Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Other Side of Certainty: How to Follow Jesus When Easy Answers No Longer Work

Rate this book
From Black-and-White Belief to a Faith Full of Color God is so much bigger than the box we often try to put him in.Spiritual platitudes, easy answers, and rigid expressions of belief often cannot bear the weight of life's real questions. For those whose faith has been shaped by black-and-white certainty or narrow church cultures, what can it look like to untangle your faith and experience Jesus more fully?In The Other Side of Certainty, Kristin Mockler Young invites you to shift from a faith of pressure, judgmentalism, and conformity to one of curiosity, exploration, and freedom. Kristin's gentle guidance will help you navigate through the confusion to find where God's grace and love are present, helping you see that God really is bigger than all your doubts, choices, past selves, or difficult circumstances.The Other Side of Certainty will help you Move beyond rigid, black-and-white beliefs toward a faith with room for wonder;Embrace curiosity and questions as vital parts of your spiritual growth; andEncounter a deeper understanding of who God is and the joy and freedom he wants you to live in.
Rather than clinging to certainty, you can choose wonder. Rather than fearing questions or tensions, you can embrace the mystery of a God who is far beyond your understanding. As you shift your focus from legalism to love, you can make room for not knowing and discover you're getting to know God―and yourself―better in the process.As much as you want to hold on to Jesus, he is holding on to you all the more. Discover a vibrant, honest faith on the other side of certainty.

200 pages, Paperback

Published October 6, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Kristin Mockler Young

1 book1 follower
Kristin Mockler Young is a teaching pastor at Mosaic Church and host of the Becoming Church podcast. Through her teaching, podcast, and Turning the Gem Substack, Kristin encourages curiosity over certainty and helps people discover God in unexpected places. Kristin and her husband, Peter, live in Charlotte, North Carolina, with their daughters, Marlee and Margot.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
21 (72%)
4 stars
4 (13%)
3 stars
2 (6%)
2 stars
2 (6%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews
Profile Image for Ortinel G.
3 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 24, 2026
I just finished reading The Other Side of Certainty and all I can say is: wow. This book is a breath of fresh air.

At a time when so much of Christianity feels weighed down by division, toxicity, and harmful expressions of faith, this book offers something profoundly different. It is beautifully written, engaging, accessible, humorous, and deeply thought-provoking. Above all, it leaves the reader with a renewed sense of wonder at the love and beauty of God, which so often meets us in uncertainty and the complexities of life rather than in easy answers.

Throughout the book, Kristin walks alongside the reader as both a friend and fellow pilgrim, gently guiding those navigating deconstruction or learning to let go of religious certainty. With warmth, theological depth, wisdom, and grace, she reminds us that certainty has never been the goal of the Christian faith. Instead, it is often in the wrestling, the questions, and the surrender of certainty that we begin to embody the way of Jesus through love, service, forgiveness, and self-giving.

Every chapter is outstanding, but without giving too much away, one chapter that particularly stayed with me explored the dangers of religious certainty in friendships. It is one of the most insightful reflections I have read on how unhealthy religious beliefs and attitudes can damage relationships, replacing love with control.

I've only scratched the surface of what this book offers. The Other Side of Certainty is a must-read for anyone who has been shaped by Christianity or the church, whether you remain within it or have walked away. Kirsten reminds us that Jesus and his message of love are far bigger than doctrinal statements or religious certainty.

Thank you, Kristin, for your faithfulness in writing this book. A tremendous gift to the global church for generations.

Please get this book.
1 review
October 6, 2026
This is the right book at the right moment. Kristin Mockler Young tackles the hard questions of faith, deconstruction, and modern Christianity, with plenty of humor and wisdom, and doesn’t give answers, but gives you a window to the other side, where questions are welcome and God is waiting for you. Highly recommend this book for anyone examining their faith, especially those who need to hear that having questions is okay and God is still with us through the wondering.
Profile Image for Brianna.
53 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 6, 2026
If you are somebody that has wrestled with doubt in your Christian faith, and are either still in the trenches of it, or you are on the other side but with a much different looking faith than before - this book would be a great one for you to help navigate that exhausting path (been there.) It has a lot of very practical takeaways and is also encouraging!
One of the things I really loved about this book, was that you could tell that the author had a lot of experience in pastoral ministry. Chapters 7, 8, and 9 were where the author really shined with this, and I was able to take away a lot from those chapters. There was an emphasis on unity and charity with differences among Christians, and I never felt coddled, rather I was encouraged to grow.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion!
Profile Image for LAMONT D.
1,714 reviews17 followers
October 11, 2026
I saw this author was on a podcast from my church, so I looked the book up and said why not. Probably should not have ventured there because I have strong feelings on her overall premise of the book. I do not doubt that she is a very sincere believer/minister that wants the church to show the love of Jesus as authentically as possible. And it appears that there are plenty of resources listed and verses pointed to that would help the reader throughout the book.

The basic problem is this. When she states that our relationship with Jesus must be founded on something other than the certainty of knowledge, that is a huge red flag in my book and belief system. As Proverbs 1:7 states: "The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge. Fools despise wisdom and instruction (ESV)." As she reiterates her opinion in the final chapter: "As you learn to outgrow the restriction of a boxed-in religion that controls with authority, fear, conformity, and obligation, you are learning to think for yourself, use your voice, advocate for what's right." The question is what is right? Who decides what is right? Well, her pathway leads to whatever is right in your own eyes is what matters which is at the heart of the deconstruction movement in the church. This is classic!

Earlier she emphasized that your inner voice would guide you toward what is true along with feelings. Again, more red flags go up when you emphasize feelings because if you follow your feelings you will end up doing what you feel is right in your own eyes. Basically, I guess the white American Christianity movement has been all wrong and now we need to find a better way or path to Jesus. She does have a point that there have been problems in the church because the church is made up of people that are imperfect and hypocritical. But where is the truth to be found? In God's Word. Look at who Jesus is and what He says within the counsel of the entire Bible. There are no questions too big for God so yes seek to find your faith by asking tough questions. Ultimately, you have to trust someone so do not trust yourself, trust God!
Profile Image for Michelle Schubert.
2 reviews
Review of advance copy
October 6, 2026
If you have questions about your faith, doubts even (pearls clutched and all), this book is a safe place, a warm hug, a gentle reminder from a friend who's been there that you are not alone, that it will be okay, and that God is big enough to handle what you have for him. Deconstruction has been like a four-letter word in years past; not here. Not with Kristin. You will get to remember who you are (and how good that is!), feel seen if you are feeling alone, and see that you are surrounded by others who have curiosity and wonder and that those things are welcome (seriously) as you follow Jesus. The best part? You will not feel hung out to dry in mere ethereal thoughtfulfulness. Kristin writes for your next step. A safe landing now and encouragement for your next move, on your terms, for REAL life. Imagine!? A faith for everyday real life that still holds Jesus as true North. If you need that, this book is for you.
1 review
October 6, 2026
What I appreciated most about this book was the relatability with which the author writes. Her humor and pop-culture nods spoke to me. The Chapter 8 subject of friendship and the way Religious Certainty led to judgment and criticism stepped on my toes in the best way. I enjoyed the book because it challenged me to stay close to Jesus as I continue to reexamine my faith and beliefs and reassured me that I'm not alone. I would recommend this book to anyone who used to be certain about their faith and now, not so much. To anyone who is examining their beliefs and wondering, "Why do I actually believe this?" or "Is this from Jesus or just tradition/religion?" You won't find specific answers, but you will leave feeling encouraged that you aren't the only one. Chips and girly pop references are a delightful bonus.
46 reviews
October 11, 2026
The Other Side of Certainty by Kristin Mockler Young is a thoughtful and vulnerable presentation of other ways to look at faith and certainty. Part memoir, part scripture study, and part journaling guide, the author gently guides us through examining faith through a lens of wonder and curiosity rather than certainty and shame. This book is like a comforting cup of tea during a challenging journey. I can see myself working through this book again to revisit questions as my faith journey continues.

I’m grateful to NetGalley and InterVarsity Press for the opportunity to read an ARC of this book.
1 review
October 2, 2026
Love the book's heart for the heavy burdened! The words in the book were so sweet and carefully crafted! The references to both scripture, and seeds in secular media that God plants in the world. Are gentile observations that seem to point out the glue that holds a broken world together. This book is for teens, adults, and people from all walks of life. We need more voices that remind us of our similarities, and that encourage us to be a united body actively showing the love of Christ by helping others. May God grant us more of this!
2 reviews
October 7, 2026
When Kristin Mockler Young announced her book about embracing uncertainty and finding Jesus in the midst of a growing and changing faith, I absolutely had to get my hands on it. Whether you call it “deconstruction” or “reevaluation” or “evolving hermeneutics,” if seeing Jesus in the midst of the fear of uncertainty speaks to what you have gone or are going through, this lovely book is for you. As a pastor who has been through just that, I know you’ll feel seen as you read.

Genuinely, one of the best, bravest, and most compassionate takes on the struggle for certainty in faith!
1 review1 follower
October 8, 2026
This book is easy to read. Kristin’s writing style feels like you are hearing from a friend rather than working through dense hard to read prose. The ideas however— I found myself reading, putting it down, rereading and thinking about how much pain I could have avoided had this book existed earlier. She lovingly challenged the religious views of my childhood and helped me to see there is so much more to learn. Thank you Kristin!
Profile Image for Ashley.
8 reviews
September 25, 2026
I genuinely appreciate the encouraging tone and hope-filled journey the author takes us on as readers. Rather than coming from a place of criticism and “burn it all down,” she gently takes us by the hand and invites us into curiosity and an exploration of a better way. In the end, you’ll come away from this book holding on with clarity to the things that are certain, and courageously letting go of the things that no longer work.
7 reviews3 followers
November 2, 2026
This book is the perfect companion alongside your curiosity. as you question and unpack so much of the evangelical/legalistic gunk many of us in america were raised in, it will be so refreshing and comforting to have Kristin beside you, supporting you in the full range of exploration. This is a great read for anyone decongesting, but specially for those who want a different path besides just letting it all burn.
3 reviews
October 26, 2026
Spoiler but I am giving this book to EVERYONE for Christmas. Kristin does such a phenomenal job of giving space to ask questions while standing firm on a deep faith foundation where a personal relationship with Christ is at the center. And a pop culture reference here and there? Even better! This book is accessible, it’s challenging, it’s for you and it’s for me. Thank you Kristin!!
13 reviews
October 22, 2026
Kristen is a Pastor who understands the nuances surrounding deconstruction. She doesn’t condemn it like some pastors and Christian influencers. She gently and boldly leads readers through what it could look like and how to do it well and come out the other side.
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews