The classic Hallmark holiday movie gets turned upside down when a teen leaves her small-town Christmas tree farm in pursuit of the city girl who swept her off her feet in this cheeky and cozy rom-com by Food Network competitor Stef Ferrari.
Bennie Bosley has Christmas spirit on lock. Her borderline magical ability to give the perfect gift, encyclopedic knowledge of holiday movies, and skill as a baker working at a literal Christmas tree farm mean she’s the authority on all things merry. So, when Bennie sees sparkles after bumping into the most stunning girl she’s ever seen in her small Connecticut town, her friends are all shocked that Bennie doesn’t seem to realize what this real holiday magic at work…and the perfect opportunity for her much-needed first kiss.
There’s just one her mystery girl, Eve, lives in Brooklyn and Bennie never got her number or her last name. But showing up unexpectedly to make a big romantic gesture is a classic holiday trope for a reason, right? And her friends aren’t about to miss the fireworks.
But what was supposed to be a quick Christmas adventure turns into a scramble across Brooklyn when the biggest snowstorm of the decade hits. Will Bennie and crew be able to track Eve down for a merrily ever after and still make it back for their last Cooper Farm Christmas Eve party, or is their holiday movie moment destined for the cutting room floor?
Bennie just wants two things: To get into film school so she can make queer holiday movies, and to get her first kiss. A chance encounter with a cute girl at the Christmas tree farm where Bennie works increases the chance of the latter...if she can just find the girl again. And what's Christmas if not a chance to take a road trip to NYC, attempt her first-ever documentary while she's at it, and get the girl?
I like a cute Christmas book, I like queer romance, and (if we're being honest here) I really like punny titles. And this was good fun—Bennie has a solid friend group, all with well-developed senses of adventure, and they get up to some good-natured minor chaos in NYC. (I also appreciated that this wasn't their first time in the city; they're still functionally tourists, but slightly less wide-eyed than they might be.)
Bennie's "documentary" plot felt a bit thin; she puts down her camera every time someone does or says something that doesn't fit with her view of Christmas magic, even if it's an objectively interesting moment (or if there's something more interesting to say than "look! magic!"). I did like the way her film school arc plays out—not unrealistic—but I was waiting and waiting for a moment when it would get through to her that she was going to have a hard time making her documentary if all she was filming was a montage of context-free happy moments, and that moment really never comes. (And...I know I'm old, but 27 uses of "ya know" is at least 25 uses too many.)
The romance is fine; I see what Bennie likes in Eve, though their romance is really based on vibes and fumes (could turn out great! Just, the entire book is kind of an extended meet-cute, so who knows how things would go once they actually got to spend real time with each other). In the end it's a cute, fast, fun holiday read, albeit probably one that won't stick with me.
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
Super cute sapphic holiday rom-com for a teen audience! Bennie is all about holiday spirit, but this year things are changing. Her friends have new things going on, her sister is back in rehab, and she is struggling with it. When she meets a cute girl from Brooklyn, she and her friends take a road trip to the city in hopes of tracking down said girl for Bennie's very first kiss. It's fun and heartfelt and a lot about friendship and adjusting to change and difficulty, not just about the romance. I definitely enjoyed it. I received a copy of this book for review from the publisher, all opinions are my own.
Bennie Bosley is basically Christmas personified. She works at her family’s Christmas tree farm, bakes, knows an alarming amount about holiday movies, believes in Christmas magic, and dreams of making queer Christmas rom coms someday.
And then she meets Eve. ✨ Instant spark . ✨ Mysterious girl. ✨ Potential first kiss. ✨ No last name. ✨ No phone number.
Bennie and her friends decide the only solution is to GO TO BROOKLYN AND FIND HER. The adventure with Bennie, Izaac, Cash, and Diya was SO much fun. Their friendship felt like the heart of the story and I loved watching them navigate that weird bittersweet period where you're still living inside all the traditions you've grown up with while realizing that everything is about to change. Graduation is coming. College plans are happening. Friendships are evolving. Families are complicated. And this might be their last Christmas exactly like this.🥹
Bennie is dealing with some heavier family stuff involving her sister's mental health and addiction recovery.
The romance with Eve was cute. It's about a first connection. A first kiss. A first real romantic possibility. It's about figuring out what you want while you're also figuring out who you're becoming.
Bennie does make some questionable choices in her quest to find Eve. Watching her learn that real life doesn't follow a screenplay was one of my favorite parts. Because the best moments aren't necessarily the perfectly scripted ones. They're the messy, unexpected, completely unscripted moments. And there are SO many fun ones in this book. 🎄 Christmas tree farm 🍪 Baking 🏙️ Brooklyn adventures ❄️ Snowstorm chaos 🎬 Holiday movie references 👯♀️ Best friend shenanigans 🌈 Sapphic romance 💋 First kiss nerves ✨ Christmas magic 🥹 Growing up and letting go
Pining for You was cute, funny, nostalgic, heartfelt, and ridiculously festive.🎄
This YA Sapphic romance is joyously chaotic with strong holiday vibes.
Bennie is all about the holiday season She works at a bakery at the Cooper Family Organic Farm, which sells Christmas trees. She and her friends have a Horrible Hallmark Movie Marathon and exchange ugly Christmas socks each year. They also reverse carol (knock on your door and demand a song.
Then Bennie meets cute with Eve at the farm, literally bumping into Eve and spilling hot apple cider (ofc) on her. Bennie becomes obsessed with Eve. So Bennie, with the help of her merry (and a bit manic) group of high school friends, tracks Eve all the way to Brooklyn, using the slimmest of clues. In a blizzard.
The positives of this book? The energy of Bennie and her merry group of BFFs. The love at first sight obsession, which is also a common teenage thing. The level of Christmas cheer.
The negatives, for me, were the sheer number of characters and the relentless feel of the story. I was more in the mood for a cozy story for a rainy day, and this book exhausted me a little. I’m a long way from being a teenager, so it could be that.
What happens when you combine Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist with Happiest Season?
Bennie loves Christmas and wants to make Hallmark movies after graduation, but first she needs to have a first kiss. Then she meets Eve briefly and what follows in a hilarious adventure into Brooklyn in search both a Christmas kiss, but also Christmas magic.
This book was so fun. I liked that buried within the comedy and shenanigan's of this group of friends were true trials each person was dealing with. It tackled that last holiday season before the friends and traditions you have had your whole life change. Everyone has a new plan for after high school and everyone has a different thing they are dealing with in pursuit of that new life.
Bennie's desire to stay present while the world churns around her is a compelling conflict that slowly gets more relevant as you learn about all the things she is dealing with.
**potential spoilers**
While the love story in this is cute and I enjoyed it, it is not the heart of this book. Its refreshing to read a YA rom com where you get the feeling that the two people could or could not work out in the long run. There is a earnestness about it. Its new and fresh. It gets to be vulnerable in the end, which feels more authentic then a declaration of love that seems to imply they will work forever.
Synopsis: 🎄❤️💚 Bennie Bosley is a Christmas-obsessed girl who works at her family’s Christmas tree farm and dreams of making queer holiday movies. When she meets Eve, a beautiful girl who sweeps her off her feet, she thinks she might finally get her own Christmas-movie moment. There’s just one problem: Eve lives in Brooklyn, and Bennie doesn’t even have her phone number! So, naturally, Bennie and her friends set off on a Christmas adventure to find her, complete with a snowstorm and plenty of holiday chaos.
My thoughts: 💭 I loved the cozy holiday-movie vibes this story brings! Between the friendships, romance, Christmas magic, and the adventure of chasing a little happily-ever-after, there’s plenty to enjoy. I also appreciated that the story had more going on beneath all the Christmas cheer, with themes of family, friendship, growing up, and figuring out what comes next.
A sweet, festive YA read that gives you a little taste of Christmas magic. Definitely a cute addition to my holiday reading list! ❤️
Thank you to the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review! All opinions are my own.
This was a cute little YA Christmas story. It follows Bennie, who works at a bakery located on a Christmas tree farm. She loves all things Christmas. After meeting the girl of her dreams, Bennie and her friend group try to track down the girl so Bennie can have her perfect first kiss.
First off, I loved Bennie’s Christmas cheer. She loved everything about Christmas and it was so relatable to me. She especially loved Dickens’ A Christmas Carol and there were a few fun references to that in the book as well. I also loved all the fun Christmas activities she came up with for her friends to do in the days and weeks leading up to Christmas.
This is set in small town Connecticut, and I loved the small town (and state!) rep. The little town was charming and the tree farm especially. It would be so fun to work there!
The friend group was fun and I liked that they always supported each other. This book is a little nostalgic at times as well, with Bennie realizing that this is their last Christmas together before college and whatnot.
The romance was fine. I actually really liked Eve as a character. However, Bennie came off as a little stalkerish to do everything that she did to find Eve, especially considering how little information she had to go on. I didn’t blame Eve at all for being mad when she found out the real reason that Bennie “just happened” to find her.
Still, this was a cute read with plenty of festive feels. 3.5 stars, rounded up.
Thank you to the publisher, Simon and Schuster Children’s Publishing, for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
A cozy Christmas rom com that reads like a sapphic Hallmark movie, the senior high schooler FMC, Bosley, instantly falls for Eva, a girl she meets just before Christmas at Bisley’s job at a Christmas tree farm. Unfortunately Eva works at a bakery in NYC. What follows is Bosley and her close knit group of friends going on a field trip to NYC to find the girl of her dreams. I received an eARC from Netgalley and the publishers; all opinions are my own.
Well, this one wasn’t for me and I am going to keep this short. I think some will like this holiday romance but for me it had way too much going on in the way of storylines and characters. While I finished it I had such a hard time staying engaged. But I thank Simon and Schuster for the complementary eARC to read ahead of publication via NetGalley,
Thank you to NetGalley for an advance copy of this title which released September 4. I normally reserve one star ratings for books I do not finish. I DID finish this book - solely because it was provided as an advance copy and I felt obligated. Otherwise I would not have finished. This book was cheesy and overly simplistic. There was potential for character growth and for the main character to deal with big issues, but she didn’t. Instead mountains were made out of molehills with a ridiculous plot and random characters who could have been interesting, but were sidelined. I would like to say I would be interested I. further titles exploring all the other characters but I cannot even say that. I suppose if you like a cheesy romance à la hallmark channel (and I realize it is somewhat marketed that way) this MAY be worth your time. Maybe I read this at the wrong time in my life but I cannot recommend this one at all
Thank you Simon & Schuster for Young Readers and NetGalley for the advanced copy. I really wanted to enjoy this holiday story, but it didn’t hit a high note for me. The only moment where I was elated was during trivia (no spoilers!), but otherwise it fell flat. I think it’s the writing style overall for me.. there were a lot of characters with a lot of storylines & it felt like the author was trying to make it a holiday read by throwing in a classic holiday song, catchphrase, or movie etc. every other paragraph. 2.75 ⭐️
The writing style of this did not vibe with me and I dnf'd because the author mentioned the girl looking up how much rehab costs using a chatbot?! Now I understand that the author might not even be referring to ai however it makes me feel icky and she could have easily just found rehab websites to find the cost.
Bennie has watched enough holiday movies that somewhere along the way she became convinced grand romantic gestures are a perfectly reasonable substitute for basic communication. She bumps into one gorgeous girl, sees literal sparkles, doesn't get a phone number, doesn't get a last name, and somehow lands on, "Guess we're going to Brooklyn." I was sitting there thinking... this is either going to end in true love or a restraining order, and honestly I wasn't sure which.
The funniest part is that nobody in her life pumps the brakes. These friends are the definition of "I support women's rights, but more importantly I support women's deeply questionable decisions." Instead of saying, "Maybe wait until fate gives you another chance," they basically grab their coats and go, "Road trip!" Everybody deserves friends this loyal. Everybody also deserves at least one friend who occasionally says, "Girl... let's think this through."
Bennie is aggressively Christmas. Not regular Christmas. She works at a bakery on a Christmas tree farm. She knows every holiday movie trope. She can apparently solve emotional problems with baked goods and the perfect gift. If Santa needed someone to cover his shift, she'd already have her apron on before he finished asking. Her entire personality runs on peppermint and optimism, and honestly, it was kind of impossible not to root for her even while she was making choices that made me quietly cover my face.
Then poor Eve enters this situation having absolutely no idea she's become the center of someone's Hallmark-inspired scavenger hunt. I actually liked her because she reacted like an actual human being instead of instantly accepting, "Oh yes, of course you tracked me across state lines because destiny." The romance works best when they're simply talking to each other instead of destiny trying to throw glitter at every conversation.
The trip through Brooklyn during a massive snowstorm felt exactly like watching people who have committed too hard to a plan to admit maybe the plan was a little ridiculous. Every time I thought, "Surely this is where they'll give up," someone found a fresh burst of holiday spirit and kept marching through the snow like Christmas itself had issued marching orders. I had to respect the commitment even while laughing at it.
Underneath all the peppermint chaos, there's this quiet sadness hanging over everything because Bennie and her friends know this is probably their last Christmas before life scatters them in different directions. That landed harder than I expected. One minute they're chasing a girl through New York because romance has completely overridden common sense, and the next you're remembering what it felt like when growing up suddenly stopped being something that happened someday and started happening right now.
By the end I realized I'd stopped worrying about whether Bennie would get her movie-worthy kiss and started hoping this friend group could somehow bottle this exact version of themselves before adulthood got its hands on them. They're messy, supportive, dramatic, occasionally fueled by spectacularly bad ideas, and somehow that's exactly why they work.
This ended up being a cozy little holiday read that had me smiling more than swooning, and that's perfectly fine. I had fun hanging out with these lovable weirdos, even if I spent a good chunk of the book wanting to hand Bennie a piece of paper that simply said, "Get. Her. Phone. Number." Solid 3 stars from me.
Merry Mayhem Prize: For Treating "I Met a Cute Girl Once" Like a Full-Time Christmas Mission
And thank you to Simon & Schuster Children's Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC. I arrived expecting hot chocolate and mistletoe, and somehow ended up following a holiday search party powered entirely by baked goods, friendship, and Hallmark-level confidence.
Book: Pining for You Author: Stef Ferrari Rating: 4 Out of 5 Stars
I would like to thank the publisher, Simon and Schuster Books for Young Readers, for sending me an ARC. Yes, I am fully aware that it is August and I am reviewing a Christmas story. However, I am a firm believer in reading what makes you happy, and Christmas stories put me in a good mood. Is this one perfect? No. Did I have a great time with it? Yes, I did.
Bennie Bosley knows everything there is to know about Christmas. She works at her family's Christmas tree farm, has a talent for baking, can quote holiday movies, and seems to have a gift for finding the perfect present for everyone. What she does not have is much experience with romance. That changes when Bennie meets Eve, a beautiful girl who seems to appear straight out of one of Bennie's favourite holiday movies. There is just one problem. Eve lives in Brooklyn, and Bennie never gets her last name or even her phone number. Convinced that making a grand romantic gesture is exactly what a Christmas movie heroine would do, Bennie heads to the city with her friends to find the girl who has captured her heart. Their holiday adventure quickly becomes more complicated when a massive snowstorm hits Brooklyn. With Christmas Eve approaching and Bennie's family's final holiday celebration at the tree farm waiting for her back home, Bennie and her friends race across the city in search of Eve. If everything goes according to plan, Bennie might get her holiday movie ending. If not, her perfect Christmas adventure could end in disaster.
This is a YA Christmas romance about love at first sight and missed chances. Bennie has always wanted that first kiss to be magical and on Christmas. After all, she lives and breathes Christmas. In fact, it’s what she wants to do with her life. She wants to make holiday films. She quickly finds herself in her real life when she and friends decide to take off to New York to find Eve. It’s a wild ride full of adventure, family, and a bit of romance. It’s quirky, out there, and just plain fun. That’s how I would describe this book. It’s fun, and sometimes you just need a fun read in your life.
Now, this does not mean that it is all fun. Bennie is dealing with an absent mother and a sister who is battling addiction and mental illness. She is trying to figure out her university goals, while trying to hold onto Christmas traditions and magic. She’s trying to relive the past where everything was the same, but life doesn’t work like that. She’s struggling with it. She’s clinging to it because she is hurting and is afraid of what the future may hold. It also ends up taking away from the magic of the season. Because she keeps trying to hold onto the past, she doesn’t see what is right in front of her. She doesn’t see the new traditions and the new things that life has to offer. It actually ends up causing her to miss out on what is in front of her. She has to learn that, unlike a movie, life is not scripted and that it is those unscripted moments that make life amazing.
Now, the writing is okay. It does come across as a bit childish at times, but I felt like it added to Bennie’s voice. She is a teenager, and the writing is very much teenage. There were times that I felt like it could have been better, but most of the time, I thought it worked. There is a lot of slang and a lot of cultural references. I don’t mind this in books, but there were times that I thought it was a bit over the top. Yet, there were times that I found it to be rather enjoyable.
For the most part, I did enjoy this holiday romance. It was just a fun read, and sometimes you need that in your life.
Pining for You by Stef Ferrari is a charming, festive YA romance that captures Christmas spirit, friendship, family, and a dash of holiday chaos. It offers all the elements of a classic Hallmark Christmas film but with a delightful, queer twist.
Bennie Bosley adores Christmas. She works on a Christmas tree farm, enjoys baking and holiday movies, and dreams of creating her own queer Christmas rom-coms. When she unexpectedly meets Eve and feels an instant connection, Bennie believes she's finally experiencing her own Christmas-movie moment. However, Eve leaves for Brooklyn before Bennie can get her number. What ensues is a journey with Bennie and her friends as they try to find Eve, facing a major snowstorm and their resolve to reach home for their traditional Christmas Eve celebration.
I really enjoyed the friendship among Bennie, Diya, Cash, and Izaac in this book. Their bond adds depth and warmth to the story. While they support one another, they also face the inevitable change that graduation brings, signaling a new chapter in their lives. This makes the story more than just Bennie's quest for love; it explores themes of growing up, evolving friendships, family challenges, and understanding that real life rarely aligns with the idealized endings seen in movies.
I also liked that the book openly addresses more serious topics. Bennie navigates complex emotions related to her older sister's bipolar disorder and addiction recovery, while Eve manages her own family responsibilities. These heavier moments add depth to the characters and help balance the otherwise cheerful Christmas atmosphere.
The relationship between Bennie and Eve is charming and suitable for their age. I enjoyed seeing Bennie's view of the "perfect" romantic moment evolve as she realizes that real relationships are not like scripted holiday movies. The story is filled with Christmas references, traditions, baking, snow, and holiday-movie moments. However, at times, there seemed to be an excess of Christmas references. I also questioned some of Bennie's choices while she was searching for Eve, even though I understood they aligned with her desire to make a grand romantic gesture.
Still, Pining for You is charming, warm, and easy to read. I particularly appreciated that beneath the Christmas festivities, it tells a story about embracing change and understanding that loved ones can matter more than achieving a flawless moment.
I suggest this for readers who love YA romance, LGBTQ+ stories, found family, close-knit friend groups, Christmas movies, holiday adventures, and cozy romances with heartfelt moments.
Overall, Pining for You delivered the cozy Christmas atmosphere I was seeking while providing more depth than anticipated. It was amusing, emotional, inclusive, and filled with festive spirit. If you enjoy Hallmark Christmas movies but wish they showcased more diversity, this book is certainly a great addition to your holiday reading list.
Thanks to Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers and NetGalley for offering an advance copy of Pining for You; I appreciate the opportunity and share my honest opinion. All views are my own.
🎄 Tropes & Vibes 🎄 Christmas tree farm ❄️ Snowstorm adventure 🌈 Sapphic romance 💘 Love at first sight 👯 Close-knit friend group 🗽 Brooklyn adventure 🎓 High school seniors / coming of age 🎬 Hallmark Christmas movie vibes 🍪 Baking ✨ Christmas magic 💋 First kiss 🥹 Growing up & changing friendships 🌶️ 0 peppers
💚 What I Liked I really enjoyed the Christmas atmosphere in this one. Between the Christmas tree farm, baking, snowstorm, holiday traditions, and Bennie's absolute love of everything Christmas, it definitely delivered those festive vibes. 🎄
I also really liked the friendship aspect of the story. Bennie's friend group and their chaotic adventure ended up being more interesting to me than the romance itself. I especially liked the underlying theme of being in your senior year and realizing that friendships, traditions, and life in general are about to change. There were also some heavier family topics mixed into the story that gave it more depth than I initially expected.
💔 What Didn't Work for Me Unfortunately, I never completely connected with Bennie or the story. There were a lot of characters and individual storylines to keep track of, which made everything feel a little too busy for me. At times, I felt like I was bouncing between so many different things that I couldn't become fully invested in any one storyline.
The writing style also wasn't quite for me. I normally don't mind YA at my age, but this one felt particularly young, and some of Bennie's choices and the overall chaotic energy were harder for me to connect with.
I also expected a little more from the romance. The entire adventure begins because Bennie is determined to find Eve after their very brief meeting, but the romance itself ultimately felt more like a subplot than the heart of the book. I ended up being much more interested in Bennie's friendships and the group's impending graduation than whether she actually found the girl.
✨ Overall Review Pining for You had all the ingredients for an adorable holiday read—Christmas tree farm vibes, baking, a snowstorm, a chaotic trip to Brooklyn, a close-knit friend group, and a sweet sapphic romance. 🎄❄️
There were definitely things I enjoyed, especially the festive atmosphere, friendships, and the bittersweet coming-of-age element of realizing this could be the last Christmas where everything feels the way it always has.
Unfortunately, the combination of so many characters and storylines, the writing style, and the very YA feel kept me from completely connecting with it. I also went in expecting the romance to play a larger role and found myself much more invested in the friendship dynamics instead.
Overall, this was a cute and festive read with tons of Christmas spirit and some surprisingly meaningful themes about friendship, family, and growing up. It wasn't quite the holiday romance I was hoping for, but I can see it working really well for readers who enjoy very YA, chaotic holiday adventures with strong friendship themes and a sweet sapphic romantic subplot.
I'm still not entirely sure how I feel about this book. Bennie is a high school senior who works at...some sort of Christmas tree-type emporium in Connecticut. She encounters Eve, who lives in Brooklyn, and she and her friends decide to go into the city to try to find her so Bennie can capitalize on Christmas magic and have her first kiss.
That description makes it sound a lot lighter than it is. Bennie and her friends are pretty much all dealing with fairly weighty issues--as is Eve. It's pretty much all family issues, but Bennie and her friends are also facing down the end of high school and all of the change that comes with that. It's a hard, transitional time of life, to be sure. But that's all heavier than the Hallmark Christmas movie description makes it out to be.
The story itself is pretty cute, and I enjoyed Bennie's group of friends and how much they were there for each other. (I didn't need as much explicit "We're a found family, yay!" exposition as there was, but this is YA, so I should probably give it a pass.) Bennie herself could be a bit annoying at times, though in a way that was fairly realistic for a teenager from Connecticut. She wants to go to film school and so keeps recording on a Camcorder as the group traipses about New York, but doesn't realize that not everyone wants to be recorded and is hurt when she's told so. I could also very much relate to her frustration at not being able to participate in a number of her normal Christmas traditions--because this is a Hallmark-esque story (Bennie's goal is to make queer Christmas rom-coms), Bennie is all about the magic of Christmas, and throughout the book has to confront that not everything is magical, that Christmas can be hard for people. She also finds Christmas magic in unexpected places and moments, so it does even out.
Also, Bennie and Eve's relationship is great (though the third act crisis seemed...off). As someone who also had my first kiss later than many others (though my friends were never this invested in making sure I got it), I could relate to Bennie's feelings about it.
Unfortunately, I wasn't particularly enamored of Ferrari's writing; I'm not sure whether it was trying to sound Zoomer or what, but it was a bit cringe-inducing to me, a Xennial. At times, it was a bit of a slog, oddly enough, and there were chunks I wound up skipping--particularly at the end, where there was a multi-page speech spelling out the lessons of the book. Good for Bennie for learning them, and I guess theoretically young people reading the book might need them spelled out, but it felt a bit like it was underestimating the audience.
Still, would 100% watch the tv movie adaptation.
Thank you to Simon and Schuster Children’s Publishing for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
It was obvious from the author's dedication and acknowledgements that this book was a labor of love, but unfortunately, that made it even more clear that this book was more gratifying to write than it was to read. The MC, Bennie, is a high school senior who thinks and acts more like a middle schooler, while her friends all come across as true young adults, even a little older than their stated ages. The obsession with Christmas "magic" (a word that gets used constantly in the book) comes off as childish and more than a little unhealthy, rather than quirky. I appreciated all the queer representation and how the author touched on some serious topics like mental illness, addiction, parental death, and divorce, but the fact that all of these things were in the book meant that it lacked focus and ended up being utterly too long.
The writing was also a big reason I ended up skimming a lot of chapters, as Bennie's internal monologue was tedious, and the language (presumably meant to be Gen Alpha slang) came off as very "Hello, fellow kids!" and not very authentic. That said, I'm an adult reading this YA, so perhaps things felt more cringe for that reason, but I have to wonder if teen audiences will appreciate the language. There were other turns of phrase that were overused, such as references to chestnuts roasting over an open fire, and the constant references to people as "humans." The pacing was also really off, with an out-of-left-field 3rd act breakup, and the rushed resolution of a bunch of the conflicts that were building up throughout the book. Overall, this book should have been a joy to read, but instead it was a slog. Again, it truly came through that the author loved writing this book, but that enthusiasm might have tainted an otherwise promising premise.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers for the opportunity to read this ARC and share my honest feedback!
I wasn't sure how I felt about this book for the first 5-15% and I am so glad I stuck along for the ride. While the book takes a second to get into its pacing, it ultimately a book I very much enjoyed. This story tackles so many topics and at the end I did feel like I was experiencing what life would like through the eyes of someone who went through the things that Bennie has gone through.
I very much loved the found family aspect of this story, and how sometimes even when we think we are showing up for our friends it might not be in the way they actually need or want. Sometimes it's hard for us to communicate with one another and sometimes we are doing our best just to get by. Bennie is full of Chistmas magic and cheer on the outside, yet inside she is struggling to hold onto her belief of magic. When her friends encourage her to go on a mission to find the girl she connected with to get her first kiss at Christmas we are taken on a whirlwind trip filled with some amazing moments.
I did not expect to cry as much as I did reading this story, at the end of the day they were good tears and good emotions to feel and I think it speaks to how well the author ultimately pull you into the story that I had such a strong reaction. No lie I think I cried through the last 15% of the book, sometimes sad tears and other times good tears.
If you want a Christmas story with heart, love, and lessons I recommend this one. It was a very pleasant surprise! Thank you to the publisher for providing an advanced readers copy via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Pining for You is exactly the kind of feel-good holiday romance I want when I'm looking for something sweet, charming, and full of Christmas magic.
Bennie Bosley is absolutely adorable. She knows everything there is to know about Christmas movies, has a talent for baking, works on a Christmas tree farm, and apparently has a little holiday magic working in her favor. When she meets the mysterious Eve and immediately feels that spark, Bennie decides to follow her heart and embark on a very Hallmark-worthy adventure to find her.
What I loved most was the cozy atmosphere. The Christmas tree farm, holiday traditions, baking, snow, and small-town setting create such a warm backdrop. Then the story takes Bennie and her friends into Brooklyn, turning the whole thing into a fun holiday chase filled with snowstorm chaos and romantic possibilities.
Bennie's enthusiasm and optimism made her easy to root for, and the story has that wonderfully cheesy holiday-movie quality without taking itself too seriously. I also enjoyed the friendship between Bennie and her crew. Having friends willing to jump into a potentially ridiculous romantic adventure makes the whole journey even more fun.
This is a sweet YA romance with plenty of holiday spirit, LGBTQ+ representation, friendship, and a little bit of Christmas magic. It definitely gave me the warm-and-fuzzy feelings I was looking for.
A charming holiday read that's perfect for curling up with a blanket, a cup of something warm, and maybe a Christmas movie playing in the background.
“Pining for You” was an amusing, heartwarming and romantic story. I enjoyed the friendship between Bennie, Izaac, Cash, and Diya. I also enjoyed the interactions between Bennie and Eve. Bennie loves Christmas and the magic of the season. And her professional goal is to make Christmas rom-coms with queer characters/themes. But various stressors in her life and the lives of her friends, as well as pending changes as three of them approach the end of high school, have dimmed the magic somewhat and disrupted the Christmas traditions. However, a meet cute with Eve at the Christmas tree farm where she works, and her hopes of getting her first kiss at Christmas will result in her and her friends taking an impromptu trip to Brooklyn to find Eve. The trip will not be without its mishaps, and Bennie will see more negativity than she would prefer. However, she will also learn what issues have been bothering her friends and see some positive developments regarding some of those issues. And she will get helpful advice for coping with her own family situation. More significantly, she will also see plenty of evidence of the true Christmas spirit.
There are many great moments in the book — the meet cute; tamales; drag queens and polka, etc. However, Hugo answering the winning trivia question is the most beautiful moment of the story; once you read the story and understand Hugo’s background and situation, I think you will agree. Though Bennie’s first kiss was pretty special too.
This book had all the ingredients for a heartfelt romance, but unfortunately, it never quite came together for me.
The story started with plenty of promise. The instant connection between the main characters had me intrigued, and I was ready to see where their journey would lead. When Bernie literally travels to another city to track down the girl she believes could be "the one," I expected a deeper exploration of that devotion, along with the emotional payoff that comes with such a grand gesture.
Instead, the story felt surface-level and rushed. There were several opportunities to build tension, develop the relationship, and create meaningful character growth, but those moments never fully materialized. I kept waiting for the plot to dig deeper, and it just never happened.
My biggest frustration was Bernie. Throughout the book, she constantly went back and forth about their traditions and what she wanted for her future. On one hand, she was determined to find her girl and pursue this relationship, but on the other, she seemed unable to commit to her own choices. The repeated indecision became exhausting rather than compelling, making it difficult for me to stay invested in her character arc.
Overall, Pining for You wasn't a terrible read, but it felt like a story with a lot of untapped potential. The premise had me hooked, but the execution left me wanting much more from both the romance and the characters.
Pining for you was a really cute YA holiday story but I could not figure out some of the dynamics with these being high school kids. Several of them just don’t come home and it’s not a big deal and their parents don’t notice. We follow Bennie, who works in a bakery at a Christmas tree farm and literally crashes into who she declares “the girl of her dreams” and is then obsessed with tracking her down and having her perfect first kiss moment. This would have been cute if they did not have this one fifteen minute interaction and it wasn’t built up to be a made in the stars idea. They’re 17 and it all just felt a little off.
The entire issue with Bennies sister could have had significantly more depth but it was very glossed over and yet we got a dozen pages on tamales. While the friend could was great and well fleshed out, I think we missed a lot of opportunities to learn more about why Bennie loves the holiday season so much and why the traditions she’s trying to keep with her friend group are so important to her.
Overall, this one was a miss for me but was cute enough. 2.5 rounded up.
Pining for you will be published September 8, 2026 and I received an advanced copy from Netgalley and the publishers in exchange for this review.
Thank you to Simon & Schuster Children’s Publishing for the gifted ebook. All opinions are my own. (I paired it with the audio from my library. 🫶)
Such a great YA Holiday Novel with a cute little sapphic romance guiding it along the way.
I personally wouldn’t classify this one as a “Romance” book, as the romance itself felt more like a side plot? Whereas I felt the MC, Bennie, spent most of her time on adventures with her friends, while trying to *find* her potential love interest (and thinking about the future). BUT, I still thought it was a very enjoyable, holiday-vibe read.
The NYC adventures with her friends were definitely a big highlight for me. Great side characters, and so many *things* going on with all of them as they grow closer and closer to adulthood/graduation.
The holiday vibes were strong, with a Christmas Tree Farm, snow, present shopping, and a super fun trivia game.
There were also some really emotional bits, especially having to do with Bennie’s feelings regarding her older sister. (TW for mental illness/drug abuse). I thought these tougher bits were handled with care, and thought it was done well for the YA subset of readers.
Overall, a great little YA read, perfect for the Holiday season.
Audiobook notes: Sarah Beth Goer was so good! With the voices and perfectly encapsulating everything Bennie was feeling and going through. Will definitely be on the lookout for more from her!
What this book is giving: ✅ YA Queer Holiday Novel ✅ Single POV ✅ High School Senior ✅ Planning for the future ✅ Childhood Friend Group ✅ Christmas Magic ✅ Sapphic Romantic Subplot
Thank you to NetGalley & the publisher for the ARC!
I'll be honest, this one didn't grab me right away, but it grew on me.
Fair warning: this has a very specific YA voice: the writing style is basically Gen Z talking out loud on the page. If that's not your thing, this probably won't convert you.
The plot is inspired by Christmas rom coms, and it tells you so, both in the summary and throughout the book, so you already know the shape of where it's headed. Bennie is basically Buddy the Elf. This did annoy me at first tbh. But it grew on me.
Bennie's friend group all felt like real, distinct people rather than accessories orbiting the main character, which is such a relief in this genre. The diversity also felt baked in rather than a checklist.
A Christmas book publish date in September is a choice, but honestly? Nice little preview of what's coming down the pike in a few months. The Brooklyn-in-Christmas atmosphere delivered exactly what I wanted from it.
TLDR: slow starter, but the friend group and the holiday chaos won me over. Recommend if you don't mind a heavy dose of Gen Z voice.
Thank you to Simon Teen for the advance reader copy. These are my opinions.
Pining for You is an interesting coming-of-age story. I can't really classify it as a romance, despite its marketing. It's primarily focused on just one main character, Bennie Bosley. As Christmas approaches, she is hoping for a perfect first kiss during the holiday and wants to become a filmmaker of Hallmark-style Christmas movies featuring queer main characters.
The book highlights her struggles with the upcoming end of high school and separation from friends. There is a strong Christmas element, but I found it more than a little sad. It seemed to regularly zoom in on the ways in which Christmas is not really magical. The overall tone was quite heavy, especially as we learn that Bennie's sister is in rehab for a second time.
We barely see Bennie interact with her love interest, Eve. Instead, Bennie and her friends go on a trip to try to find Eve when Bennie fails to get her contact information.
So this was definitely not the queer holiday rom-com I was expecting. But there were some lovely queer found family moments.
I wanted to love this so much, but Bennie was a little TOO “wheee, Christmas!!!” for me. The fact that she expects everyone to drop everything for her Christmas plans annoyed me, and I’m not even the person that’s expected to go along with her whole schedule! I’m afraid that this passed my tolerance for cheese threshold. She’s so determined for things only to be Christmas magical that her documentary ends up not being interesting at all.
I also didn’t really love that we’re going to do a desperate road trip to find the cute girl again. Girl. Please. That’s called stalking.
I also had a difficult time following the characters and storylines. It felt a little crowded while not having quite enough substance. There was a lot going on, but every time there was a chance for depth or real emotion, it was missed. I so badly wanted some character growth or reflection that would have softened the cheesiness and made it have just a little bit more meaning.
I appreciate so much that this is a queer YA holiday romance book. I hope there are many more! I just found this one a little too cheesy and a little too simplistic for my personal taste.
Bennie believes in Christmas magic. So much so that she wants to go to Hollywood and create the perfect holiday movie. But then she meets Eve. Their meeting is quick and fleeting but the lasting impression left on Bennie leaves her wanting to find Eve again and to create a holiday documentary proving that the magic of Christmas is real. This is such a beautiful story one that shows that life is fluid. Sometimes things have to change in order for things to get better. Change can be hard, but it doesn’t always mean that it is the end. In fact, sometimes taking a risk can lead you to changing someone’s life. The only thing that I will say is that finding Eve does seem to stretch out and I wanted maybe a bit more interaction between her and Bennie. However, I loved all the characters you meet along the way and their stories. Thank you so much to Simon and Schuster and Netgalley for allowing me to read an advance copy of this title.
This was a quick and lighthearted read that definitely felt like a (sapphic) Hallmark holiday movie. It captured small town vibes, a cozy holiday atmosphere, and good friendships.
Was the romance plot line a bit dramatic and unrealistic, yes, but again it lived up to the expectations of a Hallmark meet-cute fall fast enough to travel after the girl who changed your life in the best way.
It was a cute read with lovable characters. There was a diverse cast of characters and I really liked seeing the adventure of the friend group in New York searching for Eve.
(Note: I received this copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Thank you to Simon Teen for the opportunity!)
POV: First Person Spice Level: n/a Sad Level: 💧💧 Would I Recommend? Yes Favorite Character(s): Izaac Emojis Based on Vibes: 🗽🎄📸