This searing romantasy and heart-stopping follow-up to Her Hidden Fire finds Éadha a desperate fugitive, hopelessly torn between fear and defiance, human and dragon . . . and Ionáin and Gry. Each impossible choice will take her further down a path from which she may never return.
Éadha is on the run, having narrowly escaped the cruel grip of the Master Channellers. Relentlessly hunted, she is pushed to the very edge of her world—a place of ancient magic and long-held secrets where she must create a new life for herself in ways she never imagined.
Ionáin is forced to come to terms with the fact that he has no power, nor did he ever. Imprisoned deep in the Fodder holds, he faces the stark reality of what it means to be an enemy of the Masters as he tries to make sense of his future . . . with or without Éadha.
Gry finds himself walking a dangerous line between protecting his Family’s secret legacy and being true to his feelings for Éadha. With his newly revealed powers, he must train with the Masters he despises and find some way to destroy the very system that makes him elite—before that system can destroy Éadha.
Told from three perspectives, Her Rising Flame is a whirlwind sequel of world-shattering secrets, wrenching heartache, and the terrible consequences of power.
Clíodhna O’Sullivan is a writer based in Co. Louth, Ireland. She works part-time as a legal counsel. In the last few years, she has taken part in several writer events, including as a panel moderator at a Terry Pratchett conference in DCU and panellist at the Cymera festival in Edinburgh. She’s reasonably fluent in German and plays in a band, Molasha (you can find them on Spotify!). She is married with three children, one of whom is autistic, as well as far too many cats and a dog.
After the end of the first book I had high hopes for the action that could take place in this sequel. While I enjoyed the story I just feel like some things personally fell flat. Ionáin’s POVs didn’t really add much to the story for me, and felt like a waste of time. We learned absolutely nothing new from them and it was mostly him being whiney, and while I understand the situation he is in is at the fault of Éadha and him being upset I just felt the story would have still worked without them. And speaking of Éadha and Ionáin… girl could just not let this boy that has shown her time and time again that she doesn’t actually matter go. “We have to play the game”… BS he chose to play the game and ignore her and treat her like shit for the approval and acceptance of others and would’ve always left her behind. If she wasn’t his keeper they never ever would have been together and he just thought what he was doing was okay and still in the book she risked not only her life but the life of the dragons for that pitiful boy. Maelsun is dead because she chose to go back to try and rescue Ionáin who literally already told her he wouldn’t go with her!! I understand not wanting him to die for her choices but she should’ve thought of the consequences if/when it was found out. She led the masters right to their door. Gry is a cutie and has always helped and been there for Éadha no matter what and she constantly snubs him by flirting and kissing him and then still choosing Ionáin. The ending was honestly a let down… I am aware this is a trilogy and even on chapter 35 I was like how in tf are we getting a whole ass battle and wrap up in 2 chapters… one of which was her making out with Gry??? Basically we didn’t. The battle scene really fell short for me. It was the longest chapter in the book yet it was extremely rushed and bounced so much between POVs to also like an outside looking in style POV writing that it just felt all over the place. No real justice was brought, and she kind of gave up almost immediately just because of goddamn Ionáin… AGAIN!! Then the power transfer made no sense, left herself defenseless all for Ionáin to miss more shots than he made. Gry stood up beside her despite his family and aunt and the take down of Huath was kind of lame… he’s been this big bad since she was a child and it all was very meh. I am upset by it because this could have been something really epic and it just fell short for me. I am interested in how this series will wrap up. I feel like this book was left both finished and unfinished and didn’t really indicated the direction of the next book. Obviously the Masters retreated but it just kind of full stopped so will be interesting to see where this takes us.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
A little slower than the first, but still as enjoyable.
Following on the heels of her grand escape from Lambay Island, Éadha of Ailm must seek the truth of her gifts from the mysterious, and dangerous, dragon allies to stay alive and overthrow the cruel masters who rule the world.
This is an immensely enjoyable sequel, if a little slow in the middle and needing a tighter voice. The two additional POVs really help to flesh out the world by showing us how the Channeller system works from multiple ranks within. Meanwhile, Gry is now a Channeller, and must secretly gather allies, like Ailbhe, Éadha's rival Keeper dormmate, and Linn, the only other female Channeller, and Ionáin has become Fodder, imprisoned beneath the stronghold so he can be drained of his life force. Of all the POVs I think we should've seen more of him, especially as Fodder. The other characters in his POV are given only one scene of real bonding between them before they're never seen again. Ironically this is in counter to one of the morals of the story: that using people for such means is starkly dehumanising, and yet, as we don't get to meet the Fodder properly, they end up becoming plot devices anyway.
All that said, I had a fun time with this one. I would be interested to know where the third book is going, because this one ties up a lot of the threads pretty well (besides the romance haha).
WILL I READ ON? Yes.
ARC received from Penguin Random House UK Children's in exchange for an honest review. This title releases 5th November 2026.
I read Her Rising Flame as a checkout from Libby, reading both the ebook and audiobook in tandem.
The story picks up after the last story. I felt it was still slow in the build-up; though a lot does happen, it was paced more slowly. Things actively get turned upside down, and more is learned and revealed about what it means to be our FMC. The ending was where I was most excited for the growth of our FMC, where she realized, and had been realizing throughout this story, who she is and what she might be capable of. The romance is still a slow burn, and we are shown glimpses of the romance, but it is very much in the background.
Much like the first book, this one seemed to have a lot of building elements to it before it got to the ending, and we start to get a little more understanding, closure, and glimpses into what might be next for book three. I didn't annotate a lot in the book, but the last ten chapters or so had some really great statements, and I really loved the revelations. I am excited to see where book three will take us in July.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for approving me to read this book, I’m rating it 4.25 stars.
Book 2 packed a punch, after the events of book 1 things were looking a little chaotic and dangerous to say the least. Our FMC is on the run seeking sanctuary in unexpected places, her path opens up more than just the truth of the Leah’s history and also sets her on a journey of what might be next.
Our two MMC’s find themselves in precarious situations that have a real role reversal feel to it. My heart broke for them both in different ways, they both seemed to realise the people closest to them aren’t quite what they seem. There’s new allies, love, darkness and betrayal at the heart of book 2, but oh does it make a powerful combination as we unravel the depths of what the channellers and masters will do to hold onto power. The end of book 2 sets us up for what I feel may be a descent into how far our characters might go to win and be free of tyranny.
Thank you PRH audio for the ALC and Penguin teen Canada for the arc 🫶
💭: The book starts off right where book 1 ends and because of this I was expecting a bit more action, but the majority of the book had a slower pace. I did enjoy that we got to spend more time with the dragons and got to learn more about their history. I would have loved even more of a focus on this though! The two additional POVs in this one were nice to add some different perspectives. Although this book is YA, there are definitely important topics (classism, patriarchy) discussed which I enjoyed. This book has a love triangle, which doesn’t always work for me, but I think it’s done well in this one. The ending was quite action packed, and perhaps a little rushed, but I’m curious to see how book 3 will wrap up the story.
🎧: This book is narrated by Evanna Lynch, Eoghan Collins, and Stefan McCusker in a dual style narration. The audio is really well done and it’s definitely the format I would recommend. A lot of the names in the book are based off Irish names so it was great hearing the narration with the correct pronunciation. I enjoyed doing my immersive read because I could see the spelling of the words and learn how it was pronounced and it really pulled me into the story.
Thank you, Penguin Teen Canada and NetGalley, for an advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Rating: 4.5/5⭐ Spice: 0.5/5🌶️
Quick Summary: Set in a world governed by the powerful Master Channellers, Her Rising Flame by Clíodhna O’Sullivan follows Éadha, Ionáin, and Gry as they navigate the consequences of the events of the previous book. While Éadha flees the Masters and searches for a new life, Ionáin is imprisoned in the Fodder holds and struggles to understand his future without his powers. Meanwhile, Gry must train with the Masters despite despising their system, all while protecting his Family’s secret legacy and grappling with his feelings for Éadha.
Read if you like: ⚡️young adult fantasy dystopian trilogy ⚡️love triangle (done in the best way), but this time each person has a POV ⚡️Game of Thrones mother of dragon vibes (or maybe I should say sister of dragon) ⚡️fugitive heroines relentlessly hunted by the authorities ⚡️powers with consequences
If you like this, read this: 📚Red Queen by Victoria Aveyard (for more young adult fantopian but without the dragons) 📚Traitors by Willa Hollis (for an adult fantopian with amazing romantic tension and more "world wants to destroy the girl with power") 📚Sky's End by Marc Gregson (for more unique magic system, but make it a male main character)
*full list of trigger warnings can be found at the end of this review
**SPOILER-FREE REVIEW**
Short statement: I have finally made a decision on who I'm rooting for in this love triangle. And the choice shocked even me.
Things I liked: I love that the start of this book is the end of a scene from the previous book. The sentence that ended a chapter of Her Hidden Fire is the sentence that began Her Rising Flame. There is a small bit of overlap, and it really helped to get back into the story quickly. This would be a really cool trait to add to some other series. Imagine if the start of every sequel (okay, maybe not EVERY) started with the ending scene of the last book. It could also act as a mini recap.
When I say I get whiplash with this story, know that it is self-inflicted. I could very well choose a side of the love triangle and stick with it, but instead, I let Clíodhna's incredible writing pull me every which way. How can I go from sympathizing with Ionáin and hating Éadha in the first chapter to understanding Éadha and her actions in the very next? It was the same with the last book, where I couldn't decide who I liked more of the two love interests. I am never like that! I always make my choice and stick with it, but noooo, Clíodhna had to go and make things hard for me (I say lovingly). It is an incredible reflection of Clíodhna's ability to make a reader switch up so quickly on a character. She gives you insight into thoughts and feelings you hadn't considered earlier. (Side note: I know who I'm rooting for now. I have made up my mind.)
Ummmmm, you're going to give me Chapter 11 and then take it from me?!!
Blú is adorable. Honestly, there are no notes on him. A cat?! Sign me up! He is adorable and so full of life. I will now be adding Blú to my short but growing list of favourite side characters/favourite main character companions. Some of the other characters on this list include, but are not limited to, the gargoyle from The Knight and The Moth and Manchee from The Knife of Never Letting Go. More books need a lovable, non-human companion. AND a note to the authors who plan to add such characters: I pass on a message from all readers; don't be afraid to add a disclaimer at the start of the book to say that no lovable, non-human companions will be killed in the making of your book. It would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.
Side note: I read further into the book, and I just have to say... I forgive you, Clíodhna, for what you took from me in Chapter 11.
I seriously can't believe how good Clíodhna is at writing romance. My only complaint is that there isn't more of it. I want more in the next book! The tension between the characters and the true emotions that they share is unmatched. I can't remember the last time I read a book with romance in it where I truly felt the connection between the characters. Not to mention, I usually HATE love triangles, but every part of me loves this one. I don't know. I can't understand this phenomenon. Clíodhna just knows what she's doing.
I have to take a moment to appreciate how well the multi POV was done in this book. I rated both book 1 and book 2 the same, but I would say I liked book 2 more simply because of how well the multi POV was done. I loved getting to witness the internal thoughts of each character. It gave new insights that I had not considered previously. I would also like to mention that some chapters would slightly overlap, but in the best way! You would go, "Wait, what was this character thinking during this scene?" And then Clíodhna would go, ask, and you shall receive! This book was an incredible experience. I will be counting down the days until book 3.
Things I didn’t like: I wish there was a recap of Leah's story near the start of this book. I had to wait a few months between the two books, so Leah's story was not fresh in my mind. I feel that if I had even a brief mention of Leah's story, I would've understood things more when it came up. I can only say so much without giving any spoilers. And this review wouldn't be considered spoiler-free if I added spoilers, now would it? So, you're just going to have to trust me on this one. (Please note that this paragraph of my review did not impact my overall rating. This is merely an observation.)
Is BLANK [redacted to avoid spoilers] invincible? Truly. Like, how many times can someone be hit with a fireball to the chest before they actually cease living? I am not a fan of characters that are made to seem invincible simply to build tension. Tension and suspense should be built through the character's demeanour and their actions, not by them being unexplainably and unbelievably strong. If you lay down the laws of this world, i.e. fall ball to chest = death, then you can't break the rules just because this character is crucial to the story. You've got to keep things consistent.
I'm not going to lie, the end of this book is the reason it isn't 5 stars. The ending of this book felt very much like a TV series scared of getting cancelled. It doesn't feel like there is more story to tell. You could tell me this series is a duology and I would believe you. It felt like the publisher was worried that the second book wouldn't sell, so they told the author not to leave off on a cliffhanger. All I have to say is, I want a cliffhanger. I want tragedy. I want loss of a character so insane that I cry. However, with all that being said, I loved this book. I was so enthralled through it all that I feel empty now that I'm not reading it. As you can tell, the very few things I didn't quite like about this book didn't have a huge impact on my overall experience.
If this is/was a series, would I continue? ABSOLUTELY; is that even a question??
Is this a genre/type of book I would normally read? yes If no, did the genre/type of book affect my rating? n/a
Do I recommend it? YESS Who would I recommend it to? anyone looking for a young adult fantasy book with dragons to fill that desire for Fourth Wing
If I had a kid in MIDDLE school, would I let them read this? maybe, I would say the tongue during kissing is a bit much, but it wasn't too bad; definitely way more appropriate than other books being marketed to grade 7 If I had a kid in HIGH school, would I let them read this? yes
My ranking of all the books in the series: 1. Her Rising Flame 2. Her Hidden Fire
**Content and Structure Overview**
Age Category: young adult Fiction/Non-Fiction: fiction Genre: fantasy, dystopian, romance Subgenres: love triangle, class divide Series/Standalone: trilogy
Book-to-screen adaptation? no
POV: triple POV, third person, past tense POV Character(s): 17-year-old male (Ionáin, pronounced Yun-aw-in), 17-year-old female (Éadha, pronounced Eh-ya), 17-year-old male (Gry Flemin)
Romance: straight romance Spice: 0.5/5🌶️
Is there heavy kissing? yes, roughly 3 scenes Wandering hands/mouths? a bit, it was more wandering eyes though Is there below-the-belt shenanigans? no Is there a fade-to-black scene? no Is there on-page horizontal tango? no
Is there profanity? yes, but it doesn't happen often F-word? yes, with first occurrence in Chapter 4, very infrequent use, once at the start and once at the end
Trigger Warnings: *disclaimer: this section contains specific details pertaining to this story; please note that character names and exact timestamps of events have not been included in the creation of this list 🚨animal cruelty and death 🚨bodily injuries (blood loss, broken bones, burns, concussion, cuts, internal bleeding, ruptured organs, skull fracture) 🚨dead bodies (burned, charred, floating in water, turned to ash) 🚨death and murder (burned to death, drowning, exhaustion, organ overload and failure) 🚨death of a loved one and/or family member 🚨drugging 🚨grief and loss 🚨gore (blood, graphic description of dead bodies) 🚨imprisonment (gagged, restrained, used) 🚨mentions of rape and rape resulting in pregnancy 🚨torture (mind torture) 🚨violence (fire violence, magic violence, physical violence, war violence)
Quotes Worth Remembering: "You always did confuse doing things for him for love." "Ye can't try to own someone and not have them turn on you eventually." "My power breaks the things I love." "To meet again as strangers." "Change doesn't come. It's made." "Every choice worth making involves something foregone. If we focus only on what we lose, we'd never make any choice." "Humanity's a hard habit to break." "Nothing ever changes without knowing the truth first." "It's not my job to be someone else's fantasy of change."
Not as strong as the first book imo, but a solid continuation.
I wanted to love this as much as the first one, but I think there were some pacing issues. The three POVs slowed down the story a fair amount, and there was also a lot of relatively pointless traveling. Characters would travel huge distances (absurdly quickly) just to have one conversation and then leave and go travel many miles to go to a new place. The stakes also weirdly didn’t feel as high in this one, as our main characters were largely unthreatened and miraculously saved from any actual danger.
I did really like the backstory we get for the dragons in this one, I wish more of that had been explored but we weren’t actually with the dragons for very long, which was my main problem with book 1 as well.
I’ve seen some other review complaining about the romance being a bit confused, but I actually like it, I find the love triangle a strong part of the book BECAUSE of the confusion not in spite of it. A real love triangle shouldn’t have a clear answer.
So yeah, overall a bit weak but I’m excited for book 3.
Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for this eARC!
Favourite tropes: - YA yearning - Dragons! - A niche one - when an animal (tiny kitten in this case) is saved from the brink of death and becomes a loyal companion to the FMC
Thank you to Clíodhna O’Sullivan and Penguin Random House UK Children's for an eARC of this book on NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Overall, this was a very enjoyable read. It picks up right where book 1 finishes and expands from one POV (Éadha) to three (adding Ionáin and Gry).
One of my favourite parts of book one was the magic system, particularly the source of magic and its roots in classism. The additional POVs expanded the scope and allowed us to travel to more places in the world, and there is a very interesting development in the magic system toward the end of the book. The triple POV also kept the plot moving at a good rate, especially when the characters were not in the same location. It also allowed us to get to know Gry and Ionáin better, having only seen them through Éadha’s eyes previously.
This book solidifies the love triangle from book one so if you’re not a fan of love triangles, you have been warned! As it’s YA, there’s naturally no spice but there is PLENTY of yearning. I’m not usually a huge fan of love triangles but I actually enjoyed this dynamic, as the two men reflected different parts of Éadha’s life - the comfort and ‘safety’ of home vs her newly-embraced power and all that comes with it. I genuinely have no idea how it will resolve and I’m not entirely sure who I want her to end up with!
Overall, this was a solid second book in a series, which while not expanding the magic system, did expand the scope through additional POVs and new locations. The plot moves along nicely and we get some significant character development, especially in the dynamic between the trio. anded the scope through additional POVs and new locations. The plot moves along nicely and we get some significant character development, especially in the dynamic between the trio. I’m looking forward to picking up book three when it’s available!
Her Rising Flame is a really strong second book in the trilogy and completely avoids the dreaded second-book slump.
At the end of book one, all of the characters are left in pretty terrible places, so this book is all about dealing with the aftermath. While the first book reveals that the system that’s been in place for generations is deeply flawed, this one explores why it exists and what it actually takes to dismantle it. I loved watching the characters slowly challenge everything they’ve been taught and realize that the world isn’t as black and white as they once believed.
The way this book handles anger and grief was especially well done. Each character has to decide what to do with those emotions, and seeing them learn how to break cycles instead of repeating them made for some really satisfying character growth. For a YA fantasy, it was refreshing to see such nuanced choices and mature development.
The romance takes a bit of a backseat, but I didn’t mind because the story, world-building, and character arcs are so compelling. The pacing stays fast, we learn so much more about the world’s history, and there are plenty of twists and high stakes moments.
I’m really excited to see how everything comes together in book three. If you were worried about a second-book slump, don’t be, this one absolutely delivers.
The first book in the series was an unexpected delight earlier this year, so I was really looking forward to continuing the story in the sequel. The second book was maybe a bit slower pacing than the first, but it was still pretty engaging and I read it in a few days. Dragons? Magic system with consequences? Two strong love interests? ANIMAL SIDEKICK? I didn't want to put it down!
I do think this book suffers a bit from being book 2 in a trilogy, though with that said I'm still not really sure how this is all going to wrap up in the last book. It really feels like we are hitting some peaks at the end of book 2, so I'm intrigued to see how much more there really is left to fill the third book. It almost feels as if like... sure, things aren't fully wrapped up, but there's no huge cliffhanger ending like in book 1. If I never got a third book, I'd equate it to if The OC Season 4 never existed, not like Netflix cancelling Mindhunter cliffhanger betrayal. That being said when book 3 comes out, I'm absolutely going to continue reading – I feel like the magic system is unique and there's so many parallels to real life that can be drawn from the story. It really packs a punch beyond just a love triangle YA romantasy.
Thank you to the author, publisher, and Netgalley for the eARC of this book, I definitely would recommend it!
Thank You NetGalley and Penguin Young Reader’s Group for a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review! All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
Her Rising Flame is Book 2 in Her Hidden Fire Trilogy. It continues where book 1 left off. We see Eadha is now on the run from the Master Channelers. They will stop at nothing to find and eliminate her. They do not appreciate the fact that she has outwitted and overpowered them. Ionain is now pure Fodder for his supposed role in everything. And Gry is stuck between trying to help Eadha and Ionain and following through on his responsibility to his family and the secrets they carry regarding the Leah. A war is brewing between the Master Channelers, the apprentices, Eadha, and the Dragons! The question is, whose side will everyone choose? Gry attempts to muster more help from his fellow apprentices without the Master Channelers finding out, so he will risk a great deal. Who will win this coming battle? When I finished this, I knew I needed the last book in the trilogy, but alas....I have to wait You can feel the tension in the book, and I don’t mean just the looming war! I mean the love triangle brewing between Eadha, Gry, and Ionain. Eadha has some important choices she must make, as well as Gry and Ionain. I loved reading this novel, it pulled me right into the story! You don’t want to miss this when it comes out November 3, 2026!
Thank you NetGalley and Penguin Random House UK Children’s for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This story started immediately where the last book left off. I really enjoyed the addition of the extra POV’s.
I was quite surprised with one of the big twists and that made it very hard to put the book down. To be honest, I would’ve loved even more time with the dragons.
At the end, I felt like the story was halfway wrapped up but I also hard some questions so I’m happy we’ll have a third book that’ll wrap the story up completely.
And did you know this series has been optioned for a YA series adaptation? Truly such wonderful news and I hope it will translate to the screen well!
Wow Ionain really is an idiot cinnamon roll, that poor boy. I’m glad he’s not a jerk like most of the men in this book but wow were his chapters hard to read. The reveal about Leah was fantastic and I was also completely convinced Eadha was going to become a dragon. In hindsight of course she wouldn’t because where would the love triangle go then haha. I was annoyed at her for not being able to choose between Ionain and Gry. It didn’t feel very fair to either of them. I didn’t enjoy this book as much as the last, possibly just because so much of it was Eadha being indecisive in different ways.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I read Book 1 ages ago, and honestly, all I remember is that I hadn't really enjoyed it. Finally got around to picking up Book 2, and I think it was a lil better than the first one. Though the ending was kinda meh.
And that's pretty much all I have to say about this series.
Amazing! I’m looking forward to the third book in the series! Love triangles aren’t my thing, but this one almost feels like a “why choose” situation with the guys! 🤷♀️ The storyline moves quickly, and the characters have depth.
Her Rising Flame was exactly what I wanted from a sequel: bigger stakes, deeper character work, more complicated relationships and a world that suddenly feels much larger than it did in the first book. I already liked the foundations of Her Hidden Fire, but this second instalment made me considerably more invested in Éadha, Ionáin and Gry because all three are forced to confront who they are when the structures that previously defined them begin to collapse.
The decision to tell the story through three different perspectives worked extremely well for me. Éadha, Ionáin and Gry are physically separated for much of the story, but their individual journeys constantly echo one another. Each of them is confronting power from a completely different position: Éadha as someone being hunted for hers, Ionáin as someone discovering that the power he thought he possessed never existed, and Gry as someone suddenly given access to the very system he despises.
Éadha remained the character I was most emotionally invested in.
After escaping the Master Channellers on the back of a dragon, she is no longer simply questioning the world she grew up in — she is actively being hunted by it. Her journey eventually takes her toward the Dragon Archipelago, where she hopes to find safety and answers about her nature and abilities.
What I loved most about her arc was the tension between freedom and fear. Escaping oppression does not suddenly make her free emotionally. She has spent so long being told what she is allowed to be that even when those physical restrictions disappear, she still has to work out what she actually wants.
There is also much more anger in her this time, and I appreciated that. She isn’t endlessly noble or forgiving. She is frightened, frustrated and increasingly unwilling to accept a system that has harmed so many people. That made her development feel much stronger than if she had simply become a confident fantasy heroine overnight.
Her connection to the dragons was another highlight for me. The mythology surrounding them becomes much more important here, and those sections gave the story a sense of wonder that balanced some of the darker political material. Kirkus also specifically noted the sequel’s integration of Irish mythology, and that influence gives the fantasy world a more distinctive identity.
Ionáin surprised me the most.
His storyline is painful because so much of his identity has been stripped away. He has to confront the fact that he has no power and never did, while imprisoned in the Fodder holds and treated as an enemy of the Masters. PenguinRandomhouse.com I initially worried that, separated from Éadha, his chapters might feel less important. Instead, I thought they gave him much more depth.
His story forces him to exist outside the role he thought he occupied. Without status, power or Éadha beside him, who is he? I found that question much more interesting than simply waiting for him to reunite with her.
His chapters are also some of the darkest emotionally. There is a vulnerability to Ionáin here that made me understand him better, particularly because his future is suddenly completely uncertain. I liked seeing him struggle with resentment, fear and the consequences of decisions that can no longer be undone.
Gry’s storyline might be the most politically interesting of the three.
After discovering his own abilities, he has to train alongside the Masters while simultaneously wanting to undermine the system that gives him privilege. He is also trying to protect his family’s secrets and deal with his feelings for Éadha.
That contradiction made his chapters genuinely tense.
He can survive partly because the system values what he is, while Éadha is endangered by that same system. I liked that the book doesn’t ignore the discomfort of that position. Gry wants change, but he is also benefiting from the hierarchy he wants to destroy.
And then there is the relationship between Éadha, Ionáin and Gry.
The love triangle becomes much more complicated here, and surprisingly, I didn’t mind it. Love triangles often frustrate me when they exist simply to prolong romantic indecision, but here the relationships are intertwined with identity, loyalty and power. Éadha’s feelings cannot easily be separated from everything else happening to her. Both relationships represent something different, and the physical separation between the characters gives those feelings space to become messier rather than immediately resolving themselves.
I genuinely changed my mind more than once about what I wanted romantically, which is probably the best compliment I can give a love triangle.
The larger political themes were also stronger in this sequel.
The story increasingly questions who is allowed to possess power, who gets punished for having it and how institutions convince people that inequality is simply the natural order of things. Reviews from both School Library Journal and Kirkus have highlighted the book’s themes of feminism and justice, and I thought those ideas were woven naturally into the characters’ individual struggles rather than feeling like an external message placed on top of the fantasy. PenguinRandomhouse.com Clíodhna O’Sullivan’s writing also felt more confident to me here.
The prose is still very accessible and fast-moving, but there is more emotional weight behind it. She doesn’t overload the reader with decorative description, which helps keep the story moving even when the political and magical world is becoming increasingly complicated.
I particularly liked the way the three POVs differ emotionally. Éadha’s chapters carry urgency and uncertainty, Ionáin’s feel more claustrophobic and introspective, while Gry’s are filled with the tension of constantly performing loyalty to people he despises. That variation prevented the alternating perspectives from becoming repetitive.
The pacing is also much stronger than I expected from a middle book. Second instalments can sometimes feel like long bridges between an exciting beginning and a dramatic finale, but this one actually feels necessary. The characters change, the world expands and important truths reshape what we previously understood.
There is a lot happening, dragons, secrets, imprisonment, magical training, political resistance and romantic tension, but for most of the book I thought the balance worked.
My only real reservation is that the three-POV structure occasionally made me impatient. There were moments when one storyline reached a particularly tense point and I desperately wanted to stay there instead of switching characters. A few revelations also arrive quickly enough that I would have liked slightly more time to process their emotional consequences. And yes, sometimes I wanted considerably more dragons.
But these are very small criticisms compared with how invested I became.
What impressed me most about Her Rising Flame is that it doesn’t simply repeat what worked in the first book. The characters have been scattered, their assumptions have been destroyed and each of them is forced to rebuild their understanding of the world from a completely different position.
Éadha is discovering what freedom actually costs.
Ionáin is learning who he is without the identity he was given.
Gry is discovering what it means to resist a system while standing inside it.
That made the story feel larger, darker and much more emotionally complex.
This was a fantastic sequel for me, full of dragons, political tension, Irish-inspired mythology, complicated relationships and characters who became far more interesting once everything familiar was taken away from them.
Not quite a perfect five because I occasionally wanted more breathing room between some of the major developments, but this came extremely close.
Thank you so much to Clíodhna O’Sullivan, Penguin Random House UK Children’s, Penguin and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC. I really appreciate the opportunity to continue this series and to read and review this book.
This series is steadily becoming one of the more memorable ones for me. The narrative choices that O’Sullivan makes in books 1 and 2 set it apart from a lot of current YA Fantasy, and so the story feels both large and small, vast and yet still comforting, like a quaint home in a dense, wild landscape.
In Her Rising Flame, we return to Domhain and a familiar cast of characters. Éadha has fled from the Masters, who are enraged by her existence and her unwillingness to be part of a harmful, broken system built upon abuse and suffering. They’ve set out to destroy her, weaving careful lies around the truth that paint her as a threat to her fellow apprentices, and the hunt quickly begins.
Éadha fears she has nowhere to go but to follow the dragon she escaped with, although there may be allies yet that she can trust to help her. As the relentless power of the Masters closes in, Éadha is forced to make a choice that could alter her entire life and may cost her the very thing that has kept her going. Ionáin, meanwhile, must reckon with the truth that he has no Channeler ability, and so will endure an entirely different fate than what he had envisioned for himself just days before. And Gry, forced now to accept his inheritance and step into a role he never wanted, must find a way to make a difference in the oncoming war despite the fear of what will happen if his resistance is discovered.
Peril, wonder, and romance fill the pages as Éadha continues her journey and discovers the parts of history that the Masters buried, which might prove to be the key to their defeat, if she can accept the hefty price.
…
This was a great installment and continuation of Éadha’s story. Her struggle against the Masters is painful and reflects the very real hopelessness that can enter your mind when it seems that no matter what you do, your opponent will do worse. It feels like an impossible battle to win, but there’s still some hope left in Éadha’s allies, and it is that alliance and support that can mean victory for those who aim to end a harmful system.
The romance in the story continues to progress, and challenges arise alongside small triumphs. The intimate moments often feel hard-won, but sometimes they also feel misplaced. I know where I hope Éadha will go, and I know who I hope for her to go to when the story comes to a close. But that doesn’t mean that I don’t appreciate both relationships and their value to Éadha. I want to see everyone with a happy ending in book 3, and I’m especially interested in seeing where Ionáin’s new development will take him.
4/5 stars. I’m pretty pleased with this second book, and I’m excited for the next one!
Thank you NetGalley, and the publisher, Penguin Young Readers Group, for the ARC. This is my honest, transparent review.
So I really enjoyed the first book, and when this popped up on Edelweiss, I immediately reached out to the publisher to get permission for it. I’m really glad I did, because I enjoyed this story and where it went as well. And now to see this wasn’t the end, like I’d kind of assumed it might just be a duology at first. I had wondered at about 80% if the story could finish up in what was left or not.
This was a good continuation of the first book. Éadha is now on her own. She first tries to go to her home, where of course she really did know she couldn’t stay. But then she tries to go to Gry’s family, as they were the ones who had connections to what she has found out about her powers. Unfortunately she can’t stay there either, as the Masters go to find out if she might be there or if they might know where she is because of their connections. So in the end she must go back and be with the dragons. While there she finds out about the original Leah, and how the dragons came to be and what their actual connection is.
I can’t remember if we got anyone’s POV in the first book other than Éadha’s. But in this one we get the other two characters who are definitely in a love triangle. Ionáin and Gry. Ionáin was her childhood friend and of course who she is sure she is in love with. But Gry is the new guy. Ionáin is suffering now because the Masters have found out he had no power all along, and not only that, at the end of the first book, he helped her escape. So his punished. Gry is able to survive and even be treated finally much better as the fact that he does have power is now known even as he hid it before, and he is able to claim that Éadha drained his power and knocked him out before taking off. Even though actually he told her to take his power to help her fight and get away. Gry has his own feelings for Éadha, but tries to step aside because of her feelings for Ionáin. Gry also tries to pull in others from the school to his side. By showing them how the women have been kept from being able to have the power, even though one of them definitely does. And another has been kept as a channeler instead of ever becoming a master.
While Éadha comes back to save Ionáin, it only leads the Masters to take their fight to the islands of the dragons. Once there, the fight is massive and so many deaths. And while the dragons and Éadha and her friends may have somewhat come out the victors of this fight, the Masters have retreated, but they know they will try to recoup and come back to finish it off. Éadha must now figure out how can she save her friends, the dragons especially, but also how can she and her friends help the world to change. To save all the people being used as fodder by these masters, to give everyone a fair chance. And that is where I believe the 3rd book will take us. It seems that will come out in July I think? So I need to be on the lookout for that one too!
There is some romance, and while nothing really happens or is explicit, most is kind of fade to black or else interrupted before anything can happen.
Her Rising Flame by Cliodhna O'Sullivan Her Hidden Fire #2 Fantasy NetGalley eARC Pub Date: Nov 3, 2026 Penguin Young Readers/Viking Books Age: 16+
Eadha is running from the Master Channellers, knowing that if they catch her, she is dead. But the places she thought were home or safe, hurried her away to protect both them and her. Her last choice is the islands at the edge of the world.
Finding out he has no powers, Ionain is imprisoned as Fodder, at the mercy of the Weavers and the Masters in the castle above, and he knows his time is limited.
Believed innocent; victim of Eadha's attack, Gry now must train as a Channeller to keep protecting his family's legacy, and hide his true feelings for Eadha while listening to the Masters plot her destruction.
This is the second and final book of the series and picks up after the previous book, though it lacks a decent recap. There is some spaced here and there, like when a character is brought up, but without an earlier backstory, that person is a little vague. A nightmare of said person while Eadha is sleeping would be a great place to add something like that, and would give her, the person, and the 'trauma' depth.
I'm also not a big fan of multiple perspectives, and this one has three, but the chapters are titled with which character's POV it is, so that helps, but sometimes there's a blur, as if the author forgot who they were writing about.
But this story was great! It moved along at a good pace and kept to the plot and storyline while adding more depth to the characters, magic, and history of the world. I will admit that I was a little disappointed with the... spoiler... Sure, it made sense and added to the magic/history/drama/'war', but it felt a bit too much, and with a side of eww.
The other... spoiler... could have been a little more descriptive, more this and that.... to really put things in motion and give it that jolt readers crave. But instead, the action wasn't very detailed; feeling hurried, and then dropped and flatlined.
There are a lot of class differences: rich/poor, and the rich bullying and controlling/sacrificing the poor, violence, and, of course, there had to be adult content. It didn't go far, but it still pushed the boundaries, so it's not suitable for readers under sixteen. (It is sad that adult content is added to books that could really give younger readers a feeling for empathy, something that I think is missing, but sex sells.)
Overall, great story/series!
3 Stars
This eARC was granted by Penguin Young Readers/Viking Books through NetGalley (Thank You) in exchange for my honest review.
First of all, thank you to Penguin Young Readers Group and NetGalley for the opportunity to ARC read Her Rising Flame.
There's always a little bit of nervousness going into a sequel after loving the first book. Thankfully, Her Rising Flame exceeded every expectation I had.
I genuinely could not put this book down. I read the entire thing in a single day because every time I thought I'd stop, another chapter pulled me right back in. It's one of those sequels that constantly gives you just one more thing to discover.
One of the biggest strengths this time around is the addition of multiple points of view. Instead of simply making the cast larger, each perspective adds something meaningful to the story. It gives a much broader understanding of the world, the conflict, and the impossible decisions every character is forced to make. I found myself equally invested no matter whose chapter I was reading.
I also loved how much bigger everything felt. The mysteries introduced in the first book begin to unravel, long-held beliefs are challenged, and pieces of the history finally start falling into place. Every revelation made me even more excited to see where the trilogy is headed.
The character growth was another standout. Everyone is pushed outside their comfort zones, and watching them evolve because of those experiences made the emotional moments land even harder. There were several twists I didn't see coming, and I loved how naturally earlier plot threads came back into play.
As for the romance... let's just say this book completely messed with my loyalties. I started out convinced I knew exactly who I was rooting for, but by the final page I wasn't nearly as certain. The relationships become far more layered, and I'm now fully invested in seeing how everything unfolds in the final installment.
If I had one small critique, it's that the middle slows down a little compared to the fast-paced beginning and ending. Even so, I never lost interest because every quieter moment was building toward something worthwhile.
Overall, this is exactly the kind of sequel I hope for. It doesn't simply continue the story—it expands it in every possible way. Bigger stakes, stronger character development, fascinating world-building, and enough twists to keep me completely hooked. I finished this book even more invested in the series than I was after Book One, and now the wait for the finale begins.
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House UK Children’s for a copy of this eARC! I would be happy giving this a 3.5 star rating if Goodreads allowed!
This book picks up IMMEDIATELY after the finale of book one. It keeps a quick pace, even through large sections of meandering across wilderness. I enjoyed the plot of this more than Her Hidden Fire which shows the writing has matured somewhat, and that I’m still invested in the very interesting magical world contained in Domhain. The expansion of multiple perspectives to see Gry and Ionáin’s stories helped me see Ionáin as less of a self absorbed prick, though I’ll be honest I still truly don’t understand why Éadha would still care for him this much. It also meant we got to spend more time with Fodder, learn their strategies for survival, see more of the continent through Gry’s family and, of course, we got to see the dragons!! This was the most exciting part to me, but it does take a good chunk of the book to get there as Éadha shows her youth and sentimentality in her decisions within the early chapters. But once we’re there, a lot of reveals and twists happen which make the plot quite fun!
My biggest critiques come in the romance elements. I’m honestly confused whether this is going to turn poly, whether we’re going to have Éadha just choosing herself and no man, or if she’s leaning towards Ionáin as we see Gry step back. This would really piss me off as I am a 110% Gry fan and think Ionáin should just go home. There’s no clarity and lots of confusing moments which, in Ionáin’s case don’t build up their romance, and in Gry’s case there is some romantic build up and progression… but nothing concrete. Alongside this romance confusion is the end where, yes, Éadha does have the last shot at our big villain, but she makes choices regarding her power which I just don’t get. I’d rather have seen her be all powerful than hammer in this idea that she is a giver. I want to see her take and really embrace her power, but perhaps that’s just my desire for female power showing. Perhaps that will happen in the final book of the trilogy? I’m honestly not sure what will happen in the third book, but I sincerely hope some romantic clarity will come.
I will absolutely be reading the conclusion to this trilogy, though I’m skeptical about how the romantic arc can be satisfyingly concluded. From what we learn in book two as well… I’m also not sure where we go from here other than more war and perhaps revolution. I guess I’ll see in what comes next!
A bit slower than the first, definitely suffering from middle book syndrome. Not a whole lot happens, but the pieces and parts are being moved into position for a hopefully epic finale.
The goods: the world-building is still really great. I like that we've got this entire governmental system built on a really believable lie rather than something stupid and readily apparent like in other common YA fantasies these days. I like that a good number of side characters are willing to buck the system, though I wish more of them had the balls to actually stand by their beliefs I completely understand how hard to is to go up against such a massive entity. That all felt really well fleshed out. I still highly enjoy Gry and his whole character, and I want the world for him.
The not so goods: Éadha is still infuriatingly reckless in this book, just getting an idea into her head and charging after it full tilt, no consideration or even second guessing. And most of what she's doing is so clearly a mistake. She claims she's done all this learning from her errors, but really she's just copping the excuse that everyone around her suffers. WHY COULD THAT BE, ÉADHA? Yes, part of the fault lies with the government after her, but SO MUCH of her problems are of her own making. I also hate her wishiwashiness with both boys, and if this love triangle goes on any further--or worse, if those comments towards the end of "sharing" and "passing it on" are hinting at a throuple--I will riot. I will scream and DNF, and then I will riot. Gry deserves better than that. Hell, as much as she irritates me, Éadha deserves better than that. For all the apologies she felt she owed Ionáin, he owed her WAY more for his absolute fuckery in the first book. He shouldn't be worth kissing her boots, and she's groveling to him for trying to save him? Fuck that noise. He can have his redemption arc, but if he gets the girl, this series will have been a massive disappointment and waste of time for me.
Overall, an entertaining but firmly middle book that suffered from some pacing issues and seemingly going in circles for a while, but once the plot got going, it really got going. I'll definitely be reading the last one, and crossing my fingers that it doesn't turn out the way I think it might.
Huge thanks to Netgalley and Penguin Random House for this e-ARC in exchange for my honest review!
This second book really outdid itself!! It was such an improvement from the first book and I devoured it. I really felt like this moved so well and the three different POVs were impactful and moved the plot along to where we ended. Now I do not know if this is the last book in the series. It seems like it could end here but it also seems like this could just be the beginning. It is very difficult to say this series should be classified as a romantasy and be compared to Powerless (throw up emoji). I feel that this characterization is a total marketing miscalculation that it leads readers to expect something different from what they are getting. When I listened to O'Sullivan's description of the first book and why she wrote it and what the themes are, THAT is what made it all made sense and made me want to read this book. I feel that the publisher filled the first book and some of the second books marketing with useless buzzwords that really take away from the real theme within the series which is exploration and inequality. Especially since it derives from the struggle of the author and of being an Irish person. The "love triangle" is hardly anything in comparison to the main plot and themes. This is a high fantasy with a little bit of romance and complex characters and a complex world. The world building and magic was top notch and it flowed so well in this book and all the work that was done in the first book paid off. This series is a true example of you cannot judge a first book until you have read the whole series. I loved the way this all ended and I was very pleased with everything. Every single chapter had me hanging onto every word. I felt like there was a little bit of growth for our FMC, but a lot of growth for our MMCs. Éadha still continued to be irrational and stubborn, but many times there were people there to stop her from making the wrong decision which was nice. I still feel that she needed to be aged up to match the rest of the characters, they all felt much more mature than she did even in this book still. Other than that I have no complaints and would continue to read this series if there are more books to come.
Thank you NetGalley and Penguin Young Readers Group | Viking Books for Young Readers for this e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This is an ARC for Her Rising Flame by Clíodhna O'Sullivan. It is book two in a trilogy. I would like to thank Penguin Young Readers Group for providing me with this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
This ARC was not offered in Kindle format, so I had to read it on my phone. If you are like me, and wear corrective lenses and reading glasses then you know this is not ideal. Due to eye strain, I could only read for short periods at a time. This is in no way the author's fault, but I wish the publisher, or whoever was responsible for formatting the ARC, would have offered a Kindle version like everyone else does.
Unlike book one, which is written only from the POV of the FMC—Éadha—this installment is written from three; Éadha's, and her two possible love interests Ionaín's and Gry's. I have noticed that more books are doing this as they move from the first book to later books in the series. I liked all three of the perspectives, but I found myself enjoying Éadha's more than the others. One of the reasons is because she is with some amazing dragons during a large portion of the book!
Dragons are ubiquitous in fantasy stories—and they are usually static in the genre—but in this book they are quite unique! They are able to speak, but they prefer to communicate telepathically. The way they come into being is also a creative aspect in O'Sullivan's telling. I will not say how this happens, because spoilers! But, you will love it when you read it. Maybe the most interesting aspect is their compassion and peaceful nature. They will only fight if attacked first.
Being a YA book, the romance in the story is PG, which I liked, because it fits this novel well. While the trope is not exactly "why choose", it leans very close to it. I am not a fan of this or love triangles in general, so I did not love this aspect of the book. This is just a personal preference and I know that many people do enjoy it.
I highly recommend this book, especially if you are a fan of magic, amazing dragons, light romance with love triangles and books where the "little guy" fights the hegemonic oppressors. I am looking forward to book three!
Her Rising Flame by Cliodhna O'Sullivan ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Young Readers Group for the eARC!
Her Rising Flame picks up right where we left off, with Éadha on the run from the Master Channellers. Before fleeing, she meets with Ionáin to not only confess her feelings but also reveal the terrible thing she did with his powers. Ionáin struggles to come to terms with life without his abilities while also being viewed as an accomplice to Éadha's actions. Loyalties within his family are tested, and true colors begin to emerge as the consequences of the previous book continue to unfold.
As for Gry, he is quickly learning that being part of the First Family means every move he makes is watched and scrutinized. Walking the fine line between appearing loyal to the Master Channellers while hiding his feelings for Éadha proves far more difficult—and dangerous—than he anticipated.
Having three different perspectives in this installment added a deeper layer to the story than the first book. With the characters spread across different regions of the land, each viewpoint provided new insight into the unfolding events. In book one, we primarily experienced Éadha's frustration and heartbreak as Ionáin seemed hot and cold toward her. This time, however, we gain a much better understanding of Ionáin's perspective, particularly his complicated family dynamics and relationship with his uncle.
Not only do we get to see how Éadha's secret ultimately plays out, but we also witness the repercussions of Gry's own choices and secrets. Watching the consequences unfold from multiple perspectives made the story feel richer and more emotionally impactful.
One element that stood out more prominently in this book was the folklore surrounding Leah. I thought it was a unique and fascinating addition to the worldbuilding that added even more depth to the story. Without giving too much away, I am very intrigued to see where book three takes both the dragons and the evolving folklore.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This is a rare middle book in a trilogy that is better than the first. We pick up exactly where Her Hidden Fire left off with Éadha fleeing to the dragon isles, Ionáin exposed as powerless, and Gry desperately trying to figure out how to save Éadha and keep up his double life for the sake of his family. The introduction of Ionáin and Gry’s POVs helps to balance this book and expands the reader’s understanding of the different dynamics at play, which works well as this one is fairly fast-paced, especially when the dragons are actively involved.
Unlike the first book, I really enjoyed the relationship between all of the main characters. I liked how much Ionáin grows, and I also appreciated that the soft, self-sacrificial core of Éadha’s character, while frustrating, was itself a plot point that hopefully spells out growth for the final novel. I felt that Gry outshone the other two in this book, struggling with his own desires and morals and constantly forced to come up with creative solutions to the constant flow of problems that barge into his path. As a character-focused YA fantasy, I felt satisfied by our main cast and their growth even when the villainy passed firmly into the realm of cartoonish evil.
The passage of time is too fluid, and I found I had to occasionally pause reading to look back at the previous couple of chapters to figure out when exactly the unfolding action was occurring in relation to other events. This is very excusable in Ionáin’s chapters as he spends most of the novel with an increasingly limited ability to accurately assess how much time has passed. It’s less excusable in Éadha’s chapters, particularly in the middle of the novel where her magical growth is the focus. Gry’s chapters are more grounded, and, despite the fact this dude takes massive head and bodily trauma like it’s his job, his POV is the most grounded in the day to day. Overall, this is a great second book, and I will pick up the third one with hopes this will stick the landing.
The first book in the series was one of my top reads of 2025 (I had an ARC of the first book too) and I knew I had to request the second book. One thing that I thought was interesting was the introduction of multiple POVs. Of course, given how the last book ended, multiple POVs were definitely necessary with most of the plot-critical characters being separated. However, I didn't find the POV of Gry to be that compelling or interesting as he was remarkably centered on Éadha.
The first chapter starts of literally where the last book ended, which I think will be nice for people who didn't re-read this book before reading the sequel. However, I did have some trouble remembering some of the names of minor characters from the first book which made the glossary at front useful. The introduction of talking dragons was interesting although I think it would have been better if they remained relatively un-talking like the last book. I also liked how the book dived into the dynamics of the Keepers and how the system was designed to encourage Keepers to be angry at the people rather then those in charge.
The overall story felt a little directionless compared to the first. In the first, the characters had clear goals and motivations set against the backdrop of a magical school. In this one, all of the characters seem to wander around various settings without any concrete plans. While that is more realistic (how exactly are teenagers realistically going to take down an entire system?) it doesn't exactly make for the most compelling story. This book definitely goes more into the world-building which was interesting and answered a lot of questions from the previous book that I had. However, some of it was presented in info-dumps. Overall, this was a good and solid sequel but it wasn't quite as thrilling as the first.