At Firenze, the reclusive artist Adrian Delafield's Florentine enclave in St John's Wood, the whispers of an impending tragedy are growing louder. The tension between the fanatical zealot of a housekeeper Miss Trimming and Delafield's sister Virgilia is just shy of fever pitch, when a cold morning at the house finds Trimming and Adrian sprawled at either end of the staircase – upstairs, an injury; downstairs, death. The windows and doors were all locked from the inside, and yet Inspector Julian Rivers, trained to see the malice behind deadly accident, suspects that a murderer had a hand in the fell deed. But if this is true, Rivers is faced with both the inexplicable puzzle of motive, and the task of untangling an impossible crime.
Edith Caroline Rivett (who wrote under the pseudonyms E.C.R. Lorac, Carol Carnac, Carol Rivett, and Mary le Bourne) was a British crime writer. She was born in Hendon, Middlesex (now London). She attended the South Hampstead High School, and the Central School of Arts and Crafts in London.
She was a member of the Detection Club. She was a very prolific writer, having written forty-eight mysteries under her first pen name, and twenty-three under her second. She was an important author of the Golden Age of Detective Fiction.
This is one of ECR Lorac's Julian Rivers mysteries that she wrote under the pseudonym of Carol Carnac. I'm fond of Chief Inspector Rivers and his younger colleague Inspector Lancing. Their verbal exchanges were for me the highlight of this book. Otherwise, it was a so-so 'locked room' mystery. There wasn't a whole lot of action, until the last 50 pages, when everything came to a head. I felt the same way that Rivers did about most of the characters-exasperated! I feel like I've read too many of the author's books too close together--I figured out the major baddie from early on. However, the book had the virtue of being short, so it was a quick read. Not one of her best, but I don't feel like I wasted my time.
Another enjoyable Lorac/Carnac. This one involves art, religious mania and a curious locked house mystery. I'm thankful for the British Library Crime Classics for reprinting such forgotten authors, because I thoroughly enjoy her work.
I will be honest and I prefer the author's MacDonald detective character to the Rivers detective but nonetheless this is a uniformly high standard writing as expected from Carnac/Lorac.
The villain and the motive were not perhaps so difficult to find, I think anyone who reads a lot of Golden Age crime novels would say the same. The quality therefore has to be in the writing and the characters and this was good as always.
Not one of my favourite Loracs, although still an enjoyable listen. Mark Meadows’ narration was excellent and kept the large cast distinct throughout.
The central mystery didn’t quite convince me. The death initially appears accidental, and I found it difficult to believe the investigation would have progressed as far as it did. By the time the solution arrived, the chain of reasoning felt more convoluted than inevitable.
What ultimately lifted the novel was its emotional complexity. The ending is more morally ambiguous than many Golden Age mysteries, and I appreciated that Lorac allowed the reader to feel sympathy alongside judgment. It isn’t one of her strongest puzzles, but it’s an interesting and thoughtful one.
This is possibly the worst book I have ever read. I literally had to take my eyes and force them to read this. Nothing exciting or worthwhile happens until about page 130, and the characters are so dull I just wanted to punch myself to liven things up even a tiny bit. If you ever see this, pass.
The Late Miss Trimming is a strange woman, a housekeeper with a religious mania and obsessive devotion to her master. She ends up dead in what looks like a domestic accident but the police aren't convinced. And yet, all the doors were locked from the inside and there's a missing tradesman who did work on the house...
A solid mystery, but like another book of hers I'd read recently, the key clue doesn't arrive until very late in the game so it's impossible to solve the mystery before the detective. This story had a really weird character, Miss Trimming herself. She was bizarre and uncanny, but some of the plot twists later in the story shed some light on why she came across that way. In fact, there were several plot twists that I did NOT see coming and the ones I suspected did not eventuate and/or proved to be red herrings, so that's a bonus, I love being surprised.
The characters are well drawn, the plot is solid. My biggest complaint is the pace - both of her novels kind of dragged until the last third or so. We have a long introduction to all the characters and the situational context, we have a long middle where nothing much happens other than lots of conversations to deepen our understanding of the characters and their relationships and then finally there's action in the last third. I had no idea who the murderer was until the last few pages when the critical clue was discovered.
These Inspector Rivers mysteries aren't strictly cosy and this one ends up being surprisingly dark once everything is known. While there's a sense that all will be OK in the end, none of the characters are particularly likeable and we never get close enough to them to really connect, keeping this more of a cerebral mystery. Would definitely read more of these if only I could find them as sadly her books are largely out of print.
Adrian Delafield used to be a celebrated painter, but these days the old man is a recluse at his home in St John’s Wood, jealously guarded by his housekeeper Miss Trimming. But when she is found dead at the bottom of the stairs, and Delafield is found badly hurt after seemingly trying to help her, the police - and some of people around the household are not convinced it was an accident - despite the fact that the house was locked tight. This is a relatively recent release, hot on the heels of the success of other Carnacs for the BLCC and it's a really good one.
I love a mystery that features artists and this is a nice variation on the theme - Delafield is very much a relic of a prior artistic era, a curiosity that has been (mostly) forgotten. His household is fascinating - and has that staple of the mystery genre: a religious fanatic, but there is a backstory to it (more than you get in many of these!) that means you do come to understand how Miss Trimming might have turned out the way she did. Well worth a look - probably my favourite of this selection.
The house was locked: the owner's daughter and the doctor tried the doors and checked the windows. There was no possible way that a murderer had left the premises before they arrived. And yet, there is a dead body. Surely this is the case of an accidental death? The detective doesn't think so. Small things -- the placement of a clock, a strange accident, the reconnection between the owner and an old friend -- suggest that something more nefarious was afoot.
I really enjoyed this novel. It was slow but well-paced with a reasonable (albeit not unforeseen conclusion). I had a three hour journey and this book took me exactly three hours to read, which made me like it even more.
This was first published in 1956 so it's quite a late Carnac/Lorac/Rivett.
Effectively it's a locked room mystery, though here its a whole house that is locked up. So was the victim killed or was it just an accident. Once again it's Chief Inspector Rivers and Inspector Lancing who are the lead detectives on the case.
Once again the author has populated the book with largely believable characters who act reasonably, given the parameters that the author has given them. Maybe the ending is a little bot of an anticlimax, after all of the theories that come to nothing the answer seems to just appear in River's head.
But despite that I enjoyed the story and I like the main characters.
One of the best crime novels of the 20C. The more I read E.R.C.Lorac (Carnac), the more confused I am that she was not one of the Big Three Golden Age writers, rather than Gladys Mitchell. She outdoes Mitchell on every front.
As always with this author, the story clips along at good rate, is highly readable, and populated with likeable characters, but this one exceeds all expectations in plot, delivery, and character development. It really does keep you guessing until the last few pages. Couldn't put it down.
I really do love this author, whichever pseudonym she is using. Her characters are always well-defined, the settings vivid, and her dialogue just clips along. The settings-up is realistic and the detectives’ frustration is quite believable; they strongly suspect foul play and doggedly explore clues and leads. Very enjoyable novel.
I still can't explain why anyone bothered to do all that investingating in what looked very convincingly to be an accidental death. There was absolutely no reason for the local police, let alone Scotland Yard, to waste so many resources and manpower. None of that was explained satisfactorily. Still a good enough plot at the end.
Very enjoyable whodunnit where the characters and the setting are more important than the puzzle. I really enjoy the author’s emphasis on people and place. I like her detective Rivers - not a maverick, just a decent man.
Carnac or Lorac, I love this author’s work in either guise. This one is a classic locked room mystery, and a clever one. The clues are there and it’s a tricky whodunnit. Recommended.