After rocketing to pop stardom practically overnight, all Marceline wants is a calm holiday at home. What she gets is a run-in with her bad-boy high-school crush, Lucas. Could this Ghost of Christmas Past also become her new muse?
When Marceline Freeze went to Juilliard to study violin, she didn’t expect it to lead to a Best New Artist Grammy. Now, after a whirlwind tour and early-onset fame fatigue, she’s looking forward to a normal Christmas in her snowy North Carolina hometown. But all bets are off the second she walks into My Place, the coffee shop that was her refuge growing up. It’s gotten an infuriating Scandi-chic makeover courtesy of its new Lucas North, the rebellious firestarter she worshipped from afar as a teenager.
Cute cute cute cute!! This book was so stinking cute!! It’s like the perfect vibe for snuggling up under a fluffy blanket with some cocoa with a fire going!!
The romance is very sweet! It had a fun Hallmark holiday vibe. I also loved the family dynamic. Marceline’s sister being a little jealous of her success was interesting to see. I also loved how she had to navigate being a famous person coming back to her little town.
Overall, I highly recommend this! It’s so cute and cozy and I will definitely be reading again once it’s closer to the holidays!!
Read if you like: Small town romance Famous Person x Normal Person Hallmark vibes Holiday romance Banter
Thank you so much to NetGalley and 831 Stories for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!!
✨ Thank you to NetGalley and 831 Stories for the ARC of First Famous Christmas! ✨
First Famous Christmas is deeply reminiscent of a classic Hallmark Christmas movie - a perfectly serviceable and cozy companion to a warm mug of hot cocoa on the couch on a snowy December day. This story had excellent setting and vibes - the return of a newly-famous musician to her small town right before the holidays, complete with complex family dynamics, rediscovering her love of the craft at a time when she's doubting her skill the most, and rekindling her flirtation with the now grown town bad boy.
There's a certain nostalgia and humbleness of this novella that made it a perfectly atmospheric read for the holiday season, but I wanted a bit more from it, particularly in the build-up and tension between the main characters before the romance begins in earnest. Similarly, the conflict arrives abruptly and is resolved all too quickly for my liking, but that seems to be the nature of these condensed stories. With more pages, I think Wittmer would have been able to provide more of the depth I am typically looking for in a romance.
Despite these flaws, the characters feel genuine, well developed, and rather unique. It's easy to get a sense of who they are and to understand their motivations in a short amount of time, which is an impressive feat given the limited page count here. I enjoyed the dynamics of the Freeze family potentially more than the romance in this story (I'm not sure what that says about me!) and appreciated that there was more to the FMC's life in her town than just the man. Bonus points for hating on the town millionaires, Wittmer definitely made them feel insufferable but realistically characterized and I had a great time rooting against them the whole time. There were moments that were a bit far fetched but if you're able to suspend disbelief (in much the same vein as a Hallmark movie) and just go with the vibes, you will likely enjoy it.
I love picking up the 831 Stories novellas. I think of them like a warm chocolate chip cookie - a nice palette cleanser between longer or heavier novels. First Famous Christmas is no exception and it would be a lovely addition to a holiday reading list if you want a short, enjoyable story that gets you in the Christmas spirit.
i can't put my finger on why exactly this didn't work for me, but i know the biggest issue is the tone. another reviewer called it sardonic and i have to agree.
i expected a cosy, feel-good home for the holidays story with a dash of pop star in love with the boy next door - only to feel like i was being made fun of on every page, reading a parody of what the author thought silly romance readers like. it truly felt like an snl skit, just getting more ridiculous. the story is undeveloped, the characters have no voice or personality, the pacing is abysmal and the narrative threads lead nowhere.
idk how you mess up a very straightforward hallmark movie. alas here we are.
thank you to netgalley and the publisher for the arc.
A novella so good I forgot I was supposed to be making dinner!
I loved every bit of Carrie Wittmer’s debut romance! Was it cheesy? Yes, did it give millennial vibes which I loved? YES! Did it feel out of sorts sometimes and hard to follow? Yes BUT it also brought me to a magical small town…not unlike my own, full of Christmas traditions and silly characters. I think had this been a regular length novel, all the pieces would have fallen together a little better but when it’s a novella, what can you do!? With that being said…I could have used at least 100 more pages. This was my first toe dip into the Christmas season of books and it was perfect.
My First Famous Christmas follows Marceline (love the name) through some newly found fame that she didn’t really want or care about but she loves her music. She comes home to have a normal Christmas….quickly finding that normal and celebrity don’t really mix. She reunites with Lucas, her high school crush and we are brought on a journey of A LOT of tension and fun as they get to know one another in a different decade.
I loved it! I loved the pop culture references, I loved the love story, I loved the family dynamics and Marceline figuring herself out again. It was hard to follow at times and all but the love story felt rushed…I really think this could have been a full novel and I would have loved it even more!
Thank you NetGalley & 831 Stories for the ARC in exchange for my honest review! What a treat!
Thank you Net Galley and 831 Stories for access to this ARC!
Unfortunately, this did not hit for me and I found it to be generically surface level and all over the place. The overall narrative is interesting - I love a home for the holidays story - but it does not quite get there for me. There were too many threads here that are not fully developed and feel confined in this novella. The dialogue was funny at times but felt stilted and at war with the tone here. It wanted to be both serious about fame and also a silly holiday story with a bizarre family and small town gone corporate. I don’t know but I wanted to love this - I loved the 2010s indie music mentioned, but found the original songs within to be cringe. This would probably work better if fully developed into a novel with more space to explore this town and world. But here it just did not work for me - devastating!
I really hate that this advanced reader copy of “First Famous Stories” is my first impression of 831 Stories, a catalogue of romance novellas that have won over the contemporary book scene in recent years. Yet, here I am.
Was this a quick, mindless read? Absolutely! In fact, this holiday romcom had all of the makings of a great Hallmark movie: a charming Southern town, a great cast of quirky local characters, a successful out-of-towner, a coffee shop owner, a burgeoning romance, and a low-risk mystery. The only things missing? Any sense of plot or character development!
Most of the time, these predictable stories keep us hooked because of some sort of catalyzing plot factor. A chef is opening a new location of his Michelin-guide restaurant in 90 days. The librarian is throwing a 24-hour-readathon at the end of summer. The Christmas parade is in three days, and the coordinator dropped out. Each of these scenarios, however corny, have some semblance of urgency. Yet, nothing of the sort existed here, in the world of Marceline, Lucas, and Hope Gap, NC. I aimlessly wandered the days leading up to Christmas, hoping something, anything would happen to “hook” me. It wasn’t the plot, and it also wasn’t the characters, who I feel I barely got to know over the couple hundred pages. How many times, and in how many ways, can one say “Lucas smells like cigarettes, coffee, flour, and sex”? And how much cringier could those music scenes get?
All in all, I’m disappointed by this one. Maybe this was the wrong 831 romance to start with, and maybe the ARC will be edited to perfection for its wide release. I’m hoping I can give the series another chance.
After quickly rising to fame and a Best New Artist Grammy, classical musician Marceline is feeling burned out and blocked. So, she heads home to small town North Carolina to spend Christmas with her family, where she quickly realizes that not only have she and her family members changed, but her small town has become a destination and a lot less small than she remembers. On top of everything, the boy who heavily influenced that successful album and she never quite forgot years ago has also returned, and it seems everyone is hiding something. What better time for them to all come out than Christmas?
I picked this as my first holiday read of 2026, and really wanted to love it... Unfortunately, it was just okay. I love a famous person/normal person trope, especially with a shared history/second chance romance, but this felt very much like a Hallmark movie, and not in the way I usually like. It just felt flat and so slow, and just did not pull me in the way these novellas normally do. It had all the pieces, takes place during the holidays, and there are fun holiday traditions and vibes, and a messy family and past, but I just didn't find myself caring for the characters all that much... And despite having all the right pieces, it just didn't FEEL like a holiday romance to me. Perhaps I have just been so spoiled with the other 831 Stories books, and just set my expectations too high, or maybe a wrong book wrong time situation? I think if you readers are looking for a read that is quick, easy, and light, that might slowly ease you into the holiday season, it's not a bad choice, but wouldn't be my top recommendation. I am so bummed to have not loved this one, but I am hopeful it will find it's audience.
Thank you to NetGalley, 831 Stories Romance, and author Carrie Wittmer, for the eARC of First Famous Christmas!
ARC review, Thank you NetGalley and 831 stories for this.
I really enjoyed it. One thing I look forward to during Holiday season is Hallmark movies and this book gives you that vibe. Like you just picture the small-town setting and put the characters in the book in there and you've got yourself a Hallmark movie!
A new famous musician returns to her hometown just wanting a normal Christmas(non-famous). There are complex family issues...a jealous sister, a proud mom and a rekindling a flirtation with the towns "bad boy". I do feel like I wanted more of the relationship aspect of things, both with the jealous sister and the romance. It kind of felt like they were abrupt beginning and resolve...I wanted more story in between. this, I do realize this is a novella and if too much is put in, it wouldn't be that.
I do feel like the relationships and characters felt genuine and well developed. The story is well done, where you feel the nostalgia, and you get an idea of who the characters really are. Again, I say it's very Hallmark like, which I like, but it does make it very predictable. But to me, that is ok! I definitely enjoyed the book and look forward to more. I may even want to sit and re-read as Christmas gets closer.
Thank you, 831 Stories and NetGalley, for another amazing eARC! I absolutely swooned for this story!!!! I thought 831 Stories couldn't get any better, but this holiday moment is now in the top 5! I loved the banter and chemistry between these two! It all felt so natural and so realistic and believable to see these two make it forever. Although I am not a famous singer, I did relate SO hard to Marceline and her relationship with her hometown. The amount of highlights throughout the books is so wild in the best way! I obviously was giggling and kicking my feet over the romance, but also found myself laughing out loud at some of the very relatable one-liners from Marceline! I loved seeing how Lucas supported her and allowed her to be her true self throughout their time together! I cannot recommend this enough for any of the Nov 1st girlies looking for a quick but fulfilling holiday romance!
Firstly, thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an early copy. I think this story was really cute. I love a like fake celebrity story with a romance plot, but with this one I don’t think I was as connected to the characters. I do think it read really quickly and was just super easy; I just don’t think I cared for the characters as much as I wanted to. I do think that this can be a really good palate cleanser in between books because it was still enjoyable to see what happened. I did guess the twist a little early on, but I rarely think I’m right, so it still caught me off guard. Overall, I did enjoy this book and do recommend it. Thank you again to the publisher and NetGalley for the early copy.
I was really excited about the premise of this one, but unfortunately, it fell a little flat for me.
I found myself feeling like I was bouncing around from one paragraph to the next, and at times it was a bit overwhelming to keep up with everything happening. The overall storyline was there, and I could see what the book was going for, but I think I would have enjoyed it more if it had been given the space of a full-length novel.
I wanted a little more room for the story and its characters to develop rather than feeling like everything was happening so quickly.
Thank you to 831 Stories for the uncorrected proof. All opinions are my own.
I loved First Famous Christmas! I am not famous, but I live far away from my hometown and there is something so nostalgic about going back home for Christmas. The familiarity of everything is so lovely and just brings back so many memories for me in the same way that it did for Marceline. Her relationship with Lucas was so real and fun as well. I loved how she started using her fame for things for herself (date to the Biltmore, etc). The reveal of the decor from "My Place" being in Lucas' apartment was also sweet. I would recommend this as a feel good holiday romance with the perfect amount of sibling drama for anyone looking to get into the holiday spirit!
As the first Christmas book I read for the holiday season, I was very excited! It sounded like the perfect start for a holiday romance. It ended up being not what I anticipated. I did not enjoy the writing. There were way too many modern day references, and it overshadowed the plot. It was not as cozy as I wanted it to be. I could not care for the relationship at all.
Thank you NetGalley & 831 Stories for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
north carolina, c’mon and raise up! as a carolina girl who has a special place in her heart for western nc, i ate this right up.
the storyline felt very much like a hallmark movie, but where the main characters are actually cool and have excellent taste in music. marceline—once small town girl, now world-famous musician—yearns for simpler times and heads back to her small home town for the holidays. almost immediately, she runs into resident bad boy (literally a convicted arsonist) and her childhood crush, lucas north. it’s a classic story, but with its own unique spin. shout out indie sleaze!
thank you to carrie wittmer, 831 stories and netgalley for this e-arc 🤍
Ok this was a very cute holiday romance. It gave all the winter / Christmas vibes and very spicy! Marceline is back home and runs into the hometown bad boy whom she’s always had a crush on. Marceline wants to enjoy her small hometown after becoming a famous violinist. She seems to have lost her spark and with the help of Lucas finds her home. Really cute holiday novela, would recommend to anyone who was a fast holiday read.
Thank you 831 Stories and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.
I really did not want First Famous Christmas by Carrie Wittmer to end. I really enjoyed how the romance was set up with the young crush turned to finding one another later in life. A great Christmastime romance that I’ll have to read again for the holidays! Thank you to NetGalley and 831 Stories for the ARC!
First famous Christmas is definitely a netflix/hallmark Christmas movie book. It was good for some parts but othere elements of the storyline were lacking/missing for me.
Thank you to Netgalley and 831 stories for the advanced copy.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This started out slow for me but got better as it went on.
Marcelina is a child prodigy violinist who grows up to be a pop star, and I don’t really know what her violin playing added to the plot. I liked the uniqueness of it, but I don’t think it necessarily contributed much to the story.
I would have loved to have some chapters from Lucas’s POV mixed in. We learn at the end that he was always in love with her, but I think it would have enriched the story to see some of that earlier on.
I actually LOVED the third-act breakup in this—I GASPED. I just wish the book had been a little longer so the resolution afterward could have been fleshed out more. I felt like she was too quick to forgive him.
But overall, this was a fun, cute read!
ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
The plot seemed promising but something wasn't connecting with the characters for me. It felt unemotional, just performative action based emotions. I did like that the the FMC is a famous musician with a classical instrument. Overall, it just needs more connection for me.
*Provided an advance copy from the publisher for review. All opinions are my own.
First Famous Christmas was not for me. I didn’t understand many of the references, and the characters and their relationships never felt believable. There is a child who receives TMZ push notifications and constantly asks strangely adult questions, while the entire family acts awkwardly around her—even though she is supposedly extremely close to her mother.
The relationship between the sisters was equally confusing. We are told that Marceline’s sister always wants to be the center of attention and that they aren’t close, but most of the tension seemed to come from Marceline rather than anything her sister actually did. The idea that one family essentially owns the entire town was also poorly explained. There was simply too much happening for such a short story, and none of it had enough time to develop.
By the 80% mark, Marceline no longer came across as someone understandably overwhelmed by sudden fame. Instead, she seemed paranoid, self-absorbed, and surprisingly entitled. She repeatedly insists that she wants everyone to treat her normally, yet she views ordinary situations through the lens of her glamorous new life and assumes that every awkward interaction must be about her. That contradiction could have created an interesting exploration of how fame changes a person, but it wasn’t developed enough. The supporting characters were similarly one-dimensional, especially her father, whose entire personality seemed to consist of asking trivia questions.
The ending was particularly frustrating because the main conflict felt rushed and poorly handled. Marceline makes an impulsive decision based on very little information, without taking the time to ask questions or understand the full situation. Because the family dynamics, romance, and other subplots were already underdeveloped, the final conflict didn’t feel earned—it seemed manufactured to create a dramatic climax. There were simply too many ideas competing for space in such a short book, and none were explored deeply enough to make the ending satisfying.
Perfect for Hallmark and Gilmore Girls fans, "First Famous Christmas" follows Grammy winner Marceline Freeze, a Juilliard trained violinist and singer whose fame has through the roof. Marceline is grappling with living her life in the headlines and under pressure to produce her next album. When she heads home to Hope Gap, North Carolina for her annual "Freeze Family Christmas," she is instantly thrust into the spotlight, despite trying to remain humble for her family.
Despite her wishes for a normal Christmas in the Hallmark-esque town, it's anything but. From her mom closing the grocery store for her to shop, tabloids and paparazzi catching her off guard, to stopping into her favorite coffee shop "My Place" and finding that it's completely change. How can Marceline have a normal Christmas, when everything has changed.
As Marceline deals with how fame changes her, the story unfolds through memories of the past. As she tries to spend normal family time together, she finds herself drawn to a ghost from her past: Luca, the new owner of My Place. The former bad boy who burned down a building, Luca is someone Marceline always admired from afar. As she and Luca spend time together in My Place, Marceline has to reckon with the fallout of fame, burnout and what the holidays are truly all about.
Thank you to 831 stories & NetGalley for an ARC for my work column. A version of this review will be published in my Shopping Bag Book Column for The Wave, a publication of the Cape May Star & Wave Newspaper.
I have read every novella from 831 stories and I love the concept, but can admit that not every single story lands for me, First Famous Christmas being one. I felt that there were a few gaps in the reader knowledge (why is the family so adamant about a going by their last name, why is Kirby a lurking baby daddy and talked about in a peculiar way and I felt the main romance was missing a stronger connection/chemistry. I needed more from the sister relationship (perhaps less on Kirby). I really wanted to love this Hallmark-y Christmas story but it just did not hit the mark for me. If you like Christmas romances, give this one a chance!
A Hallmark Christmas movie, but make it spicy and indie. With an excessive amount of holiday-related similes and metaphors.
This was alright. Hope Gap is a cute town that goes all out for the holidays and goes a bit nuts when their favorite daughter comes home from Hollywood. She unofficially goes to work in her old hangout, the coffee shop that's been taken over by her teenage crush. There's ongoing beef with the richest family in town and it continues in earnest at Christmas.
I found Marceline and Lucas's romance to be a bit hard to believe ... they grew up in the same small town but were virtual strangers who longed for each other secretly. Unlikely, but so much of a good romance novel is just that. I was very confused as to how old they were supposed to be, when this story was supposed to be set aside from pop culture references. They seemed both Gen Z and millennial. Weird.
Lucas definitely fits the indie sleaze greaser vibe if that's what the author was going for. Not sure why Marceline was hot and bothered over him owning only one pair of pants and I could only hope that he washed them frequently. His family situation and a believable story behind why he supposedly committed arson were bothering me throughout. He's the brooding bad boy, I guess we just go with that.
I haven't really even talked about Marceline. She was fine, I couldn't really figure out whether I liked her or not. She kinda gets lost in all of her fame complications and helping her family prepare for Christmas. She seems like a bit of an indie darling prototype, which is cute I suppose. I do like a story that caters more to us hipster weirdoes.
A lot happens in this book for only 211 pages, the more I think about it. I was just never completely sold on the idea of Marceline and Lucas. And the third-act breakup ... well that was just rude.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an early review copy.
It begins on Christmas Eve, with Marceline rushing home after a performance at the local theatre. Her family’s annual Christmas party is underway, and her crush, Lucas, will be there. But when Lucas is arrested and the party is interrupted, Marceline is devastated. The next morning, she finds a gift from Lucas outside her bedroom door: four vinyl records and a gift card that reads, “Lucas North Starter Pack.” This gift will change the course of Marceline’s future.
In the present, Marceline is exhausted after releasing two successful albums and completing a world tour. She’s struggling with the cost of fame. She hates being watched and judged, and hopes that spending Christmas in her small hometown of Hope Gap will offer the respite she desperately needs. But as soon as she arrives, she realizes it won’t. She can't leave her parents' house without people staring and filming, and even her family doesn’t know how to act around her. Then there’s Lucas, her teenage crush. They haven’t spoken since she left town years ago, but Marceline has never forgotten him. Could this Christmas in Hope Gap finally bring them together?
First Famous Christmas feels like a Hallmark Christmas movie with a little Gilmore Girls mixed in. I enjoyed the story at first, but it became disjointed over time. Some subplots, including one about an evil mayor who seemed much older than his stated age, and the tabloid stories, didn’t feel like they added much to the story. I also felt that Marceline and Lucas’s relationship developed very quickly. I did enjoy Marceline’s family dynamic, especially her relationship with her sister, Eloise. All in all, it was still a fun, quick holiday read.
eARC thanks to 831 stories and netgalley in exchange for an honest review
This had a Hallmark Christmas Movie vibe, with a bit more spice. It follows a successful musician who returns to the small town she grew up in for the holidays and reunites with her crush.
This was a nice, cosy holiday read, though it did feel a little rushed toward the end, even for a novella. Some parts could have been trimmed, like the villains, who felt unnecessary given how little they were involved. Trimming those elements could have left more time to wrap up the story without it feeling rushed.
There was plenty to like about the story; Marceline's family was super delightful and really added to the story's charm. I now want to go to one of their Christmas Eve parties! I really enjoyed the parts focusing on Marceline navigating fame, her relationships with her family and her hometown, and how she actually wants to live her life.
There were a lot of pop culture references and high-end brand name drops, which got a bit tiring after a while. The music references were justified by their importance to the story and Marceline's journey. At the start, I also felt like I was being thrown names and places at me very quickly without much context, and I struggled to keep up with who was who. Being unfamiliar with some places and shops, as I am not from the US, probably didn’t help, but once it settled, it was fine, and I understood who everyone was.
It wasn’t an overly in-your-face Christmas story either, which was nice. It’s set during the festive season and features a few holiday events, but Christmas itself isn't the entire plot.
Marceline Freeze is heading back to her North Carolina small town hometown for Christmas for the first time since hit the top of charts with her breakout violin/pop album. She just wants everything to be normal for a few weeks, sick of everyone watching her and more importantly, wondering where her next album is. Reconnecting with Lucas North, her high school crush, in her favorite/only hometown coffee shop is just a bonus, right?
This one started off promising with a great flashback from 10 years ago, but then it just kinda petered out. Marceline is SO determined to have “normal” Christmas with her family, even though nothing about her or her family is “normal.” She never really makes an effort with them, just kinda flitting back and forth between her childhood home and My Place, the coffee shop, always happy when her family is doing something “regular” but not participating. Plus she’s mad that My Place is different since Nash died, but since we don’t ever get a good handle on why Nash was so important to her, it just felt like whining.
The third act break up/reveal/make up went way too quickly and felt unearned. Marceline’s relationship with her music could have been explored more and I was more worried that she was about taking her violin around to all these cold places. Stacey deserves better!