A treasure chest of never-before-collected essays from Frank McCourt, Pulitzer Prize–winning memoirist, and his boisterous brother Malachy, publishing on the 30th anniversary of Angela’s Ashes, with a foreword by Colum McCann
In 1996, a retired New York City high school English teacher published a memoir that took the publishing world by storm. Angela’s Ashes, the story of Frank McCourt’s childhood in Ireland, was a bold account of poverty and family tragedy, suffused with humor and compassion. It went on to sell over ten million copies and won the Pulitzer Prize and National Book Critics Circle Award.
Frank McCourt was suddenly an internationally celebrated memoirist, a writer who had invigorated the genre. But most readers didn’t know that Angela’s Ashes wasn’t Frank’s first published writing.
For years, he and his actor brother Malachy contributed a column to a neighborhood newspaper called The West Side Spirit. Malachy, himself a bestselling writer, also contributed to Our Town, Irish America, and The Southampton Review. And Frank went on to write for prominent publications including The New Yorker, The New York Times, Esquire, Life, and Rolling Stone.
Sez I to Myself collects the best of those essays and works of journalism. Here the brothers McCourt tackle parades and pubs, classrooms and churches, the immigrant experience, loss, 9/11, the writing life, and more. This is a charming, tender, and insightful collection, a welcome new book from two masterful and much-loved writers.
Francis McCourt was an Irish-American teacher and writer. He won a Pulitzer Prize for his book Angela's Ashes, a tragicomic memoir of the misery and squalor of his childhood.
In the concluding essay in this wonderful book of essays written by the brothers Frank or Malachy McCourt, Frank is speaking to a conference of teachers. He's already implied in his talk that he's off script, which is to say he has diverted from both his written materials and the subject matter that he was asked to address. In this digression, McCourt talks about what it's really like to be a teacher, the honesty of the students, the stories each has of their lives, and in particular, being a teacher in the New York City public schools, many of which were not at Stuyvesant where McCourt spent 18 years before he retired and wrote what I thought might have been the best book I ever read, certainly the best memoir. But before he winds up his digression, he tells a story to the group of teachers sitting before him and says that, even in retirement, walking around New York City, he recognizes former students who address him and remind him that he used to be their teacher.
Sometimes, McCourt says, I recognize them, too. So, he tells his audience, I'm walking down 2nd Avenue in the Village, and a young man approaches and addresses him as follows, "hello, Mr. McCourt" and as Frank tells the story, he says back to the young man, "Hi, Moose." Well, the young man must be surprised because he says to McCourt, you remember my name? And, McCourt says back, sure, I do Moose Klein, I know you were in my class. The young man says back, yes, I was in your class for 2 years. McCourt says, "so, how're you doing, Moose?" The young man replied:
"I was in your class for two years, and because of you, I became a poet. And now I'm starving. And fuck you."
McCourt tells his audience, "You can't beat those moments of honesty."
Frank died first and Malachy lived on until 2024, and he gave himself the prerogative of including more of his essays in this book. Both are terrific writers, but Frank McCourt, I think, was something truly special. He never forgot that he was dirt poor and that his mother had nothing when she came alone to America with her struggling family. McCourt was the real thing with a very deep spiritual side, even though, like Malachy, he rejected Roman Catholicism, or should I say Irish Roman Catholicism, because, as anyone can see, the Irish were not just Catholics but the true believers of the Faith. McCourt, having been raised Catholic became a bit of an apostate like Malachy, who, in addition, was a flat out atheist, made no pretenses of accepting anything the Church tried to impart to him, and added all the sins of a few of the priests and nuns to include anyone serving the Church as a priest or nun. Frank probably felt most of that anger, too, but while Frank rejected the most of the doctrine and the demand for subservience, he lived according to some of those simple, most fundamental ethical principles of love, empathy, good will toward all, contrition, respect for immigrants and their families, and humor, something that being poor, Irish, and Catholic instilled in him for his entire life. And, of course, he never lost the humour that being Irish, Catholic, and poor requires just to get through life. If you read Angela's Ashes, or Tis, or even most of these essays, you'll understand what I mean. The real thing, Frank McCourt was.
One more thing. If you want to understand the depth of Frank McCourt's curiosity and his love of the written word, read the essay about Tim Costello, the bartender at a saloon McCourt, just arrived in New York, frequented. Costello told McCourt, to "get out my bar" and walk a few blocks over to the NYC Public Library, perhaps New York's best contribution to civilization, and get a library card which allowed him, said Costello, to order a book, pick it up in the reading room, and read it there or take it home if you promise to return it soon enough. This same essay first appeared in the NY Times in 1997, the first time I remember reading it, and now I was reading it again. Despite all the years between readings, I had the same warm feeling I had when I read it the first time. Anyone who has ever walked through the NYC Public Library and its kingly Reading Room will instantly understand what McCourt was saying and writing about, which is, I believe, what made him the real thing and the great writer he was.
Sez I to Myself is a rich and engaging collection that brings together Frank McCourt and Malachy McCourt's newspaper columns, essays from major American publications, and public speeches. Previously scattered across different sources, these pieces come together here to showcase the brothers' distinctive, yet complementary, voices.
The subjects range widely: reviews of various pubs and houses of faith, the shadow cast by 9/11, obituaries for friends, Frank's memories of the classroom, and the lifelong imprint of an Irish Catholic upbringing. Moving from everyday observations to deeper cultural and personal insights, the essays blend wit with genuine emotional depth.
What makes this collection shine is the brothers' spot-on, honest, and often laugh-out-loud storytelling. Sharp observations, heartfelt memories, and moments of real humor sit side by side. You can't help but think how lucky the people who actually knew them were, but through this book, readers get the chance to know them a little too. Wise, honest, and never afraid to say things as they saw them, these two voices are a genuine find for fans of memoir and personal essay alike.
Sez I to Myself: The Collected Essays by Frank and Malachy McCourt is a very highly recommended collection of essays, articles, and speeches from the brothers which span decades. For those who have enjoyed their writing over the years this will be a welcomed and cherished addition to your library. I have been anxiously anticipating reading this and it was a pleasure to do so.
Both of the McCourt brothers were gifted story tellers and known for their wit, shared memories, insight and keen observations. All of the pieces included are exceptionally well-written and distinctly personal from their individual points-of-view. The pieces in this collection run the gamut from humorous to deeply serious. Frank (1930–2009) died at 72 and his brother, Malachy (1931–2024) at 92. It is a pleasure to read every one of these pieces.
The essays are sorted into eight topics. Each essay is presented with it's title, where it was published, the date of publication and which McCourt authored the piece. There is a Foreword and Editor's note by Tom Allon and Jonah Allon and Acknowledgements at the end. Contents include (I'm only including the date and author of the essays):
The Writing Life: Looking at Schools, Bars, and Houses of Worship (1987, Frank); My Mission: Write 800 Words Weekly (2001, Malachy); Growing Dependent on the Wayne Independent (2003, Malachy); Excerpt from a 2003 Speech at the Southampton Writers Conference (Frank); Yes, I Can Go Home Again (2000, Malachy)
McSorley's and the Rest: McSorley's: A Great Manhattan Pub (1987, Frank); Kiss Me I'm Irish (1999, Malachy); Yes, Recovery's Possible (2001, Malachy); A Ship, A Pint, and a Pamplona (1988, Frank)
The Religious Life: When You Think of God What Do You See? (1998, Frank); Defenders of the Faith (2000, Malachy); The People of Mercy at Ansche Chesed (1988, Frank); This Old House (1999, Malachy); Exploration and "Humanness" (1988, Frank); They're Seeking Scapegoats (2002, Malachy); The Pope and I (2003, Frank); Mourning My Pals (2001, Malachy); Spiritual Business as Usual at Methodist Church (1988, Frank); Where We Pray (2004, Frank)
New York City and 9/11: We Share Certain Images From the 11th. They Won't Go Away (2001, Frank); A Season to Honor Fallen Firefighters (2001, Malachy); The Dog's Days of Summer (2004, Frank); Advice: Get Out (2001, Malachy); New York: My Town, One Year On (2002, Frank); Packing For America (2004; Frank); Remembering John Scanlon (2001, Malachy); Because of the Pitcher's Eye (2000, Frank); What About the Homeless? (2005, Malachy); From an Affair with Books to a Book Fair (1997, Frank); How Tragedy Reveals America's Vital Heart (2001, Malachy); Seeing Rudy the G. Through a Hayes (1999, Malachy); The Day the Lights Went Out: Blackouts, a Rite of New York (2003, Frank)
The Classroom: On Staten Island: a Buried Treasure (1998, Frank); Brandeis Class Examines Afro-American Literature (1987, Frank); Mothers Who Get By (1997, Frank); An Immodest Proposal (1999, Malachy); What Children Really Want for 1988 (1988, Frank); Love and Learning at Children's Storefront (1988, Frank); Not for Extra Credit (1999, Frank); Hope and Education (1998, Frank); This West Side Story Is Doing What You Want (1988, Frank)
The Irish Life and St. Patrick's Day: Visiting with Bill at a Magazine Pow Wow (2001, Malachy); Patrick Was No Saint (2002, Malachy); Getting Mired in the Oul' Sod (1970, Frank); Cardinal Sins (1999, Malachy); On the Trail of a Jewish Princess (1971, Frank); Neighbors Provide Entertainment (1998, Malachy); Back on the Job (2002, Malachy); A Parcel of Celtic Paradox (1998, Frank); Ashes to Ashes? (2001, Malachy); Blowing the Lid Off... The Spud (1990, Frank); James Joyce Destroyed My Romance (1997, Frank)
Family: My Mother (2009, Frank); Not Ordinary Ever (1999, Malachy); Christmas Past (1997, Frank); The Brother (1998, Malachy); The Random Nature of the Grim Reaper (2000, Malachy); The Good Old Days of Raising Kids Are Over (2001, Malachy); My Unsainted Brother (2009, Malachy); Deadhead Daughter (1998, Frank)
Bits and Pieces: The Puritanical Punishing World of Business (2001, Malachy); A Diseased Nation Moans (2000, Malachy); Saluting a Fine Young Man (1999, Malachy); Closing a Hellhole (2000, Malachy); Smoke Out the Smokers (2002, Malachy); A Speech at the 2002 Southampton Writers Conference (Frank)
Sez I to Myself: The Collected Essays is an excellent choice for those who appreciated the McCourt's writing and is perfect addition to any library. Thanks to Abrams Press for providing me with an advance reader's copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and expresses my honest opinion.
For those familiar and unfamiliar with the writings of Frank and Malachy McCourt, “Sez I to Myself: The Collected Essays of Frank & Malachy McCourt”, will be an unexpected surprise. This is a most impressive collection of essays edited by Tom Allon and his son Jonah – Tom Allon may be known best as the publisher of Manhattan community newspapers where many of these essays first appeared in print. This is a superb introduction to the McCourt brothers’ writings for those unfamiliar with them, but it will also appeal to long-time fans of their writing, with Frank probably known best still for his memoirs “Angela’s Ashes”, “’Tis” and “Teacher Man”, and Malachy for his memoirs and his books on Irish culture and history. This essay collection is a superb journalistic recounting of what life was like in New York City from the late 1980s to early 2000s; those essays written by Malachy concluded always with the phrase “Sez I to Myself”. The essay collection is introduced by a terse, quite memorable, foreword from notable Irish writer Colum McCann, who notes how important their journalistic essays are, and how they will be compared favorably with the writings of noted New York City-based journalists and authors Pete Hamill and his brothers, as well as Jimmy Breslin, noting that though they themselves weren’t journalists, did write like them, with Frank’s writing especially notable for its “more subtle and poetic approach”. McCann’s essay concludes with a memorable description of what would be one of Frank McCourt’s final moments on earth back in July, 2009.
The essays were collected by members of the McCourt family and Tom Allon, who edited them with his son Jonah. The essay collection is divided into eight sections; The Writing Life, McSorley’s and the Rest, The Religious Life, New York City and 9/11. The Classroom, The Irish Life and St. Patrick’s Day, Family, and Bits and Pieces. Essays in each of the sections often have the writings of one brother follow the other, giving readers a rich, quite extensive, look at the similarities and differences between their writings. If there are surprises in this volume, then it is first and foremost, the ample humility that the brothers show within their writings, which might be a lesson worth learning for others interested in writing, not only journalism, but for subjects as diverse as the fine arts, economics, history and the sciences. What is also surprising that in The Classroom, doesn’t describe his teaching life at Stuyvesant High School – where he spent most of his career teaching – but instead, has brief essays describing teaching styles of various teachers as well as a brief autobiographical essay that discusses how he became a teacher. In the sections The Religious Life and The Irish Life and St. Patrick’s Day, the brothers describe their conflicted views of Roman Catholic Christianity – especially the Irish version – and Irish culture and history, especially surrounding the celebration of St. Patrick’s Day. Other sections cover their time in many of New York City’s most notable Irish-American bars (McSorley’s and the Rest), and their reaction to and subsequent response to 9/11 and what transpired in New York City in the years immediately following the 9/11 terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center.
I can’t conclude this review without noting that those interested in the literary legacy left by the Brothers McCourt should read the writings of journalists David Lipsky – most likely Frank’s best student who is himself also a highly regarded author of fiction – and Laurie Gwen Shapiro and Alissa Quart, novelist and memoirist Susan J. Gilman and playwright Maureen McSherry. On a more personal note, I will add that I attended a memorial service for Frank’s former students that was organized by Gilman and McSherry within days of Frank’s passing in 2009. (I will note that I was fortunate to have been one of Frank’s prize winning students when I studied English and creative writing with him during my junior year at New York City’s prestigious Stuyvesant High School.)
Without question, “Sez I to Myself” will be an excellent addition to anyone’s library, whether they are devoted fans of the Brothers McCourt or encountering their writings for the first time. This is a remarkably terse, well-edited essay collection that compares favorably with other essay collections I have read, most notably those written by the late Harvard University evolutionary biologist and invertebrate paleontologist Stephen Jay Gould.
The audiobook version of this was a bit confusing at first; I think I listened to 3 intros in a row--thinking each was the beginning of the book--before it finally started. The two brothers have very distinct styles (despite using the same narrator) so it took me a while to adjust to the extremely different tones in their writing, until I learned to pay more attention to each chapter intro to know what I was getting into. Some of the chapters are quite funny and insightful, while some are crushing and bitter. Both siblings care deeply about vulnerable populations (as you'd expect from Angela's Ashes), and have intense politics as a result, though the "Sez I, to Myself" at the end of many chapters makes the writing come across as reflective rather than combative.
I really enjoyed the interplay of the two brothers whose lives (of course) interact sometimes, so you sometimes see things from both perspectives--like one brother describing his life in the classroom, then later the sibling talks about his brother as a teacher and students he's met. Although the book does include intermittent insightful humor, it also spends time diving into items with painful clarity, like discussing a divorce and subsequently failing a daughter. It can be quite intense, but ultimately is a satisfying read that feels deeply important.
----- NOTE: I received a free copy of this audiobook in exchange for a review expressing my personal opinions.
Sez I to Myself: The Collected Essays of Frank and Malachy McCourt
This collection gathers the brothers’ writing from newspaper columns, major American publications, and public speeches, bringing their distinctive voices together in this publication.
The subjects range widely: reviews of various pubs and houses of faith, the shadow cast by 9/11, obituaries for friends, Frank’s memories of the classroom, and the lifelong imprint of an Irish Catholic upbringing.
For readers who have enjoyed their memoirs, appreciate Irish writing, or savour a blend of wit and melancholy, these chapters have much to offer you as insights into the lives of Angela’s infamous sons.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I enjoyed reading Sez I to Myself considerably more than I anticipated. The collection of essays brought me back to a time and challenged my memories. As a teacher myself the protrayal of life in the classroom was very accurate I found it humorous and at times very touching. This collection made me laugh while also containing great sadness. This book is a very different and worthwhile read. The brothers were such fine writers if felt like such a treat to enjoy these uncovered treasures.
This is just so wonderful. I was listening to these guys, relating to their experiences, and wishing I was as nice as they are. They've clearly made such an impression on so many people and you can see why here. These essays talk about topics that are so relevant to the world today. Thanks to NetGalley for letting me listen to this beautifully narrated collection
I took Frank McCourt’s creative writing course four semesters in a row at Stuyvesant High School. I fell for his charm, humor and kindness the first class. My memories of him had receded over the decades since graduating. Reading Sez I to Myself has been like meeting him all over again. It was so good to be in his company again, to be reminded of the old stories, to read some new ones and to meet his wild and funny brother.
I loved Frank McCourt’s books: Angela’s Ashes (in my top 10), ‘Tis, Teacher Man. I loved Malachy McCourt’s writings, and growing up, I listened to his radio shows so long ago. This is a fascinating book, essays written by both brothers with such familiarity, wit, and such keen observation. Highly recommended for fans, and those who will be fans.
A magnificent collection of essays by Frank McCourt and his brother Malachy. The humour found in Angela's Ashes shows itself in a number of these magnificent essay. If you've read Angela's Ashes you will know what a treat your in for. If you haven't read Angela's Ashes, dip in you'll love it. I received a review copy of this book free of charge and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This is a book of essays or short stories by the brothers Frank and Malachy McCourt. Their stories are from newspaper columns and other writings. They write with humor and wit and keep your attention. I have enjoyed all their books, from Angela's Ashes and Monk Swimming. They are both gone now, so I was excited to find this book of Essays. It is a wonderful book full of their Irish stories.
Various newpaper articles and speeches given by the brothers, they showcase a NYC where each bar was its own neighborhood, as well as memories of their childhood, reviews of restaurants and sermons. Interesting to see the articles vs the later ones, when they were both famous. Skipped some of Malachy's, but read each of Franks...
This was a fun and easy listen! Loved the narrator’s voice, he was very pleasant on the ear. This collection of essays made for good background noise while doing other things - some were very interesting and some not so much, but overall I enjoyed this. I wish each essay had been its own chapter though, as that would have made it easier to skip ahead if one did not interest me!
After reading Angela's Ashes, 'Tis and Teacher Man I was thrilled to receive this copy of Sez I to Myself by the brothers McCourt. A number of the essays were funny, and a few were sad, but they were all thought-provoking. They bring life to simple experiences and heart to the sad ones.
To be honest, when I received this arc in the spring, I wasn't too excited to pick it up. When I finally got around to it, I was charmed. Two distinct but complementary voices. Understated in a sly Irish way and dryly humorous (my favorite kind).
A very interesting, at times serious and at times amusing, collection of articles written by the two McCourt brothers, Frank and Malachy. The articles written for a variety of publications give a fascinating insight into what was happening at various times and their views. Beautifully written and a pleasure to read. Recommended. Thank you to NetGalley for an arc in exchange for an honest review.