What do you think?
Rate this book
Silk and Sensibility
Not yet published
Expected 15 Sep 26Two sisters with conflicting attitudes on passion and restraint must each choose between the traditions that bind their hearts and pursuing the love that could save them.
Sense and Sensibility meets Ming-dynasty China in this sweeping romantic retelling of love, duty, and sisterhood.
Nineteen-year-old Ailin is torn between duty and desire. Following her father’s death, her family must rely on the wealthy Jiang clan for financial survival. Though Ailin knows she must marry strategically to help her family, her heart has already been captured by the poor but gentle scholar Enze. When his family opposes their union, Ailin knows she must hide her feelings from everyone until she can strengthen her dowry and stand on her own terms.
Meilin encourages her older sister to fight for her personal desires, but Meilin’s romantic ideals conflict with Ailin’s devotion to duty. Meilin believes in being honest about one’s feelings regardless of what others may think, and she unabashedly pursues a charming playwright while also clashing with a frustratingly handsome but gruff army captain.
The sisters would do anything to help the other find happiness, but their assumptions about restraint and passion are as different as earth and sky. Ailin feels honor bound to her family yet is unable to deny her love for Enze, even as circumstances push them further apart, while Meilin grapples with unexpected feelings for Captain Bai and societal restrictions that leave little room for her own hopes.
Silk and Sensibility explores the delicate cultural expectations of womanhood in historical China by following two sisters who must learn to balance loyalty and longing, courage and constraint, to claim their own happiness.
Sense and Sensibility meets Ming-dynasty China in this sweeping romantic retelling of love, duty, and sisterhood.
Nineteen-year-old Ailin is torn between duty and desire. Following her father’s death, her family must rely on the wealthy Jiang clan for financial survival. Though Ailin knows she must marry strategically to help her family, her heart has already been captured by the poor but gentle scholar Enze. When his family opposes their union, Ailin knows she must hide her feelings from everyone until she can strengthen her dowry and stand on her own terms.
Meilin encourages her older sister to fight for her personal desires, but Meilin’s romantic ideals conflict with Ailin’s devotion to duty. Meilin believes in being honest about one’s feelings regardless of what others may think, and she unabashedly pursues a charming playwright while also clashing with a frustratingly handsome but gruff army captain.
The sisters would do anything to help the other find happiness, but their assumptions about restraint and passion are as different as earth and sky. Ailin feels honor bound to her family yet is unable to deny her love for Enze, even as circumstances push them further apart, while Meilin grapples with unexpected feelings for Captain Bai and societal restrictions that leave little room for her own hopes.
Silk and Sensibility explores the delicate cultural expectations of womanhood in historical China by following two sisters who must learn to balance loyalty and longing, courage and constraint, to claim their own happiness.
368 pages, Hardcover
Expected publication September 15, 2026
About the author
Mengxi Seeley
1 book13 followersMengxi Seeley is a 1.5 generation immigrant born in China and raised in Utah. She has an MA in East Asian Studies from Stanford University and a BA in international relations from Brigham Young University. After working for many years as an academic translator, she now writes novels inspired by historical research, but with fantastically happy endings. Her debut novel, Silk and Sensibility, will be published in September 2026 by Shadow Mountain.
Mengxi actively participates in the Storymakers Conference, where she has taught as faculty and led the "Diversity Ink" group. When not writing, she enjoys reading, gardening, running, and over-analyzing movies with her family. She lives in Virginia with two little princesses and an absent-minded professor.
Mengxi actively participates in the Storymakers Conference, where she has taught as faculty and led the "Diversity Ink" group. When not writing, she enjoys reading, gardening, running, and over-analyzing movies with her family. She lives in Virginia with two little princesses and an absent-minded professor.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I like to thank the publisher and NetGalley for allowing me a read of this book.
I love CDramas. I love Austen. I love no-spice romance. So having all three of these key points in this book was absolutely perfect. Sense and Sensibility is my second favorite book of hers.
I loved the era it was set in. I love the work that the author did in adapting the Ming dynasty. The clothing and the binding of the feet were two things that I noticed instantly. Having Ailin being the one who bound her feet made sense, I could not see Meilin being the one who did. She was too free-spirted, opinionated for decorum and rules.
I loved the changes that the author did to the stories that they still came to the same plot beats. Again, all fit within the time period and the CDrama style of expression.
I have to say that I marked the book down a star for the Willoughby / Wei character. He just kind of existed and didn't really bond that well with Meilin and was fleeting. I wanted him to be a bit more present in the story, but I guess that was the point of the character of Meilin, she fell too quickly and without really knowing the man. Yet, I just didn't get a good attachment from them.
All in all, if you're a CDrama fan, Austen fan looking for a new interpretation, this is a solid debut and one you should give a read.
I love CDramas. I love Austen. I love no-spice romance. So having all three of these key points in this book was absolutely perfect. Sense and Sensibility is my second favorite book of hers.
I loved the era it was set in. I love the work that the author did in adapting the Ming dynasty. The clothing and the binding of the feet were two things that I noticed instantly. Having Ailin being the one who bound her feet made sense, I could not see Meilin being the one who did. She was too free-spirted, opinionated for decorum and rules.
I loved the changes that the author did to the stories that they still came to the same plot beats. Again, all fit within the time period and the CDrama style of expression.
I have to say that I marked the book down a star for the Willoughby / Wei character. He just kind of existed and didn't really bond that well with Meilin and was fleeting. I wanted him to be a bit more present in the story, but I guess that was the point of the character of Meilin, she fell too quickly and without really knowing the man. Yet, I just didn't get a good attachment from them.
All in all, if you're a CDrama fan, Austen fan looking for a new interpretation, this is a solid debut and one you should give a read.
Want to Read
April 8, 2026"A charming retelling of Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility set in Ming-dynasty China."
That's all I needed to know.
April 19, 2026
Wonderfully romantic!
This was an ARC.
This was an ARC.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you Netgalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for the advanced reader’s copy! I’m a big sucker for retellings of classic books, and as soon as I saw that my request had been accepted, I couldn’t have been more thrilled!
Silk and Sensibility is a Chinese retelling of Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility. We start off very similarly in both novels, with our two FMCs, Ailin (aka Elinor) and Meilin (aka Marianne), falling upon hard times when their father dies and their inheritance is largely taken from them by their greedy step-family. Ailin, being the eldest, feels the pressure the most to provide for her sisters and mother. In going out to seek her uncle's help, Ailin runs into their step-mother's brother Fan Enze (aka Edward) and they begin a cautious yet sincere courtship. When his sister, however, makes certain untoward claims about the nature of their relationship, Ailin's mother is forced to make the decision to leave their home and move in with their uncle's family in Suzhou. From there, we are introduced to the chaotic Jiang family, the charming aspiring playwright Wei, and the gruff military Captain Bai.
I have to say, my favourite part of the book is how smoothly Mengxi Seeley took the social, cultural, and historical differences between 18th century England and Ming Dynasty China and made them work so well for this new adaptation. Fan Enze's career as a studious scholar preparing for the state exam seems like the natural choice for the reserved and intelligent Edward Ferrars; Master Wei's predisposition for the romanticism of the stage and playwriting fitting in with his alluring and untrustworthy counterpart Mr. Willoughby; and, perhaps most genius of all, having Captain Bai train his soldiers in fighting pirates (a well known issue during the Ming Dynasty) where Colonel Brandon fought in the East Indies. Every choice in the story is well thought out and intentional. Instead of the piano, Meilin is very talented with the zither and teaches Bai’s daughter. Ailin not only takes an active role in the management of their family and home but also contributes through selling her paintings. The concept of her being a talented but unsure artist who uses her skills to get her family out of difficult situations, both financially and socially, gave her so much more agency and really solidified her in my mind as a well-developed and interesting character. Enze's unsent letters too at the beginning of every chapter gave us a better look into his character which might’ve otherwise been one-dimensional.
I think the one small disappointment I found in the book was over the fact that Meilin already knew about what Ailin was going through in being away from Enze and having to watch him being matched with Shen Lusi. It diminished the emotional impact from the of novel when Marianne realized how selfish she had been to make others worry about her when her own sister suffered in silence. I also find that some parts of the book have very on-the-nose writing, making it harder to feel properly involved in the story.
Other than this, however, I really did enjoy Silk and Sensibility. The themes of family and especially of sisterhood, of loss and grief, and of the importance of the delicate balance between the emotional and rational were discussed in a way that clearly shows Seeley’s love for Jane Austen and respect for the original work. Thank you again Netgalley for the arc!
Silk and Sensibility is a Chinese retelling of Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility. We start off very similarly in both novels, with our two FMCs, Ailin (aka Elinor) and Meilin (aka Marianne), falling upon hard times when their father dies and their inheritance is largely taken from them by their greedy step-family. Ailin, being the eldest, feels the pressure the most to provide for her sisters and mother. In going out to seek her uncle's help, Ailin runs into their step-mother's brother Fan Enze (aka Edward) and they begin a cautious yet sincere courtship. When his sister, however, makes certain untoward claims about the nature of their relationship, Ailin's mother is forced to make the decision to leave their home and move in with their uncle's family in Suzhou. From there, we are introduced to the chaotic Jiang family, the charming aspiring playwright Wei, and the gruff military Captain Bai.
I have to say, my favourite part of the book is how smoothly Mengxi Seeley took the social, cultural, and historical differences between 18th century England and Ming Dynasty China and made them work so well for this new adaptation. Fan Enze's career as a studious scholar preparing for the state exam seems like the natural choice for the reserved and intelligent Edward Ferrars; Master Wei's predisposition for the romanticism of the stage and playwriting fitting in with his alluring and untrustworthy counterpart Mr. Willoughby; and, perhaps most genius of all, having Captain Bai train his soldiers in fighting pirates (a well known issue during the Ming Dynasty) where Colonel Brandon fought in the East Indies. Every choice in the story is well thought out and intentional. Instead of the piano, Meilin is very talented with the zither and teaches Bai’s daughter. Ailin not only takes an active role in the management of their family and home but also contributes through selling her paintings. The concept of her being a talented but unsure artist who uses her skills to get her family out of difficult situations, both financially and socially, gave her so much more agency and really solidified her in my mind as a well-developed and interesting character. Enze's unsent letters too at the beginning of every chapter gave us a better look into his character which might’ve otherwise been one-dimensional.
I think the one small disappointment I found in the book was over the fact that Meilin already knew about what Ailin was going through in being away from Enze and having to watch him being matched with Shen Lusi. It diminished the emotional impact from the of novel when Marianne realized how selfish she had been to make others worry about her when her own sister suffered in silence. I also find that some parts of the book have very on-the-nose writing, making it harder to feel properly involved in the story.
Other than this, however, I really did enjoy Silk and Sensibility. The themes of family and especially of sisterhood, of loss and grief, and of the importance of the delicate balance between the emotional and rational were discussed in a way that clearly shows Seeley’s love for Jane Austen and respect for the original work. Thank you again Netgalley for the arc!
June 15, 2026
Silk and Sensibility is a Chinese retelling of Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility, set during the Ming dynasty, and it offers a fresh cultural reimagining of a familiar classic. I went in a little uncertain, especially since I haven’t read Austen’s original, but the novel stands firmly on its own. While the opening chapters felt slightly slow for me, the story soon found its rhythm and became an engaging, often charming reading experience that kept me invested until the end.
The novel follows two sisters, Ailin and Meilin, whose personalities mirror the emotional and rational balance at the heart of Austen’s work. Ailin, the eldest, is thoughtful, responsible, and quietly determined, especially as she navigates financial hardship and her growing feelings for Enze. Meilin, by contrast, is more impulsive, sheltered, and emotionally expressive, leading to a more complicated romantic path involving multiple suitors. Alongside them is their younger sister Mingming, whose youthful energy adds warmth to the family dynamic. The relationships between the sisters form the emotional core of the story, highlighting themes of loyalty, responsibility, and emotional growth.
One of the novel’s strongest elements is how seamlessly it translates Austen’s characters and plot structure into a historical Chinese setting. From scholarly examination culture and artistic traditions like zither music and painting, to references such as piracy and military service shaping character equivalents, the adaptation feels intentional and well-researched. These cultural and historical details enrich the story without overwhelming it, making the world feel vivid and immersive.
I especially appreciated how the author gave the characters more agency within this setting. Ailin’s role in supporting her family through both emotional labor and artistic contribution made her feel grounded and capable, while Enze’s perspective, occasionally revealed through letters, added depth to his character. The romance arcs—ranging from restrained and slow-burning to more chaotic and emotionally complex—also gave the story a tone reminiscent of a historical Chinese drama, which made it especially enjoyable to follow.
That said, there were moments where the emotional impact felt slightly softened by narrative choices, and at times the writing could be a bit on-the-nose, making certain developments feel less subtle than they might have been. Still, these issues did not significantly diminish the overall reading experience.
Ultimately, Silk and Sensibility is a warm, accessible, and culturally rich retelling that balances romance, family dynamics, and personal growth. It captures the spirit of Austen’s original while reimagining it through a distinct historical lens. Fans of Chinese dramas, historical romance, or Austen adaptations will likely find it a rewarding read.
The novel follows two sisters, Ailin and Meilin, whose personalities mirror the emotional and rational balance at the heart of Austen’s work. Ailin, the eldest, is thoughtful, responsible, and quietly determined, especially as she navigates financial hardship and her growing feelings for Enze. Meilin, by contrast, is more impulsive, sheltered, and emotionally expressive, leading to a more complicated romantic path involving multiple suitors. Alongside them is their younger sister Mingming, whose youthful energy adds warmth to the family dynamic. The relationships between the sisters form the emotional core of the story, highlighting themes of loyalty, responsibility, and emotional growth.
One of the novel’s strongest elements is how seamlessly it translates Austen’s characters and plot structure into a historical Chinese setting. From scholarly examination culture and artistic traditions like zither music and painting, to references such as piracy and military service shaping character equivalents, the adaptation feels intentional and well-researched. These cultural and historical details enrich the story without overwhelming it, making the world feel vivid and immersive.
I especially appreciated how the author gave the characters more agency within this setting. Ailin’s role in supporting her family through both emotional labor and artistic contribution made her feel grounded and capable, while Enze’s perspective, occasionally revealed through letters, added depth to his character. The romance arcs—ranging from restrained and slow-burning to more chaotic and emotionally complex—also gave the story a tone reminiscent of a historical Chinese drama, which made it especially enjoyable to follow.
That said, there were moments where the emotional impact felt slightly softened by narrative choices, and at times the writing could be a bit on-the-nose, making certain developments feel less subtle than they might have been. Still, these issues did not significantly diminish the overall reading experience.
Ultimately, Silk and Sensibility is a warm, accessible, and culturally rich retelling that balances romance, family dynamics, and personal growth. It captures the spirit of Austen’s original while reimagining it through a distinct historical lens. Fans of Chinese dramas, historical romance, or Austen adaptations will likely find it a rewarding read.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Ailin and Meilin are two sisters facing the death of their father and the change in circumstances it has brought them. Ailin is dutiful down to her bound feet and Meilin has her head in the clouds. This story is inspired by Austen's Sense and Sensibility. I have read this book and seen a TV adaptation but to be honest, I never remember what happens. So, reading this story was rather new. I am a sucker for all things Ming dynasty so this book was right up my alley though I would prefer if the names used tones. I also thought the text could use more pronouns. Names are repeated a lot.
As far as the characters go, I felt Ailin was the better developed of the sisters. She is the most like me and ended up being my favorite by the end. She stands out from so many FMC written today because while she is reserved she has her own strengths. I also am impressed that the author chose a main character to have bound feet yet not make that the center of who she is. I enjoyed her story so much!
The chapters probably do not need to be named after the character’s point of view as the passages are very much third person and I did not feel each chapter reflected one sister’s view more or less.
The romance was also too instant for what I like, but I did like Enze. I liked that he was shy and unremarkable. This added a real element to the story as most people are average and there are enough Gastons out there. So, while he wasn’t handsome beyond redemption he was a realistic character and someone a person like Ailin would be attracted too. Fan Eze is a wonderful MC. He is not proud or brooding. So, he is a relief. Honestly, it is not that hard to write a gentleman and not a man-child. I also liked that he is not actually engaged, which is something I disliked about Edward. Thank you, Mengxi Seeley.
Meilin. I’m not sure why I struggled to get close to her, but I had the same experience with Marrianne. I did not dislike her though. Her character development was wonderfully written and I was surprised at her bravery. Also, as a writer of a character that plays the guqin, I liked reading about her zither playing. Bai was okay, and he did grow on me by the end of the story. To be honest, I think I only despised one character out of the entire set and that one should be obvious.
All and all, I liked this book and wish for more like this. My favorite scene was probably the sibling row that happens at about the hallway mark. Not because I like fighting, but because it is very well written. I would read this author again.
As far as the characters go, I felt Ailin was the better developed of the sisters. She is the most like me and ended up being my favorite by the end. She stands out from so many FMC written today because while she is reserved she has her own strengths. I also am impressed that the author chose a main character to have bound feet yet not make that the center of who she is. I enjoyed her story so much!
The chapters probably do not need to be named after the character’s point of view as the passages are very much third person and I did not feel each chapter reflected one sister’s view more or less.
The romance was also too instant for what I like, but I did like Enze. I liked that he was shy and unremarkable. This added a real element to the story as most people are average and there are enough Gastons out there. So, while he wasn’t handsome beyond redemption he was a realistic character and someone a person like Ailin would be attracted too. Fan Eze is a wonderful MC. He is not proud or brooding. So, he is a relief. Honestly, it is not that hard to write a gentleman and not a man-child. I also liked that he is not actually engaged, which is something I disliked about Edward. Thank you, Mengxi Seeley.
Meilin. I’m not sure why I struggled to get close to her, but I had the same experience with Marrianne. I did not dislike her though. Her character development was wonderfully written and I was surprised at her bravery. Also, as a writer of a character that plays the guqin, I liked reading about her zither playing. Bai was okay, and he did grow on me by the end of the story. To be honest, I think I only despised one character out of the entire set and that one should be obvious.
All and all, I liked this book and wish for more like this. My favorite scene was probably the sibling row that happens at about the hallway mark. Not because I like fighting, but because it is very well written. I would read this author again.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you so so much to Netgalley and the publisher for an e-arc of Silk and Sensibility. This is an incredibly impressive debut!
Just as a preface, I have not read any of Jane Austen's works, but I am familiar with the broad strokes of her characters. I picked up Silk and Sensibility because it sounded right up my alley and it did not disappoint!
Ailin and Meilin are sisters, but they couldn't be more different. As the eldest daughter, Ailin takes care to act as a dutiful daughter who follows proper societal expectations even though her heart may lead her in a different direction. On the other hand, Meilin is the middle daughter and is relatively free with her heart and her actions because she believes that she should be able to follow her heart regardless of what is dutiful or proper. This causes both sisters to clash when it comes to their respective love lives and marriage prospects. Meilin believes Ailin is too self-less and because of that may lose the love of her life. Ailin believes Meilin isn't careful enough with her heart and doesn't act enough in accordance with what society believes is proper. The novel follows both sisters and the rest of their family as they navigate love, hardship, heartbreak, and everything else in between.
Do not go into this thinking that since you have read Sense and Sensibility that you have read Silk and Sensibility. While the broad plot beats may be present, the societal expectations for women are completely different. Silk and Sensibility discusses foot binding, differences in matriarchal and patriarchal households, and is seeped in 16th century Chinese culture. Seeley makes Austen's broad ideas her own as she adapts the overarching themes of Sense and Sensibility into a completely different culture. Ailin is interested in painting and her accomplishments as a painter are very much at the forefront of the novel. Likewise, Meilin is accomplished with the zither, so music is also at the forefront because she expresses herself musically.
The novel does alternate between Ailin and Meilin's third person POV. Seeley allows the reader to intimately spend time with both sisters. I loved seeing events from both sister's POV because they are both so alike (inwardly), but express those emotions outwardly in a different way. I love how supportive their family is of each of the sisters with whom they choose to marry. (Grandmother Jiang is my absolute favorite. We love a meddling grandmother.)
This was an incredibly romantic read and I encourage you all to read it!
Just as a preface, I have not read any of Jane Austen's works, but I am familiar with the broad strokes of her characters. I picked up Silk and Sensibility because it sounded right up my alley and it did not disappoint!
Ailin and Meilin are sisters, but they couldn't be more different. As the eldest daughter, Ailin takes care to act as a dutiful daughter who follows proper societal expectations even though her heart may lead her in a different direction. On the other hand, Meilin is the middle daughter and is relatively free with her heart and her actions because she believes that she should be able to follow her heart regardless of what is dutiful or proper. This causes both sisters to clash when it comes to their respective love lives and marriage prospects. Meilin believes Ailin is too self-less and because of that may lose the love of her life. Ailin believes Meilin isn't careful enough with her heart and doesn't act enough in accordance with what society believes is proper. The novel follows both sisters and the rest of their family as they navigate love, hardship, heartbreak, and everything else in between.
Do not go into this thinking that since you have read Sense and Sensibility that you have read Silk and Sensibility. While the broad plot beats may be present, the societal expectations for women are completely different. Silk and Sensibility discusses foot binding, differences in matriarchal and patriarchal households, and is seeped in 16th century Chinese culture. Seeley makes Austen's broad ideas her own as she adapts the overarching themes of Sense and Sensibility into a completely different culture. Ailin is interested in painting and her accomplishments as a painter are very much at the forefront of the novel. Likewise, Meilin is accomplished with the zither, so music is also at the forefront because she expresses herself musically.
The novel does alternate between Ailin and Meilin's third person POV. Seeley allows the reader to intimately spend time with both sisters. I loved seeing events from both sister's POV because they are both so alike (inwardly), but express those emotions outwardly in a different way. I love how supportive their family is of each of the sisters with whom they choose to marry. (Grandmother Jiang is my absolute favorite. We love a meddling grandmother.)
This was an incredibly romantic read and I encourage you all to read it!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
3.5/5
Many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing an eARC of this book.
Huge fan of Jane Austen, and I'm always down to read Austen-inspired spin-offs or retellings. Strictly speaking, Sense and Sensibility is not my favorite Austen romance. But like the author mentioned in her notes, I did find Elinor to be a more compelling and relatable character compared to Marianne. So one thing I did appreciate especially was how Silk and Sensibility gave her emotional struggle a stronger presence in the narrative.
But that being said, the central tension between the two sisters in Sense and Sensibility stems from their different personalities and, importantly, miscommunication (particularly on Elinor's side) about the depth of her feeling for Edward Ferrars. Giving Meilin the knowledge of Ailin's heartbreak while also having her oscillating between understanding her sister's grief and accusing her of being unfeeling seems just a bit contradictory. Still, I think the sibling relationship between Meilin and Ailin has its time to shine, and it's all really quite sweet. Silk and Sensibility especially makes Meilin more sympathetic and understanding towards Ailin's struggles, which gave a deeper sense of connection between the sisters. (And let's not forget Mingming, either. She was super cute haha)
The prose sometimes read a little awkwardly. Some phrases in particular sounded a bit too literally translated from Chinese and ended up kind of clunky ("dumb melon" for, presumably, 傻瓜 comes to mind).
I really liked the letters written by Fan Enze in between each chapter, to get more of his perspective—because if there's one thing I could have used way more of in the original novel, it was Edward grovelling for Elinor's forgiveness—and I think, ultimately, this is Silk and Sensibility's most effective addition to the love story. In Austen's S&S, I do feel like Edward gets relegated to the background for most of the book, and his story is told solely through Elinor and Lucy's conflict. I also quite liked the way that this story was interwoven in a historical Chinese context, with the provincial exams being Enze's way of establishing himself/his living. I think it was a really nice spin-off of what happens in S&S.
Overall, a charming story, though I found the prose awkward at times.
Many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing an eARC of this book.
Huge fan of Jane Austen, and I'm always down to read Austen-inspired spin-offs or retellings. Strictly speaking, Sense and Sensibility is not my favorite Austen romance. But like the author mentioned in her notes, I did find Elinor to be a more compelling and relatable character compared to Marianne. So one thing I did appreciate especially was how Silk and Sensibility gave her emotional struggle a stronger presence in the narrative.
But that being said, the central tension between the two sisters in Sense and Sensibility stems from their different personalities and, importantly, miscommunication (particularly on Elinor's side) about the depth of her feeling for Edward Ferrars. Giving Meilin the knowledge of Ailin's heartbreak while also having her oscillating between understanding her sister's grief and accusing her of being unfeeling seems just a bit contradictory. Still, I think the sibling relationship between Meilin and Ailin has its time to shine, and it's all really quite sweet. Silk and Sensibility especially makes Meilin more sympathetic and understanding towards Ailin's struggles, which gave a deeper sense of connection between the sisters. (And let's not forget Mingming, either. She was super cute haha)
The prose sometimes read a little awkwardly. Some phrases in particular sounded a bit too literally translated from Chinese and ended up kind of clunky ("dumb melon" for, presumably, 傻瓜 comes to mind).
I really liked the letters written by Fan Enze in between each chapter, to get more of his perspective—because if there's one thing I could have used way more of in the original novel, it was Edward grovelling for Elinor's forgiveness—and I think, ultimately, this is Silk and Sensibility's most effective addition to the love story. In Austen's S&S, I do feel like Edward gets relegated to the background for most of the book, and his story is told solely through Elinor and Lucy's conflict. I also quite liked the way that this story was interwoven in a historical Chinese context, with the provincial exams being Enze's way of establishing himself/his living. I think it was a really nice spin-off of what happens in S&S.
Overall, a charming story, though I found the prose awkward at times.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
First I'd like to thank the publisher for an arc of this book in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own. I feel like it has been a long time since I read a novel that I loved as much as I did this book. I always have a soft spot for Jane Austen inspired stories but I also have high expectations in that regard because of how much I love her works. I have seen Austen retelling done well and I have seen Austen retellings done poorly. This is without a doubt my absolute favorite. The setting works perfectly for a retelling of Sense and Sensibility while making the story feel fresh, new and interesting, while still having that wonderful coziness of familiarity. The characters of Elinor and Marianne, in this story it's Ailin and Meilin, worked perfectly. I adored them both, even though they both had their frustrating moments. But so did the original sisters and it's all part of their growth as the story progresses. I could relate to parts of both of their personalities, Ailin's more reserved nature and Meilin's romantic nature. And of course we can't forget our male leads! They were both done so wonderfully, they were sweet, gentle, kind, strong and dashing. I loved every time they were on page and interacted with our two female leads! Perfect for anyone looking for a sweet, clean read that will still have you grinning and kicking your heels. I loved every moment of this story and I plan on pre-ordering this the next time I place a book order! I look forward to what else this author had in store! I would honestly read a retelling of all of Austen's works set in this time and location!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This book was so good! Sense and Sensibility in Ming Dynasty China was such a fascinating choice; I loved seeing the story reimagined as taking place before it was written, in a different setting yet with similar constraints and responsibilities. Fan Enze was a perfect reimagining of Edward Ferrars - I'm not sure I've ever come across an adaptation that so completely encapsulates Edward's complicated character as a worthy love interest notwithstanding his glaring shortcomings. The other characters were similarly done well, although this version does miss a little of the jovial sociality that exists with the Middletons and Mrs. Jennings in the original; but, then, the political subplot we get instead is arguably even a better fit to show how different Ailin/Elinor and Meilin/Marianne are from each other and yet still how closely they are tied together. The beginning scene of Ailin and Enze with the umbrella was super powerful, and the strong emotions continued through the epigraphs - so then when he gave the letters to her I was so moved (it felt like a Wentworth moment). I highly recommend this gorgeous historical romance!
Thank you to Shadow Mountain and Netgalley for the ARC; all opinions are my own.
Thank you to Shadow Mountain and Netgalley for the ARC; all opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to Shadow Mountain Publishing and NetGalley for providing this ARC for review!
Silk and Sensibility is a retelling of Jane Austen’s classic, Sense and Sensibility, set in Ming-dynasty China.
I'd like to preface my review by stating that I never read Sense and Sensibility, so I have nothing to offer on how I think it compares with the original.
I loved this book! It's obvious how much care and research went into making the story as historically accurate as possible. Even though I wasn't familiar with the original story going in, I was surprised by how well everything fit together, since I knew that the original setting was very different. Touching on filial piety pressures, feet binding, wokou raids, and other expectations from women of a higher class in Ming dynasty China was fascinating to read about.
The longing between Ailin and Enze was top tier. I loved the unsent letters from Enze that started each chapter. Most of my highlights from the book came from his letters. They're so romantic and poetic. Meilin and her determination to fight for her family was lovely. I had so much fun learning about the zither through her. Her love story was much more lively, which I also highly enjoyed.
Silk and Sensibility is a retelling of Jane Austen’s classic, Sense and Sensibility, set in Ming-dynasty China.
I'd like to preface my review by stating that I never read Sense and Sensibility, so I have nothing to offer on how I think it compares with the original.
I loved this book! It's obvious how much care and research went into making the story as historically accurate as possible. Even though I wasn't familiar with the original story going in, I was surprised by how well everything fit together, since I knew that the original setting was very different. Touching on filial piety pressures, feet binding, wokou raids, and other expectations from women of a higher class in Ming dynasty China was fascinating to read about.
The longing between Ailin and Enze was top tier. I loved the unsent letters from Enze that started each chapter. Most of my highlights from the book came from his letters. They're so romantic and poetic. Meilin and her determination to fight for her family was lovely. I had so much fun learning about the zither through her. Her love story was much more lively, which I also highly enjoyed.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
1550s Ming China, like 1800s England, is a world with strict limits for women so Austen's Sense & Sensibility transfers over well with many of the same issues facing women, particularly all the protocols around their interactions (or permitted lack theirof) with men.
This is a solid retelling with a number of subtle changes from Austen's original due to the different location/time period. It must have been the point of view selected but I felt I was watching players on a stage rather than utterly inhabiting each of the characters (chapters are from either Ailin or Meilin's points of view). Nevertheless, an enjoyable read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This is a solid retelling with a number of subtle changes from Austen's original due to the different location/time period. It must have been the point of view selected but I felt I was watching players on a stage rather than utterly inhabiting each of the characters (chapters are from either Ailin or Meilin's points of view). Nevertheless, an enjoyable read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Silk and Sensibility is a retelling of Sense and Sensibility that takes place in the Ming dynasty of China. It is a sweet story, that follows the original almost exactly, but with interesting twists that align with ancient Chinese culture. The writing is engaging and easy to follow. The characters are reincarnations of Austen's and don't vary; a good and bad thing. While I love the original, I would have liked a little more variance in the retelling.
This is a squeaky clean book appropriate for anyone who loves a good romance.
I received a free advance reader copy. All opinions are my own.
This is a squeaky clean book appropriate for anyone who loves a good romance.
I received a free advance reader copy. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
eArc via Netgalley
Mengxi Seeley's Silk and Sensibility is a beautiful love letter to Jane Austen within Ming dynasty China. Cultures, expectations, and politics may differ across time but one thing remains true: the heart wants, yearns, and desires love.
I like literary retellings (and Chinese dramas). So when I saw talk about this book on Threads, I knew it would be something I would personally enjoy (and I was right).
A must read for Jane Austen fans.
Mengxi Seeley's Silk and Sensibility is a beautiful love letter to Jane Austen within Ming dynasty China. Cultures, expectations, and politics may differ across time but one thing remains true: the heart wants, yearns, and desires love.
I like literary retellings (and Chinese dramas). So when I saw talk about this book on Threads, I knew it would be something I would personally enjoy (and I was right).
A must read for Jane Austen fans.
Read
July 1, 2026What a fun read! I loved the nostalgia and anticipation I felt with the parallels to Sense and Sensibility, but also loved the newness of moments that differred, and learning about Ming Dynasty culture all along the way. The historical piece of this book was well done and interesting. My heart also really loved the beautiful love letter exerpts at the start of the chapters!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This book is a work of art. I have lots of fun seeing how the author changed the names into Chinese, and how the inspiration was obvious but also made sense, super clever. I also loved the historical setting and that it felt really authentical, like the footbinding and the preparation to the imperial exams. It was a super fun and interesting way to portrait this story.
May 10, 2026
I enjoyed this book.
I love Austen. I love Asian themed books. This was a win for me.
I do think it was a bit slow, and at times it was confusing with names and relationships but it is atmospheric and lovely.
I love Austen. I love Asian themed books. This was a win for me.
I do think it was a bit slow, and at times it was confusing with names and relationships but it is atmospheric and lovely.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
My lovely chinese dynasty drama read 💕 I'm invested with the love stories of two sisters. RECOMMENDED!!!!
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews