In this wordless, all-ages graphic novel, our protagonist discovers a leaf that radiates a vibrant life. He returns to a meticulously wrought metropolis—depicted in somber grays and blues—and searches for answers. During his quest, he stumbles upon a man who knows what's really happening in the city's labyrinthine ducts; a woman who spends her life studying and classifying obsolete flora; and the truth about the ever-dwindling environment.
Powerful and subtle Chinese silent graphic novel that reminds one of Shaun Tan's The Arrival in style, exquisite pencil drawings, muted allegorical story of industrialization and the need for light and color. A leaf, representative of the natural world opposing the oppressive urbanscape, emanates colored light in the dark city. There's an environmental theme as we see both the increasing loss of the natural world and the possibility, maybe even necessity, of the presence of nature in our increasingly stressful urban lives.
I see now that the back cover also mentions Chris Van Allsburg's Jumanji as another comparison, and that seems right, too.
Don't know silent graphic novels for all ages? Check out the three mentioned here or go to my GN-Silent list for suggestions!
میتونین از اینجا کتاب رو قرض بگیرین برای یک ساعت و بخونین: https://archive.org/details/leaf0000m... اخیرا خیلی به گرافیک ناولهای بدون نوشته علاقه پیدا کردم و متاسفانه سخت پیدا میشن توی اینترنت. تجربهی جالبیه خوندنشون، مخصوصا این کار چینی از نظرم اثر قابل توجهیه.
Amongst the humdrum day of the city autumn, where cables replace vines, lamps smother fireflies and factories obscure mountains, a young man finds a curiously glowing leaf.
An utterly exquisite, wordless story of natural beauty in a mechanical world. Although mostly printed in dull pencil grey, the book is splashed with serene and sombre blues and warming gold lights, adding a tranquil, at times cozy feel to the expressive faces and compact streets of our protagonist, making the greyscale all the more morose and lifeless whenever the fleeting colour vanishes.
As to the story, there is none to some extent, save our hero's quest to find the secret of his luminescent tree feather, but really the answer is irrevelevant. If I could sound like a complete ponce for a moment (rather than just a regular one), the story is less a narrative and more a sensation, invoking nostalgia, alienation and, crucially, hope. Hope of what, nostalgia for when and why we should feel so alone and isolated is never overtly stated, but the feelings it invokes are palpable and very universal. Although the setting is distinctly East Asian at times, the city itself can feel like any town, in any country, with its narrow alley ways, lifeless bricks, street hawkers and dreary jobs, but everywhere dimly glows with both real and false, but always comforting, little lights.
Really gorgeous and interesting concept...it was a little unclear what was happening in some parts, but I think with longer time spent dwelling on the details, more meanings could be found.
Shaun Tan’ın Uzak eserindeki gibi sözcük kullanılmamış. Çizimleri Uzak’a benzer ama daha basit denilebilinir. Hiç kelime olmadığı için Türkçe baskısını beklemek zorunda değilsiniz. Amazon ya da bookdepository gibi sitelerden alın derim.
Beautiful, beautiful art, but the lack of dialogue made this a little too obtuse for me. This definitely requires a 2nd read as there was a lot that I just didn't "get" here, though I understood that it was an examination of technology vs nature and a critique of industrialization.
The artwork showcased here is *beautiful* though. Ma's style is very soft and uses pencils (or maybe charcoals) to draw these barren urban landscapes that are packed with detail. The judicious use of colour (blues and yellows) is used to good effect as well. The art alone makes it worth a "read" (it's a wordless comic, so you're not reading per se, but you know what I mean).
This book itself looks like such an art piece, the librarian even commented on it during checkout! I love this art style in a graphic novel, with beautiful shading. I particularly found the expressiveness of our main character well drawn. I am not sure the story overall resonated with me; I felt it lacked some of the emotional clarity and depth that could have driven its message home. I don’t think this is because of its wordlessness. One of my top 5 books of all time is The Arrival, which this is often compared to. I don’t think that is entirely true, but it does have the same quiet loneliness. I’m sad this didn’t have the impact I hoped for but overall, beautiful art.
An urbanite walks around the woods outside of his city when he comes across a strange, glowing leaf. He pockets the oddity before returning back to the metropolis to resume his daily drudgery, soon realizing that the leaf in his possession seems to be altering the environment by causing other objects to illuminate. He starts to seek out local experts that may know more about this leaf's strange properties, and in doing so discovers revelations about how his civilization operates and its connection to nature.
This was just ok, cozy and intricate charcoal pencil art in service of an uninspired and shallow narrative. The messaging of the book is not much more substantive than "humanity shouldn't exploit the environment" which, while as good a moral as any, seems rather superficially developed in this book. While it feels a bit unfair to criticize a silent comic for not delivering complex themes, this experience felt so thin and on-the-nose that I feel underwhelmed instead of moved. There is perhaps some contextual framing I missed which touches on the particular flavor of industrialized resource extraction present in 20th Century China, but the overall presentation seemed rather broad and neutered to draw any interesting parallels.
The art is really enticing however, with a soft but richly penciled aesthetic that utilizes some attractive two / three tone palettes. The visual language is snug and warm, evocative when nature and civilization reach harmony but also feels a bit incongruent when used to depict the more severe or unnatural settings (like a sweatshop that seems comfy). I also didn't really understand the thematic reason behind the transition between blue and yellow dominated palettes (yellow means society is becoming more in tune with nature?) but the contrast helped keep the visual experience fresh in any case.
En bok som med sin ordlösa historia, allegoriska tematik, alternativa, lätt steampunk-inspirerade verklighet och mjuka, semirealistiska, sepiafärgade blyertsteckningar är tydligt inspirerad av illustratören Shaun Tan i allmänhet och hans hyllade storverk Ankomsten i synnerhet. Sämre förebilder kan man dock ha, och Mas serieroman står på egna ben. Berättelse är öppen för tolkningar, men handla övergripande om kontrasten mellan industrialismen och naturen, representerad av glödande löv som huvudpersonen försöker förstå sig på. Serien är vacker, med en enfärgad verklighet som bryts av visuellt av blå och gula element, som bär olika allegoriska konnotationer. Inte riktigt en fempoängare, men helt klart en av de bättre serieromanerna jag läst på ett bra tag.
English: A book that with its wordless history, allegorical themes, alternative, steampunk-inspired reality and soft, semi-realistic, sepia pencil drawings are clearly inspired by illustrator Shaun Tan in general and his acclaimed masterpiece The Arrival in particular. But you can of course have worse role models, and Ma's graphic novel has its own merits. The story is open to interpretation, but seems to discuss the contrast between industrialization and nature, represented by glowing leaves that the main character tries to understand. This graphic novel is beautifully rendered, with a mono-colour reality that is visually interspersed by blue and yellow elements, which carry different allegorical connotations. The Leaf is not perfect, but it's definitely one of the better graphic novels I've read in a while.
I don't get it. It's beautifully drawn. The gray drawings warmed up with the glow of yellow as the light jumps from object to object. It's interesting to have seen the city grow out from the one house and then become a labyrinth of pipes on the sides and roofs of all the houses leading out towards the what, light factory? time factory? I don't know. wordless comics apparently can be about nothing and something all at once.
I wasn't that excited about this book. While the premise was interesting, I was never pulled into the heart of the story. The book is full of wonderful line drawings with intentionally sparse colouring that helps to focus your attention to allow better understanding of the wordless story. I can't describe exactly what was missing for me - the pacing seemed good.
From an art standpoint, I thought the illustrations were beautiful. From a storytelling standpoint, I am not sure what the book was about. I had to read the summary on the back of the book so I could get a handle on the plot.
Leaf by Daishu Ma is a dreamily realized story that is told in silent panels and beautifully illustrated pencil. The artwork displays gorgeous renditions of both the natural and industrial world while also breathing life on the page that almost feels so perfect that it could be rendered in a 3D program with a pencil shader. It reminds me of My Favorite Thing Is Monsters with the level of detail and precision (but this one does not have writing).
The lead character finds a special leaf and goes on an adventure that ponders around the mixture of organic and manmade. Unfortunately, the actual panels are more interpretive than narrative. I learned more about the story when I read the description of the book after finishing. I got the broad strokes while I was reading, but I didn’t catch as much of the detail in the narrative.
Nevertheless, the book is a nice read. I’m glad I got it through the library because the art was amazing but the narrative was just okay, so I saved some money on that front. Check to see if your library has a copy either physically or digitally for a nice, pleasant read.
"grainy" covers-> if sticker remover skip ex-library
China!
Despite the excitement of rare origin and wordlessness, this is confusing and boring. It's only a bit endearing. I'm not going to try to describe it and what it MIGHT "mean" so read the others' takes on that.
The art is a very good pencilfest of nature versus metropolis.
Beautiful, but a little hard to follow in places! The description says “all ages” but I don’t think this is a picture book that young children would enjoy. Better for adults who are looking for something similar to Shaun Tan’s Arrival.
3.5 stars rounded up. Lovely and mysterious and maybe just a little lacking? I feel like there was a large idea here that was somewhat imperfectly communicated. Although, perhaps that was intentional? A gorgeously rendered sad world that I’m sure is intended as a warning for our own.
A wonderful gentle adventure, illustrated in a style very reminiscent of my favourite book, Shaun Tan's The Arrival. I love how the silent storytelling encourages you to read slowly and really soak in every panel. Beautiful book. Will be re-reading it for sure.