From nationally bestselling author and artist Grant Snider comes a powerful and inventive middle-grade illustrated novel-in-verse about overcoming perfectionism, discovering the power of art, and surviving seventh grade“A beautifully written, designed, and illustrated story! Grant Snider's poetry sings and captivated my heart on every page! I couldn't put it down! Buy it. Read it. Share it!” —John Schu, librarian and New York Times bestselling author of Louder Than HungerAdam has always been the kid who could draw. But this year, everything feels off.His parents are fighting. A bully is picking on him. There's a new artist in school. His life is changing . . . faster than he can keep up.As Adam's world turns upside down, he can feel his love of drawing slipping away. But who is Adam without art?
Grant Snider began drawing and writing before he knew what he was doing. Soon it was too late to stop.
He is the author of the picture books WHAT COLOR IS NIGHT? and WHAT SOUND IS MORNING? and the creator of Incidental Comics. His comics were collected and published in the books THE SHAPE OF IDEAS and I WILL JUDGE YOU BY YOUR BOOKSHELF. Grant's comics about creativity and the human condition have appeared in The New York Times, The New Yorker, and The Best American Comics.
Grant lives in Wichita, Kansas with his wife, daughter, and three sons, where he also practices orthodontics. You can often find him carrying a sketchbook, lost in his own thoughts.
Poor Adam Zanes (nicknamed A2Z by his bestie Gideon Dawes)! In this illustrated book of poems targeted at tweens and teens, one poem summarizes Adam’s dilemma:
The closer I look the more I realize My family is not normal
His mother and alcoholic father loudly argue over his drinking. Until they stop speaking at all. Adam’s older brother Evan has gone off to college. On top of that, seventh-grader Adam encounters a bully and falls to second-best artist behind a new girl, Marisa Mira.
Author/illustrator Grant Snider traces Adam’s seventh-grade year at Goldengrove Middle School when the boy who loved drawing decides to give it up, thinking it’s useless if you’re not the best. We see how Adam deals with his parents’ separation, his own lack of self-esteem and finding his place. The middle-grade novel started out a bit sappy, but Snider really nailed the ending.
In the interest of full disclosure, I received this book from NetGalley, ABRAMS Kids and Amulet Books in exchange for an honest review.
Adam Zanes loves to draw because it takes his focus off of the problems in his life, and it's part of his identity. He's the best drawer in the seventh grade at Goldengrove Middle School. His best friend, Gideon, is into stand up comedy and is more popular than Adam, who feels like his sidekick. When a new student, Marisa, arrives in his art class, he starts to realize he might not be the best drawer anymore. Other things are weighing on him. His brother Evan is off at college, and his father is drinking more and more, and fighting with his mother. There's also classmate Jason, who is mean to him for no particularly good reason. As the school year progresses, we see Adam's perspective (as well as illustrations) for the school dance, trick or treat, and the film on puberty that his class is shown. This is particulary pertinent, as Adam is struggling with a variety of adolescent conditions, like acne and voice changes. He's unhappy in art class, which usually is a place that brings him joy, and after he drawings a disturbing portrait of his father surrounded by beer cans, the teacher has him visit with Mr. Hopkins, the school counselor. After his father moves out, Adam doesn't hand in some of his homework and is visibly unhappy. Mr. Hoping suggests that he try something new, since he's not drawing, and Adam tries several activities before realizing that running for Coach Wilson on the track team is enjoyable. He visits his father at his new apartment, and is glad to see his father start to get his life back on track. He even bonds with Jason over the fact that their fathers live in the same complex. Will Adam be able to regain his joy in drawing once his difficult year starts to settle down? Strengths: There will always be middle school students who are very interested in drawing, and who take great comfort in carrying their notebooks around with them, but there aren't that many books (other than Kowitt's 2011 The Loser List) that have characters with this interest. Adam faces a number of realistic challenges, including the all too common occurence of parents separating. He has a great support network, with teachers at school checking on him, Evan and his mother being involved, and Gideon, who is a great friend. I love that he got involved with running and laughed out loud that the track team was referred to as "the stick figures": middle school runners do often look just like that! Snider is the author of a variety of illustrated philosophical works that are often in verse, so it was interesting to see him turn his hand to middle grade. It also helps explain the allusion to Hopkins' poem, Spring and Fall. Not sure that many tweens will get the reference to Goldengrove! Weaknesses: This is a novel in verse, which is still a hard sell at my school. Had there been more pictures, students might be more likely to pick it up. I'm not sure any middle schools show videos about puberty-- that's a very 1970s thing I have not seen done during my teaching career, which started in 1989! Not a lot happens in the book, but there is a lot of swirling angst. What I really think: This is a good choice for readers who enjoyed the illustrated angst of middle school in Schu's 2024 Louder Than Hunger or Vivat's 2016 Frazzled.
Adam has always been known for his artistic abilities. He’s found comfort and joy in expressing himself through drawing. However, this school year brings challenges he never expected. Tension between his parents makes home life difficult, a bully turns school into a struggle, and the arrival of a talented new artist named Marisa leaves Adam questioning his own abilities. As he tries to navigate these changes, the passion that once came so naturally to him begins to fade. Drawing has always been an important part of his identity and it no longer provides the same sense of happiness or security. Caught between the pressures of growing up and the fear of losing what makes him unique, Adam must find his footing as he faces an increasingly unfamiliar world.
Grant Snider explores family struggles, insecurity, friendship, and the awkwardness of growing up in this illustrated novel in verse. I appreciated how realistically Adam’s challenges were portrayed, particularly the helplessness of watching your family change and the frustration of dealing with a bully. Adam’s gradual journey toward opening himself up again has some genuinely sweet moments, and I loved the illustrations, which add personality and emotion to his experiences. That said, this was just an okay read for me. I could sympathize with Adam and recognize the validity of his struggles, but I never felt particularly connected to him. I’m also not the biggest fan of novels in verse, which may have contributed to my difficulty getting invested in the story. While I appreciated the themes of accepting imperfection, exploring new interests, and learning that you don’t always have to be the best at something to enjoy it, the emotional impact fell a little flat for me. On the other hand, I enjoyed seeing the art and appreciated that the art that was described in the text was also illustrated for readers to see. I think the progression in the illustrations complimented the story nicely. The art style was quite unique in that it consisted of black and white sketches which reminded me of doodling in the margins of paper in school when I was younger. The art style was definitely fitting for Adam. Ultimately, I think I appreciated what this book was trying to accomplish more than I actually enjoyed reading it. There’s nothing particularly wrong with the story, and I can see it resonating with young readers navigating similar experiences. It just didn’t quite click for me personally.
Pine Reads Review would like to thank NetGalley and Amulet Books for sending us an ARC in exchange for an honest review. Any quotes are taken from an advanced copy and may be subject to change before final publication.
Follow us on Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, and Facebook @pinereadsreview, and check out our website at www.pinereadsreview.com for reviews, author interviews, blogs, podcast episodes, and more!
Thank you ABRAM kids and NetGalley for the chance to read this ARC!
Adam Zanes is your average kid going through puberty and seventh grade, enjoying creating comics and art. Yet this year his parents are fighting, sometimes loudly sometimes quietly, a bully keeps picking on him, a new kid in school is better at art than him. He struggles to keep up with all the changes going on in his life, slowly giving up on art and other things. When a picture sends him to the counselor's office at a teacher's recommendation, Adam is given some homework-trying something new. Despite the struggles, Adam learns from this crazy year, slowly getting his creative spark back.
I've been a huge fan of Snider's work-his comics are so inspiring, so I was ecstatic to hear he was writing a novel in verse and also be able to read it! This is such a wonderful story, this will speak to a lot of creatives. It can be hard to create when times get tough and it feels so cathartic feeling inspired again.
Adam's story really captures growing up such as puberty being "like drawing a horse on a bicycle", the frustrations of dealing with a bully, and the helplessness when your parents are fighting. I was captured by his story as he starts to close himself off and then slowly being to open up again. There's also some joys that warm your heart such as taking a bath after getting muddy, trading cards with friends, and even-one I think that any kid or kid-at-heart will love-getting a gummy worm stuck on the ceiling and watching it just stick there, which is such a great symbolism of just hanging in there in toughest of times, because that's all you really can do, and it does get better.
The art is also fantastic-there are a few comics such as a catapult actually launching cats-wonder if that's actually been done in real life-several art projects that display lessons, to even crumbled up papers that show Adam's frustration and separation of art.
Overall, this is a wonderful tale about growing up, learning to embrace imperfection and trying new things. Perfect for all the creative kiddos and some adults out there.
Favorite Poem-since this is a novel-in verse-"The Imperfectionist Club", I won't quote all of it here but I absolutely adore the last two lines, "There's room in the club for everyone. Will you join us?"
I love Grant Snider's illustration style very much. Many of his other books are some of my favorites including: Poetry Comics which I love. He is someone I actively follow on social media and I was excited to get an early copy of this book to review.
This is a novel-in-verse with his illustrations throughout the entire book. It follows a middle-schooler named Adam who is dealing with his parents fighting all the time, because of his father's alcoholism. Adam also has growing feelings of self-doubt. Everything is changing for him as he starts seventh grade. Then he decides to give up drawing because he doesn't feel like he is the best at it anymore when a new girl joins his class, who is also an artist. The story follows his entire school year and his journey to self-discovery.
The Year I Stopped Drawing is a relatable book for any age. I believe we all have had at least one moment in our life where we began to doubt ourselves. Middle school is a hard enough time in an adolescent's life and Adam is also dealing with his brother leaving for college, a bully, not feeling like he is good enough, and his parents' fighting.
Grant Snider's art is fantastic and goes along with the story perfectly. I love how we get Adam's thoughts through the poetry and also the illustrations. Such a great way to tell an artist's story. It was wonderful to experience him finding his way again. I particularly loved the ending.
A great story about growing up, finding one's place in the world, and embracing your imperfections. It would be a good read for younger and many older readers alike.
*Thank you Amulet Books, Grant Snider, and NetGalley for my ARC of this book. All opinions are my own.*
I received an autographed ARC of this at the American Library Association conference.
This is the point in my review where I'd usually say something like "verse novels aren't really my thing, but I liked this one alright." I've now read enough of these that I should probably just stop saying that. I don't generally care for poetry, especially non-rhyming poetry, but I do like the way verse novels are easily approachable and relatively quick to read, which is a thing I don't have that much time for these days (ironic, given what I do for a living).
Now enough about me. Adam Zanes (a.k.a. A2Z) is a budding artist and average tween boy whose school year goes off the rails when his parents start having problems at home. Through basically no fault of his own, his life begins to fall apart. To make things worse, a new girl moves to his school and she's a better artist than him! Now, Adam struggles to find comfort in his favorite hobby, his new art teacher earns his distrust, and he finds himself unwillingly having regular visits with the school counselor.
I really found this to be a moving and authentic portrayal of a boy struggling with a difficult home life. Junior high is a tough time for almost anybody, so I think this book definitely would find some welcome readers in the middle grade/younger YA range.
Grant Snider’s The Year I Stopped Drawing is a one-of-a-kind gem. It’s a book I’d love to hand to every sixth grade student as they walk into the school year to tell them, “Don’t worry. It gets better.” Snider has crafted an engaging but honest narrative in verse complimented by doodles, aphorisms, and coping strategies that offer light(ness) in the turmoil of middle school.
Adam is in seventh grade, and he’s always been the best drawer in his class. But this year, things are just off. There’s some trouble at home. There’s a bully. There’s a new girl who might draw better than him. There are many people looking out for him: his friend, his teacher, his parents, his older brother, his counselor. But he’s lost and confused. With a lot of patience and a willingness to try new things, Adam begins to hear the wisdom, care, and vulnerability of others, and he keeps “hanging on” to find his way.
I can’t stress how important this book is for kids, but it’s also really important for adults raising or working with tweens and teens. Every reader will feel seen. Every reader will find hope.
The Year I Stopped Drawing covers Adam's seventh-grade year. His father's drinking causes his family to shatter, a burden made worse for Adam with his brother off to college. Drawing had been his place to find himself, but the upside-down status of his family leaves him disconnected from his art.
Snider's Poetry Comics is one of the most popular poetry volumes in my middle school library, so I love that he chose to tell Adam's story as an illustrated verse novel. Fans of John Schu's Louder Than Hunger will see comparisons -- though this one doesn't feel quite as heavy, maybe because Adam discovers a sense of belonging with the track team. This will be a great title for my reluctant readers -- I just hope they don't find the gummy worm too inspiring.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the digital review copy.
Digital ARC provided by publisher. Lovely illustrations accompany (are) this novel in verse. The author tells a story of a young person who experiences that moment when doubt comes in and they stop doing. He creates a believable and relatable world that upper middle grade through adult readers can appreciate. Fighting parents and the devastation that comes with a family split; bullying at school; changing friendships that are so puzzling at any age, but especially in the middle years. It was a lot without feeling like a lot, and, yet, it’s a lot.
Super relatable for anyone (at any age!) who has let a passion or hobby go during an emotional time or mental health struggle. Love the sketches throughout and the novel in verse style makes this incredibly readable for middle grade kids, too.
Beautifully creative book, with the words, illustrations and layout of prose adding to the sense of the characters feelings. This book tackles big topics effortlessly, showing the journey away from and towards hope for the future.
I read this after purchasing it at my local independent bookstore. It is a gift for my 12-year-old great-nephew. I loved it! Such a great book for those awkward middle school years. Hopefully, it will be a hit for him, as well.
This was a quick read in which most middle school readers will find much to relate to from self-doubt to absolute horror about changing bodies to fury over parents' fighting. Touching at times, humorous at others. A solid addition.