The definitive account of how a discarded strand of hair found in Thomas Jefferson’s Bible led to a sweeping, multi-year genomic investigation, drawing on technological advances in DNA to finally resolve a 200-year national controversy.
“Written with the gravitas of history and the pace of a thriller, Richard Kurin’s landmark account is vital and compelling.”—Jon Meacham, Pulitzer Prize–winning author of Thomas The Art of Power
In 2011, staff at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History discovered what appeared to be a hair—light red, possibly human—pressed between the pages of the Thomas Jefferson Bible. That hair sparked an unprecedented scientific determining if modern genomics could recover Jefferson’s DNA and finally resolve the most divisive and enduring question surrounding his life—the paternity of the children of Sally Hemings, one of hundreds of African Americans enslaved by Thomas Jefferson.
For over two centuries, the Jefferson–Hemings controversy has shaped American debates about race, power, slavery, and the mythology of the Founding Fathers. Historians have argued fiercely. Descendants have lived with uncertainty. DNA technology in the 1990s brought us closer, but not all the way; the evidence remained incomplete. Until now. In this riveting narrative—part scientific detective story, part historical epic—Richard Kurin, distinguished scholar and museum official, leads readers through the fifteen-year-long genomic investigation conducted with leading DNA scientists, archaeologists, genealogists, forensic experts, and Jefferson and Hemings’ descendants across the country.
The result is the first conclusive, scientifically validated answer to a question that has reverberated since the eighteenth century—an answer that settles the historical record, deepens our understanding of Jefferson, honors generations of family oral history, and asks America to confront the full complexity of its origins.
This book, which surprised many of us in the History community upon its release, will be exceedingly important for Sally Hemings’s descendants and for the historical community. The extensive process of DNA sequencing and cross testing was convincing to me and just further proved that Sally Hemings was forced to have children with Thomas Jefferson, one of our most well-known and consequential founders. I am glad that Sally Hemings’s descendants now have irrefutable biological proof of their ancestral connection to Thomas Jefferson. Although, the question must be asked: why did this book or scientific study need to exist? Sally Hemings’s own children attested to the fact that Thomas Jefferson was their father on census forms, in oral history interviews in the 1800s, and in stories passed down to their descendants, as meticulously documented in Annette Gordon-Reed’s thorough first book on this subject. That proof should have been enough for the Monticello Association and the nay-sayers in History to believe the truth of what Thomas Jefferson did to Sally Hemings.
This book does not provide another perspective or even a definitive take on what the relationship between Jefferson and Hemings was like. Instead, it documents the twists and turns of the scientific study of Thomas Jefferson’s DNA. The choice not to more thoroughly explore the dynamics of the relationship, particularly using new scholarship by Emily Owens, was a bit disappointing to me. But, perhaps the author aimed to seem uninvested in those debates.
The research on DNA sequencing, particularly of Thomas Jefferson’s hair and the saliva of his descendants, seems to be of great importance scientifically. There are many ethical questions that may be asked about the study itself. Should Hemings’s descendants’ DNA be such a large parts of public debates over slavery? How ethical is it to degrade archival materials just to answer a question of one family’s lineage? How will these technologies be used in the future?
Overall, I would say this book is written well and it was very interesting to be taken behind the scenes on such a monumental discovery. However, I would say that this book will not include an ethical scaffolding on how to approach questions of consent during slavery or seriously tackle the implications of this study for Jefferson’s descendants through his wife, many of whom have discounted the Hemings Jefferson descendants
Most in the genealogical community are familiar with the 200-year-old question: Was Thomas Jefferson the father of Sally Hemings’s children? Sally Hemings was enslaved at Jefferson’s Monticello. She was 30 years younger than Jefferson and the half-sister of Jefferson’s first wife. Their relationship existed within the profoundly unequal circumstances of slavery. This month, a new book was published that is touted as the definitive account of a multiyear research project at the Smithsonian to attempt to answer the question of Jefferson’s paternity in relation to Sally Hemings’s children. It all started years ago when an effort was undertaken to restore the Jefferson Bible, a book of Jefferson’s own making that compared Bible texts in multiple languages side by side. It was a true cut-and-paste job. During the restoration effort, several hairs were found that were theorized to be those of its maker. The researchers and scientists at the Smithsonian began to wonder: Could DNA be recovered from those hairs and compared with DNA from descendants of Jefferson and Sally Hemings? Easier said than done. It took years of genetic research, coupled with the work of genealogists, to identify the relationships that could be proven. If you have an interest in DNA, genetic genealogy, or American history, you may want to consider this book, written by the man who headed the project, Richard Kurin. I listened to the audiobook and was completely engrossed—not only in the science, but also in the politics and human emotion tied up in a single case of paternity that could change the discussion of this Founding Father forever.
Incredibly important piece of work, that perhaps only a place like the Smithsonian could have managed. In addition, the research begun by the Smithsonian for a question of history is now being used to assist in cold crime cases -- a demonstration of the basic question 'what if'.
I certainly didn't understand all the details and nuances of the scientific trials and tests, but the results are a wonderful conformation of the importance of oral history and tradition.
Superbly written and researched. It is both a historical record and one of discovery. I enjoyed every chapter. For those of us who followed the documentary record for many years, especially through the excellent work of Annette Gordon-Reed, we already knew what the truth was. This book is confirmation of it.
Always fascinated by Jefferson and the Sally Hemings story, I picked up this newest book on the scientific research done on their connection. Kurin, who works for the Smithsonian, details how a pasted-in reddish hair found in Jefferson's personal cut-and-pasted "Bible" got him wondering if DNA could be extracted from it. If it could, it might be compared to the DNA of modern descendants of Sally Hemings, to see if portions matched and pointed to biological relationship. DNA techniques from earlier years had already demonstrated that the descendants were products of *a* Jefferson, but new techniques might narrow it down to *the* Jefferson. Until recently, usable DNA could not be extracted from hair that had no follicle attached, but the latest methods have opened new doors, along with plenty of detective work from Kurin and a vast team. The book is pretty technical in places, but I learned new things about the families. I wonder if, by uploading what has been pieced together of Jefferson's genome, and by continuing to reverse-engineer Sally Hemings', we might one day find the long-lost offspring of Beverly and Harriet Hemings and get answers about their parentage and fate as well!
If you’re in the scientific community or the descendants this might be interesting JDG was curious about it. And as we were taking a jaunt to Monticello we decided to listen to For us…tedious and repetitive beyond description
The first I was aware of the Hemmings issue was mid ‘70s in a biography of TJ
Science confirms what oral history has passed down for centuries in this thorough examination of the journey to find and map out Thomas Jefferson's DNA and compare it to the descendants of his daughters of his wife and of the sons of his enslaved mistress, Sally Hemings. I've long had an interest in the subject and was eager to dive into this one.
Kurin does an excellent job explaining the history of the Jefferson-Hemings connection and charting the handling of that connection by the families involved. While the scientific aspects went way over my head, it was still exciting to read how things slowly came together over time and what the team learned. I was particularly interested in the genealogical and archaeological explorations made in furtherance of the project.
The author doesn't comment on the actual relationship between Hemings and Jefferson itself, doesn't try to label it as coercion/rape or a romance, though he does acknowledge the power dynamics inherent in the situation, which I like. We can speculate all we like, but that is for historical fiction. It wouldn't have a place in a more scientific study.
Overall, a great read! I will be very interested to see what happens from here.
Who would have thought that a discarded hair in Thomas Jefferson’s bible would turn into a scientific journey to answer a 200+ year old mystery - did Thomas Jefferson father the children of his slave, Sally Hemings?
Genetic genealogy has always captured my attention when it’s used to solve true crime cases, so I was intrigued to see how, with modern technology, they could use it on samples that were so old. This book goes into a lot of detail about the multi-year research study they conducted to get to the bottom of the mystery and all the twists and turns along the way. It was quite technical at times but overall kept me engaged.
While it sticks to a very scientific lense, it gives the audience much to consider in terms of the ethical implications of the relationship between Sally and Jefferson. This confirmation of oral history passed down by generations will also likely alter how many view Jefferson and his legacy.
Great book! I was glad to finally have unrefutable proof after all this time.
There is no way for us to know exactly what kind of relationship Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemmings had, other than she was enslaved by him and he was 30 years older than her. That their "relationship" and I use that term loosely, was a consensual one is difficult for me to believe, since it supposedly started when she was 14! She was a child and couldn't give consent. She couldn't say no to him. Did it evolve into something meaningful later on? We will never know that.
This was a wonderful, impeccably scholarly book delving into the 200-year-old mystery swirling around the enslaved Sally Hemings, and the paternity of her children, alleged for nearly the entire 200 years to be Thomas Jefferson. Richard Kurin spearheaded teams from the Smithsonian and other institutions to get the answers that have so long evaded researchers. He used modern, advanced DNA techniques to provide the final answer.
As a genealogist and fertility nurse, I was familiar with and able to understand this wonderful book more easily than most. After reading Annette Gordon Reed's books I was so glad to see the story proven scientifically. I remember 2 visits to Monticello 20 years apart. The 1st when docents were almost insulted by my question and the last when a UVA history professor said most assuredly it was true. Thank you for the proof.
In 2011, the author had the inspiration that DNA from Thomas Jefferson might be used to determine the parentage of Sally Hemings' children. Speculation in this area dated from Jefferson's time: visitors noticed enslaved Blacks with red hair, an unusual characteristic. The project took over a decade and required advances in DNA techniques. Probably only an institution like the Smithsonian could undertake such a challenging project.
This project opens up to the sunlight the very essence of America’s history and tells the wonderful story of the Jefferson-Hemings ‘family’. We are so fortunate to have the expertise and scholarship of the Smithsonian spearheading this search for the ‘Truth”.
5 stars, and I dont hand them out thay easily. This was fascinating. It touched on so many topics I love learning about: American history, culture and mythology, and genomics, and genealogy. Really compelling read.
Quite good and complete without getting too lost in the weeds. A compelling blend of history and forensics and how technology can alter our understanding and answer long-held questions. It was also entertaining!
A work of historical importance that finally lays to rest once and for all the 200-year old mystery of whether Thomas Jefferson fathered the children of his slave Sally Hemings.