Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Books of Dubious Origin #2

Witches of Questionable Intent

Rate this book
A librarian witch must use her bookish knowledge to track down a dangerous, magical tome, in this enchanting novel from New York Times bestselling author Jenn McKinlay.

Thanks to her training as a librarian and her newfound magical abilities, Zoe Ziakas thinks she has a handle on her job at the Museum of Literature safeguarding the secret collection of enchanted tomes known as the Books of Dubious Origin. But when Jasper Griffin—the colleague she’s been crushing on—reports that their most volatile acquisition, The Book of Shadows, has been stolen, Zoe’s carefully cataloged world unravels.

This isn’t just any magical text. It carries unquestionable power, twisting truth into illusion and turning allies into enemies. Once its power is unleashed, no one can trust what they see or who they are.

To track down the book, Zoe, Jasper, and the rest of the BODO team plunge into a perilous hunt that takes them from shadowy midnight markets to demon-infested streets, all while wrangling an unpredictable hellhound puppy. But when the thief begins to invoke the book’s darkest spells, Zoe faces an impossible challenge: How does she stop a curse that can rewrite reality itself?

If she can’t separate fact from fiction, the story won’t just end—it will be erased.

368 pages, Kindle Edition

First published November 10, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jenn McKinlay

93 books5,611 followers
Jenn is the New York Times, USA Today, and Publishers Weekly bestselling author of several mystery and romance series. She is also the winner of the RT Reviewers’ Choice Award for romantic comedy and the Fresh Fiction award for best cozy mystery. A TEDx speaker, she is always happy to talk books, writing, reading, and the creative process to anyone who cares to listen. She lives in sunny Arizona in a house that is overrun with books, pets, and her husband’s guitars.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
61 (35%)
4 stars
74 (43%)
3 stars
27 (15%)
2 stars
8 (4%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 59 reviews
Profile Image for Short, Sweet and Cozy.
1,645 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 3, 2026
Witches of Questionable Intent is the 2nd book in Jenn McKinlay's Books of Dubious Origin series and it is awesome! The characters and fantasy world pulled me right in and kept me entertained right through the end. Zoe Ziakas is a new witch and now works at the Museum of Literature that houses the Books of Dubious Origin (BODO). Her boss is Miles and her coworkers are Olive, Tariq and Jasper. Zoe has a crush on Jasper which adds to the story. Jasper is on a job and returns with the Book of Shadows which has spells that give the user power. When the Book of Shadows is stolen from the BODO, they have to figure out how to get it back. Their search takes them through a magical market and enemy locations. Zoe learns a lot along the way and the BODO team is a second family. They don't know who to trust and they realize things are not what they appear to be. Zoe gets Diego, a puppy that turns into a hellhound. Diego is a fun addition to the story. There is so much to love about these characters and the story. The creativity that went into creating it all is impressive and makes the story come to life! #WitchesOfQuestionableIntent #BooksOfDubiousOrigin #NetGalley #BerkleyPublishingGroup #AcePublishing
Profile Image for ☕️Kimberly  (Caffeinated Reviewer).
3,745 reviews814 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 31, 2026
Continuing to enjoy this series.

Witches of Questionable Intent is the second audiobook in the Books of Dubious Origin series. Like most fantasy series, the books build on each other, and for this reason, I recommend listening in the order of their release. In book one, Zoe received a grimoire, which began unlocking her abilities. You’ll need to grab the first book, Witches of Dubious Origin, to learn more.

Zoe’s career as a librarian is coming in handy as she works and trains at the BODO (Books of Dubious Origin Department) hidden at the Museum of Literature. She loves her job protecting these enchanted tomes and is making friends with her team. In particular, the half-demon and their leader, Jasper Griffin. When Jasper tells Zoe, Tariq, and Olive that a recently acquired book has been stolen, the team sets out to find the Book of Shadows. The tale that unfolded kept me listening into the wee hours as the danger grew and the kisses smoldered.

McKinlay did a stellar job with the world-building for this series. We meet many supernatural creatures, and the role of the BODO is quite clear. All the characters are unique, and the pacing superb.

The team first searches the magical hidden market, and Zoe ends up adopting a pup. But Diego is not an ordinary pup as you will soon learn. As a new witch with a powerful grimoire, Zoe soon finds herself acting as bait to lure the thief out. Twists, turns, spells and danger abound.

I adore the team at BODO and the books contain with in. Some have their own spunky personalities. Zoe’s grimoire has its own personality as it comes to her aid. The theft wrapped up, and I am excited to see what happens next. The romance is a slow-burn, and I am enjoying the journey.

How could I not listen when the narrator is none other than Saskia Maarleveld? She brings each character to life with unique voices and can switch between female and male effortlessly. From pacing to tone, she enhanced my overall enjoyment of the tale, and I cannot imagine enjoying this series any other way.

If you like cozy paranormal fantasy with motley crews, magic and mystery, you’ll want to grab this series.

This review was originally published at Caffeinated Reviewer
Profile Image for Paige.
341 reviews12 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
November 2, 2026
This is book 2 in the Books of Dubious Origin series. Another action packed book with lots of twists and dark humor. I would name all the things I loved, but those would be spoilers. I will say that I really like all of the different character personalities and am looking forward to book 3!

*Provided an advance copy from the publisher for review. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for The Romance Book Disciple (Samantha).
2,181 reviews367 followers
November 11, 2026
Witches of Questionable Intent is a continuation of the Books of Dubious Origins series by Jenn McKinley. Librarian Zoe has to track down a stolen book with her coworkers. Oh, and that book is kind of dangerous.

Zoe has a crush on Jasper so there is tension! Oh, and a magical dog!! Zoe is learning more about her new powers and growing as a witch. Her magic comes from the grimoire, and she is still finding its powers. She and the BODO team are on a mission to get The Book of Shadows back and its exciting! You get a cozy fantasy story with a (very) slow burn romance, and fun side characters.

You need to read the books in order, so start with Witches of Dubious Origin first! The series is unique and engaging, so its not a hardship!
Profile Image for Deb.
55 reviews
November 18, 2026
I am sooo loving this new series! I love the character development and all their interactions! Mystery, humor, and light romance all in one - can't wait for the next book to see what crazy adventure Zoe and gang go on!🩷
3,700 reviews39 followers
November 10, 2026
Witches of Questionable Intent by Jenn McKinlay is the second in a series featuring the Books of Dubious Origin, BODO, which was a part of the Museum of Literature in New York City. It was housed in a historic Gilded Age Mansion. Zoe had come to accept the secret of magic running in her family that her mother had tried so hard to keep. But, she is a novice, as her trainer, Olive, points out on a regular basis. Then something good happens, Jasper returns. He had been off on a mission, she didn’t know what, but she was happy he was back. It turns out he had been looking for a book, which he had found, and now had returned it to the vault at the BODO. There was celebration all around with the pinnacle, the Annual Fundraising Gala, a costume ball with all costumes based on book characters. Zoe had an amazing costume and it was appreciated by all, especially Jasper. Then, tragedy struck, and it took an interesting form.

Thus began the quest to recapture the book, along with many revelations along the way. More than any author I have ever read, McKinlay imbues her heroines with her own personality. She is a living example of “voice.” This is an interesting group of people that Zoe works with and he villains are even more interesting. The plot was good, and it was a chase, full of magic. Zoe is still getting used to it all and sometimes her powers surprised even her. It was a good chase: a fantasy thriller. Good read!

I was invited to read Witches of Questionable Intent by Berkley Publishing Group. All thoughts and opinions are mine. #Netgalley #BerkleyPublishingGroup #JennMcKinlay #WitchesOfQuestionableIntent
1,795 reviews26 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 26, 2026
Zoe is becoming more adept at her witch skills and finds that she needs them now more than ever. The recently acquired Book of Shadows has been stolen and it’s up to Zoe, Jasper, Miles, Tariq, and Olive, the BODO team, to get it back before the thief can use it. The team faces a number of challenges and are in great danger. They aren’t sure who they can trust. Zoe rescues an adorable puppy she names Diego that turns out to be a hellhound and the two bond instantly. Diego turns out to be a great addition to the team.

Secrets are revealed about Jasper, Zoe’s grimoire and The Book of Shadows and Zoe learns how to time travel. An exciting addition to the Books of Dubious Origin series!

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Shannon.
9,765 reviews464 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 6, 2026
This second book in the series was just as much fun as the first!! Zoe grows into her newly discovered powers, teams up with colleagues, her familiar and her half-demon love interest, Jasper to take down a demon intent on stealing a book of incredible power. New secrets are revealed, loyalties are tested and there's even a fun time travel moment into the past where Zoe gets to see her dead mother. This really felt like an incredibly well executed episode of Charmed! I was here for it all and can't wait to see where the series goes next! Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early digital copy and @prhaudio for a complimentary ALC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Tyler Hancsak.
652 reviews209 followers
October 26, 2026
I didn’t even know this sequel was coming, but boy oh boy was it fun! This was a perfect way to continue the story and further develop the world and characters.
Profile Image for Marlene.
3,640 reviews255 followers
November 13, 2026
Librarian and witch, Zoe Ziakas may have been the “witch of dubious origin” of the first book in this delightful cozy urban fantasy series, but she’s absolutely NOT the “witch of questionable intent” in this follow-up.

Zoe may not have come fully into her powers – at least not yet – and she’s not always certain of precisely what she’s doing – although she’s learning the magic she was once denied as fast as she can – but her intentions are not questionable at all.

Not that there isn’t at least one witch with extremely questionable motives causing havoc in this story. (And not that Zoe herself doesn’t cause the occasional bit of havoc when her magical reach occasionally exceeds the grasp of her newly trained powers). But Zoe is one of the librarians on the staff of the BODO, the Books of Dubious Origin department of the Museum of Literature, and her motives – and those of her colleagues’ – are all on the side of good.

This second entry opens on the heels of the ending of the first. At the end of Witches of Dubious Origin, Zoe’s colleague and maybe/might be/could be boyfriend, Jasper Griffin, is assigned to track down and return with the legendary “Book of Shadows”. A grimoire believed to be entirely mythical until the BODO received the assignment from the Global Council of Magisters.

Jasper’s return WITH the “Book of Shadows” sends the librarians of the BODO into a frenzy of dangerous scenarios – including a literal frenzied dancing mania that is barely stopped in time. A dance of distraction to cover up the theft of the Book of Shadows by the nefarious demon, McWrath, aided and abetted in theft by the Odessa Van Doren, the witch of extremely dubious intent of the title.

With the Book of Shadows in his grasp, McWrath could rewrite history and memory for everyone on Earth. He could make himself a literally unstoppable tyrant, not just through the power of magic and money and armies, but by controlling people’s memories so that any rebellion would be doomed before it began.

He can’t be allowed to keep the Book of Shadows. It’s up to Zoe and her friends to stop him, even as he rewrites their memories of everything they’ve accomplished. To succeed, Zoe will need to figure out her own powers and learn to use her own grimoire.

And she’ll need the help of a magical book-cat to find her mother. Her mother may be hiding in the past, the present, or even the future. It doesn’t matter, because cats, especially book-cats, can go wherever and whenever they want. IF they want to cooperate, that is.

Escape Rating A-: The first book, Witches of Dubious Origin, was utterly delightful from beginning to end. It wasn’t quite ALL setup and introduction, but a lot of it was. And it zinged along because there was so much to set up and all of it was fun and fascinating. (And, like many readers, I love a good training montage and that first book was all about Zoe learning and training and introducing herself – and the reader! – to a world we’d all want to live in. In spite of the danger.

This second book is a bit darker. Zoe may not understand everything – at least not yet. She’s clearly the newbie at the BODO and her more senior colleagues make it clear that she still has a lot to learn. But they’re (mostly) kind about it and certainly willing to take the time to train her up right.

But fate – and McWrath (terrible villain and terribly obvious name) – have other plans, and this time around Zoe gets thrown into the deep end of the danger on every side.

Beginning with her love interest, Jasper, who has been keeping a really big secret that Zoe really needs to know. A secret which is both the least of their troubles (this time around) and the key to the resolution of the case.

From one perspective, this story is a whirlwind evocation of many magical locations and tropes. From Jasper’s magical origins to the twinkling but dangerous magical market, to Zoe’s acquisition of her familiar (and vice versa) as well as the nature of that familiar creature, all the way to the “Phantom of the Opera” style setting of the faux denouement of the story.

Underneath all of that, the stakes are extremely high. McWrath is seeking a rewrite of history – and the future that derives from it – on a scale that hasn’t been seen since Star Trek: First Contact – in spite of the way that SF reference mixes metaphors.

This is also one of those rare stories where all the Chekhov’s guns come down off the various mantelpieces and are effectively fired by the end. Every dropped clue and tiny detail in the early chapters comes to some sort of satisfactory – if frequently dangerous – conclusion before the story as a whole works all of its magic.

Part of that magic is that this is also Zoe’s coming-into-power story. She started the first book disbelieving completely in magic, but ends this second book having fully accepted and invested herself in her growing power.

At the same time, this is also the story of a found family, very much like the circumstances in the Mythwoven series. Zoe was abandoned by her mother as a young girl. Her mother was running from magical enemies who would kill them both – and ultimately did kill her. Zoe was left safe in the arms of her mother’s dearest friend, but she’s never recovered emotionally from that abandonment. In the BODO she’s found a new family, a real love, and finally the reconnection with her mother that she’s always craved.

No matter how fraught THAT’s going to be in future books in the series. Which there certainly will be, as the ending of this book sets up the necessity for four more books in the series, and I can’t wait to see who, along with what dangers, turn up with the discoveries of the Books of Echoes, the Book of Whispers, the Book of Secrets and the Book of Destiny in future volumes.

Originally published at Reading Reality
Profile Image for ✰ Bianca ✰ BJ's Book Blog ✰ .
2,408 reviews1,347 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
July 14, 2026
description
description

4.5 Stars

We're back with our BODO gang from the Books of Dubious Origin at the NY Museum of Literature. Zoe is pretty new at this witch job and she's still trying to find out how everything works - especially her family's old spell book. And suddenly they're right in the middle of another book mystery: the book of shadows has been stolen right from under their noses. Demons! Off we go to save the world again. With all that danger and excitement, there's also a little time for some romance and fun and we get a cute little magical puppy!
I really enjoyed reading this second book - please read the first book first!
I hope that this will be a very long series - I'm already in love with Zoe and Jasper and all the others!

WITCHES OF QUESTIONABLE CONTENT was a great 2nd book in this cozy magical crime series. Mysterious. Funny. Dangerous. Supernatural. Sweet. Adorable. Exciting.

If you can't click the buy-links
from your phone - click ► HERE!


description
💜 💜



Smokin Hot Book Blog Smokin Hot Book Blog Smokin Hot Book Blog Smokin Hot Book Blog


Profile Image for Steph Stump.
8 reviews
November 19, 2026
I absolutely loved returning to this world and these characters. Witches of Questionable Intent didn’t quite reach the full five stars that Witches of Dubious Origin did for me, but considering I landed at 4.75, we are very firmly in nitpicking territory here.
All of the returning characters continue to be wonderful, and I really enjoyed the direction this book took by expanding on the rare and powerful magical books that were already such an important part of the first story. The search for the Book of Shadows gave this book its own adventure while also opening up the larger mythology of the series in a way that has me very intrigued about where everything is heading. By the end, I definitely had my little conspiracy-theory hat on about where the larger mystery surrounding these books might be heading. I have a very specific theory about where this is going, and I will be delighted if I'm right.
Most of what kept this from another five-star rating came down to the villain and some of the execution surrounding Zoe's magic. I wasn't especially drawn to the villain in this one,
I don't necessarily object to Zoe's emotions being tied to her magic, especially when she is still so new to her abilities, but I would love to see more of her magical development come through learning and practice. Zoe is such a bookish character and is now completely steeped in the world of BODO, so it feels particularly fitting for her growth to involve studying, experimenting, practicing, and gradually figuring out what she's capable of. I think I expected her to be a little further along by this point because of everything and everyone she now has access to. That said, she's still very much a baby witch, and it feels like we're reaching a point where she may finally be able to explore her grimoire and abilities more intentionally. I'm really hoping that's something we get to see in future books.
I also wanted a little more development between Zoe and Jasper. I genuinely like them together, which is probably why I noticed the pacing so much.

Overall, though, these are relatively small criticisms of a book I thoroughly enjoyed. I still love this cast, I love BODO, and I particularly love that the mythology surrounding these incredibly rare magical books is getting bigger rather than each book simply feeling like another isolated adventure. There is clearly more going on here, and the possibilities introduced in this book have made me even more curious about the larger direction of the series.
Witches of Dubious Origin still has the slightest edge for me at a full five stars, but Witches of Questionable Intent came incredibly close. I have some nitpicks, I have theories, and most importantly, I absolutely want to keep following Zoe and the rest of the BODO crew wherever this increasingly strange magical-book situation takes them next.
Profile Image for Stephanie.
1,539 reviews38 followers
November 12, 2026
Zoe Zaikas is still getting a handle on her magic, learning her grimoire, and settling into her job in the Books of Dubious Origin department at the Museum of Literature when her crush, Jasper Griffin, suddenly returns from an assignment. Jasper has retrieved the Book of Shadows for safe storage; however, shortly after its arrival at the Library, the book is stolen by a demon. In the wrong hands, the Book of Shadows could unravel the world. Now assigned to the team tasked with retrieving it, Zoe and Jasper must work together to flush out the demon and the witch determined to use the book for evil. To combat their enemies, Zoe needs to quickly build confidence in her magic skills and gain a deeper understanding of her grimoire. At the same time, Zoe and Jasper must navigate their relationship as secrets unfold during their search. With danger coming from every angle, Zoe must rely on her unique skills and call upon unexpected allies to help the Library regain the Book of Shadows.

Witches of Questionable Intent is the second book in the Books of Dubious Origin Series.  This is a fun and exciting fantasy romance.  The action started right away, pulling me in with danger and suspense.  The characters are all wonderful and distinct.  I enjoyed each of their quirks and abilities.  Zoe's character holds immeasurable strength but needs to be confident in her abilities and connection to her magic.  As the demon who stole the Book of Shadows creates trouble, Zoe's timeline to harness her powers shortens.  I enjoyed watching her grow and rely on her instincts and use her magic to help herself, her colleagues, and connect with her grimoire.  Jasper was an amazing partner, he moved at Zoe's speed, communicated well and seemed to know what she needed as their relationship progressed.  I enjoyed Diego most of all, a seemingly chaotic puppy that turned into a powerful, magical asset.  The story's pace moved quickly as Zoe faced multiple dangerous and demanding scenarios.  I enjoyed the mystery of the Book of Shadows and the different places the team explored while tracking it down including the night market, the opera house and more of the Library itself. With more secrets revealed and more books to track down, I'm looking forward to the third book.

This book was received for free in return for an honest review. 


1,306 reviews40 followers
November 20, 2026
Zoe Ziakas is a librarian working with enchanted tomes known as the Books of Dubious Origin. Her crush and colleague Jasper Griffin soon reports that their most volatile acquisition, The Book of Shadows, has been stolen. It contains spells capable of rewriting reality and warping perceptions. Zoe, Jasper, and other members of the BODO team plunge into a search for the book while caring for a hellhound puppy. When the thief begins to use the book’s darkest spells, Zoe isn't sure she can stop a curse that can rewrite reality.

Witches of Questionable Intent is the first I've read with Zoe, but it's the second book of the Books Of Dubious Origin series. There are references to what happened in the first book,but it's easy enough to dive right in and keep going without reading the first book. (If you are interested, you can check out Donna's review of book 1.) Zoe isn't in complete control of her magic, and possesses a powerful family grimoire that will only allow her to use. While she's learning about the magical world for the first time, we do too. Magical and somewhat sentient books and artifacts are real in this world, as are all manner of magical creatures and alternate realities.

The story moves rapidly, and I agree with Jasper's assessment about Zoe being chaotic. It's not her fault, because she (and we) don't know the rules. There are specific ones for dealing with demons, meeting witch covens, or moving through a magical midnight market. The missing spellbook is important to find, and Zoe agrees to do her part in tracking it down, including serving as bait. This is how we get to meet new characters and see places, and she picks up a hellhound puppy by accident. Everyone else knows who she's dealing with before she does, and must explain it and coach her on how to interact with them. She's a fast learner, and the situations escalate faster than her colleagues expect them to.

Zoe careens from one situation to another, hence the sense of chaos and rapid pace as we turn the pages. The story ends with a clear hook for future novels in the series, and you might have a guess as to what will happen to these dangerous books. Time will tell if future books in the series match that guess.
274 reviews
November 13, 2026
Witches of Questionable Intent picks up a few months after Witches of Dubious Origin ends, returning the reader to the B.O.D.O. as Zoe to continues her witch training, and her work in the department. Her relationship with Jasper has been on pause as he was away on a top secret assignment, and their romance keeps progressing quite slowly in this book. Everyone is settling in to their normal routines when the arrival of The Book of Shadows sets the team off on a new adventure. This quest has a fairytale feel, giving Zoe, Jasper, Miles, Olive and Tariq an almost Arthurian vibe as they work together to retrieve a new book of dubious origin for the department. I liked this sequel even more than the first book. Witches of Dubious Origins was great but the start of a new magical series always necessitates a lot of time spent on essential world building, explaining the magic system and introducing a number of core characters. In this book, the reader gets to dive right into the action and it takes a more linear path that is easy to follow and understand. The focus is definitely on character development as they navigate a lighthearted mystery. The action is enough to keep me invested without feeling too dark, although the story could have a little more depth as sometimes things seemed to work out too perfectly and easily. I really appreciate the depth of the core team at the B.O.D.O and how essential they all are to the story. The found family bonds continue to grow and deepen. Each character is fully fleshed out and I’m excited to learn more about them as this story really reads as an ensemble piece. The addition of Diego was especially wonderful. Animal familiars are always a good choice. Some mysteries from book one get answered, tying up a number of loose ends, while still leaving enough of an opening for the next book. I really liked how the plot furthers the lore of the world and sets up the next book, as well as the arc of the series as a whole. This is a fun, cozy fantasy series that is easy to read and function as a nice palate cleanser. I am looking forward to the next book in the series!

Thank you to Berkley and NetGalley for the complimentary arc.
Profile Image for Darla Taylor.
1,959 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 19, 2026
Zoe Ziakas is a trained librarian who has newfound magical abilities. She believes she has a handle on things, especially with her new job at the Museum of Literature. There she helps safeguard a special collection of enchanted tomes known as the Books of Dubious Origin. But when her colleague, Jasper Griffin, tells her that their newest acquisition, "The Book of Shadows", has been stolen her carefully crafted world comes apart. This isn't just any magical book, it has unimaginable power that can twist truth into illusion and turn allies into enemies. Once its power is unleashed, nothing can be trusted.

To track the book down, Zoe and Jasper along with tbe rest of tbe BODO team start a perilous hunt taking them from shadowy midnight markets to demon-infested streets. Along the way, Zoe gains a hellhound puppy while she and Jasper develop a deeper bond. But when the thief begins to use the book's darkest spells, Zoe faces an impossible challenge ~ stopping a curse that can rewrite reality. To stop their story from being erased, she has to separate fact from fiction.

This is the second book in a new series by Jenn McKinlay and it was an absolutely thrilling read. I received a copy of this book from NetGalley and Berkley and this is my honest, unbiased review. I was drawn into this tantalizing tale and kept hooked from beginning to end. The book was incredibly well-written with well-developed characters and a fast-paced plot. This is a fascinating paranormal story with intrigue, romance, and suspense along with a magical crime to be solved. There's also an utterly adorable hellhound puppy who almost takes over the story in an amazing way. Jenn McKinlay is a fabulous author and storyteller whose books are automatic reads for me. Each of her books, from cozies and more, whisk you away for at least a few hours taking you to another world. I thoroughly enjoyed this magical series which is a first for the author. Both books were beyond excellent reads and I highly recommend them.
Profile Image for Beth.
482 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 7, 2026
Thank you to PRH Audio for the gifted ALC and Ace Books for the gifted finished copy and eARC!

*This is a review for a second book in a series, this will be spoiler free but I do hint at things that occur in book 1, so if you want to go in blind of vibes maybe skip for now.*

I was able to ARC read the first book in this series by Jenn McKinlay, Witches of Dubious Origin, last year and I enjoyed it so much. It was cozy and filled with found family and learning about yourself, and I loved it. This second installment had the same vibes just enhanced. Zoe is really coming into her own, her relationship with Jasper is deepening and lovely, and the found family is just even stronger. I was fortunate to be able to immersive read this with PRH Audio. The audio was so good, Saskia Maarleveld did a great job. She gives each character their own distinct personality and tone, her pacing and inflections were great and I was able to listen at my normal 2x speed with no issues. I definitely recommend an immersive read for this one!

The plot was really good too, I enjoyed the mystery of her family's grimoire and deciphering it, I enjoyed the mystery of figuring out who stole the strong magical book that Jasper had acquired, and the found family was just awesome. It's one of my favorite tropes and this one just felt like a big hug. I would recommend reading these books in order, I think the first book's background for the characters and Zoe's journey is important to have. I also really enjoyed that we learned more of Jasper's background. He felt like a really strong character in this installment.

Overall I would totally recommend this series for a cozy fantasy read, they are packed with fun, action, and loveable characters. This is releasing November 10th!

 *This ALC was given by PRH Audio and a finished copy and eARC was provided by Ace Books through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.*
Profile Image for Anna Tan.
Author 37 books178 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 30, 2026
I feel like librarian witches are slowly becoming my thing lol.

A dangerous magical tome has been stolen, and it's up to Zoe Ziakas and her colleagues at the Books of Dubious Origin (BODO) department of the Museum of Literature to track it down. Obviously, her more experienced colleagues are the ones organising the hunt, but Zoe has a perk they can use to their advantage - as a witch still learning to control her powers and settling into the city, she has unprecedented access to investigate people and places that the others already have history (and beef) with.

I actually picked this up because I thought it was a standalone, but it turned out to be book 2. At any rate, the story arcs are completely separate - Witches of Dubious Origin is about how Zoe received her family grimoire and discovers her magical heritage; it forms a background to this story, but this is a completely new arc. Except for, I suppose, the budding romance between Zoe and the very handsome containment specialist, Jasper Griffin which kinda sparked a little then and is building up now.

Zoe is determined and resourceful, the romance and banter is sparkling and witty, Jasper is *rolls eyes* stereotypically British, making for a very fun read. Though, tbh, I spent more than enough time sniggering because every time they mentioned BODO, I felt like they were calling the entire department stupid ["bodoh" means stupid in Malay].

The conclusion is an obvious set up for more books in the series, but as far as the main plot goes, this one finishes very satisfactorily.

Note: I received a digital ARC of this book from Berkley via NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Profile Image for Mikala.
529 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 8, 2026
Witches of Questionable Intent is the second book in Jenn McKinlay's Books of Dubious Origin series. It brings back Zoe Ziakas, the librarian turned witch, and the BODO team at the Museum of Literature as they try to track down the stolen Book of Shadows. It was a pretty cute read. There are midnight markets, demons, a slow-burn crush on Jasper, and a found family that clearly works for a lot of readers. Still, nothing here defies the genre. Zoe is another clumsy witch who turns out to be powerful when it counts. Aren't they all? I finished the book and was already struggling to remember it or keep it separate from the other books like it.

Diego the hellhound is easily the best character. He brings the most life and humor to every scene he's in. I did find his change from a fluffy, romping puppy into a tired, too-cool-for-school teenager a bit jarring, though. The time travel felt unnecessary and overdone for a story like this. I understand that readers love a happy ending where the witch gets to have her cake and eat it too, or in this case, her mother. For me it felt like an easy way to tie things up instead of something the story had earned.

My biggest wish is that this book had more of its own identity. If I fed The Book of Doors, Neil Gaiman's Neverwhere, and The Book of Lost Hours into an AI, I think it would spit out this series or something very close to it. Fans of cozy fantasy and magical libraries who loved the first book will probably enjoy this one. If you want something that stands out from the pack, though, this isn't it.

Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley/Ace for the advance copy. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for S Mille.
172 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 6, 2026
A librarian who’s a witch, tracking down magical books? What’s not to love?

Zoe is one of five librarians of the Museum of Literature who use their magic to safeguard a collection of enchanted books called the Books of Dubious Origin. Jasper Griffin, her sort of boyfriend (as in they met, then he was sent off on a case before they got beyond a couple of dates) has just returned from a two month mission with a recovered book, The Book of Shadows. It’s safely locked in the library vault, but later during the Booklover’s Gala (the biggest fundraiser event for the library) someone steals it, although not before casting a wild spell on the guests. Now the team has to figure out who stole the book and get it back before they unleash it’s power.

Even though this is the second book in the series and not quiet a standalone, I adored it. A little romance, a little mystery, a little magic - and a lot of fun. Zoe’s a newbie witch, so she hast have people and things explained to her which works well to explain it to the reader as well. My only complaint is that there wasn’t enough detail about what happened to Zoe’s parents; a minor complaint as I’ve already added the first book to my TBR pile.

Recommended - I received a copy of this from NetGalley.com that I voluntarily chose to review.
Profile Image for Lynn L.
959 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
November 5, 2026
While Zoe Ziakis has been working at the Museum of Literature in New York that houses magical volumes called Books of Dubious Origin, she has also been learning how to wield her own new found magical abilities. Zoe is behind others of her kind and has had to double up working hard to learn to use her family grimoire. One of her colleagues, Jasper Griffin, whom she has a beginning relationship with, has returned from a secret mission to acquire The Book of Shadows. The book is extremely powerful and dangerous because the one controlling it could potentially control the world.

Not long after Jasper returns, and during a ball at the library, the book is stolen by a known enemy. Zoe, Jasper, and the library team do all they can to track down the missing book including going to the midnight market where all manner of supernatural beings trade and shop. Zoe ends up coming home with a puppy who can transform into her much needed guardian.

Zoe and crew have a monumental task ahead chasing the thief who always seems to be one step of ahead them using the book to change reality so that confusion reigns. It seems that even if they can accomplish this task, new information related to the book will keep them searching even after its return. This is the second book in the Books of Dubious Origins series; however, it can be read as a standalone.
Profile Image for bella.
604 reviews29 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 9, 2026
I really enjoyed the first book in this series, Witches of Dubious Origins, and I was so excited to pick up the second one a little earlier thanks to the publisher. This second book absolutely didn't disappoint. In a week where everything could go wrong in my life, this book provided a much needed get away from adulting, and did what I always expect from Jenn McKinlay.... delight me with every page!!

Our favourite witches are back at the Books of Dubious Origin and this time the Book of Shadows has been stolen right under their noses. New witch and librarian Zoe is going to need all the help she can to get it back! Maybe even risking her life in the process!!!

I'm a big of Jenn McKinlay's cozy mysteries and I was so sad when she finished writing them, but little did I know she would give me something even better... a cozy fantasy series!!! I love this series. She's wrapped all the warmth of small town charm in her cozies, into this fantastical world and I just love it. While Zoe is a new witch, she is certainly coming into her powers with strength, and this time she has a four legged friend helping her!!! I loooove her new companion and I can't wait to see how he "helps" in the next book.

This series is cozy fantasy perfection, and if you like cozy and fantasy it should be on your Fall reading list.
Profile Image for Erica Binges Books.
844 reviews59 followers
November 16, 2026
4 stars. Witches of Questionable Intent brings us back with Zoe and the BODO gang and I coudn't be more excited to be back in this world. You definitely have to read book 1, because although book 2 (this one) has it's own sort of mystery/ adventure, it becomes clear that there's an overarching plot that's going to develop across several books. Basically, Zoe is new to the whole witchcraft thing. She's a brilliant librarian who used to eschew everything witchy. But after her mother died and a magical grimoire that only opens for her appeared, her entire world was thrust upside down. She's now working with the gang who deal with books of dubious origin, and the found family vibes are strong! The BODO gang are helping Zoe get a hold of her powers, while also dealing with all sorts of craziness that only a library full of magical books can create. Book 2 picks up right where Book 1 left off, include with Zoe and Jasper's burgeoning romance. We learn a bit more about Jasper in this one, including meeting his father (yikess!). If you like cozy books about books with a sweet romance, paranormal elements, and tons of action, then this series if for you! Thank you so much to Berkley Romance (partner) and netgalley for the ARC and physical copy in exchange for my honest review!
293 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
July 10, 2026
– I’ve been enjoying this series by McKinlay which comes across as a cozy fantasy/mystery book. I think one of the reasons that I like this series is because it is about books, librarians and magic. What a great combination, especially from a librarian’s point of view. McKinley has written up strong characters that have grown over the two books in the series so far. I find the plot and the twist move the book at a great pace. I do find that you need to read the first book to really enjoy the second book in the series. Zoe is training to be a librarian for the Museum of Literature, which holds magical books that can be dangerous to the outside world. The librarian’s job is to find these dangerous and magical tomes and safekeep them in the museum. Well, one such book “The Book of Shadows” has been found by Jasper and brought back to the museum. While they are at a Ball, a mage has stolen “The Books of Shadows” and is causing havoc for the Zoe and her crew. Well worth reading if you enjoy a cozy fantasy or mystery. Thank you to Edelweiss and Ace for an advanced readers copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Soulfire.
546 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 28, 2026
Finished reading Witches of Questionable Intent by Jenn McKinlay book two in the Books of Dubious Origin series. I received this from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review, the book doesn't hit shelves until November 10th, 2026.
I've greatly enjoyed McKinlay's cozy mystery series in the past so I was excited to read the first book in this series. I thought it had potential and I was beyond excited when I was approved for this eArc. Unfortunately, this book was not for me. I wanted to like it but the romance and relationships between the characters annoyed me, they were superficial and didn't seem "real". One person is her mentor and is just constantly hard on her and that's all she is. Two others are older men that are sweet, that's it. Then her romantic interest is the worst. He's British and protective of her and even though you learn more about his past it's only ever revealed to further the plot. I could not get invested in any of the characters, even the lead. The world was interesting and what I enjoyed the most, but sadly it didn't save the book for me. I hate to say it, but I won't be continuing the series.
Profile Image for Bee.
287 reviews17 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 1, 2026
In this second book, Witches of Questionable Intent by Jenn McKinlay, part of the Books of Dubious Origins (BODO) series, the stakes are higher as our favorite librarian witch, Zoe, faces new challenges in the magical community she's come to embrace. I love how our FMC, Zoe, grows in confidence as she learns to use her magic while unlocking the secrets of her grimoire. She’s headstrong and intelligent, and doesn't back down from the challenges ahead. I love how we are getting to know more of the BODO characters, along with the introduction of new creatures and characters. Not all is as it first seems, and I like that the story keeps the reader guessing while the plot moves along. I always find myself cheering Zoe on while also reminding myself to slow down so I don’t miss important moments in my excitement to keep reading.

Thank you to NetGalley, author Jenn McKinlay, and the team at Berkley Publishing Group for letting me dive into a JM book once again. The mix of mystery, fantasy, and romance speaks to my curious soul.

Must-read book one: Witches of Dubious Origin, before diving into book two!
Profile Image for Jessica Bellemore.
306 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 25, 2026
The witchy sequel we all wanted is here and better than ever.

Zoe Ziakis finally feels like she’s acclimating to her role working with Books of Dubious Origin (BODO) at the Museum of Literature…until the Book of Shadows is stolen from right under her and her coworkers' noses. Now it’s up to them to find the book before it’s used for the wrong purposes.

The BODO is so deliciously described that I could almost see the spa-like room that reveals itself to Zoe after a tough encounter, and hear the crackling office fires.

The further building of the magical world is bar-none, not unexpected from the exceptionally talented Jenn McKinlay, and I refuse to spoil anything other than saying one of my favourite additions: Diego.

The story sets up readers for wanting further adventure with the BODO crew, and I for one can’t wait to get my little hands on book 3 in the hopefully near future.

Thank you to Berkley Publishing Group I Ace and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book for free in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Ann Schwarz.
Author 4 books8 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 26, 2026
Zoe Ziakis and the BODO team are back in this second installment of the Books of Dubious Origins series. This time, Zoe and her colleagues must find a book that was stolen from the library before the thief can use it and alter reality for everyone. I truly enjoyed seeing Zoe grow in her powers and skills as a witch. She's finally begun to fully embrace who she is in this book. We also get to explore more of the magical world, and on one such adventure, Zoe acquires a familiar. A loyal and protective hellhound that can masquerade as a wiggly, adorable puppy. Diego is a great addition to the team. I also enjoyed learning more about Jasper and more about Zoe's grimoire. The low-level spice in the developing romance between Zoe and Jasper added additional fun to a cute, paranormal cozy mystery. Happily, I think there are more adventures to come for Zoe, Diego, and her fellow librarians and I cannot wait!

Thank you to both NetGalley and Berkley Publishing for allowing me to read this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for April.
3,379 reviews14 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 10, 2026
Witches of Questionable Intent is aptly named as Zoe and the crew of the BODO comes up against witches and other life forms that have very questionable intentions.
A new Grimoire is the focus of the book. It leads them to a magical market, into the clutches of the local coven and to an abandoned gilded age theater.
Zoe is so well written that she feels real to me. I love watching her develop in these two books.
Jasper has secrets that are partially revealed. Olive might be less intimidating than she first appeared…what? I said might. Tariq and Miles bring the comfort to BODO.
I love the baby book dragons and wish their debut took up a little more of the book. But I guess we had to move on to facing the big bad.
Jenn McKinlay is coming into her own with the addition of cozy fantasy to her repertoire.
I really enjoyed reading Witches of Questionable Intent and can’t wait to find out what comes next.
Thanks to Netgalley and Berkley Publishing Group for access to a pre-release copy of the book.
Profile Image for Sara.
303 reviews32 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 1, 2026
Thank you, Netgalley, for allowing me to read the second instalment in the Books of Dubious Origin.

Zoe Ziakas is back and this time it is absolutely action packed! There isn't a moment of calm. The poor girl is just trying to learn her magic and the emotions of her grimoire. But seriously, I couldn't put the book down. And I love our newest Hellhound addition to the crew!

Zoe has been training her skills with the help of Agnes and the crew. Her beau, Jasper Griffin, returned from a secret trip where he obtained a powerful book, the Book of Shadows. But they weren't the only ones looking for this book. One night the museum was ransacked and the book was stolen from their vault.

Facing a rogue demon and a high ranking witch with ill intentions, the BODO crew set off to recover the book. When the most powerful spell is unleashed within the book, they must determine what is real and what is fake before it's too late.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 59 reviews