There is always a danger when grounding a piece of fiction against a very particular aspect of reality, especially when making your characters so well-known in their field, that it can grate a little. That it can make it seem as if you are raising your pretend people above those who would have been their real-life contemporaries, or even crediting them with achievements which really belonged to others.
This was an issues I had with the closest comparison I can think of to Tim Pieraccini’s No Way to Beehive, Salman Rushdie’s The Ground Beneath Her Feet, but it is certainly not an issue here. Pieraccini never gives you the feeling that he is trying to make his characters more important and significant than the real-world acts mentioned – instead, he integrates the ‘reality’ of The Sweet Pills perfectly with history and popular culture as we know them.
The real strength of the story though, and always the most important element in any work of fiction, is that it makes you care about these characters. It makes you want to know what happens to them next. And it really does immerse you in a world which feels real; anyone with an interest in the popular culture and social history of the 1960s, or of British pop music of that period, will find themselves deeply engaged with this story. But even if you're not interested in those things, I do think this is very much worth a read as you'll want to spend time in the company of these characters.
That’s to such an extent that No Way to Beehive also overcomes the other issue which can strike stories of this kind, and again particularly so with The Ground Beneath Her Feet – that the music doesn’t really exist, the songs aren’t real, you don’t know them and never can, but on the page we are told how great they were. Once again, I never felt that was a major problem here, because the format and the writing were so compelling that they carry you along on the characters’ journeys so you don’t stop and wonder about those sorts of issues.
Definitely recommended for anybody who wants to lose themselves in an expertly-constructed narrative with very real-feeling characters in a pitch-perfect depiction of an aspect of the 1960s. Even if it didn’t really happen this way, it’ll fully convince you that it could well have done.
I found this story quite addictive. And it was so well written and clearly a labour of love by the author.
Throughout, I suspected and hoped that the book portrayed real life events, so much so that I googled in vain for more information about The Sweet Pills. It was a wrench to have to come to terms with the discovery that it was indeed all fiction. What a shame that our musical history does not include this dynamic group!
The Sweet Pills also wonderfully echoes Taylor Jenkins Reid’s epic Daisy Jones & The Six, of course!