This book genuinely surprised me—in the best way. As someone who reads a lot of fantasy, I’m usually pretty good at spotting the twists before they land. That wasn’t the case here. I kept thinking I had a handle on where the story was heading, and I was wrong more than once. That unpredictability alone made the reading experience feel fresh and exciting.
The pacing is fast, and at times the transitions felt a little abrupt or jumpy. That said, it never pulled me out of the story. If anything, it added to the urgency of everything unfolding around Merrin. For a debut novel, it’s impressive. The scope of the world, the political tension, the magic, and the emotional stakes are ambitious, and K.D. Harding handles them with confidence.
One of the strongest elements is the world-building. It’s layered in naturally rather than delivered in heavy blocks of exposition, which makes it easy to stay immersed. The academy setting, the trials, and the undercurrent of shifting loyalties all create a story that feels expansive without being overwhelming.
Merrin is a compelling lead—determined, flawed, and driven to prove she is more than her title. Her relationships, especially with Laya, add heart to the story. The dynamic between strength, vulnerability, and loyalty is handled well, and the side characters feel purposeful rather than decorative. There’s clearly more to uncover with several of them, which makes me curious to see how future books will develop their arcs.
What stood out most to me is that this story doesn’t rely on predictable tropes or unnecessary embellishments to hold attention. It’s character-driven, layered with mystery, and confident in its own direction. You can see the foundation for something much bigger being built.
For a first book, Gifted sets a high bar. I’m looking forward to seeing where the series goes next.