is selfish of her; There are scenes of being locked in a room, items destroyed, & moments of them berating, being unkind to, and excluding Celine from events.
Mentions of deaths & grief (including Celine for her parents and what could have been with her step-family); Mentions of lies, lying, & deception (which is suggested for Celine to do, but she does not); Mentions of gossip & rumors (including a story that goes around about the prince that is believed, but is not true); A few mentions of a possible kidnapping; A couple mentions of stealing & jail.
Sexual/Romance-
3 hand/fingers kisses,
1 almost kiss (a sentence),
1 kiss lasting a sentence with no details,
Remembering hand/fingers kisses and warmth (up to a couple sentences).
Some touches, embraces, nearness, warmth, noticing, blushes, & attraction (up to 2-3 sentences).
Mentions of being sweet on someone; A mention of flirting.
“Thank you all so much for helping me. I couldn’t have done this without you.”
“You could have, but I don’t think you would have.”
(This part perfectly describes our Cinderella and her love interest 🥹)
This was adorable, I have tears in my eyes at the happiness of that ending. Which is exactly how I want to feel after reading a wonderful fairytale retelling. I’m literally this emoji: 🥹🥹🥹🥹
I didn’t want to put the book down to make notes, that’s how you know I was fully invested into the story and didn’t want to stop reading. “Sleep? Who needs sleep? Not me.” says the girl who finished this book at three am. Whoops. But it was just too cute and completely distracted me from everything. Currently sitting at a 4.5 star rating 🌟
- Cinderella retelling
- no magic
- lots of baking
- single POV with a bonus in the love interest's POV
- sweetest Cinderella that has to learn to stand up for herself
- green flag love interest
- step-mother and stepsisters were awful but not eye-twitching awful
- super clean
- very much reminiscing of The Great British Bake-Off
- precious overall and a 4.5 star rating from me
Jacque was great. Arthur was great. Shadow was great. Mouse was especially great. 🥰 I hope we can have spin-off books set in this world with Jacque and the princess’ stories.
The stepmother was subtly awful, but not absolutely horrible hold-me-back-or-I’m-gonna-pull-her-hair-out level. The stepsisters were decent and not evil—perhaps overstepping and not realizing that their wishes were sacrifices for Celine, but not super evil—so that was nice. My eye didn’t twitch at all with these three unlike other Cinderella retellings I’ve read, which is often my gauge for that.
Did I know where the Cinderella plot was going? Yes. Did I care? Absolutely not. This was a fantastic version of Cinderella and even as someone who would take a potato in any form rather than a slice of cake, I greatly enjoyed this fall-themed, dessert-themed retelling of it.
Make sure you read the bonus story that is in Mouse’s POV. It was precious and solidified my opinion that he was such a green flag love interest because of wanting to help Celine stand up for herself without berating her or being frustrated with her like other male leads might be; he truly cared for her and her well-being.
This was my first book by this author and while I’m an easy sell on Cinderella retellings, I cannot wait to read more of her books now because after reading this book, I’m giddy at the thought of potentially finding a new fairytale retelling author to read.
Last note, but if you loved “The Reluctant Godfather” by Allison Tebo &/or “Callie and the Pumpkin Seed” by Sarah Beran: you have great taste, but also you would probably really enjoy this book as well! Those are more humorous and while this book had moments of that, it was still super sweet and enjoyable with a ton of baking.
Main Content-
Spiritual-
A few mentions of magic and fairy godmothers (which are implied not to be real); A mention of fate denying a woman her husband (due to his early death).
Language-
No language stronger than ‘blast it all’ (used twice in the bonus short story); A mention of someone swearing (not written out).
Negative-
While Celine’s step-family are not incredibly cruel/evil, they do have ways of manipulating her and due to it, she’s come to believe that if she puts her needs or wants before theirs, it is selfish of her; There are scenes of being locked in a room, items destroyed, & moments of them berating, being unkind to, and excluding Celine from events.
Mentions of deaths & grief (including Celine for her parents and what could have been with her step-family); Mentions of lies, lying, & deception (which is suggested for Celine to do, but she does not); Mentions of gossip & rumors (including a story that goes around about the prince that is believed, but is not true); A few mentions of a possible kidnapping; A couple mentions of stealing & jail.
Sexual/Romance-
3 hand/fingers kisses,
1 almost kiss (a sentence),
1 kiss lasting a sentence with no details,
Remembering hand/fingers kisses and warmth (up to a couple sentences).
Some touches, embraces, nearness, warmth, noticing, blushes, & attraction (up to 2-3 sentences).
Mentions of being sweet on someone; A mention of flirting.
![Profile Image for Jacquelyn 💐 {This Rapunzel Reads} [Jesus Christ, my Living Hope].](https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/users/1783567243i/169222098._UX200_CR0,0,200,200_.jpg)
May 12, 2026
I received this e-book arc from the author in exchange for an honest review. OK, this was an adorable retelling of Cinderella. I loved all of the baking aspects and how different and yet similar it was to the Cinderella story. Celine was such a sweet character. I just loved her. Mouse was definitely interesting. The two of them were super cute together. I do wish I would’ve seen more of them together. I loved just everything that was so different in this retelling. It came together so well. I did guess the plot twist and I thought it was great. This is definitely a good fall read! The cover is just adorable! I love pumpkin, so this is right up my alley. I definitely recommend and can’t wait to get my hands on a physical copy!
August 22, 2026
4.5 stars
I am really glad I read this book. It's pretty good, not the best, but very well done. This is my second book from Mrs. Marshall and I really love the way she portrays her characters and the way they feel or make others feel.
The way Cinder family's didn't like her is very relatable. It wasn't an upfront hate, where you know and everybody knows and we all think Cinder is dumb because she is the only one who doesn't see it. They weren't verbally or physically abusive with her but psychologically. At times, you could she how she felt like she was part of her step family and she was important for them. And yes, she was, but not in the way she imagined. She was taken advantage of many times because she was always trying to fit in but you then she that her "family" was leaving her out all the time.
The short story didn't add anything to the main story, so don't bother reading it. And I have a question: what's up with all the credits made by Cinder's stepmother? It wasn't explained what happened with that.
Also this book is not lighthearted and cute. There's no banter between the main characters and there's not much romance even tho you can clearly see they were made for each other.
I am not sure I agreed the reason of the prince for lying. It felt weird, out of place and unnecessary.
Warning: excessive descriptions of pastries, baking procedures and French names of sweets (which I love btw).
Favorite quotes:
"Many foolish people in this world will underestimate you. Why do their work for them by underestimating yourself?”
“Gilding imperfections only makes the flaws shine brighter.”
"When you’re treated well by one group, it makes it easier to see that another is taking advantage of you."
I am really glad I read this book. It's pretty good, not the best, but very well done. This is my second book from Mrs. Marshall and I really love the way she portrays her characters and the way they feel or make others feel.
The way Cinder family's didn't like her is very relatable. It wasn't an upfront hate, where you know and everybody knows and we all think Cinder is dumb because she is the only one who doesn't see it. They weren't verbally or physically abusive with her but psychologically. At times, you could she how she felt like she was part of her step family and she was important for them. And yes, she was, but not in the way she imagined. She was taken advantage of many times because she was always trying to fit in but you then she that her "family" was leaving her out all the time.
The short story didn't add anything to the main story, so don't bother reading it. And I have a question: what's up with all the credits made by Cinder's stepmother? It wasn't explained what happened with that.
Also this book is not lighthearted and cute. There's no banter between the main characters and there's not much romance even tho you can clearly see they were made for each other.
I am not sure I agreed the reason of the prince for lying. It felt weird, out of place and unnecessary.
Warning: excessive descriptions of pastries, baking procedures and French names of sweets (which I love btw).
Favorite quotes:
"Many foolish people in this world will underestimate you. Why do their work for them by underestimating yourself?”
“Gilding imperfections only makes the flaws shine brighter.”
"When you’re treated well by one group, it makes it easier to see that another is taking advantage of you."
May 17, 2026
ARC Review - A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries by A.G Marshall.
10/10! I devoured this book and loved everything about it. A standalone Cinderella retelling, part of the multi author Enchanting Confections.
What if Cinderella became Celine, and she wanted to enter a royal baking contest instead of going to a ball. This version of Celine as a baker and making friends with “Mouse” the next door cobbler apprentice. It’s such a sweet story with heartfelt moments.
Celine’s terrible stepmother and stepsisters are the absolute worst! I did get annoyed with Celine at some point because she was so blind, but it was also because she had such a pure heart.
Mouse and all the other characters climbs right into your heart and the story just makes you feel all giddy.
I will happily recommend to all readers who enjoys a great fairytale retelling. A no spice, friends to lovers with awesome found family and it will leave your mouth watering for all the delicious pasties made!!
10/10! I devoured this book and loved everything about it. A standalone Cinderella retelling, part of the multi author Enchanting Confections.
What if Cinderella became Celine, and she wanted to enter a royal baking contest instead of going to a ball. This version of Celine as a baker and making friends with “Mouse” the next door cobbler apprentice. It’s such a sweet story with heartfelt moments.
Celine’s terrible stepmother and stepsisters are the absolute worst! I did get annoyed with Celine at some point because she was so blind, but it was also because she had such a pure heart.
Mouse and all the other characters climbs right into your heart and the story just makes you feel all giddy.
I will happily recommend to all readers who enjoys a great fairytale retelling. A no spice, friends to lovers with awesome found family and it will leave your mouth watering for all the delicious pasties made!!
May 31, 2026
AG has a way of writing that is so wonderful! I will read anything she writes!
She has taken a somewhat overdone fairytale and breathed new life into it! What a great read! And the food!! Oh, to be a character in the book who gets to sample all of the yummies!
Loved this read!
The whole series so far is such a "sweet-treat." Yep! Went there!
Can't wait for more deliciousness (oops!) from this MAS!!
She has taken a somewhat overdone fairytale and breathed new life into it! What a great read! And the food!! Oh, to be a character in the book who gets to sample all of the yummies!
Loved this read!
The whole series so far is such a "sweet-treat." Yep! Went there!
Can't wait for more deliciousness (oops!) from this MAS!!
September 1, 2026
This was such a CUTE "Cinderella" retelling! Substitutes a Ball for a baking competition. Clever names for characters and a adorable twist! 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Review of advance copy received from Author
This was my first novella by this author but I had enjoyed a couple much shorter short stories by her previously and had high hopes for this since it sounded fun. This book met my expectations and was a really enjoyable Retelling of Cinderella full of fall vibes, wonderful sounding desserts, and interesting characters. I loved getting to know both Celine "Cinder" and Mouse and seeing Celine realize her growing feelings for him. This story also has a lot of fun side characters including the other baker's in the competition. Celine's step mother as well as her step sister Eugenie were extremely unappreciative of all Celine did for them but her step sister Felicity wasn't as bad. The epilogue was a fun look into the future and I plan to read more by this author.
Steam Rating: Glimpses and Kisses 🔥
I received a free advanced reader copy of this book from the Enchanting Confections ARC Team and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Steam Rating: Glimpses and Kisses 🔥
I received a free advanced reader copy of this book from the Enchanting Confections ARC Team and am voluntarily leaving a review.
May 22, 2026
*I received an ARC from the author, and all opinions are my own.
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries is a cozy, delectable Cinderella retelling with friends-to-lovers, baking competitions, and finding your worth!
This book was so cute! It had super cozy vibes and was a wonderful take on the Cinderella story.
I loved the take on Cinderella. One of my favorite Cinderella retellings is The Coronation Ball by Melanie Cellier, mainly because it took place in a baking setting. This book did that but on a deeper level that I really enjoyed. We got the stepfamily cruelty, but it more nuanced in this book. Honestly, for part of this book I was struggling to figure out if they were being mean or just oblivious. The author did an amazing job of making this hard for the reader to figure out right along with Celine. I also loved how the prince was incorporated into this story. It wasn’t a ball to find a bride, but a welcome home ball, which I like a little more. The way the shoes were incorporated was absolutely amazing and I loved it so, so much! It was perfect and fit the story so well.
Celine was an amazing character! She was so kind and hardworking. A big part of the book was her finding her self-worth and realizing that she was talented and mattered. It was an incredibly moving storyline, and I loved how Mouse guided her, but also wasn’t forceful. Celine had the classic Cinderella kindness, but it felt more realistic and authentic this book. There was some grief exploration, but it wasn’t the center of the book.
I loved Mouse! He was such a sweet character, and I loved how he cared for Celine. He was always showing up for her no matter what, and even when she didn’t ask. It was so sweet and I loved their friendship!
The romance was a friends-to-lovers, as well as a little bit of a slow burn. It took most of the book for their feelings to be realized, but I loved seeing them as friends. And the ending where they chose each other and discussed what their lives would be like together was very sweet.
The stepfamily was interesting. Again, they were written wonderfully, as it was hard to figure out if they were meaning to be cruel. They were and the way they treated Celine was awful and became progressively worse.
The baking in this book was absolutely amazing! I am not the biggest baker, but I do love a good baked good. This entire book I was wanting to jump up and make something delicious. It was wonderfully immersive- you really felt like you were in a bakery. The bakery and the competition were the perfect setting and made the story so unique and fun. This has been compared to The Great British Bake Off, but fantasy, and while I haven’t seen a lot of that show, I have to agree. This is pure baking show vibes and I adored it.
I also loved the baking competition contestants! They were amazing and they were so kind and considerate towards Celine. Arthur, Martha, and Jacque were wonderful characters. I especially loved the quiet way Arthur cared for Celine- it was sweet and fatherly, providing nice moments of kindness and support throughout the story. Jacque was also a lovely character, who provided some humor throughout the story.
The ending was so sweet! I love a good ending, and this one was wonderful. It was everything I want from a fairytale, and I was very happy with it. I also particularly liked how Celine took time to heal before she married. I thought that was a nice inclusion.
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries is a cozy Cinderella retelling, with friendship, baking, and realizing your worth!
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries will be released on May 29, 2026.
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries is a cozy, delectable Cinderella retelling with friends-to-lovers, baking competitions, and finding your worth!
This book was so cute! It had super cozy vibes and was a wonderful take on the Cinderella story.
I loved the take on Cinderella. One of my favorite Cinderella retellings is The Coronation Ball by Melanie Cellier, mainly because it took place in a baking setting. This book did that but on a deeper level that I really enjoyed. We got the stepfamily cruelty, but it more nuanced in this book. Honestly, for part of this book I was struggling to figure out if they were being mean or just oblivious. The author did an amazing job of making this hard for the reader to figure out right along with Celine. I also loved how the prince was incorporated into this story. It wasn’t a ball to find a bride, but a welcome home ball, which I like a little more. The way the shoes were incorporated was absolutely amazing and I loved it so, so much! It was perfect and fit the story so well.
Celine was an amazing character! She was so kind and hardworking. A big part of the book was her finding her self-worth and realizing that she was talented and mattered. It was an incredibly moving storyline, and I loved how Mouse guided her, but also wasn’t forceful. Celine had the classic Cinderella kindness, but it felt more realistic and authentic this book. There was some grief exploration, but it wasn’t the center of the book.
I loved Mouse! He was such a sweet character, and I loved how he cared for Celine. He was always showing up for her no matter what, and even when she didn’t ask. It was so sweet and I loved their friendship!
The romance was a friends-to-lovers, as well as a little bit of a slow burn. It took most of the book for their feelings to be realized, but I loved seeing them as friends. And the ending where they chose each other and discussed what their lives would be like together was very sweet.
The stepfamily was interesting. Again, they were written wonderfully, as it was hard to figure out if they were meaning to be cruel. They were and the way they treated Celine was awful and became progressively worse.
The baking in this book was absolutely amazing! I am not the biggest baker, but I do love a good baked good. This entire book I was wanting to jump up and make something delicious. It was wonderfully immersive- you really felt like you were in a bakery. The bakery and the competition were the perfect setting and made the story so unique and fun. This has been compared to The Great British Bake Off, but fantasy, and while I haven’t seen a lot of that show, I have to agree. This is pure baking show vibes and I adored it.
I also loved the baking competition contestants! They were amazing and they were so kind and considerate towards Celine. Arthur, Martha, and Jacque were wonderful characters. I especially loved the quiet way Arthur cared for Celine- it was sweet and fatherly, providing nice moments of kindness and support throughout the story. Jacque was also a lovely character, who provided some humor throughout the story.
The ending was so sweet! I love a good ending, and this one was wonderful. It was everything I want from a fairytale, and I was very happy with it. I also particularly liked how Celine took time to heal before she married. I thought that was a nice inclusion.
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries is a cozy Cinderella retelling, with friendship, baking, and realizing your worth!
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries will be released on May 29, 2026.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Solid 4.5 stars!
Y’all, this has got to be one of my favorite Cinderella retellings of all time! A. G. Marshall, you have yourself a new devoted reader! This book was super cozy, with just enough tension to keep me up until midnight.
You know those baking competition shows? I felt like I was in one of them! Also, as someone who could probably burn water, I was able to follow along really well and wasn’t confused by the technical terms. I’ve never read a book with this sort of plot before, and I loved it!
*Sigh of delight* Mouse and Celine’s romance was squeaky clean. Seriously, if I had to define a cozy comfort read, it would be this book. Although I guessed the twist involving a certain character from the beginning, I really didn’t care because I was enjoying the story so much.
I think it’s amazing and very admirable that Celine loved her family and wanted to care for them in any way she could. However, it did get to a certain point where I really wanted her to stand up for herself. In my opinion, she was a bit of a pushover earlier in the story. I was relieved when she finally realized that her family was mistreating her and that she deserved better.
If I had to pick a favorite character, it would definitely be Jaques! He’s such a rascal, but at the same time he’s so sweet. He completely stole every scene he was in with his sass!
My favorite quote...
“You suit that dress,” he said. “Don’t you mean it suits me?” “It didn’t look half so good before you put it on.”
_________________________
Brief overview of the romance content
- Light noticing
- 2 hand kisses
- A non-detailed kiss
- He rests he forehead against hers briefly
Brief overview of other content
- Some verbal abuse
- Gaslighting
- A bit of grief over the death of a parent. (In the past)
_________________________
Overall, this was such a sweet book with barely any content, so I would personally be comfortable recommending it for ages 12 and up. Thanks to the author for the arc copy!
Y’all, this has got to be one of my favorite Cinderella retellings of all time! A. G. Marshall, you have yourself a new devoted reader! This book was super cozy, with just enough tension to keep me up until midnight.
You know those baking competition shows? I felt like I was in one of them! Also, as someone who could probably burn water, I was able to follow along really well and wasn’t confused by the technical terms. I’ve never read a book with this sort of plot before, and I loved it!
*Sigh of delight* Mouse and Celine’s romance was squeaky clean. Seriously, if I had to define a cozy comfort read, it would be this book. Although I guessed the twist involving a certain character from the beginning, I really didn’t care because I was enjoying the story so much.
I think it’s amazing and very admirable that Celine loved her family and wanted to care for them in any way she could. However, it did get to a certain point where I really wanted her to stand up for herself. In my opinion, she was a bit of a pushover earlier in the story. I was relieved when she finally realized that her family was mistreating her and that she deserved better.
If I had to pick a favorite character, it would definitely be Jaques! He’s such a rascal, but at the same time he’s so sweet. He completely stole every scene he was in with his sass!
My favorite quote...
“You suit that dress,” he said. “Don’t you mean it suits me?” “It didn’t look half so good before you put it on.”
_________________________
Brief overview of the romance content
- Light noticing
- 2 hand kisses
- A non-detailed kiss
- He rests he forehead against hers briefly
Brief overview of other content
- Some verbal abuse
- Gaslighting
- A bit of grief over the death of a parent. (In the past)
_________________________
Overall, this was such a sweet book with barely any content, so I would personally be comfortable recommending it for ages 12 and up. Thanks to the author for the arc copy!
June 1, 2026
I received an early copy from the author but all thoughts and opinions are my own :)
I was completely blown away with this adorable retelling of Cinderella. The fairyale is so incredibly well known and reimagines so many times that I wasn't sure what the author was going to come up with. I simply could not put this story down. I read it within a couple of ours. Celine is an incredibly kind and thoughtful FMC (true to the Cinderella character) but our MMC was the most pleasant suprise. He is everything a partner should be. Caring, thoughtful, assertive, and discerning. A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries perfectly captures what a beautiful and loving relationship should be and how kidness in the end always ends up rewarded in the best way. It may not be in the way we imagined but it is always so much more. It also captures all the right elements of the origional Cinderella story while also giving the same magical and inspiring feel of the live action movie that Disney did. The romance is subtle but in the BESt way. You watch a love that is founded on friendship and respect, grow and creep up on the main characters and I found myself falling in love with their love. I actually want more of their life after the story because I fell in love with these characters and their relationship to the point I couldnt get enought of them. Disapointment that there wasn't more to read when I got to the end of the book is not something I have felt when reading in a bit. But more importantly I loved the message of still being a kind, loving, and genergous AND being able to go after what you want and need. Often when you are a generous and loving person you feel that the ability to go after what you want and need cannot cohabitate with being a good person. I loved watching the FMC learn that this is not the case and that both can exist and that by helping yourself you are abile to give so much more. If you havent read this little book yet, you NEED to! If you have a long TBR put in on there, this is also a perfect Fall read and you can save it for that cozy time of the year!
I was completely blown away with this adorable retelling of Cinderella. The fairyale is so incredibly well known and reimagines so many times that I wasn't sure what the author was going to come up with. I simply could not put this story down. I read it within a couple of ours. Celine is an incredibly kind and thoughtful FMC (true to the Cinderella character) but our MMC was the most pleasant suprise. He is everything a partner should be. Caring, thoughtful, assertive, and discerning. A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries perfectly captures what a beautiful and loving relationship should be and how kidness in the end always ends up rewarded in the best way. It may not be in the way we imagined but it is always so much more. It also captures all the right elements of the origional Cinderella story while also giving the same magical and inspiring feel of the live action movie that Disney did. The romance is subtle but in the BESt way. You watch a love that is founded on friendship and respect, grow and creep up on the main characters and I found myself falling in love with their love. I actually want more of their life after the story because I fell in love with these characters and their relationship to the point I couldnt get enought of them. Disapointment that there wasn't more to read when I got to the end of the book is not something I have felt when reading in a bit. But more importantly I loved the message of still being a kind, loving, and genergous AND being able to go after what you want and need. Often when you are a generous and loving person you feel that the ability to go after what you want and need cannot cohabitate with being a good person. I loved watching the FMC learn that this is not the case and that both can exist and that by helping yourself you are abile to give so much more. If you havent read this little book yet, you NEED to! If you have a long TBR put in on there, this is also a perfect Fall read and you can save it for that cozy time of the year!
Review of advance copy received from Author
Gut rating: ⭐⭐⭐
CAWPILE rating: TBD
Spice: Kisses
ARC publication date: May 29th 2026
Tropes: Cinderella inspired, fairytale retelling, baking competition, secret identity, rags to riches, found family, betrayal
Quote: And yet, Mouse had come. He always found her somehow, and he always knew what she needed.
My synopsis
Blackthorne Bakery is renowned in society for it's delicious pastries handmade by Mrs Blackthorne and her two daughters. Little does society know that the Blackthorne's mistreated stepdaughter Celine does all the hard work stuck down in a windowless basement, with most recipes her own creation.
When a royal patisserie competition is announced with a staggering prize, the Blackthornes are adamant they'll win, as long as Celine does all the work. Encouraged by her friend Mouse to enter secretly too, Celine steps into a dazzling world of new friends, cruel foes, and life-changing opportunities.
My review
A nice Cinderella retelling with strong leads and baking fun that fell a little short in the found family attempt.
What I liked
- Celine was a great Cinderella reimagined who shone despite her circumstances. I really liked the caring MMC Mouse and his humble motivations, too. His heavy involvement in the story was a great twist to the original story!
- I really enjoyed the detailed dive into making pastries, and it was so easy to picture the basement bakery. Having the story's star recipe (eggless pumpkin muffins) at the end was a nice touch, too!
What I didn't like
- While I liked Jacque, he felt a little pointless, and the found family element with the bakers etc felt unfounded and forced. The orphanage scene felt a little left field as if to pad the book out, too, rather than being important to the story.
With thanks to the author for providing me with this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Trigger warnings: Domestic abuse, bullying, gaslighting, kidnapping, death of parent, injury detail, classism, confinement
CAWPILE rating: TBD
Spice: Kisses
ARC publication date: May 29th 2026
Tropes: Cinderella inspired, fairytale retelling, baking competition, secret identity, rags to riches, found family, betrayal
Quote: And yet, Mouse had come. He always found her somehow, and he always knew what she needed.
My synopsis
Blackthorne Bakery is renowned in society for it's delicious pastries handmade by Mrs Blackthorne and her two daughters. Little does society know that the Blackthorne's mistreated stepdaughter Celine does all the hard work stuck down in a windowless basement, with most recipes her own creation.
When a royal patisserie competition is announced with a staggering prize, the Blackthornes are adamant they'll win, as long as Celine does all the work. Encouraged by her friend Mouse to enter secretly too, Celine steps into a dazzling world of new friends, cruel foes, and life-changing opportunities.
My review
A nice Cinderella retelling with strong leads and baking fun that fell a little short in the found family attempt.
What I liked
- Celine was a great Cinderella reimagined who shone despite her circumstances. I really liked the caring MMC Mouse and his humble motivations, too. His heavy involvement in the story was a great twist to the original story!
- I really enjoyed the detailed dive into making pastries, and it was so easy to picture the basement bakery. Having the story's star recipe (eggless pumpkin muffins) at the end was a nice touch, too!
What I didn't like
- While I liked Jacque, he felt a little pointless, and the found family element with the bakers etc felt unfounded and forced. The orphanage scene felt a little left field as if to pad the book out, too, rather than being important to the story.
With thanks to the author for providing me with this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Trigger warnings: Domestic abuse, bullying, gaslighting, kidnapping, death of parent, injury detail, classism, confinement
August 1, 2026
Overall I enjoyed this lovely retelling of Cinderella, especially the second half after Celine starts to realize that her stepfamily has actually been treating her very poorly. The beginning is a little slow and frustrating because sweet, trusting Celine believes her stepmother's lies and evasions so wholeheartedly that she repeats them to herself like a mantra: "everyone must do their part to keep the family business running." But somehow that means her stepsisters getting to wear fancy clothes they haven't been forced to save up for themselves, Celine having to work solely in the basement bakery and never interacting with customers or going to parties, getting up early to do the bulk of the work before her stepfamily comes downstairs to put the finishing touches on things, and sleeping in the freezing attic, yet Celine never notices or questions the glaring discrepancies. Anything she asks for for herself is deemed "selfish" and she is berated for not trying hard enough to keep up with the ever-growing mountain of work, and she takes it all to heart. It is only once her friends Mouse (the gentle cobbler's apprentice next door) and Arthur (the kind deliveryman) convince her to enter the royal baking competition that she begins to realize that everything is not as her stepmother has always claimed. Her baking is not mediocre. Her stepsisters never have to make the personal sacrifices she does, and indeed frequently either take credit for her work or steal her ideas outright. If her stepfamily notices her at all, they view her as a scullery maid, not an equal member "doing her part." As Mouse and her other friends had hoped, Celine discovers she deserves more than the exploitation she's settled for, without them actually coming out and saying anything--they're not constantly telling her she should stand up for herself, as many side characters in Cinderella retellings do. They give her the support and opportunity to find her own self-worth and choose a better life on her own terms. She also discovers that her feelings for Mouse have evolved from friendship into something more, just as his apprenticeship is coming to an end and they may have to say goodbye.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I did receive this book as an ARC in return for a true review, which this is, but I wanted to let anyone reading this know that there are slight spoilers for the characters after the first paragraph. But also, this is a cinderella retelling soo... we already know how this story ultimately ends.
The Great British Bake off meets Cinderella in this fairytale retelling.
I loved getting to see the twists on the old characters we know and love, they way A.G. Marshall was able to bring new life into this story by the small changes she made in the characters and settings was *chefs kiss*
Celine, our main girl, not having a stepfamily made of pure evil was refreshing though it did leave me stressed for part of this book as I was constantly waiting for the other shoe to drop. Don't mistake me and think her family was sunshine and roses though, I was ready to FIGHT her stepmother during this book for the subtle ways she was acting towards Celine. She did get her due reward in the end though.
I loved all the new characters that were added in, I feel like they gave the story new depth and helped Celine grow and learn who she was outside of the shadow of her family.
Mouse silently loving and taking care of Celine throughout the entire book gave me life. It just goes to show that we don't need every MMC to be and alpha male and that we need more MMCs who genuinely love and take care of the FMC in the background. A.G. Marshall showed that its possible in this book to have strong characters without everyone being a war general/hero/fighter in fantasy.
TBH y'all I read this book yesterday and I already want to go back and reread it to stay in this world and with these characters. This is not going to be the last book of hers I read and I hope there's more books set in this world.
The Great British Bake off meets Cinderella in this fairytale retelling.
I loved getting to see the twists on the old characters we know and love, they way A.G. Marshall was able to bring new life into this story by the small changes she made in the characters and settings was *chefs kiss*
Celine, our main girl, not having a stepfamily made of pure evil was refreshing though it did leave me stressed for part of this book as I was constantly waiting for the other shoe to drop. Don't mistake me and think her family was sunshine and roses though, I was ready to FIGHT her stepmother during this book for the subtle ways she was acting towards Celine. She did get her due reward in the end though.
I loved all the new characters that were added in, I feel like they gave the story new depth and helped Celine grow and learn who she was outside of the shadow of her family.
Mouse silently loving and taking care of Celine throughout the entire book gave me life. It just goes to show that we don't need every MMC to be and alpha male and that we need more MMCs who genuinely love and take care of the FMC in the background. A.G. Marshall showed that its possible in this book to have strong characters without everyone being a war general/hero/fighter in fantasy.
TBH y'all I read this book yesterday and I already want to go back and reread it to stay in this world and with these characters. This is not going to be the last book of hers I read and I hope there's more books set in this world.
June 2, 2026
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries by A.G. Marshall is part of the Enchanting Confections series, a collection of clean and cozy stories. This standalone novella is a wonderful retelling of Cinderella.
While I was not familiar with the original fairy tales that inspired the previous books, Cinderella is one of my favorites. I found A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries to be a fantastical, entertaining take on the classic tale that is exceedingly on-theme with the concept of enchanting confections.
While her stepmother and stepsisters bask in the dining room spotlight, Celine Blackthorne is the force behind the baking and upkeep of the kingdom’s most fashionable bakery. When a Royal Patisserie Competition threatens to expose her family’s lack of coin and talent, Celine enters anonymously with the help of the cobbler’s apprentice next door to save the business. Celine risks her anonymity to protect the very people who take her for granted, but when the contest requires her to move from the bakery to the ballroom, her secret may not stay hidden for long. As the heat rises in the royal kitchen, Celine must decide if she’s baking for her family’s approval or for a love that’s as sweet as it is unexpected.
First of all, I loved the variety of sweets and pastries that the bakery setting offered. Celine's recipe book should honestly be considered for publication!
The baking competition was an excellent vehicle for adding new twists to a familiar story. While the plot was somewhat predictable, the book still managed to keep me wondering exactly how Celine would overcome the actions of her stepfamily. I also couldn't help but grow incredibly fond of the cobbler’s apprentice and the other side characters who treat Celine with the kindness she deserves.
Highly recommended for those who enjoy cozy fairy tales, baking competitions, and decadent desserts!
While I was not familiar with the original fairy tales that inspired the previous books, Cinderella is one of my favorites. I found A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries to be a fantastical, entertaining take on the classic tale that is exceedingly on-theme with the concept of enchanting confections.
While her stepmother and stepsisters bask in the dining room spotlight, Celine Blackthorne is the force behind the baking and upkeep of the kingdom’s most fashionable bakery. When a Royal Patisserie Competition threatens to expose her family’s lack of coin and talent, Celine enters anonymously with the help of the cobbler’s apprentice next door to save the business. Celine risks her anonymity to protect the very people who take her for granted, but when the contest requires her to move from the bakery to the ballroom, her secret may not stay hidden for long. As the heat rises in the royal kitchen, Celine must decide if she’s baking for her family’s approval or for a love that’s as sweet as it is unexpected.
First of all, I loved the variety of sweets and pastries that the bakery setting offered. Celine's recipe book should honestly be considered for publication!
The baking competition was an excellent vehicle for adding new twists to a familiar story. While the plot was somewhat predictable, the book still managed to keep me wondering exactly how Celine would overcome the actions of her stepfamily. I also couldn't help but grow incredibly fond of the cobbler’s apprentice and the other side characters who treat Celine with the kindness she deserves.
Highly recommended for those who enjoy cozy fairy tales, baking competitions, and decadent desserts!
Review of advance copy received from Author
A Sweet Journey of Recognizing One's Self Worth and a Baking Competition!
I love A.G. Marshall's books, so I was excited to see that she was participating in the Enchanting Confetions multi-author series. A Pan of Pumpkins and Pastries was exactly what I had hoped for with the sweet romance, baking competition, and character growth.
The characters really made the book stand out to me. The stepmother lives up to the Cinderella stereotype as a masterful manipulator skilled at gaslighting. The stepsisters aren't awful, but they are uncaring with no problem taking advantage of Celine. Celine herself is a wonderful character. I was livid with her stepfamily on her behalf due to their treatment of her and was glad when she starts rediscovering her sense of self-worth as she interacted with more people who viewed her as a person rather than a convenient invisible servant. The romance with Mouse is wonderful. We barely see him, but he makes the most of his limited page time. He cares about everyone around him and helps Celine while letting her be the one in control. His and Celine's chemistry is absolutely perfect. There were plenty of references to the original Cendrillon but also plenty of differences that allowed the book to shine.
The plot, too, engaged me from start to finish. The three levels to the baking competition allowed for multiple mouthwateringdescriptions of complex desserts. I wish I could be the judge of the competitions! Altogether fantastic book that is clean in language and content. Hihgly recommend, particularly to readers who love baked goods, journeys to learn self-worth, and amazing characters.
*I received an ARC. All opinions are my own.
I love A.G. Marshall's books, so I was excited to see that she was participating in the Enchanting Confetions multi-author series. A Pan of Pumpkins and Pastries was exactly what I had hoped for with the sweet romance, baking competition, and character growth.
The characters really made the book stand out to me. The stepmother lives up to the Cinderella stereotype as a masterful manipulator skilled at gaslighting. The stepsisters aren't awful, but they are uncaring with no problem taking advantage of Celine. Celine herself is a wonderful character. I was livid with her stepfamily on her behalf due to their treatment of her and was glad when she starts rediscovering her sense of self-worth as she interacted with more people who viewed her as a person rather than a convenient invisible servant. The romance with Mouse is wonderful. We barely see him, but he makes the most of his limited page time. He cares about everyone around him and helps Celine while letting her be the one in control. His and Celine's chemistry is absolutely perfect. There were plenty of references to the original Cendrillon but also plenty of differences that allowed the book to shine.
The plot, too, engaged me from start to finish. The three levels to the baking competition allowed for multiple mouthwateringdescriptions of complex desserts. I wish I could be the judge of the competitions! Altogether fantastic book that is clean in language and content. Hihgly recommend, particularly to readers who love baked goods, journeys to learn self-worth, and amazing characters.
*I received an ARC. All opinions are my own.
September 9, 2026
4,5 stars rounded to 5
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries is the fourth book in the Enchanted Confections multiauthor series and the first book I have read by A.G. Marshall.
This was a really sweet Cinderella retelling. Sweet in the literal sense, since this story is revolving around a baking competition. There are lots of details about the baking process. While I personally love to experiment when I bake and rarely stick to recipes, I thought this element to be really interesting. If you’re not into baking it might be a bit much.
Celine was a great Cinderella, maybe a bit too naive and trusting, since it was rather obvious that she was taken advantage of, but I really liked her as a character. She was sweet and kind to everyone and I loved that she learned how it feels when you’re really appreciated through the baking competition and her friend Mouse.
I also loved Mouse and the romance between them was really sweet. I almost always love the hidden identity trope, so I enjoyed this element that’s a bit different than in the original.
I felt like there were a few too many aspects to the plot and while the pastries were described in detail, other plotlines seemed to be brushed over. To me it also seemed like everything was a bit too conveniently resolved.
Other than that I really enjoyed this cozy retelling. Especially if you’re into baking (and probably TV shows about baking competitions, I have never watched one of those so I don’t know for sure if they are similar to the book) you should give this sweet story a try.
* Thank you to the author for letting me read an advanced copy of this book. I leave this review voluntarily and the expressed opinions are my own.
A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries is the fourth book in the Enchanted Confections multiauthor series and the first book I have read by A.G. Marshall.
This was a really sweet Cinderella retelling. Sweet in the literal sense, since this story is revolving around a baking competition. There are lots of details about the baking process. While I personally love to experiment when I bake and rarely stick to recipes, I thought this element to be really interesting. If you’re not into baking it might be a bit much.
Celine was a great Cinderella, maybe a bit too naive and trusting, since it was rather obvious that she was taken advantage of, but I really liked her as a character. She was sweet and kind to everyone and I loved that she learned how it feels when you’re really appreciated through the baking competition and her friend Mouse.
I also loved Mouse and the romance between them was really sweet. I almost always love the hidden identity trope, so I enjoyed this element that’s a bit different than in the original.
I felt like there were a few too many aspects to the plot and while the pastries were described in detail, other plotlines seemed to be brushed over. To me it also seemed like everything was a bit too conveniently resolved.
Other than that I really enjoyed this cozy retelling. Especially if you’re into baking (and probably TV shows about baking competitions, I have never watched one of those so I don’t know for sure if they are similar to the book) you should give this sweet story a try.
* Thank you to the author for letting me read an advanced copy of this book. I leave this review voluntarily and the expressed opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Warnings: grief from past death of parents
This was an amazing Cinderella retelling about finding your own worth and standing up for yourself. It had all the right elements and made me feel so many emotions! There were secret identities, a baking competition, some humor, and lots of heart. I loved watching "Cinder" (Celine) and "Mouse's" friendship form, how he was able to know exactly what she needed before she did, and how he was always trying to get her to see her worth. I enjoyed the mystery of his character and how she began to piece it all together towards the end. While I had my suspicions, I still loved how the story was executed. The world-building was finely detailed and I felt like I could have stepped into the story and tasted all of the baked goods. The baking competition was such a good way to show camaraderie between all of the contestants, and really showcased the true colors of Celine's step family. I was rooting for side characters just as much as Celine and "Mouse". It was heartbreaking to watch Celine realize how little her stepfamily thought of her, how they took credit for everything she did, and all she wanted was to help their bakery thrive. I highly recommend this slow-burn, no-spice fairytale retelling for any reader!
I received an Advanced Reader Copy with no expectation of a review. All opinions are my own.
This was an amazing Cinderella retelling about finding your own worth and standing up for yourself. It had all the right elements and made me feel so many emotions! There were secret identities, a baking competition, some humor, and lots of heart. I loved watching "Cinder" (Celine) and "Mouse's" friendship form, how he was able to know exactly what she needed before she did, and how he was always trying to get her to see her worth. I enjoyed the mystery of his character and how she began to piece it all together towards the end. While I had my suspicions, I still loved how the story was executed. The world-building was finely detailed and I felt like I could have stepped into the story and tasted all of the baked goods. The baking competition was such a good way to show camaraderie between all of the contestants, and really showcased the true colors of Celine's step family. I was rooting for side characters just as much as Celine and "Mouse". It was heartbreaking to watch Celine realize how little her stepfamily thought of her, how they took credit for everything she did, and all she wanted was to help their bakery thrive. I highly recommend this slow-burn, no-spice fairytale retelling for any reader!
I received an Advanced Reader Copy with no expectation of a review. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
When I first started reading, I thought oh no…this book is already using fancy sounding words that I think are dishes? I’m not an expert baker but after that first moment of I’m in over my head, I was fine. I was quickly sucked into the story & all of the baking was described so wonderfully that it made me hungry just reading it! I fell in love with all of the amazing characters like Celine, Arthur, Mouse, Jacque, & all of the bakers in the competition! I started this story expecting a Cinderella retelling but it’s a beautiful tale about a baker firstly, falling in love, & choosing a world of possibilities! I was so invested in the story unfolding & I loved Mouse! It takes someone special to see you as you are & to make you see it to! This story is so beautifully paced & takes you on a journey that is so satisfying that your heart feels warm & full! This is my first book by A.G. Marshall & it definitely won’t be my last! I’m sitting here hoping I found the right words to express how fantastic it was! I’m somewhere between the smile that finishing left behind & wanting to start over just to stay in the story a little while longer! Please tell me there is a bonus epilogue…I really want to see just a little bit further than where it stopped?!
P.S.- Side effects of reading this book are staying up too late & a need to go bake something delicious!
P.S.- Side effects of reading this book are staying up too late & a need to go bake something delicious!
June 1, 2026
I was lucky to receive an ARC of A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries and I apologize that the review is late. I really enjoyed this cozy Cinderella retelling. Similar to when I would watch The Great British Bake-Off this book made me smile and feel a bit hungry.
Instead of having the traditional ball A. G. Marshall has her characters participate in a royal baking competition. While I admit to being a little skeptical on how this would play out, the plot line works well with the book and the theme of the Enchanting Confections series.
Celine (the books Cinderella) is a fantastic baker with a kind heart. There were times in the beginning where I felt she was too obedient to her selfish stepfamily but she grows wonderfully as a character and it was an enjoyable journey of self-growth to watch. Her love interest Mouse is very supportive and a bit mysterious. I loved his introduction. It was so cute and cleverly done! I also enjoyed Celine’s friendship with the young orphan Jacque and his speech towards the end was very touching.
Overall A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries is a fantastic and sweet retelling of Cinderella and a wonderful inclusion to the multi-author series. I can’t wait to read more of A. G. Marshall’s other books too as this is not her first Cinderella retelling as she has four!
Instead of having the traditional ball A. G. Marshall has her characters participate in a royal baking competition. While I admit to being a little skeptical on how this would play out, the plot line works well with the book and the theme of the Enchanting Confections series.
Celine (the books Cinderella) is a fantastic baker with a kind heart. There were times in the beginning where I felt she was too obedient to her selfish stepfamily but she grows wonderfully as a character and it was an enjoyable journey of self-growth to watch. Her love interest Mouse is very supportive and a bit mysterious. I loved his introduction. It was so cute and cleverly done! I also enjoyed Celine’s friendship with the young orphan Jacque and his speech towards the end was very touching.
Overall A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries is a fantastic and sweet retelling of Cinderella and a wonderful inclusion to the multi-author series. I can’t wait to read more of A. G. Marshall’s other books too as this is not her first Cinderella retelling as she has four!
June 13, 2026
Cinderella is one of my favorite fairytales for retellings. I love seeing all of the unique twists on Cinder and this story didn't disappoint!!
This book is perfect for autumn... it gives all the cozy vibes and has wonderful autumn recipes. If you are in need of a cozy, comforting read, this book is for you.
Celine is a bit naive, but not annoyingly so. She is very sweet and generous and wants to think the best of her family. Its sad seeing how she is treated and when she finally realizes they are taking advantage of her kindness. Her growth in the story is lovely.
Mouse is such a sweet character. He has a big heart and he is so supportive of Celine. If you love a cinnamon roll mmc, you will love him. Although the story definitely focuses more on Celine than Mouse.
There is also a wonderful cast of side characters with really sweet (but light) found family vibes.
It was also fun reading about all of the treats and recipes used in the story. If you are into baking or baking shows/competitions you will enjoy this.
This story is slower paced (not in a bad way, but dont expect a page-turner/fast-paced plot) it is very character driven and cozy.
If you enjoy cozy reads, autumn vibes, sweet characters, chaotic puppies, and lots of baking, then this story is for you.
I received an ARC from the author - all opinions are my own.
This book is perfect for autumn... it gives all the cozy vibes and has wonderful autumn recipes. If you are in need of a cozy, comforting read, this book is for you.
Celine is a bit naive, but not annoyingly so. She is very sweet and generous and wants to think the best of her family. Its sad seeing how she is treated and when she finally realizes they are taking advantage of her kindness. Her growth in the story is lovely.
Mouse is such a sweet character. He has a big heart and he is so supportive of Celine. If you love a cinnamon roll mmc, you will love him. Although the story definitely focuses more on Celine than Mouse.
There is also a wonderful cast of side characters with really sweet (but light) found family vibes.
It was also fun reading about all of the treats and recipes used in the story. If you are into baking or baking shows/competitions you will enjoy this.
This story is slower paced (not in a bad way, but dont expect a page-turner/fast-paced plot) it is very character driven and cozy.
If you enjoy cozy reads, autumn vibes, sweet characters, chaotic puppies, and lots of baking, then this story is for you.
I received an ARC from the author - all opinions are my own.
May 18, 2026
This book was so sweet. I loved Celine and her story. Cinderella is a favorite story of mine so this retelling was one I really enjoyed.
This was an interesting and fun take on Cinderella. Baking competition instead of a ball, instead of an actual mouse there is an apprentice nicknamed mouse, etc. These details made this story unique and interesting.
I loved watching Celine become the best version of herself and standing up for what she wanted. She might have been the one running things behind the scenes but she was done being in the shadows.
When it came to her stepmother I didn’t like her and she lived up to the character she was based on. That woman took advantage of Celine and put her down. When it came to the stepsisters I liked one and didn’t like the other and that is all I will say.
I loved all the side characters and how they had such important parts and weren’t just there. They all had stories and roles they played.
I will say I figured out the mystery surrounding a character very quickly. I won’t say anything else to not spoil but I was pleased when I found out I was correct.
Overall I really liked this book and the characters. I read this book as an arc.
This was an interesting and fun take on Cinderella. Baking competition instead of a ball, instead of an actual mouse there is an apprentice nicknamed mouse, etc. These details made this story unique and interesting.
I loved watching Celine become the best version of herself and standing up for what she wanted. She might have been the one running things behind the scenes but she was done being in the shadows.
When it came to her stepmother I didn’t like her and she lived up to the character she was based on. That woman took advantage of Celine and put her down. When it came to the stepsisters I liked one and didn’t like the other and that is all I will say.
I loved all the side characters and how they had such important parts and weren’t just there. They all had stories and roles they played.
I will say I figured out the mystery surrounding a character very quickly. I won’t say anything else to not spoil but I was pleased when I found out I was correct.
Overall I really liked this book and the characters. I read this book as an arc.
May 21, 2026
Voluntary honest ARC review
I love this story so much! The story is good, it is well written, it has great description that flows well, and all the characters are each distinct from one another and feel real.
This book is honestly one of my favorites now! 🫠❤️
I loved the asthetic! I enjoyed it so much. It was sweet, cozy, emotional, and enjoyable.
I learned a few things (and also looked a few up) about pastries and the other things that were baked in this story which was interesting. Well done with the descriptions and research Mrs. Marshall!
The romance was sweet. It was a very tasteful seasoning with the story.
There was no unnecessary kissing! (there was a single one at the very end of the book which was undescribed.)
The only criticism I have of this book is that the main character: Celine took a few chapters too long to realise something that was right in front of her face. All the clues were there but she made what I felt like were silly excuses as to why they didn't mean what they meant.
I hope there will be more books like this from the author in the same world!
Thank you for the ARC A. G. Marshall! I loved it.
I love this story so much! The story is good, it is well written, it has great description that flows well, and all the characters are each distinct from one another and feel real.
This book is honestly one of my favorites now! 🫠❤️
I loved the asthetic! I enjoyed it so much. It was sweet, cozy, emotional, and enjoyable.
I learned a few things (and also looked a few up) about pastries and the other things that were baked in this story which was interesting. Well done with the descriptions and research Mrs. Marshall!
The romance was sweet. It was a very tasteful seasoning with the story.
There was no unnecessary kissing! (there was a single one at the very end of the book which was undescribed.)
The only criticism I have of this book is that the main character: Celine took a few chapters too long to realise something that was right in front of her face. All the clues were there but she made what I felt like were silly excuses as to why they didn't mean what they meant.
I hope there will be more books like this from the author in the same world!
Thank you for the ARC A. G. Marshall! I loved it.
May 25, 2026
This is a Cinderella retelling, so there are the elements of the stepmother, stepsisters, and Celine (Cinder) doing all the work. But the Mouse is a person, and there’s a baking competition! I hated so much that Celine couldn’t see for half the book that she was being used. She wanted to help her family, and she genuinely thought she was, but she couldn’t see that she was being 100% taken advantage of.
I liked how she finally realized it, in seeing how others treat her compared to her family. I was furious with the stepmother of course, but also with Felicity. While Eugenie seemed oblivious, Felicity saw what was happening but didn’t feel strongly enough to speak out or do anything to stop it.
I loved the found family of (most of) the bakers who made it to the last round, and that they kept in touch after the competition and we found out what they ended up doing. I also loved the little side romance between the delivery man and the orphanage owner, and how they were so sweet to Celine and helped her as well.
I really loved the prince’s plot, I can’t say more but I loved how it was done!
* I received an eARC from the author. Thanks! All opinions are my own.
I liked how she finally realized it, in seeing how others treat her compared to her family. I was furious with the stepmother of course, but also with Felicity. While Eugenie seemed oblivious, Felicity saw what was happening but didn’t feel strongly enough to speak out or do anything to stop it.
I loved the found family of (most of) the bakers who made it to the last round, and that they kept in touch after the competition and we found out what they ended up doing. I also loved the little side romance between the delivery man and the orphanage owner, and how they were so sweet to Celine and helped her as well.
I really loved the prince’s plot, I can’t say more but I loved how it was done!
* I received an eARC from the author. Thanks! All opinions are my own.
June 7, 2026
Flawlessly Delightful
Reading A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries felt like a warm hug and brought so much joy. I loved the community around Celine and how tenderly the clean sweet no spice romance developed within it. He did a good job of making her feel seen by both him and their friends and eventually by herself. I also enjoyed the detail, creativity, and richness the baking was described with.
It had a cozy Great British Baking Show feel to it that added drama and fun. The step family played their parts well. Other familiar elements got unique twists that felt almost like a scavenger hunt throughout the book. The only thing the book is missing is the ability to taste one of the delectable desserts, but even that is taken care of with a recipe in the back.
This book is perfect when you want something sweet, exciting, and substantive with a dash of yearning for fall weather and flavors. I cannot recommend A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries enough and I’m already looking forward to my next reread of it.
Reading A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries felt like a warm hug and brought so much joy. I loved the community around Celine and how tenderly the clean sweet no spice romance developed within it. He did a good job of making her feel seen by both him and their friends and eventually by herself. I also enjoyed the detail, creativity, and richness the baking was described with.
It had a cozy Great British Baking Show feel to it that added drama and fun. The step family played their parts well. Other familiar elements got unique twists that felt almost like a scavenger hunt throughout the book. The only thing the book is missing is the ability to taste one of the delectable desserts, but even that is taken care of with a recipe in the back.
This book is perfect when you want something sweet, exciting, and substantive with a dash of yearning for fall weather and flavors. I cannot recommend A Pan of Pumpkin and Pastries enough and I’m already looking forward to my next reread of it.
June 16, 2026
My goodness was Celine an idiot
Look, I've read more Cinderella retellings than I can count. I'm all about princes in disguise. But it's a careful balance, and this one fell on the wrong side of the line to her being shamefully oblivious instead of sweet tempered. I mean, how could she not see that her step family was taking advantage of her? And the prince getting taken away without being able to say a single sentence? Ludicrous and overly contrived. Also TOO MANY PASTRIES. This series hasn't been my favorite to start (WHY do we have to have a sweet themed multi author series?!) but this one was brutal compared to the others. Just lots of details on really HOW to bake. Which was honestly admirable, but not something I'm interested in learning, given that I, along with much of the population of our country, try NOT to eat pastries since they're not healthy. Hence why I think this entire series is a tad tasteless. Normally I enjoy AG Marshall, but this book just didn't do it for me.
Look, I've read more Cinderella retellings than I can count. I'm all about princes in disguise. But it's a careful balance, and this one fell on the wrong side of the line to her being shamefully oblivious instead of sweet tempered. I mean, how could she not see that her step family was taking advantage of her? And the prince getting taken away without being able to say a single sentence? Ludicrous and overly contrived. Also TOO MANY PASTRIES. This series hasn't been my favorite to start (WHY do we have to have a sweet themed multi author series?!) but this one was brutal compared to the others. Just lots of details on really HOW to bake. Which was honestly admirable, but not something I'm interested in learning, given that I, along with much of the population of our country, try NOT to eat pastries since they're not healthy. Hence why I think this entire series is a tad tasteless. Normally I enjoy AG Marshall, but this book just didn't do it for me.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I loved this Cinderella retelling so much! The messages of finding your worth and choosing to stand up for yourself were beautifully written. Everyone needs a Mouse in their lives to see them as they truly are.
Celine spends her days, and many nights, in the bakery basement preparing all of the pastries for the day. Even though she recognizes that things aren’t fair (her one dress is falling apart while her step sisters have multiple dresses in new condition), she is happy serving where she can and helping bring joy to the people who eat her baked goods. Her joy comes from her friend in the fireplace, the cobbler’s apprentice, the one person who seems to see her when then the people closest to her are blind. When the King holds a baking competition to find the royal baker for the Prince’s home coming ball, Celine hopes to have a chance at the prize money. Thankfully she has some good friends who are ready to support her, because this competition will not be a piece of cake!
Celine spends her days, and many nights, in the bakery basement preparing all of the pastries for the day. Even though she recognizes that things aren’t fair (her one dress is falling apart while her step sisters have multiple dresses in new condition), she is happy serving where she can and helping bring joy to the people who eat her baked goods. Her joy comes from her friend in the fireplace, the cobbler’s apprentice, the one person who seems to see her when then the people closest to her are blind. When the King holds a baking competition to find the royal baker for the Prince’s home coming ball, Celine hopes to have a chance at the prize money. Thankfully she has some good friends who are ready to support her, because this competition will not be a piece of cake!
May 15, 2026
Oh my goodness!! I loved this book! This is a retelling of Cinderella; however, it includes a baking challenge. Because I love to bake as well, I really enjoyed reading about all of the various treats and decorations. I have to admit that I did look up the pronunciation of a couple of words, but I did know how to say croquembouche and even what it was.
Not only did I love the food, but I also really enjoyed the characters and setting. I enjoyed this far more than the original Cinderella story because it was more of a love story than the original. Cinder and Mouse had such a wonderful relationship that developed in the perfect way. Arthur, Jacque, and the rest of the characters really drew me in as well. Even though this is the first book that I’ve read from A.G. Marshall, I’m hooked. I’m already planning on reading the rest of her books.
I received this as an ARC book, but the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Not only did I love the food, but I also really enjoyed the characters and setting. I enjoyed this far more than the original Cinderella story because it was more of a love story than the original. Cinder and Mouse had such a wonderful relationship that developed in the perfect way. Arthur, Jacque, and the rest of the characters really drew me in as well. Even though this is the first book that I’ve read from A.G. Marshall, I’m hooked. I’m already planning on reading the rest of her books.
I received this as an ARC book, but the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
If you love Cinderella and the Great British Baking Bake Off, you will LOVE this story! Absolutely adorable! It was such a sweet and charming retelling of Cinderella. I loved the mashup of Cinderella and a baking competition! Super creative and had all the classic Cinderella elements. Celine was relatable character. She had fantastic character growth. Loved seeing how she blossomed throughout the book. Her relationship with Mouse was so endearing. They seriously had the sweetest friendship. Mouse was my favorite character. He was a constant friend. Always was encouraging and believed in Celine. I loved how their relationship developed and grew. There were many fantastic side characters. Madeleine was one of my favorite side characters and I hope she will get a story someday. This book was a lovely and enjoyable read!
I volunteered to read an ARC copy of the book and all thoughts are my own.
I volunteered to read an ARC copy of the book and all thoughts are my own.
Read
May 25, 2026I received an arc of this book and it was a great read (most especially in Autumn)!
In this version of the classic story of Cinderella and set in eighteenth century France, the stepmother and stepsister own a bakery (called Blackthorne Bakery) and the titular character (Celine) is the scullery maid who has to do most of the cleaning when she bakes treats her stepfamily ends up taking the credit for them. The only one who gives her credit are her closest friends, including the kind and handsome Cobbler apprentice next door, who Celine calls “Mouse” and has a few secrets. However, an announcement for a Royal Patisserie competition is announced might just give her the chance to decide whether to either save the reputation of her family’s bakery or for the love of her dearest friend.
This truly is a sweet tale of romance and finding what makes you happy. Plus, the descriptions of all the sweet desserts made in it will make your mouth water!
In this version of the classic story of Cinderella and set in eighteenth century France, the stepmother and stepsister own a bakery (called Blackthorne Bakery) and the titular character (Celine) is the scullery maid who has to do most of the cleaning when she bakes treats her stepfamily ends up taking the credit for them. The only one who gives her credit are her closest friends, including the kind and handsome Cobbler apprentice next door, who Celine calls “Mouse” and has a few secrets. However, an announcement for a Royal Patisserie competition is announced might just give her the chance to decide whether to either save the reputation of her family’s bakery or for the love of her dearest friend.
This truly is a sweet tale of romance and finding what makes you happy. Plus, the descriptions of all the sweet desserts made in it will make your mouth water!
June 14, 2026
This was a charming story. I really liked the bakery setting and the baking competition. I thought it was cute that Celine and the MMC were neighbors and that they talked to each other through the fireplace.
I wanted more surprise when a certain person's real identity was revealed, but at the same time I did like that the other certain person actually figured it out instead of being annoyingly blind to all the clues.
This whole story featured a vibrant cast of characters. Celine's stepsisters were perfectly awful and bratty and her stepmother was exactly what you'd expect from a Cinderella-esque stepmother. The other contestants in the baking competition were fun. I especially liked Jacques. He added a delightfully lighthearted thread to the story.
If you're a fan of Cinderella retellings, be sure to check out this book!
Thanks to the author for providing me with an ARC. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.
I wanted more surprise when a certain person's real identity was revealed, but at the same time I did like that the other certain person actually figured it out instead of being annoyingly blind to all the clues.
This whole story featured a vibrant cast of characters. Celine's stepsisters were perfectly awful and bratty and her stepmother was exactly what you'd expect from a Cinderella-esque stepmother. The other contestants in the baking competition were fun. I especially liked Jacques. He added a delightfully lighthearted thread to the story.
If you're a fan of Cinderella retellings, be sure to check out this book!
Thanks to the author for providing me with an ARC. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 91 reviews