What do you think?
Rate this book
The Fiction of Us
Lilah Rayne knows how to write a love story. Living one is another matter entirely.
After her breakup mirrors the novel she wrote under her secret pen name, Lilah retreats to Wattlewood Ridge—a small mountain town where bookstores matter, friendships run deep, and magic hums quietly beneath the surface. Back in her old apartment above Brew & Bloom Café, she plans to regroup, heal, and stay invisible.
Then she meets Lucas Castle.
Quiet, steady, and rebuilding the beloved Inkwell & Ivy bookstore, Lucas feels like someone Lilah already knows—like a story she once imagined and never meant to live. As their connection deepens through shared silences and slow mornings, the town begins returning pieces of Lilah she thought she’d lost.
But when her past threatens to expose everything she’s been hiding, Lilah must decide whether she’s brave enough to be seen. Not as the woman she writes, but as the one who feels.
The Fiction of Us is a slow-burn, small-town romance about second chances, soft magic, and choosing love that doesn’t need to be loud to be real.
After her breakup mirrors the novel she wrote under her secret pen name, Lilah retreats to Wattlewood Ridge—a small mountain town where bookstores matter, friendships run deep, and magic hums quietly beneath the surface. Back in her old apartment above Brew & Bloom Café, she plans to regroup, heal, and stay invisible.
Then she meets Lucas Castle.
Quiet, steady, and rebuilding the beloved Inkwell & Ivy bookstore, Lucas feels like someone Lilah already knows—like a story she once imagined and never meant to live. As their connection deepens through shared silences and slow mornings, the town begins returning pieces of Lilah she thought she’d lost.
But when her past threatens to expose everything she’s been hiding, Lilah must decide whether she’s brave enough to be seen. Not as the woman she writes, but as the one who feels.
The Fiction of Us is a slow-burn, small-town romance about second chances, soft magic, and choosing love that doesn’t need to be loud to be real.
393 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 10, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews
April 11, 2026
WOW.
What a magical read, so cozy but with a real backbone of a storyline too! Sometimes cozy books can get lost in the comfort and lose the plot, but Shae has kept this all together in a delicious package 😍 What a delightful read.
The writing style and characters tickled my brain in all the right places, I couldn't put this book down - I was so hungry for more! Ravenous really!
I'm unsure if this is planned to be a series but I really hope so, as much as I adored the main character development, I really fell in love with alot of the side characters too 🥰🫶🏻
One small bone to pick with Shae though - it's Parma, not Parmy 👀😂 I will die on that hill!
Ashley Poston lovers, seriously, this book is for you!
What a magical read, so cozy but with a real backbone of a storyline too! Sometimes cozy books can get lost in the comfort and lose the plot, but Shae has kept this all together in a delicious package 😍 What a delightful read.
The writing style and characters tickled my brain in all the right places, I couldn't put this book down - I was so hungry for more! Ravenous really!
I'm unsure if this is planned to be a series but I really hope so, as much as I adored the main character development, I really fell in love with alot of the side characters too 🥰🫶🏻
One small bone to pick with Shae though - it's Parma, not Parmy 👀😂 I will die on that hill!
Ashley Poston lovers, seriously, this book is for you!
July 10, 2026
4.5 Stars⭐️
The Fiction of Us was so much more than a small-town romance😭😭
This was poetry. This was heart. This was a gentle reminder that healing doesn't always happen in grand, dramatic moments. It can be found in quiet mornings, kind people, well loved bookstores, and the courage to let yourself be truly seen!!!
Lilah's journey completely stole my heart. Watching her slowly peel back the layers she'd hidden behind for so long felt incredibly raw and authentic. Lucas wasn't there to save her; he simply created a space where she could finally be herself, and I adored that.
Wattlewood Ridge felt like a character of its own. From the charming café to the beloved bookstore, every page wrapped me in warmth and comfort while still carrying an emotional depth that lingered long after I finished.
More than anything, this story is for anyone who has ever felt unseen, misunderstood, or like they were somehow too much. It's a reminder that you don't have to shrink yourself to be worthy of love, and that the right people will embrace every part of who you are.
One quote that perfectly captures the soul of this story is:
"…taught me that stories aren't just escapes, they're anchors. That quiet people still have plenty to say. That sometimes healing, looks like rearranging a shelf until something in you clicks back into place."🥹
The only reason this wasn't a full five stars was that I found the pacing a little slow in parts, but the beautiful writing and emotional depth more than made up for it.
From me to you after reading this: May you never feel like you have to hide behind a version of yourself just to be accepted💌💌
The Fiction of Us was so much more than a small-town romance😭😭
This was poetry. This was heart. This was a gentle reminder that healing doesn't always happen in grand, dramatic moments. It can be found in quiet mornings, kind people, well loved bookstores, and the courage to let yourself be truly seen!!!
Lilah's journey completely stole my heart. Watching her slowly peel back the layers she'd hidden behind for so long felt incredibly raw and authentic. Lucas wasn't there to save her; he simply created a space where she could finally be herself, and I adored that.
Wattlewood Ridge felt like a character of its own. From the charming café to the beloved bookstore, every page wrapped me in warmth and comfort while still carrying an emotional depth that lingered long after I finished.
More than anything, this story is for anyone who has ever felt unseen, misunderstood, or like they were somehow too much. It's a reminder that you don't have to shrink yourself to be worthy of love, and that the right people will embrace every part of who you are.
One quote that perfectly captures the soul of this story is:
"…taught me that stories aren't just escapes, they're anchors. That quiet people still have plenty to say. That sometimes healing, looks like rearranging a shelf until something in you clicks back into place."🥹
The only reason this wasn't a full five stars was that I found the pacing a little slow in parts, but the beautiful writing and emotional depth more than made up for it.
From me to you after reading this: May you never feel like you have to hide behind a version of yourself just to be accepted💌💌
April 30, 2026
This was such a sweet, wholesome read.
Relatable in so many ways.
I really enjoyed the whimsical elements that had been weaved throughout, the under current of “fate” working in mysterious ways.
I look forward to reading more from Shae!
Relatable in so many ways.
I really enjoyed the whimsical elements that had been weaved throughout, the under current of “fate” working in mysterious ways.
I look forward to reading more from Shae!
March 1, 2026
Firstly, thank you to The Berry Agency and Shae for the opportunity to ARC read this book!
If you love Ashley Poston’s writing style and magic she brings then you will DEFINITELY love this book! 🥰
The Fiction of Us follows Lilah who wrote a novel about moving on and finds herself following the magically journey she wrote into her own life. Then there Lucas who’s just trying to do his Aunt’s memory proud by reopening the bookstore and seems to have found himself falling in love with the small town of Wattlewood Ridge. 1000% recommend this book if you want a little magic in your life 🥰
If you love Ashley Poston’s writing style and magic she brings then you will DEFINITELY love this book! 🥰
The Fiction of Us follows Lilah who wrote a novel about moving on and finds herself following the magically journey she wrote into her own life. Then there Lucas who’s just trying to do his Aunt’s memory proud by reopening the bookstore and seems to have found himself falling in love with the small town of Wattlewood Ridge. 1000% recommend this book if you want a little magic in your life 🥰
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 4, 2026
Enjoyed this book a lot. Was an easy read which is great.
It’s a cute romance in a small town with a happy ending.
Twists along the way but in a calm way. Great read!!
Will recommend.
It’s a cute romance in a small town with a happy ending.
Twists along the way but in a calm way. Great read!!
Will recommend.
May 8, 2026
I was fortunate enough to receive an ARC of The Fiction of Us, and if you love Gilmore Girls–style small-town vibes with a whimsical, magical, serendipitous “writing your fate into reality” element (think The Lost City), this one’s for you.
Lilah, the main character, grapples with imposter syndrome and that all-too-familiar feeling of not being good enough—something so many of us can relate to. Then she meets Lucas, a walking green flag and ultimate cinnamon roll MMC, who is exactly what Lilah needs.
This was my first real dive into magical realism, and I was not disappointed.
What a beautiful debut—Shae, you should be so proud.
Lilah, the main character, grapples with imposter syndrome and that all-too-familiar feeling of not being good enough—something so many of us can relate to. Then she meets Lucas, a walking green flag and ultimate cinnamon roll MMC, who is exactly what Lilah needs.
This was my first real dive into magical realism, and I was not disappointed.
What a beautiful debut—Shae, you should be so proud.
March 14, 2026
Let me start by saying I do not do a lot of romance novels. That was my main goal this year was to dip my toe and find the romance novels that I do like. And guys I found it.
This book follows Lilah and Lucas, and it was magical, I ate it up. Which isn’t normal for me so it speaks volumes when I say this is a 5 star read.
And for a dabue novel, she’s done an excellent job.
Shae’s writing style was perfect I don’t think I’d change a single thing.. the book kept me engaged and wanting more. And if you found your self wanting more then you may want to pick up the sweet treat anthology to read Shaes story.
I think interconnecting romances are my thing.
And this plot had me locked down.
And I even had some theory’s running around my head for the rest of the series. And I need them yesterday lol.
So if you like cozy small town romances and a too cute to boot story then this is the book for you!
This book follows Lilah and Lucas, and it was magical, I ate it up. Which isn’t normal for me so it speaks volumes when I say this is a 5 star read.
And for a dabue novel, she’s done an excellent job.
Shae’s writing style was perfect I don’t think I’d change a single thing.. the book kept me engaged and wanting more. And if you found your self wanting more then you may want to pick up the sweet treat anthology to read Shaes story.
I think interconnecting romances are my thing.
And this plot had me locked down.
And I even had some theory’s running around my head for the rest of the series. And I need them yesterday lol.
So if you like cozy small town romances and a too cute to boot story then this is the book for you!
April 15, 2026
“It’s a story about shedding the version of yourself someone else made small, and about telling the truth, even when your voice shakes.”
The Fiction of us
By Shae Roberts
Paperhearts Series
Debut novel
Released April 10th 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️.5
What to expect
🍃Small town
🍃Magical Realism
🍃Author FMC
🍃Found Family
🍃Slow Burn
🍃Bookstore Owner MMC
My Thoughts
Firstly, I have not read Magical Realism before. So this was new to me.
Reading The Fiction Of Us, had left me a little speechless and emotional, by the end, in such a good way. I had to take a moment and think, of exactly how this made me feel. I needed To gather my thoughts, because Trying to find the words without taking alot of the parts from the book and saying here …this!!! Wasn’t easy!
“People will love this book, not just for the story, but for the heart in it.”
It gave me emotions, like I didn’t know that some of this would have reflected things throughout my own life, though maybe not in the same way as Lilahs/lolas. It made me feel and I really mean that, it’s raw, it’s brave, it’s honesty, it’s impactful, it’s theirs and it sure is written in a way that makes you understand.
“It felt like someone cracked themselves open and wrote it all down. I kept seeing myself in it, moments I thought were mine alone. It was like being known without anyone asking.”
There is so much depth to this! I felt it within the first few chapters! I definitely didn’t think some things would hit me. But I guess, we don’t understand until, we read it somewhere and resonate with it, in some way.
“Some stories don’t end. They just keep turning the page.”
Perhaps you should prepare for an emotionally beautiful written story! Shaes writing style is something else.
What a Debut!!!!
XO
The Fiction of us
By Shae Roberts
Paperhearts Series
Debut novel
Released April 10th 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️.5
What to expect
🍃Small town
🍃Magical Realism
🍃Author FMC
🍃Found Family
🍃Slow Burn
🍃Bookstore Owner MMC
My Thoughts
Firstly, I have not read Magical Realism before. So this was new to me.
Reading The Fiction Of Us, had left me a little speechless and emotional, by the end, in such a good way. I had to take a moment and think, of exactly how this made me feel. I needed To gather my thoughts, because Trying to find the words without taking alot of the parts from the book and saying here …this!!! Wasn’t easy!
“People will love this book, not just for the story, but for the heart in it.”
It gave me emotions, like I didn’t know that some of this would have reflected things throughout my own life, though maybe not in the same way as Lilahs/lolas. It made me feel and I really mean that, it’s raw, it’s brave, it’s honesty, it’s impactful, it’s theirs and it sure is written in a way that makes you understand.
“It felt like someone cracked themselves open and wrote it all down. I kept seeing myself in it, moments I thought were mine alone. It was like being known without anyone asking.”
There is so much depth to this! I felt it within the first few chapters! I definitely didn’t think some things would hit me. But I guess, we don’t understand until, we read it somewhere and resonate with it, in some way.
“Some stories don’t end. They just keep turning the page.”
Perhaps you should prepare for an emotionally beautiful written story! Shaes writing style is something else.
What a Debut!!!!
XO
March 10, 2026
I was lucky enough to receive an ARC copy of The Fiction of Us by Shae Roberts and I’m so grateful I had the chance to read it.
This was my first time reading anything by Shae and I was genuinely blown away by how beautiful the writing was. From the first few chapters I felt completely drawn into the story. The writing style is thoughtful, immersive, and quietly emotional in a way that makes you really feel the characters’ journeys.
The story follows Lilah Rayne, a writer who has secretly published a novel under a pen name, one that unexpectedly becomes hugely successful. After breaking up with a boyfriend who never truly supported her writing, she returns to her old apartment to start again. There she meets a local bookstore owner who has just inherited the shop from his late aunt, and the two slowly become part of each other’s lives.
At its heart, this is a small-town contemporary romance, but it’s also about finding your confidence, rebuilding after disappointment, and allowing yourself to step into the life you’re meant to live. Lilah’s journey of learning to believe in herself was especially lovely to read, and the growing relationship between her and Lucas felt natural, tender, and very real.
I completely ate this story up and enjoyed every second of it. It’s the kind of book you sink into and don’t want to leave. Warm, emotional, and beautifully written, The Fiction of Us was delicious.
Thank you again to Shae Roberts for the opportunity to read this ARC. I’ll definitely be looking out for more of her books in the future
This was my first time reading anything by Shae and I was genuinely blown away by how beautiful the writing was. From the first few chapters I felt completely drawn into the story. The writing style is thoughtful, immersive, and quietly emotional in a way that makes you really feel the characters’ journeys.
The story follows Lilah Rayne, a writer who has secretly published a novel under a pen name, one that unexpectedly becomes hugely successful. After breaking up with a boyfriend who never truly supported her writing, she returns to her old apartment to start again. There she meets a local bookstore owner who has just inherited the shop from his late aunt, and the two slowly become part of each other’s lives.
At its heart, this is a small-town contemporary romance, but it’s also about finding your confidence, rebuilding after disappointment, and allowing yourself to step into the life you’re meant to live. Lilah’s journey of learning to believe in herself was especially lovely to read, and the growing relationship between her and Lucas felt natural, tender, and very real.
I completely ate this story up and enjoyed every second of it. It’s the kind of book you sink into and don’t want to leave. Warm, emotional, and beautifully written, The Fiction of Us was delicious.
Thank you again to Shae Roberts for the opportunity to read this ARC. I’ll definitely be looking out for more of her books in the future
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 11, 2026
Sometimes you pick up a book and it’s like putting on a cosy sweater or holding a warm mug of hot chocolate. This book was like that for me.
This book is definitely for the bookish girlies. A cute little town, a cosy bookstore and a mysterious author from a small town remarkably similar to Wattlewood Ridge, where the story takes place.
Lilah is a secret author who just when her career is taking off, her life falls apart. While sorting out her life Lilah returns to the small town she lived in previously and to her previous role as a barista at the local coffee shop. Being such a small town everyone’s interest is piqued when there is a new owner for their local bookstore. Enter Lucas and his sassy shop assistant, Jasper, who is determined to discover the true identity of the author of the latest viral novel.
This is a cute story which explores the question do we write our own stories or are they written for us? I really enjoyed this book. It was a nice easy read and I’m looking forward to more from this author.
This book is definitely for the bookish girlies. A cute little town, a cosy bookstore and a mysterious author from a small town remarkably similar to Wattlewood Ridge, where the story takes place.
Lilah is a secret author who just when her career is taking off, her life falls apart. While sorting out her life Lilah returns to the small town she lived in previously and to her previous role as a barista at the local coffee shop. Being such a small town everyone’s interest is piqued when there is a new owner for their local bookstore. Enter Lucas and his sassy shop assistant, Jasper, who is determined to discover the true identity of the author of the latest viral novel.
This is a cute story which explores the question do we write our own stories or are they written for us? I really enjoyed this book. It was a nice easy read and I’m looking forward to more from this author.
March 23, 2026
I absolutely loved this book. From the first few chapters, it completely stole my heart. It’s one of those stories that feels gentle and comforting, but at the same time keeps you turning the pages because you just need to know what happens next.
The writing style was beautiful without being heavy. It flowed so easily that I got completely lost in Wattlewood Ridge, and the soft magic woven through the story made it feel warm and almost nostalgic. I especially loved the quiet moments. The shared silences, slow mornings, and the way emotions were built gradually rather than rushed. The slow-burn romance felt genuine and earned, which made it even more satisfying.
Lilah’s character growth was one of my favourite parts. Watching her slowly rebuild herself, piece by piece, and learn to be seen for who she really is felt authentic and emotional. Her journey didn’t feel forced, it felt real, and I found myself really rooting for her. Lucas was the perfect balance to her too; steady, gentle, and exactly what the story needed.
This was a page-turner for me, but not in a dramatic, high-stakes way, more in a “just one more chapter before bed” way that turns into several. It’s soft, heartfelt, and quietly powerful.
I read this as an ARC, and I can already say I’ll be buying a paperback copy when it releases. It’s definitely a story I want to keep on my shelf and revisit. If you love small-town romance, slow-burn connections, and stories focused on healing, this one is absolutely worth picking up.
The writing style was beautiful without being heavy. It flowed so easily that I got completely lost in Wattlewood Ridge, and the soft magic woven through the story made it feel warm and almost nostalgic. I especially loved the quiet moments. The shared silences, slow mornings, and the way emotions were built gradually rather than rushed. The slow-burn romance felt genuine and earned, which made it even more satisfying.
Lilah’s character growth was one of my favourite parts. Watching her slowly rebuild herself, piece by piece, and learn to be seen for who she really is felt authentic and emotional. Her journey didn’t feel forced, it felt real, and I found myself really rooting for her. Lucas was the perfect balance to her too; steady, gentle, and exactly what the story needed.
This was a page-turner for me, but not in a dramatic, high-stakes way, more in a “just one more chapter before bed” way that turns into several. It’s soft, heartfelt, and quietly powerful.
I read this as an ARC, and I can already say I’ll be buying a paperback copy when it releases. It’s definitely a story I want to keep on my shelf and revisit. If you love small-town romance, slow-burn connections, and stories focused on healing, this one is absolutely worth picking up.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 10, 2026
I received this book from the author and Betty Agency in exchange for an honest review
Oh my gosh! I could not put this book down. I was flying through it needing to know what was going to happen next for Lilah and Lucas. I absolutely love this small town and the towns people. They are so welcoming and loving. I wish the bookstore was real because I so want to go in! I am already wanting book two. Like what am I going to do until it gets released? I can’t wait until I am back into this small town
Oh my gosh! I could not put this book down. I was flying through it needing to know what was going to happen next for Lilah and Lucas. I absolutely love this small town and the towns people. They are so welcoming and loving. I wish the bookstore was real because I so want to go in! I am already wanting book two. Like what am I going to do until it gets released? I can’t wait until I am back into this small town
June 24, 2026
Just popping in to report that I tabbed the absolute heck out of this book. It spoke directly to my cosy, magical-realism-loving heart. A story about healing, softness, and learning not to shrink yourself into a box just to make other people comfortable.
Shae’s words hit a little too close to home. This is the kind of book you read with your favourite candle lit, curled up beneath a blanket. Gentle, comforting, and quietly profound, it’s a reminder that taking up space is not the same thing as being too much.
Shae’s words hit a little too close to home. This is the kind of book you read with your favourite candle lit, curled up beneath a blanket. Gentle, comforting, and quietly profound, it’s a reminder that taking up space is not the same thing as being too much.
April 11, 2026
The fiction of us was such a delight to read! Beautifully written and completely immersive in such a cozy, romantic setting. The characters are deep and well rounded and I have fallen in love with Wattlewood Ridge! What an amazing debut for Miss Shae. I can not wait to follow this series for the following books! Love love love
June 15, 2026
Giving gilmore girls small town vibes
I had a great time reading "the fiction
of us" It was kinda giving me Gilmore Girls
Vibes small town,heartbreak growth,
and healing.
I loved the slow pace, how that is allowed
Me to be drawn in. Once I started reading
I was transported to wattlewood, I could
smell the coffee, baked goods
and the books
I had a great time reading "the fiction
of us" It was kinda giving me Gilmore Girls
Vibes small town,heartbreak growth,
and healing.
I loved the slow pace, how that is allowed
Me to be drawn in. Once I started reading
I was transported to wattlewood, I could
smell the coffee, baked goods
and the books
August 1, 2026
THIS BOOK 🥹✨
The Fiction of Us holds so much beauty, and it holds space for finding magic in the every day. To find calm in the chaos and choose to stay.
I just kept highlighting because there are so many lines that just captured and melted my heart! The poeticism, the small touches of whimsy everywhere. Truly, so breathtaking! Thank you, thank you for such a stunning read Shae ✨
PS: Monty is everything 🥰
The Fiction of Us holds so much beauty, and it holds space for finding magic in the every day. To find calm in the chaos and choose to stay.
I just kept highlighting because there are so many lines that just captured and melted my heart! The poeticism, the small touches of whimsy everywhere. Truly, so breathtaking! Thank you, thank you for such a stunning read Shae ✨
PS: Monty is everything 🥰
March 8, 2026
I received this book as an ARC and I appreciate being able to read this story. It was such a cute read. I enjoyed reading both points of view. This story is a cute small town romance and shows that love can turn up when you least expect it
April 23, 2026
I loved the story line of this book!
Initially it was really hard to get into it, I did find it a little difficult to want to pick it up and read it.
But I did push through, and it got better thankfully.
The ending had my heart very warm and fluffy 🥰
Initially it was really hard to get into it, I did find it a little difficult to want to pick it up and read it.
But I did push through, and it got better thankfully.
The ending had my heart very warm and fluffy 🥰
April 26, 2026
Really enjoyed this book. Loved the journey, the outline of the story and the characters. I didn't want to stop reading and think we need a spin off of other characters stories like Marley and Ezra. Would recommend.
August 12, 2026
This was such a cute fun read, anything small town romance you have my attention. I adored all the characters but especially the FMC and MMC. The chemistry between them both and how supportive they were of each other was chefs kiss
May 27, 2026
This book was everything I needed and more at the point in time I was reading it. It is such a beautiful story and there was emotional depth. A beautiful small town cozy bookshop vibe to the story and a strong female character who finally decided to put herself first. Loved it.
Review of advance copy received from Author
If you want a light, dual-POV romance with characters who dive into introspection with a touch of magical realism that’s all surrounded by a bookish atmosphere, this one’s for you.
Thank you to Shae Roberts and The Berry Agency for the ARC!
Small Spoiler Warning: slight spoilers regarding themes and format only, no spoilers for specific scenes or the ending
3.5/5 stars
Synopsis
The Fiction of Us, the debut adult romance novel by indie Australian author Shae Roberts, is a charming bit of author-ception as we follow the journey of Lilah Rayne, who is a romance author herself writing under a pseudonym. After a breakup following the launch of her newest book, her burnout takes her back home to her friends, her familiar job at the local café, and her flat right above it. What she wasn’t expecting to find, especially moving into the old cottage she adores, is the new bookstore owner, Lucas Castle.
Shared grief and a love for literature start to bring Lilah and Lucas together when events and conversations in her own life begin unfolding eerily similar to those in her latest novel, asking Lilah to wrestle with the concept of truth in all of its forms. What is real and what is fiction? What would it mean to be in an honest relationship? What would it mean to be honest about her identity? And can she figure it all out before a threat to her carefully compartmented life brings it crashing down?
I did enjoy this novel for the most part and think it’s a very nice debut, but there are some aspects that personally didn’t work as well for me. But let’s start with the positive aspects of this novel, which undoubtedly outnumber the negatives.
The Great
Emotionally Intelligent and Well-Developed MMC
I find an unfortunate trend in many romance novels where the male lead tends to have the depth and forethought of a piece of cardboard. His motivations are rarely explained, let alone aligned with a deeper thought process, and his emotions are simply reactionary and possessive. Lucas, our male lead in The Fiction of Us, couldn't be further from that description. Honestly, the chapters from his POV were some of my favorite parts of the book. They show us a man whose motivations, insecurities, actions, and attitudes all tie back to his past and his changing mental state, particularly influenced by how he is handling his grief. He is introverted and slightly brooding without having to be mean to others to demonstrate his depth. I know some aren’t fans of a dual-POV book, but I love them, and Roberts really takes advantage of the format to paint a portrait of a realistic yet different male archetype than we’re used to seeing: one who reflects on himself, is in touch with his inner world, and doesn’t take his strife out on the people around him.
Interesting and Fun Side Characters with Diverse Personalities
Getting to know the side characters was one of the best parts of this book. They are fun, quirky, get our nerdy love interests out of their shells, and are the oxygen that truly brings the small town to life. My favorites were the ones who strayed from archetypal expectation. For instance, Jasper, the MMC’s best friend, is not only rambunctious but also emotional, friendly, and a proud romance reader. I appreciate the care that Roberts takes to develop her male characters in particular, as they could've easily slipped into boring, traditionally masculine stereotypes otherwise.
Vivid and Varied Sensory Descriptions of Settings
The descriptions of each new setting were some of my favorite parts of the novel, and I think that sensory environmental descriptions are something that Roberts excels at. She really paints a picture that is unique in color palette, scent, sound, and surroundings for each place throughout the novel, and it easily transports the reader there.
A Love Letter to Authors and Readers
When discussing via her characters the realities of being an author and her attitude towards readers, Roberts’s own perspective shines through. From the real anxiety about reviews surrounding a new release to the complicated desire to connect with your readers when writing behind a pseudonym, Roberts’s opinions make Lilah’s authorial perspective all the more real. Not only does she put forth these ideas, but they impact how Lilah feels about herself and drive her future actions. The largest point that Roberts carries throughout the book is the transformative power of the written word, how it can make anyone feel seen at any life stage, and the love an author has for their supportive readers. The love and optimism towards the entire bookish community is palpable and is arguably a thank-you to its readers.
Unique Depth of Theme for a Small-Town Romance Novel
One of the more interesting aspects of this novel is the emotional depth given to the characters and the subsequent plot. Without spoiling too much, our leads are both experiencing grief. The interesting part is that they are grieving on different timelines and in different forms. Grief can look like honoring their legacy and sharing their memories, but it can also look like reclusion and self-doubt becuase they aren’t there to guide to you. I appreciate this exploration in the subplot that is done subtly but in an interesting way, as you can catch a lot of details about their parallel grief journeys if you pay a little attention.
In addition, both lead characters go through more introspection than I would expect from a light romance novel. I’d argue that because of this fact, this one is more character-driven than plot-driven, as their arcs unfold largely due to internal developments. Both characters question their behavior and attitudes regarding not only their budding relationshiop but of themselves as people in relation to their past and who they want to grow into. I appreciate the emotional intelligence given to these characters in a genre where plots are often made more dramatic by miscommunications ad misunderstandings.
A Calming Read That Still Maintains Stakes
There is undoubtedly tension and plot driving this book forward, but even in its serious scenes, a mellow, gentle tone remains as a throughline. If you’re looking for a light read that maintains your attention without spiking anxiety, with an atmosphere similar to that of Before The Coffee Gets Cold and Days at the Morisaki Bookshop, but in a story that puts romance at the forefront, this is it.
Adorable Illustrations
There are small illustrations to differentiate each chapter’s POV and throughout for scene breaks that all add to the whimsical, bookish atmosphere.
A Defense for Using Modern Vernacular in Novels
This novel, like many others both in and out of the romance genre, utilizes modern diction and slang in dialogue and internal monologue. This can be a detractor for some, and it used to be for me. However, novels have always done this and used the language of their time; we just don’t recognize that because most of us aren’t acquainted with the manner of speaking of previous eras across the world, so we chalk it all up to what we expect, and that is assuming it all is written formally. I posit that using modern diction appropriately has its place and importance as it contributes to the time capsule that is our current era of literature, and it thus a justified boon in most cases.
The Not-So-Great
Unearned Character Growth
While I do respect the level of interiority and introspection in this novel, the problem arises when a character solves all of their own issues without having any external reckoning from an obstacle or another character’s perspective that contrasts their own to induce that growth. All of Lilah’s friends are unwaveringly supportive of all of her thoughts and choices. She does face more concrete obstacles towards the latter third of the book, but prior to that, she is coming to character arc-defining realizations about herself completely on her own. If that was always possible, then why did she have such a stubborn and flawed internal narrative to begin with, if she could just talk herself into improving without anything having to occur to challenge that? Both lead characters are guilty of this, and both face a surpising lack of obstacles along with being treated with the ease of several plot conveniences that give them everything they could want. I wish Roberts risked giving both more external obstacles to really show us the difference between how they started the book as people versus how they ended it via their actions.
Lilah’s Underdeveloped Insecurity
I do like the paradox that is set up as Lilah’s desire to be honest in her work and relationships that is juxtaposed with her impulse to hide behind a pseudonym. However, the insecurity behind this fear is one of the major examples of telling rather than showing in this book. Lilah repeatedly lets us know that she is afraid that people will not like her if they see her true self. This is compounded when an ex-boyfriend tells her the same and insists that her actions contributed to their breakup. However, we never see Lilah act as anything but genuinely nice, compassionate, and respectful towards the people she interacts with. Her inner monologue does not even betray a sense of malice, anger, manipulation, or regret. I wish we got more scenes or interiority that explored any concrete examples of her doing wrong by someone in the past to justify why she feels this way about herself. Otherwise, we lose a sense of consequence during the tension of what would happen if Lilah were to reveal her true identity, because everyone in her personal life already loves her for who she is.
Redundant Interiority with Lilah’s Journal Entries
Unfortunately, the journal entries that close each of the chapters in Lilah’s POV may have been my least favorite aspect of the book. I tried to remain optimistic about them, but they just consistently repeated sentiments already conveyed in different (and sometimes the same) words used earlier in the chapter. I feel this could have been a much more effective aspect if each chapter itself explored less of Lilah’s interiority or left more ambiguity, thus making the closing journal entries revelations to the reader that add a different perspective on the events we just read or further depth to Lilah/her relationship with Lucas.
Unresolved Magical Realism
This one I add with a caveat, as the unexplained nature of the system/causes for the magical happenings in the novel might appeal to other readers who enjoy that supernatural air that surrounds the environment of a story. However, for me, the fact that there is no real resolution that ends up explaining the magical events that happen throughout the book left me feeling slightly unsatisfied. The setup for the magic system itself is quite cute and I don’t mind it at all, but the subsequent events themselves were framed almost as a mystery of “how is this happening?" that I was looking forward to solving, but it unfortunately just left me with more questions.
Small Spelling/Punctuation/Grammar Mistakes
These didn’t take away from the flow of the story too much and are to be expected on ARC copies. I assume these will be remedied in later editions.
Final Thoughts
The Fiction of Us was an overall pleasant experience for me, with its dreamy environments, engaging side characters, a well-done dual-POV, a clear love for the literary community, and explorations of human insecurity and grief. However, some redundancy of interiority, plot conveniences, and unearned character growth took me out of the story at times. While there were a few things that I didn’t love about this book, there were plenty of merits as well, and I can absolutely see there being an audience who thoroughly enjoys this novel. If you’re a romance reader, a bookish girlie, or someone looking for a light read that touches on deeper emotional themes while remaining optimistic and a little magical, I’d wager you’d enjoy this book. Given the magnetism that the side characters had in this novel, I would consider reading the future books about their stories that will be released in the Paper Hearts series. The Fiction of Us is ultimately a lovely debut by Shae Roberts—an author with vivid prose, emotionally developed characters, a clear passion for her work, and the potential to craft a great romance series.
Thank you to Shae Roberts and The Berry Agency for the ARC!
Small Spoiler Warning: slight spoilers regarding themes and format only, no spoilers for specific scenes or the ending
3.5/5 stars
Synopsis
The Fiction of Us, the debut adult romance novel by indie Australian author Shae Roberts, is a charming bit of author-ception as we follow the journey of Lilah Rayne, who is a romance author herself writing under a pseudonym. After a breakup following the launch of her newest book, her burnout takes her back home to her friends, her familiar job at the local café, and her flat right above it. What she wasn’t expecting to find, especially moving into the old cottage she adores, is the new bookstore owner, Lucas Castle.
Shared grief and a love for literature start to bring Lilah and Lucas together when events and conversations in her own life begin unfolding eerily similar to those in her latest novel, asking Lilah to wrestle with the concept of truth in all of its forms. What is real and what is fiction? What would it mean to be in an honest relationship? What would it mean to be honest about her identity? And can she figure it all out before a threat to her carefully compartmented life brings it crashing down?
I did enjoy this novel for the most part and think it’s a very nice debut, but there are some aspects that personally didn’t work as well for me. But let’s start with the positive aspects of this novel, which undoubtedly outnumber the negatives.
The Great
Emotionally Intelligent and Well-Developed MMC
I find an unfortunate trend in many romance novels where the male lead tends to have the depth and forethought of a piece of cardboard. His motivations are rarely explained, let alone aligned with a deeper thought process, and his emotions are simply reactionary and possessive. Lucas, our male lead in The Fiction of Us, couldn't be further from that description. Honestly, the chapters from his POV were some of my favorite parts of the book. They show us a man whose motivations, insecurities, actions, and attitudes all tie back to his past and his changing mental state, particularly influenced by how he is handling his grief. He is introverted and slightly brooding without having to be mean to others to demonstrate his depth. I know some aren’t fans of a dual-POV book, but I love them, and Roberts really takes advantage of the format to paint a portrait of a realistic yet different male archetype than we’re used to seeing: one who reflects on himself, is in touch with his inner world, and doesn’t take his strife out on the people around him.
Interesting and Fun Side Characters with Diverse Personalities
Getting to know the side characters was one of the best parts of this book. They are fun, quirky, get our nerdy love interests out of their shells, and are the oxygen that truly brings the small town to life. My favorites were the ones who strayed from archetypal expectation. For instance, Jasper, the MMC’s best friend, is not only rambunctious but also emotional, friendly, and a proud romance reader. I appreciate the care that Roberts takes to develop her male characters in particular, as they could've easily slipped into boring, traditionally masculine stereotypes otherwise.
Vivid and Varied Sensory Descriptions of Settings
The descriptions of each new setting were some of my favorite parts of the novel, and I think that sensory environmental descriptions are something that Roberts excels at. She really paints a picture that is unique in color palette, scent, sound, and surroundings for each place throughout the novel, and it easily transports the reader there.
A Love Letter to Authors and Readers
When discussing via her characters the realities of being an author and her attitude towards readers, Roberts’s own perspective shines through. From the real anxiety about reviews surrounding a new release to the complicated desire to connect with your readers when writing behind a pseudonym, Roberts’s opinions make Lilah’s authorial perspective all the more real. Not only does she put forth these ideas, but they impact how Lilah feels about herself and drive her future actions. The largest point that Roberts carries throughout the book is the transformative power of the written word, how it can make anyone feel seen at any life stage, and the love an author has for their supportive readers. The love and optimism towards the entire bookish community is palpable and is arguably a thank-you to its readers.
Unique Depth of Theme for a Small-Town Romance Novel
One of the more interesting aspects of this novel is the emotional depth given to the characters and the subsequent plot. Without spoiling too much, our leads are both experiencing grief. The interesting part is that they are grieving on different timelines and in different forms. Grief can look like honoring their legacy and sharing their memories, but it can also look like reclusion and self-doubt becuase they aren’t there to guide to you. I appreciate this exploration in the subplot that is done subtly but in an interesting way, as you can catch a lot of details about their parallel grief journeys if you pay a little attention.
In addition, both lead characters go through more introspection than I would expect from a light romance novel. I’d argue that because of this fact, this one is more character-driven than plot-driven, as their arcs unfold largely due to internal developments. Both characters question their behavior and attitudes regarding not only their budding relationshiop but of themselves as people in relation to their past and who they want to grow into. I appreciate the emotional intelligence given to these characters in a genre where plots are often made more dramatic by miscommunications ad misunderstandings.
A Calming Read That Still Maintains Stakes
There is undoubtedly tension and plot driving this book forward, but even in its serious scenes, a mellow, gentle tone remains as a throughline. If you’re looking for a light read that maintains your attention without spiking anxiety, with an atmosphere similar to that of Before The Coffee Gets Cold and Days at the Morisaki Bookshop, but in a story that puts romance at the forefront, this is it.
Adorable Illustrations
There are small illustrations to differentiate each chapter’s POV and throughout for scene breaks that all add to the whimsical, bookish atmosphere.
A Defense for Using Modern Vernacular in Novels
This novel, like many others both in and out of the romance genre, utilizes modern diction and slang in dialogue and internal monologue. This can be a detractor for some, and it used to be for me. However, novels have always done this and used the language of their time; we just don’t recognize that because most of us aren’t acquainted with the manner of speaking of previous eras across the world, so we chalk it all up to what we expect, and that is assuming it all is written formally. I posit that using modern diction appropriately has its place and importance as it contributes to the time capsule that is our current era of literature, and it thus a justified boon in most cases.
The Not-So-Great
Unearned Character Growth
While I do respect the level of interiority and introspection in this novel, the problem arises when a character solves all of their own issues without having any external reckoning from an obstacle or another character’s perspective that contrasts their own to induce that growth. All of Lilah’s friends are unwaveringly supportive of all of her thoughts and choices. She does face more concrete obstacles towards the latter third of the book, but prior to that, she is coming to character arc-defining realizations about herself completely on her own. If that was always possible, then why did she have such a stubborn and flawed internal narrative to begin with, if she could just talk herself into improving without anything having to occur to challenge that? Both lead characters are guilty of this, and both face a surpising lack of obstacles along with being treated with the ease of several plot conveniences that give them everything they could want. I wish Roberts risked giving both more external obstacles to really show us the difference between how they started the book as people versus how they ended it via their actions.
Lilah’s Underdeveloped Insecurity
I do like the paradox that is set up as Lilah’s desire to be honest in her work and relationships that is juxtaposed with her impulse to hide behind a pseudonym. However, the insecurity behind this fear is one of the major examples of telling rather than showing in this book. Lilah repeatedly lets us know that she is afraid that people will not like her if they see her true self. This is compounded when an ex-boyfriend tells her the same and insists that her actions contributed to their breakup. However, we never see Lilah act as anything but genuinely nice, compassionate, and respectful towards the people she interacts with. Her inner monologue does not even betray a sense of malice, anger, manipulation, or regret. I wish we got more scenes or interiority that explored any concrete examples of her doing wrong by someone in the past to justify why she feels this way about herself. Otherwise, we lose a sense of consequence during the tension of what would happen if Lilah were to reveal her true identity, because everyone in her personal life already loves her for who she is.
Redundant Interiority with Lilah’s Journal Entries
Unfortunately, the journal entries that close each of the chapters in Lilah’s POV may have been my least favorite aspect of the book. I tried to remain optimistic about them, but they just consistently repeated sentiments already conveyed in different (and sometimes the same) words used earlier in the chapter. I feel this could have been a much more effective aspect if each chapter itself explored less of Lilah’s interiority or left more ambiguity, thus making the closing journal entries revelations to the reader that add a different perspective on the events we just read or further depth to Lilah/her relationship with Lucas.
Unresolved Magical Realism
This one I add with a caveat, as the unexplained nature of the system/causes for the magical happenings in the novel might appeal to other readers who enjoy that supernatural air that surrounds the environment of a story. However, for me, the fact that there is no real resolution that ends up explaining the magical events that happen throughout the book left me feeling slightly unsatisfied. The setup for the magic system itself is quite cute and I don’t mind it at all, but the subsequent events themselves were framed almost as a mystery of “how is this happening?" that I was looking forward to solving, but it unfortunately just left me with more questions.
Small Spelling/Punctuation/Grammar Mistakes
These didn’t take away from the flow of the story too much and are to be expected on ARC copies. I assume these will be remedied in later editions.
Final Thoughts
The Fiction of Us was an overall pleasant experience for me, with its dreamy environments, engaging side characters, a well-done dual-POV, a clear love for the literary community, and explorations of human insecurity and grief. However, some redundancy of interiority, plot conveniences, and unearned character growth took me out of the story at times. While there were a few things that I didn’t love about this book, there were plenty of merits as well, and I can absolutely see there being an audience who thoroughly enjoys this novel. If you’re a romance reader, a bookish girlie, or someone looking for a light read that touches on deeper emotional themes while remaining optimistic and a little magical, I’d wager you’d enjoy this book. Given the magnetism that the side characters had in this novel, I would consider reading the future books about their stories that will be released in the Paper Hearts series. The Fiction of Us is ultimately a lovely debut by Shae Roberts—an author with vivid prose, emotionally developed characters, a clear passion for her work, and the potential to craft a great romance series.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 9, 2026
What a lovely love letter of Grief and Growth.
I read Shae’s story in the Sweet Treat Anthology and was so excited for The Fiction of Us to release and it didn’t disappoint!
Shae writes so beautifully and while this is different to what I’d usually read, I enjoyed it thoroughly. I could imagine Wattlewood Ridge so clearly and the story really played out like a movie to me. I can’t wait for the rest of the Paper Hearts series and the Easter eggs I noticed through out already has me giddy for them!
The impact of grief whether from the loss of a loved one or the breakdown of a relationship is so well done and it was so moving to read (even had ME tearing up here and there). I really understood Lilah and if you’re someone who’s ever lost yourself, you really feel with her. Lucas is my fav “bookish Bob the Builder” and his consistency and steadiness really makes me obsessed with him.
The characters are all loveable apart from Justin who deserves a punch (kindly). Shae really hit it out of the park with the characters in her book, none of them feel flat and there’s a feel of real to them and how they react.
Like Carol’s letters, this can definitely be an impactful book if it finds you just at the right time you need it. I’d highly recommend this to anyone especially if they relate to having to shrink themselves or felt like they lost their self somewhere along the way.
Fav quote- “ Letting go isn’t always loud, sometimes it’s a quiet choice you make at 2 a.m. with no audience”
I read Shae’s story in the Sweet Treat Anthology and was so excited for The Fiction of Us to release and it didn’t disappoint!
Shae writes so beautifully and while this is different to what I’d usually read, I enjoyed it thoroughly. I could imagine Wattlewood Ridge so clearly and the story really played out like a movie to me. I can’t wait for the rest of the Paper Hearts series and the Easter eggs I noticed through out already has me giddy for them!
The impact of grief whether from the loss of a loved one or the breakdown of a relationship is so well done and it was so moving to read (even had ME tearing up here and there). I really understood Lilah and if you’re someone who’s ever lost yourself, you really feel with her. Lucas is my fav “bookish Bob the Builder” and his consistency and steadiness really makes me obsessed with him.
The characters are all loveable apart from Justin who deserves a punch (kindly). Shae really hit it out of the park with the characters in her book, none of them feel flat and there’s a feel of real to them and how they react.
Like Carol’s letters, this can definitely be an impactful book if it finds you just at the right time you need it. I’d highly recommend this to anyone especially if they relate to having to shrink themselves or felt like they lost their self somewhere along the way.
Fav quote- “ Letting go isn’t always loud, sometimes it’s a quiet choice you make at 2 a.m. with no audience”
May 20, 2026
This book made me feel.
4.5⭐️
#Australian
#smalltown
4.5⭐️
#Australian
#smalltown
Read
March 20, 2026I am a proper cozy romance girly and this author managed to write the voices in my head and my story all in one. This book tugged me, squeezed me, hugged me and loved me in all the right places. Honestly, it was crazy in places how spooky it was to see bits of my life in it's pages. This book is perfect for that cozy rainy weekend read, with a sprinkle of the fates thrown in. XXX
March 15, 2026
3.5 stars
I was lucky enough to be give a ARC by The Berry Agency!
When they say this is a slow burn, they really mean it. I found the first half of the book to be quite slow, as there was a lot of character development which I did appreciate for the second half of the book.
I think most people can resonate with being with someone who makes you feel small and how going on your personal development journey to find yourself again can be a roller coaster.
The second half of the book that pace picked up more and I was more engaged with the characters and the story.
If you’re looking for spicy this isn’t for you. If you want a very easy read, that is beautiful written and reminds us to be kind to ourselves no matter what we are going through in life. This is for you
I was lucky enough to be give a ARC by The Berry Agency!
When they say this is a slow burn, they really mean it. I found the first half of the book to be quite slow, as there was a lot of character development which I did appreciate for the second half of the book.
I think most people can resonate with being with someone who makes you feel small and how going on your personal development journey to find yourself again can be a roller coaster.
The second half of the book that pace picked up more and I was more engaged with the characters and the story.
If you’re looking for spicy this isn’t for you. If you want a very easy read, that is beautiful written and reminds us to be kind to ourselves no matter what we are going through in life. This is for you
May 9, 2026
“This is a space safe for emotional outbursts, and apparently bookstore men who smell like character development”
What a fantastic book The Fiction of Us is!
I enjoyed every bit of this from the deep and sometimes heart wrenching moments reminding us that all we are looking for in life is for people to see us and love us for who we are - not having to hide behind another name - to the light hearted and fun filled moments.
Looking forward to learning more about the characters and people who live within Wattlewood Ridge.
What a fantastic book The Fiction of Us is!
I enjoyed every bit of this from the deep and sometimes heart wrenching moments reminding us that all we are looking for in life is for people to see us and love us for who we are - not having to hide behind another name - to the light hearted and fun filled moments.
Looking forward to learning more about the characters and people who live within Wattlewood Ridge.
May 22, 2026
The fiction of us
✍️ @shaeeslibrary
📚 @theberryagency
📅 11 April 2026
5 🌟
Recently, while I was on holidays at my parents, the weather turned bitter cold, so I decided to snuggle up with Molly under Mums homemade crochet throw rug with a cuppa and read. What l wasn't expecting, was not to move until l had completely finished this gem. Molly didn't move either 😆 Talk about perfection. I was hooked 💕
It's:
Slow burn,
Small town romance,
Inkwell & Ivy Bookshop,
Brew & Bloom Cafe,
A Bookshop cat,
Soft magic,
Second chances,
Choosing love,
Friendships,
Toxic breakup,
Found family,
Author Events,
Healing,
Secret pen name,
Slow mornings,
Secrets,
Magic wishing tree,
Reading nook chair,
Whimsical,
Gilmore Girl vibes,
Imposter Syndrome,
A beautiful debut,
Moving on,
Happy ever after,
Inheritance,
Warm, fuzzy feelings,
Heartfelt,
Local pub trivia night,
Small town markets,
Hallmark movie vibes,
When love turns up when you least expect it,
Grief & loss,
Dual POV,
A dreamy setting for a story,
And so mcuh more.
I have found my new book boyfriend in Lucas. 🥺
Lilah Rayne knows how to write a love story. Living one is another matter entirely.
After her breakup mirrors the novel she wrote under her secret pen name, Lilah retreats to Wattlewood Ridge—a small mountain town where bookstores matter, friendships run deep, and magic hums quietly beneath the surface. Back in her old apartment above Brew & Bloom Café, she plans to regroup, heal, and stay invisible.
Then she meets Lucas Castle.
Quiet, steady, and rebuilding the beloved Inkwell & Ivy bookstore, Lucas feels like someone Lilah already knows—like a story she once imagined and never meant to live. As their connection deepens through shared silences and slow mornings, the town begins returning pieces of Lilah she thought she’d lost.
But when her past threatens to expose everything she’s been hiding, Lilah must decide whether she’s brave enough to be seen. Not as the woman she writes, but as the one who feels.
I can't wait for Book 2, Shae. Xx
❓️ What was the last book that you couldn't let go of and had to read start to finish?
✍️ @shaeeslibrary
📚 @theberryagency
📅 11 April 2026
5 🌟
Recently, while I was on holidays at my parents, the weather turned bitter cold, so I decided to snuggle up with Molly under Mums homemade crochet throw rug with a cuppa and read. What l wasn't expecting, was not to move until l had completely finished this gem. Molly didn't move either 😆 Talk about perfection. I was hooked 💕
It's:
Slow burn,
Small town romance,
Inkwell & Ivy Bookshop,
Brew & Bloom Cafe,
A Bookshop cat,
Soft magic,
Second chances,
Choosing love,
Friendships,
Toxic breakup,
Found family,
Author Events,
Healing,
Secret pen name,
Slow mornings,
Secrets,
Magic wishing tree,
Reading nook chair,
Whimsical,
Gilmore Girl vibes,
Imposter Syndrome,
A beautiful debut,
Moving on,
Happy ever after,
Inheritance,
Warm, fuzzy feelings,
Heartfelt,
Local pub trivia night,
Small town markets,
Hallmark movie vibes,
When love turns up when you least expect it,
Grief & loss,
Dual POV,
A dreamy setting for a story,
And so mcuh more.
I have found my new book boyfriend in Lucas. 🥺
Lilah Rayne knows how to write a love story. Living one is another matter entirely.
After her breakup mirrors the novel she wrote under her secret pen name, Lilah retreats to Wattlewood Ridge—a small mountain town where bookstores matter, friendships run deep, and magic hums quietly beneath the surface. Back in her old apartment above Brew & Bloom Café, she plans to regroup, heal, and stay invisible.
Then she meets Lucas Castle.
Quiet, steady, and rebuilding the beloved Inkwell & Ivy bookstore, Lucas feels like someone Lilah already knows—like a story she once imagined and never meant to live. As their connection deepens through shared silences and slow mornings, the town begins returning pieces of Lilah she thought she’d lost.
But when her past threatens to expose everything she’s been hiding, Lilah must decide whether she’s brave enough to be seen. Not as the woman she writes, but as the one who feels.
I can't wait for Book 2, Shae. Xx
❓️ What was the last book that you couldn't let go of and had to read start to finish?
Review of advance copy received from Author
Rating
4.5/5
spice
1.5/5
If you are looking for a book with a slow-burning romance with magical realism, this is the book for you. The fiction of us is book 1 in the Paper Hearts series by Shae Roberts, releasing on 11/04/2026. Firstly, I would like to thank the Berry Agency and Shae Roberts for an ARC. Importantly, this book may contain triggering topics, so please check trigger warnings/content warnings before reading.
This was such an amazing cozy romance read, and the magical realism is my favourite part, adding so much to the plot and story. The family aspect was written so well, especially with Lilah and what she goes through, showing that sometimes family does not have to be blood; it can be your friends. Each of the tropes/ parts really worked together really well, creating such an amazing read that had me hooked from the start. The magical realism added so much curiosity and was just the perfect touch of magic; it felt as if it was all planned out from the book and a fated story.
Lucas and Lilah's relationship was written so beautifully, building a relationship from the ground up, from strangers to friends to lovers. I really love how it showed that they were so supportive of each other, and when they needed space, they did that . Lilah was my favourite character, hid who she was cause people did not believe in her and was scared to show her true self . It was amazing seeing her with her group of friends, not just build herself and her confidence back up (after the breakup) but seem to find her home, her safe space. Lucas character was written so beautifully, he is a true book boyfriend, bringing your favourite things over when you are sad and just being there for you. Is he the man of Lilah's book, you will have to read on release day?
I really enjoyed this book and highly recommend picking it up on release day. Happy reading.
4.5/5
spice
1.5/5
If you are looking for a book with a slow-burning romance with magical realism, this is the book for you. The fiction of us is book 1 in the Paper Hearts series by Shae Roberts, releasing on 11/04/2026. Firstly, I would like to thank the Berry Agency and Shae Roberts for an ARC. Importantly, this book may contain triggering topics, so please check trigger warnings/content warnings before reading.
This was such an amazing cozy romance read, and the magical realism is my favourite part, adding so much to the plot and story. The family aspect was written so well, especially with Lilah and what she goes through, showing that sometimes family does not have to be blood; it can be your friends. Each of the tropes/ parts really worked together really well, creating such an amazing read that had me hooked from the start. The magical realism added so much curiosity and was just the perfect touch of magic; it felt as if it was all planned out from the book and a fated story.
Lucas and Lilah's relationship was written so beautifully, building a relationship from the ground up, from strangers to friends to lovers. I really love how it showed that they were so supportive of each other, and when they needed space, they did that . Lilah was my favourite character, hid who she was cause people did not believe in her and was scared to show her true self . It was amazing seeing her with her group of friends, not just build herself and her confidence back up (after the breakup) but seem to find her home, her safe space. Lucas character was written so beautifully, he is a true book boyfriend, bringing your favourite things over when you are sad and just being there for you. Is he the man of Lilah's book, you will have to read on release day?
I really enjoyed this book and highly recommend picking it up on release day. Happy reading.
April 30, 2026
I’ve just finished The Fiction of Us by Shae Roberts, and I’ll start by saying this: I am absolutely not the target audience for a soft, slow-burn romance.
I’m usually over in the corner demanding plot, lore, magic, violence, political mutiny, betrayal, maybe a kingdom or two collapsing before breakfast. So naturally, I wandered into a small-town romance with soft magic and emotional healing like a raccoon in a tearoom.
That said, Shae Roberts can write. The book is sweet, gentle, and has a lovely sense of atmosphere. Wattlewood Ridge feels warm and inviting, and the story has that cosy, bookstore-and-coffee-shop charm that romance readers will probably adore.
For me, though, things felt a little too convenient. The characters often seemed to receive exactly what they needed at exactly the right time, and I was craving more conflict. Even the blackmailing ex-partner had a surprisingly tidy moment of self-awareness and exited with a note. Personally, I wanted him to storm in, embarrass himself spectacularly, force Lilah to finally stand her ground in front of everyone, and then have Lucas launch him out of the bookstore like a disgraced paperback. Sadly, my thirst for drama was denied.
Also, and I say this with affection, the cat had more personality than most of the cast. Absolute scene-stealer. Give that feline a spin-off.
Overall, this was cute, soft, and well-written, but not quite my cup of tea. Romance readers who enjoy small-town settings, second chances, gentle magic, and low-conflict emotional healing will likely get much more from it than I did.
For me, it’s a 3 out of 5 stars — charming, cosy, and sweet, but I personally needed a little more bite with my bookshop romance.
I’m usually over in the corner demanding plot, lore, magic, violence, political mutiny, betrayal, maybe a kingdom or two collapsing before breakfast. So naturally, I wandered into a small-town romance with soft magic and emotional healing like a raccoon in a tearoom.
That said, Shae Roberts can write. The book is sweet, gentle, and has a lovely sense of atmosphere. Wattlewood Ridge feels warm and inviting, and the story has that cosy, bookstore-and-coffee-shop charm that romance readers will probably adore.
For me, though, things felt a little too convenient. The characters often seemed to receive exactly what they needed at exactly the right time, and I was craving more conflict. Even the blackmailing ex-partner had a surprisingly tidy moment of self-awareness and exited with a note. Personally, I wanted him to storm in, embarrass himself spectacularly, force Lilah to finally stand her ground in front of everyone, and then have Lucas launch him out of the bookstore like a disgraced paperback. Sadly, my thirst for drama was denied.
Also, and I say this with affection, the cat had more personality than most of the cast. Absolute scene-stealer. Give that feline a spin-off.
Overall, this was cute, soft, and well-written, but not quite my cup of tea. Romance readers who enjoy small-town settings, second chances, gentle magic, and low-conflict emotional healing will likely get much more from it than I did.
For me, it’s a 3 out of 5 stars — charming, cosy, and sweet, but I personally needed a little more bite with my bookshop romance.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews