What do you think?
Rate this book
Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax
282 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 20, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I loved every page of this book. Dare I say, I enjoyed it even more than Jane Austen’s Emma. The prose and the wittiness of the dialogue were beautifully reminiscent of Austen’s writing. The characters were well-rounded and fleshed out, I have no complaints to be honest and I would love to read more historical regency romance novels by this author.
Thank you netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an early copy in exchange for an honest review.
I loved every page of this book. Dare I say, I enjoyed it even more than Jane Austen’s Emma. The prose and the wittiness of the dialogue were beautifully reminiscent of Austen’s writing. The characters were well-rounded and fleshed out, I have no complaints to be honest and I would love to read more historical regency romance novels by this author.
Thank you netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an early copy in exchange for an honest review.
April 26, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2 (4.5 stars, rounded down here)
As a lover of Jane Austen‘s Emma, I knew this voll would be a joy to read. And let me spoiler you…it totally was!!!
At first, Jane and Emma don’t get along very well. But after helping her, Emma realizes that she might’ve been wrong and sets out to help Jane find a husband so she doesn’t have to be a become a governess.
I really liked reading about Emma and Jane‘s story, especially as a person who previously enjoyed Jane Austen’s ‘Emma‘, it was relatively easy to know and remember the characters and purely enjoy the story. And I gotta say, this book displayed peak lesbian yearning! (a thing my lesbian heart loved so much). Plus, the enemies (or initial dislike) to lovers aspect was done really well too. I especially liked how nicely the different social classes were displayed and how this made Emma and Jane have miss communications. It really added to the realism of the story. Besides that, I also really liked how Sappho’s poems were mentioned (thanks to Aunt Hetty) and generally, I want to add that I adored how the author managed to keep the same atmosphere and tone as Jane Austen had in her works but still added their own flair.
Speaking of which writing, I really adored the writing and prose of the story. Especially after having read some books that didn’t really speak to me writing wise, reading this felt like a breeze of fresh air. I even wished the book would’ve been a big longer because I connected so well with the characters and just wanted to continue to live in their world (and see what more would happen and how aunt Hetty was doing haha). Besides that, I also really liked how the author displayed a lavender marriage in this book and how well it fit to the story. Especially because the times weren’t inclusive at all, it was really nice to read how the author managed to portray that but still managed to show how homosexual pairs were able to co-exist (even if it was somewhat in hiding).
Overall, I really liked this story, the characters and just the whole general atmosphere of the story!!!
And I still wish it would’ve been a bit longer.
A really well deserved 4.5 stars from me.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a free copy in exchange for an honest and voluntarily given review!
As a lover of Jane Austen‘s Emma, I knew this voll would be a joy to read. And let me spoiler you…it totally was!!!
At first, Jane and Emma don’t get along very well. But after helping her, Emma realizes that she might’ve been wrong and sets out to help Jane find a husband so she doesn’t have to be a become a governess.
I really liked reading about Emma and Jane‘s story, especially as a person who previously enjoyed Jane Austen’s ‘Emma‘, it was relatively easy to know and remember the characters and purely enjoy the story. And I gotta say, this book displayed peak lesbian yearning! (a thing my lesbian heart loved so much). Plus, the enemies (or initial dislike) to lovers aspect was done really well too. I especially liked how nicely the different social classes were displayed and how this made Emma and Jane have miss communications. It really added to the realism of the story. Besides that, I also really liked how Sappho’s poems were mentioned (thanks to Aunt Hetty) and generally, I want to add that I adored how the author managed to keep the same atmosphere and tone as Jane Austen had in her works but still added their own flair.
Speaking of which writing, I really adored the writing and prose of the story. Especially after having read some books that didn’t really speak to me writing wise, reading this felt like a breeze of fresh air. I even wished the book would’ve been a big longer because I connected so well with the characters and just wanted to continue to live in their world (and see what more would happen and how aunt Hetty was doing haha). Besides that, I also really liked how the author displayed a lavender marriage in this book and how well it fit to the story. Especially because the times weren’t inclusive at all, it was really nice to read how the author managed to portray that but still managed to show how homosexual pairs were able to co-exist (even if it was somewhat in hiding).
Overall, I really liked this story, the characters and just the whole general atmosphere of the story!!!
And I still wish it would’ve been a bit longer.
A really well deserved 4.5 stars from me.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a free copy in exchange for an honest and voluntarily given review!
Review of advance copy received from Author
While I am not one for Austen fanfic, this book was delightful. The way the author twisted the original into a sapphic love story was clever. It was also well written, mimicking the style of Jane Austen.
And finally, a romance novelist that gets it right in terms of how circumspect with shenanigans respectable unmarried ladies have to be.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
And finally, a romance novelist that gets it right in terms of how circumspect with shenanigans respectable unmarried ladies have to be.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 26, 2026
If you have read Jane Austen’s Emma and expect this book to be true to the story, then don’t read it. It is very different except for the fact that Emma is just as obnoxious as in the original story. I quickly turned off my expectations and saw this as something very different and then a very enjoyable read, the 2nd half my favourite when you really know all characters.
It is very enjoyable to read about how Emma tries to matchmake a very reluctant Jane with Frank Churchill. Jane has no interest in him though, but only eyes for Emma, does Emma feel the same? How they slowly fall for each other and all the complications because of Emma’s stupid ways is quite something to read about.
It is very enjoyable to read about how Emma tries to matchmake a very reluctant Jane with Frank Churchill. Jane has no interest in him though, but only eyes for Emma, does Emma feel the same? How they slowly fall for each other and all the complications because of Emma’s stupid ways is quite something to read about.
May 25, 2026
This is probably a 4.25-4.5 but I’m rounding up because I absolutely adore this trend of reinterpreting stories and characters from classic literature through a queer lens.
This was a very fun reinterpretation of Emma where she realises that her avoidance of marriage might be something to do her preference for the fairer sex, and for Jane Fairfax in particular.
I thought the author really nailed the characters voices, Emma’s in particular with her brand of charm and entitledness. V fun. Definitely recommend.
This was a very fun reinterpretation of Emma where she realises that her avoidance of marriage might be something to do her preference for the fairer sex, and for Jane Fairfax in particular.
I thought the author really nailed the characters voices, Emma’s in particular with her brand of charm and entitledness. V fun. Definitely recommend.
May 20, 2026
4.5⭐️ I loved Jane Austen’s Emma when I was younger and I was intrigued to read this story! I received an advance review copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I felt the characters were well developed and easy to read. I enjoyed the banter between Jane and Emma, their enemies to lovers romance fleshed out and relatable (in a sense of the times).
I enjoyed how the author kept to the times, Jane Austen style, and also established same sex couples finding their hea.
Recommend!
I felt the characters were well developed and easy to read. I enjoyed the banter between Jane and Emma, their enemies to lovers romance fleshed out and relatable (in a sense of the times).
I enjoyed how the author kept to the times, Jane Austen style, and also established same sex couples finding their hea.
Recommend!
Read
February 19, 2026Miss Woudhouse and Miss Fairfax offers a tender and emotionally layered exploration of connection, misunderstanding, and quiet longing. Despite moving in the same social circles, Emma Woodhouse initially sees Jane Fairfax as cold and distant—her accomplishments in art and music serving as an uncomfortable reminder of Emma’s own unused potential. What begins as irritation slowly transforms into understanding when Emma is forced into closer proximity with Jane and discovers that what she mistook for reserve is, in fact, vulnerability.
The novel is overall very well written, with the historical setting beautifully woven into the story. The restrictions of the time—what women are permitted to do, what they must sacrifice, and how much significance a simple gift can carry—are subtly but powerfully portrayed. These societal boundaries give emotional weight to every interaction.
The connection that gradually develops between Emma and Jane feels authentic and earned. Their misunderstandings are just as convincing as their growing intimacy, which makes their relationship feel human rather than idealized. The dual perspectives are especially effective, offering insight into both women’s internal struggles and deepening the emotional impact of their evolving bond.
It’s a thoughtful, character-driven story where longing simmers beneath propriety, and where love grows not from grand gestures, but from quiet recognition and understanding.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The novel is overall very well written, with the historical setting beautifully woven into the story. The restrictions of the time—what women are permitted to do, what they must sacrifice, and how much significance a simple gift can carry—are subtly but powerfully portrayed. These societal boundaries give emotional weight to every interaction.
The connection that gradually develops between Emma and Jane feels authentic and earned. Their misunderstandings are just as convincing as their growing intimacy, which makes their relationship feel human rather than idealized. The dual perspectives are especially effective, offering insight into both women’s internal struggles and deepening the emotional impact of their evolving bond.
It’s a thoughtful, character-driven story where longing simmers beneath propriety, and where love grows not from grand gestures, but from quiet recognition and understanding.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy
Thank you BookSirens and author Maisie Jardelle for this ARC opportunity. I am very happy to share my honest review.
I absolutely love historic sapphic romance and am particularly fond of Regency era books! The summary blurb was very enticing and I was so excited to read this. This book was a joy to read and I had a tough time putting it down. The book is described as a retelling of Jane Austen's Emma and I must confess that I've never read that so I came in really not having any preconceived notions about the book. In truth, I think that I had a greater appreciation of this story having never read Austen's version because I could appreciate the sweet story I read without any sort of constant comparison. This book is a wonderful slow burn romance with so much sensuality between two women who, despite moving in similar circles, seem so different. It was a charming and satisfying historical sapphic romance that I very much enjoyed.
This story is messy and indulgent all at once. Emma Woodhouse is wealthy and often the matchmaker within her social circle. She is intelligent and enjoys a life of wealth and social privilege but that doesn't mean she's happy. Her insistence on matchmaking feels like emotional avoidance. She enjoys helping others and it doesn't hurt that it forces her to ignore herself and her own emotional messiness and what is lacking in her life. She's not a fan of Jane Fairfax but for no real reason. Of course that is quickly remedied as the two begin to spend more time together. Sure, Emma is supposed to help Jane find a suitable husband but somewhere along the way everything changes. Emma begins to see that Jane is not at all cold but rather painfully shy, very sweet and incredibly sincere. She stirs something in Emma that she can't quite name at first. These new feelings make finding Jane a husband impossible as every suitor feels wrong and fills her with jealousy. In time it was clear that both women were feeling something so much more for each other. The attraction is there and the desire grows with every interaction.
Jane and Emma are both enjoyable characters. They are both strong willed, intelligent and simply lovely. I could see that they genuinely began to have real feelings for one another and it was so rewarding. The longing and pining was so well developed and I greatly enjoyed that angst and tension. However, the moments where they gave in were the most satisfying. I loved the dynamic between Emman and Jane. It was really sweet to see them fall and the sweet innocence of first love made me smile. The chemistry is fantastic and there are multiple scenes that will dance around in my head for the foreseeable future. I loved the addition of the steamy scene so much! The spice was tender and authentic but definitely added so much depth to the love story. This was a time where we were women weren't allowed to love other women and watching these two beautiful women fall in love and act on it truly melted my heart. This book was so much more than a romance but a journey in self discovery and exploration. Emma and Jane find something in each other they never believed possible. I fell in love right along with them.
This is a great book by Maisie Jardelle and I really enjoyed her writing style. I will absolutely look for more by this author. The writing is appropriate for the time period but embodies a clear and easy to read prose. The stylee Jardelle implements is unique and enjoyable. She uses the structural restraint of Regency era fiction and infuses it with a modern feel complete with deep emotion and a touch spicy intensity. I appreciated the careful attention to detail when describing the elements associated with the time period. The pacing works so well as the gradual development of real feelings was realistic and believable. I personally really enjoyed the conversations and interactions between Emma and Jane a great deal. Jardelle's use of dialogue is special and it carries with it a ton of subtext which makes the story that much more compelling. I found both Emma and Jane to be very likeable characters who nestled their way into my heart. Jardelle created dynamic and deep characters which really made the story come alive.
This book was so enjoyable to read and I am definitely adding it to my re-read list. This was a wonderful historical sapphic romance with a distinctive tone and voice. The Regency era setting adds so much to the story but the characters are what makes it shine. Emma and Jane transcend social expectation and embrace a sweet love that will make you swoon. I highly recommend this book for any lovers of sapphic romance who appreciate strong characters and deep connections.
I absolutely love historic sapphic romance and am particularly fond of Regency era books! The summary blurb was very enticing and I was so excited to read this. This book was a joy to read and I had a tough time putting it down. The book is described as a retelling of Jane Austen's Emma and I must confess that I've never read that so I came in really not having any preconceived notions about the book. In truth, I think that I had a greater appreciation of this story having never read Austen's version because I could appreciate the sweet story I read without any sort of constant comparison. This book is a wonderful slow burn romance with so much sensuality between two women who, despite moving in similar circles, seem so different. It was a charming and satisfying historical sapphic romance that I very much enjoyed.
This story is messy and indulgent all at once. Emma Woodhouse is wealthy and often the matchmaker within her social circle. She is intelligent and enjoys a life of wealth and social privilege but that doesn't mean she's happy. Her insistence on matchmaking feels like emotional avoidance. She enjoys helping others and it doesn't hurt that it forces her to ignore herself and her own emotional messiness and what is lacking in her life. She's not a fan of Jane Fairfax but for no real reason. Of course that is quickly remedied as the two begin to spend more time together. Sure, Emma is supposed to help Jane find a suitable husband but somewhere along the way everything changes. Emma begins to see that Jane is not at all cold but rather painfully shy, very sweet and incredibly sincere. She stirs something in Emma that she can't quite name at first. These new feelings make finding Jane a husband impossible as every suitor feels wrong and fills her with jealousy. In time it was clear that both women were feeling something so much more for each other. The attraction is there and the desire grows with every interaction.
Jane and Emma are both enjoyable characters. They are both strong willed, intelligent and simply lovely. I could see that they genuinely began to have real feelings for one another and it was so rewarding. The longing and pining was so well developed and I greatly enjoyed that angst and tension. However, the moments where they gave in were the most satisfying. I loved the dynamic between Emman and Jane. It was really sweet to see them fall and the sweet innocence of first love made me smile. The chemistry is fantastic and there are multiple scenes that will dance around in my head for the foreseeable future. I loved the addition of the steamy scene so much! The spice was tender and authentic but definitely added so much depth to the love story. This was a time where we were women weren't allowed to love other women and watching these two beautiful women fall in love and act on it truly melted my heart. This book was so much more than a romance but a journey in self discovery and exploration. Emma and Jane find something in each other they never believed possible. I fell in love right along with them.
This is a great book by Maisie Jardelle and I really enjoyed her writing style. I will absolutely look for more by this author. The writing is appropriate for the time period but embodies a clear and easy to read prose. The stylee Jardelle implements is unique and enjoyable. She uses the structural restraint of Regency era fiction and infuses it with a modern feel complete with deep emotion and a touch spicy intensity. I appreciated the careful attention to detail when describing the elements associated with the time period. The pacing works so well as the gradual development of real feelings was realistic and believable. I personally really enjoyed the conversations and interactions between Emma and Jane a great deal. Jardelle's use of dialogue is special and it carries with it a ton of subtext which makes the story that much more compelling. I found both Emma and Jane to be very likeable characters who nestled their way into my heart. Jardelle created dynamic and deep characters which really made the story come alive.
This book was so enjoyable to read and I am definitely adding it to my re-read list. This was a wonderful historical sapphic romance with a distinctive tone and voice. The Regency era setting adds so much to the story but the characters are what makes it shine. Emma and Jane transcend social expectation and embrace a sweet love that will make you swoon. I highly recommend this book for any lovers of sapphic romance who appreciate strong characters and deep connections.
June 2, 2026
Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax by Maisie Jardelle.
Emma Woodhouse has never been able to warm to Jane Fairfax. They move in the same circles, they're around the same age, and yet something about Jane — her composure, her quiet brilliance at the pianoforte and in everything else she turns her hand to — has always rubbed Emma the wrong way. It doesn't help that Jane's accomplishments are a constant reminder of what Emma might have achieved herself, had she spent less time orchestrating other people's love lives and more time applying her own considerable talents. But when Emma finds herself doing Jane an unexpected kindness, she's caught off guard by the genuine warmth she receives in return. What she had always read as coldness, she begins to understand, was really just shyness. With Jane facing a future as a governess unless a good match can be found, Emma throws herself into the task of finding her one — only to discover, the more time she spends with Jane, that her heart isn't quite in it for the reasons she thought.
I absolutely loved this author's debut. It's a wonderful mix of correctly observed Regency sensibilities — the kind that makes you feel like you've stepped straight into a Jane Austen novel — but with sapphic characters at the heart of it. And there's no fade to black here either. We're right there alongside Emma and Jane as they figure it all out, navigating feelings neither of them has the language for in a world that certainly doesn't hand them a roadmap. The humor Jardelle weaves through the story is a genuine delight, and the cast of characters is as unforgettable as anything Austen herself might have dreamed up. I hope Jardelle keeps publishing these queer historical gems — this is exactly the kind of book the genre needs more of.
5 Stars
Emma Woodhouse has never been able to warm to Jane Fairfax. They move in the same circles, they're around the same age, and yet something about Jane — her composure, her quiet brilliance at the pianoforte and in everything else she turns her hand to — has always rubbed Emma the wrong way. It doesn't help that Jane's accomplishments are a constant reminder of what Emma might have achieved herself, had she spent less time orchestrating other people's love lives and more time applying her own considerable talents. But when Emma finds herself doing Jane an unexpected kindness, she's caught off guard by the genuine warmth she receives in return. What she had always read as coldness, she begins to understand, was really just shyness. With Jane facing a future as a governess unless a good match can be found, Emma throws herself into the task of finding her one — only to discover, the more time she spends with Jane, that her heart isn't quite in it for the reasons she thought.
I absolutely loved this author's debut. It's a wonderful mix of correctly observed Regency sensibilities — the kind that makes you feel like you've stepped straight into a Jane Austen novel — but with sapphic characters at the heart of it. And there's no fade to black here either. We're right there alongside Emma and Jane as they figure it all out, navigating feelings neither of them has the language for in a world that certainly doesn't hand them a roadmap. The humor Jardelle weaves through the story is a genuine delight, and the cast of characters is as unforgettable as anything Austen herself might have dreamed up. I hope Jardelle keeps publishing these queer historical gems — this is exactly the kind of book the genre needs more of.
5 Stars
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
(rounded up from 4.5)
I love a good queer retelling of a regency story, particularly one of Jane Austen's works. I have to immediately appreciate that the writing style, particularly with the dialogue, is as close to Jane Austen's witty style as I have seen in a romance retelling, which infinitely increased my enjoyment of this book.
One of the worst things that can happen to a romance is when the main characters are not interesting or unsympathetic and this book certainly avoids that trap. Emma and Jane are interesting and well-fleshed-out characters of opposing financial circumstances and personalities. Emma Woodhouse is witty, outgoing, outspoken, and absolutely not modest about her own charms while Jane is shy, intelligent, and deeply traumatised by a life of having others determine the course of her life, since she has no fortune of her own. The two start off very believably at odds due to their childhood natures and grow to understand each other and fall in love in a very organic fashion, which is even more impressive due to it being a regency romance.
I must also appreciate that the book sticks to the primary story beats from Emma to make it a true retelling that takes into account the generally invisible world of queer men and women in this time period and how they are incredibly restricted by societal rules for class, rank, and money even for friendships.
I had a wonderful time and found this a very easy read, deeply engaging, and often quite charmingly funny as Emma has a bit of an ego and Jane is very much good for her once they become more candid in their conversations.
I love a good queer retelling of a regency story, particularly one of Jane Austen's works. I have to immediately appreciate that the writing style, particularly with the dialogue, is as close to Jane Austen's witty style as I have seen in a romance retelling, which infinitely increased my enjoyment of this book.
One of the worst things that can happen to a romance is when the main characters are not interesting or unsympathetic and this book certainly avoids that trap. Emma and Jane are interesting and well-fleshed-out characters of opposing financial circumstances and personalities. Emma Woodhouse is witty, outgoing, outspoken, and absolutely not modest about her own charms while Jane is shy, intelligent, and deeply traumatised by a life of having others determine the course of her life, since she has no fortune of her own. The two start off very believably at odds due to their childhood natures and grow to understand each other and fall in love in a very organic fashion, which is even more impressive due to it being a regency romance.
I must also appreciate that the book sticks to the primary story beats from Emma to make it a true retelling that takes into account the generally invisible world of queer men and women in this time period and how they are incredibly restricted by societal rules for class, rank, and money even for friendships.
I had a wonderful time and found this a very easy read, deeply engaging, and often quite charmingly funny as Emma has a bit of an ego and Jane is very much good for her once they become more candid in their conversations.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax has all I could want from a sapphic retelling of Emma. It captures all the social workings and balance between desires, prestige, and reserved dignity in the most English way possible. There are of course the pelisse, reticules, carriage rides, nuncheon, the stays!
Emma and Jane come together as adults after missed chances of friendship in their youths, and while Jane's coldness to Emma seems justified, I never really got Emma's issues with Jane. Also, for all of Harriet's dislike of Emma over a misunderstood incident in their youth, the scene where it comes to light could have used more build up.
All in all, I could have used more of the initial tension between them (especially Jane) and their sexual awakening. The abruptness from their first physical contact to the intense declaration of feelings felt bewildering, but also fairly standard with regency romances. However, the payoff was strong and Jane standing up for herself was a welcome change of pace.
While it does not linger on the societal norms and heteronormativity, it doesn't deny them, and while Emma and Jane do find their queer found families, it doesn't seem forced or unbelievable. So, in that regard I find it strikes just the right balance of not pretending the time period was different, but not not being a total downer, either. Thank you ARC provided by Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op for the book for review consideration via NetGalley and it is written with full honesty.
Emma and Jane come together as adults after missed chances of friendship in their youths, and while Jane's coldness to Emma seems justified, I never really got Emma's issues with Jane. Also, for all of Harriet's dislike of Emma over a misunderstood incident in their youth, the scene where it comes to light could have used more build up.
All in all, I could have used more of the initial tension between them (especially Jane) and their sexual awakening. The abruptness from their first physical contact to the intense declaration of feelings felt bewildering, but also fairly standard with regency romances. However, the payoff was strong and Jane standing up for herself was a welcome change of pace.
While it does not linger on the societal norms and heteronormativity, it doesn't deny them, and while Emma and Jane do find their queer found families, it doesn't seem forced or unbelievable. So, in that regard I find it strikes just the right balance of not pretending the time period was different, but not not being a total downer, either. Thank you ARC provided by Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op for the book for review consideration via NetGalley and it is written with full honesty.
Review of advance copy
To be honest, I am a fan of Jane Austen, so this book fell easily into my reading genre, but, having said that, oftentimes the attempts to mirror Austen's cultural awareness and character development falls short. This book did not! This story mixes two women from vastly different economic backgrounds and social standings, but who, at their core, have so much more in common than divides them. The story involves reminding the reader about how class wars and attitudes greatly impacted a woman's ability to live separate from her parents' demand for marriage, love be damned! Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax meet in a fortuitous manner, both related to their love of designing hats for the upper-crust, of which one is a member and the other just a common hat maker. This book reminded me of the conditions in which so many people lived back then, and still live today, to be honest. Many of the discussions and issues faced by these two woman still exist today, maybe not surrounding hat making, but definitely amongst the classist society that still exits and the belief that the people who struggle somehow brought it upon themselves. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and readily recommend it to any Jane Austen enthusiast. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
So lovely
Emma and Jane don’t get on at first, especially as Emma finds Jane very cold but after helping her with something realises she might have been wrong. Determined to help Jane marry well, Emma sets out to find her the perfect husband to spare her having to become a governess but finds herself hoping she could be with Jane instead.
This is marketed as a retelling of Emma by Jane Austen, which I have never read, but if it is along the same lines as this story, I think I should. This had the perfect amount of tension between them to start that when they were sort of forced together, it meant Emma was resistant to Jane for the longest time. She really tried to fight anything she was feeling for her. When she realised she quite liked Jane, then she got a bit pouty and sulky about her showing any interest to anyone else, which was quite amusing.
When it was revealed that Jane was actually shy and reserved and that’s why Emma hadn’t taken much of a liking to her, it made sense why Emma had thought as she had. The behaviour from Jane did come across that way. My heart broke for them both a bit when Jane did go away to be a governess, but I had no doubt Emma would find a way to bring her back to her.
Really enjoyable and a lovely secret romance between two women at a time where it wasn’t that likely.
Emma and Jane don’t get on at first, especially as Emma finds Jane very cold but after helping her with something realises she might have been wrong. Determined to help Jane marry well, Emma sets out to find her the perfect husband to spare her having to become a governess but finds herself hoping she could be with Jane instead.
This is marketed as a retelling of Emma by Jane Austen, which I have never read, but if it is along the same lines as this story, I think I should. This had the perfect amount of tension between them to start that when they were sort of forced together, it meant Emma was resistant to Jane for the longest time. She really tried to fight anything she was feeling for her. When she realised she quite liked Jane, then she got a bit pouty and sulky about her showing any interest to anyone else, which was quite amusing.
When it was revealed that Jane was actually shy and reserved and that’s why Emma hadn’t taken much of a liking to her, it made sense why Emma had thought as she had. The behaviour from Jane did come across that way. My heart broke for them both a bit when Jane did go away to be a governess, but I had no doubt Emma would find a way to bring her back to her.
Really enjoyable and a lovely secret romance between two women at a time where it wasn’t that likely.
Review of advance copy
A Delightful, Tender Reimagining of Austen’s World
Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax by Maisie Jardelle is an absolute delight—a sparkling, heartfelt reimagining that breathes fresh life into two beloved Austen heroines. Jardelle captures the wit, charm, and social nuance of the Regency era beautifully while weaving in a romance that feels both authentic and deeply moving.
Emma Woodhouse’s confidence and vivacity shine just as brightly as ever, but here we get to see her vulnerability in a new light. Paired with the quiet strength and complexity of Jane Fairfax, the dynamic between them is captivating—full of tension, longing, and ultimately, emotional payoff that feels well-earned.
The writing strikes a perfect balance: elegant and reminiscent of Austen’s voice without ever feeling imitative or heavy. The chemistry between Emma and Jane builds naturally, making every glance and conversation feel significant. It’s a gentle, character-driven story that rewards patience with richly satisfying emotional depth.
Perfect for fans of Emma and readers who love sapphic historical romance, this novel is both a loving homage and a beautifully original story in its own right. I closed it smiling—and immediately wishing for more.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax by Maisie Jardelle is an absolute delight—a sparkling, heartfelt reimagining that breathes fresh life into two beloved Austen heroines. Jardelle captures the wit, charm, and social nuance of the Regency era beautifully while weaving in a romance that feels both authentic and deeply moving.
Emma Woodhouse’s confidence and vivacity shine just as brightly as ever, but here we get to see her vulnerability in a new light. Paired with the quiet strength and complexity of Jane Fairfax, the dynamic between them is captivating—full of tension, longing, and ultimately, emotional payoff that feels well-earned.
The writing strikes a perfect balance: elegant and reminiscent of Austen’s voice without ever feeling imitative or heavy. The chemistry between Emma and Jane builds naturally, making every glance and conversation feel significant. It’s a gentle, character-driven story that rewards patience with richly satisfying emotional depth.
Perfect for fans of Emma and readers who love sapphic historical romance, this novel is both a loving homage and a beautifully original story in its own right. I closed it smiling—and immediately wishing for more.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 8, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
I’ve never read Emma by Jane Austen, so I don’t know anything about the characters. I do think if I knew the original, it might have been easier for me to follow all the characters that were introduced quickly. I found myself trying to remember who was who and how they were related to one another.
Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax is a perfect example of sapphic yearning! The author does such an amazing job at depicting it. I liked that the lack of knowledge the women had when it came to having sex was explored. It was realistic and entertaining to see the two discover pleasure. The angst was also well done! I loved all the characters and I love when I fall in love with side characters. Aunt Hetty was quirky and such a wonderful addition to the story.
I do feel like the book just ended. It ended on a good note but I would’ve liked a little more of a wrap up. It felt like there could’ve been more. I love epilogues and while the last couple of chapters spanned a couple of weeks, I would’ve liked to see more into their future.
Overall it was a great historical romance. I do not know how true to the original story this version was, but the yearning and angst was *chefs kiss*
I’ve never read Emma by Jane Austen, so I don’t know anything about the characters. I do think if I knew the original, it might have been easier for me to follow all the characters that were introduced quickly. I found myself trying to remember who was who and how they were related to one another.
Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax is a perfect example of sapphic yearning! The author does such an amazing job at depicting it. I liked that the lack of knowledge the women had when it came to having sex was explored. It was realistic and entertaining to see the two discover pleasure. The angst was also well done! I loved all the characters and I love when I fall in love with side characters. Aunt Hetty was quirky and such a wonderful addition to the story.
I do feel like the book just ended. It ended on a good note but I would’ve liked a little more of a wrap up. It felt like there could’ve been more. I love epilogues and while the last couple of chapters spanned a couple of weeks, I would’ve liked to see more into their future.
Overall it was a great historical romance. I do not know how true to the original story this version was, but the yearning and angst was *chefs kiss*
Review of advance copy received from Author
For fans new to Austen or those seeking a steamier variation.
This reinterpretation has its own original take, complete with “surging desires.” The text delivers the expected highs and lows, confident in its revised approach from a bathing machine encounter, a churchyard, the poetry of Sappho, a length of red ribbon, and a gift in a pine box.
The dining, drawing room, and ballroom exchanges have the edge that a reader expects, like: “Never marry?” exclaimed Mrs Campbell. “What a peculiar notion!” Expectations and the unexpected will clash in Highbury, Hartfield, and White Hart [The Coles], complicated by the gamut of social position, which the author writes about especially well.
Enjoy Jane and Emma’s complex exploratory journey as delicious flutters stir their chests and share the hope that whatever eventuates, “it should involve a lot of kissing.”
There is delightful attention to period detail, well-woven subplots, and fully developed secondary characters whose roles and actions deepen the novel's steamy themes. An engaging read that delivers.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This reinterpretation has its own original take, complete with “surging desires.” The text delivers the expected highs and lows, confident in its revised approach from a bathing machine encounter, a churchyard, the poetry of Sappho, a length of red ribbon, and a gift in a pine box.
The dining, drawing room, and ballroom exchanges have the edge that a reader expects, like: “Never marry?” exclaimed Mrs Campbell. “What a peculiar notion!” Expectations and the unexpected will clash in Highbury, Hartfield, and White Hart [The Coles], complicated by the gamut of social position, which the author writes about especially well.
Enjoy Jane and Emma’s complex exploratory journey as delicious flutters stir their chests and share the hope that whatever eventuates, “it should involve a lot of kissing.”
There is delightful attention to period detail, well-woven subplots, and fully developed secondary characters whose roles and actions deepen the novel's steamy themes. An engaging read that delivers.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
OMG, THE YEARNING!
I had to start with that, because truthfully, the longing and yearning in this historical romance are absolutely top-tier.
The book offers a wonderful representation of queer love in an era where propriety and modesty were of the utmost importance. Seeing Emma use and bend society’s rules to her will is incredibly empowering and heartwarming, especially when it comes to Jane.
The relationship is a slow burn, but you can clearly see the mutual pining and love blossoming from the very beginning. I did find Emma a bit obtuse and self-centered at times, but she redeems herself by the end. I found myself feeling proud of her and her growth.
An honorable mention must go to the prose, which I thoroughly enjoyed. Even though English is not my first language, it flowed beautifully, and the period-appropriate dialogue was stunning.
If you are a fan of historical queer romance, the rich girl/poor girl trope, forbidden love, and spicy scenes, this book is definitely for you.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an early copy in exchange for an honest review.
I had to start with that, because truthfully, the longing and yearning in this historical romance are absolutely top-tier.
The book offers a wonderful representation of queer love in an era where propriety and modesty were of the utmost importance. Seeing Emma use and bend society’s rules to her will is incredibly empowering and heartwarming, especially when it comes to Jane.
The relationship is a slow burn, but you can clearly see the mutual pining and love blossoming from the very beginning. I did find Emma a bit obtuse and self-centered at times, but she redeems herself by the end. I found myself feeling proud of her and her growth.
An honorable mention must go to the prose, which I thoroughly enjoyed. Even though English is not my first language, it flowed beautifully, and the period-appropriate dialogue was stunning.
If you are a fan of historical queer romance, the rich girl/poor girl trope, forbidden love, and spicy scenes, this book is definitely for you.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an early copy in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy
4 stars. Sapphic Jane Austen retellings are my absolute weakness! I can’t get enough of them. I’m used to P&P retellings so I was excited to see this one is Emma. This was gorgeously written and very well paced.
Jane and Emma are both very headstrong women and I really enjoyed both characters a lot. Wonderful chemistry between them and the longing and pining was my favorite. There’s some spice which was great and I even liked the drama and miscommunication between them. I can tell the author did a lot of research because this doesn’t play out how sapphic historicals typically do and it definitely feels more true to the time period while still giving the characters their HEA. A really good read and I would highly recommend it if you’re fan of Austen.
Spice: ❤️🔥❤️🔥/❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
Content Warning:
*I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Jane and Emma are both very headstrong women and I really enjoyed both characters a lot. Wonderful chemistry between them and the longing and pining was my favorite. There’s some spice which was great and I even liked the drama and miscommunication between them. I can tell the author did a lot of research because this doesn’t play out how sapphic historicals typically do and it definitely feels more true to the time period while still giving the characters their HEA. A really good read and I would highly recommend it if you’re fan of Austen.
Spice: ❤️🔥❤️🔥/❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
Content Warning:
*I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I really enjoyed this sapphic reimagining of Miss Fairfax & Miss Woodhouse. With a similar writing style to Jane Austen, it follows the evolving relationship between Emma Woodhouse and Jane Fairfax, reframing their story with a romantic lens and giving more depth to the tension, restraint and quiet understanding between them. It captures that classic Austen tone and social nuance, but with a fresh perspective and honestly, I think I preferred this outcome and take.
The characters felt vivid and thoughtfully developed, and I loved the exploration of their dynamic with longing, conflict, and tenderness. It balances familiar regency charm with something more intimate and emotionally resonant. I really enjoyed the historical setting and background of the other characters.
A really engaging, satisfying reinterpretation that lingers after the final page.
Thank you to NetGalley for the e-arc and Maisie for writing this, I really enjoyed it and would highly recommend!
The characters felt vivid and thoughtfully developed, and I loved the exploration of their dynamic with longing, conflict, and tenderness. It balances familiar regency charm with something more intimate and emotionally resonant. I really enjoyed the historical setting and background of the other characters.
A really engaging, satisfying reinterpretation that lingers after the final page.
Thank you to NetGalley for the e-arc and Maisie for writing this, I really enjoyed it and would highly recommend!
June 1, 2026
Overall Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice Rating: 🌶
What a charming story! You will follow Emma and Jane as they navigate interacting with one another after a previously tumultuous childhood around each other. There was always a tension between them and Jane having the desire to have Emma's attention and approval. What starts as a friendly assist in sharing a bathing hut leads to rising emotions and further tension. These two women navigate their desires while keeping their blossoming relationship from prying eyes. Can they overcome the obstacles thrown their way or will their relationship fizzle out?
This was a fairly quick but enjoyable read! I hope that it will be available in a physical book eventually. This had a fantastic amount of angst and yearning. The writing seemed perfect for the era and had quite a few moments where I was laughing and doing a double take at some of the lines.
If you enjoy historical romance then this is perfect for you
Spice Rating: 🌶
What a charming story! You will follow Emma and Jane as they navigate interacting with one another after a previously tumultuous childhood around each other. There was always a tension between them and Jane having the desire to have Emma's attention and approval. What starts as a friendly assist in sharing a bathing hut leads to rising emotions and further tension. These two women navigate their desires while keeping their blossoming relationship from prying eyes. Can they overcome the obstacles thrown their way or will their relationship fizzle out?
This was a fairly quick but enjoyable read! I hope that it will be available in a physical book eventually. This had a fantastic amount of angst and yearning. The writing seemed perfect for the era and had quite a few moments where I was laughing and doing a double take at some of the lines.
If you enjoy historical romance then this is perfect for you
Review of advance copy
Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax
Maisie Jardelle
A complicated introduction to Jane Fairfax and Emma Woodhouse in the unenviable position of Emma being sent away to marry in Ireland. That means her companion Jane is to be returned home. Friend Emma is being sent in the carriage to fetch her. In such true Bridgerton manner the language is very formal. After many conversations Emma states she does not want a husband. She does want to be friends with Jane Fairfax. The adventure with the bathing machines was well researched. The issue of the piano uncoverswhat is deemed a pursuant and impropriety. Of course the men and aunts in their lives want to find them husbands but all they want is each other
Maisie Jardelle
A complicated introduction to Jane Fairfax and Emma Woodhouse in the unenviable position of Emma being sent away to marry in Ireland. That means her companion Jane is to be returned home. Friend Emma is being sent in the carriage to fetch her. In such true Bridgerton manner the language is very formal. After many conversations Emma states she does not want a husband. She does want to be friends with Jane Fairfax. The adventure with the bathing machines was well researched. The issue of the piano uncoverswhat is deemed a pursuant and impropriety. Of course the men and aunts in their lives want to find them husbands but all they want is each other
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Adored this! Such a wonderful retelling that worked so well within the spirit of the original story! Jardelle's characterisation of Emma was so well done, a bit snooty and a lot obvious but ultimately well intentioned. It was romantic and written in a way that felt cotemporary but still very in line with the writing of the original text. I loved the lavender marriage plot and it worked sooo well as a way to end the story! Definitely a book I'll be recommending to people!
Truly this book's only sin is the god awful cover, I get what it's trying to do but this is 100 per cent the type of cover that would put people off picking the book up - still way better than it being AI tho!
Thank you to Netgalley and Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op for an arc in exchange for an honest review!
Truly this book's only sin is the god awful cover, I get what it's trying to do but this is 100 per cent the type of cover that would put people off picking the book up - still way better than it being AI tho!
Thank you to Netgalley and Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op for an arc in exchange for an honest review!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Truthfully I have never read the original Emma novel, or any of Jane Austen's other works. However, despite this, I still enjoyed this book.
I thought the writing was clever and engaging and I liked seeing Emma and Jane get to know one another.
While I did find Emma very inconsiderate and naive at times, I appreciated that she attempted to redeem herself.
Overall, I think this is probably a solid retelling and it's an interesting sapphic historical romance in its own right. 4/5 stars.
Truthfully I have never read the original Emma novel, or any of Jane Austen's other works. However, despite this, I still enjoyed this book.
I thought the writing was clever and engaging and I liked seeing Emma and Jane get to know one another.
While I did find Emma very inconsiderate and naive at times, I appreciated that she attempted to redeem herself.
Overall, I think this is probably a solid retelling and it's an interesting sapphic historical romance in its own right. 4/5 stars.
Review of advance copy received from Author
A wonderful story, deep and emotional, with well-developed characters. The emotional torments of Emma and Jane correspond to the morality of the people in this period and the expressive means beautifully reflect the time in which the events unfold. I enjoyed the action and it was interesting to see the author's point of view on how two women would have discovered each other and what they wanted in an era without the modern amenities and an abundance of information in books. I recommend to everyone who loves the classics of old times!
Review of advance copy
I really enjoyed this - the attention to detail of what is important to keep from Emma was amazing, the life breathed into well-known characters was lovely, they felt like they had new life thanks to Jardelle. Making it sapphic as a brilliant call, and something I've been waiting for. This was an extremely well-executed and original take on a beloved classic. Thank you Maisie, you nailed it!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
3.5. Very much enjoyed the scene setting tho’ had great trouble at the start keeping straight in my head who was who. Not helped by surnames and first names being used at different times, as well as one character changing name through marriage…. A me issue, I am sure.
Things settled down, and I settled down to enjoy this novel. I enjoyed the odious creature in the style of the many odious creatures that have preceded her….. She had some great lines!
Things settled down, and I settled down to enjoy this novel. I enjoyed the odious creature in the style of the many odious creatures that have preceded her….. She had some great lines!
Review of advance copy received from Author
A simple story of first love being that of a female , female first love a story that is so innocent and often sweet in its exploration of romance , exploration and naivety and passion.
An enjoyable story that goes beyond what is expected of these times written with a care and attention of there situation and consequence’s.
An enjoyable story that goes beyond what is expected of these times written with a care and attention of there situation and consequence’s.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Miss Woodhouse and Miss Fairfax is a sapphic reimagining of Jane Austen's Emma. I was already a fan of Emma so I found this an enjoyable read. Not only were the characters well rounded and engaging, but the writing style was similar to Jane Austen's making it a believable retelling. I'd love to see more queer reinterpretations of classic novels.
June 4, 2026
I didn't really feel the connection between Emma and Jane- it felt like it went from apathy to love in two seconds flat, and I just didn't vibe. And Emma as a character wasn't for me- she was so oblivious and it drove me nuts. The book just wasn't quite my cup of tea.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A reimagining of Emma from Jane Austen that somehow manages to both keep some of the quaintness of the original work while feeding in some borderline BDSM scenes. The yearning was sweet but not as poignant as it could have been if the character perspectives had stayed consistent.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews