What do you think?
Rate this book
A Dangerous Justice
The first adventure in the thrilling Justice Belstrang mystery series from John Pilkington. A must-read for fans of C. J. Sansom. 🩸📜 England, 1616. Ex-magistrate Robert Belstrang, bored with country life, comes to London to investigate the strange disappearance of Thomas Jessop, son of a poor Catholic neighbour. He finds the youth in Bedlam asylum, silent and starving himself. But when he tries to free Jessop Belstrang finds himself the target of a dark plot to silence him… by any means necessary.
But Robert Belstrang is a stubborn man, and with the help of ex-soldier Daniel Oldrigg he sticks doggedly to his purpose. Their investigations take them deep into the fear-ridden Catholic underworld – where Belstrang soon uncovers a plan with its roots in the Gunpowder Plot of more than a decade ago.
The underbelly of London is a murky place, but Belstrang will strain every sinew to out the corruption... or die trying.
*This title was previously published as Legacy.
But Robert Belstrang is a stubborn man, and with the help of ex-soldier Daniel Oldrigg he sticks doggedly to his purpose. Their investigations take them deep into the fear-ridden Catholic underworld – where Belstrang soon uncovers a plan with its roots in the Gunpowder Plot of more than a decade ago.
The underbelly of London is a murky place, but Belstrang will strain every sinew to out the corruption... or die trying.
*This title was previously published as Legacy.
238 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 23, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews
June 11, 2026
I absolutely love anything historical, whether it’s fact or fiction, and I really liked this first instalment in the ‘Justice Belstrang mystery series’.
The adventure takes place in England in 1616, and ex-Magistrate, Robert Belstrang is tasked with going to London and finding the whereabouts of his poor, neighbours son, who apparently has gone on a pilgrimage.
Belstrang is anxious about venturing on this mission, as the family of the missing son, is Catholic, whereas Belstrang is Protestant…
This is a time when Catholics were imprisoned for their beliefs, and would meet and pray, etc, in secret. Only a decade earlier, the accused who were involved in the ‘Gunpowder Plot’, were captured, and were publicly executed at the Tower of London. But Belstrang feels as though he has a neighbourly duty to try to locate the missing, 19 year old, Thomas Jessop…
He finds the boy starving and near death, in Bedlam Asylum. Whilst trying to get him released, Robert Belstrang becomes the target, of a dark plot to silence him. But Belstrang is no fool, and with his stubbornness, continues on his mission, with the purpose of putting an end to this corruption, even if it means, risking his life.
I was so involved in this story, that I couldn’t wait to continue reading it, whenever I was doing something else. I ate this up, and I can’t wait to read the other books in this series.
4 ⭐️
Thanks to John Pilkington, Boldwood Books, and NetGalley, for providing me with this free ARC, with which I leave a voluntary review.
Available: 23 June 2026
The adventure takes place in England in 1616, and ex-Magistrate, Robert Belstrang is tasked with going to London and finding the whereabouts of his poor, neighbours son, who apparently has gone on a pilgrimage.
Belstrang is anxious about venturing on this mission, as the family of the missing son, is Catholic, whereas Belstrang is Protestant…
This is a time when Catholics were imprisoned for their beliefs, and would meet and pray, etc, in secret. Only a decade earlier, the accused who were involved in the ‘Gunpowder Plot’, were captured, and were publicly executed at the Tower of London. But Belstrang feels as though he has a neighbourly duty to try to locate the missing, 19 year old, Thomas Jessop…
He finds the boy starving and near death, in Bedlam Asylum. Whilst trying to get him released, Robert Belstrang becomes the target, of a dark plot to silence him. But Belstrang is no fool, and with his stubbornness, continues on his mission, with the purpose of putting an end to this corruption, even if it means, risking his life.
I was so involved in this story, that I couldn’t wait to continue reading it, whenever I was doing something else. I ate this up, and I can’t wait to read the other books in this series.
4 ⭐️
Thanks to John Pilkington, Boldwood Books, and NetGalley, for providing me with this free ARC, with which I leave a voluntary review.
Available: 23 June 2026
June 23, 2026
Retired magistrate Robert Belstrang travels from Worcestershire to London to find Thomas Jessop, the missing son of a Catholic neighbour. He discovers the young man confined in Bedlam, silent and wasting away. Trying to secure his freedom draws Belstrang into a conspiracy rooted in the Gunpowder Plot of 1605, with powerful forces set on silencing him. Helped by ex‑soldier Daniel Oldrigg, he navigates the city’s hostile, anti‑Catholic streets to uncover corruption and stand for true justice.
Strong sense of Jacobean London—religious fear, legal bias, squalor, and political unease—perfectly realised.
Belstrang is thoughtful, principled, and determined; an older, unflashy hero who wins sympathy and respect.
A slow‑burn investigation weaving historical events, religious tension, and official corruption; reminiscent of C.J. Sansom’s Shardlake series but less brutal, more character‑focused.
Pace is measured and deliberate, driven by dialogue, research, and atmosphere rather than fast action. If you prefer rapid‑fire thrillers, it may feel slow; if you enjoy immersive historical crime, it excels.
A thoughtful, well‑crafted start to the series. Rich in period detail and moral weight, ideal for fans of historical mystery and Stuart‑era fiction.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
First and foremost, a large thank you to NetGalley, John Pilkington, and Boldwood Books for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
John Pilkington delivers a respectable historical mystery with this debut featuring Robert Belstrang, though the novel never fully rises above the conventions of the genre. Set in early 17th-century England, the story follows Belstrang, a former magistrate pulled from his quiet country life to investigate the strange disappearance of Thomas Jessop’s son, a Catholic later discovered starving himself in an asylum. What initially appears to be a straightforward inquiry soon evolves into a deeper conspiracy tied to religious tensions and secrets buried for more than a decade.
Pilkington succeeds most in crafting atmosphere and pacing. The short chapters keep the narrative moving briskly, and the historical backdrop is presented with enough detail to immerse the reader without overwhelming the mystery itself. London’s darker corners and the ever-present fear surrounding Catholic persecution provide an engaging setting that adds texture to the investigation. The novel is at its best when Belstrang is navigating these dangerous spaces, uncertain whom he can trust.
Robert Belstrang proves to be a capable lead, if not an especially memorable one. His determination and adaptability make him easy enough to follow, particularly as he becomes entangled in matters far more dangerous than he anticipated. The supporting cast serves its purpose well, especially the former soldier assisting him, though few characters leave a lasting impression beyond their immediate role in the plot. Likewise, the antagonists carry an ominous presence, but they occasionally feel more functional than fully developed.
The story maintains steady momentum throughout, and Pilkington does a commendable job layering twists into the investigation without allowing the narrative to stall. At times, however, the novel leans heavily on familiar genre tropes, and some revelations lack the impact they seem intended to carry. While the historical context is interesting and clearly researched, the emotional depth and character complexity occasionally fall short of elevating the novel beyond a solid, entertaining read.
Overall, this is a decent debut that offers enough intrigue and historical atmosphere to satisfy fans of historical mysteries. Though it may not distinguish itself significantly within the crowded genre, Pilkington shows promise as a storyteller with a good sense of pacing and setting. Readers who enjoy fast-moving historical investigations with religious intrigue and conspiratorial undertones will likely find enough here to keep them engaged.
Kudos, Mr. PIlkington, for a decent historical mystery.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at: http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
John Pilkington delivers a respectable historical mystery with this debut featuring Robert Belstrang, though the novel never fully rises above the conventions of the genre. Set in early 17th-century England, the story follows Belstrang, a former magistrate pulled from his quiet country life to investigate the strange disappearance of Thomas Jessop’s son, a Catholic later discovered starving himself in an asylum. What initially appears to be a straightforward inquiry soon evolves into a deeper conspiracy tied to religious tensions and secrets buried for more than a decade.
Pilkington succeeds most in crafting atmosphere and pacing. The short chapters keep the narrative moving briskly, and the historical backdrop is presented with enough detail to immerse the reader without overwhelming the mystery itself. London’s darker corners and the ever-present fear surrounding Catholic persecution provide an engaging setting that adds texture to the investigation. The novel is at its best when Belstrang is navigating these dangerous spaces, uncertain whom he can trust.
Robert Belstrang proves to be a capable lead, if not an especially memorable one. His determination and adaptability make him easy enough to follow, particularly as he becomes entangled in matters far more dangerous than he anticipated. The supporting cast serves its purpose well, especially the former soldier assisting him, though few characters leave a lasting impression beyond their immediate role in the plot. Likewise, the antagonists carry an ominous presence, but they occasionally feel more functional than fully developed.
The story maintains steady momentum throughout, and Pilkington does a commendable job layering twists into the investigation without allowing the narrative to stall. At times, however, the novel leans heavily on familiar genre tropes, and some revelations lack the impact they seem intended to carry. While the historical context is interesting and clearly researched, the emotional depth and character complexity occasionally fall short of elevating the novel beyond a solid, entertaining read.
Overall, this is a decent debut that offers enough intrigue and historical atmosphere to satisfy fans of historical mysteries. Though it may not distinguish itself significantly within the crowded genre, Pilkington shows promise as a storyteller with a good sense of pacing and setting. Readers who enjoy fast-moving historical investigations with religious intrigue and conspiratorial undertones will likely find enough here to keep them engaged.
Kudos, Mr. PIlkington, for a decent historical mystery.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at: http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
June 23, 2026
3.5 stars for me. Closer to 4.
My thanks to Boldwood books the publisher and NetGalley for providing me this John Pilkington book as an advance review copy in exchange for an honest review.
Historical mysteries are always a balancing act. Get the history right and the mystery can suffer. Focus too much on the mystery and the historical setting can feel little more than wallpaper.
I tend to steer clear of most books in this vertical but the blurb was too enticing in this one.
And fortunately for me, A Dangerous Justice manages to find a comfortable middle ground, delivering an engaging mystery wrapped in a vividly realised Jacobean England.
Set in 1616, the story follows Robert Belstrang, a former magistrate drawn into the investigation of a young Catholic man's disappearance. What begins innocuously as a seemingly straightforward inquiry soon develops into something far more dangerous, exposing political intrigue, religious tensions and secrets that powerful people would rather keep buried.
One of the novel's greatest strengths is its atmosphere. JP brings early seventeenth century London to life with impressive detail. The picture of the city feels authentic, from its crowded streets and uneasy political climate to the ever present suspicion surrounding Catholics in the years following the Gunpowder Plot. Readers who enjoy becoming fully immersed in a historical setting will find plenty to appreciate here especially if they read up about the times.
I also enjoyed Robert Belstrang as a protagonist. He is intelligent without being infallible, determined without becoming reckless and his investigative partnership with Daniel Oldrigg adds a welcome dynamic to the story. Their interactions help keep the narrative moving even when the investigation becomes more methodical.
The mystery itself is well constructed, although I did find the pacing somewhat uneven being afflicted with an acute love for thrillers. The opening is strong and the final sections deliver satisfying revelations, but the middle portion occasionally slows under the weight of its historical detail and numerous political threads. There were moments when I found myself admiring the research more than feeling fully invested in the unfolding investigation.
That said, readers who enjoy richly detailed historical fiction may view this as a strength rather than a weakness. JP clearly knows his subject matter, and that expertise shines throughout the novel.
Overall, A Dangerous Justice is a thoughtful and atmospheric historical mystery that combines real historical tensions with an intriguing investigation. While the pacing prevented it from becoming a complete page turner for me, the strong sense of place, engaging protagonist and carefully researched setting make this a promising start to what could be an excellent series.
Recommended for fans of historical mysteries, political intrigue, religious conspiracies and immersive period settings.
My thanks to Boldwood books the publisher and NetGalley for providing me this John Pilkington book as an advance review copy in exchange for an honest review.
Historical mysteries are always a balancing act. Get the history right and the mystery can suffer. Focus too much on the mystery and the historical setting can feel little more than wallpaper.
I tend to steer clear of most books in this vertical but the blurb was too enticing in this one.
And fortunately for me, A Dangerous Justice manages to find a comfortable middle ground, delivering an engaging mystery wrapped in a vividly realised Jacobean England.
Set in 1616, the story follows Robert Belstrang, a former magistrate drawn into the investigation of a young Catholic man's disappearance. What begins innocuously as a seemingly straightforward inquiry soon develops into something far more dangerous, exposing political intrigue, religious tensions and secrets that powerful people would rather keep buried.
One of the novel's greatest strengths is its atmosphere. JP brings early seventeenth century London to life with impressive detail. The picture of the city feels authentic, from its crowded streets and uneasy political climate to the ever present suspicion surrounding Catholics in the years following the Gunpowder Plot. Readers who enjoy becoming fully immersed in a historical setting will find plenty to appreciate here especially if they read up about the times.
I also enjoyed Robert Belstrang as a protagonist. He is intelligent without being infallible, determined without becoming reckless and his investigative partnership with Daniel Oldrigg adds a welcome dynamic to the story. Their interactions help keep the narrative moving even when the investigation becomes more methodical.
The mystery itself is well constructed, although I did find the pacing somewhat uneven being afflicted with an acute love for thrillers. The opening is strong and the final sections deliver satisfying revelations, but the middle portion occasionally slows under the weight of its historical detail and numerous political threads. There were moments when I found myself admiring the research more than feeling fully invested in the unfolding investigation.
That said, readers who enjoy richly detailed historical fiction may view this as a strength rather than a weakness. JP clearly knows his subject matter, and that expertise shines throughout the novel.
Overall, A Dangerous Justice is a thoughtful and atmospheric historical mystery that combines real historical tensions with an intriguing investigation. While the pacing prevented it from becoming a complete page turner for me, the strong sense of place, engaging protagonist and carefully researched setting make this a promising start to what could be an excellent series.
Recommended for fans of historical mysteries, political intrigue, religious conspiracies and immersive period settings.
June 29, 2026
Please note that A Dangerous Justice from John Pilkington is breath of fresh air in the Historic Fiction Crime genre which will prove to be addictive, so thankfully, this is book one in the new series ‘A Justice Belstrang Mystery’.
Set in 1616, Robert Belstrang, a recently retired Magistrate finds he is bored, the daily life of a retired and affluent man in the country can be one that has little change or excitement involved.
When a neighbour comes to him to beg a favour, that of trying to find his estranged son Thomas Jessop, who went to London, sending a message that his family would be proud of him and then appeared to vanish, he is reluctant to get involved.
The family are Catholic, suffering for their religion, which as a stout Protestant causes Belstrang some serious conflict, but he reluctantly agrees to see what he can do once he reaches London.
He finds his return to the City is both interesting and enlightening, but once he begins to try and find out what happened to Thomas, he realises that whatever the headstrong young man had become embroiled in was very dangerous indeed.
Bribery gets him into see Thomas, now mute and residing in Bedlam, a meal with an occasional friend finds him locked up in a holding cell wondering exactly what is happening, why and who is behind his so-called arrest.
With his recent investigations appearing to have faint links to the recent attempt to overthrow the Government through the Gunpowder Plot; an event which was a catastrophic failure, Belstrang is drawn into a side of London life that is both dangerous and informative. It is the underbelly of London!
Belstrang seeks refuge with an old and trusted friend and is now determined to find out exactly what it was that has seen Thomas incarcerated in Bedlam, which then becomes a very dangerous undertaking.
Being the stubborn man he is, Belstrang refuses to give in or succumb to the pressure a certain clandestine sector of Government bring to bear, and with the help of a man, an ex-soldier he is not sure he can fully trust, sets out to right a serious and dangerous wrong.
A Dangerous Justice captures the intense and dangerous environment prevalent in London of 1616, when to be Catholic was dangerous, James I was ruling England and Parliament was rife with fractions, plots and danger. A refreshing and engrossing read from John Pilkington.
This title was previously published as Legacy.
Set in 1616, Robert Belstrang, a recently retired Magistrate finds he is bored, the daily life of a retired and affluent man in the country can be one that has little change or excitement involved.
When a neighbour comes to him to beg a favour, that of trying to find his estranged son Thomas Jessop, who went to London, sending a message that his family would be proud of him and then appeared to vanish, he is reluctant to get involved.
The family are Catholic, suffering for their religion, which as a stout Protestant causes Belstrang some serious conflict, but he reluctantly agrees to see what he can do once he reaches London.
He finds his return to the City is both interesting and enlightening, but once he begins to try and find out what happened to Thomas, he realises that whatever the headstrong young man had become embroiled in was very dangerous indeed.
Bribery gets him into see Thomas, now mute and residing in Bedlam, a meal with an occasional friend finds him locked up in a holding cell wondering exactly what is happening, why and who is behind his so-called arrest.
With his recent investigations appearing to have faint links to the recent attempt to overthrow the Government through the Gunpowder Plot; an event which was a catastrophic failure, Belstrang is drawn into a side of London life that is both dangerous and informative. It is the underbelly of London!
Belstrang seeks refuge with an old and trusted friend and is now determined to find out exactly what it was that has seen Thomas incarcerated in Bedlam, which then becomes a very dangerous undertaking.
Being the stubborn man he is, Belstrang refuses to give in or succumb to the pressure a certain clandestine sector of Government bring to bear, and with the help of a man, an ex-soldier he is not sure he can fully trust, sets out to right a serious and dangerous wrong.
A Dangerous Justice captures the intense and dangerous environment prevalent in London of 1616, when to be Catholic was dangerous, James I was ruling England and Parliament was rife with fractions, plots and danger. A refreshing and engrossing read from John Pilkington.
This title was previously published as Legacy.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley, John Pilkington, and Boldwood Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
As a huge fan of historical fiction, A Dangerous Justice immediately caught my attention with its early 17th-century London setting, religious intrigue, and mystery surrounding the aftermath of the Gunpowder Plot. John Pilkington clearly knows how to create an atmospheric historical backdrop, and that ended up being the strongest aspect of the novel for me.
The story follows former magistrate Robert Belstrang as he leaves behind quiet country life to investigate the disappearance of a neighbour’s son, only to uncover secrets tied to England’s dangerous Catholic underworld. The premise is genuinely intriguing, and there are moments where the novel really shines, particularly when exploring the fear, paranoia, and corruption woven into Jacobean London society.
Pilkington’s research is evident throughout the book, and the historical details help immerse the reader in the setting without becoming overwhelming. I also appreciated the short chapters and steady pacing, which kept the story moving even during quieter stretches. The conspiracy elements and religious tensions added an interesting layer to the mystery.
That said, I did find myself wanting more tension and suspense overall. While the investigation itself was solid, the story often felt like it was plodding along rather than building real momentum. I never fully felt the danger or urgency that the premise seemed to promise. Robert Belstrang is a capable protagonist, but I struggled to fully connect with him at times, especially since much of the story focuses heavily on his internal thoughts and conversations rather than sharper emotional stakes or action.
Even so, there is definitely potential here for the series moving forward. The historical atmosphere is strong, the mystery is well-constructed, and fans of slower-burning historical investigations will likely enjoy spending time in this world. While this one ended up being just an okay read for me personally, I can still see the promise in the Justice Belstrang series and would be interested to see how both the character and the tension develop in future installments.
As a huge fan of historical fiction, A Dangerous Justice immediately caught my attention with its early 17th-century London setting, religious intrigue, and mystery surrounding the aftermath of the Gunpowder Plot. John Pilkington clearly knows how to create an atmospheric historical backdrop, and that ended up being the strongest aspect of the novel for me.
The story follows former magistrate Robert Belstrang as he leaves behind quiet country life to investigate the disappearance of a neighbour’s son, only to uncover secrets tied to England’s dangerous Catholic underworld. The premise is genuinely intriguing, and there are moments where the novel really shines, particularly when exploring the fear, paranoia, and corruption woven into Jacobean London society.
Pilkington’s research is evident throughout the book, and the historical details help immerse the reader in the setting without becoming overwhelming. I also appreciated the short chapters and steady pacing, which kept the story moving even during quieter stretches. The conspiracy elements and religious tensions added an interesting layer to the mystery.
That said, I did find myself wanting more tension and suspense overall. While the investigation itself was solid, the story often felt like it was plodding along rather than building real momentum. I never fully felt the danger or urgency that the premise seemed to promise. Robert Belstrang is a capable protagonist, but I struggled to fully connect with him at times, especially since much of the story focuses heavily on his internal thoughts and conversations rather than sharper emotional stakes or action.
Even so, there is definitely potential here for the series moving forward. The historical atmosphere is strong, the mystery is well-constructed, and fans of slower-burning historical investigations will likely enjoy spending time in this world. While this one ended up being just an okay read for me personally, I can still see the promise in the Justice Belstrang series and would be interested to see how both the character and the tension develop in future installments.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A new series set in 1616. Robert Belstrang is a retired Magistrate living near Worcester. His close neighbour John Jessop
asks to see him in an urgent and personal family matter. He and his wife have received a letter from their son,Thomas, he has been out of contact with them for months, apparently he is in London, not Wales as he told them! Could Robert read the letter and offer advice?
The letter is worrying. Thomas is asking forgiveness for being involved in something that could be a possible Catholic plot. John cannot go to London to find his son, as a Papist, he is forbidden to travel under threat of his property being forfeit, would Robert go in his stead and find out what Thomas is involved in and bring him back home?
King James is on the throne. After the foiled Gunpowder plot, he has shown a great mistrust of the Catholics in his realm, he also fears Witchcraft and he would rather enjoy the company of handsome young men at his court. The King is planning to marry his heir, Prince Charles to a Spanish bride, if that happens, England would eventually be ruled by Papists.
Robert decides to go to London and investigate. He will go and visit his daughter, Anne, his granddaughter, Kate, and his son- in - law, George, and try to find out more about Thomas and his activities.
However, people in London know more about this affair than Robert does, and he finds himself put into peril, whilst trying to do a kindness for a neighbour. There is a trip to a prison, a mental hospital and numerous court intrigues add to the tension and menace that stalks Robert and his friends throughout.
This is a thrilling adventure that involves spies, traitors, and deceptions from the very top level of society. Justice is a very scarce commodity to seek and be given. A fast paced and intricately plotted story, full of historical facts and unusual characters. Some significant dates will help the armchair detectives.
A promising start to a new series, I greatly enjoyed previous books. The febrile atmosphere of those days is portrayed vividly, and the story draws the reader in. Looking forward to the next instalment.
asks to see him in an urgent and personal family matter. He and his wife have received a letter from their son,Thomas, he has been out of contact with them for months, apparently he is in London, not Wales as he told them! Could Robert read the letter and offer advice?
The letter is worrying. Thomas is asking forgiveness for being involved in something that could be a possible Catholic plot. John cannot go to London to find his son, as a Papist, he is forbidden to travel under threat of his property being forfeit, would Robert go in his stead and find out what Thomas is involved in and bring him back home?
King James is on the throne. After the foiled Gunpowder plot, he has shown a great mistrust of the Catholics in his realm, he also fears Witchcraft and he would rather enjoy the company of handsome young men at his court. The King is planning to marry his heir, Prince Charles to a Spanish bride, if that happens, England would eventually be ruled by Papists.
Robert decides to go to London and investigate. He will go and visit his daughter, Anne, his granddaughter, Kate, and his son- in - law, George, and try to find out more about Thomas and his activities.
However, people in London know more about this affair than Robert does, and he finds himself put into peril, whilst trying to do a kindness for a neighbour. There is a trip to a prison, a mental hospital and numerous court intrigues add to the tension and menace that stalks Robert and his friends throughout.
This is a thrilling adventure that involves spies, traitors, and deceptions from the very top level of society. Justice is a very scarce commodity to seek and be given. A fast paced and intricately plotted story, full of historical facts and unusual characters. Some significant dates will help the armchair detectives.
A promising start to a new series, I greatly enjoyed previous books. The febrile atmosphere of those days is portrayed vividly, and the story draws the reader in. Looking forward to the next instalment.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A Dangerous Justice, is the first book in the belstrang mysteries by John Pilkington It is 1616 and retired judge Robert Belstrang gets a visit from his Catholic neighbor John Jessup. It seems his son went to London and he hasn’t heard from him in months and recently received a very alarming letter. with the whole of London being Protestant Robert has many reasons not to investigate where Thomas is, especially because everyone knows the jesup’s secretly and illegally worship in the Catholic faith not to mention Thomas was a bit of a troublemaker back in the day. Fortunately for Mr. Jessup Robert has more than one reason to go to London so he decides to look for him. One thing leads to another and he investigates those that were last to see Thomas and this includes a widow what Robert isn’t expecting is for one of his own peers bringing him to a lavish dinner and in a nice way warns him off the case. at the dinner he learns a couple of things he didn’t know but none of it makes him want to stop searching as a matter of fact quite the opposite. at first Thomas‘s dad thought him dead and when Robert finds him he almost feels as if he probably should be. Can Robert save Thomas from those that are out to keep them quiet or does Thomas need help saving him from his self. this was a really good book I love royal politics in historical books and when it said it was like CJ Samson I was so down to read it I read every book in the Matthew Shardlake series and will probably read every book in this one. It was well done the story flowed with great momentum I do want to say I did guess who the bad guy was but as they say even a broken clock can be right twice a day so don’t take that as any slight on the book. if you want a good story that historical fiction with the great mystery tied in to Royal politics in the 1700s then don’t skip this book I really enjoyed it and I’m gonna be so down to read the next one. #NetGalley, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview,
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A Dangerous Justice is a gripping start to the Justice Belstrang series, and I was hooked from the moment Robert Belstrang stepped onto the page. John Pilkington captures 1616 London with such vivid, gritty detail — the fear, the tension, the religious divides simmering beneath the surface — that it feels like walking through the city’s shadowy alleys alongside him.
Belstrang himself is a fantastic lead: stubborn, principled, and carrying just enough weariness to make him instantly believable. His attempt to help a neighbour’s missing son spirals into something far darker than expected, and the moment the investigation leads him to Bedlam, the story takes on a wonderfully sinister edge. The stakes rise quickly, and the sense of danger feels real.
I especially enjoyed the partnership between Belstrang and Daniel Oldrigg. Their dynamic adds warmth and grit in equal measure, grounding the story as it delves deeper into the murky Catholic underworld and the lingering echoes of the Gunpowder Plot. The plot is tight, full of twists, and packed with the kind of historical intrigue that keeps you turning pages.
Fans of C. J. Sansom, Ann Cleeves, and richly detailed historical crime fiction will find so much to love here. It’s atmospheric, clever, and thoroughly immersive — a strong first instalment that promises an exciting series ahead. A dark, engaging mystery that proves justice in Jacobean England is anything but simple.
With thanks to John Pilkington, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Belstrang himself is a fantastic lead: stubborn, principled, and carrying just enough weariness to make him instantly believable. His attempt to help a neighbour’s missing son spirals into something far darker than expected, and the moment the investigation leads him to Bedlam, the story takes on a wonderfully sinister edge. The stakes rise quickly, and the sense of danger feels real.
I especially enjoyed the partnership between Belstrang and Daniel Oldrigg. Their dynamic adds warmth and grit in equal measure, grounding the story as it delves deeper into the murky Catholic underworld and the lingering echoes of the Gunpowder Plot. The plot is tight, full of twists, and packed with the kind of historical intrigue that keeps you turning pages.
Fans of C. J. Sansom, Ann Cleeves, and richly detailed historical crime fiction will find so much to love here. It’s atmospheric, clever, and thoroughly immersive — a strong first instalment that promises an exciting series ahead. A dark, engaging mystery that proves justice in Jacobean England is anything but simple.
With thanks to John Pilkington, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
July 9, 2026
This was a fairly entertaining mystery set in the 1600s.
I was surprised to find there was no murder and this more akin to a historical thriller than anything else. You have a missing son, lying witnesses, kidnap, more lies, violence and plots within plots. The whole story moves along at a brisk pace once you reach London.
The characters on the whole are entertaining and interesting. Our main character presents a empathic figure, a Protestant who has perhaps lost some of the religious fire of his youth yet isn't so blind that he refuses to help Catholics This was a time of religious upheaval when the type of Christianity you believed in could see you fined, harried and even killed. Despite that, he still comes across as believable in his compassion.
I enjoyed the whole plot, the throwback to the gunpowder plot and this new threat that circled around the king. I also enjoy any book that has James as the paranoid waster he was.
The ending felt a little neat and at the same time somewhat rushed. It was all wrapped up in a couple of conversations which explained the plot and then gave us a handy way out where before all had seemed dark.
All in all though fun and an easy way to spend a couple of hours.
~Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review~
I was surprised to find there was no murder and this more akin to a historical thriller than anything else. You have a missing son, lying witnesses, kidnap, more lies, violence and plots within plots. The whole story moves along at a brisk pace once you reach London.
The characters on the whole are entertaining and interesting. Our main character presents a empathic figure, a Protestant who has perhaps lost some of the religious fire of his youth yet isn't so blind that he refuses to help Catholics This was a time of religious upheaval when the type of Christianity you believed in could see you fined, harried and even killed. Despite that, he still comes across as believable in his compassion.
I enjoyed the whole plot, the throwback to the gunpowder plot and this new threat that circled around the king. I also enjoy any book that has James as the paranoid waster he was.
The ending felt a little neat and at the same time somewhat rushed. It was all wrapped up in a couple of conversations which explained the plot and then gave us a handy way out where before all had seemed dark.
All in all though fun and an easy way to spend a couple of hours.
~Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review~
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I haven't read a lot of historical fiction to date, but this might well be the book to bring about a change in my reading matter. The fact that it's book one of a mystery series is purely coincidental. 😉
The justice alluded to in the title is ex-magistrate, Robert Belstrang. Belstrang is approached by his Catholic neighbour, John Jessop, with a plea to help find his son Thomas, whose last known whereabouts is London. 📜⚖️
The year is 1616, and King James is on the throne. The London that Robert Belstrang finds himself in is very different to the London he remembers from his days at court. It's not long before his inquiries into the whereabouts of Thomas Jessop reach the ears of the young man's puppetmasters, and Robert soon finds himself in a lot of trouble. 📜⚖️
Although a bit of a slow burn, there are plenty of twists to keep the story from becoming boring. I liked Robert Belstrang. He may be past his prime, but he is obstinate and will let nothing get in the way of his task. He also has some empathy for the Jessops, despite their being Catholic. 📜⚖️
I enjoyed this book immensely, and look forward to the next in the Justice Belstrang series. 📜⚖️
Thanks to Boldwood Books and Netgalley for the ARC.
The justice alluded to in the title is ex-magistrate, Robert Belstrang. Belstrang is approached by his Catholic neighbour, John Jessop, with a plea to help find his son Thomas, whose last known whereabouts is London. 📜⚖️
The year is 1616, and King James is on the throne. The London that Robert Belstrang finds himself in is very different to the London he remembers from his days at court. It's not long before his inquiries into the whereabouts of Thomas Jessop reach the ears of the young man's puppetmasters, and Robert soon finds himself in a lot of trouble. 📜⚖️
Although a bit of a slow burn, there are plenty of twists to keep the story from becoming boring. I liked Robert Belstrang. He may be past his prime, but he is obstinate and will let nothing get in the way of his task. He also has some empathy for the Jessops, despite their being Catholic. 📜⚖️
I enjoyed this book immensely, and look forward to the next in the Justice Belstrang series. 📜⚖️
Thanks to Boldwood Books and Netgalley for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
3.5 stars rounded up
The Justice Belstrang Mysteries Book 1
England 1616: Ex-magistrate Robert Belstrand, bored with country life, comes to London to investigate the strange disappearance of Thomas Jessop, son of a poor Catholic neighbour. He finds the youth in Bedlam asylum, silent and starving himself. But when he tries to free Jessop, Belstrang finds himself the target of a dark plot to silence him.... by any means necessary. But Robert Belstrandg is a stubborn man, and with the help of ex-soldier Daniel Oldrigg, he sticks doggedly to his purpose. Their investigations take them deep into the fear-ridden Catholic underworld - where Belstrang soon uncovers a plan with its roots in the Gunpowder Plot of more than a decade ago.
I loved the setting for this religious story set around the aftermath of the gunpowder plot. The author had definitely done his research into the book. This is an atmospheric read, but the pace is on the slow side. We do get some twists along the way. The story is told in the first person and the plot is interesting.
Published 23rd June 2026
I would like to thank #NetGalley #BoldwoodBooks and the author #JohnPilkington for my ARC of #ADangerousJustice in exchange for an honest review.
The Justice Belstrang Mysteries Book 1
England 1616: Ex-magistrate Robert Belstrand, bored with country life, comes to London to investigate the strange disappearance of Thomas Jessop, son of a poor Catholic neighbour. He finds the youth in Bedlam asylum, silent and starving himself. But when he tries to free Jessop, Belstrang finds himself the target of a dark plot to silence him.... by any means necessary. But Robert Belstrandg is a stubborn man, and with the help of ex-soldier Daniel Oldrigg, he sticks doggedly to his purpose. Their investigations take them deep into the fear-ridden Catholic underworld - where Belstrang soon uncovers a plan with its roots in the Gunpowder Plot of more than a decade ago.
I loved the setting for this religious story set around the aftermath of the gunpowder plot. The author had definitely done his research into the book. This is an atmospheric read, but the pace is on the slow side. We do get some twists along the way. The story is told in the first person and the plot is interesting.
Published 23rd June 2026
I would like to thank #NetGalley #BoldwoodBooks and the author #JohnPilkington for my ARC of #ADangerousJustice in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
It's my first time reading a book by John Pilkington, and what better way to start than with his new series? I dived into this book completely blind, without knowing what to expect, which definitely added an extra thrill to my experience. What greeted me between the pages was a slow-paced, yet captivating historical mystery set in England during the King James era of 1616. Robert Belstrang, an ex-magistrate, is approached by a neighbour with a plea to help find his son, Thomas Jessop, who has disappeared. Untangling that mystery and discovering what happened to the boy leads Belstrang to London, and soon everything spirals out of control. The conspiracy he finds himself in is far deeper than he anticipated. I loved the way every place and surrounding in the book was crafted, how descriptive and immersive it was, making you feel as if you are standing there too. I adored Robert Belstrang's character with his relentless will; even when he became a target meant to silence him, he didn't cower but pressed on with his mission, determined to put an end to what he uncovered. Slow-burning with conspiracies lurking in every corner, full of twists and turns, and never a dull moment. I love that it is yet another wonderful read that I picked up outside my usual fantasy comfort zone.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A Dangerous Justice marks the start of a new series by John Pilkington, this one centring around the retired magistrate Robert Belstrang who has left London to live in the quiet of the countryside. He returns to the city, though, after his neighbour asks him to find out what has happened to his missing son, Thomas Jessop. The Jessops are Catholic and Belstrang is soon drawn into the dangerous political and religious divisions which are rife under King James I.
I have very much enjoyed the previous works by John Pilkington that I’ve read and this one was just as good. He has a real knack for bringing London in the 17th century to life and the mysteries are engrossing but believable. The plots are always based very much around the time and place, and the prevailing politics of the age are crucial. The story is less focused on fast paced action and more on building atmosphere and giving us a glimpse of the dangers and fears of life at the time, and he always manages to place the actions and thoughts of the characters firmly in the period. This is really excellent historical fiction and I’m looking forward to reading more about Justice Belstrang.
I have very much enjoyed the previous works by John Pilkington that I’ve read and this one was just as good. He has a real knack for bringing London in the 17th century to life and the mysteries are engrossing but believable. The plots are always based very much around the time and place, and the prevailing politics of the age are crucial. The story is less focused on fast paced action and more on building atmosphere and giving us a glimpse of the dangers and fears of life at the time, and he always manages to place the actions and thoughts of the characters firmly in the period. This is really excellent historical fiction and I’m looking forward to reading more about Justice Belstrang.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I thank NetGalley and Boldwood Books for an advance reader copy of A Dangerous Justice. All opinions and comments are my own.
A tension-filled London still affected by the aftermath of the “gunpowder plot” finds ex-magistrate Robert Belstrang caught up in something that soon begins to spiral out of control when a search for the son of a Catholic neighbor finds him enmeshed in secrets and more secrets in A Dangerous Justice. Author John Pilkington never wastes a page involving his readers in Belstrang’s quest to find the missing boy, only to uncover much more than he could ever have imagined. There’s never a quiet moment in A Dangerous Justice, with Belstrang encountering conspiracies in every taproom, street corner and especially in the opulent rooms at court.
And when the truth is revealed, it is Belstrang and his son-in-law that find themselves needing to bring everything to a conclusion that will serve as an end. One that many a man of law will appreciate. Pilkington has crafted an exciting tale filled with twists, captivating characters and an unsettled city that will enthrall readers at every turn of its dark and shadowy streets.
A tension-filled London still affected by the aftermath of the “gunpowder plot” finds ex-magistrate Robert Belstrang caught up in something that soon begins to spiral out of control when a search for the son of a Catholic neighbor finds him enmeshed in secrets and more secrets in A Dangerous Justice. Author John Pilkington never wastes a page involving his readers in Belstrang’s quest to find the missing boy, only to uncover much more than he could ever have imagined. There’s never a quiet moment in A Dangerous Justice, with Belstrang encountering conspiracies in every taproom, street corner and especially in the opulent rooms at court.
And when the truth is revealed, it is Belstrang and his son-in-law that find themselves needing to bring everything to a conclusion that will serve as an end. One that many a man of law will appreciate. Pilkington has crafted an exciting tale filled with twists, captivating characters and an unsettled city that will enthrall readers at every turn of its dark and shadowy streets.
July 4, 2026
A nice easy historical mystery that feels low stakes, with some twists that keep it moving.
I enjoyed this one, though it didn’t bowl me over.
The plot is an interesting speculation on the machinations against early 17th century English Protestant King James Stuart’s life that the public may not have been privy to. Amongst Catholic persecution and the Guy Fawkes business, Stuart would most certainly have been watching his back. I liked the political intrigue and mysterious motives, though the story fell a little flat for such a high stakes happenings.
Justice Belstrang is a decent protagonist, but lacks presence. I feel like he needed to be just a little bit quirkier, have a bit more depth, wield a touch more influence. As it was, his performance felt a little flat as the relentless pursuer of justice. Perhaps subsequent books in the series expand his character and gravitas.
This book is a good palate cleanser with mystery and history, and has its place on the historical fiction shelf - just don’t expect epic.
Thank you to the author, Boldwood Books, and NetGalley for the digital advance reader copy. All opinions are my own.
I enjoyed this one, though it didn’t bowl me over.
The plot is an interesting speculation on the machinations against early 17th century English Protestant King James Stuart’s life that the public may not have been privy to. Amongst Catholic persecution and the Guy Fawkes business, Stuart would most certainly have been watching his back. I liked the political intrigue and mysterious motives, though the story fell a little flat for such a high stakes happenings.
Justice Belstrang is a decent protagonist, but lacks presence. I feel like he needed to be just a little bit quirkier, have a bit more depth, wield a touch more influence. As it was, his performance felt a little flat as the relentless pursuer of justice. Perhaps subsequent books in the series expand his character and gravitas.
This book is a good palate cleanser with mystery and history, and has its place on the historical fiction shelf - just don’t expect epic.
Thank you to the author, Boldwood Books, and NetGalley for the digital advance reader copy. All opinions are my own.
August 1, 2026
Thus begins Justice Belstrang’s Year of Astonishment.
1616, King James is on the throne. Times might be more relaxed but men must be vigilant. Plots and counter plots attend an innocent inquiry made by Belstrang’s neighbor in Worcester. He’s been asked by a papist neighbor to journey to London to discover what has happened to his son Thomas.
Reluctant to do so, nevertheless he departs and goes to London. He will make enquires, visit his daughter and son-in-law (a man he has little time for) and return.
That was his thought! By the time he’s halfway through he has discovered plots that throw innocents to the wolves, justice sorely lacking, himself thrown into Debtor’s prison, and so much more.
It’s the ten year anniversary of the gunpowder plot. The population is nervous.
Pilkington’s writing is accessible, describes the times accurately, whilst weaving a deft and accessible mystery
I found myself unable to put down this likeable tale narrated by a righteous skeptic.
A Boldwood Books ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
1616, King James is on the throne. Times might be more relaxed but men must be vigilant. Plots and counter plots attend an innocent inquiry made by Belstrang’s neighbor in Worcester. He’s been asked by a papist neighbor to journey to London to discover what has happened to his son Thomas.
Reluctant to do so, nevertheless he departs and goes to London. He will make enquires, visit his daughter and son-in-law (a man he has little time for) and return.
That was his thought! By the time he’s halfway through he has discovered plots that throw innocents to the wolves, justice sorely lacking, himself thrown into Debtor’s prison, and so much more.
It’s the ten year anniversary of the gunpowder plot. The population is nervous.
Pilkington’s writing is accessible, describes the times accurately, whilst weaving a deft and accessible mystery
I found myself unable to put down this likeable tale narrated by a righteous skeptic.
A Boldwood Books ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
July 15, 2026
First in the series of Justice Belstrange this was historical fiction, very well told. No frills, no histrionics.
Justice Belstrange now retired, is seeking his neighbours son who has gone missing in London. The problem is that the neighbours is strong Catholic, and 1616 was not a good time to be Catholic. There was severe antagonism and witch-hunt for anyone with a hint of being Catholic and Belstrange was going very close to being tarred as popish in his quest.
Belstrange finds the boy eventually at the Bedlam Asylum in a very psychotic state. But the question is not without danger because Belstrange has now become the target of the rich and powerful at the Court. He is maligned, drugged thrown in jail - all to intimidate him and force him to give up on the search for Thomas Jessop and return home. But Belstrange once he decides on something is determined and he is one man who will fight for justice.
The best of historical fiction coupled with religious fear make this an excellent read.
Justice Belstrange now retired, is seeking his neighbours son who has gone missing in London. The problem is that the neighbours is strong Catholic, and 1616 was not a good time to be Catholic. There was severe antagonism and witch-hunt for anyone with a hint of being Catholic and Belstrange was going very close to being tarred as popish in his quest.
Belstrange finds the boy eventually at the Bedlam Asylum in a very psychotic state. But the question is not without danger because Belstrange has now become the target of the rich and powerful at the Court. He is maligned, drugged thrown in jail - all to intimidate him and force him to give up on the search for Thomas Jessop and return home. But Belstrange once he decides on something is determined and he is one man who will fight for justice.
The best of historical fiction coupled with religious fear make this an excellent read.
June 25, 2026
Robert Belstrang is back with a historical mystery that will put his life in danger!
Belstrang is headed to London to help his neighbor find his son who went on a pilgrimage there but hasn't returned. These are very dangerous times since being Catholic could get you imprisoned. Belstrang does find the boy, Thomas Jessop, but the conditions he finds them in are deplorable. The boy was kept at the Bedlam Assylum. As he tries to help get the boy out, Belstrang is caught in a corrupt and strategic ploy to keep him silenced.
I enjoy how this series started strong and nothing is more enticing than a mystery set in the past. I like how historical facts are portrayed and how they are incorporated into the novel. The story moved quickly and the twists arrive perfectly during the investigation. There is never a dull moment in this story.
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for this eARC. All opinions are entirely my own.
Belstrang is headed to London to help his neighbor find his son who went on a pilgrimage there but hasn't returned. These are very dangerous times since being Catholic could get you imprisoned. Belstrang does find the boy, Thomas Jessop, but the conditions he finds them in are deplorable. The boy was kept at the Bedlam Assylum. As he tries to help get the boy out, Belstrang is caught in a corrupt and strategic ploy to keep him silenced.
I enjoy how this series started strong and nothing is more enticing than a mystery set in the past. I like how historical facts are portrayed and how they are incorporated into the novel. The story moved quickly and the twists arrive perfectly during the investigation. There is never a dull moment in this story.
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for this eARC. All opinions are entirely my own.
July 30, 2026
Deep in the heart of Worcestershire Justice Belstrang lives a quiet life until his neighbour appears on his doorstep pleading for help. Jessop is a catholic and so is subject to limitations on his movements but his son has gone missing in London and he asks Belstrang to go to find him. When Belstrang arrives in London he discovers that the boy is in the Bedlam Hospital, then Belstrang is drugged and placed in debtors prison. Calling on his old contacts Belstrang is set free and discovers that young Jessop is a dupe in a plot to assainate the King, coming so soon after the Gunpowder Treason this is serious.
The reader knows what they are going to get from a Pilkington novel and this new series is no exception. It's a pacy story with lots of intrigue, the setting is interesting being the mid-point of James I's reign. Belstrang is an intriguing proponent, there is clearly an interesting backstory which is only hinted at in this book. All together an enjoyable read
The reader knows what they are going to get from a Pilkington novel and this new series is no exception. It's a pacy story with lots of intrigue, the setting is interesting being the mid-point of James I's reign. Belstrang is an intriguing proponent, there is clearly an interesting backstory which is only hinted at in this book. All together an enjoyable read
June 29, 2026
1616. Former Justice Robert Belstrang is asked by his neighbour, John Jessop, if he could go to London to see if his son, Thomas, is alive. John and his wife have received their son’s belongings together with his last letter, which contained worrying content. The letter gave an address in London but, as a Catholic, John is unable to travel without a warrant and the Sheriff is not likely to grant him one. Reluctantly Robert Belstrang agrees – it will also give him an opportunity to see his daughter, meet his grand-daughter and also to try and mend his relationship with his son-in-law.
What seems to be an innocuous request to give assistance to a neighbour leads Robert into a great deal of trouble, nearly costing him his life.
A fascinating storyline with lots of historical detail and plots galore!
Thanks to Net Galley and Boldwood Books for an ARC for my honest review.
What seems to be an innocuous request to give assistance to a neighbour leads Robert into a great deal of trouble, nearly costing him his life.
A fascinating storyline with lots of historical detail and plots galore!
Thanks to Net Galley and Boldwood Books for an ARC for my honest review.
August 27, 2026
The Justice Belstrang Mysteries Book 1
Well deserved 5 🌟 review
I enjoyed this book so much that I purchased the next book.
The way the story is written it feels as if the main character is sitting with you discussing how everything happened, from when his friend asked him to go to London to find his son and bring him home, to his travels and the trials and tribulations that he experienced. Set during the reign of King James I (VI of Scotland) in a staunchly Protestant England the young man he’s looking for is Catholic and has been arrested. Everyone is suspicious of Belstrang and he’s being followed and being warned off his search. It’s an interesting plot with plenty of twists and turns before our Justice Belstrang gets to the bottom of the mystery and not everyone is who they seem.
Excellent read, I loved it 👍🏼
Well deserved 5 🌟 review
I enjoyed this book so much that I purchased the next book.
The way the story is written it feels as if the main character is sitting with you discussing how everything happened, from when his friend asked him to go to London to find his son and bring him home, to his travels and the trials and tribulations that he experienced. Set during the reign of King James I (VI of Scotland) in a staunchly Protestant England the young man he’s looking for is Catholic and has been arrested. Everyone is suspicious of Belstrang and he’s being followed and being warned off his search. It’s an interesting plot with plenty of twists and turns before our Justice Belstrang gets to the bottom of the mystery and not everyone is who they seem.
Excellent read, I loved it 👍🏼
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A promising series! I enjoyed it, though I felt something was missing: there was not much tension, and I think too many thoughts conveyed by Belstrang. The novel is written in the first person, and I found Belstrang lacking in a way. I found his way of dealing with people somehow irritating, as if threatening them was his only way to make them talk. On the other hand, the novel enjoys an atmospheric historical background which is interesting. The plot was well done (albeit the lack of tension), leading the way to a satisfying conclusion. If the main character gets a bit more interesting in the following books, the series will be really compelling!
I received a digital copy of this novel from NetGalley and I have voluntarily written an honest review.
I received a digital copy of this novel from NetGalley and I have voluntarily written an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A new series from John Pilkington. This concerns ex-magistrate Robert Belstrang who is petitioned by his neighbour to look for his son who is missing in London. This is a gripping story of plotters and subterfugue during the reign of King James the first of England and sixth of Scotland. With well described locations and characters we are lead into the story as if we were actually there. The locations are described in such a way that it is easy to picture the area and a plus for me, it also mentions the place of my birth (and where I still live) in Essex. I could feel the indignation of the characters when things didn't go their way. A thoroughly satisfying ending rounded off an excellent read. With thanks to the author and Boldwood Books for the opportunity to read this book.
July 9, 2026
This tale took me longer to get into with the style of writing. It started to grow on me after a while but it is not a favorite for me. It is set in the early 1600's and the main character is a retired justice (story told by him). There is a lot from that time period that I am not familiar with and that may have affect some of my understanding/ enjoyment of the story. I feel the author understood that period well but it took a bit for me to get used to his way of telling the story.
The many obstacles that he encountered seemed to make him more determined instead of discouraging him, His sense of justice prevailed in his endeavors even though he no longer served in that capacity.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
The many obstacles that he encountered seemed to make him more determined instead of discouraging him, His sense of justice prevailed in his endeavors even though he no longer served in that capacity.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is the first in a new series by John Pilkington. I've enjoyed their other books and was interested to see what this series would be about.
Set in 17th century, it focuses on the former Justice Robert Belstrang. Now living in the country he becomes involved in the disappearance of a neighbour’s son.
It leads him to the murky side of London's political stage and also to the desperation of prisons and Bedlam. It's an intriguing and absorbing plot that touches on post-Gubpowder Plot politics.
It's coming out June 23rd and I would thoroughly recommend it to people that enjoy historical mystery novels.
Thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC
Set in 17th century, it focuses on the former Justice Robert Belstrang. Now living in the country he becomes involved in the disappearance of a neighbour’s son.
It leads him to the murky side of London's political stage and also to the desperation of prisons and Bedlam. It's an intriguing and absorbing plot that touches on post-Gubpowder Plot politics.
It's coming out June 23rd and I would thoroughly recommend it to people that enjoy historical mystery novels.
Thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC
June 24, 2026
You know....you're just trying to do a nice thing for a neighbor and it blows up in your face. Go figure.
I enjoy historical mysteries and this ticked all of my boxes. It was also a bit of a slow read for me since the wording, although correct for 1616, bogged me down a bit. As the story unfolded, the reading did get easier as the story got more compelling.
My takeaway, nothing changes. There will always be people in power who want to subjugate others, then try to cover it up. This book was a bit of a history lesson for me, since I knew little about living in 1616 England. I liked the blending of historical fact with fictional characters. A worthwhile read.
I enjoy historical mysteries and this ticked all of my boxes. It was also a bit of a slow read for me since the wording, although correct for 1616, bogged me down a bit. As the story unfolded, the reading did get easier as the story got more compelling.
My takeaway, nothing changes. There will always be people in power who want to subjugate others, then try to cover it up. This book was a bit of a history lesson for me, since I knew little about living in 1616 England. I liked the blending of historical fact with fictional characters. A worthwhile read.
June 29, 2026
Overall 3.75*
First thing to note is that this story is a republication of a book entitled "Legacy" .
It is set in the 17th c with both fact and fiction intertwined which I enjoy. The description of life back then was very realistic and you definitely wouldn't have wanted to be in prison back then least of all in Bedlam where part of it is set. The timeline is 10 years after the failed Gunpowder plot, with the background idea that another attempt has been tried. It may have been different in England then however as a Scot, there is no way that a Protestant would help a Roman Catholic however friendly they may be !
Thanks to Netgalley/Boldwood books for the ARC
First thing to note is that this story is a republication of a book entitled "Legacy" .
It is set in the 17th c with both fact and fiction intertwined which I enjoy. The description of life back then was very realistic and you definitely wouldn't have wanted to be in prison back then least of all in Bedlam where part of it is set. The timeline is 10 years after the failed Gunpowder plot, with the background idea that another attempt has been tried. It may have been different in England then however as a Scot, there is no way that a Protestant would help a Roman Catholic however friendly they may be !
Thanks to Netgalley/Boldwood books for the ARC
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I DO like a book that teaches me something, and this one is set in a time I've never given a moments thought.
So I'm now somewhat wiser on the politics of religion at the time and the consequences of keeping your faith.
Belstrang is a decent lead, capable and fair I thought.
Quite laid back in terms of pacing and tension I thought, but it doesn't detract from the book.
An enjoyable bit of historical fiction.
Thanks to netgalley for the free digital copy
So I'm now somewhat wiser on the politics of religion at the time and the consequences of keeping your faith.
Belstrang is a decent lead, capable and fair I thought.
Quite laid back in terms of pacing and tension I thought, but it doesn't detract from the book.
An enjoyable bit of historical fiction.
Thanks to netgalley for the free digital copy
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
My thanks to the Author publisher's and NetGalley for providing me with a Kindle version of this book to read and honestly review.
This is a quality story well written, atmospheric descriptive and intelligent storytelling with superb characterisation throughout. A slow burner of a mystery that develops with plenty of surprises and twists along the way. An excellent start to the series.
Completely recommended.
This is a quality story well written, atmospheric descriptive and intelligent storytelling with superb characterisation throughout. A slow burner of a mystery that develops with plenty of surprises and twists along the way. An excellent start to the series.
Completely recommended.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews