I haven't read All Quiet on the Western Front but others have suggested that this was basically the Japanese fantasy version of that. Here we have the story of a young woman volunteering as a soldier to help support the orphanage she was raised in. As a result of that decision she underwent the horror of trench warfare and how greedily it consumed people and left the soil dark with all the iron in their blood.
The characters' development here were fantastic. There were people you hated at the beginning but as the story progressed in the next books, you came to understand their actions more and why they behaved as such. I loved the camaraderie between the soldiers, the brutal realities that they had to face daily and the little things they did to make living just a bit more bearable.
But that also made the tragedies all the more painful to read. People died in war, easily, uselessly and carelessly so. That was a fact that I had to swallow again and again and it never got any better. The author made me care about them that it hurt when they inevitably died like the fate of so many soldiers in war.
It is not often that the isekai MC ends up in a terrible situation and it doesn't look temporary either. She is a young untrained medic at the active front in a low-fantasy trench war struggling to survive in a very harsh environment that gives the reader the feeling that survival is as much a matter of skill as luck. The setup is also intriguing with an amateur historian digging up a diary which is what we read with a few moments in said historians point of view to add a bit of context to the events. Not sure it was necessary, since it feels a bit odd in that there are definitely sections that don't read as a diary and more as a first person story. Overall a solid read, although a rather dark one at that.
What an amazing plot and storyline. The story progression was incredibly captivating, and honestly, I didn’t expect this book to be this good.
I picked it up completely at random, expecting nothing more than a light, easy read—a generic isekai with a simple plot that I could breeze through.
I was so wrong.
The story turned out to be much more compelling and emotionally impactful than I expected. Definitely one of those books that surprises you in the best possible way.