What do you think?
A Shadow Over the World: Franklin D. Roosevelt, the Rise of Fascism, and the Making of America's World War II
From New York Times bestselling author William I. Hitchcock, a riveting revisionist portrait of Franklin Delano Roosevelt in the lead-up to World War II, tracing his—and America’s—awakening to the threat of fascism.
How did FDR and the American public respond to the rise of dictators across Europe and Asia on the eve of World War II? The familiar narrative is that they reacted with indifference and embraced isolationism. Only with the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor were Americans reluctantly drawn into the global conflict. But distinguished historian William I. Hitchcock reveals a far more complex and surprising story.
From the time Mussolini came to power in 1922 to America’s entry into the war in 1941, Americans engaged in a fraught national debate over the rising threat—and for some, the lure—of fascism. At the center of this debate was Roosevelt himself. When he took office in 1933, Roosevelt was determined to avoid foreign entanglements that would harm his ambitious domestic agenda of the New Deal. But over the course of his first two terms, a network of journalists, activists, advisers, and diplomats gradually awakened him to the global dangers of fascism.
Roosevelt’s transformation was part of a larger national reckoning with authoritarianism around the world. A Shadow Over the World shines a light on a time when a coalition of courageous humanists gathered around a visionary leader to forge a new purpose for to protect democracy, oppose imperialism, support human rights, and lead a global fight for freedom. Their successful struggle against the dark forces of fascism holds powerful lessons for our own perilous times.
How did FDR and the American public respond to the rise of dictators across Europe and Asia on the eve of World War II? The familiar narrative is that they reacted with indifference and embraced isolationism. Only with the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor were Americans reluctantly drawn into the global conflict. But distinguished historian William I. Hitchcock reveals a far more complex and surprising story.
From the time Mussolini came to power in 1922 to America’s entry into the war in 1941, Americans engaged in a fraught national debate over the rising threat—and for some, the lure—of fascism. At the center of this debate was Roosevelt himself. When he took office in 1933, Roosevelt was determined to avoid foreign entanglements that would harm his ambitious domestic agenda of the New Deal. But over the course of his first two terms, a network of journalists, activists, advisers, and diplomats gradually awakened him to the global dangers of fascism.
Roosevelt’s transformation was part of a larger national reckoning with authoritarianism around the world. A Shadow Over the World shines a light on a time when a coalition of courageous humanists gathered around a visionary leader to forge a new purpose for to protect democracy, oppose imperialism, support human rights, and lead a global fight for freedom. Their successful struggle against the dark forces of fascism holds powerful lessons for our own perilous times.
- GenresHistoryWorld War II
736 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 15, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
Read
September 27, 2026Thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for the digital copy of this book; I am leaving this review voluntarily.
A Shadow Over the World is a hefty tome, but sometimes I want a deep dive into a subject. It tells the story of the time before the rise of fascism in Europe and what led to it. The rise of Hitler, Stalin, and Mussolini appealed to plenty of Americans, too, that’s the part that our textbooks left out.
The book carefully examines the struggle to protect democratic ideals of America by activists and journalists who tried to show those in power the threat. Their focus on the systemic threats to democracy by authoritarianism is eerily similar to modern times, but by studying the past can help us tackle it and dismantle it from within.
Franklin Roosevelt wanted to focus on domestic issues when he ran for president. The Great Depression was in full swing, and he ran for president because he knew he could help the country, just as he helped the state of New York as governor. He had a cadre of people surrounding him who made him realize that the threats to Europe would soon threaten the United States, too.
A Shadow Over the World is the first book I’ve read that really spends a lot of time studying the isolationist movement in the United States. The America First Committee, with American hero Charles Lindbergh as the mouthpiece, had a lot of members and support. It wasn’t just a few thousand people dotting the country; it was a very popular movement. It was up to Franklin Roosevelt as president to move the needle of public opinion away from isolationism because he knew the Allies would need help from the U.S.
I really liked this book and its focus, but it was a bit wordy, coming in around 700 pages. However, I really didn’t find any parts that could have been edited. Take your time when reading or listening to absorb all the information presented. The United States has a long history of underlying fascism.
A Shadow Over the World is a hefty tome, but sometimes I want a deep dive into a subject. It tells the story of the time before the rise of fascism in Europe and what led to it. The rise of Hitler, Stalin, and Mussolini appealed to plenty of Americans, too, that’s the part that our textbooks left out.
The book carefully examines the struggle to protect democratic ideals of America by activists and journalists who tried to show those in power the threat. Their focus on the systemic threats to democracy by authoritarianism is eerily similar to modern times, but by studying the past can help us tackle it and dismantle it from within.
Franklin Roosevelt wanted to focus on domestic issues when he ran for president. The Great Depression was in full swing, and he ran for president because he knew he could help the country, just as he helped the state of New York as governor. He had a cadre of people surrounding him who made him realize that the threats to Europe would soon threaten the United States, too.
A Shadow Over the World is the first book I’ve read that really spends a lot of time studying the isolationist movement in the United States. The America First Committee, with American hero Charles Lindbergh as the mouthpiece, had a lot of members and support. It wasn’t just a few thousand people dotting the country; it was a very popular movement. It was up to Franklin Roosevelt as president to move the needle of public opinion away from isolationism because he knew the Allies would need help from the U.S.
I really liked this book and its focus, but it was a bit wordy, coming in around 700 pages. However, I really didn’t find any parts that could have been edited. Take your time when reading or listening to absorb all the information presented. The United States has a long history of underlying fascism.
October 4, 2026
My father graduated high school in 1935. My mother in 1937. My father and his college graduate mother were well read and active readers of current events. This book allows me to sit next to them and read the morning paper and discuss world events as they unfolded.
I am thoroughly enjoying this history while at the same time absorbing the beginning of the horrors of WWII.
I am thoroughly enjoying this history while at the same time absorbing the beginning of the horrors of WWII.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Review: A Shadow Over the World by William I. Hitchcock
I received an advance reader copy of this book from NetGalley and Simon & Schuster in exchange for an honest review. It publishes September 15th.
First, the simple stuff: this is a well-written book. It's over 700 pages, covering almost two decades of political and diplomatic history, and I still didn't want it to end. That's rare for a book this size. Hitchcock writes narrative nonfiction the way it should be done — well sourced, but told through scenes and real voices instead of dry facts. He quotes letters, diaries, speeches, and memos on almost every page, so it feels less like reading a history text and more like watching it unfold.
The book covers the rise of Mussolini, Hitler, and Stalin, and how fascism actually had some appeal here in the U.S. too. It goes into Japan's brutal invasion of China, including Nanking, and gives real weight to Mussolini's invasion of Ethiopia. The Spanish Civil War gets a full chapter of its own — an early test of America's Neutrality Act, which in trying to stay neutral ended up hurting the victims of aggression as much as the aggressors.
But the heart of the book is FDR himself. Hitchcock shows him in 1933, focused entirely on the New Deal and determined to stay out of foreign trouble, and traces how that changed. It wasn't Roosevelt alone — it was a network of people around him. Journalists like Dorothy Thompson and Walter Lippmann. Cabinet members like Harold Ickes. Justice Felix Frankfurter. Eleanor Roosevelt, to a degree. Writers like Archibald MacLeish. Even A. Philip Randolph, whose civil rights organizing tied the fight against fascism abroad to unfinished business with democracy at home.
On the other side, Hitchcock gives real space to the isolationists — Charles Lindbergh and the America First Committee, along with the radio priest Charles Coughlin, who ended up openly sympathetic to Mussolini and worse. This wasn't a fringe movement. It was popular, and the book doesn't pretend otherwise.
The path runs in stages: neutrality, then cash-and-carry, then Lend-Lease, then the destroyers-for-bases deal, with each new act of aggression — Czechoslovakia, Munich, the fall of France — pushing FDR a little further. The book builds to the Atlantic Conference in August 1941, aboard the USS Augusta, where Hitchcock says plainly that FDR had already committed the country to the fight against fascism. The timing and shape of it were still unknown, but the course was set. Pearl Harbor comes just over three months later, and gets barely a mention at the end. That's not an oversight — it's the point. Roosevelt's private decision had already been made.
I give this book 5 stars and highly recommend it to anyone interested in WWII or FDR history. Hitchcock may not be as well known as Atkinson, Larson, or Goodwin, but his quote-driven narrative nonfiction ranks right up there with them.
I received an advance reader copy of this book from NetGalley and Simon & Schuster in exchange for an honest review. It publishes September 15th.
First, the simple stuff: this is a well-written book. It's over 700 pages, covering almost two decades of political and diplomatic history, and I still didn't want it to end. That's rare for a book this size. Hitchcock writes narrative nonfiction the way it should be done — well sourced, but told through scenes and real voices instead of dry facts. He quotes letters, diaries, speeches, and memos on almost every page, so it feels less like reading a history text and more like watching it unfold.
The book covers the rise of Mussolini, Hitler, and Stalin, and how fascism actually had some appeal here in the U.S. too. It goes into Japan's brutal invasion of China, including Nanking, and gives real weight to Mussolini's invasion of Ethiopia. The Spanish Civil War gets a full chapter of its own — an early test of America's Neutrality Act, which in trying to stay neutral ended up hurting the victims of aggression as much as the aggressors.
But the heart of the book is FDR himself. Hitchcock shows him in 1933, focused entirely on the New Deal and determined to stay out of foreign trouble, and traces how that changed. It wasn't Roosevelt alone — it was a network of people around him. Journalists like Dorothy Thompson and Walter Lippmann. Cabinet members like Harold Ickes. Justice Felix Frankfurter. Eleanor Roosevelt, to a degree. Writers like Archibald MacLeish. Even A. Philip Randolph, whose civil rights organizing tied the fight against fascism abroad to unfinished business with democracy at home.
On the other side, Hitchcock gives real space to the isolationists — Charles Lindbergh and the America First Committee, along with the radio priest Charles Coughlin, who ended up openly sympathetic to Mussolini and worse. This wasn't a fringe movement. It was popular, and the book doesn't pretend otherwise.
The path runs in stages: neutrality, then cash-and-carry, then Lend-Lease, then the destroyers-for-bases deal, with each new act of aggression — Czechoslovakia, Munich, the fall of France — pushing FDR a little further. The book builds to the Atlantic Conference in August 1941, aboard the USS Augusta, where Hitchcock says plainly that FDR had already committed the country to the fight against fascism. The timing and shape of it were still unknown, but the course was set. Pearl Harbor comes just over three months later, and gets barely a mention at the end. That's not an oversight — it's the point. Roosevelt's private decision had already been made.
I give this book 5 stars and highly recommend it to anyone interested in WWII or FDR history. Hitchcock may not be as well known as Atkinson, Larson, or Goodwin, but his quote-driven narrative nonfiction ranks right up there with them.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews