Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Frosted Fakes

Rate this book
Fake it till you bake it.

Being the daughter of a celebrity chef is one thing. Being a catastrophe in the kitchen is quite another. So when Julia Richardson’s mother gives her an ultimatum, and a bakery in the village of Oakhaven, Julia knows she's doomed.

Elliott Sinclair is a tattooed, self-taught baking prodigy with trust issues and zero patience for privileged amateurs. When Julia crashes into her life, literally, it's hatred at first sight.

Until, during a surprise visit from her mother, Julia panics and calls Elliott her girlfriend. Now they've come to an Elliott bakes, Julia pretends she can, and they both fake being madly in love. Simple, right?

Except Julia's finding it’s harder to fake feelings than fondants. And Elliott's icy walls are developing some very inconvenient cracks. Throw in a scheming rival baker, a meddling celebrity mother, and an employee whose courage is making them both rethink their own lies, and this fake relationship is a recipe for disaster. Or is it?

Frosted Fakes is a grumpy-sunshine, fake-dating, opposites-attract sapphic romcom with a very happy ending from bestselling Sapphic writer Sienna Waters, author of The Reluctant Romantic, For My Finale, and The Farmer Has a Wife.

317 pages, Kindle Edition

Published June 25, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Sienna Waters

90 books259 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
156 (49%)
4 stars
101 (32%)
3 stars
55 (17%)
2 stars
2 (<1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews
Profile Image for Fran Sappharc.
977 reviews49 followers
July 15, 2026
Loved it! I found the start amusing and remained amused for the whole book, apart from the bits that touched me!
Profile Image for Misha.
1,933 reviews81 followers
July 5, 2026
(rounded down from 4.25)

Wholesome, funny, and with a cast of fun side characters, as expected. The humour is very dry (i.e. British), and the grumpy/sunshine dynamic is very good, as usual. I always know I can rely on Sienna for a light romance (very low on angst) and mostly just a good time with a bunch of fun characters and a cute romance at the centre to root for.
140 reviews3 followers
July 12, 2026
Good characters and enjoyable fun read. I do think it’s a bit loose on some detail. You can’t sell or buy a building with a sitting tenant without realising. Also the whole fake dating thing was odd because everyone important already knew and I wasn’t sure why there was a big dramatic reveal along the lines of I can’t lie any more when there hadn’t actually been any lying. I don’t recall them ever saying Julia was baking.
Anyway all still enjoyable just not my favourite by this author who has after all set themselves a very high bar.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Lyn Denison.
Author 18 books71 followers
August 20, 2026
Read and enjoy! Another great Sienna Waters’ book with the usual hilarious, plus a touch of ‘lump in the throat’. There’s a wonderful cast of supporting characters, including an awful mother, and our MCs are as different as they can be. The basis of the plot-line is being true to yourself.

There are some great one-liners, too. For example, Julia described herself in family photos as looking ‘like a random tourist who’d accidentally photobombed.’ Then ‘It turned out rock bottom had a cellar’. And my favourite, ‘Real life is just a romance novel with worse editing’.

There’s also a peak back at Oakhaven, which was and still is a great series.
291 reviews2 followers
June 28, 2026
being honest is hard..

Your mother is a famous chef, your brother and sister are as well and you can set ice sculptures on fire. Your mother’s decided you’ve coasted long enough and bought you a bakery. So far you’ve set the smoke detector off 4-5 times a day burnt everything you’ve tried to make and the apartment above the bakery where you were supposed to live already had a tenant. A grumpy tenant.

Sienna has done it again created lovable, realistic characters a story that is completely enjoyable.
747 reviews6 followers
July 6, 2026
OK so I might be crying through my tears, this is just that good.

How can someone be so good with words? Sienna Waters has a gift that keeps on giving. Her style is gentle, at times it twists your insides then suddenly everything is just right! This tale covers so much ground emotionally, you just have to take the time to devour every word like you do your favorite pastry!
Profile Image for fred jones.
1,969 reviews14 followers
November 2, 2026
It is rare for a book to have me up until 1.30 on a work night and for me to hope my 8% kindle charge lasts but this one did. Romantic with a wonderful dry humour, great dialogue and the perfect HEA. The youngest me!bee of a cooking dynasty who set fire to an ice sculpture is oven a bakery by her mother as a last chance meets the grumpy sitting tenant baker. Just loved it.
Profile Image for Jenna.
115 reviews3 followers
July 16, 2026
Heart melting

Fake dating is absolutely one of my favourite tropes, so I was destined to love this book for that alone...

The characters are so well rounded, and every single name that appears on the page comes to life.

The only downside is that now I really want a croissant (or 6).
564 reviews13 followers
July 23, 2026
Very enjoyable read.

Very enjoyable read! Great story with equally great characters, main and supporting cast. I thought I wrote a pretty good review but I was told the review needed seven more words. Love Amazon
13 reviews1 follower
August 4, 2026
something fresh

Sienna Waters wrote a lovely heartfelt love story. She included some very serious parts of being a human that are terrifying to admit to the people you love. Hopefully we learn the lessons she has written so eloquently about.
42 reviews1 follower
August 31, 2026
heartwarming

A lovely story,slow at the start but gradually improves.
I have read a story similar to this but cannot remember the author.
Again a nice story and a slow romance from opposites to attraction,and the rest is love.
24 reviews
October 7, 2026
Funny and entertaining

A nice fake girlfriends story with lots of humor and hilarious incidents. So much truth in this story about pretending, fear, honesty, and assuming people just don't know. Some parts made me tear up, but that could just be me. I loved it.
5 reviews
June 27, 2026
DELICIOUS!

Excellent build. The story unfolds like a perfectly kneaded pastry. The character development proves like a fine yeast dough rises.
10 reviews
August 3, 2026
So good, had me in tears at one point, Sienna knows how to bring characters to life and put yourself in their shoes.
31 reviews1 follower
October 3, 2026
cranky black cat meets earnest people pleaser

These two were chronically, irrevocably, a mess. It was very entertaining. I recommend it if you want a chuckle and a deserved HEA.
Profile Image for Anna Furtado.
Author 5 books3 followers
October 10, 2026
It started a little slow, but it ended in true Sienna Waters fashion: where it ought to be! 😉
Profile Image for tee.
47 reviews1 follower
July 21, 2026
cute cute story but had spelling mistakes in it😔
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews