I love comics.
I’ve never been quite as avid a reader as many of the really hardcore comic geeks, but I absolutely remember the comic strips I read when I was real young, as part of learning to read - i.e. Disney Adventures magazines, hand-me-downs from my parents, et cetera. As an adult, I like comics from both North America and Japan, though I’m slightly biased toward the latter. This here, though, is a non-superhero/fantasy/sci-fi example - rather, it’s a comic strip. I own all except two of the Calvin and Hobbes books, which came out after I completed my collection for the first time, but I didn’t see much point in buying them - it wasn’t anything I didn’t already have. Except in the case of the exhibition guide book, which I’m contemplating buying. I like all the books, but this one here is probably my favorite, so it’s the focus of today’s review.
The book’s main two highlights, for me, are the art and the commentaries. The art isn’t really anything new - it’s rather like a “best of” collection, but the strips feature color art, which is an enjoyable plus. Since Calvin and Hobbes has never gotten any adaptation whatsoever, it’s hard to imagine color images when looking at the strips in black and white, so the book makes it nice to see Watterson’s idea of how everything looks colored. And each strip includes a bit of commentary from Bill Watterson, some of which is particularly resonant with me as a reader. One rather amusing piece of commentary comes with the strip depicting Calvin flying his fighter jet and blasting his school, before cutting back to him begrudgingly dragging himself into class: "Some readers thought it was inexcusable to show a kid fantasizing about bombing his school off the face of the earth. Apparently some of my readers were never kids themselves."
Which reminds me of one reason I’m fond not only of this particular book, but of the series in general: that it’s being told from a kid’s perspective. Although my views on being a kid are aptly described by Watterson’s line “I’ve never understood people who remember childhood as an idyllic time,” it still is fun every now and then to read a story where the main character is a child, and the atmosphere is neither overly idealistic nor too pessimistic. In the case of Calvin and Hobbes, the author isn’t afraid to show the less positive aspects of being a kid - case in point, being a student (on his experiences in school, Watterson mentions that he did pretty well, but doesn’t remember it with much fondness), and grown-ups being in charge - while simultaneously not making it overly depressing. Apart from that, probably the main aspect I like of the story having a kid for the main character is the use of imagination.
Childhood is the point in life where people can think in all kinds of whimsical, fantastical ways, a creativity which I think too many people lose when they become adults. It’s always nice for me to see other author’s who’ve similarly held on to that creative way of thinking, and to see how they use it. In the title protagonist’s case, he imagines all kinds of fantasies, seeing his parents and teacher as aliens, and himself as a hero, to name a few examples. Some readers have posited a darker interpretation, that Calvin is suffering from schizophrenia or a related mental illness, and that these are manifestations of it - but I just see it as a kid being a kid. Another part of the story I like is that it’s never clarified if Hobbes is actually alive, or just Calvin’s imagination - that’s an interesting ambiguity.
Overall, I recommend the book for any Calvin and Hobbes fan, especially if you’re looking to keep your collection small. The book provides an opportunity to enjoy many of the series’ best strips while concurrently looking at some of the author’s in-depth writing, and makes for an interesting read.
Rating: 4.5 out of 5