The first ferry of the new term arrives in six days. Let us hope it finds you alive and well.
When Bronte Cade’s mother vanishes, the only clue she leaves behind is an invitation to a retreat for magical poets. Determined to find answers, Bronte attends in her mother’s place by masquerading as the esteemed Dr. Sappho Cade.
But when Bronte arrives at the Radley School of Poetry, she finds the island abandoned—save for six other confused poets, one line of an unfinished poem, and an anonymous host who issues a chillingultimatum through an enchanted gramophone: complete the spell, and they may return home on the next ferry. Fail, and they die.
There’s another problem: Bronte isn’t magical.
With escape impossible, the body count rising, and her mother still missing, Bronte forms a wary alliance with the infuriating yet brilliant Marlowe Fang. Together, they race to unmask their host before Bronte is exposed—or worse, the next victim.
But beneath the host’s sinister scheme lies an even more insidious plot, one decades in the making. It bleeds beyond the shores of Radley like an ink stain, and no one’s hands are clean. Least of all the people Bronte trusts most.
Julie Lew loves all things fantasy and horror, the darker and queerer the better. They are the author of the adult gothic horror novel, THE WIVES OF HERRICK HALL, and the YA fantasy mystery, DEATH IN VERSE (out September 22nd, 2026). She lives in the Pacific Northwest with her partner, and when she’s not writing books about the magical and the monstrous, she’s likely playing endless games of fetch with her chihuahua-terrier mix pup Kody.
You can find Julie at julielew.com or on Instagram @_julielew_.
Poets. Poems. Murder. Mystery. Death. Life. Mother. Twins. War. Magic. Immortality. Sacrifice. Becoming the monster.
Death in Verse feels like someone threw dark academia, a murder mystery, historical fantasy, magical poetry and a deeply dysfunctional family into a blender and somehow got something that actually works.
First of all, I think the magic system is easily one of my favorite things about this book. The idea that poetry can literally shape and manipulate magic is so fun, especially because the book doesn’t treat poetry as just a quirky aesthetic. It becomes a weapon, a political tool, a source of power and eventually something much more morally complicated. I really liked how the story asks what happens when something as intimate and creative as language becomes something governments and institutions can capitalize on. The conversations surrounding the Consortium, war and the weaponization of magic gave the fantasy a surprisingly sharp political edge and I think that made the story much more interesting than a simple “magical school + murder mystery” setup would have been.
Bronte is also such a fun protagonist to follow because she feels wonderfully, painfully human. She’s smart but makes questionable decisions, brave but absolutely terrified, stubborn but vulnerable. And yet, that is exactly why I rooted for her. She has spent her entire life believing she is ordinary, while also carrying the complicated weight of being a daughter who feels like she was never quite enough for her mother. Watching her slowly question everything she thought she knew about herself, her mother and her own abilities was one of my favorite parts of the book.
And then there is Marlowe. Their relationship with Bronte was probably my favorite part of the book, even though I desperately wanted the romance to cook for a little longer. This is technically an enemies-to-lovers-ish situation, except they’re less “I hate you” and more “you are deeply irritating and unfortunately I keep thinking about you,” which, frankly, is my favorite flavor of romance. I just wish we had gotten more banter, more tension, more reluctant closeness, more moments where they slowly realize they’re becoming important to each other. The romance doesn’t feel forced, especially considering the circumstances they’re in, but it does feel a little rushed. I wanted that relationship to simmer a bit more.
The multiple POVs also worked surprisingly well for me because they gave the story room to explore how differently these characters experience the same world. Marlowe’s perspective in particular adds so much emotional weight to the story, especially when it comes to their identity, their relationship with Eliot, their experiences with racism and transphobia and their complicated relationship with poetry itself. I really appreciated having a nonbinary character whose identity is simply part of who they are rather than the entirety of their character. Their story also fits beautifully into the book’s larger questions about belonging, power and who gets to decide what makes someone valuable.
I will say that the first part of the book didn’t completely grab me. I think the first 40% or so is noticeably weaker than everything that follows. The setup is interesting and there are definitely intriguing questions being introduced but I wasn’t nearly as invested as I became later on. Once the mystery starts unraveling and the implications of the magic become clearer though, the book really takes off. Somehow the plot managed to make me feel both “I KNEW IT” and “WHAT THE HELL” at various points, which I still don’t entirely understand but I respect the achievement.
What stayed with me most though, is how deeply tragic this story feels beneath all the murder mystery and magical poetry. These characters are so young and so many of them have been shaped, manipulated, exploited or outright broken by systems much larger than themselves. The Consortium turns magic into power, power into political influence and political influence into violence, while convincing the people caught inside it that they should be grateful for the privilege. The book understands that war doesn’t just destroy people on battlefields and that sometimes it gets into schools, families, identities, friendships and the very things people once loved. Poetry, which should have been something beautiful, becomes something capable of killing.
The ending does give us something that I would consider considerably satisfying but I would still absolutely call this a tragedy in some form. There is resolution, yes, but not the kind that magically cleans up all the emotional wreckage left behind. These people have lost too much and even when the immediate danger passes, you can feel that they will have to live with what happened.
TL;DR: Overall, Death in Verse is a dark, clever, wonderfully strange little book about poetry and power and all the terrible things people will do when they believe they deserve to control both. It has a haunting atmosphere, an incredibly unique magic system, characters I genuinely cared about, queer representation I loved seeing and enough murder, secrets, political corruption, emotional devastation and yearning to keep me thoroughly entertained. I wish the opening had hooked me sooner and I desperately wanted more time for the romance to develop but the payoff made the slower beginning worth it. If you like dark academia, deadly mysteries, morally complicated magic, characters trapped inside oppressive systems and books that make you stare at the ceiling afterward, I think this one is very much worth picking up.
The cover and title definitely caught my eye while perusing the offerings at my local library. An interesting enough story but very wordy, especially in the beginning. It was longer than needed. Character development and world building were executed well. The plot was unique, but sadly, probably a book I won't remember.
Death in Verse by Julie Lew is the perfect read for a rainy fall day. It's a YA dark academia mystery featuring magic, murder and enough twists and turns to keep you turning pages well into the night. It's beautifully written with amazing multidimensional characters, a unique plot and magic system and an emotional pull that keeps you invested from start to finish. It's definitely one to add to your fall TBR.
Tropes:
🥀Dark Academia 🔪Murder Mystery 🌈Queer & Nonbinary Representation ✨Poetry Magic
Thank you to Julie Lew and Union Square & Co. for the arc and for having me on the street team.
As lyrical as it is brutal, "Death in Verse" is a haunting fantasy about language, power, and the violence of institutions that decide whose voices deserve to exist. Perfect for readers who love dark historical fantasy, politically charged magic systems, and stories where survival itself is an act of defiance.
9/21/2026 Absolutely perfect. New favorite of 2026.
Full review to come.
~~~~~~
10/13/2026
There was something about the title that called to me. The word "verse" made me pause as once upon a time I fancied myself something of an amateur poet, writing my own pieces in childhood until well into high school before setting that aside. As such, I spent a lot of time reading poetry and verse and it's always held a soft spot in my soul. So here was a magical title, Death in Verse, and the cadence of the words rang in my head and I knew I needed to read this book. The fact that it was also a mystery just made me that much more determined to read this book and I'm happy to report that I loved, LOVED, this story in the end and I sincerely hope there will be more in this world to come in the future.
First off, the world-building was so very intricate and interesting. I found myself easily believing in the magic of the story, the way "poets" has been changed to indicate the people who have been devoting their entire lives to learning and writing poems, or spells, and how their work has been shaping the world. The fact that the lead was an outsider, not a poet but the daughter of one, allowed for the reader to learn the ins and outs of the school where a large portion of the book takes place. The "Radley School of Poetry" felt familiar in the sense of being an institution of learning devoted to the teaching of a craft and its existence felt like a necessary location to truly show the divide that lead character, Bronte Cade, felt as someone who was not magical and therefore had been barred entry to a school where her own mother spent a large amount of her time. The fact that her mother going missing was the catalyst that led to Bronte finally setting foot at the school also helped with presenting the turmoil the location represented. This place was supposed to help shape poets and instead, it's carefully revealed over the course of the writing that it was actually a place of torment in more ways than one and that fact was handled with a deft eye for detail by Lew.
Every reveal led to something more that made the story evolve, showing the pain and anguish of certain characters trying to find their place in the world and being forced to spend years attending this school because it was considered their place and their right as being people with magic. With the story going back and forth between Bronte and also Marlowe Fang, Marlowe's brother Eliot and several of the other gathered poets at the school, Lew was able to show a hidden side to the world of magic in this story while also revealing that this school and what it represented was a double-edged sword, causing pain in more ways than we readers will probably ever know. The fact that Lew showed how those in power used poets to work for them, developing spells for war and so on, filled in the ideas of the world beyond the scope of the book and there is so much more I can't wait to see Lew develop should this story continue.
As for the characters, I loved Bronte and Marlowe. I wanted to protect these two darlings with everything I had and I was eager to see when their motivations would finally align and a partnership would form. I was impressed with Bronte and the fact that despite being practically cast aside by her mother after learning she didn't have magic, the fact that she would still go out of her way to try to find her mother after she went missing was just astounding. I would have left mummy dearest to her own machinations as I'm sure she would not have done the same for her daughter had the situations been reversed, that was the impression given of Dr. Sappho Cade. As for Marlowe, every reveal given about them made my heart ache. I wanted to scoop Marlowe and Eliot up and keep them safe from harm and their treatment at the school by their peers and their teachers made me sick to my stomach. I felt like every snide remark and, well, Marlowe's entire attitude, was well-warranted after seeing the way they grew up. They deserved so much more and I hope now that Bronte is in the picture with them, that the two of these kids will find some measure of peace in the future. Please? If it's not too much to ask?
As for the plot, I was intrigued by the start with the setup Lew created for this story. Seven poets have been drawn back to the school and tasked with completing a poem. They have six days to complete the poem but as the days pass, they start to get picked off, one by one. The various points-of-view helped to fill in so many different aspects of the story and each character had a different part to play and various details revealed about them that I did not see coming at all thanks to the talent of Lew's writing. I was drawn in from the start, trying to carefully consider al the facts but I did not see that final reveal at all until it was on the page in front of me. The difficult part about talking about a mystery book is trying to explain exactly what impressed me the most about the story without spoiling the experience of it so I hope when I say that the mystery is only half of the fun of this book, people will understand that there is so much more to expect with this book if they give it a try. I, for one, will be going back to read Lew's previous release, The Wives of Herrick Hall, and silently wait for news of another book set in this world.
I called this one of my new favorite reads of 2026 but honestly, this is just a new all-time favorite book of mine. It was just that awesome for me.
Rating on my Scale: 10 Stars, obviously. I finished this book nearly a month ago and I'm terribly behind in writing my reviews but I can still recall so much of this story in intricate detail so yeah, definitely a favorite of mine.
My thanks to NetGalley, Union Square & Co. and Julie Lew for the eARC of this book in exchange for a review. All opinions are my own.
Death in Verse is perfect for readers looking for a suspenseful, YA murder mystery. It has released just in time for spooky season. Each of the characters is unique and it was intriguing to see all their back stories fall into place. I enjoyed the dual POV and flashback chapters. I think that these can be hard to write but they added to the suspense of the story. I was really excited for the premise of the magic system, but it fell flat for me. I was expecting more spells to happen and for it to feel more magical.
Thank you to Union Square & Co for a gifted copy of the ebook.
When Bronte Cade’s mother vanishes, the only clue she leaves behind is an invitation to a retreat for magical poets. Determined to find answers, Bronte attends in her mother’s place by masquerading as the esteemed Dr. Sappho Cade.
But when Bronte arrives at the Radley School of Poetry, she finds the island abandoned—save for six other confused poets, one line of an unfinished poem, and an anonymous host who issues a chilling ultimatum through an enchanted gramophone: complete the spell, and they may return home on the next ferry. Fail, and they die.
There’s another problem: Bronte isn’t magical.
With escape impossible, the body count rising, and her mother still missing, Bronte forms a wary alliance with the infuriating yet brilliant Marlowe Fang. Together, they race to unmask their host before Bronte is exposed—or worse, the next victim.
But beneath the host’s sinister scheme lies an even more insidious plot, one decades in the making. It bleeds beyond the shores of Radley like an ink stain, and no one’s hands are clean. Least of all the people Bronte trusts most.
I was so thrilled to be invited to participate in Julie Lew's street team, and I was even more excited to learn that we would be receiving ARCs as street team members! I want to start out by saying my street team status does not affect my views of this novel whatsoever, and that I wouldn't be rating is so high if I didn't truly believe it was a phenomenal read.
I knew Lew was extraordinarily skilled after I read their first novel, The Wives of Harrick Hall, which I also was lucky enough to receive and review the ARC for. Just like its precursor, Death In Verse was decadently dark, viciously beautiful, and uniquely magnificent. Featuring a cast of queer characters and a unique magic system and conflict that builds, builds, builds, it is truly one of my favorite reads of the year so far!
Death In Verse is an compilation of many things I love in a novel: dark academia, original magic, and characters readers will want to die for. I especially liked the poetry composition of the magic (I may be a bit biased) and how it was twisted and spun into something unique that truly fit the darker nature of the story.
Lew is also incredibly respectful in writing queer voices, and I felt seen both by the characters in the book and how they presented themselves. It was easy to grow comforted by the narrative voice, and their experiences were visceral in a way that is utterly relatable and phenomenally eloquent. I loved this book, and I cannot WAIT to read whatever Lew writes next!
I am blown away by this debut novel from Julie Lew. It is so clever and creative. As someone who studied English Lit, postgrad, I was super delighted by the poetry-based magic system and the fun literary allusions (ex. character names Brontë, Eliot, Marlowe, Ambrose, etc.), as well as the technical poetry lingo throughout.
This was also a nice little detour from my usual heavily romance focused reads. While there is a romance subplot, this story is foremost a mystery.
But I think what I was most surprised by and impressed with, is how this novel, although fantasy, is grounded in historical reality. References to the Great War and the sharply divided opinions among citizens over the country’s involvement add a sense of political and social tension that feels grounded in the period rather than simply decorative. That historical grounding is especially powerful in Marlowe’s character. Non-binary and a Chinese immigrant, they encounter bullying, discrimination and slurs. These moments can be difficult to read, but they serve a purpose: they acknowledge the prejudices and exclusions that shaped the lives of marginalized people at the time, rather than smoothing them over for the sake of a fantasy narrative. We also see Marlowe, and their twin Eliot, grapple with a true sense of belonging and identity through language. Marlowe is frustrated that they cannot remember the language that their birth parents spoke: “Cantonese--the language their parents loved them in, the language they fashioned their dreams for them, the language the sea robbed them of--they knew not one word.”
The book uses fantasy not to escape history, but to explore it. This invites us to consider how some of the conflicts and prejudices of the past continue to echo in the present. It also explores the way language/words can be both a weapon and a refuge. Words can be used to exclude, but they can also create identity/belonging (magic, if you will).
This book is ripe for meaningful discussion. A perfect pick for Book Clubs and even the classroom. Highly recommend this one!
(2.5 stars) Fun time but just not for me. This started off with a pretty promising plot but unfortunately I was quickly turned off by the dialogue, it felt unnatural and corny at times. The characters ages range from teenager to damn near senior citizen and yet it took me at least 100 pages to realize they weren’t all 17 years old by the way they talked (except for agatha but that’s because her name is fucking agatha). I was also quite put off by how much the characters feelings were being shoved in my face, it felt a bit like the author didn’t trust the reader to have basic comprehension skills. I still did enjoy the plot itself and was pleasantly surprised by the big reveal.
This book completely caught me by surprise! I went in not really knowing what to expect, and I ended up being so invested in the story and especially in its characters. It gave me such strong *And Then There Were None* vibes, with the mystery, secrets, and feeling that there was always something else waiting to be uncovered.
Bronte was such an interesting protagonist. I really liked following her throughout the story and watching her deal with everything she discovers while trying to make sense of her own feelings. She is clever, determined, and incredibly protective of the people she loves, especially her mother, despite how complicated their relationship is.
But Marlowe completely stole my heart. They are such a beautifully written character, and their story honestly broke my heart. Their childhood with Eliot, losing their parents, and everything they experienced because of discrimination added so much depth to their character. I especially loved seeing how intelligent they are while simultaneously struggling to recognize their own strength. There was something so emotional about reading their perspective because you could really understand their fears, insecurities, and the way they saw themselves.
The mystery itself was also really well done. I loved how the story moves between the past and the present, with each timeline slowly revealing more about the characters, the school, and everything that happened there. The transitions never felt confusing or unnecessary—they actually made me more curious about what had happened and how it connected to the present.
There are some really dark themes throughout the book, including family secrets, manipulation, lies, and institutional violence, but I liked how these were balanced with friendship, loyalty, and the characters' determination to protect one another. At its heart, this is also a story about finding your voice and refusing to let other people decide who you are.
Overall, this was such an engaging and emotional read. The characters were definitely the highlight for me, especially Marlowe, and the twists kept me wanting to know what would happen next. And even though poetry is definitely not my area of expertise 😂, I actually really enjoyed the poems and the way they were incorporated into the magic system.
I was absolutely enchanted by the premise, but alas, in practice I found this really dull. Present-tense is not my favourite, and it didn’t work here, imo. The setting is slightly historical, the USA just post WW1, which is not at all a period I’m interested in. And if poetry magic has always existed, why does this world look so similar to ours? Why is the technological level the same? Why is there misogyny if women have always been capable of magic just like men? Etc. The worldbuilding felt really superficial.
I was really delighted to discover that Bronte is not the sole PoV character; Marlowe, a nonbinary Chinese American poetry magician, starts having half the chapters about a quarter of the way into the book. At which point, I wondered what on earth we needed Bronte’s PoV for, to be honest. Marlowe is infinitely more interesting; they and their twin are magically bonded, something that only occurs in identical twins two or three times a century; they’re orphans, their parents having died on the passage to the USA, so they don’t know their birthnames and have been completely cut off from Chinese culture; and AS obviously-Asian folks, they’ve gone to school for poetry magic – which, predictably, many of the white students etc are appalled by. With all that, Bronte not being magical was not nearly enough to keep her interesting.
Even with Marlowe’s PoV, though, this book just didn’t hold my attention. It’s reasonable that the gathered poets spend ages looking for a way to escape, rather than getting immediately down to work on the poem-spell…but wow was it boring reading about them wandering around the island, looking for the boat that’s been removed or realising that the telephone lines have all been cut. Etc. All the while different people are working out that Bronte is not in fact her mother, and hissing and spitting at each other, and YAWN.
It just took way too long to get started. Even all the promises of the synopsis couldn’t keep me reading – I kept falling asleep instead.
₊˚ Death in Verse 🌊 ◌ 📜 ‧₊˚ (Spoiler free review!) ❝ Finish the spell before the clock runs out. ❞ ‼️warning: hate speech, misgendering, racism, war discussion, violence and death. - bisexual, nonbinary representation Genre: historical, dark fantasy, mystery, romance sub plot. Rating: 4 📝📝📝📝 tropes: Slow burn, found family, enemies to lovers.
𓆟 ‧₊˚ Plot analysis
In this hauntingly mystery dark fantasy, In 1920 Bronte Cade’s mother disappears and leaves an invitation to a secluded island where the poetry school is located, where she meets all these poets who possess magic and they are all tasked to finish a poem without knowing it’s intent. They have 4 days to finish it and through those days one of them gets murdered but the real question is who is the host? The historical part of this is that some of the poets have been used by the consortium to influence the WWI.
₊˚ 🪶 ◌ 🐚 ‧₊˚ My thoughts: First of all, the cover and description captivated me but the UNIQUE plot truly pulled me in. I liked the concept of poets having to use their magic to finish a spell with limited time. I enjoyed the complex characters and dark magic elements and the world building in this story and i also liked how the author portrayed the backstories of the characters and the multiple POVS because it shows that EVERYONE on this island has secrets👀 and it keeps you guessing because every time i thought i would predict who the host was or what the ending was, I got it wrong 😭.
`✦ ˑ ִֶ 𓂃⊹ 𝗣𝗿𝗲-𝗥𝗲𝗮𝗱: YAYAY thank you Netgalley and Union Square & Co for the arc. Magical poets with mystery plot and a island?! im so excited to start this dark fantasy! 🥹📝✨🖤
This book was such a pleasant surprise! I loved the "And then there were none" vibes, and I think it was even better because the characters had interesting backgrounds and defined personalities.
Bronte is one of the MCs, and I like how she handles the conflicting emotions as the story progresses and uncovers some interesting secrets. She is determined and intelligent, and despite her complex relationship with her mother, Bronte will do whatever it takes to make sure she is ok.
As much as I liked her, my favorite character was Marlowe. They are a beautiful person inside and out. They and their brother Eliot had a very difficult childhood, having lost their parents and being discriminated for one reason or another.
It was heartbreaking to read about Marlowe's childhood, their time at school, and how, despite being so intelligent, he can't realize how strong and resilient he is. I fell in love with them and how their character was written. As a reader, you could feel what they felt and understand their thoughts and fears. It was just beautiful.
The plot has really interesting twists, and I loved the back-and-forth between past and present. The past provides social context, character background, and insights into how the school operates. And these back-and-forths are perfectly done, keeping the story flowing smoothly.
Family secrets, institutional violence, deception and lies, and manipulation are the dark elements in the story. But they are nicely balanced with friendship, loyalty, and strong characters that will fight to keep their loved ones safe and find their voice in a world that wants them shut.
For me, this book is an absolute yes. It was engaging, interesting, and emotional, with amazing characters, and even though I understand little to nothing about poetry, I think the poems to cast magic were nice.
This book was overall very good. Well written with twists and suspense throughout the entire plot. While I did get lost sometimes with all the poetry verses and how they were supposed to work with magic, once I understood how it all worked, the story really became more interesting.
The alternating timelines were a great addition to the story. They really provided a deeper understanding of what was currently happening at the school of Radley. They were not confusing and I was easily able to keep track of what year it was as the story progressed. The same goes for the multiple point of views. Getting to know the guests more really helped bring the book all together.
I really enjoyed watching how Bronte and Marlowe's relationship developed. The author did such a great job in describing both of their emotions that you actually felt them. I personally did not like Marlowe at the beginning (which I think was the author's intent), but they slowly began to grow on me. By the end, they were my favorite guest!
The murders and mystery theme felt like you were reading the game of Clue with poetry threaded in. There was a host who invited 7 guests to a dinner and as each guest begins to be murdered, you are actively trying to figure out where will the next body appear, how will they have died, and who is the murderer among them? Mrs. Peacock in the library with the revolver! I absolutely love the game of Clue so I very much enjoyed trying to solve the case.
I loved/hated the ending. Hated it because of who ended up being the host/murderer, but loved how other relationships came together. It was definitely an emotional ending! I would definitely recommend this book to others who enjoy mysteries.
I did not expect to be broken by a fantastical murder mystery.
Seven poets were invited to a deserted island and forced to complete a poem, with only one line and no other context. Ambiguous clients are the worst, but this one actually kills.
Death in Verse is a satisfying murder mystery that explores helicopter parenting, exploitation, discrimination, lived experiences of immigrants trying to find their footing in a foreign land, politics and conflict fuelled by poem-powered magic.
The best part? It weaves these themes seamlessly into the plot, using them to build characters I’d root for only to break my heart.
Bronte, our main character with no magic abilities, finds herself amongst these poets. I loved slowly piecing together who her mother, Sappho, was through their eyes. What first seemed like a strained mother and daughter relationship gradually became something worth rooting for between two deeply flawed characters.
I enjoyed the world-building and adore the duality devised from the magic system. Ngl, I was impressed it managed to slip in a romance subplot that, although rushed, doesn’t feel too forced.
I live for plot twists in murder mystery, and Death in Verse did not disappoint. That final twist had me going back and forth between hating the villain and sympathising with the motive.
Overall, Death in Verse reads like Decagon House Murders meets Babel, but with a more satisfying, well-paced plot. My only regret was having left it on my TBR for so long.
I’m a big fan of dark academia (especially when it includes magic), so the concept of this book was right up my alley. Add that to a locked-room mystery, and I was sold!
I’m pleased to say that this book lived up to my expectations. There was so much to love about this story—from the magical poets, to the mysterious school, to complicated family relationships, to the main character lying about who she is right from the start. It’s clear that there are many suspicions and secrets woven throughout the school and the cast of characters, and I was intrigued to find out more!
The queer representation in this novel was great, and I appreciated that the difficulties and prejudices they face in society was present on the page and felt realistic (sometimes in a lessened way, which I can understand). In terms of Bronte herself, I thought she was a great main character to follow along with as she tries to decipher what happened to her missing mother.
I liked that there was romance in this book; however, I felt like it fell a bit flat to me, only because the fast pacing of the novel didn’t allow us as much time to see the relationship develop. I think a lot of YA readers won’t mind that though, and I personally still enjoyed this novel overall.
I would recommend this novel for fans of YA dark academia mysteries!
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Union Square & Co. - A subsidiary of Sterling Publishing | Union Square & Co. for allowing me to read the eARC!
There’s nothing particularly wrong with this book (though I question what time period it is, given the derogatory terminology used—but maybe I just missed something). The writing was fine, and the pacing was pretty good.
With that said, I wasn’t engaged with the story, and found myself growing bored fairly early on. So I think it’s best that I set this book aside.
i’m a consistent lover of magic dark academia, and the concept of a locked-room mystery about magical poets at a mysterious school was super appealing. the book does a great job of getting your attention right off the bat with a tense lie and set-up for the main character’s presence and suspicions. i really enjoyed the queer characters in this book, the prejudices and difficulties they faced felt realistic (though downplayed in places, which i’m not really complaining about), while still finding places for themselves as queer people have always done. the mystery itself was exciting and interesting, though the romance fell a little flat for me because of how fast the pace of it was and the timing of certain events. however, i think most of the bits of this book that hit less for me were because it’s a YA novel, so if you are a YA reader who loves dark academia mysteries and complicated family relationships, you would likely enjoy death in verse. thanks to the publisher and netgalley for the arc!
(Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher. This has not impacted my review which is unbiased and honest.)
Death in Verse feels lyrical without even taking into consideration the gorgeous poetry. Lew's YA debut is a world of rolling fog, isolated islands, and the feeling of sparks on the wind. I expected an action packed story about murder, ambition, and investigation. What I didn't expect, was a story about mothers and daughters. Death in Verse examines the distance between these new friends and unlikely allies, but also between the people we are supposed to know the most, the ones we love. Death in Verse revolve around ambition and survival. Trapped and forced to create, Death in Verse unfolds the mystery of the past and secrets which others will do whatever it takes to keep buried.
Absolutely love this book! It’s a chilling story that had me eyeing each character and analyzing every move to figure out whether they were the killer. Bronte and Marlowe are such compelling characters that you can’t help but root for, and their relationship is truly beautiful. Lew does such an excellent job keeping you hooked with well-developed and complex characters, beautiful writing, and a dark and fascinating world. I couldn’t stop turning the page because I just had to know who the killer was!
I was excited to be invited to participate in Julie Lew’s street team. However, my status as a street team member does not affect my views.
An absolutely stellar book that truly has it all, I love it so much!
I was so excited when I saw the description of this book, which has everything I love—poetry, magic, creepy old buildings on deserted islands, everybody accusing everybody else of murder. I’m thrilled to say DEATH IN VERSE exceeded my wildest expectations. It’s like Agatha Christie meets magic school with the melodramatic vibe of the TV show Dickinson, and there were multiple twists I entirely failed to see coming. This book is a love letter to the romantic poets, and I feel like those poets—who all were overly dramatic teens at one point—would consider this a fitting tribute. Definitely going to be recommending this one to everyone I know!
I absolutely love the world building for Death In Verse. It is so atmospheric. Dark, gloomy, and raining. The perfect setting for an isolated school. The characters are also wonderful. There are so many secrets kept between them yet somehow they do grow. My favorite characters have to be Marlowe and Bronte. I love how they are able to lean on one another throughout the book. However, I could have never imagined that ending. The villian of the story wasn't who I thought it was and it broke my heart. This is definitely a book that needs to be on everyone's TBR/bookshelf.
The cover is gorgeous and the synopsis very intriguing, however I just couldn’t get into the story. There were lots of things I liked but not enough to keep my interest. Specifically Brontë’s name is just so cute. I also loved the poetry magic system it was unique. This is much more of a mystery than a fantasy though. And quite the historical academia but not very dark. Thank you to NetGalley, Atria Books, and Julie Yew for the chance to read a digital galley in advanced! All opinions are my own.
Something about the writing style wasn't for me. The book is not written poorly, but I didn't connect with the writing. By the middle of the fourth chapter, I was confused. A 17-year-old is masquerading as her mother, who worked at the school where poets are being lured in for a mysterious reason. Also, there is talk about a boat coming to get them, after being told they need to find a verse that will free them. The premise of the story was very interesting, and the cover was eerily beautiful, but I had no desire to keep reading.
This is set just after WW1 and we see a really big divide between the poets and the 'normies'.
I liked how we saw differing opinions on the Consortium and I also really liked the magic system.
I didnt really connect with the characters just because this book was really fast paced. Also, I didn't really see the buildup for the romance and so I couldn't really get behind them.
This book also deals with racism and transphobia, and I liked how they were handled.
I want more historical Fiction books with a murder mystery type subplot.
I enjoyed Death in Verse tremendously; the world felt grounded, the prose was intricate and immediate, and the characters felt fully fleshed out. I was on the edge of my seat as I watched the mystery unravel, and eagerly devoured the growing connection between Brontë and Marlowe. I would wholeheartedly recommend this book to fans of magic and mystery!
This story gives a real murder-mystery vibe - which unfortunately for me was a bit off putting, as I was more interested in the magic aspect. There were flashbacks used, which can be informative for the reader but for me felt like it was taking me out of the moment too soon.
Marlowe was an interesting character, but that was it for me. Sorry!
Death in Verse follows Bronte, a young woman posing as her mother after her mysterious disappearance, as she returns to the school where her mother once taught.
What follows is a dark, atmospheric mystery filled with magic, secrets, and enough twists and turns to keep you guessing at every turn. The whole thing gave me such strong Clue vibes (which I loved), and I was absolutely obsessed with it.
Julie has an incredibly melodic style of writing that carries you effortlessly from page to page. She clearly cares for her characters, which shines through in the way they are described and challenges them to push the boundaries of what we think we know about them.
There’s something about a mysterious school, a suspicious cast of characters, and secrets hiding around every corner that makes for the perfect spooky-season read. I already know this one is going straight onto my list of books to revisit every spooky season.
The book itself was an interesting concept. Kinda like an escape room experience made into a book form. I will say it takes place in the 1920s and there's a TON of derogatory words used against races that aren't white people so keep that in mind while reading. There's also a non-binary character which was cool. The whole story itself was interesting as well.
Oh, this was brilliant to the point it made my heart ACHE. The world is cruel, and it can force the worst out of people. But there is also so much care, and love, and sometimes those are the scariest things of all.