I want to be the person I was when I had such a fun time with book one last month, because this volume annoyed me so bad.
I was excited to get into this one because book 1 was ridiculous, but fun. This one just irritated me and the thing is it's probably not that different from book one?? The pacing just felt really stilted like it jumped to new scenes with no flow. The sex scenes kind of made me uncomfortable because I had this feeling of dread the whole time. I was so worried someone specifically a child was going to walk in on them and he almost does!! I really didn't like that. I don't mind an element of vouyerism/exhibitionism, but in this it just gave me the absolute ick, because I just kept thinking of the children or relatives running around.
They also tried to expand on the lore a little more, but it was frankly just too jumbled. I feel like there were too many parts with the two new characters, one being a researcher who may expose them and one being a child with dead/missing parents, the mystery of the island's history, and Avel wanting to have kids. It was too much in my silly book. I wish I liked this more, but I just felt so uncomfortable and annoyed the whole time.
This volume had more it wanted to tell which made the pacing and narrative a bit messy. We have two new characters, some new lore, explaining existing lore, and not even of their kids!!! I was really looking forward them having a bunch of kiddos but it was a very small part of the story. I do like the potential someday spinoff! That could be very sweet. I did like both of the new characters well, they were interesting.
The art is lovely just like the first volume. 4/6 stars
I received this book from the publisher in exchange of an honest review.
I absolutely LOVED the first book (which was HIGH on my list of books I seriously needed in my life and I was already considering getting the German translation) and so I was super duper excited to see the second book/the sequel on Edelweiss!
But… but.. this one just didn’t work for me entirely. The addition of that biologist who is just a bit too eager to discover things and is constantly butting in? NAH. I disliked that guy from the start and I wanted him out of the story so badly. I could live with Enoha especially since Avel and Tukiri wanted a kid anyway and Enoha was a cutie who needed a new family. But I just wasn’t into the biologist. Sure, he did get better, but he felt like such an obvious plot device added to help along the plot. Whereas all I wanted was just more Tukiri and Avel and see them build their family. I just wanted to see my favourite couple and how they are doing now.
And we did also get it but they had to be so secretive about it now with a little one running around and a biologist dude popping up at the most bad moments. Still, I was happy to see my couple again and see that they were still doing well and looking forward to celebrating their first year anniversary together. They are so cute together and I loved seeing Avel take a bit more action, he is supposed to be the bottom, but he is not letting that stop him from cough doing some extra activities and expressing his hunger.
While I wish the lore had been shown without that biologist, I did enjoy the lore and I love seeing some more of the world, a lot of things make sense. The blood drinking, the gender switching (though again outwardly they stay male). I loved that Avel was able to discover a new side to himself, something that I am sure will make the romance between him and Tukiri even more special.
And Enoha was such a cutie. I felt for the poor little one, lost his parents, all alone. I loved how he attached himself to Avel and Tukiri (or well, mostly Avel as he tried biting Tukiri, haha, though maybe it is out of love?). I loved how he got more and more used to life at this new place and made friends (and maybe even more given the ending, teehee).
The ending was such a sweet one and I loved that one the most of the whole book, haha. Congrats to Tukiri and Avel!
I was at least happy that we didn’t get glowsticks like the last time, haha. This time we got full penises and all that.
All in all, I am disappointed in this one. I just had expected a bit more romance/more sexy times. More how are they doing now and less OMG LORE (which is nice, but not entirely want I wanted, haha). I am still happy I got the chance to read this one though, thank you to the publisher. Oh, and given the afterword, please author give me all those side stories!
So if you read this with the same level of disbelief suspended as volume 1 and then just accept the mythology/ancestral lore for how the island came to be as good enough, but most importantly ignore the danger Dylan represents as impending invasion of colonialism, I think this is just as enjoyable.
I chose to intentionally just read it for the art, fluff and ridiculous premise so I’m choosing to give it 4 stars BUT I feel it’s worth noting that I was disappointed in introduction of an outsider like Dylan that really was unnecessary to the storyline that was handled so flippantly/halfassed. We have the patriarchs acknowledging the danger the outside world has and wanting to keep things secret and the two MCs naively thinking what’s the harm to share everything when they first meet him (because the patriarchs decided generations ago to not keep their villages fully informed on their history and raised on half truths and unexplained rituals) and then in the end when they learn the risks they say “I guess you have to live here forever” and Dylan says “cool” and that’s apparently the end?! It’s silly because I’ll happily suspend my belief on people shifting into sharks but ask me to suspend my belief that some outsider raised on colonial world views of “discovery = extraction and convert” would be satisfied to never tell anyone of their “discovery” and just happily live their life “trapped” on the island because they were simple told they had to, and I’m having a hard time staying in the fantasy. At least spend sometime forcing the issue for him or figurative tying his hands on the matter because at this point I still think he will try to send his notes “home” one day. And it’s not that “deep” of a story so I wish they never even introduced him since it wasn’t dealt with well.
Again if things like that don’t bother you I think this is still good. I just think it could have been so much better with very little work.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I loved both Avel and Tukiri. Loved seeing their marriage and how stinky cute they were together. Then Enoha their foster child and Dylan the crazy uncle. Such an amazing little family.
The while rivalry was so anticlimactic. I thought it would be a huge deal but it wasn’t. Tho the story of the black and white sharks was cute!
Loved seeing their children and then Enoha as an almost adult. I hope we get more of this author and world.
I do have a complain tho, whoever printed the physical manga what the fuck were you doing when sizing the font? It was so hard to read!!! Such a small font.
This was such a good sequel!! I was expecting it to be mostly just fluff and married coital bliss, but we got more backstory and some really interesting plot twists, AND more family growth 😍 couldn’t ask for a better second volume. I love Tukiri & Avel 🥹 (and I adore Enoha!)
While the title does feel misleading, I still enjoyed this addition to the series. I found the lore behind the two tribes to be very interesting. However, the yin compared to the yang form is freaking stupid! Make it a full on rather than a tiny appendage.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Wenn man bemerkt dass man die Fortsetzung vor dem ersten Band gelesen hat,ergibt das Wirrwarr auch einen Sinn 🤭 Hat mich gut unterhalten und war wunderbar spicy.
Such a good volume! At first I was thinking the outsider was going to bring more problems/drama then anything, but instead he helped with the plot. I was also worried that there was going to be a part where Avel closes himself off or pushes Tukiri away- luckily that is not the case. Their relationship is still sweet and you can tell they genuinely care for each other. Plus, we learn the secret of the two tribes in this volume. Like volume one, it does have it's spicy moments.