The expert author of Murderabilia brings a fresh new approach to the irresistible subject of true crime with this statistic-based telling of some of the most notorious murders of all time.
Veteran true crime master Harold Schechter presents hundreds of chilling tales of murder and mayhem told through the fascinating lens of numerology. Each story begins with a number or statistic, followed by a thrilling account of its relevance to a notorious crime or an aspect of forensic investigation, all starting with the number 1—marking the first murder in Colonial America—and reaching into the millions.
Readers will learn why the number 215,000 finally put Al Capone into prison, or how the number 2915 played into the case of alleged JFK assassin Lee Harvey Oswald. How the infamous Dr. H. H. Holmes, the “Chicago Bluebeard,” was acutely aware of his 27-victim body count, or how the number 70 helps shed light on the criminal profiles of serial killers.
With stunning and grisly photos throughout, Murder by the Numbers is a must-have for any true crime obsessive.
Aka Jon A. Harrald (joint pseudonym with Jonna Gormley Semeiks)
Harold Schechter is a true crime writer who specializes in serial killers. He attended the State University of New York in Buffalo, where he obtained a Ph.D. A resident of New York City, Schechter is professor of American literature and popular culture at Queens College of the City University of New York.
Among his nonfiction works are the historical true-crime classics Fatal, Fiend, Deviant, Deranged, and Depraved. He also authors a critically acclaimed mystery series featuring Edgar Allan Poe, which includes The Hum Bug and Nevermore and The Mask of Red Death.
Schechter is married to poet Kimiko Hahn. He has two daughters from a previous marriage: the writer Lauren Oliver and professor of philosophy Elizabeth Schechter.
Title and author: Murder by the Numbers: 199 Chilling Tales of True Crime by Harold Schechter Publisher: Workman Publishing Company Pages: 272 Publication date: October 6, 2026
Thank you very much to the publisher, who provided this ARC through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review!
Okay so my bias must be revealed: Harold Schechter is one of my favorite true crime writers & I think has a lot of responsibility for the transition in popularity away from lurid true novels to more straight-forward and journalistic tones. I was so thrilled to get this ARC into my hot little hands.
I think this book is a fun twist on classic Schechter. A sort of semi-encyclopedia of true crime stories, ordered by numbers: specifically, a number that is important or relevant to the story being told. I was delighted to come across quite a few stories I've never heard before, and finding a new perspective or focus on the stories I was already familiar with. For example, I was familiar with Scott Peterson, but I had never read about the list of 33 things, written by his sister, that showed his guilt. And I had never heard of Joe Roy Metheny, whose weight (450lbs) led to him being called The World's Fattest Serial Killer. Murder by the Numbers is chock-a-block full of a variety of horrific, morbid, bloody little tidbits and I enjoyed thumbing through each. Some I found just fascinating or interesting, and others connected more directly with my interests and will for sure lead to further reading elsewhere.
There is some amount of factual wibble-wobble here (don't get me started on the long-lived Erzsébet Báthori frame up). But I don't really hold that against Schechter in particular; there's an acceptable level of slipperiness in most true crime since it's very difficult to get a 100% accurate reporting of (1) historical incidents and (2) crimes where the only people there were the victim(s) and the killer. There is also some material repeated in multiple entries/stories. Again, though, that only detracted a little from my enjoyment.
Altogether though, I think this is just a fun and informative little trip into true crime. This would be a good buy both for someone looking to dip a toe into the genre & also a good bookshelf display piece for a fanatic.
My thanks to NetGalley and Workman Publishing Company for an advance copy of this book that examines various crimes and atrocites through the lens of numbers, not looking for proofs or theroies why, but more of an examination of a troubled world that even science can't explain.
I once read a quote that said that if one understood math, one could understand the secrets of the world. Maybe one can understand the world, but math does not help in understandinig the evil that man can do. Numbers though can try to balance out certain acts, make them acceptable to us, make us see things in ways that we might not have looked at them before. A little bit of normalacy in the not normal world of murder. Murder by the Numbers: 199 Chilling Tales of True Crime by professor and long time true time chronciler Harold Schechter is a new look at crimes both infamous and forgotten, a study through numbers of the evil that makes up our world.
The book is broken into 199 different sections, each dealing with a specfic number and the crime. There might be numbers for victims, or the amount of times the suspect in the case was passed over by police. The number one is about the first murder and public execution in the American colonies. Some numbers might be trial times, or even years spent in prision. Each section though gives a brief look at a specific crime, some known for numerous documentaries and pod casts, some forgotten by time. The basics of the case are given, investigations detailed, and sometimes even punishments. An encyclopedia of crime but told in numbers.
I have read quite a lot by Schechter over the years, both fiction, his true crime and even his graphic novels. Schechter is a very good writer, able to write books like this withoug exploiting the issue, giving a just the facts kind of telling that is quite refreshing. Most true crime books are a little odd, a little breathy in some places. Some like to roll in the crime scene. Schechter is more of a chronicler, telling what happened, what went wrong, and what might have been if investigations were handled better. The added aspect of numbers is quite interesting, though sometimes one can sense a little digging to find a number that works. In many ways this is a primer on muder, snippets of crimes from throughout history and around the world, told well.
For true crime fans and pod cast listeners this will be a fascinating book. Schechter has a real gift in this kind of writing, and has quite a lot of books on this subject. The added numerolgy was a nice detail that gave the book an interesting view, not just a repeating of classic tales. Perfect for true crime fans, an introduction to the darkness that many humans are capable of commiting.
Harold Schechter is one of my favorite true crime writers. He doesn't sensationalize or disrespect the victims of the crimes he talks about.
This work is a quaint twist on the true crime listicle expanded into a complete book. All based on numbers. Each entry has something to do with the number in its title. It could mean 45 minutes or 45 years. It just has to have a significant number to build upon.
Personally I hate numbers but the way the book is put together feels fresh. Especially knowing the author has written run of the mill tue crime encyclopedias. I won't say there aren't duplicate entries crime-wise from those encylopedias, but it does still feel fresh and in some cases the entry might be an update or a new piece of the puzzle from your typical true crime book. Such as the fact you may not have heard about the size in gallons of each drum filled with explosives in the Oklahoma City Bombings is 55.
The book, like all of Schechter's others, is well put together and dumbs things down without feeling condescending. He makes his work approachable. He treats everything with the respect it deserves. There are a lot of bad authors of true crime books out there who seem to just want to sell books in that skeezy way that brings shame to the genre (making you want to create a Son of Sam Law regarding the genre as a whole) and makes the gruesome criminals' victims into fodder rather than people who were innocent and didn't deserve to be raped and/or murdered..
Thank you to NetGalley and Workman Publishing Company for the review copy!
Thank you Netgalley for an early access version of the book.
2 – Number of copies I'll be ordering for friends when this releases.
5 – Number of stars I'd give this book.
25 – Approximate number of Wikipedia rabbit holes I disappeared into while reading.
100 – Percent chance I read Harold Schechter's next book.
This is my second Harold Schechter book after Murderabilia, and once again he delivered. As a data analyst and a true crime fan, Murder by the Numbers felt like it was written specifically for someone with my interests. The concept of exploring crime through statistics, records, patterns, and numbers is fascinating on its own, but Schechter takes that premise and turns it into a thoroughly engaging read.
One thing I especially appreciated was how accessible the book felt. The chapters are easy to digest, making it simple to read a little at a time or get lost for an entire evening. Along the way, I encountered numerous historical crimes, cases, and events that were completely new to me, leading to more than a few research sessions after I put the book down.
Informative, entertaining, and filled with fascinating stories, Murder by the Numbers is an easy recommendation for true crime readers. I already know a couple of friends who will be receiving copies as gifts.
True Crime is an enthralling genre which I occasionally dip into. Murder by the Numbers by Harold Schechter describes the significance of the number (starting with "1) relating to the murder story. Examples include crimes from hundreds of years ago to recent days, both known cases and those lesser known. Topic examples are varied, such as the price in cents of a box of rat poison in 1862, the number of surviving nutshell cold case studies (Frances Glessner Lee's crime scene miniatures are compelling to read about), the number of items on the hare psychopathy checklist, a physical address number, the weight in pounds of the guillotine blade, the number of sleeping pills reportedly swallowed by Marilyn Monroe, the year the term "serial killer" was coined, and the publication year of the first forensic medicine book. Fascinating stuff.
Due to the often-gruesome nature of the entries, this is a book to read a bit at a time. Photographs and illustrations accompany the stories. The writing is incredible and the amount of research is staggering. A highly informative book which explores some new-to-me aspects of criminal minds, the crimes themselves, and crime detection.
Harold Schecter is the reigning king of true crime in my opinion. Here we have short,(when I say short I mean 1 or two pages long!!), stories arranged around numbers that fit the crime. Here we have 9 for the number of times Peter Sutcliff, AKA The Yorkshire Ripper was interrogated by the police before being apprehended as an example
The writing is very short and to the point. If your looking for a book that aims to answer why these horrible murders took place you’re reading the wrong book. These are short, minutely detailed vinnettes of the crimes in question.
I loved the format of this one and think it would be an excellent starting off point to anyone curious about the true crime genre. 4 stars NetGalley and the publishers granted me an ARC of this work and I thank them from the bottom of my blackened heart!! These words are my own with no assistance from AI, another book reviewer, or any grammar teacher as you can surely tell!!! #fragmented sentence !!!
This was a very brief overview of 199 crimes. Each chapter started with the number and then would discuss a crime about said number, but some of them felt like a bit of stretch at times and or were literally only a sentence or two. There are a lot of popular cases covered in this (Lizzie Borden, Ed Gein, etc.) but the majority of them felt like they were cases I had never heard of before, which I appreciated. Basically this is just a brief introduction to these crimes so this would be a good reference book, but you will have to look elsewhere for a more in depth look at a case.
This was a unique way to explore the subject of murder. As a true crime fan, I enjoyed coming across several cases I had never heard of before. I also thought using numbers to introduce each entry was an interesting approach, even if some of the connections felt like a bit of a stretch.
My biggest issue was the format. At times, it felt more like reading a textbook than a true crime book, which made it harder to get into. I think a more user-friendly layout would have made the information easier to follow and more enjoyable to read. Overall, a great resource for true crime fans.
I really enjoyed this book, and you can genuinely tell how much research the author put into it. I loved the number concept and how it didn't just end when we got to a 100.
I loved seeing people and events that I know a lot about being brought to light in this book. Most notably being from Ohio, I love that the author included the Rhoden family murders. But there were also popular events or people such as Billy Milligan, the Amityville house, Jonbenet Ramsey, the mcdonalds massacre, and the Tylenol murders.
Thank you to Netgalley, Harold Schechter, and Workman Publishing Company for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for my honest feedback and opinion.
Harold Schechter takes traditional fact finding and turns it on it's head with Murder by the Numbers. Each story is 'numbered' by either a number or a statistic that is important to that particular chapter. Short, but informative of so many different events, but yet enough information to keep you interested as you dive further into the book. Especially for those who are interested in patterns, oddities, and trying to make sense of out something that defies it. Highly recommend! *I received a copy of this book from NetGalley. This review is my own opinion*
Murder by the Numbers is an encyclopedic style recounting of historical tales of true crime and the famous number associated with them. This was an interesting book and I definitely hadn't heard of some the cases in this before. My only gripe is that some of the numbers felt like cop outs because they couldn't find a big enough case associated with the number. 3.5/5 stars.
Thank you to NetGalley for a free ARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
The numbers/stories vary from a basic statistic to succinct stories. I read about stories I'd never heard (finally, something new!) and I skipped over some more well known stories and I read some well known ones to read their numerical value.
I didn't find this book to revel in the depravity of true crime or a lazy attempt to capitalize on true crime's popularity. It actually felt like there was an earnest interest in the topic.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing this book in exchange for an honest review. Schechter always comes up with an interesting way of writing his true crime books and this one didn't disappoint. I recommend this book for any true crime fan as it gives short highlights of various crimes and criminals by which the reader can read more about these in other books.
A great almost encyclopedia of different events in true crime. As someone who has listened to true crime podcasts before, many of these cases I did know— but also many id never heard about. Quite an interesting read.
Read via ARC from NetGalley Is a good book to use if you are doing research for a psychology class or studying mental health in that it gives insight to what these criminals were thinking to cause them to do what they did.
With brief entries about a variety of murders, this book should find its audience. Readers are likely to find cases that they wish to dive into and find more details.