Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Last Temptation of Beck: The Untold Story of a Pop Messiah

Rate this book
From the author of the New York Times bestseller Ringmaster and the Hugo finalist True Believer, a propulsive and stylish account of Beck, who was received as a pop messiah in the 1990s, but whose closest friends and most devoted fans never knew his buried secrets.

Once upon a time, there was a man who made himself into a myth.

He went by a single Beck. He sang songs that didn’t make easy sense in plain English, but which were somehow undeniable to those who heard them. He mined a dizzying array of musical styles from the past to construct albums that were eminently of the zeitgeist. Before and after the smash success of his 1993 single “Loser,” he was the hardest-working slacker in America. He went platinum multiple times over. And for a time, he was regarded by journalists and devoted fans alike as the “pop messiah”—a title that referred not just to the new energy he brought to the radio and MTV, but to the devotion he inspired.

But something happened to Beck Hansen, right at the dawn of this century. His music, once defiant and bombastic, turned morose and inward facing. Beck destroyed the online forum where his devoted fans had gathered. He cut ties with the small collective of LA-based bohemians he’d come up alongside, surrounding himself instead with sycophants and celebrities. Beck had been born and raised in the Church of Scientology; many in his orbit feared he’d been pulled back to the faith.

Beck’s music has continued to win accolades, including multiple Grammys. But the true story of Beck in the nineties and beyond has never been told.

With sensitivity and an arrestingly original style, New York Times bestselling author Josephine Riesman offers a vivid and multifaceted look at a singular artist and the generation for whom he became a reluctant spokesman. Drawing from interviews with those who’ve been closest to Beck, as well as troves of never-before-published documents, Riesman offers a story about authenticity and irony, paranoia and belief. Situated at the last gasp of the millennium, it’s more than a simple biography—it’s a riveting drama about the blurry lines between fandom and worship; between myth and lies; and between the old world that is dying and the new one that still struggles to be born.

336 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 6, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Josephine Riesman

1 book8 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
18 (14%)
4 stars
41 (33%)
3 stars
32 (26%)
2 stars
21 (17%)
1 star
10 (8%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
Profile Image for Kasia.
300 reviews47 followers
October 7, 2026
**ARC of this book provided by publisher in exchange for an honest review**

Sometimes I allow myself to enter the giveaway of the book only based on the cover and the title because it usually leads me to places that I would normally not consider visiting. Sometimes I hate where I'm at and sometimes I have this huh moment that shows me that there is enjoyment outside of my comfort zone. The Last Temptation of Beck is a book that I would not pick up if I saw it in the library or the bookstore but I'm nevertheless happy that I've read. It tells the story of a pop star Beck (that I have no interest in whatsoever) told in a format that I usually don't appreciate (a sort of conversational non-fiction - I prefer my non-fiction to be on the "drier" side).

Here is the kicker - The Last Temptation of Beck drips with enthusiasm and excitement and I just could not resist it - I'm a sucker for passionate people that are great storytellers. The whole controversy of Beck, the affiliation with mysterious Scientology Church and double suicide that is tied to his persona creates an opening that pulled me right in and kept me on the edge of my seat. I was so invested that I turned the blind eye on the moments when author started rambling about fascism or drawing conclusions that were way too far-fetched. Unfortunately with the progress of the pages my interest started waning to finally discovered that explosive beginning does not match a rather tepid ending.

It was a great read that helped me step out of the comfort zone, discover some new music and fresh topics that I will probably explore deeper in the future. But it lacked a journalistic rigor that I usually expect from this kind of publications. Its a good book for anyone - not just the Beck fans.
Profile Image for Amy.
31 reviews4 followers
October 8, 2026
The one star is for the potentially excellent book that Riesman could have written about her own story, which she gives short shrift at the end here. But this book purports to be about Beck, so the review must be predominantly about that.

One of my earliest childhood memories, from age 4, is of seeing news coverage about Jonestown. I’ve been fascinated by the toxic pull of cults my entire life, since long before I discovered Beck in college and became an ardent lifelong fan. I was thus already quite well aware of all the factual information presented in this book about both Beck and Scientology.

I’m also a former journalist, but I didn’t need that background to discern that a large percentage of the Beck content here (and please note that there are a LOT of digressive parts throughout) is pure speculation. And in the end, what is it saying? Does Riesman blame him directly for the fates of Theresa and Jeremy? I don’t think she does, so what is the point here?

I doubt Beck will ever write his own memoir, but I hope he does. It, too, may be somewhat speculative. We all invent fictions about our own backstories. But we shouldn’t create and publish those about other people without their consent and under the guise of truth. There are no receipts here, nor a worthy purpose.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Jennifer.
251 reviews29 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 27, 2026
This book was frustrating because it couldn't decide if it wanted to be 1) a biography of Beck 2) a take-down of Scientology or 3) a recounting of personal fandom & internet music fandom in the 2000s. It ended up not succeeding in any of the aims very well. The author obviously did a ton of research but the writing and source attribution was very hard to follow.

Profile Image for Stacy40pages.
2,553 reviews194 followers
October 16, 2026
The Last Temptation of Beck by Josephine Riesman. Thanks to atria for the gifted Arc ⭐️⭐️⭐️

The true story about Beck Hansen, who blew up in the minutes but also broke ties with many and destroyed an online forum of fans.

I remember when Loser came out and how it was everywhere. I was in middle school and everyone was singing it. Despite its predominance and meaning in my adolescence, I never really knew anything about the man behind the song. The best part of this book for me was the inside look at Scientology, and nothing is held back. Beck’s actual story within the book was okay, but nothing extremely dramatic got me. If you’re a music fan then it would definitely be an interesting one.

The Last Temptation of Beck is available now (pub date was moved up and I didn’t realize!)

Read if you like:
-Unusual upbringings
-LA life
-Music biographies
-Scientology history


“He may have been born in Los Angeles, but he was raised in another universe.”
Profile Image for Phil Lofton.
115 reviews
October 21, 2026
This is a fascinating book in so many ways, because it wobbles back and forth between brilliance and unethical horror.

The examination of Beck's artistic heritage through the profile of his parents and Al Hansen was a compelling intro to the book, as was the examination of Beck's early childhood. Then there's a disclosure of Beck's circumstance that is frankly not the author's to make, and its inclusion doesn't add much to the book.

The dive into Beck's rise from busker to rock hero is just as compelling as his family tree, and we get to see glimpses of how he and his friends took the world by storm with Mellow Gold all the way through Sea Change, the period of Beck's output where the author focuses her investigation. I appreciated the ways that Riesman challenged the creation myth of Sea Change, and the focus that she provided on Leigh Limon's life in that period and afterward was certainly a highlight of the book.

Then we get off the rails again. The Guero album cycle and what follows gets basically reduced down to Beck retreating into comfortable patterns (the Dust Brothers redux, Morning Phase) and reclusive eccentricities (The Record Club, The Song Reader). This is confusing to read from one fan to another, as it completely glosses over the life-altering and potentially career-ending spinal injury he suffered during the Guero cycle (I mean completely - I don't believe the author even mentions it). He also had two small children during this time. The framing not including both of these doesn't do the book any favors in terms of perceived objectivity.

Additionally, while our narrative centers on the perspectives of Beck's friends in the early era, by the end Riesman is hanging the narrative of Beck's retreat on a stalker and the unfortunate arc of a pair of artists at the periphery of Beck's orbit. The book struggles hard to try to push its point by the end. Then, in the afterward, the author tosses us brilliance: a reflection on Beck paired against the author's own identity as a Trans woman seeking refuge in Portugal. It's a moving essay, and on its own it would be an exceptional piece of writing. But it isn't on its own.

So much of this book is thought-provoking So much of this book should not have been included. Beck does not need defending: he's rich, famous and connected. The news is full of how people can exploit any one of those three buckets, let alone all three. Scientology and Beck's participation in it certainly deserves scrutiny, and its impact on the people surrounding Beck merits criticism and investigation. I'm not poo-pooing that element of the book. What I am saying is that disclosing someone's abuse as a tangential part of a biography is unethical, and discussion of trauma like that shouldn't be done in this way. What I am saying is that using the book-long arc of the book to tie the tragedy of Theresa Duncan and Jeremy Blake to Beck is at best irresponsible. What I am saying is that neither of these elements are essential to the book, and both heavily detract from one's ability to take it seriously as objective journalism.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Rob Saucedo.
Author 2 books19 followers
Read
October 20, 2026
Josephine Riesman’s THE LAST TEMPTATION OF BECK is a fascinating book. It’s not really a biography; so much of the story it paints about Beck’s life comes from sources with a tenuous connection to the pop star. It’s written like a thriller; the prose has a pulp-novel propulsiveness that makes the book immensely readable. It’s tawdry and often exploitative, but it’s also written by someone who clearly loves Beck and his music. In many ways, THE LAST TEMPTATION OF BECK feels like the natural conclusion of what a music book looks like when it’s written by somebody raised on the internet.

The book explores the life and music of Beck Hansen. It’s also about how Scientology swallowed the singer whole, causing him to cut off friends and lovers and threaten to derail his creative output. The book frequently uses anonymous sources, and when it doesn’t, it relies on former friends who haven’t spoken to Beck in years or former stalkers who once dug through his garbage.
If my wife had charged me a quarter every time I abused her with a new piece of Beck trivia, she could buy dinner at Red Lobster this weekend.

All that said, I can’t quite put my finger on how I feel about THE LAST TEMPTATION OF BECK. It’s a damn entertaining book; I breezed through it in less than a week, but something about its lack of a clear portrait of the man feels slightly worrisome. In a lot of ways, THE LAST TEMPTATION OF BECK reminded me a lot of YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING - both are blurry looks at an individual who has done everything possible to hide their true feelings and motivations. It’s probably just as impossible to truly know and understand Beck as it is to know and understand Elizabeth Holmes.

Anyway, if you’re a fan of Beck, ‘90s music, and have a rubberneck fascination with the inner machinations of Scientology, I wholeheartedly recommend THE LAST TEMPTATION OF BECK. Just be prepared for more questions than answers.
Profile Image for Patricio Padua.
55 reviews8 followers
August 31, 2026
Fascinating even if, like me, you’re not a big Beck fan. Riesman dives deep into Beck’s complicated history with Scientology, from his parents’ deep roots to the notorious case of Theresa Duncan and Jeremy Blake, which frames the narrative. This reads like true crime or horror more than pop biography, a real page turner that only flags at the end. My only quibble is that the final act isn’t dramatically satisfying, but how can there be satisfaction in this tortured tale?
Profile Image for Lissa00.
1,390 reviews30 followers
September 15, 2026
I, like the author, was a huge Beck fan as a teenager and attended one of his concerts on the Odelay tour. But then his music sort of faded to the background for me and I've never stopped to consider why. Josephine Riesman's book helps fill in these gaps. This is a fascinating exploration of a Generation X musician whose backstory was even more mysterious than his odd lyrics. I received a digital copy of this book via NetGalley.
Profile Image for Rebecca Rubenstein.
188 reviews4 followers
November 6, 2026
As a massive Beck fan during the mid-90’s, I was tickled to see my contribution to the Gellow Mold ‘zine referenced in this book. My maiden name is even cited in the endnotes. :) Honored to be a footnote in Beck history.
Profile Image for Nate Deprey.
1,382 reviews9 followers
October 27, 2026
Three stars until the afterward
Sort of about Beck
Wants to be a memoir
Guero is a very good record despite this book's narrative
Yup Josephine, I read Going Clear too
141 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
August 12, 2026
Incredibly well researched and well written. But, I think to fully enjoy this book, you would need to be a much bigger Beck fan than I realized I was. What a wild and weird life, and what an odd dude. Always seems to be the case, when Scientology is involved though. Also, how he treated his ex Leigh was shameful and awful. Soulless, which again, seems to track for Scientology.
2,199 reviews62 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 8, 2026
My thanks to NetGalley and Atria Books for an advance copy of a book that is a biography of a popular rock star, an examination of fame, religion, belonging and even parenting, along with a view of this modern world we find ourselves in, a time of encroaching darkness, when even the most wonder that is music seems powerless to lift the mood, and restore the light.

I was working in a independent record store when Loser premiered on MTV. At least that is where I think I first head about the one named singer Beck, who wasn't the guitarist par excellence Jeff Beck. My first thoughts were the song was cute, a little bit novelty like something heard on Dr. Demento, though the video was pretty striking. As usually my pulse was not on the zietgeist, and the song blew up. However not with myself. I admired the talent, but never really got behind Beck, as there was a lot of great music coming out. However he was popular, sold well, and meant a lot to a lot of people. My interest was not that strong, so I knew little about what came after with Beck. I knew there were other albums, I knew a Grammy also. So I was surprised to see that Josephine Riesman was writing on Beck, after books about such pop culture troublemakers like Stan Lee, and Vince McMahon. After reading this I can see why. The Last Temptation of Beck: The Untold Story of a Pop Messiah by Josephine Riesman is the story about a man who found fame and belonging after years of having neither, about the world he found himself in, the world he couldn't escape, and rise and fall of much in society, effects of which we are dealing with today.

Bek David Campbell, was born in Los Angles to a father who was a moderately successful musician, and a mother who was Bohemian in thought and in raising a family. The parents separated, but shared one common ideal, belonging to the Church of Scientology. This gave them access that both helped and probably hindered young Bek. Bek, later changed to Beck in school, and even later to Beck Hansen, went to Scientology schools, which taught more about being controlled rather than education. Beck was estranged from his father, and his mother made it quite clear she was not a helicopter parent. More a zeppelin parent, flying above it all. Beck was good at music, and even better at adapting personas. Taking traits, styles and incorporating them into his own music. Soon Beck had a music deal, one a small label, that suddenly blew up in a time when music was changing, as was the music industry. Beck suddenly found himself popular, his music playing everywhere. Fans stealing his garbage to understand his thoughts. This was a little too much for Beck, overwhelming in both fame and expectations. And watching in the background was a group that was always willing to help, and gain more converts.

Reading this was an exploration of fame, of music, and of thinking at the end of the 20th century. Music was changing, the idea of selling out was not being seen as a bad thing. And over it all was the Church of Scientology, a cult so strange only a weird science fiction writer could have invented it. I had wondered why Riesman, such a great chronicler of showmen and self-made hucksters would care about Beck. Riesman looks at everything, the music, the scene, even the art scene, as Beck's grandfather was a well-known artist. The writing is really good, as are many of the subplots, one would not think would appear in a book about Beck. This was a more darker tale than I expected and Odeley-like version of America, with fame, religion, politics, parenting all making an appearance. Riesman is an excellent writer, one able to find connections where one does not expect them. Also a passionate writer, especially on the state of the world, and how certain celebrities are detached from it.

This is the third biography by Riesman I have read, and while I was more familiar with Stan Lee and Vince McMahon, this is one I found myself most effected by. The music, the detached family life, being used for religion, being so detached that adopting personas was easier than taking a stand. A really well-done biography, and one that I know I will think about quite a bit. A eagerly await what Riesman has planned next.
Profile Image for Andy.
42 reviews2 followers
October 4, 2026
This is a review of an advance copy received from NetGalley

I’m not really sure how I feel about this book. Having grown up a massive Beck fan, especially of the Midnite Vultures era, I was excited to read about the life of a musician that, really, no one knows much about.

Did I get that? Yes. There was plenty for me to learn about a musician that has such a varied career. I didn’t know much about where Beck came from or the role Scientology played in his life/career. Years and years ago, Beck was the one who get me to learn about Scientology and, for better or for worse, it is something that I have found myself drawn to learning about, especially as more and more gets revealed about the secretive organization.

My issues with the book were threefold:

First, the book became less about Beck and more about Scientology. There were a few places where the author looked thought there was smoke but there was no fire. Sure, it’s an organization that is known to be corrupt and its connections to Beck seem to be well-documented. I loved the album Sea Change and bought into the idea that it was based on a relationship went wrong. Was this all due to interference from the church? Probably…I’m willing to believe it. But more and more, the book focused on the aspects that weren’t related to Beck. And those that were seem somewhat thin such as…a person whose thinking is related to Leigh…um…

This leads to my second issue…Anna. An investigator who becomes obsessed with Beck, is super active on the message boards, and goes as far as digging through his trash. This seems less like a person looking for something and more like a fan who gets in too deep.

Finally, the two artists who had previously worked with Beck. Yes, it seems like some people may have been shitty to them. Maybe Scientology even had something to do with it. But really, it ends up feeling like two paranoid people who weren’t doing as well and they would have liked. The author even points out that they would have been small potatoes, not enough for the church to go after. Tom Cruise and his company was really that concerned about these two?

Ultimately, it wasn’t bad and I really enjoyed reading it. I feel like I learned a lot and Beck remains one my favorite artists. Worth the read but there is a lot worth skipping through.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
38 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 28, 2026
3.5 stars

I took a shot at this Biography of Beck based on some nostalgia from my 90s youth, as I do remember enjoying some of his songs but I was never especially a fan. There is a wealth of stories here from an array of figures in Beck’s life which paint an interesting and continuously enigmatic picture.

I liked the writing in and of itself and think Riesman has a talent and would seek out more books from the same author but I think the book presents more as a series of essays or vignettes that never fully come together for me. Going into the book based on the description and the title, I thought there would be a very defined culminating event but there isn’t. It’s understandable based on Beck being very private even in his closest relationships, but it changes the overall feel of the book. I also felt like the ending was very passionate but also a bit of a stretch, but perhaps this was because I wasn’t especially impacted by Beck even in his hey day.

I did find a lot of the stories fascinating and there’s a lot of passion and effort put in to finding out information although the way it’s written makes it a little hard to note how much is directly from sources and how much is from the author.

Overall an interesting read and I would recommend it to anyone interested in Beck (I don’t think you have to be a fan to enjoy this), Scientology, or culture of the 90’s and early 2000s.

Thank you to Atria Books, Josephine Riesman, and Netgalley
369 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Goodreads Giveaways
September 26, 2026
Great read. A pleasant surprise as I'm not familiar with his music. It's a story of a neglected child and indifferent parents, and a confusing Scientology connection. He made himself what he is today, which can be admired and appreciated. Very interesting and informative book. Thank you to Goodreads and Atria Books for the ARC.
Profile Image for Trisha.
6,208 reviews249 followers
Want to Read
March 12, 2026
I don't often read biographies but. . .um, THIS ONE SOUNDS SO GOOD!!!

I remember listening to Beck. Where did he go?

Pub date: 11/2026
I'll be looking for this one!
Profile Image for Teresa.
1,045 reviews8 followers
October 20, 2026
Partly true crime, partly biography, partly a screed on scientology, partly a history on the music scene of the early 90s. That's what we have in The Last Temptation of Beck, an oddly confusing title. Confusing because I was expecting a more Beck focused account. Riesman delivers the edges, but never cracks the center of what makes Beck tick. Her admiration for his music over the years fueled this endeavor, she made it personal.

Some of the tangents seemed a bit of a stretch. Giving credence to individuals who routinely searched Beck's trash for "clues" was a head scratcher. Many many people in Beck's orbit, including his mother, contributed, but without his own input, let alone blessing, the whole effort felt off. And kind of icky.

Oodles of research (over 25% of the pages in my copy), good effort, mixed results.

My thanks to NetGalley and Atria Books for the Advance Reader Copy. (pub. date 10/6/2026)
9 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Goodreads Giveaways
September 25, 2026
The book never really reveals much information about the private man Beck. There is some interesting history and background on the Church of Scientology. Overall the books seems to lose its way while never really finding Beck.
115 reviews2 followers
October 13, 2026
Idk, Beck kind of sucks. Also a bummer that all the albums of his I like are considered his worst albums.

I slept on it, and I woke up disliking the book even more. Not even sure who this is for.
Profile Image for Brian Shevory.
458 reviews19 followers
October 25, 2026
Like the author, Josephine Riesman, and many of the other fans featured in the intriguing book The Last Temptation of Beck: The Untold Story of a Pop Messiah, I was an early adherent of Beck. I fell in love with his strange visions, loving the sound of “Loser” and “Beercan”. However, once I began to listen to his b-sides for these songs, I absolutely loved his work. Songs like “Soul Sucking Jerk”, “Got No Mind”, “Corvette Bummer”, and especially “Fume” really spoke to my adolescence as well as my interest in expanding the confines of alternative music. Beck’s music was strange, funny, and unique, standing out among a crowded music store filled with crunchy grunge power chords and riffs. Although I loved his experimentation, I especially loved his acoustic work on One Foot in the Grave, Stereopathic Soulmanure, and A Western Harvest Field by Moonlight. I loved how raw and experimental they were, allowing listeners into the odd process that Beck used to construct (or maybe de-construct) these idiosyncratic songs. The first section of Riesman’s book takes us through these thrilling times to see how Beck not only developed his musicianship, but also how he evolved from a strange hip-hop loving folk and blues musician into the party boy who had two turntables and a microphone. Riesman’s reporting, though, doesn’t just focus on Beck’s life and career. Rather, she takes the fans’ perspectives, reminding readers how exciting and different Beck’s music was, and how it spoke to those who were different, those who didn’t fit in with the typical crowds in schools or who were searching for new and different sounds. She introduces us Truck and Donna, two fans who ended up creating Beck fanzines and websites in the early days of the internet. It was amazing to learn how both of these fans eventually gained access to Beck, although in different ways. Riesman’s reporting allows us to see not only how indifferent Beck initially was to success, but also how uncomfortable he was to fame and attention. I actually liked how Riesman includes multiple narratives that detail Beck’s biography and career development with his fan’s perspectives and interests. Also included in these chapters are a focus on Beck’s family, including his mother, his Scientologist and musical father, and his Fluxus-performance artist grandfather, Al Hansen, whose own life seemed to be shaped more by myth and memory than reality and history. Riesman skillfully constructs chapters with these competing narratives to allow readers to learn more about the enigmatic Beck, and how guarded his background is. While Riesman indicates part of this was due to Beck’s discomfort with the limelight initially, she also suggests that his eventual engagement with the Church of Scientology also has something to do with his changing public persona that remained cautiously guarded.
Although I don’t know much about Scientology except from Lawrence Wright’s incredible book Going Clear (which was cited throughout some of the chapters), it’s clear that Scientology has had a disruptive impact on many people’s lives. Riesman provides some background about the origins of Scientology, as well as their growth from a strange sci-fi group to an IRS recognized religion, without getting into the strange and sordid details. I was actually impressed with how concise her reporting is. Although there have been rumors about Beck’s involvement with Scientology and some evidence provided from Riesman, no of it seems to indicate a definitive explanation for Beck’s later music nor his personal life. I too agree that Beck’s music, especially after Sea Change seemed to become somewhat vapid, with occasional good songs here and there. Nothing ever reached the consistent whole album of records like Odelay or Mutations. It can be difficult to continuously reinvent oneself or find ways to keep music fresh and appealing. We’ve seen this with many other artists who struggle with remaining relevant while still trying to maintain creative control from record labels. Could it be that Beck was under pressure to craft more hit singles rather than pursue his passion and interest in exploring new sounds? Was the record label looking for more of the same, banking on safe, formulaic music rather than exciting experimentation? Riesman seems to suggest that Beck’s father, David Campbell, and other Scientologists were more to blame, as Beck began to be viewed as a pop music messiah who might also be able to recruit new members with his infectious and popular music. She cites the role of actors like Tom Cruise who attribute their popularity and success to Scientology’s principles. It’s an interesting premise, but one that Riesman is never able to completely nail. Much of the evidence she relies on is based on events, interviews with friends of friends, and other kinds of speculation that I found somewhat questionable. At the center of the Riesman’s claims are the tragic deaths of Jeremy Blake and Theresa Duncan, two artists who had connections to Beck. Jeremy Blake, a digital artist, worked with Beck on the cover for Sea Change, while his partner Theresa Duncan proposed that Beck star in a movie she was planning to direct that was a 1970s set in NYC take on Alice in Wonderland. Duncan and Blake both died at their own hands in July 2007, and there’s been speculation that their deaths were the result of harassment by Scientology, with Riesman implicitly blaming Beck for their deaths. It was pretty shocking to read since there was no clear evidence of harassment. Riesman documents that Blake and Duncan grew increasingly conspiratorial and paranoid, eventually withdrawing into a strange apartment in NYC. While Duncan blamed Beck’s eventually exit from the planned film for the project’s failure, it looked to me like the possibility of the changing tastes in films. Films like these are especially hard to find funding for, and I would imagine that a first time female director might face additional challenges to making a 1970s remake of Alice in Wonderland set in NYC. I wondered if possibly Duncan and Riesman were attributing the obstacles that this project faced to other outside forces. This also made the implications of Beck’s involvement in their deaths even more frustrating since there was no clear evidence to show this. While Scientology does have a history of harassing its perceived enemies, and Riesman provides examples and the kinds of labeling that the organization uses for those who pose a threat, it’s not clear why Beck or Scientology would mark Blake and Duncan as suppressive persons or why they were considered fair game especially when they didn’t really seem to attack Beck. Riesman does suggest that Beck possibly wanted out, but was pulled back in to Scientology, but again, there’s not real definitive evidence.
This kind of hearsay was also used to document Beck’s breakup with his longtime partner Leigh Limon, who helped style Beck during his transformation from urban slacker to a retro-styled entertainer. As Riesman documents, Limon eventually grew distant from Beck as he continued to tour the world and she remained at home. She made attempts to spend more time with him, but he remained aloof and distant. Riesman notes how Beck’s father and mother became more of a presence in his life as he became more famous, and suggests that this was the reason for Beck’s distance from Limon. However, as Riesman also noted with pre-fame Beck, he was always aloof and distant, struggling to interact with others and often seeming spacy or disengaged. I wondered too how much fame and the pressure to maintain hit records and tour constantly may have challenged him and affected his relationships with those he was close with. He seemed like he was unconcerned about fame, and listening to some of his earlier independent releases, he didn’t seem like he wanted to make pop music, but rather pursued his own idiosyncratic passions and interests. We also have to remember that this was around the time of Kurt Kobain’s death, where alternative music was experiencing a kind of identity crisis, with calls to keep things real and not sell out. Could Beck’s success also have created his own identity crisis? Riesman’s reporting says that Beck accused Limon of cheating and substance abuse, apparently fed to him by other Scientologists while he was touring Japan. While this is also a possibility, I wondered why Beck would believe accusations like this, especially about a loved one, without verifying. I ended up empathizing with Limon, whose job, home, car, and other possessions were all owned by Beck. She was swiftly evicted and struggled to get back on her feet. Riesman didn’t interview her, but provides details about what she is currently up to and how she saw Beck at a concert, but didn’t talk to him. Limon’s experience, as well as those of some of Beck’s other early supporters, were troubling and sad, yet it’s not completely clear whether Scientology factored into these breaks or not. Even if they did, I don’t necessarily think they caused the deaths of Blake and Duncan. I would need to review more of the facts to make any clear indication, and while Riesman creates a compelling narrative, it seemed like the facts operate more around correlation than causation.
Despite these fallacies, Riesman has crafted an exciting book about an enigmatic figure in the music world who has undergone many transformations (or Mutations) not only musically but also stylistically. I loved learning more about Beck’s early beginnings in LA and New York, and how his strange blend of folk music and hip-hop gradually evolved to become such a fascinating mix of styles. I also loved learning about his family, especially his grandfather and mother, who each participated in the art world that possibly shaped Beck’s own vision and styles. Nevertheless, Riesman also reports on some of the questionable behavior from Beck that led to fallouts, estrangements, and other breaks that seemed to come from nowhere without warning. Whether it was scientology or some other variable, Riesman seems to have her mind made up. I appreciated her reporting, but I had my own questions about these claims. Nevertheless, this was a fascinating read, and it spurred my renewed interest in Beck’s music and life. Highly recommended! Many thanks to Atria Books and NetGalley for sharing an advanced copy.
Profile Image for Wendi Manning.
322 reviews16 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 30, 2026
Wow, a lot of mixed feelings here. The author has a lot of predetermined ideas going in and it feels like she wrote this around them.

She hates Scientology, but who doesn’t? She brings in Satanism and the occult, ok fine. She doesn’t like what Beck did to his ex girlfriend, so much so that she recounts conversations and events as fact that she wasn’t there for and couldn’t possibly know. That’s a big problem.

She is a huge Beck fan but she doesn’t really like him or have any respect for him as a person. That’s another problem. She treats him the way she says he treats others. She tells his secrets like she has permission. She doesn’t. If he was a Danny Masterson type, that’s one thing. Beck isn’t though, and abuse that he suffered as a minor and has never talked about should be his to tell. This book isn’t authorized and because of that, a lot of liberties are taken.

I’ve read and liked her other books and was looking forward to this one, but she whiffed on this. Too big of an axe to grind.

I don’t think I recommend it.

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Sarina Uriza .
16 reviews2 followers
October 12, 2026
In reading other reviews about this book, I realize I fall into the category of being a Beck-o-Phile for a brief but highly integral portion of my adolescence. My introduction to Beck was via Loser - which was kind of a necessity to have in one’s arsenal of skate boarding knowledge and culture - should one be trying to traverse that scene. I found the Mellow Gold album okay but I wasn’t rabid for more. Then I stumbled upon Odelay - and just as the Author of this book avers - my life was changed. I played the album front to back and back to front thousands of times. Today, even after so many years - the album still stands out amongst the other top 10 albums of my adolescence. The album itself is perfectly arranged, each song in its place. Each song offers a different vibe yet cohesively meshes with each other. Then there are the lyrics to the songs themselves, mysterious, melodic, morose, and downright nonsense at times. All of this imprinted itself into my still forming frontal cortex.

There was limited information about Beck at the time and I chalked that up to the infancy of the internet. As time has gone by… turns out that’s not why there exists little information about Beck and the information available is conflicting. I scoured bookstores and music stores to find any magazine I could that had references to Beck. I remember getting my hands on an AP issue that featured Beck on the cover lying on his side propped up by his elbow dressed in vintage car salesman attire à la Limón. The magazine had a multi page interview and touted him as the Golden Boy. No mention of his Scientology affiliation or about his youth. I can’t recall if it was in this article or another music mag where Beck is said to have not made it past 7th grade.

Unfortunately, after Odelay Beck musically took a turn that didn’t resonate with me, which is highlighted in this book. There are other artists that I started listening to at a young age that I have grown with and connect with today (ex NIN/Trent Reznor). Each release from Beck following Odelay has produced at least one song that I get into - and it’s usually the most depressive and melancholy one on his album. Although Odelay contains uplifting dance music, there is a sense of searching and abandonment that Beck conveyed to me that I felt deeply at the time of discovering it and even now that his follow-up albums lack.

Some say Sea of Change was Beck’s most depressing album. For some reason, when I have tried to get into it, it lacked the authentic sound of heartbreak and longing I was accustomed to. Don’t get me wrong… the lyrics are heartbreaking. But it’s something in Beck’s tone that is devoid of the lonely roaming…

Jack-Ass on Odelay -
“I’ve been drifting along
In the same stale shoes
Loose ends tying a noose
In the back of my mind”

One song that was reminiscent of an Odelay song on Sea Change is Lost Cause…it reminded me of Jack-Ass only it was a Grammy filtered, studio ironed version of it….

“Your sorry eyes, they cut through bone
Make it hard to leave you alone
Leave you here wearing your wounds
Waving your guns at somebody new”

And perhaps the problem is … the songs almost all point their daggers at someone else and not inwardly. Self deprecation breeds melancholy. Even if you’re crying a river of tears - blaming others for your pain breeds narcissism.

What I like about this unauthorized biography was that the author put into words - or introduced other concepts - on what I could not, regarding the shift from Beck Odelay to today. Was the Odelay and pre-Odelay Beck the real Beck? Or was that an awkward amalgamation of a 20-something child of Scientology with limited parental guidance wandering and mimicking the art and music he clung to for comfort? Is the real artist who we see today - apparently or allegedly not a Scientologist?

Beck just released a new album, of which I am currently trying to digest. I guess I am selfishly - just as others are, looking for something that I want. Imposing upon this artist my desire to feel what I felt as a youth… and I know this is a futile exercise. So, I’m trying to experience the new album and maybe even do a revisit of the others with my fully developed frontal cortex and without any expectations or desires.

I agree the book may be somewhat of a hard read if there is no connection to liking Beck or the Author. I would say for those interested and you have no previous experience with Beck to play Odelay front to back and then read the book.
Profile Image for DJMikeG.
526 reviews30 followers
November 17, 2026
A mostly excellent, very different sort of a biography on legendary musician Beck. Beck is a very complicated person, and absolutely a musical genius, and this book mostly captured that. I really enjoyed the sections of the book concerned with younger Beck in his pre fame years, and his meteoric rise to stardom from being a nobody living in a shack behind someone's house. It really is an awe inspiring tale.
The larger, overarching tale is of a kid, raised in a cult, who leaves the cult, becomes a star and lured back into the cult by his family. It is a very involving, tragic sort of tale. I couldn't put the book down, I tore through it in three days. All that said, this book is not without it's faults.
Riesman goes into deep detail on the suicides of artists Theresa Duncan and Jeremy Blake and the events leading up to those tragedies. This whole section of the book really did not click with me. It isn't very clear what Riesman is trying to convey, but it is written in a True Crime style, so it makes you think she is claiming these deaths were somehow caused by Beck, but looking at what she shares about these cases, it is really unclear. Overall, this whole part of the book came across as sensationalistic and True Crimey for the sake of being True Crime.
Riesman seems to be a fan of big declarative statement, even if they aren't really true, which is weird to see in a book that was supposedly obsessively fact checked. Towards the end of the book she writes something to the effect of "Beck's career as a pop star was over", this book came out just as Beck's widely acclaimed new album Ride Lonesome was released. Sure doesn't seem like his career is over, eh?
I also found it weird that she kind of goes after him for not speaking out against Trump and ICE. Beck has never been outspoken on politics, ever, which is mentioned earlier in the book.
The call that Scientology is a fascist organization is a good, accurate take, but I don't think Riesman's rambling account of a dying Portuguese dictator worked as a parallel with Beck's story, like at all. This kind of reveals that Riesman is using a writerly trick of taking two very disparate things and connecting them to make an earth shattering point, but she is swinging for that and missing.
So yeah, overall, this is a great book, it just has some issues that maybe a better editorial staff could have tightened up. Four stars for the fascinating glimpse of the early years of a complicated, incredibly strange and massively talented artist.
Profile Image for Dana.
187 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 5, 2026
This is a fantastic celebrity biography that explores the stardom of the musician Beck as well as his and his family's involvement in the Church of Scientology. I was a casual fan when he broke through, but I did not follow his career after his first two albums. But Beck was a notable Gen X mainstay and I knew a few things about him, but not much. I enjoyed learning about Beck's life from a writer who really shows incredible enthusiasm for the subject. I will say, however, that the way he acted when the Church forced him to break up with Leigh was despicable and I lost a lot of respect for him. And his other actions that were controlled by Scientology after that point were also pretty disgusting. I suppose I went into this knowing very little and came out with a strong reminder that celebrities can be very disappointing.

An interesting side story deals with the bizarre tragedy of Theresa Duncan and Jeremy Blake. I have gone down that particular rabbit hole several times because it fascinates me and I enjoy both of their art. I absolutely believe that their downfall has Scientology written all over it, and I enjoyed its inclusion.

The book is thorough and well written, an entertaining read that I highly recommend to fans of Beck, indie music, true crime-style stories about cults, and celebrity profiles.

Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for providing a review copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Sara M..
104 reviews6 followers
October 6, 2026
I don't quite know what to make of this book. I picked it up because I really enjoy Beck's music, especially funnily enough if you've read the book - Sea Changes. I suppose I wasn't sure what to expect going into it, but it was sort of different than I thought it would be. It was well written and mostly compelling, but it sort of reads like the author is a disgruntled fan complaining that Beck's music changed/"the old stuff was better". It also felt odd that no one actually close to Beck, besides his former webmaster, was willing to talk for this book. It read like hearsay a little bit. I liked the bits about the history of scientology - I didn't previously know much about the religious cult. I always knew Beck was a scientologist, but didn't know what that meant really. It was interesting to have some context. The church of scientology probably did affect his behavior a lot when he was in the thick of it and that sucks, but it sounds like he has come out the other side and moved away from the church. Despite the sort of critical view of Beck in this book, I still am a fan. I've seen him twice and both times have been fantastic. Also - how appropriate that this book is coming out just as his new album is dropping. Overall, pretty well written, but I didn't love it.
74 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 25, 2026
The Last Temptation of Beck is so much more interesting than a straightforward music biography. I loved the way Riesman digs into the strange mythology that grew around Beck in the ’90s—the “Loser” era, the genre-hopping albums, the irony, and the almost cult-like devotion of his fans. The shift around the turn of the millennium was especially fascinating, when Beck’s music became darker and more inward while he shut down the online community that had formed around him and distanced himself from the LA scene that helped shape him.

What really worked for me was the focus on the people who actually knew Beck and the way their stories complicate the public version of him. His connection to Scientology, the changing friendships, and the line between an artist creating a persona and people genuinely believing the myth make this feel like much more than a celebrity biography. It’s a really fascinating look at fandom, authenticity, and what happens when the person everyone thinks they know becomes impossible to separate from the character he created.
Profile Image for Nick Padula.
Author 1 book11 followers
September 25, 2026
Previously, I read Riesman’s Stan Lee biography which was a fascinating exposé on the near-mythical comic book mogul. By chance, I stumbled upon this while combing through NetGalley’s catalog and had to give it a look-see.

This book served as an investigation into the elusive alternative music figure Beck and his connections to Scientology. I was never the biggest fan of Beck, so I was fine with these damning revelations. My wife used to be a bit of a fan, so every so often as I was reading this, I’d tell her one of the facts from this to keep her in the loop.

Like with her last book I read, Riesman’s writing style feels like a compelling psychological drama instead of a dry statement of facts. I can sometimes struggle reading nonfiction, but when it’s written like this, I have a great time.

Thank you to NetGalley, Simon & Schuster, and Josephine Riesman for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for eva tomlinson.
111 reviews1 follower
November 5, 2026
interesting… i was intrigued to read this after the variety article came out but i think it only offered so much more. not entirely convinced beck is out of scientology but okay… the second half (post 2002ish) felt rushed and unsatisfying. i understand if you can’t access your direct source material but why release this third hand retelling that so often throws its hands up and says “oh who knows”. i do think some of this comes from beck closing off even more himself but it is hard to trust or believe what went on at all. random asides about historical events like world war ii and 9/11 and im sorry but i really dont think that has anything to do w what we’re talking about. and my fault for reading the afterword bc that really has nothing to do with it and the weird strings they tie back to beck like oh gen x voted for trump like okay???? like yes what you’re saying is true but why am i reading this rn
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Berslon Pank.
282 reviews2 followers
November 20, 2026
What was this book? It says it's about Beck but it feels like it is about the author's own relationship to being a fan of Beck. Something changed for the author around 2000 so there are a lot of inferences made to prove by suggestion that something happened to Beck.

The way Theresa's and Jeremy's deaths are treated in here also suggests that Scientology and Beck had a part in it. Sources are quoted as saying T & J were almost certainly not targeted by Scientology but then continues to drill into their deaths in a way that left me needing to remind myself of the earlier sources because there was a lot more talk about scientology and their deaths after the source was quoted.

Then there's an afterword where the author talks about Portugal and her own story. It's interesting and has a line that I went back to read several times because it gave me so much pleasure but the connection to the rest of the story is forced.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for alexandria dickson.
20 reviews
October 8, 2026
Great writing and investigative digging by Josephine. I really enjoyed this book, although I will say this is more of a book on investigative journalism than a traditional biography. Nonetheless, it is still great work. As a huge fan of Beck, it’s a bit disappointing to read about him ghosting the people who cared the most about him, and also how he became a diva of sorts when he decided to go all in with Scientology. Didn’t see any of that coming but it all makes sense.

Either way, phenomenal book and an unfortunate cherry on top type of ending that wrapped everything up to bring the content back to present day with parallels similar to what the U.S. is experiencing. 10/10 would read again.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews