I can't express how much I was looking towards reading this book - I have heard amazing things about Louise Douglas and her books (The Secret by the Lake was my first read by this author, somehow have never managed to read other novels, even though I have them on my TBR pile, of course!), and lately heard only prizes from friends about this newest release. Also, after reading the blurb I was convinced this is for sure going to be up to my bookish street.
So I started reading it and waited, and waited, and waited for something to wow me as much as it wow-ed the other bloggers. Don't get me wrong, it was a beautifully written and thoroughly plotted story, but it just didn't make such impression on me. I am not against paranormal in the stories, but this time I just couldn't get this whole ghost subplot. Sure, I know it was there to rehabilitate one of the characters, but on the whole it just didn't sit with me. Also, relatively quickly I guessed the two important to the story things - namely what happened to Caroline and what was happening to Viviane, and who was involved in this dirty business, and that there was much more to Caroline that met the eyes. So when the grande finale arrived, I was not at all surprised. Sure, Caroline's presence was needed to explain what happened in the past, to stop the history to repeat itself but altogether, for me it made the whole reading just unbelievable - somehow it didn't fit this kind of book.
Nevertheless, even though I guessed what happened 30 years ago and what was happening now, revealing this fact by the author has shocked me and made me feel so, so sad and powerless. Maybe because something such sinister was happening all the time and there was no - one there to help? I must admit, it broke my heart a little.
The atmosphere in this book is so grim - I had a feeling that the fog hovering over the lake is twining around me, I just could feel the chill. We have a character here fighting a depression after her husband has been murdered, we have a cold, unloved house, we have a very sad and tragic past, and it only gets creepier and creepier, especially when Viviane, Julia's daughter, becomes a new best friend - Julia's dead sister, Caroline. It's really amazing that the author has managed to create such atmosphere, make the book so ghostly, full of intrigues and tragic incidents. The characters in the story are also not the easiest ones to like or to relate to, at least in my case. I understand that Julia and Viviane's lives went upside down and I truly fell for them, but Julia was not the only widow in the world, right? I couldn't watch the poor Viviane, so abandoned and so alone in this sad, grim house - Julia was just too much into her own grief and she seemed to just wash her hands of all the things that were happening in her life. Fortunately there was Amy to pick up what was broken, and I don't want to think what would happen without her? The local villagers were not too happy, as well, and I'd rather not live there.
Louise Douglas has also added an element of romance, but - sadly - it also didn't sit with me. This relationship between Amy and Daniel seemed so forced and unrealistic to me - Amy fells in love with him almost immediately, after one very uninspiring conversation, and she is the one initiating everything and in her mind giving birth to their children.
The lake, and also the cottage the women lived in, are separate characters in this story, and the descriptions of them both were really giving me the creeps. There was always this heavy, implying something atmosphere around the lake, and the house, with all the closed doors, cold rooms and creaky steps was not my idea of a cosy, welcoming home.
But nevertheless, even though it was not my favourite read, I still was able to see and appreciate a quality of this story - the beautiful writing, great storytelling and interesting plot, and I am truly looking forward to reading other Louise's books. She has also managed to transport me into the world of the characters, back in time to the village, such great the writing was. I welcome how the author mixed the paranormal elements with the family drama, and I am really sorry that it didn't work for me, but I am sure it can send a shiver or two down your spine. Louise Douglas has delivered a captivating, sophisticated and beautifully written story, a very complex, multi - layered one, full of twists and turns and I really appreciate this fact, as well as the tension being so palpable through the pages. full of secrets and lies - perfect for this time of the year.
Copy provided by publisher in exchange for a review.