What do you think?
Rate this book
A Contrary Betrothal
A Cherokee lieutenant, a colonel’s daughter, and a desperate fight to protect both land and love.
Sam Hicks may be the educated son of a Cherokee chief, but his command of multiple languages and diplomatic skills can’t erase the prejudice he faces as a mixed-blood warrior. When he’s tasked with guarding Colonel Moore’s spirited daughter, Susanna, at a wilderness fort, he never expects to lose his heart to a woman he can never have.
Susanna Moore dreams of making her own way on the frontier like her Cherokee stepmother. The last thing she wants is an arranged marriage to the fort’s stuffy doctor—especially after she meets the noble and intelligent Sam Hicks. When she’s captured by a turncoat warrior during a Creek uprising, Sam risks everything to save her.
Their shared values and growing love give them hope—but with the Creek War raging and cultural pressures mounting, can a Cherokee lieutenant and a colonel’s daughter overcome the loyalties and prejudices set against them?
Sam Hicks may be the educated son of a Cherokee chief, but his command of multiple languages and diplomatic skills can’t erase the prejudice he faces as a mixed-blood warrior. When he’s tasked with guarding Colonel Moore’s spirited daughter, Susanna, at a wilderness fort, he never expects to lose his heart to a woman he can never have.
Susanna Moore dreams of making her own way on the frontier like her Cherokee stepmother. The last thing she wants is an arranged marriage to the fort’s stuffy doctor—especially after she meets the noble and intelligent Sam Hicks. When she’s captured by a turncoat warrior during a Creek uprising, Sam risks everything to save her.
Their shared values and growing love give them hope—but with the Creek War raging and cultural pressures mounting, can a Cherokee lieutenant and a colonel’s daughter overcome the loyalties and prejudices set against them?
- GenresRomanceHistorical
279 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 18, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
August 29, 2026
“‘Not yet.’ ‘Soon.’ ‘Almost.’” George picked up a pine frond and examined it carefully. “Seems like a lot of things not happening.” “That is the way of it for our people, George.”
An obscure quote? Perhaps. But I find it very accurately describes the frustration of the Cherokee people in the time of this book, A Contrary Betrothal, by Denise Farnsworth . ( Which, though book #6 in this series, Scouts of the Revolution, this was originally published as Bent Tree Bride. Fair warning to those who don’t like to buy a new book only to discover they have already read it!)
I think I could wax eloquent and write a whole book about my thoughts on this novel. At the very least, I would love to discuss the political intrigue and double standards presented between the Caucasians, the Cherokee, and the Red Stick people (who I was motivated to research on my own). If I were still teaching upper elementary, this book’s facts (delineated with historical figures mentioned and separating fact from artistic license) along with the very real political climate would help provide background into my lessons. Farnsworth makes me feel deeply the angst of the Cherokee people and the Red Sticks, both who realize the precariousness of their possession of the Tennessee-North Carolina mountain forest land. Each tribe must choose a side of the War of 1812 to side with- the British or the Americans- and pray that their side wins, and that said government will keep the promises they make to their Native American partners.
It is into this massive backdrop of confusion that Farnsworth places her two star-crossed lovers. One, Sam Hicks, is a mixed-blood Cherokee and Caucasian. Which means, he fights for his place in either world. Trained in both, he has the skills of a Cherokee warrior, but is ridiculed because he doesn’t follow all their tortuous customs, having learned about Jesus from missionaries. His ultimate questions: can he fight like a Cherokee and restore his lost honor? Will his mixed blood mean he must relinquish his love for Susanna which grows as he is assigned by her double-standard enforcing father to be her body guard?
“The man who’d captured her imagination from a single day’s meeting was a Cherokee. White women did not marry Cherokee men.” Poor Susanna! Her powerful Caucasian father, himself married a second time to a wonderful Cherokee woman, insists Susanna can only marry a Caucasian man, esp. his choice, Dr. Hawkins. The whole book, I was rather violently seething with Susanna at her father’s total inability to see his double standards. Unfortunately, it is one I see exhibited by people today, some very close to me. How can you honestly love a spouse and denounce or hold prejudice against their people? What about ourselves? Do we say we don’t have prejudices, but they linger in big and small ways? Our faith speaks to that!!
I think what makes this book one of true sadness for me, is that we have the perspective of history behind us. We know how the greed for land and gain in this area affects the Native Americans. But I would be a liar not to be grateful that this land is part of our country now where we can travel, visit,or live freely. Farnsworth shows both the underbelly of all three cultures, and those who are honestly trying to, through faith in God, and following human kindness, make the best of trying times. Keep your eyes open for important historical figures (one I didn’t recognize!) that are included in this emotional, faith-filled, romantic book!
At the risk of running on too long, when I saw the list of comparable Christian historical authors, I understood immediately why I loved this book. Here they are: Michelle Griep, Shannon McNear, Laura Frantz, and Lori Benton. *Le Sigh*
I received a copy of the book from CelebrateLit, the author and Wild Heart Books via BookFunnel. I bought my own ecopy and I’m off to buy a pb copy for trophy shelf. No positive opinion was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“She was most definitely not in control. But she believed in Someone who was. And if she believed His goodness, she also must believe He had a good future for her.”
“To be without a clan is to be without an identity.”
“Then you cannot fight this war to prove yourself to the colonel. That is fighting from a position of weakness. You are sure to lose. Instead, you must forgive the colonel. If you fight, it must be what you believe is right before God, asking Him to come alongside you to help our people. That is fighting from a position of strength.”
“Is it ever a just cause to turn brothers against each other? Do we deceive ourselves that the English won’t take the land of the Creeks if they win this war, then turn on us for ours?”
“Save your anger. To show restraint is wiser than to engage a fool.”
“I want the two wolves to lie together inside. In peace.”
“He’d fallen to quoting scriptures in his head after that. By the time they crossed Chockelocko Creek, he’d restored some semblance of inner peace.”
“Sam saw the way forward in words, not wars.”
An obscure quote? Perhaps. But I find it very accurately describes the frustration of the Cherokee people in the time of this book, A Contrary Betrothal, by Denise Farnsworth . ( Which, though book #6 in this series, Scouts of the Revolution, this was originally published as Bent Tree Bride. Fair warning to those who don’t like to buy a new book only to discover they have already read it!)
I think I could wax eloquent and write a whole book about my thoughts on this novel. At the very least, I would love to discuss the political intrigue and double standards presented between the Caucasians, the Cherokee, and the Red Stick people (who I was motivated to research on my own). If I were still teaching upper elementary, this book’s facts (delineated with historical figures mentioned and separating fact from artistic license) along with the very real political climate would help provide background into my lessons. Farnsworth makes me feel deeply the angst of the Cherokee people and the Red Sticks, both who realize the precariousness of their possession of the Tennessee-North Carolina mountain forest land. Each tribe must choose a side of the War of 1812 to side with- the British or the Americans- and pray that their side wins, and that said government will keep the promises they make to their Native American partners.
It is into this massive backdrop of confusion that Farnsworth places her two star-crossed lovers. One, Sam Hicks, is a mixed-blood Cherokee and Caucasian. Which means, he fights for his place in either world. Trained in both, he has the skills of a Cherokee warrior, but is ridiculed because he doesn’t follow all their tortuous customs, having learned about Jesus from missionaries. His ultimate questions: can he fight like a Cherokee and restore his lost honor? Will his mixed blood mean he must relinquish his love for Susanna which grows as he is assigned by her double-standard enforcing father to be her body guard?
“The man who’d captured her imagination from a single day’s meeting was a Cherokee. White women did not marry Cherokee men.” Poor Susanna! Her powerful Caucasian father, himself married a second time to a wonderful Cherokee woman, insists Susanna can only marry a Caucasian man, esp. his choice, Dr. Hawkins. The whole book, I was rather violently seething with Susanna at her father’s total inability to see his double standards. Unfortunately, it is one I see exhibited by people today, some very close to me. How can you honestly love a spouse and denounce or hold prejudice against their people? What about ourselves? Do we say we don’t have prejudices, but they linger in big and small ways? Our faith speaks to that!!
I think what makes this book one of true sadness for me, is that we have the perspective of history behind us. We know how the greed for land and gain in this area affects the Native Americans. But I would be a liar not to be grateful that this land is part of our country now where we can travel, visit,or live freely. Farnsworth shows both the underbelly of all three cultures, and those who are honestly trying to, through faith in God, and following human kindness, make the best of trying times. Keep your eyes open for important historical figures (one I didn’t recognize!) that are included in this emotional, faith-filled, romantic book!
At the risk of running on too long, when I saw the list of comparable Christian historical authors, I understood immediately why I loved this book. Here they are: Michelle Griep, Shannon McNear, Laura Frantz, and Lori Benton. *Le Sigh*
I received a copy of the book from CelebrateLit, the author and Wild Heart Books via BookFunnel. I bought my own ecopy and I’m off to buy a pb copy for trophy shelf. No positive opinion was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“She was most definitely not in control. But she believed in Someone who was. And if she believed His goodness, she also must believe He had a good future for her.”
“To be without a clan is to be without an identity.”
“Then you cannot fight this war to prove yourself to the colonel. That is fighting from a position of weakness. You are sure to lose. Instead, you must forgive the colonel. If you fight, it must be what you believe is right before God, asking Him to come alongside you to help our people. That is fighting from a position of strength.”
“Is it ever a just cause to turn brothers against each other? Do we deceive ourselves that the English won’t take the land of the Creeks if they win this war, then turn on us for ours?”
“Save your anger. To show restraint is wiser than to engage a fool.”
“I want the two wolves to lie together inside. In peace.”
“He’d fallen to quoting scriptures in his head after that. By the time they crossed Chockelocko Creek, he’d restored some semblance of inner peace.”
“Sam saw the way forward in words, not wars.”
September 3, 2026
A Contrary Betrothal by Denise Farnsworth, writing as Denise Weimer, is a Christian Historical Romance. Some love stories are complicated. Others seem downright impossible.
That’s what makes this historical romance so captivating. From the moment Sam Hicks and Susanna Moore meet, it’s clear that there are far more obstacles standing between them than simply admitting they care for one another. With cultural expectations, prejudice, family pressures, and a war threatening the frontier, their love is going to be tested in ways neither of them could have imagined.
Sam Hicks immediately caught my attention. He’s intelligent, educated, and skilled at diplomacy, speaking multiple languages and carrying himself with the kind of quiet strength that makes him an easy hero to admire. Yet despite everything he has accomplished, he still faces prejudice because of his mixed heritage. He knows that being a Cherokee lieutenant comes with limitations—and falling in love with a colonel’s daughter is definitely crossing a line society has drawn for him.
Then there’s Susanna.
I loved that Susanna isn’t content to do what everyone expects of her. She dreams of creating a life for herself on the frontier, following the example of her Cherokee stepmother. An arranged marriage to the fort doctor is the last thing she wants, especially once she meets Sam and discovers a man who challenges her expectations in all the best ways.
The connection between Sam and Susanna develops against a backdrop of danger and uncertainty, making their romance all the more compelling. They share values, respect one another, and slowly discover that their feelings are becoming much deeper than either intended. But knowing they love each other doesn’t magically make the obstacles disappear.
In fact, those obstacles become even more dangerous when Susanna is captured during the Creek uprising.
Sam is willing to risk everything to bring her home, and this part of the story adds an exciting layer of adventure to an already engaging romance. With the Creek War raging around them, Sam and Susanna aren’t just fighting for their future together—they’re fighting to survive.
What I especially enjoyed about this story is that the romance isn’t isolated from the historical setting. The cultural tensions and prejudice Sam faces feel like an important part of his character and his journey. At the same time, Susanna’s determination to make her own choices gives her a strength that makes her easy to cheer for.
There’s something satisfying about watching two people who aren’t supposed to be together discover that their shared values and growing love may be stronger than the expectations placed upon them.
If you enjoy Christian historical romance with frontier adventure, strong and independent heroines, honorable heroes, cultural conflict, and a romance that has plenty of obstacles to overcome, this one deserves a place on your reading list.
Sam and Susanna’s story is a reminder that sometimes love requires courage—not just to pursue it, but to stand up for what you believe is right when everyone around you says you shouldn’t.
And honestly, those are the kinds of love stories I find hardest to put down.
So if you enjoy Christian historical romances, check out A Contrary Betrothal by Denise Farnsworth writing as Denise Weimer. I definitely recommend it.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
That’s what makes this historical romance so captivating. From the moment Sam Hicks and Susanna Moore meet, it’s clear that there are far more obstacles standing between them than simply admitting they care for one another. With cultural expectations, prejudice, family pressures, and a war threatening the frontier, their love is going to be tested in ways neither of them could have imagined.
Sam Hicks immediately caught my attention. He’s intelligent, educated, and skilled at diplomacy, speaking multiple languages and carrying himself with the kind of quiet strength that makes him an easy hero to admire. Yet despite everything he has accomplished, he still faces prejudice because of his mixed heritage. He knows that being a Cherokee lieutenant comes with limitations—and falling in love with a colonel’s daughter is definitely crossing a line society has drawn for him.
Then there’s Susanna.
I loved that Susanna isn’t content to do what everyone expects of her. She dreams of creating a life for herself on the frontier, following the example of her Cherokee stepmother. An arranged marriage to the fort doctor is the last thing she wants, especially once she meets Sam and discovers a man who challenges her expectations in all the best ways.
The connection between Sam and Susanna develops against a backdrop of danger and uncertainty, making their romance all the more compelling. They share values, respect one another, and slowly discover that their feelings are becoming much deeper than either intended. But knowing they love each other doesn’t magically make the obstacles disappear.
In fact, those obstacles become even more dangerous when Susanna is captured during the Creek uprising.
Sam is willing to risk everything to bring her home, and this part of the story adds an exciting layer of adventure to an already engaging romance. With the Creek War raging around them, Sam and Susanna aren’t just fighting for their future together—they’re fighting to survive.
What I especially enjoyed about this story is that the romance isn’t isolated from the historical setting. The cultural tensions and prejudice Sam faces feel like an important part of his character and his journey. At the same time, Susanna’s determination to make her own choices gives her a strength that makes her easy to cheer for.
There’s something satisfying about watching two people who aren’t supposed to be together discover that their shared values and growing love may be stronger than the expectations placed upon them.
If you enjoy Christian historical romance with frontier adventure, strong and independent heroines, honorable heroes, cultural conflict, and a romance that has plenty of obstacles to overcome, this one deserves a place on your reading list.
Sam and Susanna’s story is a reminder that sometimes love requires courage—not just to pursue it, but to stand up for what you believe is right when everyone around you says you shouldn’t.
And honestly, those are the kinds of love stories I find hardest to put down.
So if you enjoy Christian historical romances, check out A Contrary Betrothal by Denise Farnsworth writing as Denise Weimer. I definitely recommend it.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
September 4, 2026
MY THOUGHTS
Historical fiction has always been one of my favorite genres, and this time period is one of my favorites to read about, so I was pretty excited to pick up A Contrary Betrothal. I am also a huge fan of this author. I loved getting pulled into the setting of the Creek War and learning more about the Cherokee people who fought alongside American troops. This is exactly the kind of historical fiction that has me finishing a chapter and then wanting to go look things up because now I need to know more.
Sam was probably my favorite character. He’s strong, smart, honorable, and protective. Because of his Cherokee heritage, he’s constantly dealing with people who make assumptions about him before actually getting to know him. I really liked his quiet strength and the way his personality came through without him needing to be the loudest person in the room.
And Susanna? She definitely has opinions. 😂 She’s independent, stubborn, determined, and really not interested in everyone else deciding what her life is supposed to look like. I love strong and fierce characters. I loved that about her! She has plenty of spirit, and considering everything women had to deal with during this time period, I couldn’t really blame her for wanting some say in her own future.
For me, the historical setting and the characters were definitely the highlights of this one. Give me interesting history, characters with actual personalities, some danger, faith, and a romance involving two people who can both be a little stubborn, and I’m happy!
Thank you to Denise Farnsworth, Wild Heart Books, and Celebrate Lit for providing me with a complimentary copy of A Contrary Betrothal. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Historical fiction has always been one of my favorite genres, and this time period is one of my favorites to read about, so I was pretty excited to pick up A Contrary Betrothal. I am also a huge fan of this author. I loved getting pulled into the setting of the Creek War and learning more about the Cherokee people who fought alongside American troops. This is exactly the kind of historical fiction that has me finishing a chapter and then wanting to go look things up because now I need to know more.
Sam was probably my favorite character. He’s strong, smart, honorable, and protective. Because of his Cherokee heritage, he’s constantly dealing with people who make assumptions about him before actually getting to know him. I really liked his quiet strength and the way his personality came through without him needing to be the loudest person in the room.
And Susanna? She definitely has opinions. 😂 She’s independent, stubborn, determined, and really not interested in everyone else deciding what her life is supposed to look like. I love strong and fierce characters. I loved that about her! She has plenty of spirit, and considering everything women had to deal with during this time period, I couldn’t really blame her for wanting some say in her own future.
For me, the historical setting and the characters were definitely the highlights of this one. Give me interesting history, characters with actual personalities, some danger, faith, and a romance involving two people who can both be a little stubborn, and I’m happy!
Thank you to Denise Farnsworth, Wild Heart Books, and Celebrate Lit for providing me with a complimentary copy of A Contrary Betrothal. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
September 4, 2026
What you might need to know:
A Contrary Betrothal by Denise Farnsworth is the sixth book in the Scouts of the Georgia Frontier series. Set in Cherokee Territory in 1813 this book. This book features Susanna Moore the daughter of a US Colonel and Sam Hicks who is the son of a Cherokee Chief. While this book is the sixth in the series it can be read as a standalone.
What you might need to know:
This book was previously published as Bent Tree Bride.
This book is set in 1813, this book does feature war and death, the author does include some of the deaths on the page.
This book features white and native conflict as well as prejudice.
What I think about this book:
Susanna has been raised by her father and Cherokee step mother, she is a strong young woman who has embraced her step family. I really appreciated her strength and steadfastness in the face of extreme adversity. Sam was also a wonderful character, he is caught between two worlds and not fully accepted in either, however he did not allow this to keep him from working to serve both to better the country. One of my least favorite characters in the book may have been Colonel Moore, however looking at it with a historical lens and knowing what happened to the Cherokee people when they were forcibly removed from their lands I try to remind myself that he may have seen the writing on the wall. Once again Farnsworth did a wonderful job of tackling a tough time period and bringing to life with characters that kept me captivated. I will definitely read more books by her!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Celebrate Lit, this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
A Contrary Betrothal by Denise Farnsworth is the sixth book in the Scouts of the Georgia Frontier series. Set in Cherokee Territory in 1813 this book. This book features Susanna Moore the daughter of a US Colonel and Sam Hicks who is the son of a Cherokee Chief. While this book is the sixth in the series it can be read as a standalone.
What you might need to know:
This book was previously published as Bent Tree Bride.
This book is set in 1813, this book does feature war and death, the author does include some of the deaths on the page.
This book features white and native conflict as well as prejudice.
What I think about this book:
Susanna has been raised by her father and Cherokee step mother, she is a strong young woman who has embraced her step family. I really appreciated her strength and steadfastness in the face of extreme adversity. Sam was also a wonderful character, he is caught between two worlds and not fully accepted in either, however he did not allow this to keep him from working to serve both to better the country. One of my least favorite characters in the book may have been Colonel Moore, however looking at it with a historical lens and knowing what happened to the Cherokee people when they were forcibly removed from their lands I try to remind myself that he may have seen the writing on the wall. Once again Farnsworth did a wonderful job of tackling a tough time period and bringing to life with characters that kept me captivated. I will definitely read more books by her!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Celebrate Lit, this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
September 8, 2026
This novel transported me back into history from the first page of this couple's first meet. Seemingly from different worlds, these two have been told they are not meant for one another. Sam Hicks is half Cherokee and an invaluable asset to the Americans during the War of 1812 and continues to be. The moment Susanna Moore bumps into him, he experiences feelings he never has before. Susanna on the other hand was trying to hide from the man that her father deems is the perfect match for her. A much older man that Susanna does not love nor does she want to be married too.
Her father has double standards on who can marry his daughter even though his wife is half Cherokee. Poor Susanna, I felt her anger and pain of the double standards her father pushed on her. Then due to circumstances, Sam is ordered to be Susanna and her brother's guard. Things get a little bit interesting as you have two people who are attracted to one another always in each other's presence.
This was an interesting novel going back to 1813 and the turmoil and trouble that was still going on as our nation was still so young. Of allegiances and battles that shaped her, and of a love that would not flicker and go out. There was a couple of battlefronts for freedom taking place, the battlefield and within the heart.
I was provided a copy of this novel from the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review, and all views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
Her father has double standards on who can marry his daughter even though his wife is half Cherokee. Poor Susanna, I felt her anger and pain of the double standards her father pushed on her. Then due to circumstances, Sam is ordered to be Susanna and her brother's guard. Things get a little bit interesting as you have two people who are attracted to one another always in each other's presence.
This was an interesting novel going back to 1813 and the turmoil and trouble that was still going on as our nation was still so young. Of allegiances and battles that shaped her, and of a love that would not flicker and go out. There was a couple of battlefronts for freedom taking place, the battlefield and within the heart.
I was provided a copy of this novel from the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review, and all views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is the first book that I have read in this series, and have already bought the five previous books. Just haven't had the chance to read them yet , but I can't wait to dive into them. While this story is fictional, I enjoyed reading about this time in history that has actual facts in it. Susanna is the eldest daughter of Captain Moore and he wants her to marry the doctor. Sam Hicks is part of the Cherokee Regiment who takes their orders from Captain Moore. There seems to be a spark between them and Sam knows that nothing will come of it because of their different backgrounds. As the war starts and word is sent about Captain Moore being sick, his wife comes to his aid and brings Susanna along to help. With Sam being asked to watch over her and her younger brother, he becomes more attached. But with the doctor near that has asked for her hand in marriage and the war raging, what will happen? I felt myself being torn in two while reading. I didn't know how the story would turn out. I won't say whether or not it has a happy ending, don't want to give away any spoilers. I just know that I love reading books like this, even with the war scenes. It's a part of our history whether we like what happened or not. I look forward to reading more books from this author. I received a complimentary copy of this book, but was not required to leave a positive review. All opinions are what I thought of the story.
August 24, 2026
A Contrary Betrothal is the sixth book in the Scouts of the Georgis Frontier series by Denise Farnsworth. While being part of a series, this story makes a good stand-alone story. This story takes place in 1813 and gives a look into the Creek War, between the Red Stick Indians and the 1813 replicating the final wars between the Red Sticks Indians and those of the American and Cherokee nations.
Sam is a Cherokee scout for Susanna’s father when the two meet. There is an understanding that she should marry a local doctor, but she is immediately drawn to Sam. As they spend time together the feelings are mutual, but they have many things that stand in their way, especially those of their nationalities.
This is a nicely written story that is based on real events in our nation’s history. The author has done a lot of research to make this story close to what actually happened. I appreciate how she tells of the happenings without going into great details. I like that she gives detailed accounts of those at the end of the story. I enjoyed how Sam watches over Susanna and her family. I enjoyed the background information about both Sam and Susanna’s families. I enjoyed the relationship she has with her stepmother and siblings and how her father works to protect them. I especially enjoy the spunk her stepmother has where it comes to her father when he is ill.
I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book, this is my honest review.
Sam is a Cherokee scout for Susanna’s father when the two meet. There is an understanding that she should marry a local doctor, but she is immediately drawn to Sam. As they spend time together the feelings are mutual, but they have many things that stand in their way, especially those of their nationalities.
This is a nicely written story that is based on real events in our nation’s history. The author has done a lot of research to make this story close to what actually happened. I appreciate how she tells of the happenings without going into great details. I like that she gives detailed accounts of those at the end of the story. I enjoyed how Sam watches over Susanna and her family. I enjoyed the background information about both Sam and Susanna’s families. I enjoyed the relationship she has with her stepmother and siblings and how her father works to protect them. I especially enjoy the spunk her stepmother has where it comes to her father when he is ill.
I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book, this is my honest review.
September 5, 2026
Historical fiction is one of my favorite genres. I love history. It’s such a great part of who and what we are today, whether we want to admit it or not. I firmly believe we should study history and learn from it so we don’t repeat our mistakes.
This is book six in a series. I’ve been told you don’t have to read the series in order to make sense of the novel and that it can be read as a stand-alone. However, I always advocate reading a series in order. So take that as you will but do yourself a favor and add six books to your to be read pile. You won’t regret it.
So let’s get started.
Captain Moore wants his daughter to marry the doctor. Dare I say he’s already said she will? But that’s not what she wants. She’s a bit lively and indepent. Susanna comes out to stay with her father when he’s ill. Sam Hicks is part of the Cherokee regiment that is under her father and is tasked with watching out for and keeping her safe.
Proximity anyone?
The year is 1813. He’s Cherokee. She’s white. A romance between them is doomed from the start. It’s an amazing read and I fully support it!
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, which I received from Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review, nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
This is book six in a series. I’ve been told you don’t have to read the series in order to make sense of the novel and that it can be read as a stand-alone. However, I always advocate reading a series in order. So take that as you will but do yourself a favor and add six books to your to be read pile. You won’t regret it.
So let’s get started.
Captain Moore wants his daughter to marry the doctor. Dare I say he’s already said she will? But that’s not what she wants. She’s a bit lively and indepent. Susanna comes out to stay with her father when he’s ill. Sam Hicks is part of the Cherokee regiment that is under her father and is tasked with watching out for and keeping her safe.
Proximity anyone?
The year is 1813. He’s Cherokee. She’s white. A romance between them is doomed from the start. It’s an amazing read and I fully support it!
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, which I received from Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review, nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
Want to Read
September 6, 2026A Contrary Betrothal (originally published as Bent Tree Bride) is the sixth book of "The Scouts of the Georgia Frontier" series, and as is typical of Farnsworth, is well researched and well written. It can be read as a stand alone.
As you know (if you've been reading my blog for very long) that I love history, so historical fiction is my favorite genre. When actual historical figures pop up in that book, all the better! For example, mention is made of Andrew Jackson, and David Crockett, as well as John Ross (a name I ran across in some of my personal research on my ex-husband). Another reason this story appealed to me is, I know I have some Cherokee anscestry in my family.
I could really feel for both Sam and Susannah, and their growing attraction for each other in spite of some impossible odds against them. Although she is white, her step mother is Cherokee. But her father wants her to marry a white man. Sam is mixed race, white and Cherokee, and faces prejudice from both sides.
The setting is 1813, during the conflict between the Red Stick Indians and the American/Cherokee forces. Some of the brutality is eluded to, but nothing graphic.
If you enjoy historical fiction, with a touch of romance and a dose of faith, you will want to add this to your TBR list (as well as the rest of the series).
I received a complimentary copy. These opinions are my own.
As you know (if you've been reading my blog for very long) that I love history, so historical fiction is my favorite genre. When actual historical figures pop up in that book, all the better! For example, mention is made of Andrew Jackson, and David Crockett, as well as John Ross (a name I ran across in some of my personal research on my ex-husband). Another reason this story appealed to me is, I know I have some Cherokee anscestry in my family.
I could really feel for both Sam and Susannah, and their growing attraction for each other in spite of some impossible odds against them. Although she is white, her step mother is Cherokee. But her father wants her to marry a white man. Sam is mixed race, white and Cherokee, and faces prejudice from both sides.
The setting is 1813, during the conflict between the Red Stick Indians and the American/Cherokee forces. Some of the brutality is eluded to, but nothing graphic.
If you enjoy historical fiction, with a touch of romance and a dose of faith, you will want to add this to your TBR list (as well as the rest of the series).
I received a complimentary copy. These opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I've read all the previous books in this series but you don't have to read them to read this story. The author always does a fantastic job of researching her facts before writing every book. After the end of the book, she writes a very comprehensive guide as to what is actual truth in the story and what she has added as fiction, so the reader knows what parts of the book is actual history. That is what I enjoy.
I have to say that this story was a little more difficult for me to read because of the war aspect which includes the native American ways of violence. The author doesn't dwell on it, and it is truth but it's always hard for me to read it! That's just me! However, the lovely romance between Sam and Susanna was wonderful. It was very difficult in those days for two different classes to choose who they desired to marry. Sam was intelligent, humble and kind. He loved Susanna so much but being of another race and class made it hard to offer for her hand, plus he didn't enjoy being a warrior. Susanna was the daughter of Sam's commanding officer, and she didn't enjoy the higher society lifestyle although she really didn't live like that on the frontier. All the hardships she went through prepared her for life with Sam. Will they be able to be together or not? Time will tell.
I have to say that this story was a little more difficult for me to read because of the war aspect which includes the native American ways of violence. The author doesn't dwell on it, and it is truth but it's always hard for me to read it! That's just me! However, the lovely romance between Sam and Susanna was wonderful. It was very difficult in those days for two different classes to choose who they desired to marry. Sam was intelligent, humble and kind. He loved Susanna so much but being of another race and class made it hard to offer for her hand, plus he didn't enjoy being a warrior. Susanna was the daughter of Sam's commanding officer, and she didn't enjoy the higher society lifestyle although she really didn't live like that on the frontier. All the hardships she went through prepared her for life with Sam. Will they be able to be together or not? Time will tell.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This is an excellent historical novel set in 1813 replicating the final wars between the Red Sticks Indians and the joint forces of the Americans and Cherokee nation. The research was very well done, even in revealing the brutality of the times (nothing excessively graphic is written). My maternal grandmother has ancestry among the Cherokee nation from the reservation in North Carolina, so I enjoyed learning about the some of traditions, customs, thoughts, and words given.
Sam and Susanna come to know each other when Sam’s services as Cherokee scout are needed by her father, Captain Moore. Because Susanna is white and Sam is part Cherokee, they didn’t except the spark they felt to grow. But it did, and now they face hard questions and decisions, some of which are out of their control. They have much maturing to do as they both learn to let God control their lives. They do have a happy ending, but it is hard to read of the prejudices that people hold against others because of their family/ancestry.
I have enjoyed this series. I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and these are my voluntary and honest opinions. I was not required to leave a positive review.
Sam and Susanna come to know each other when Sam’s services as Cherokee scout are needed by her father, Captain Moore. Because Susanna is white and Sam is part Cherokee, they didn’t except the spark they felt to grow. But it did, and now they face hard questions and decisions, some of which are out of their control. They have much maturing to do as they both learn to let God control their lives. They do have a happy ending, but it is hard to read of the prejudices that people hold against others because of their family/ancestry.
I have enjoyed this series. I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and these are my voluntary and honest opinions. I was not required to leave a positive review.
September 1, 2026
Sam and Susanna are from different areas of the same side. Sam is skilled and takes his position seriously but is still faced with prejudice as the son of a Cherokee chief - on both sides of his mixed race. The story takes place at a wilderness fort. Susanna's stepmother is Cherokee and she would really like to be more like her. Her father prefers an older doctor for her, but after meeting Sam - well, you know. She's captured and Sam risks all to bring her back. As their attraction grows, they discover that they share values and draw closer, but the Creek war and prejudices against them don't make it easy. So well told, you look forward to getting back to the story each time you have to put it down.
I received this book free from the author, publisher and CelebrateLit book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
#AContraryBetrothal #DeniseFarnsworth #DeniseWeimer #BooksYouCanFeelGoodAbout #CelebrateLit #ChristianWesterns #WildHeartBooks
I received this book free from the author, publisher and CelebrateLit book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
#AContraryBetrothal #DeniseFarnsworth #DeniseWeimer #BooksYouCanFeelGoodAbout #CelebrateLit #ChristianWesterns #WildHeartBooks
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This is book 6, the final one in Farnsworth’s series - Scouts of the Georgia Frontier. Some of the earlier books in the series are related to the events in this book, as well as Farnsworth’s contribution to Freed by the Frontier, but you do not have to have read all those before reading this one.
The main love story drew me in, and I liked the characters and their interactions and the challenges to their relationship. I did not enjoy all the action and atrocities of the 1813-14 Red Stick War portion of the War of 1812 that took place in Tennessee and Alabama, involving Cherokee and Creek Indians along with US, British, and French troops.
Farnsworth fills her books with historical fact, which makes them all the more interesting, but sometimes the historical facts are pretty depressing.
"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own."
The main love story drew me in, and I liked the characters and their interactions and the challenges to their relationship. I did not enjoy all the action and atrocities of the 1813-14 Red Stick War portion of the War of 1812 that took place in Tennessee and Alabama, involving Cherokee and Creek Indians along with US, British, and French troops.
Farnsworth fills her books with historical fact, which makes them all the more interesting, but sometimes the historical facts are pretty depressing.
"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own."
August 29, 2026
The author does a really good job of taking readers back in time where difference in cultures were evident. Sam was interesting because he took his responsibilities with the Cherokee Regiment very serious. Times were hard trying to keep peace as people took sides and were determined to fight for their beliefs.
Susanna is a sweet character who wants to follow in her mother’s footsteps. I think her father had different plans for her though. He has chosen who she is to marry. I don’t think he consulted with Susanna though. When she and Sam cross paths, you can tell there is a hint of attraction.
I like how the two main characters work through differences and turn to God as they are challenged by circumstances. A beautiful story of overcoming prejudge, trusting God and working together as tensions mount in this historical look at war.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
Susanna is a sweet character who wants to follow in her mother’s footsteps. I think her father had different plans for her though. He has chosen who she is to marry. I don’t think he consulted with Susanna though. When she and Sam cross paths, you can tell there is a hint of attraction.
I like how the two main characters work through differences and turn to God as they are challenged by circumstances. A beautiful story of overcoming prejudge, trusting God and working together as tensions mount in this historical look at war.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
September 2, 2026
Another throughly satisfying read from the Scouts of the Georgia Frontier series. This is book six but each can be read as a stand-alone. I love that this author has the ability to blend actual facts with fiction seamlessly. She draws us in and we step back in time to 1813 on the Tennessee Cherokee Nation Border as we witness the Cherokee and Red Stick Creeks have to make choices as to whose side they must fight on the British or Americans in order to try to preserve their beloved people. My heart bled as I read of this difficult period in history and how prejudices colored judgement of others on each side. I loved the characterizations and the spiritual truths that are woven in. A well rounded read of faith, family, history,sweet romance, and human struggles. Be sure to read the Author’s notes at the end as they are very interesting and informative.
I received a complimentary copy from CelebrateLit/Wild Heart Books. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
I received a complimentary copy from CelebrateLit/Wild Heart Books. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
1813 was a tumultuous time along the Tennessee-Cherokee nation border. There was a great deal of unrest as the various peoples tried to make a stand for their land against those who would take it away. Sam Hicks was part Cherokee, part white and well educated. He was not a warrior, but acted as an emissary for Colonel Meigs and Colonel Moore. His ability to speak several languages was in great demand.
Susanna Moore found herself with two men who wanted to marry her. Dr. Hawkins was a widower with three children, older and not what she was hoping for. Sam, on the other hand, did not fit what her father wanted for his only white daughter. Would any of them survive the skirmishes and if so, who would win her hand?
This 6th book in the Scouts of the Georgia Frontier series was received through Wild Heart Books and BookFunnel. These thoughts are my own and were in no way solicited.
Susanna Moore found herself with two men who wanted to marry her. Dr. Hawkins was a widower with three children, older and not what she was hoping for. Sam, on the other hand, did not fit what her father wanted for his only white daughter. Would any of them survive the skirmishes and if so, who would win her hand?
This 6th book in the Scouts of the Georgia Frontier series was received through Wild Heart Books and BookFunnel. These thoughts are my own and were in no way solicited.
August 20, 2026
Scouts of the Georgia Frontier book 06, A Contrary Betrothal by Denise Farnsworth writing as Denise Weimer is a heartfelt historical Christian romance that captures my heart from the beginning. A time of war between Native Americans, British and the young Untied States was always on the mind of those in 1813. The fact that the Native Americans were encouraged to take sides, added to the prejudice already high. This well researched story does not make light of the problems caused to the Cherokee, even those who were educated such as Sam Hicks. Susanna Moore is naïve about the tension of the times but hopeful of having some say in her future. Yet God can guide, provide, and protect as this story so clearly illustrates. Another great addition to this series that sheds light on a time period in US history that is not so well known.
August 26, 2026
The story involves the British with a group of Indians fighting the settlers with another tribe of Indians, all for land. Right in the middle is Suzanna whose father is a Colonel. He has promised her in marriage to a doctor, whom she does not love. She has fallen for Sam Hicks, a half Cherokee, half white. Her father obviously objects. Throughout the story she fights for her choice to no avail. There is action ongoing with fighting the war and kidnapping. Some scenes were a little graphic in their descriptions but I skimmed over them quickly. They were needed I guess to show authenticity of the war. There was a final battle told about with a surprising ending. I learned a little about history and this particular war.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher through Celebrate Lit but was not required to write a review.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher through Celebrate Lit but was not required to write a review.
August 18, 2026
Formerly published as Bent Tree Bride.
Susanna Moore and Sam Hicks meet unexpectedly when Susanna hides from a suitor in the library where Sam is waiting orders from Colonel Moore. They are instantly attracted to each other, but Susanna thinks that Sam is white and Sam believes that Susanna is Cherokee. They discover each other's origins and realize that it will be almost impossible for them to have a life together especially when Colonel Moore forbids the relationship. Will their faith in God bring them together or will outside forces keep them apart?
I loved how Susanna and Sam's relationship grew. I was worried when Susanna interrupted Spring Frog's assassination attempt, and he kidnapped her. I was glad when Colonel Moore was convinced to allow Susanna and Sam to marry.
Susanna Moore and Sam Hicks meet unexpectedly when Susanna hides from a suitor in the library where Sam is waiting orders from Colonel Moore. They are instantly attracted to each other, but Susanna thinks that Sam is white and Sam believes that Susanna is Cherokee. They discover each other's origins and realize that it will be almost impossible for them to have a life together especially when Colonel Moore forbids the relationship. Will their faith in God bring them together or will outside forces keep them apart?
I loved how Susanna and Sam's relationship grew. I was worried when Susanna interrupted Spring Frog's assassination attempt, and he kidnapped her. I was glad when Colonel Moore was convinced to allow Susanna and Sam to marry.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 24, 2026
𝐀 𝐂𝐨𝐧𝐭𝐫𝐚𝐫𝐲 𝐁𝐞𝐭𝐫𝐨𝐭𝐡𝐚𝐥 is a romantic story filled with forbidden love, danger, and faith. Even if you haven’t read the earlier books in the series, this one works nicely on its own.
Sam and Susanna are such interesting characters and feel far from typical. Their struggles are real and believable, and it’s easy to root for them the whole way through. With strong tension, high stakes, and an inspiring thread of faith, this is an enjoyable read. Though I’m not a huge fan of the cover, I’m completely drawn in by the first line.
First Line: The smell of books—leather and dusty pages mingling with the burnt ash of the morning fire—stirred Sam’s blood as war cries stirred some men.
#CoverLoverBookReview received a review copy of this book. Opinions are my own.
Sam and Susanna are such interesting characters and feel far from typical. Their struggles are real and believable, and it’s easy to root for them the whole way through. With strong tension, high stakes, and an inspiring thread of faith, this is an enjoyable read. Though I’m not a huge fan of the cover, I’m completely drawn in by the first line.
First Line: The smell of books—leather and dusty pages mingling with the burnt ash of the morning fire—stirred Sam’s blood as war cries stirred some men.
#CoverLoverBookReview received a review copy of this book. Opinions are my own.
August 31, 2026
No one and I mean no one can write historical fiction like Denise Farnsworth. Once again I am blown away with her writing. The book starts in 1813 on the Tennessee-Cherokee Nation border.
Susanna was the daughter of Captain Moore. Her father had the say to whom she was to wed. His pick- Dr. Hawkins. He was alright but Susanna didn't love him.
Sam Hicks was half-Indian. He met Susanna and was smitten. But he had no chance.
Battles were raging around them. Danger lurked at every corner. Sam and Susanna couldn't stop the passion between them. They couldn't even if they tried.
A romantic read. I loved it. I don't recommend this but how can you not melt when Sam and Susanna's blood was blended together after they were injured.
Susanna was the daughter of Captain Moore. Her father had the say to whom she was to wed. His pick- Dr. Hawkins. He was alright but Susanna didn't love him.
Sam Hicks was half-Indian. He met Susanna and was smitten. But he had no chance.
Battles were raging around them. Danger lurked at every corner. Sam and Susanna couldn't stop the passion between them. They couldn't even if they tried.
A romantic read. I loved it. I don't recommend this but how can you not melt when Sam and Susanna's blood was blended together after they were injured.
September 2, 2026
I didn't like this book as much as I did the others in the series, but it still was an interesting read. I really like the two main characters trusted in God as they faced the challenge of prejudice and different customs. This is a story about the war between the Red Stick Indians and the American and Cherokee nations. To be truthful I don't remember ever hearing about the Red Stick Indians but then I am 66 and may have forgotten. But this book is fiction based on actual events in history. I like that facts are told without a lot of gory details. If you haven't read any of the series this is the last book in this series and I encourage you to read them all. I received a complimentary copy from the author and Celebrate Lit and these opinions are my own.
September 5, 2026
This is the 6th book in the "Scouts of the Georgia Frontier" series, but they can be read as standalones. This book was previously published as "Bent Tree Bride". The book is well written and well researched historically. There are some hard things that happened in our countries past and Denise Farnsworth doesn't shy away from showing them in her books. There are good biblical truths woven in. I look forward to reading more books by Denise Farnsworth.
I got a free copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own and given voluntarily. No compensation was received for my review.
I got a free copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own and given voluntarily. No compensation was received for my review.
September 7, 2026
I thought this was a good story. I liked how Susanna was strong and knew her own mind. I liked how she did everything she could to be with Sam even when the odds were stacked against them. I liked how Sam d do the right thing even when it was hard. I liked how Susanna an Sam had shared values and beliefs and were able to connect through those beliefs. I also liked learning a little bit more about Georgia’s history.
I received a complimentary book from publishers, publicists, and or authors. A review was not required and all opinions and ideas expressed are my own.
I received a complimentary book from publishers, publicists, and or authors. A review was not required and all opinions and ideas expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This is a historical romance of sorts that is based on some real events.
It took me several chapters to get fully immersed in this book. But after getting further into the story I found it very enjoyable and interesting. I enjoyed watching both Susannah and Sam grow and trust God to make a path for their future.
It took me several chapters to get fully immersed in this book. But after getting further into the story I found it very enjoyable and interesting. I enjoyed watching both Susannah and Sam grow and trust God to make a path for their future.
August 19, 2026
I loved this story! It's loaded with romance, danger, and intrigue. I love reading stories set on the American frontier and stories that involve American Indians. I hurt and cheered for Sam and Susanna. I was also drawn by the fact that Sam is of mixed-race, Cherokee and White. Denise does an excellent job with the struggles that come with being caught between two worlds.
September 4, 2026
An excellent story. Set in a time of history that I’m not very knowledgeable about. My heart goes out to the Indians. This is a Christian historical story with some romance, but mostly history. I received a copy of this book and all opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews