Two boys with the same name discover themselves, and their love for one another, during a week at summer camp. Before it's over, they will learn more about life, love, and loss than any merit badge class could have ever taught them.
Crooked Creek Serenade is a fictional account of two young Boy Scouts attending summer camp together, becoming friends, and sharing strong feelings. The characters were very articulated. By the time I finished this book, I felt I knew both boys, both named “Drew,” as well as the other scouts that were involved in the story. I was drawn into the coming-of-age story from the beginning of the book, and felt the emotions of the two boys exploring their sexuality. The storytelling was excellent. The book was definitely a tear jerker at times and also had “laugh-out-loud” moments, too. I really enjoyed the read and did not want the book to end.
The Best Book I've Ever Read. A Story That Will Stay in My Heart Forever. ❤️⭐
Where do I even begin?
I'm 47 years old, and I've read a lot of books in my life. Some have made me laugh, others have made me think, and a few have even brought me to tears.
But no story has ever touched me as deeply as Crooked Creek Serenade by Jody Marks.
And I mean that with all my heart: To me, this book is an absolute masterpiece.
The story takes place in the summer of 1997 at an American Boy Scout camp. At its heart are Andrew and Drew, two boys who meet there and, over the course of six unforgettable days, discover something that will change their lives: their first great love.
And the way Jody allows that love to unfold is something truly special.
There's the initial curiosity, the tentative steps toward each other, and that wonderful fluttering feeling when you suddenly realize someone means more to you than you're quite ready to admit. The uncertainty of whether the other person feels the same way. The excitement of every little touch, every glance, every affectionate word.
And eventually, the realization that what you're feeling really is love.
Jody describes all of this with such warmth, tenderness, and honesty that there were moments when I wanted nothing more than to step right into the story and give those two boys a hug.
But this is 1997, a time when openly gay boys were not welcome in the American Boy Scouts.
So Andrew and Drew aren't just discovering their feelings for each other. They're also trying to understand what those feelings mean and how to deal with them in a world that tells them their love isn't supposed to exist.
That combination of beautiful first love, uncertainty, hope, and fear makes their story incredibly moving.
And it's not just about the big emotions.
One of the things I love most about Jody's writing is how naturally he includes all those everyday experiences that are part of growing up.
The changes in your body, curiosity about your own sexuality, those first experiences with masturbation, the insecurities, and the occasional embarrassing moments. Even the communal showers at camp are part of that everyday life, along with all the questions and awkwardness that situations like those can bring at that age.
Jody writes about these things with such wonderful openness and naturalness, without unnecessary embarrassment or making them into something overly dramatic.
Because that's what growing up is like! You discover your body, try to make sense of your feelings, have new experiences, ask questions, and sometimes you're just wonderfully awkward.
And all of that is as much a part of Andrew and Drew as their love for each other.
But Crooked Creek Serenade isn't only about Andrew and Drew.
It's also about Matthew, and the extraordinary friendship between these three boys.
Matthew is so much more than a supporting character. The trust, loyalty, and bond between the three of them are among the most beautiful things about this book.
It's about being there for one another. Accepting each other. Judging someone not by whom they love, but by who they are.
And finding a place, and people, with whom you feel completely safe and accepted.
"Perimeter secure."
Two little words that have come to mean so incredibly much to me. ❤️
And despite all the serious themes, this book is also absolutely full of joy!
Oh, how often these boys made me laugh!
Their conversations, their humor, their teasing, and all those wonderfully ordinary, sometimes delightfully silly moments at camp.
Jody makes Andrew, Drew, and Matthew feel less like fictional characters and more like real people, with all their strengths, flaws, insecurities, and lovable quirks.
I never imagined that two fictional boys could come to mean so much to me. That I would think about them every single day. That I would keep rereading certain passages simply because I want to experience those moments again.
And that sometimes, just thinking about them is enough to bring a smile to my face or tears to my eyes.
There's something I especially want to emphasize: This book is NOT just for gay or queer readers!
Yes, at its heart is a love story between two boys. But love is love. Longing is longing. The uncertainty of whether our feelings are returned, the joy of being loved, and the desire to be accepted for who we truly are are deeply human experiences.
This story touches anyone with a heart in their chest. Regardless of gender or sexual orientation.
And it takes you on an emotional journey unlike anything I've ever experienced while reading.
I laughed, hoped, held my breath, and cried. Sometimes all within just a few pages.
And the wonderful thing is: That journey doesn't end with the first reading.
I wish I could experience that feeling of meeting Andrew and Drew for the very first time again. That excitement, that curiosity, not knowing what the next page would bring.
But at the same time, I love returning to them again and again.
Because on the second reading, your perspective changes. You know how everything fits together, you notice little details you missed before, and suddenly words, gestures, and entire scenes take on a completely different meaning.
And with every subsequent reading, there's something else to discover.
I'll accompany Andrew and Drew through that summer countless more times. And every single time, their story will touch me all over again.
But Crooked Creek Serenade has done something else to me, too.
It brought back memories I hadn't thought about in decades. Memories of my own childhood, of friendships, of people who once meant the world to me. Of feelings I thought I'd long forgotten.
I found myself looking back on my own life. On the boy I once was.
And I never expected a novel to do something like that to me.
Maybe all of this sounds completely over the top to someone who hasn't read the book yet.
I can understand that.
I never imagined I'd write such a long review of a book myself. And the funny thing is, I still haven't said nearly everything I'd love to say. 😅❤️
But how do you put something into words when it means this much to you?
Crooked Creek Serenade is the best book I've ever read.
Not simply because it's beautifully written. Not only because Andrew and Drew's love has touched me so deeply.
But because Jody Marks has managed to tell a story that, to me, has become so much more than words on a page.
A story that made me laugh, brought me to tears, and stirred something deep inside me.
Dear Jody, if you're reading this: I hope with all my heart that you know what you've created with this book. You've given me something I'll carry in my heart for the rest of my life.
And to everyone who's still wondering whether to read this book:
Please read it!
Get to know Andrew, Drew, and Matthew. Join them for those six unforgettable days. Laugh with them, feel with them, and let yourself become part of their story.
You'll understand why I love it so much.
And you'll never forget these boys.
Because there's one thought that now sums it all up for me:
Matthew said the drive to camp would take six hours.
Jody gives us six days.
I've made it to that camp myself now. And it will take me a lifetime to find my way back home. 🥹❤️
Five stars. Without a moment's hesitation.
And a very special place in my heart. Forever. ❤️⭐
I went into Crooked Creek Serenade not knowing what to expect. The synopsis didn't give much away and this appears to be a debut author finding their voice. What I found was something I wasn't prepared for.
The story centers around Andrew, Drew Two as his troop calls him, and the week he spends at Boy Scout camp. Already in the same troop, the two boys had been spending time together before camp, but the week away is where everything changed. A shared tent and a buddy system that paired them together for every activity meant there was nowhere to be except with each other. The writing put me right there with them. The night fishing, the canoe rides, the unguarded moments between activities where something was clearly shifting between them. This story reached something in me that I remembered from a long time ago.
What makes this story work is how grounded it feels. The setting, the activities, the friendships forming around the edges, all of it reads like memory rather than fiction. The author gives you just enough of the world around Drew and Andrew to make the time between them feel earned. A troop leader who sees them and shares something of himself changes everything. Two boys who finally have a word for what they're feeling, even if they're still figuring out what to do with it.
I will say this carefully because the ending deserves to be experienced without knowing what's coming. This story does not go where you expect it to. It went somewhere that cost me something to read and left me sitting with it in silence long after I finished. For a debut author, that takes courage. The ending reframes everything that came before it and lingers in a way that only the best stories do.
Product needs to come with a warning. Far out, man. Honestly. As much as I loved this book, and you can tell from the 5 stars, I am emotionally gutted. GUTTED.
'We stare calmly into one another’s eyes. I’m completely lost in him. I feel his heart beating in my chest as my blood flows through his veins. His pain and my joy. My emotions, his thoughts, our history. Us. Only him and no one else. Forever.'
The thing I adored about this was the sweetness of Andrew and Drew, the way they spoke to each other, the way they shared their thoughts and emotions in such an honest and mature way. It really makes you wonder at the way society paints masculinity, and how many real life boys are able to share themselves in this way without fear of being judged. Far too few would be my assumption.
Drew was so thoughtful, and made so many wonderful statements about the world and the way we treat people and minorities.
There were some very funny moments, too, like Matthew and Drew's comments about how hard and stiff the competition for the showers must be, after Andrew's awkward incident.
I liked Matthew's story, the things he shared with the boys, his relationship with them, and the outcome of the vote and how he was treated.
The foreshadowing was strong, and although I had my suspicions, which were correct, I did not expect the ending we received.
Talk about pulling my intestines out through my nose, putting them through a grinder, and shoving them back in again. My innards were in a constant turmoil that whole last day, knowing something was coming but not knowing what. I honestly still have the same roil. (Maybe I just saw someone's navel unexpectedly.)
I would've liked a bit more of what came after, like Andrew talking to his parents, and whether he and Matthew kept hanging out - but it did have a nice summing up. The perspective Andrew was able to take on it all seems mature. He certainly does look for the silver lining.
'I am so far past my breaking point that I am simply existing from one breath to the next. I feel like a pinball ricocheting around inside a minefield of obstacles, completely at the mercy of physics. I don’t know that it makes any difference where I am. All I am doing is waiting for the next collision.'
I feel you, Andrew, I'm right there with you, buddy.
A beautiful debut.
Edit to add: I couldn't stop thinking about this book. I literally woke up at 2am on my birthday, and then 5:30am, and all I could think about was Andrew. And Drew. And all the ways in which that ending could've been prevented. I know, we can't always have the happily ever after, and we don't even deserve it, but boy do I want it. I literally had to pick an upbeat romance filled with comedy and a HEA to remove the distress.
Crooked Creek Serenade by Jody Marks is one of the best books I've ever read- and that says quite a bit since I am a voracious reader. CCS is a work of fiction and a coming-of-age story set at a Boy Scout camp in Kentucky. As Drew 1 and Drew 2 explore the camp and take part in the activities, they discover a love for each other. Because at this time, BSA has a prohibition against gays, they have to be discreet. The two boys are young, and neither fully understands the past trauma Drew 1 has had to deal with. It comes to a head at the end. Marks expertly deals with the topic using discretion. Their love, as they discover it, is both innocent and tender, and I dare say cute. You will end up in tears just as I did, and after finishing the book, you will find yourself coming back to it again and again. I wholeheartedly give it 5 Stars- though it is worthy of so many more! A short, can't-miss read you will enjoy. It will touch your soul and heart. Review by Joseph Lewis, Author of Fan Mail and Blaze In, Blaze Out.
A wholesome and nostalgic story with a heartwrenching twist that brought back vivid memories of my times in scouting that I had long forgotten. The ending of this book is a tragic twist that left me in tears and completely caught me of gaurd.
A beautiful, healing story. I laughed out loud, bawled my eyes out, and could not stop reading this until I finished. Thank you for this wonderful book.
If you’ve ever gone to summer camp, if you’ve ever fallen in love over the summer, imagine combining the two experiences into one when you’re only 12 years old. Crooked Creek Serenade tells the story that only boys who grew up in the woods can feel in their hearts. I read this book over 24 hours and adventure through each page reliving my own memories of summer camp, thinking of friends. Thinking of boys, thinking of myself, and I spent the last hour after finishing the book curled up on the couch, processing the journey that this author is taking me on thank you Jody Marks for telling the story and sharing it with the world.
✨🏕️ POV: You picked up a wholesome summer camp story and ended up with a coming-of-age book that completely stole your heart. 🥹
Crooked Creek Serenade follows Andrew, a young Boy Scout who’s just moved up to Troop 62 and heads off to Camp Crooked Creek for a week of camping, merit badges, archery, canoeing, hiking, and trying to fit in with the older boys.
But as the days go by, camp becomes so much more than just earning badges.
Andrew starts forming a close friendship with Drew, and while he’s figuring out where he belongs in the troop, he’s also slowly figuring out who he really is.
This book had me smiling at all the little camp moments. The friendships, the troop banter, the competitions, the campfire vibes, and the beautiful outdoor setting made it feel like I was right there with them.
Andrew is such a lovable character because he’s awkward, kind, and trying his best, and watching his confidence grow throughout the story was honestly so satisfying.
What really made this book stand out, though, was the emotional depth.
Alongside all the fun camp adventures, we get Andrew’s complicated relationship with his father, Matthew quietly carrying burdens of his own, and Andrew’s journey of understanding his feelings for Drew.
Nothing felt rushed, it all unfolded naturally, making every emotional moment land even harder.
If you love character-driven stories where the biggest adventure is watching someone discover who they are, this one’s for you.
It’s nostalgic, heartfelt, and full of quiet moments that say so much. I finished it with the biggest smile and a slightly emotional heart.
The first part of the book, I wanted to love it but it was just ok. The characters were so sweet and earnest but it was almost cartoonishly so. If a food dish is just sweet and nothing to balance it out, the first few bites might be good but it loses its luster quickly.
But the second part of the book, once a little tension was introduced, was amazingly written and incredibly compelling. I almost never tear up when I'm reading but did a couple times here. As for the ending, I totally did not have that on my bingo card.
I think this is the author's first novel. I certainly hope it's not the last.
The author did not lie: if you like the movies Young Hearts and Close, you should definitely read this book. It was a smooth read overall. Personally, it was a bit too much of a slow burn for me, and—it’s probably just me—the ending felt a bit off. Still, I’d say read it and form your own opinion! It definitely won't be a re-read for me, though. I'll probably pull a Joey from Friends and put it in the freezer (S03E13) .
A sweet, haunting coming of age story that will stay with you.
I happened upon this book by chance and I’m so grateful that I did. The story is beautiful and relatable. The characters come to life and are sooo believable. At its core “Crooked Creek Serenade” is a young, queer love story that is about discovery, acceptance, and trauma. I recommend this to not just teenage readers but to older LGBTQ members who grew up in the 90’s. You will love this story forever.