A forgotten photograph. A trailblazing ancestor. And a modern woman about to discover that her family’s past holds the key to her future.
When overworked surgeon Jaanvi Chowdhury finds a mysterious photograph and a small stack of letters hidden in her Boston attic, she uncovers the remarkable story of her great-aunt Kalyani Joshi—one of the first Indian women to study medicine in 1920s London.
As Jaanvi pieces together her ancestor’s life, she discovers Kalyani’s experience of colonial oppression, her role in India’s fight for independence, and her unlikely connection with a Scottish missionary’s son, Alexander. Drawn together by their passion for literature, Kalyani and Alexander will risk everything for a free India, putting their loyalty, love, and choices to the test.
Navigating between past and present, Jaanvi confronts her own struggles. Passed over for promotion, she has lost sight of why she became a doctor. But as she learns how fiercely Kalyani fought for each opportunity—and the price she paid—Jaanvi begins to question her own carefully constructed life. Can her great-aunt’s unprecedented story help her reclaim not just her purpose in medicine but her sense of who she truly is?
A sweeping and captivating historical novel that will steal a piece of your heart, The Lost Photograph is perfect for fans of Alka Joshi, Kate Quinn, and Kristin Hannah.
Archana Maniar is an infectious disease physician and Professor of Medicine at the University of California, Davis. While she cares for patients during the day, by night, she can usually be found typing away on her laptop trying to free up the stories that have been flitting around in her mind -- usually with her cat Biju napping by her side.
As a child, Archana bounced between states, countries, and continents, having lived on both coasts of the US as well as in Mumbai, India. Before studying medicine, she studied political theory and biology at UCLA. With a perspective forged by trying to find home, her second novel, THE LOST PHOTOGRAPH, immerses the reader in Old Bombay at the verge of revolution against British colonial rule.
"THE LOST PHOTOGRAPH is a page-turner that has it all, forbidden love, clandestine meetings, and the very real danger of losing everything, including oneself. With vivid and compelling characters, the story is gripping and tender at the same time..." --Nigar Alam, Under the Tamarind Tree
"A dazzling and deeply evocative novel ... Maniar's stunning prose instantly drew me in...impossible to put down..." --Linda Wilgus, author of The Sea Child
"Maniar brings 1930s India to vibrant life with this riveting story of two women bound by blood and ambition. THE LOST PHOTOGRAPH is both intimate and sweeping ... a poignant, luminous novel that stays with you long after you've turned the last page." --Claire Booth, author of Throwing Shadows and the Hank Worth mystery series
Her first novel, DRY SPELLS, was described as "a beautiful, vivid and atmospheric novel about the pain of leaving behind your heritage and the joys of rediscovering it. Maniar’s writing transports the reader to India in this evocative story of loss and redemption." --by by Fiona Valpy, bestselling author of The Skylark's Secret
"In DRY SPELLS, lyrical prose and powerful storytelling come together to create unforgettable characters and moments ... Vividly evoking India's cultural landscapes, the book brims with color, depth, and authenticity - an immersive journey we believe with resonate with every reader" --Preeti Urs, Literary Festival Director, Indo-American Arts Council
DRY SPELLS was an editor's choice for Amazon First Reads in the UK and Australia in April 2024.
Find her on Instagram @archanamaniar and Facebook @Archana Maniar
⭐⭐⭐⭐ The Lost Photograph Archana Maniar Publication Date: September 15th, 2026 Amazon Publishing UK | Lake Union Publishing 399 Pages Amazon | Bookshop.org Genre: General Fiction | Women's Fiction
Doctor Jaanvi Chowdhury is an overworked surgeon in Boston. When she goes through her attic, she finds an old photograph and letters that tell a tale of her family's past.
In the 1920s and '30s, Jaanvi's great-aunt Kalyani has a job in the medical field in London at a time when few women did so. Kalyani becomes part of the Indian Independence movement and forms a bond with a Scottish missionary's son named Alexander. They form this bond over their shared love of literature and a free India. As Jaanvi reads about the sacrifices her great-aunt Kalyani made, she starts to get her gumption back for her passion to heal. Even though these women are a hundred years apart, they both have the same calling.
This was a very moving story to read. Both timelines were written well and were woven together nicely. The past timeline was filled with atmosphere and plenty of tension. Jaanvi's current timeline had its own struggles, and she was very relatable and felt authentic.
It's a very inspiring story of women in jobs usually ruled by men, and I loved how Jaanvi used her aunt's past to decide her future. The details and emotions made this book very engaging. I loved reading a positive story of family heritage and how these women triumph over adversity—they were such strong protagonists!
If you enjoy poignant historical fiction with a modern dual timeline, I can't recommend this enough.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
Goodreads ratings reflect reader demographics and popular enthusiasm rather than objective literary merit.
This book was a really enjoyable way to learn about a part of India’s struggle for independence – I wasn’t expecting that at all, but I was glad to learn about something I knew very little about.
The main story is set around 1929-30, where we follow Kalyani, an Indian woman, battling against cultural and family expectations in order to fulfil her dream to become a doctor. We also follow Alexander, a Scottish man who is also struggling with his own family expectations. Kalyani and Alexander both get involved in the movement for India’s independence, which was fascinating to hear about. They also begin to like each other, although it is an impossible relationship, frowned upon by society at those times, so they have to keep things secret.
There is also a second thread to the story, which is set mainly in 2019, where relatives of Kaliani, living in USA discover a photo of her and make an investigation into her life. While it was okay, I don’t really feel that this thread added much to the book, and it would have been effective enough without this thread.
At the beginning, I wasn’t sure if I was going to like this book, but I am glad that I persevered with it, as it was really quite a learning experience for me with regard to India’s history. I realise that it’s only really a little snippet of the history that we are exposed to as we read the book, but it has opened my eyes to all that I don’t know about India (and that’s a lot!).
I listened to audiobook and the narration was excellent – 5 stars. Soneela Nankani did a great job with different accents and expression in the dialogues. As a Scottish person, I can tell that the Scottish accent isn’t quite right, but it wasn’t too far off. There are very few people that can master it well. I’m glad I listened to the audiobook, rather than reading the text.
This is a good book for people who enjoy learning about history through historical fiction, and who also enjoy learning about other cultures as they read.
Thank you to Brilliance Audio and NetGalley for sharing an advance listener copy of this book with me. All opinions are my own.
THE LOST PHOTOGRAPH by Archana Maniar is an engaging dual timeline story set both in the present following a talented female Indian heritage surgeon, Jaanvi, and in the late 1920s in India following her ancestor, Kalyani, and Scottish immigrant, Alexander. This is a story that conveys a compelling narrative about two women in society, past and present, and their struggles in both. While this is a dual timeline book, the story is told in three POVs.
Both the descriptive writing and historical research bring both timelines to life. They are also intertwined perfectly. My slight problem while reading this, and while I realize it was probably necessary, was the use of so many Indian words throughout which took me out of the flow of the story at times. That said though, this is a story that is rich in Indian culture and history that is worth working through the vocabulary. The romantic subplot between Kalyani and Alexander added to the stakes and tension in the historical timeline.
I recommend this story of two women’s struggles and triumphs in the times and societies they inhabit.
I received a gifted copy of this book to read in exchange for an honest review via the author and the publishers.
The Lost Photograph is the second book I have had the pleasure of reading by Archana Maniar and was another beautifully told story full of depth and vivid settings. We follow the POV's of Jaanvi (in the present day) and her ancestor Kalyani (in the 1920s) and a Scottish missionaries son called Alexander (also in the 1920s). Jaanvi has a successful surgical career behind her and after finding her ancestors photograph in her attic, embarks on a journey of discovery that along with assessing her life leads to an unexpected turn in her future. This was such a different and beautiful story that had real events narrated into it that were well researched and voiced. I found Jaanvi a very relatable character in many ways and my heart ached for Kalyani with what she had to navigate through back in the 1920s. The book really made me think and ponder on how much yet also how little society and the rights of women has changed, progressed and stayed the same in many ways across the last 100 years and gave me a deep understanding and respect of Hindu culture and women as well. I can't wait to read more from this author who captivated from page one.
2.5 or 2.75 ⭐️ This was a fine, middle-of-the-road read that started off strong but ultimately lost momentum in the second half. I was initially drawn to Dr. Jaanvi’s storyline as a surgeon struggling with empty nest syndrome and trying to figure out how to fill the void left by her college-bound children. Kalyani’s narrative was equally intriguing at first, making for an engaging setup across both perspectives.
However, around the 50 to 60 percent mark, the book became quite repetitive. Kalyani’s plotline started retreading the exact same topics and conflicts with her brother over and over, while Jaanvi’s narrative suffered from similar stagnation. Additionally, Jaanvi’s story shifted away from the medical setting and surgical focus I was enjoying into a direction I wasn't particularly interested in reading.
Most disappointingly, the connection between the two women felt unearned at the end. Jaanvi makes a sudden decision about her life and work that is supposedly inspired by Kalyani’s story, but the resolution happens so abruptly that I couldn't feel or understand what she actually gained from Kalyani's journey. The repetitive second half and rushed payoff dragged the overall experience down, leaving what began as a promising premise feeling fairly average.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Oh my. I was a fan of Ms. Maniar after her first fabulous book, Dry Spells. I suppose my fandom has doubled with this one. The Lost Photograph reveals another side of India, or maybe I should say two more sides, since this novel is a braided story connecting a contemporary character to her blood relative who lived through and participated in the upheavals of the 1930s when India was shaking off it’s colonial rulers. We meet and follow the contemporary character, Jaanvi, and American-Indian physician, wife and mother as she awakens to question her assumed life paths. When she finds long-forgotten belongings from her great Aunt Kalyani, it sparks a renaissance in her family and in her search for a meaningful next chapter for her life. Another of the braids then follows a coming-of-age Kalyani as she is navigating a life both limited by the long-standing cultural strictures of India and the new freedoms she has glimpsed by having been allowed to spend several years in Britain as one of the first women to study medicine there. When she returns to India, hoping to find refuge in the familiar world of family and home, she finds herself struggling to make herself fit back into the mold she had left. Changes to herself, to her family structure, to her own expectations of her life, and the changes to her friendships and loyalties swirling around her as Gandhi and the resistance movements he has fostered nudge their way into her life and plans. An attraction to a forbidden romance, and a brother intent on marrying her off before she can chose her own future complicates everything. The story also follows a few other characters as needed, which lends depth, context and texture to the stories, which this author handles with grace and clarity. As well, India itself is almost another character as the author brings it so fully to life with its smells, tastes, fabrics and weather. Like in Dry Spells, rain and water play an integral part in underscoring the emotional movements of the characters. An example: “Jaanvi’s thoughtfully packaged plan felt like it was searing a hole in her pocket. She wound her way through Worcester, a steady drizzle speckling her windshield, her wipers whooshing rhythmically …. Jaanvi watched as the world went from misty to clear and back again…” And “Kalyani’s eyes drifted to the table where a tiny pool of water had collected arund the umbrella. She wished so badly she could wipe it away, as if by cleaning it off she might be able to pretend that monsoon shower and the whole afternoon that preceded it had not happened.” Ms. Maniar’s lyrical prose, character development and depth of story all work to captivate me and keep me reading long after I told myself I was turning out the light for sleep! I’m so grateful that I received a free, advance copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for my unbiased review.
I received both the audio and ebook but I ended up listening to the whole thing. I found that the narrators were perfect and loved hearing the Indian and Scottish accents. This was an interesting and emotional story. I wasn't familiar with Indian culture or the independence movement, so this was enlightening. The story has three POVs and two timelines and everything was woven together perfectly. I liked the strong female characters and the theme of independence & self-discovery. The ending was not what I was hoping for, but it makes sense. 4⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for a complimentary advanced copy of this book. All opinions expressed are my own and are in no way influenced by the author, publisher or NetGalley.
I appreciate this informative novel as I knew nothing about the people of India and their work toward independence. I like the deep dive into the culture of the time, especially the restrictions for women. The role of women in the unrest is well described here. I also like the romance aspects, emphasizing the clash of cultures. Characters are drawn well. They are informative, such as showing the disdain some of the English had for India natives.
The dual time aspect of this novel also lets us see the glass ceiling women have recently been experiencing in our modern culture. We get an idea of how life today can be inspired by ancestors. The only aspect of the novel I did not like was the use of Indian words. While there is a glossary at the end of the book it was hard to access while reading.
I do recommend this book and its revelation of an important time in India's work toward independence.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book through Partners in Crime Book Tours. My comments are an independent review.
This was a beautifully written historical fiction novel The story is set in two different time periods, 1920’s in India and 2019 in Massachusetts. Dr. Jaanvi Chowdhury is an American-Indian physician who lives with her husband and two sons in Boston. One day, while up in the attic, she comes upon a box filled with old letters and photographs. Intrigued, she soon discovers that the relics belonged to her great aunt Kalyani Joshi who was one of the first women to study medicine in England in the 1920’s. The story then shifts to Bombay, India with Kalyani traveling home aboard a ship and meeting a Scottish man named Alexander. After the chance meeting, she later runs into the Scot at a party and the two begin a relationship that centers around their mutual love of poetry as well as their concerns for India’s fight for Independence. This novel is a story about freedom, equality and ultimately love. I really enjoyed the audiobook and learning the history of India’s struggles against British rule. I highly recommend this lovely novel.
The Lost Photograph by Archana Maniar is a dual-timeline historical fiction novel that connects the life of a modern-day surgeon, Jaanvi Chowdhury, with that of her remarkable ancestor, Kalyani Joshi, weaving together themes of identity, purpose, love, and resilience against the backdrop of India’s freedom struggle.
What drew me into this story almost immediately was how relatable Jaanvi felt. As someone struggling with career uncertainty, burnout, and the fear of stepping away from the safe path she had carefully built for herself, she felt incredibly real. I connected with her restlessness, her desire and hesitation to rediscover her old passion for photography, and her search for a deeper sense of purpose beyond professional success. Watching her slowly piece together her great-aunt’s story became just as much a journey of self-discovery as it was an exploration of family history.
I was equally, if not more, invested in Kalyani’s story. Watching her navigate life in colonial India was both inspiring and compelling. From secretly slipping away to meet fellow revolutionaries and becoming actively involved in the freedom movement, to constantly clashing with her brother who was determined to marry her off, Kalyani’s journey was one of courage and conviction. Her blossoming romance with Alexander, a Scottish missionary, added a tender layer to the story. What made her such a memorable character was the balance between her vulnerability and her strength. While grappling with societal expectations, judgment, and personal struggles, she never lost sight of her dream of contributing to a free India and forging a life on her own terms. It was truly rewarding to watch her carve a path that remained faithful to both her heart and her ideals.
What I loved most about the book was its dual timeline and how, at its heart, both Jaanvi’s and Kalyani’s journeys mirrored each other. Despite living in vastly different eras, both women are confronted with their deepest fears and must ultimately discover, embrace, and claim their true purpose in life. And watching them do exactly that felt so rewarding.
One of the book’s greatest strengths was the way it vividly brought colonial India, especially Mumbai, to life. I loved witnessing Kalyani’s unwavering determination to stand up for what was right, as well as her deep joy in returning home. Through Alexander’s eyes, readers also get to experience the vibrant colours, customs, and charming eccentricities of India. The author does not shy away from portraying the brutal realities of British rule, capturing the discrimination and inhumane treatment endured by Indians with remarkable honesty. Among the most powerful moments in the novel was the women's salt march at Chowpatty, a sequence that was both heartbreaking and profoundly moving.
I was completely swept away by the chemistry between Kalyani and Alexander. Their romance unfolds through quiet moments, shared books, and unspoken emotions, making it all the more captivating. I loved how literature became their language of affection, allowing them to express feelings they could not say aloud. Every exchanged note, lingering glance, and fleeting touch carried so much meaning that I found myself smiling ear-to-ear through their scenes.
What made their relationship especially memorable was its tenderness. Alexander's admiration for Kalyani felt sincere and unwavering, while Kalyani's trust in him grew naturally amidst the chaos surrounding them. Knowing from the very beginning that their story was unlikely to have a typical happy ending, filled every happy moment with a sense of impending heartbreak. By the time the truth of Kalyani's fate began to unfold, I was emotionally invested enough to feel every loss alongside them. Keep a box of tissues handy because you are definitely going to need them.
In the end, The Lost Photograph is a moving tribute to the women who came before us and the paths they carved for future generations. It is a story about courage, sacrifice, love, and finding one’s true calling. By the final page, I felt both emotional and grateful, reflecting on the many extraordinary women whose contributions to history may never be fully known, yet continue to shape our lives today. If you love historical fiction and strong female characters, you have to pick this one!
I became a fan of Archana Maniar's writing after her debut, Dry Spells, left a lasting impact on me a couple of years ago and knew I couldn't wait to pick up her next book.
The Lost Photograph takes us on a journey of India's fight for independence from the British Empire via a dual storyline; 2019, Jaanvi, an American-Indian physician, locates an old photograph of a distant relative. The photo is of her great Aunt Kalyani at a prestigious Medical college in London, and this sparks Jaanvi's intrigue who now wants to find out more about Kalyani's life from India in the 1920-30's. The book also shows us Kalyani's perspective as a young woman striving for academic excellence at a time when women are treated as second class citizens, defying cultural restrictions and expectations imposed on her at home, but also trying to overcome the prejudices and racism suffered by Indians whilst living under British rule. Kalyani is shown as being one of the first women to study medicine in Britain and spends several years there, enjoying new freedoms and camaraderie of two close friends, Elizabeth and Emma.
Unfortunately, life has other plans and the growing fervour of the resistance movement in India, plus her own personal circumstances, means Kalyani drops out of medical school and returns to India. Back at home, with her brother trying to intervene and get her married off threatens Kalyani's plans for her future. The resistance movement, particuarly the influence of real freedom fighters (Satyagrahis) like Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay, gives Kalyani a new meaningful chapter in her life in supporting and aiding the efforts on the ground and treating peaceful protestors when they are confronted with violence by the British authorities.
The story is well fleshed out and I enjoyed reading Kalyani's forbidden romance with Alexander Wright, a missionary in India aiming to spread Christianity and convert the Indian population, who is battling his own demons eventually finds solace in the temples surrounding him. The dual timeline also shows that Jaanvi's battles are not too different to what her blood relative faces decades ago and even gives her the courage to take a risk and determine the trajectory of her life. As with Dry Spells, Maniar's writing has the ability to transport you across continents and I really felt as if I was experiencing Indian culture with the way smells, tastes, fabrics, locations and even the weather were described in this book. You could feel Kalyani's liberation as she enjoyed the downpour of the monsoon season. This book is of particular importance to shed a light on the contribution of Indian women to the Independence movement and is thoroughly researched. Having finished the book, I want to educate myself in more detail on the hardships and achievements of these unsung heroines.
Thank you Archana Maniar, Amazon Publishing UK and netgalley for an advanced copy of the book in exchange for an honest unedited review.
After reading Dry Spells by this author a couple of years ago - and really enjoying it - I was excited to see that this new book was heading our way and I couldn't wait to be transported back into another wonderful story.
Having worked hard for years, surgeon Jaanvi finds herself at a turning point in life.
With her boys about to head off to university, she wonders how her life will look once they're gone.
A visit to the attic uncovers some old boxes and a photo of one of her ancestors peaks her interest and brings the family together as they look into the life and troubles of Kalyani.
We follow the story over a dual timeline split between Jaanvi in present day US and Kalyani in a 1920's India, during a time when India was just starting to fight for its independence.
I loved how these two threads of the story wove together and I was completely invested in both of them and all its characters.
Jaanvi was so relatable - although I'm not quite in the same position workwise, I found her reminiscing and contemplation of a life after children was something that I'd been through myself over the last few years too.
It was great to see her making the most out of the time with her boys and giving them the opportunity to delve into a wonderful family history.
Picking up an old love of photography was an added bonus!
I absolutely adored Kalyani's storyline.
I'm not a huge history fan, but when incorporated into such a wonderfully written story like this, I have to admit to being completely obsessed.
Not only was the romantic thread beautifully done - yep, I definitely got a little emotional throughout - the history of an oppressed India captured my heart too.
Definitely not something I've ever thought about, but after learning the bits through the book, I've found myself stopping and researching even more since.
The culture difference was fascinating - I know some will have also been the era - but seeing India through Alexander's eyes was so special, but it also showed just how awful the other side of that was too.
Some of the scenes were heartbreaking.
I'm so grateful for those who research and create these stories as I feel this is such a great way to get everyone invested in important historical events and people who should be celebrated more than they are.
It's certainly allowed me to enjoy and learn lots and I just love this author's writing style which had me completely immersed throughout - I can't wait to read more.
It is 1929 when India is on the cusp of a revolution, wanting freedom from the British Raj. Kalyani, who had gone to London for medical studies returns to India and gets caught up in the activities of the revolution, standing against the Raj while also dealing with the stigma and prejudice associated with being a woman who dares to stand for herself in a society that wants her to be invisible and mute.
Decades later, Jaanvi, a local surgeon, comes across a photograph of her ancestor Kalyani and while searching for her story, seeks inspiration for herself.
The story spans over two timelines and effortlessly switches between them. The author has done a wonderful job of presenting India during the British Raj. The prevailing environment and the mindset of the society have been described aptly.
I liked how the author has highlighted the issues faced by Kalyani and Jaanvi in their respective timelines. The issues, while different, still share a common foundation of women being looked down upon always. While Jaanvi's story is based on the year 2019 and shows the issues present in the current day, Kalyani has it far more challenging in the 1930s, fighting for her place not just in the society but at her very home. I liked their portrayal of being independant and resolute women.
The story also shows another often overlooked side of the British Raj - the fate of a white guy in India, who has no intention to rule or dominate over the masses, who doesn't want to be someone who looks over Indians with prejudice and only wants to live his life in peace, with the woman he loves. Alexander's character has been very well-etched and you can't but sympathize with him - a person caught up in the turmoil between two worlds, one of which has the love of his life.
This is the author's second book that I read, and I love her unique style of narrative that is crisp, concise and moves at a pace that is both leisurely and engrossing. If you love women-centric books, if you are a fan of books based on India's fight to freedom, then you will love this one. Definitely recommending this one for people looking for poignant and soulful reads.
💬 My Bookish Thoughts I adore historical fiction about India and when you add a dual timeline, I’m even more intrigued!
The Lost Photograph is a beautifully written, atmospheric story following two generations of Indian women, both trying to balance their passion for medicine, their home lives and the expectations placed on them by society.
We follow Jaanvi, an overworked and under-recognised surgeon in Boston, as she begins piecing together the secret past of her trailblazing great-aunt Kalyani. Her journey takes us back to 1920s London, where Kalyani is studying medicine before returning to India during a time of colonial oppression and growing calls for independence.
I fell in love with these characters and their stories, and if it’s at all possible, this book has made me want to visit India even more! 🇮🇳
I learned so much about India’s fight for independence, the impact of colonialism, and the struggles women faced for equal access to education, professional opportunities and the freedom to make their own choices.
It’s a story about freedom, equality, identity and finding your place in a world that is constantly trying to define you — with a gorgeous love story woven throughout. ❤️
And something I found absolutely fascinating is that Archana is an infectious disease physician and Professor of Medicine at the University of California. Her medical knowledge really shines through in the descriptions of medical study, procedures and the experiences of these women pursuing careers in medicine.
📝 I also absolutely loved that Archana included a glossary. As someone who is always grateful for a little extra help with unfamiliar words and phrases, this was very welcome!
✨ Three words: Compelling 🧲 Fascinating 🌎 Important 🕊️
✨ This digital ARC was kindly gifted by Archana Maniar, Amazon UK Publishing and NetGalley. This is my honest, voluntary review.
I really wanted to like this book more than I did. Perhaps I should’ve read it rather than listened to it. I’m sure I’d have enjoyed it more in a printed version. It would, however, make a sumptuous movie. Therefore, I feel I can give it 3 stars even though I gave up halfway through.
The story is told from 3 perspectives : that of surgeon Janvee in modern day Massachusetts , and that of her long lost aunt Kalyani, as well as Scotsman Alexander who are both living in Bombay in the 1920s.
The story centers around Kalyani and I feel is one that has been told many times before. A young, beautiful, clever woman experiences prejudice and unwanted sexual advances in a foreign country. She returns home to India only to find she is faced with similar attitudes plus, in addition, a deadline to save herself from an unwanted marriage.
Of course, we all wish this story was not so common. Just because it’s been told many times before it doesn’t make it less wrong or less unfair. The story of Kalyani is reflected in the prejudice that Janvee experiences from her colleagues at work, too.
The author obviously has a lot of historical and medical knowledge, and she wants to impart this via the dialogues and thoughts of the main characters. Unfortunately, for me, this makes the dialogues feel less realistic.
I listened to the audiobook. The narrator tries hard at making the diverse accents and voices sound believable. It’s a tough job and one that would’ve benefited from having two narrators. Female Indian and Scottish male voices and accents are very, very different. It would be a wonder if one person could make both sound right. Hence this was a DNF for me.
Thank you to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for generously allowing me to listen to an ARC of this book. The opinions above are very obviously all my own. I’m sorry.
The novel is told in dual timelines, one set in 1929-30 and the other in 2019. Our modern protagonist, Jaanvi, is a mother and a doctor. This career was chosen long ago to prioritize financial stability - supporting her family. Now her children are on the cusp of leaving for college, and she faces decisions: continue advancing in her career, or perhaps rediscover the creative pursuits she loved in her younger years? Her great aunt Kalyani lives in pre-WWII India, where she is pushing barriers to become a doctor at a time and place when that was very rare. Committed to doing what she can to help her country become free of British rule, she also struggles to find her way in a society that expects her to follow the traditional path to wife and motherhood. That path doesn’t feel genuine to her, so she sets out to forge her own. I was surprised by how much I connected with and felt for Jaanvi. I’m at a similar point in my own life, with children who are young adults, and I found myself reflecting along with her on the changes and sacrifices made for family. Her attempts to rediscover who she is now, as the culmination of her life’s experiences, form the heart of her growth in the story. This was a fascinating look at Indian history from an Indian perspective. I knew very little about India’s fight for independence from British rule, and this story opened my eyes. The book made me reflect on how much of India’s story is still wrapped up with England’s rule over it. Readers who enjoy historical fiction will find a lot to love here, especially those who appreciate stories of women carving out their own paths across generations. Thank you to the author, Brilliance Publishing, and NetGalley for the ARC of this book.
An enjoyable historical fiction book full of family secrets and women discovering that the life they want is not the life that is the one that is expected of them. Dr Jaanvi Chowdhury discovers an old photograph of a great-aunt she knew nothing about. As she learns more about her great-aunt Kalyani Joshi she discovers not only more about her family but things about herself. This dual timeline story is beautifully written and shares history, the Indian war for independence, that I knew nothing about.
I found the characters to be fascinating. The connection between Kalyani and Jaanvi and their work and dreams took Jaanvi by surprise and got her thinking about her own life. Both women discovered that the life they want is not the one that is expected and they had to figure out how to make it happen. I found it interesting that Jaanvi still faced struggles being accepted as a doctor. Family plays a large part of the story and I enjoyed watching the relationships evolve.
This quote sums up Kalyani and the story and continues to resonate with me, “She had led a life undaunted”
I recommend this story to readers that enjoy historical fiction about strong women and lesser known historical events.
Thanks to Partners in Crime VBT for the free, gifted copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
The Lost Photograph by Archana Maniar is a beautiful and atmospheric historical fiction novel about India’s fight for independence. I have never been to India, but the writing made me feel as though I were right there with Kalyani and Alexander in 1930s Bombay. I loved how the two timelines—one following a surgeon uncovering her great-aunt’s remarkable story as one of the first Indian women to study medicine in 1920s London—came together in a story that felt both sweeping and deeply personal. One of my favorite things about historical fiction is discovering how ordinary lives are shaped by larger historical events, and Archana Maniar does this wonderfully. The emotional journey is just as compelling as uncovering the truth, making these characters easy to care about from beginning to end. This is another brilliant book from Archana, and The Lost Photograph will stay with me for a long time. Absolutely loved it! My sincere thanks to NetGalley and Amazon Publishing UK for providing me with a free advance review copy. All opinions are my own.
I love historical fictions with dual timelines! I seem to always prefer the past timelines better because I want to live in the past but with The Lost Photograph I loved both timelines equally. Kalyani is in the medical field in London about a hundred years ago at a time when very few women are allowed to do so. The details for this time period are vivid and you can tell alot of research went into this book. Kalyani becomes part of the Indian Independence movement and becomes friends with a missionary's son named Alexander. They share a love over wanting a free India. In the modern timeline is Kalyani's niece who found the old photograph and letters of her great aunt and is a burnt out surgeon that has lost her passion. But, through reading Kalyani's letters, Jaanvi starts to regain that passion for wanting to heal people. This book was fast paced and I loved both timelines and they flowed together perfectly. Both women's stories were very inspiring and uplifting. Because of the author's attention to detail everything felt raw and genuine and it was easy to connect to the characters. Highly recommend!
This is an interesting historical novel that examines what happens when Jaanvi, a doctor living in Boston, finds an unexpected stash of memorabilia that tells her the untold story of her great aunt, also a doctor, in pre-World War II India. But the similarities end there, with the common career choice.
Because Jaanvi's ancestor had to fight a bitter battle to become a doctor in British India, as a woman of that time, expected to focus instead on marriage and family. And that battle was compounded by Kalyani's participation in the freedom struggle for Indian Independence.
By contrast, Jaanvi made the choice to study medicine largely to benefit her family, taking into consideration the desire for a safe and lucrative career.
But now with her children soon to take their owns in life, Jaanvi discovers she too has choices to make - whether to continue on the safe road or to follow her creative heart, which yearns for freedom, as her great-aunt's did.
This works well as an audio book and will be a particularly effective introduction to India's past for those who may not be familiar with it.
I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
The historical storyline in The Lost Photograph that takes place during India’s struggle for independence is richly drawn, transporting the reader into a time when women's choices were severely restricted.
What makes this novel particularly powerful, however, is its modern-day storyline. Although female doctors today have access to opportunities that earlier generations could only dream of, they continue to still encounter sexism in subtler forms.
Ultimately, though, this is a novel about resilience. The forbidden love story provides its emotional center, while the sweeping historical context gives it depth and perspective. Women—both past and present—demonstrate that breaking barriers is rarely a single dramatic act. It is often a long process of persistence, courage, and refusing to accept the limitations others impose. Beautifully ambitious and emotionally engaging, Dr. Maniar succeeds because it makes history personal.
I was given early access to The Lost Photograph through Netgalley and this is my unbiased opinion.
The Lost Photograph by Archana Maniar is a powerful and moving story that beautifully weaves together history, culture, family, and the strength of women.
What resonated with me most were the female characters and the different ways each woman finds her voice. Their strength isn’t expressed in just one way—it evolves through their choices, their relationships, their struggles, and their willingness to challenge what is expected of them.
I also loved experiencing India’s independence movement through a female lens. We often learn about this period through political leaders and major historical events, but this story brings us into the lives of women experiencing those changes personally. Their own journeys toward independence unfold alongside a country fighting for its own.
As a South Asian woman, I especially appreciated the cultural details and the way the story explores the complexities of tradition, identity, family, and change. It is a thoughtful and beautifully layered novel with strong female characters who stayed with me after I finished the book.
I love a historical fiction story told through dual POV, especially one that is able to draw parallels and find ways to connect the stories or share a theme. The book highlights both women's need to find themselves and assert their independence and the way society may be pushing them to specific roles.
An older main character who is trying to find what is next for them, and a young woman who is looking at her life and the impact she can have on the community. I think the ending was a nice nod to the past, if not a little rushed. I think we could have spent a little more time creating the connection and bond between the two women before we got the ending.
I like that both women shared a love for medicine and you could see how that love was portrayed in both generations. We also see the sacrifices made by one generation to empower the next. Each generations fight for freedom/independence, equality for women, and finding their place in their family, community and history.
It’s a story about freedom, equality, identity and finding your place in a world that is constantly trying to define you — with a gorgeous love story woven throughout
Thank you to netgalley for the advanced listener copy.
I really wanted to love The Lost Photograph. It read as such an interesting story from a new to me author and narrator. I enjoyed the idea of a modern woman from Massachusetts trying to rediscover herself and find answers to a found photograph. The dual timeline follows a trailblazing independent young woman during India’s fight for independence. The narration by Soneela Nankani was good, though I couldn’t help feeling that a duet performance might have elevated the emotional beats and strengthened the contrast between timelines and characters. While the story started strong with a compelling plot, the pacing eventually slowed and dragged in places. Overall, an intriguing idea with moments of beauty and cultural richness, but the execution didn’t hold. 2 ½ stars I would like to thank the author, narrator, Brilliance Publishing and NetGalley for my copy of this audio, in exchange for my honest review.
The Lost Photograph by Archana Maniar is a book about Jaanvi who is our MC in this book. Jaanvi is a surgeon, that like all doctors is overwhelmed and overworked in her career. She happens one day upon a photograph and a stack of letters in her attic. These belonged to her Great Aunt- Kalyani who was one of the first people to study medicine in London in early history. This story follows two characters, modern day Jaanvi and in the past Kalyani, who are both studying medicine and working in the medical field. I love how these generations, several removed, are working on the same career path. That is true in some families. I liked the historical aspect and the fact that the women were working in fields that are intelligent and really have to step up to compete in the field. Also as a reader you can get a feeling of India's history. If you love historical fiction reads, women reads, and multi-generational reads, you will love this book.
I knew I shouldn’t start reading this on a weeknight, but my restraint absconded with my willpower the minute I laid my hands on this book. Maniar has done it again, artfully weaving the story of two women—related by blood and connected through time. Both buck the norms of a society that is geared to suppress their intelligence and passion. The book brings a much-needed perspective on the struggles of the Indian people under colonial rule and the tireless work of courageous souls who risked everything to gain independence. Any woman who has tried to break a glass ceiling, flex her independence, or get recognition for the merits of her work will savor this book like a crisp raspberry sorbet on a hot summer's night.
I received a free, advance copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for my unbiased review.
The Lost Photograph is a thoughtful historical novel about memory, family, and the stories hidden behind old photographs. As long-buried secrets begin to surface, the novel explores how a single image can connect generations and reveal parts of the past that have been forgotten or intentionally left untold. I especially enjoyed how the mystery unfolded through personal relationships rather than relying on constant twists.
One of my favorite parts of historical fiction is discovering how ordinary lives are shaped by larger historical events, and this novel does that well. The emotional journey felt just as important as uncovering the truth, making the characters easy to care about from beginning to end. My sincere thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with a free advance review copy.
This is the second book I have read by this author, and I hope she writes more! This historical fiction book starts with a current day Indian American woman and surgeon who finds an old picture of her great aunt from India, and sets out to learn her story. It is told in current day while also having a storyline of characters, including the great aunt in India during British control. It details the struggles of the people of India during the time when they were seeking independence, and the extreme difficulties they experienced. I know it's fiction but it brought to my attention that India's fight for independence took a lot more than Ghandi. The author highlights the growth and empowerment of both the female main characters in a captivating and heartwarming way. The storyline is believable and drew me in. I had a hard time putting the book down once I started reading it.
I enjoyed this post-colonial perspective historical fiction about India's Independence Movement in the 1930's, specifically the Salt Marches. The struggle for independence is reflected in the protagonist, Kaliani who is navigating between older ideas and beliefs that keep her from fully realizing who she is and her pursuit of medicine. It totters between past and present where her descendants find evidence of a love story between their great aunt and a Scottish man (which was very unusual at the time). It was a refreshing coming of age story for a young woman who wants to honour herself and also the place she comes from. I wasn't very optimistic about the fate of the love story at times, but I'm glad it had a happy ending.