In the world of sci-fi books alien abductions are an evergreen theme. We could say they are almost the beginning of the genre in all its forms, and the potential of a story about a normal life and a normal human who suddenly is swept away from his or her roots, maybe toward an alien love and an happily ever after, has always had an irresistible appeal on the reader. I, for example, love this type of books, and Unchained memory is an example of this category, that’s why a choose to read it, little did I know that I was in for a big surprise.
In fact the author of Unchained memory, Donna S. Frelick, takes a basilar theme like alien abduction but turns it beyond recognition. The reader is not sure there’s been an alien abduction till the middle of the book, and even then is not a certainty. We have a woman, Asia who as lost three hours of her life. She can’t remember what happened to her during that time, the only thing she knows it’s that something must have happened, and then there are the dreams….She can’t sleep, but she can’t even remember her nightmares. The meeting with Ethan Roberts a psychiatric doctor who treats people who believe to have been abducted by the aliens, will be the turning point of her life. She doesn’t believe that aliens were the cause of her lost time, she has no supposition about that time loss, only a great void, and the fear of being crazy.
Ethan will be able to make her remember her dreams finally, and the scenery they portrait will be a surprise for both of them, because it seem the for months she was a labor slave on an alien planet.
As you can see, this mystery about the memory loss, and the clear intent of the author to not speak clearly about aliens till the middle of the book, are similar to the approach of X-files about the aliens. The method that “says but at the same time not says”. We were never sure about the abduction of Scully, it was clear that the only possible explanation for what happened to her was an alien abduction, but we were never given incontrovertible proof of that. The same with the protagonist of this book. We are never sure till the end about the aliens and even then they are not so central to the story. We don’t even know what they look like, just a vague talk about gray men.
I think is positive to keep the reader in the dark, it creates a certain charm about the story, but at the same time if you keep him too much in the dark, he can loose interest, and in this case the waiting to some clear light about the aliens, was too long. When I read a sci-fi I want aliens. Stop. Not only a long psychological journey, that in this book was also not so profound at all, since Asia and Ethan are hot for each other from the first time they see each other, without an apparent cause.. She is beautiful, he too, so they want to have sex. It doesn’t work for me. A woman with a past like that of Asia, who not only lost three hours of her life, but also her three children in a terrible fire, and who lives in a constant sense of guilt, can’t just decide to trust immediately someone like Ethan. It’s not plausible. And the love story between them to me seem out of place and forced, also because it was too much sensual without so much depth, or so it seem to me. Instead of writing pages about their sex life and their attraction I would have love more pages about the dreams of Asia, her life as a slave….. If I was a woman who finally after years in the dark now has a clear enough idea of what happened to her, I would want to explore my memories every waking moment, to discover more and more! Not play the doctor with my doctor.
The aliens, the alien world, the slavery, and the alliance, the humans that rescue the slaves, that are themes that I would have like to have read more about. They are too much secondary in this book, so much so that I don’t even know if it can be considered a sci-fi.