Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Fate Spinner

Rate this book
Some girls fall for the villain; she falls into entire worlds.

Bound to a prophecy that marks her for death, Seraphine transports to places that shouldn’t exist every time she closes her eyes. They’re realms filled with magic and monsters―and one cursed man who was never meant to lay eyes on her.

Royal is cold, powerful, and dangerous. He’s the king of his forbidden world; guarded by dragons, no one is allowed in or out. Seraphine doesn’t understand why she can reach him or why only he can see her. But from the moment they meet, her dreams intensify as she’s pulled further into his orbit.

Terrified she’ll suddenly vanish, Royal takes Seraphine captive and holds her in an underground dungeon, the one place in his kingdom where magic is impossible―or so he thought. But Seraphine continues to be transported in her dreams, portals tearing open and seals unraveling across realms.

Even as she accidentally crosses into a werewolves’ domain, she finds herself back in Royal’s presence while she sleeps, bound by a connection she can’t control. And Seraphine’s journey becomes increasingly dangerous as she discovers new worlds, each one more fearful of who―and what―she is . . .

429 pages, Kindle Edition

First published November 17, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

T.L. Smith

89 books7,367 followers
USA Today Best Selling Author T.L. Smith loves to write her characters with flaws so beautiful and dark that you can’t turn away from. Her books have been translated into several languages. If you don’t find her in her home town of Queensland, Australia you can usually find her travelling around the world to sitting on a beach in Bali, to exploring Alcatraz in San Francisco or walking the streets of New York.



Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/authortlsmith/
Instagram - tlsmith1313
Twitter - @LsmithT
Tiktok - tlsmith.13

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
143 (27%)
4 stars
160 (30%)
3 stars
138 (26%)
2 stars
60 (11%)
1 star
28 (5%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 177 reviews
Profile Image for Liana Gold.
634 reviews603 followers
November 9, 2026
Her dreams open portals. His kingdom has no doors, so he locks her up. She keeps escaping and coming right back....
Filled by prophecy, this world is full of monsters and magic, with only one man who was never meant to lay eyes on her.

For starters, this was a beautiful book with wonderful ideas but I must admit that despite how easy this was to read, the story failed to captivate me or even keep me engaged. It started off well but by 30%, I started to lose interest because everything was underwhelming about this book. From very plain, juvenile writing and teen-like conversations, I had a really hard time appreciating everything else. Dream traveling is such an interesting topic and when done super well, the story becomes unique in its own way. Unfortunately, dream traveling fell flat here along with character development and even plot progression. The romance was by no means enemies to lovers. She was lusting after him early on and there was no chemistry or romance. They were also never truly enemies: he needed her to escape his own prison and she was just there playing hard to get. The book is marked as dark romance, but as someone who is not into that genre, I really can't even say that this truly falls within that category. Overall, while it wasn't that interesting, readers might love it for its ease and fast pace. Its short and you can read it in one sitting.


One of my Allurial picks!
Get the deluxe copy here before it hits the stores on 11/17: https://www.allurial.com/refer/g7sai1...
Profile Image for LKCREADS.
225 reviews688 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 16, 2026
There is a superior genre of Romantasy and its Dark Romantasy…

I read this book in two days…

The second I met the male main character… Royal… I was… immediately obsessed…

“Many years ago, the dragons bound me here, and the witches anchored their spell into the bones of the land itself, keyed to my blood and my power. It wasn’t chains or bars. They wove a magic so precise, so absolute, that no one could pass in or out. They feared my powers, and they were right to.”

Morally gray is good. Ok. We eat up morally gray. But when they’re even darker… that just tickles my taste buds plain and simple.

And the female main character??

“I’ve always been captivated by places where darkness and danger linger, where beauty and menace entwine.”

Um... same girl. Same.

Our female main character is able to visit other realms when she falls asleep… realms filled with magic and monsters…and one cursed man who was never meant to lay eyes on her.

Royal is cold, powerful, and dangerous. He’s the king of his forbidden world; guarded by dragons, no one is allowed in or out.

She doesn’t understand why she can reach him or why only he can see her. But from the moment they meet, her dreams intensify as she’s pulled further into his orbit.

Terrified she’ll suddenly vanish, Royal takes her captive and holds her in an underground dungeon, the one place in his kingdom where magic is impossible―or so he thought…

When I tell you… the amount of giggling you will be doing… is ridiculous.

The tension, the flirting, the banter, the high stakes, the witches, the werewolves, the vampires, the monsters, the fire, the spice, the romance, the heartbreak… this book is so delicious you will be fed so well… it’s everything.

“When I’m with you, you quiet the part of me that wants to eliminate everyone who has wronged me. When I’m not with you, I want to destroy anyone who gets in my way of getting back to you, friend or foe. I don’t care what it takes.”

Besties... this book comes out tomorrow… you need it. You need it. Happy reading!
Profile Image for Fulton.
45 reviews
June 13, 2026
SHOUT OUT TO EDELWEISS FOR THIS ARC READ!


I absolutely devoured this book.

I had been stuck in a major book slump for about two and a half weeks before picking up Fate Spinner, and the second I started reading, I knew this one was different. Every few chapters I found myself thinking, “There’s no way!” because T.L. Smith kept throwing in things I never saw coming.

Vampires? Cool.

Werewolves? Even cooler.

Dragons? Excuse me?!

The funny thing is I went into this pretty blind. I had read the blurb, but I hadn’t paid attention to the cover, the sprayed edges, or any of the little hints that might have prepared me for what was coming. So every reveal felt like a complete surprise, and I loved every second of it.

Honestly, I could have finished this book in 24 hours if I wanted to. But for the first time in a long time, I didn’t want to rush. It was so refreshing and so unique that I found myself intentionally dragging out the last 25% because I wasn’t ready for it to end.

In a market where it sometimes feels like everything is starting to blend together, Fate Spinner felt like something entirely its own. It was exciting, unpredictable, and had me hooked from beginning to end.

This was such a cool read, and I already know it’s going to be one of the books I’m most excited to recommend and sell from our mobile bookstore.
Profile Image for Lauren Keith.
560 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
November 10, 2026
Allurial box advance copy!

1.5 / 2 stars

Fate Spinner had such a good hook, and I had really high hopes for this book, but it fell very flat for me. Honestly, the whole story felt undercooked and underdeveloped. Nothing about the characters' feelings, the magic system, or the warring factions got more than a superficial explanation, and frankly, there were some pretty glaring inconsistencies that were hard to ignore.

Several little details mentioned in passing just stuck with me and completely chipped away at my suspended disbelief. I can't get over the fact that we have a road trip where the FMC, who grew up in the human realm, can't drive because she never learned how, but the werewolf who's been imprisoned in a medieval dungeon for 400 years can take the wheel without a problem. Make it make sense. By the end, there were simply too many impossibilities that were suddenly, inexplicably, and far too easily overcome.

And the mate bond, which was one of the things I was most excited about (I love a good fated mates romance), was never really explained or developed beyond "oh, these two are in love." But don't mind those mates over there who apparently hate each other for no discernible reason. I wanted more from this part of the story, and I got nothing.

There were also a fair number of missing punctuation marks and odd grammatical choices that made the reading experience even more frustrating. Overall, I just wasn't impressed. The book felt rushed, the worldbuilding needed a lot more development, and I wasn't a fan of the trope delivery. Such a promising premise, but the execution just wasn't there for me.
Profile Image for Karly.
505 reviews910 followers
November 19, 2026
The first 20% i was hooked!! This was such an intriguing concept but fell a little flat. After the 20% it lulled a bit for me. I think it felt a bit scattered at times in terms of the plot. I also wish the relationships were more developed. Both the friendships and the romance felt surface level. Especially the romance, it went from not trusting each other and being strangers to all of a sudden in love. So while I did appreciate this as a standalone and there were interesting components, I think it could’ve used 100-200 more pages to develop everything to a deeper level.
Profile Image for Katie.
138 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
November 13, 2026
The true definition of dark and gritty!

The MFC soon discovers she is a witch with the strangest power, one so rare that there hasn't been anyone like her in at least 1,000 years. She also soon learns that her fated mate is the worst possible candidate known throughout the realms, an evil king whose title was not an exaggeration. Not only does she have that to worry about, but coming into her untapped power has its own challenges. This includes fighting off every creature that now knows she exists and sees her as a threat.

There was a lot going on in this book! It kept things interesting. Most of it had to do with self discovery. The MFC had been hidden off from her homeland as well as from her powers and she has to try and learn her magic all while facing unrelenting threats. If you like Fated Mates, Supernaturals, Family Secrets, Emerging Powers, Touch her and 💀, Multiple Threats, and Unlikely Allies, you would like this book.

I was blessed with the audiobook so as far as narrations go, this was solid! It was a duel narration production. The voice actors did an incredible job at protraying the many different characters.

Trigger warnings include On-Page Death, Betrayal (not from MMC), Kidnapping, death of friends/family, & torture. There are a lot of spicy scenes in this book! This book is definitely intended for 18+ readers.

There were a few inconsistencies but they were so small, it did not affect the story in any way. They were just mild contradicting details. Overall, it was a pretty good book and I'm looking forward to the second!

I'd like to thank the author and Podium Entertainment for the ARC of this book. I am leaving my review voluntarily.
Profile Image for JKT Reviews.
39 reviews
Review of advance copy
November 15, 2026
Mother above! That was some sweet, incoherent nonsense. I blame the editor. I choose to believe that this was supposed to be the first rough draft that was accidentally published.
Allurial November pick.
Profile Image for Summer Raeven .
108 reviews
November 19, 2026
Allurial November 2026 Selection Spoiler alert: I was fooled by the artworks aesthetic 😭


So many plot holes / tropes were attempted to be thrown into this novel and it became an absolute buffoonery of a clusterfuck.
Now you might say, but why did you read the entire thing? And in such a short time span no less. The buffoonery was so mind numbing that I just kept going. Ya'll.. I love me some dark romantasy smut.. but this ain't it. It's a shame the book was so gods damned pretty.
Profile Image for Selene.
407 reviews30 followers
October 31, 2026
Thank you to podium for my ALC. the opinions are my own.

A this is duet so automatically 1000000/10 for audio. Narrators did a phenomenal job.

More bonus points for being a standalone with really excellent pacing. Really enjoyed this story it’s a fun chosen one with witches, werewolves, dragons , vampires and portals.

Didn’t really completely understand the mmcs motivation to lock her up and hurt her in the beginning but once we’ve moved on from the edgey villain vibes it was really fun
Profile Image for Julia Ross.
255 reviews170 followers
Review of advance copy
November 9, 2026
This was my pick from Allurial, the special edition is gorgeous! 🩵

This was fun and I loved the concept of different realms, portals & forbidden love.

For me though, the story flow was all over the place and I struggled to stay engaged. Still a really unique concept though.
Profile Image for Vanessa Carrillo.
94 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
May 27, 2026
Thank you Edelweiss for the advance reader copy!

This book is described as dark romantasy and let me tell you, it checked all the boxes! The plot was action packed and very intriguing. The level of heartbreak was unexpected. I will also be thinking of strawberries very differently now haha.

The romance felt like it flowed properly. I enjoyed the friendships throughout the story. I felt connected to the characters.

Overall, it was an easy read. Will there be more?
Profile Image for Kaitlin Webb.
2 reviews
Review of advance copy
November 16, 2026
November 2026 Allurial pick

This book was very disappointing. I was so interested in the concept, but it really fell flat. The idea of the world was amazing. The different magical species all being woven together by a superior, realm-altering being is something so unique compared to other stories out there right now. There were so many original ideas that could have made this so, so, so good.

Unfortunately, the writing was just terrible. The first 25% was going pretty decent. The post-apocalyptic human world the FMC is from got my attention, and then was never elaborated on. At all. What happened to the world? All we know is cities like NYC have fallen and are chaos while life in the smaller towns makes life easier to survive. This theme of things "happening with no context" follows through the whole book. After the first quarter of the book is over, it just got worse and worse.

The next pet peeve is that there is absolutely no room for imagination or any kind of anticipation to build up. As soon as something starts to happen, it happens and is over with immediately. No suspense. No chemistry among characters. No problem-solving. Everything is just immediate. Everything happens SO fast. It's just wham, wham, wham; one event happening right after another. There wasn't nearly enough build-up in the story for anything to become meaningful.

That moves us on to the next issue. The dialogue amongst characters is downright embarrassing. I got such secondhand embarrassment when any character was speaking in this book. Everything was insanely corny and cliché. It made the already too-fast chemistry building even harder to connect with, because every sentence just made me want to face palm.

Everything was too easy. There was no anticipation that something was or wasn't going to happen. If an obstacle arose, it was immediately overcome. Every dilemma was way too conveniently solved.

Again, the idea of this book was so good. I just wish the author would have handed the idea off to someone who could have actually given it the time and love it needed to simmer into an epic story. This was one of the biggest letdowns I've faced to date. I had to make myself finish it, because I wanted to know what happened. The ending was just again another cheesy disappointment.

On the plus side: the Allurial edition is absolutely beautiful. This is a gorgeous hardcover book with amazing art.

That just goes to show you can't judge a book by its very beautiful cover.
Profile Image for Ashley.
112 reviews
November 18, 2026
I wanted this to be so much better than it was. The blurb sounded so interesting with the FMC being able to transport through dreaming, and the MMC being stuck in a realm where only she can save him. The plot needed more, parts felt unfinished. There was one part where she was literally talking to someone and then the next line she was in a dream, nothing mentioned her going to sleep. She trained for 3 weeks and was able to master her powers and open realms at will. There was talk of wars starting and the FMC would transport to another realm and hook up. It was supposed to be enemies to lovers, but there was no enemies 😂 the MMC literally locked her up and hurt her, and she then was attracted to him. It was deff insta-love at its finest. I wanted to DNF at 20% and I kind of wish I had now, but wanted to give it a chance 🫠 honestly, the dragon and Seren were the best part of this book.

I received an eARC from the author in exchange for my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Caitlin.
4 reviews
November 13, 2026
This sounded very promising and ambitious, but it just falls flat for me. It felt extremely underdeveloped. This could have used more chapters or another book to give room to develop the world and plot, characters, and romance.
One of my biggest issues was the pacing. It felt uneven and rushed at many points. Seraphine goes from realm to realm, then trains with witches, then all hell breaks loose and it seems like an epic battle is about to happen, then she’s back at the castle with Royal getting her back blown out. I can’t tell what is urgent or not. Why are we being taken away from what seems like it should be a major plot point?
The worldbuilding requires heavy suspension of disbelief. A werewolf who’s been trapped in a dungeon for hundreds of years can drive? There are shower heads in this realm that’s been sealed off? The world kind of ended and Seraphine’s farming strawberries? There were many points I had to just accept what was happening and move on.
The romance wasn’t compelling either which I was sad about. The whole concept of this book feels like there should be this yearning and tension happening, but I don’t feel like we get any of that. Nothing suggests Seraphine and Royal had built anything outside of their fated bond. Also, the king’s name is Royal?
Overall, I think this was just a hot mess and I don't believe this author is for me.
Profile Image for Michellelovesreading.
1,864 reviews195 followers
November 17, 2026
Read this book in 6 days it was so good. If you like romantasy and these tropes.

Tropes:
Possessive MMC
Enemies To Lovers
Fated Mates
Dream Powers
Magical Realm

Stars:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Spice:🌶️🌶️🌶️
Profile Image for Dray Kersey.
12 reviews
November 19, 2026
Things were happening so fast that I didn’t have the emotional investment to care and got bored.
133 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Book of the Month
November 10, 2026
Note to self: you don’t need to read this author again.
Profile Image for read.with.haley.
318 reviews18 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 26, 2026
A little cheesy and underdeveloped. There was just SO much happening, and not all of it came together in a way that made sense. I struggled to feel connected to the story or the characters, even though the elements and tropes had a lot of potential. Unfortunately, I don’t think they were executed in a way that allowed me to fully enjoy the story. Overall, it was just fine. Neither good nor bad, just kinda mid. Not very memorable.

Thank you Podium Entertainment for the ALC.

✨Dark Romantasy
✨Possessive MMC
✨Enemies to Lovers
✨Dream Powers
✨Fated Mates
✨Magical Realms
✨Prophecies & Fates
✨Witches, Vampires, Werewolves
🎧Duet Narration
🌶️🌶️(2/5)
Profile Image for Katie Murphy.
1,177 reviews116 followers
November 17, 2026
TL Smith has entered her dark romantasy era and I am absolutely here for it.

When I first read the blurb I was hooked, I mean a woman whose dreams open a path to different worlds? I mean I think all of us readers would love something like that to even be possible. Well our FMC Seraphine has now began to realise that her dreams are a little too real. Normally when one dreams you can vaguely recall it the next day but Seraphine remembers it vividly and even has an encounter with our MMC that leaves a long lasting effect the next day.

On our meeting of the MMC, Royal, I had one word for him and that was intense. Now Royal is a Cursed King who is bound to his realm by a witch until the fate spinner or his mate can release him, and he is desperate after all his years of being trapped to be released and seek out those who wronged him. This is where Seraphine comes in because she is the fate spinner who can open portals amongst the realms. But this also puts a target on her back as many of these realms do not coexist in harmony and would prefer the order to remain undisrupted.

And how did Seraphine get these powers might you ask? Well while she never knew her family she was raised by a woman who she deemed as a grandmother but now that her power is growing the truth of her family history is unwinding. Her mother was a powerful witch and while she never got to meet her daughter she set her on this course. I enjoyed reading about Seraphine navigating this new world because the poor girl was completely dropped into it, especially with the arrival of the cursed kings men who was sent on behalf of royal to retrieve her.

When Royal and Seraphine meet face to face it is certainly an unpleasant encounter where neither side backs down and I was proud of Seraphine for not doing so even if it resulted her in being locked away. But while she was behind bars she met Seren, a wolf who was locked away for years. These two develop a quick and fast friendship and with Seraphines evolving powers she helps set him free which creates a platonic protector bond so to speak between them. I honestly loved the friendship between these two.

Despite Seraphine being free from the cursed kings realm she cannot deny the pull back to him and her dreams are evident to this where they meet everytime she falls asleep. Seraphine is meant to release or destroy the cursed king but this point the enemies line was definitely crossing over into the familiar territory of feelings. Even though he is stuck in his realm certain does not stop him from coming to her aid when she needs it, and that’s what I call dedication and obsession. Honestly I loved the development of their relationship from start to finish.

The author definitely through in many twists and turns in this book. Like Seraphine, I was weary of everyone expect for Seren and his sister. There was many forces at play here and our FMC had to decide which side she wanted to be on. I also loved the progressing reveal of Seraphine’s past and how it mixed with what she was facing in the present.

Overall I loved Seraphine and Royals journey. I do hope we get more in this universe as I feel there is certainly more to come.

Thank you to the author who provided this e-arc for my honest thoughts
Profile Image for TheBookmarkedLife.
114 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy
November 17, 2026
3 ⭐ | YES, NO, OR MAYBE?

YES if you enjoy romantasy with dragons, magical bonds, hidden identities, fated mates, and a mix of familiar fantasy tropes. There are some genuinely interesting concepts here, and I especially loved the unexpected found family dynamic.

NO if you need a well-developed world, a believable progression of magical powers, and a main romance that makes sense emotionally. Some character decisions were hard to get behind, and I wanted much more depth from the story.

MAYBE if you're somewhere in between and don't mind a story with lots of ideas that don't always come together.

Spoilers:


I loved the concept of the Veil, especially her ability to open portals and travel through space. I also really liked the idea of her accidentally becoming bonded to a werewolf, not romantically or as fated mates, but in a way that eventually creates an unexpected found family. That was such an interesting dynamic! The hidden identity and dystopian setting, with her working as a strawberry picker, also had so much potential.

One of my favorite things was the MMC's background. Being the son of Death himself and a witch? I honestly haven't come across that before, and I thought that part of the story was fascinating. Funny enough, I found myself more invested in the side character romances and their fated mate connections than in the actual main couple. I wanted more of those relationships!

My biggest issue was that there were just too many romantasy elements packed into one story, and some felt a little underdeveloped. We have dragons, a hidden identity, magical bonds, and the untrained chosen one who somehow figures out how to use all her powers without much training. I wanted more world-building and character development instead of so many ideas competing for attention.

And I really struggled with the MMC knowing who the FMC was to him and still choosing to lock her up and torture her. I mean, how are we supposed to move past that? Her forgiving him so easily, especially after he literally breaks her fingers, didn't quite work for me; there was zero groveling!

I also wasn't the biggest fan of the writing style. Something about the FMC's way of speaking felt a little off to me, and I never fully connected with her.

Overall, this was an okay read with some genuinely interesting concepts, but I wanted more depth, better development, and a main romance I could actually get invested in. I enjoyed parts of the story, but unfortunately, it never fully came together for me.
Profile Image for Brittany Baker.
197 reviews8 followers
October 28, 2026
Wow. This surprised me in the absolute best way! I have not had a book hook me and sink its claws in like this one did in a long time.

The plot & world building was easy to comprehend but also descriptive to get your imagination running wild. Vampires, werewolves, dragons, witches & more; different realms, magic & prophecies; but all with a uniqueness to the mix without being overwhelming. The banter between Seraphine & The Cursed King had me drooling for more from the first. I loved their dynamic and the development of each of their characters.

I cried. I laughed. It left me staring at the wall with my mouth hanging open. It made me feel, exactly like I want a book to do so.

The audiobook (ALC):
I mean, you had me at Sean Masters. His voice and the passion you feel with his narrations has never let me down. Of course, it did not disappoint this time either. I think he captured each of the male characters, along with their personalities, perfectly.

This is the first time (that I’m aware of) that I have heard Avery Crais narrating & I’m sold!! Beautiful work and did amazing! She captured the softness and the fierceness behind the characters, especially with Seraphine.

BIG THANK YOU to Podium for allowing me to listen early!
Profile Image for Timitra.
1,966 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
November 2, 2026
Fate Spinner was an engrossing, interesting and intriguing read. It grabbed me by the throat from the very beginning and held me captive to the very end. I loved this book so much. It was emotionally engaging and wrecking all in the same breath. It was packed with action, adventure, magic, so many paranormal beings, drama, betrayal, secrets, lies, a prophecy, twists, turns and so much more. The world was pretty awesome too. I loved the magic system as well. I had a few issues with the romance as far as the way it was developed. It didn't feel like a natural progression. It felt a bit wonky. That said I loved the main characters, Seraphine and Royal. I loved watching them grow over the course of the story especially Seraphine, watching her come into her own was truly to watch. Watching evil getting its comeuppance and supremely enjoyable, I took immense joy in those moments. I loved it and highly recommend it.



Copy provided by publisher through Edelweiss
Profile Image for Renee.
5,431 reviews77 followers
November 20, 2026
I received a copy of this book from the publisher/author to review.

This is the story of Seraphine and Royal. This is a fantasy book and is different from any other TL Smith book I have read. She is a girl living life the best she can when she starts having strange dreams. Dreams so real she wonders how someone could touch her and leave marks. What is happening to her ?? He is a King who has been searching for the fate spinner for many years. He never expected her to feel like his mate too. He is a cursed kind and can’t leave his castle. There is no escape. She is his only hope. And thats about all I can tell you. There’s a lot going on, and you’re figuring things out with Seraphine. What more could a girl want than an evil king, wolves, vampires and dragons!!! I really enjoyed reading this book.
Profile Image for Yvette.
190 reviews6 followers
November 20, 2026
This story follows Seraphine, a young woman who was raised to believe she was an ordinary human, never knowing that she possesses a rare gift that allows her to travel between worlds and realms. Her journey—and perhaps her fate—leads her to the Cursed King, Royal.

As Seraphine begins to uncover the truth about where she comes from, the powers she possesses, and the destiny that awaits her, she must question everything and everyone she has ever known. With danger lurking around every corner and powerful enemies determined to threaten the realms, Seraphine and Royal must face impossible obstacles and uncover secrets that could change everything.

Will Seraphine, with Royal by her side, have what it takes to overcome their enemies and protect all the realms from the evil that threatens to consume them?
Profile Image for Eva.
899 reviews17 followers
Review of advance copy
November 16, 2026
Love a witch FMC…

I'm calling her a witch, but maybe it doesn't fully fit. She could dream-travel, and he needed her to escape. While the tropes were what called me to this book, the execution was not fully there. It felt a bit like throwing every fantasy element in here and shaking it.

The MMC, being Death's son and uber powerful, needed her to escape, locked her up, and was a meanie because...? And it wasn't enemies-to-lovers, because she found him hot WAAAAY too quickly for that. Their connection was lackluster, and I found myself wanting more from the side characters' romances than the main couple.

Thank you, Podium, and the author, for this arc!
Profile Image for Jamie.
172 reviews
Review of advance copy
November 14, 2026
This was.... not good. I'm disappointed, because the basis of the plot had so much potential. I'm giving it the two stars for the ideas that were there, but the writing was weak at best. There were many aspects of the story that were underdeveloped, characters that seemed to pop up out of no where with no explanations. Even worse was the editing - basic punctuation got missed, and more than a few times I saw repetition in the phrases that didn't even make sense. On one page "he wasn't wearing a hood" then a page and a half later "he removes his hood". Things like this are impossible to overlook, for me at least.

*edited to add, I got an advance copy of this from my Allurial subscription, which was an absolute gorgeous edition
Profile Image for AGirlReadsandWrites.
83 reviews1 follower
November 20, 2026
I got this as one of my November Allurial picks. The premise of the book sounded very interesting. However, the execution of the book just fell flat for me. I felt like the characters were very one-dimensional. The story needed a lot more developmental editing. It has a lot of potential, but I just don’t really feel like it was quite ready yet. Towards the end, I didn’t care what was happening with the characters at all and I almost DNF’d it.
Profile Image for Patricia (Spellbound Stories Trish) .
3,097 reviews121 followers
Review of advance copy
November 15, 2026
Wow just WOOOW!

This is unlike anything Smith has written and loved it! Seraphine and Royal’s story is a web of deceit and lies! Their fates are bound but they have to find the truth and uncover how to save not only themselves but the their world. With so much at stake they also have to find a way to not hate each other!

I couldn’t get enough of this world Smith built and just how original and amazing it is!

A must read for anyone who loves a dark romance that will take you to a whole new world’
Profile Image for Sarimarys.
389 reviews37 followers
Read
November 17, 2026
Thank you to Podium and T.L. Smith for providing me with the free eARC and ALC!

Dreams that take you to different worlds, a forbidden kingdom, and a dangerous connection with a mysterious king? This one takes you on quite the adventure!

This was a short, easy to read, fast paced story that kept things moving. And can we talk about all the magical creatures?! You get witches, vampires, werewolves, and DRAGONS! 🐉

I also really enjoyed the audiobook! The duet style narration was a great addition and made the story even more engaging.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 177 reviews