The first fantasy saga where ASL is the magic system.
Mary Peterson has been Deaf her entire life — until that's ripped away from her.
When supernatural hearing is forced upon her, she discovers her silence was hiding more than she ever imagined. Now she can hear things no one else can: whispers in the earth, warnings from a woman trapped between worlds, and the approach of something ancient and hungry.
Three dogs appear — Jenna, Taffy, and Aleu. They're not ordinary animals. They know things. They're guiding her somewhere. And they're the only things standing between Mary and the shadows closing in.
Someone has been stealing her memories. Rewriting her past. Manipulating everything she thought was real.
The Dark Man is waiting. The woman in the mirror is screaming warnings Mary can't quite hear. And the dogs are leading her toward a truth that will change everything.
Some inheritances are worth dying for. Others are worth killing for.
Nicki Runge is a Deaf writer, actress, and filmmaker whose work puts ASL and Deaf culture at the center of the story rather than the margins.
She is the author of Songless War, a nine-book dark fantasy saga built on a premise no other fantasy series has used: American Sign Language as the magic system. The first book, The Shadows of Memory, follows Mary Peterson — Deaf her entire life until supernatural hearing is forced upon her — and releases September 1, 2026, the first day of Deaf Awareness Month.
She also writes for stage and screen. Her interactive whodunit Mystery in the Snow: The Frosted Clue was written for ImaginASL Performing Arts, and her short film script The Secret Room is a psychological thriller about a CODA child, a locked basement, and a language someone is trying to erase.
Nicki lives in Colorado, where she is at work on the remaining books in the Songless War series.
I received an Advanced Reader Copy in exchange for my honest review.
I enjoyed this one overall, especially the characters. They were vivid and distinct. One of the book's greatest strengths for me, though, was the way Deafness and the Deaf experience were woven into the story. The representation was accurate and deeply empowering. I especially appreciated that Deafness wasn't treated as simply a character trait or something for the character to overcome. Instead, the strength of Deafness and the beauty and power of sign language are integral to the story and the plot. At the same time, it remains accessible to readers who may have no familiarity with Deaf culture, sign language, or hearing loss. I thought this was handled exceptionally well, and it was one of the most meaningful aspects of the book for me. The writing style was a bit more difficult for me. The prose is certainly vivid, but at times it was a little too flowery for my taste. There were moments when nearly every sentence seemed to be competing with the one before it for the most adjectives, similes, or metaphors, and I occassionally found myself losing the thread of what was actually happening. The magic lore/history was another area where I struggled to keep up. It is obviously intricate, but there were times when I had trouble understanding how everything fit together. A few times I'd flip back several pages to see if I missed something, because it felt like there were connections I was expected to have made that weren't fully established on the page. Part of this is because it is a slow build story. Personally, I wish the stakes had been established a little sooner, so that I had been able to understand what I was supposed to be worried about or invested in earlier. I felt a sense of urgency early on, but understanding the WHY behind it sooner would have helped keep me more engaged. That said, things did start coming together more toward the end, and some of the questions I'd had throughout the book were answered. Since this is the first book in a planned nine-book series, I'm willing to give some of the remaining questions the benefit of the doubt. Hopefully the next books will fill in some of the gaps, clarify some of the confusing plot points, and show that some things that feel like plot holes right now are actually clever pieces of a much larger puzzle. One other thing that gave me pause was the artwork. There was quite a lot of it throughout the book, and it added a nice visual element (although it did lead to some confusion about characters' ages, because some looked quite a bit younger than the book later indicates that they are!), but I was surprised that I couldn't find it attributed to anyone, either in the acknowledgements or the copyright page. I couldn't find a signature of any kind in any of the images either. I believe that the author herself drew them, and I may have missed that explained somewhere, but I would have loved the artistry to be acknowledged and the artist behind it credited and celebrated! Despite my confusion in places, by the end of the book I was invested enough in the characters, the plot, and the world to continue. I'm definitely curious to see where the story goes, and to see how the next eight books shed some light on the questions this one left behind. I'll be sticking around for the next one!
✨🧏♀️📚Book Review📚🧏♀️✨ Born into silence, Mary Peterson's life changes forever when she is suddenly cursed with supernatural hearing. As she adapts to a sensory world she never knew, Mary makes a terrifying discovery: someone is stealing her memories and rewriting her past. Now, to uncover the truth, she must navigate a dangerous realm, face an ancient threat known as the Dark Man, and reach the legendary Garden of Lost Souls. Three unusual, highly intelligent dogs named Jenna, Taffy, and Aleu guide her through a treacherous supernatural landscape to uncover the truth and face an entity known as the Dark Man.
Tropes: 🧏♀️ ASL / Sign Language as Magic 🧏♀️ Disabled Protagonist / Empowered Weakness 🧏♀️ Morally Grey Guardian 🧏♀️ Found Family 🧏♀️ Hidden Identity & Lost Memories:
Genre: 🧏♀️Fantasy 🧏♀️Dark Fantasy 🧏♀️Contemporary Fantasy 🧏♀️Urban Fantasy
Rate: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I gave this 5 stars because I love magical and supernatural stories, cute characters, and the contrast between the dark man and the three unusual dogs. Mary, the main character, is a Deaf girl. I would love to read more of her story in the future! The Deaf author, Nicki, will be writing 8 more books in the series. I'm so excited and really looking forward to them! As a Deaf reader, I usually don't like the fantasy genre, but this book completely caught my attention and I loved it.
Thank you for allowing me to read your ARC of Songless War. I really enjoyed reading your first book, even though it's not about dragons!
It is a fascinating story, and I love that almost all the characters use sign language. This provides wonderful representation for the Deaf community. I particularly liked how the three guardian animals protect Mary, and how characters like her parents, Nico, her grandmother, and the Dark Man play such important roles in her journey. The way you describe Mary uncovering her identity through her memories is wonderful.
I did experience a moment of confusion at the beginning regarding Mary's age. I initially assumed she was a young teenager, so learning about her "silence of 28 years" took me a moment to process before realizing she is an adult. Additionally, as a Deaf reader, I found some of the long descriptions a bit difficult to follow. I would encourage you to consider incorporating simpler scenes to make the text more accessible for Deaf readers.
I love how strongly connected Mary is to her garden, and the plot involving her bloodline, the Dark Man, and the mystery surrounding her hidden sister is very compelling. I am so curious about the second part or your future books and cannot wait to see whether Mary chooses to uncover her past or let it go to move toward the future.
Hello from your favorite Deaf sensitivity reader! I received a free advance copy in exchange for my honest review. I am so excited to have been chosen for the arc team! I’ve been waiting (not patiently) for this book. Let me tell you, this is just the book I needed to get out of my reading slump. What’s better than a Deaf main character and magic? A magic system based on ASL. So let’s get into this. Spoilers ahead. Mary is a Deaf character who later gets supernatural hearing. While I was a bit disappointed in the supernatural hearing ability, I just know the author will not let us (the Deaf community) down. The author has mentioned more books to this series. I am excited to find out what comes from this, and how Mary finds her Deafhood again. If you love Deaf people (as you should?) and magic this book is definitely for you. Mary has the coolest plant magic any plant lover will be jealous of. Let’s not forget the magic system based on ASL! The author does a wonderful job playing that into the story, while weaving in time and space. During Mary’s trip down memory lane, trying to remember what is real and what is fabricated. We meet some lovely characters on her journey. I am so excited to see this author grow, and to see where she leads us in her story. P.s. yes I have a crush on the Dark man. No I do not feel guilty about it, and no I will not Apologize. -Blair
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Overall, I enjoyed this book and found the story very interesting. The author has a very descriptive writing style, especially when describing the surroundings, emotions, and experiences of the main character. There were several moments where I could really picture what Mary was seeing and feeling.
However, I did find the story a little difficult to follow at times. It felt like Mary was constantly moving from one place or experience to another, and sometimes I had trouble keeping track of where she was and what was happening. I also personally wished there had been a little more dialogue between the characters. Much of the book is focused on description and Mary's internal experiences, so at times it felt very dense for me as a reader.
That being said, I still enjoyed the story and wanted to keep reading to find out what happened. I especially liked the mysterious and magical elements and the way Mary's past, family, and inheritance were woven into her journey.
If you enjoy books with very descriptive, atmospheric writing and a story that focuses heavily on the main character's experiences and emotions, you may really enjoy this one.
I really enjoyed this book! I was lucky enough to get an ARC (advanced reader copy) ahead of publication date in return for an honest review. I read a LOT of books. Mostly fiction. And I LOVE a good story. This one got better and better the further I read! There are some particularly lovely sentences that I highlighted to save and read over and over again (see page 263 - absolutely gorgeous phrasing). The main character, Mary, is likeable and easy to root for. Her growth throughout the story is enjoyable to witness. I loved the inclusion of sign language and notes about Deaf culture. As someone who uses ASL myself, I found it delightful to visualize what the handshapes and movements described would look like in real life as I read. I had a hard time putting this one down as I NEEDED to know what happened next! Something that I particularly appreciated was the depth of the story with multiple vivid locations and unpredictable plot - I couldn't easily guess what would happen next and that was refreshing! The chapter artwork is also very pretty. I'm definitely going to re-read this while I wait for the next book in the series because I keep thinking about different moments in the story. Well done, Nicki! Thank you for sharing your work with the world!
I’ll be brutally honest: I had to create an account for this review. I heard some stuff about this book, so I picked it up to check it out for myself and see what it was like. I really wanted to like the book, especially with it being by a deaf author, having a storyline based around deafness, etc.
I hate to say this but… I just couldn’t enjoy it. Like… at all. It’s incredibly monotonous, repetitive, weird, and overly explanatory.
So much of it doesn’t make sense, or is confusing, or is just maddening and frustrating to read. I found myself wondering “when will this chapter end??”
I couldn’t finish it.
What’s worse… it screams “AI” to me. I often use AI for work and personal use, and it has all hallmarks of AI. Not only that, but when I asked multiple AI’s to “study” it and give me an estimate of its likelihood of being written by AI, they all independently came up with the conclusion that it is extremely likely to be AI.
I’m genuinely surprised to see all the positive reviews, and I don’t mean to be a jerk, but it really is just… not good.
Nicki Runge has summoned up the mysteries of a deep and magical journey. Treading between two worlds and further, this delightful young woman embodies the courage of the Fearless Girl Statue, facing the raging bull, in front of the New York Stock Exchange. Personal and compelling, this work is entrenched in a story that is relatable to everyone. I have been a sign language interpreter for 45 years, working with Deaf students, professionals and the entire Deaf community, and never read such an accurate and facinating parallel of wonder, power, and self-efficacy found in this amazing story. With articulate and descriptive narrative, this topic is an unprecedented mix of intrigue, discovery, and self-awareness. Songless War, Book 1, is a treasure. Can’t wait to find out the rest of the feathers to come.
Thank you to the author for allowing me to read an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
I don’t typically read fantasy, but I love supporting Deaf authors. Plus, I was thrilled to read a fantasy with Deaf representation and with ASL as the magic system.
If you’re looking for an interesting fantasy with an enjoyable storyline, great imagery, and unique concepts, look no further! A few scenes even pulled at my heartstrings and brought tears to my eyes.
I will admit there were some confusing parts, but I am assuming they will be further explained as the series continues. I also felt like Mary was younger (more like 18) than 31 years old. The writing style and the pictures made the story feel more YA in my opinion.
Overall, I enjoyed this book and I definitely look forward to reading the rest of the series!
I received free advance copy in exchange for my honest review.
This book is awesome with great opportunity for a deaf lead character, Mary, to shine throughout the book/book series. This character has wonderful supporting cast, both deaf and hearing.
This book is very descriptive which as a deaf person myself, is a perfect example of deaf culture as we love to describe things very visually however when I read, I got lost in multiple descriptive words.
I feel like this first book is like a prequel for things to come so I’m looking forward to read the unfinished business in the rest of the series and understand the connections of why things happened in book number one, Songless War:The Shadows of Memory.
I’m not usually a fan of dark fantasy, and I originally chose The Shadows of Memory because I wanted to support a Deaf author. I’m so glad I gave it a chance. I was truly amazed by how beautifully Nicki Runge wrote the story in English and incorporated ASL and Deaf culture into the book.
Her detailed writing helped me clearly picture the characters, setting, and events as I read. The mysterious atmosphere, shifting memories, strange shadows, and full of suspense. What stood out most to me was how Deaf identity and ASL are woven into the heart of the story.
Nicki has created a unique and meaningful fantasy that kept me engaged, even though dark fantasy isn’t usually my genre. I look forward to reading the next book!
I was given an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
What a debut of a novel! I’m not much of a fantasy reader because world building can be a challenge, so setting this mostly in the real world helped me see the picture. It was refreshing to have a story with a Deaf lead along with a cast of dynamic characters. I really enjoyed this and am already looking forward to the next book in the series! I think parts where I was confused are related to lore, so I’m hoping we get to see more of that in the coming books. It’s such an interesting concept, and I am ready for the lore!
I am currently reading the an eARC (Electronic Advanced Reader Copy) from the author. At this publication date, I have not finished the book (yet).
Honestly, very nicely written book. Engaging and insightful. Good balance of including Deaf characters/Deaf Culture and sign language in YA (Young Adult)/Fantasy genre.
I am looking forward to purchasing a hard copy of the book and then finishing it. It will be fun to see how the series progresses through the next 8 books after this one.