Sharing a college campus with my infuriating stepbrother should be easy. Until he crosses a line with me, and we’re pulled into a twisted, chaotic game.
Noah is straight. Preppy. Rich as sin. Everything I’m not. When I catch my stepbrother rifling through my belongings like a stalker, it sparks something inside me I can’t shake. Let the frat boy stalk me a little. I’m going to stalk him right back. One night, the mutual hatred sparks between us. We collide, and he gets a taste of me he can’t quit.
What we’re doing is bad. Wrong. …Completely consuming. But I witness something I shouldn’t one night when Noah is attacked by a violent man. When a stranger lays a hand on my new obsession, I explode.
Protecting him is my salvation. Now we’ve crossed a line forever, and there’s no chance I’m losing this game.
No one can hurt him. Mafia ties run deep in Onyx Society, and we’ve stepped on the wrong rival’s shoes. Noah is broken. Vulnerable. I see the sea of emotion behind his perfect exterior. He claims he still despises me, even when we’re close. But with his life under threat, I risk everything to defend what’s mine.
When he says I’m crazy, I say: I am. And you are, too.
Because I know we’ll both do whatever it takes to win this forbidden game.
“Kiss me or I’ll fucking die,” 4.5 ✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️ Every time I start a new book in this series, I tell myself, “okay, there is absolutely no way the next couple is gonna surprise me more than the last one… or that I’m gonna love them more.” And somehow, every single time, I end up completely wrong😭😭😭😭😭 I’m sorry Hunter and West, but Tori??? No one is holding a candle to that man for me. I’m OBSESSED with him. Like deeply, unhealthily obsesseeeeeeed. I loved every single part of this book. It wasn’t even about it being the greatest romance ever written or anything like that. It just simply gave me everything I wanted and then kept giving me more and more and more and more. I cried with them (when literally nothing that heartbreaking even happened 🤧🤧🤧 I was just overwhelmed with emotions the entire time. I couldn’t hold my tears back at all. I just love them so much and seeing them happy together made me ridiculously emotional for no reason...). And I laughed so hard so many times. I was stressed, annoyed, scared, happy - I felt EVERYTHING. And that’s what made this hit so hard for me. I cared so deeply about these characters and when a book manages to make me feel that attached, it’s over for me. And this one felt different from the other books somehow ... in a reallllllly really good way. I can’t even fully explain it. Maybe it was the vibes, the emotions, or just the dynamic between them 🤭🤭🤭 orrr how much I related to Noah 🥹🥹🥹🥹, but something about this story stood out so much instead of feeling repetitive. The push and pull between them??? The back and forth??? The way they talked to each other while being so mean and yet so ridiculously funny at the same time??? 😭😭😭😭😭 I can’t remember the last time a romance made me laugh this hard 😂😭😂😭😂😭. I’m so attached to these characters at this point that I never want this series to end. PLEASE do not let Roman’s story be the last one because I’m already upset just thinking about it 🙃🙃. And I’m SO excited for the next book. I feel like it’s one of the most anticipated books in the series for me — and YES, I say that every single time but this one feels different 👀👀👀👀 I just know Roman’s story is gonna have me foaming at the mouth 🤭, losing my mind🫠, and going completely feral in the best way possible😛😛😛😛😛😛 ...And that I’m gonna get even more attached than I already am.
I really liked Noah and Torin together. Their animosity felt real and the way their relationship progressed was really fun to read. I loved how they were so gone for each other! Torin's protective streak entertained me, especially when he couldn't figure out why he was doing it, and Noah trying to coach himself to not fall in love was adorable.
I also loved how Torin was so supportive of Noah's dream and that he was so invested in it that he was helping with the plans. I do wish though that we'd gotten to see their family's reaction to them being together and to Noah's future plans.
The mafia plot was interesting and put Roman into the story more, which definitely has me intrigued for his story coming up next!
***** I received an ARC of this book from The Author Agency, and this is my honest review
Tropes: animosity to love, step brothers, roommates, forced proximity, rich/poor Feels: 2.5/5 Steam*: 2.25/5 Kinks: domination/submission, choking and breath play, rough sex, primal play, exhibitionism Angst: low HEA: HEA Pairing: MM Triggers/potential icks/content warnings/representation: past alcohol dependence, past death of a family member, violence, attempted abduction/murder of MC, unsupportive father Cheating between MCs: No Any cheating: No Other person drama: they've known each other for years, so they've both been hooking up with other people since they've known each other. Once they start hooking up they aren't really interested in others, though Noah considers hooking up with an ex fling.
3.5 stars
Noah and Torin are in college. They've known each other for a few years, because their parents started dating and got married. They do not get along. Noah thinks that Torin is putting on an act and trying to usurp his place, trying to be the perfect son and make Noah look bad by comparison. And Torin thinks that Noah is looking down on him, and he hates Noah because he's rich and has had an easy life. Torin comes from a poor single parent family, Noah comes from a very rich family. Torin has a real chip on his shoulder about wealthy people, he thinks they are horrible humans, which is true for a lot of wealthy people, but that's not who Noah is. Torin is bisexual, Noah has always identified as straight.
It's summer, and they are both doing classes at the college during the summer. Torin moves in to Noah's frat house / secret society house for the summer. And they are forced to confront their animosity, and learn a little bit more about who each other is as a person. Noah's life gets threatened, he's being stalked and someone's trying to take him out. Torin gets protective and they get physical.
Noah has been struggling with alcohol dependence, and has turned over a new leaf, giving up alcohol and hooking up, because he actually wants a real committed relationship and he's sick of people thinking that he is just his reputation, and that he's not a good risk relationship wise. Noah's also struggling with feeling directionless in life, because Torin is good at everything he does, and Noah doesn't even have a major yet and he's well on his way through college. Noah has a dream though of running a cafe and having a bookstore, but his rich daddy laughed at that idea, because it's not profitable enough in his eyes.
This book was good on a bunch of levels. The characters were complex. The animosity and sexual tension was palpable. And the physical stuff between them was heated. And there was a lot going on with the plot, so points for that.
There were a few things that I didn't like about this book though:
- Noah and Torin didn't come out as a couple during the book to their parents, and I feel that was a big moment that should have been addressed. And Noah should have talked to his dad about his career ambitions, and resolved the plot line about him being a constant disappointment to his dad and his dad disapproving of him. It was such a big part of Noah's character arc and it just felt left dangling.
- Noah was someone that really wanted a relationship for years. And when he did have girlfriends, he was an incredibly clingy, touchy-feely boyfriend. And I felt like it was a waste that we didn't get to see him be that gone for Torin. Seeing them being clingy, touch starved, craving even platonic touching would have been so good and it would have made more sense for Noah.
- My biggest problem with the book, was that Noah fell in love / got crushes so easy and so often. I think it is really telling my point for me to quote something Noah said at 95%! "“Torin, if you’re worried that I’m catching feelings for you, just forget about it,” he says, stating every word carefully, like he’s afraid to say too much. “I’ve gotten about a thousand crushes in my life, and they always pass.”" This shouldn't have been where Noah's head was at 95%, and I honestly believe Noah... I feel like this characteristic of Noah falling for anyone is too much of a pattern in Noah's life and there wasn't anything that changed that made Torin that different to Noah. I don't believe that Noah has deep feelings for Torin. It's hard to believe given he's fallen for so many other people that Torin is anything special to him. To me, Torin is just the first one that actually liked him back and gave him the kind of sex he wanted. I feel like Noah should have addressed his problematic behavior of falling so often/fast and why he was doing it, so that when he fell for Torin that it would be believable and real.
Some notable moments:
"My heart pounds hard in my chest as I skate my palm down his back, squeezing his ass cheek. What the hell is this? Why does the singular sight of watching my cock disappear inside Noah strike me as one of the hottest things I’ve ever seen in my life? My thoughts are swirling about the future already, in an inconvenient way. Because I’m going to need this again."
"“Do you want to get punched right now?” He glares at me, but right now his attempt at malice looks more like sad puppy dog eyes. I loosen my grip on his wrist. “If you look this good while you do it, maybe.”"
*FYI about steam: I rate steam based on a combination of quality & quantity. I note kink separate from steam because I don't want to underrate steamy reads that don't have much kink.
**Note about spoilers: I like to comment on the plot of a book in reviews, so I almost always mark my reviews as containing spoilers. But I try to avoid spoiling the big dramatic moments! As a reader, I personally like to know what I'm getting into before I read a book so I know more about the content and if it's to my taste/mood, so I try to give that information in my reviews for myself when I'm considering rereading and also for other readers.
I couldn't/didn't put this book down. Read in one go and loved it. Raleigh Ruebins has the exact recipe to make delicious books for this series. Loved it.
4.5 ⭐️ “Kiss me or I’ll fucking die, he murmurs” “He’s just holding my hand. Because he feels like it”
LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVEEEEEEEEE TORIN AND NOAH!!!!!
I read this is 48 hours and I swear to the universe, I could have read this in less than a day if life didn’t get in the way. These books are CRACK! Every single book gets better and better, leaving you wanting more and more. Stepbrothers enemies to lovers? It was done so well. I can’t really explain it, but their love was so subtle. Yes they were obsessed with each other in a quiet way, and couldn’t get enough of each other once they crossed that line to sex, but actually falling in love? It’s like they were both trying to deny themselves but couldn’t. Amazing read!!!
"What I want, deep down, is the kind of spark that leads to all-out obsession. That leads to needing each other so bad it swallows us whole, and wrecks us in the best way. I’ve never had that kind of love, but I have to believe it exists. I want something so real it consumes me."
Forbidden Little Game is book 4 in Raleigh Ruebins' Crimson College series and it features one of my favourite tropes - enemies to lovers/stepbrothers. Whilst it can be read as a standalone, I would definitely suggest you read the series in order to fully appreciate the overarching storylines and cameo appearances.
This is Noah and Torin's story.
What To Expect:
🖤MM romance 🖤Dark themes 🖤Elite college environment 🖤Enemies to lovers 🖤Mine 🖤Stepbrothers 🖤Found family 🖤Bi-awakening 🖤Spicy first times 🖤HEA
I really enjoyed this 4th installment in the Crimson but in this book we see exactly how he is and where his self worth is. I felt bad for him when I saw how disposable he felt. Torin is now his stepbrother and has moved to Crimson College/Onyx house for the summer. There has always been animosity between them, so Torin arrives ready to annoy Noah. The tension between them was really good and downright delicious! I loved how protective Torin was while also helping Noah himself in a better light and encouraging him to follow his dreams. I loved how they both payed attention to what the other liked and enjoyed. I loved Noah's neediness and I also loved how much Torin enjoyed that neediness. We got the usual danger plot line which was a bit over the top, but still fun to read. We also got to see the Onyx House crew, which is always fun.
If you're in the mood for a fun step brothers to lovers story with a bit of danger and very protective main character then this is the book for you.
3.25⭐️ Noah is completely unimpressed that his new stepbrother Torin will be joining him at Crimson College. The two don’t get along, and Noah isn’t excited about it. But when Noah’s life is in danger, Torin makes it his mission to ensure Noah’s safety. And some wires definitely get crossed.
In this book, you can expect: -animosity-filled stepbrothers -dark college romance -protective and possessive MC
Yet again, I feel like my review for this book is going to be almost exactly the same as it has been for the previous three books. This book has a bunch of spice and is very much a serotonin inducing, fun kind of book. However, I still can’t say that this was a GOOD book.
I definitely feel like after reading the past four books that the books in the series are very similar in terms of characters, themes, and writing style, of course. Every book also has the line “like Pavlov’s dog” in it also for some reason?
Anyways, I read this entire series because I accidentally signed up to ARC read book 5, without realizing that it was book 5 in a series. Lucky for me, these books are definitely Bingeable and I do stand by that.
I love how action packed, angsty, and spicy these books are. The whole series has kept me hooked on what fucked up stuff will happen with these broody frat boys. I really enjoyed watching Noah's character develop from careless party boy to someone trying to get his life straight. His obsession with Torin getting turned back around on him was fun and all the drama with Roman and his mafia ties kept things exciting. I can't wait for more, these books are delicious!
I honestly have exactly zero complaints about this book 🥰 I devoured it in a day and I honestly loved everything about it.
First things first - the chemistry 🥵 I can be quite a sceptic about whether the MMCs actually have the sparks flying between them, but here I had no doubts. The spice was spicing, and I loved how the intimacy scenes were drawn out so deliciously 🤤 Chef’s kiss 🤌 The constant push and pull, “hate” - love only made it all better)
“I never know if he’s going to lunge at me and hurt me or melt against my body in need, and I like that.”
And then of course, Torin and Noah, so different but so charismatic and lovable in their own ways. Noah, my adorable precious baby, with his heart on his sleeve, so vulnerable with his feelings 🥺 And Torin, protective, obsessive and controlling, but so caring 😻 They were really perfect for each other 💗
“God, how long is it going to feel like this?” I ask. “This feeling, like my heart’s too big for my chest?” “Don’t know. But I’ll be here for as long as it takes to find out.”
An important thing for me here was the fact that while we do have a subplot running along, it remained a SUBplot, never overwhelming the relationship storyline. And what’s even more important, while we do have “mafia” here, it was moderately ridiculous 🤭
I also appreciated how Raleigh refrained from all the unnecessary drama that usually comes in stepbrother / straight guy trope. There was literally no judgement, or doubts, or denials - everything unfolded so naturally between Noah and Torin, with such care and acceptance 💗
A very comforting, low angst story with a perfect length and charming MMCs, an easy 5 stars for me 💙
Thank you very much to Raleigh Ruebins and TAA for this ARC 🫶
This was promising, but I’m utterly disappointed. They spent way too much time at each other’s throats, and then suddenly they kiss, fuck, and somehow fall hard and fast for each other. I fail to understand how any of that happened. It happened so instantly it gave me whiplash.
I know they have history, and typically with tropes like this, when the hatred the MMCs have for each other turns out to be sexual tension, fully falling for each other is gradual. It doesn’t just happen.
Now, I’m not expecting every book with this trope to be the same, obviously. But I want depth. I hate when books do this, like where are you rushing to? This book had quite a good number of pages; they just weren’t utilized well.
And with this series, I’ve never cared for the mystery/secret society storyline. It’s just never done it for me. The writing has always felt lazy to me, and I don’t even mean to sound like a hater because I do like these books.
I wouldn’t keep reading them if I didn’t. Duh.
That aside, are you trying to tell me Noah and Torin love each other? Yeah, I could believe that, but as I said, this moved way too fast for my liking, and I hated that. How do you go from hating each other to being in love because you touched each other like twice?
Sorry. Nah uh. 😐
Now I need Roman’s book. I’ve needed it since he was first introduced. His character is an enigma. Roman takes care of everyone but who takes care of Roman? Gimme his book NOWW!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Okay so we have stepbrothers who hate each other… but apparently all you need to turn hate into lust is one near-death experience and a massive adrenaline rush.
Torin slowly realizes he had Noah completely wrong, because underneath the reckless party-boy act Noah is actually soft and caring.
Their relationship development was honestly done really well. They were genuinely sweet together with just enough toxicity to keep it entertaining (I love a little mess, sue me).
The mafia/mystery plotline felt weaker to me though. I never fully understood why Noah became the target instead of Roman or the rest of his family. And why was it such a huge deal for Noah to do a pickup job for Roman’s family if he wasn’t even previously involved in their business?
I also really wish we’d gotten a proper coming-out scene with the family, because it felt like an important moment that was just skipped over.
I don’t know why everyone has rated this book so highly. it was garbage, literally slop that i wouldn’t recommend to anyone lol. Before i start I’m going to give it the slightest benefit of the doubt because i haven’t read the previous books, but if i need to read the previous books to get even a semblance of context about EVERYTHING, then it should be warned in advance.
i had many problems with it but my biggest one was i could not STAND Torin, he’s full of shit, his whole “i hate rich people” bs was so aggravating because there was no depth to it, he just sounded like an insecure loser. Him hating Noah off the bat because he THOUGHT Noah was snobby and looking down at him was so???? The book details that they have known each other for years and yet Torin never got the suspicion that his bias and prejudice towards Noah was a result of his judgemental attitude? and then the possessiveness came out of nowhere, it felt like whiplash and even up until the end i couldn’t form a connection with him at all. In addition to this, during the shower scene at the hotel before they even had an established sexual relationship (not that it would make it any better), torin mentions that he chose the first option of choking noah rather than raping him??? i genuinely do not like him. I started getting irritated because i was shipping Noah with Roman instead. - also i was expecting a talk with parents or siblings or anything but that just didn’t happen
Another thing i found that was irritating was the constant topic of Noah’s alcoholism and use of sex as an escape was so surface level it was repetitive, from context clues — his alcoholism stemmed from being the black sheep of the family, but there was very little exploration with that and his hyper sexuality, granted i didn’t know what to expect from such a short book, but a little exploration into his struggles and reasons would have been nice and even though i hate him, a deeper exploration into torins character would’ve been nice and maybe made him easier to digest.
Lastly. maybe again because i haven’t read the previous books, the whole Noah being hunted thing was so stupidly bad i actually thought it was a big joke, there were so many plot holes and missed out details that it felt like i was reading two different types of books. It felt poorly thought out and just put in to create the shift that lead to the whole obsessive possessive bullshit and to mix in with the secret society mess.
overall this book is a fat mess, i liked Noah but really didn’t feel a connection in their relationship at allllllll i was so bored i started skimming (which i hate because if im going to hate i have to hate to my full potential) but i genuinely could not read any longer it was just messy, sloppy, rushed bs.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
4.25 stars. Torin is sooo perfect, ugh, Noah despises his stepbrother. Noah is coming from the insane rich side of the two of them. Torin only sees a spoiled, drunken party brat in him. Torin entering his space at Crimson College and even living in the same house isn’t what Noah was waiting for.
When Noah’s life is in danger, Torin is the one who protects him.
The enemies-to-lovers parts didn’t last long, it was simmering. Instead, something much hotter was boiling. They are getting to know a version of the other they didn’t know about. I can’t tell much without spoiling, so I keep it at this.
What I can tell is that the kisses they share are hot. When they get further physically, it’s getting even hotter. The visuals are really well executed, I saw them clearly before my eyes, so intimate, I could feel what they feel, and my goodness that was a lot, there are so many overwhelming feelings. The protection and action parts were marvelously done. The character development was enough. I loved that the family parts were far in the background. The focus was on Torin and Noah, the darker side of the story, and the students/friends part. All well balanced, so I enjoyed this one!
Stepbrothers Forbidden Forced proximity Secret society
Crimson College Book 4
Great Book!! Fast paced but slow burn which It was ok! I really enjoyed the story it was good but I really wish it was longer, I really wanted to know more about the entire step bro situation outside the college, will they ever tell their parents? How are they going to react..? will Noah follow his dreams ??
I’m intrigued about the next book tho, hopefully we get some answers or at least snippets of it
Loved that even when is the 4th in the series I could totally understand and enjoy my reading so definitely a plus !
Thank you, the author agency and Raleigh for an opportunity to read this arc. This is my honest Review
I read it two days ago, but I’ve forgotten alot of what happened, so I’ll try make this as concise as possible. Noah was very agitating at times with his internal thoughts and came off as a petulant child with a silver spoon. While he does end up falling for Torin, the process in which that happened was furiously annoying. I liked Torin a little more, but I wasn’t able to get a personality from him, aside from being Noah’s protector.
The two’s relationship together had enough tension to slice paper on its own, and the sex was enjoyable to read. There wasn’t much wrong with the story (if I remember correctly) I just wasn’t able to connect with the characters as I hoped I would, given I liked the previous books in the series.
Another great addition to this series. Torin and Noah had wonderful chemistry. The tension between these two was perfect. The fact that they were reluctant stepbrothers made it all the more enjoyable. We got to see how the other couples were as well. I am really enjoy this world that Raleigh Ruebins has created. Each books has been a fun, spicy with a little intrigue and has been easy read for me. I look forward to the next in the series.
“Because it’s going to make me fall for you.” My heart drops, like I’m jumping from a plane. “Then fall,” I tell him. “Because I’m falling with you.”
This book was fun. It wasn't my favorite of the series but i did really enjoy the relationship between Noah and Torin. I loved the "enemies" to lovers aspect, i loved their banter and i loved the moments where they get together and just really get to know each other outside of their personal biases. I wish the whole side plot with Roman was touched on a bit more because it did kinda feel like it was happening in the background and i wanted more of it but overall this book was fun and i can't wait to see what comes next for the crimson boys.
reading this as the last book of the series has made me want to read the prior books , i’m so happy to be given the opportunity to read this arc it was amazing
Noah and Torin were oil and water, fire and ice, hating and avoiding each other for 4 years as their parents had a working relationship, then a romance, and finally a marriage, making the two stepbrothers, a situation neither welcomed. For four years each had harbored resentment for the other, believing the misconceptions each had in their head about the other. Torin believed Noah to be a spoiled rich kid, in college but spending much of his time drinking and sleeping around, aimless without a direction of what he wanted to do or be when he graduated. Noah’s reputation preceded him on campus, even though he had recently left that behind him, trying to change, but Torin didn’t know that. Noah believed Torin was this guy who had skills and could do everything, had a killer body constantly showing off without his shirt, and with a personal mission to do charitable work and save the environment and the people in it. Torin would attend all of his father’s charitable functions, and was this confident, had-it-together person which Noah could not compete with nor ever be. Even so, there was a connection between them that was a constant push-pull, a challenge to meet and one up each other, never really stopping long enough to see the real person underneath.
Things came to a head in the weeks after the wedding when Torin ended up on Noah’s university campus, living in his frat house while taking summer classes. Noah tried to ignore him, but Torin enjoyed setting Noah off, so they were constantly crossing paths, bristling as they did, but unable to stay away. But when Noah’s safety was threatened, Torin’s mission changed to one of protection, stalking Noah on campus, keeping him in sight as much as possible. And Noah found he felt safe in Torin’s presence, something totally unexpected. Something else unexpected was the physical attraction and the pull between them to be with each other, leading to an intimacy that they knew shouldn’t happen but were helpless to deny. As the danger to Noah increased, the one safe constant was each other and the connection between them, but a connection neither was sure would be temporary or something longer lasting. But since we know they will get a HEA, they do work it out as they head into their last year at school.
I found both characters to be realistic and relatable, and I liked the dual point of view to see their actions, read their texts, and hear their thoughts as they navigated this enemies to lovers dynamic. I was surprised at Noah’s reaction to Torin and their physical intimacy, no angst at all on his side as he accepted an unknown part about himself. Torin’s protectiveness of Noah seemed so out of character to me initially, but the more I learned about both characters, the more sense it made. I also liked the support and thoughtfulness Torin showed to a desire Noah shared with him, one which had been crushed by laughter in the past. It really showed Torin’s commitment to Noah and his dreams as a part of the love and care he had for Noah. For starting out as I guy I didn’t like much at the beginning, Torin really grew on me, becoming equal with the liking I had for Noah’s character, and having them get together was a perfect ending for me.
I enjoyed the supporting characters in the house, was glad that Bree was out of the picture, and was unsure about Roman’s part at times. I didn’t know if he was protective of Noah, had more than friend feelings, or even was someone Noah shouldn’t trust at one point, but was glad he really was who he seemed to be. I also liked the acceptance from his housemates and the clarity some of them had had about the relationship changes between Noah and Torin. I want to go back to read the two books in the series I haven’t read yet, and look forward to Roman’s book next. I received an advance reader copy for free and this is my voluntary review.
Here's "Forbidden Little Game" by Raleigh Reubins. It's the fourth novel in the Crimson College series.
["Sharing a college campus with my infuriating stepbrother should be easy. Until he crosses a line with me, and we’re pulled into a twisted, chaotic game.
Noah is straight. Preppy. Rich as sin. Everything I’m not. When I catch my stepbrother rifling through my belongings like a stalker, it sparks something inside me I can’t shake. Let the frat boy stalk me a little. I’m going to stalk him right back. One night, the mutual hatred sparks between us. We collide, and he gets a taste of me he can’t quit.
What we’re doing is bad. Wrong. …Completely consuming. But I witness something I shouldn’t one night when Noah is attacked by a violent man. When a stranger lays a hand on my new obsession, I explode.
Protecting him is my salvation. Now we’ve crossed a line forever, and there’s no chance I’m losing this game.
No one can hurt him. Mafia ties run deep in Onyx Society, and we’ve stepped on the wrong rival’s shoes. Noah is broken. Vulnerable. I see the sea of emotion behind his perfect exterior. He claims he still despises me, even when we’re close. But with his life under threat, I risk everything to defend what’s mine.
When he says I’m crazy, I say: I am. And you are, too.
Because I know we’ll both do whatever it takes to win this forbidden game."]
I put this one off for a while. Even though I'm a sucker for the stepbrother trope.
These two were aggravating. In a good way. They didn't like each other (understatement), but they didn't truly know each other. They didn't realize how deep their real feelings went, even as they really started to change, because...well, they're men. And they had a lot going on. And they were worried about their image and their future and how the other was feeling.
But they were sooo good for each other. They listened, they talked (eventually), they supported each other. They kept each other happy (mostly) and safe (mostly). But they held each other. They held each other through the hard times and through the soft times.
Trigger Warnings: past alcohol dependence, past death of a family member, violence, threats, stalking, classism at its (not) finest, guns, and more.
Stepbrothers, enemies to lovers, forced proximity and one very protective hero. I devoured this in a single evening. It’s my favorite of the Crimson College series so far, and I already know these two are going to stay with me.
Noah has been around the Crimson College series for a while, and here he finally gets his own story. He’s trying to keep his life clean and steady, and then his new stepbrother Torin moves into the same house at Onyx. Torin sees a spoiled, privileged party brat. Noah sees an intruder. That dislike simmers for about a minute before it turns into something much hotter, and when Noah gets tangled up in dangerous mafia business, Torin steps in to protect him.
The chemistry is electric from the start, but what really got me was watching that fierce physical pull turn into something tender and protective. It feels earned.
Torin completely swept me off my feet. His unwavering devotion, his need to protect Noah, cherish him and give him more than he ever thought he wanted, was so moving. And Noah is impossible not to love. He’s sincere, vulnerable and open-hearted, and that makes him unforgettable.
The dual POV works really well too. Both voices are distinct, so every interaction feels real and alive.
I also loved how the intimacy is handled. The spice is scorching, but it’s always balanced with tenderness and care, so the romance never gets lost in the explicit scenes. Their emotional journey felt authentic and hit me right in the feelings without being cheap or exhausting.
The external plot was thinner, though. The threat to Noah’s safety felt a bit like a convenient way to bring out Torin’s protective side, and I was left wondering why Noah was targeted in the first place. I also wanted a few more pages after the climax: an honest talk with their parents about the relationship, and Torin supporting Noah as he takes his next big step into the future. And I missed the Onyx Society brotherhood from the previous books. Here, the characters mostly appeared in brief cameos rather than feeling like a close-knit group.
None of that took away from how much I loved this book. The pacing, the passion and the emotional depth made it the kind of comforting, electric read I wish I could stay inside forever.
An easy five stars for me. I’ll be revisiting Torin and Noah very soon.
I absolutely devoured this latest addition to the Crimson College series and honestly… Noah and Torin had me hooked from the very first chapter.
The real stars of this book though - the chemistry and tension. These two are stepbrothers who act like they’d rather throw each other off a roof than admit they’re obsessed with one another, and the tension is DELICIOUS. Every interaction felt like it could end in screaming, kissing, or a full emotional breakdown, and honestly I was living for all three possibilities.
Noah has been chaos wrapped in designer clothes since book one, so finally getting inside his head and seeing what actually drives him was so satisfying. Watching him slowly unpack his toxic behaviour and make an actual effort to be better gave his character way more depth than I expected — and somehow made him even more attractive. Annoying, really. We find that out that underneath all that arrogance he’s painfully insecure and constantly trying to live up to impossible family expectations. Torin seeing through that act little by little was exactly the kind of emotional torture I signed up for.
Meanwhile, Torin is responsible, level-headed, and genuinely cares about helping people, which makes him hilariously out of place in Noah’s chaotic frat house. The two of them are constantly butting heads, and just when things couldn’t get any messier, the anonymous threats against Noah start escalating. Torin going full protective mode - Noah realising someone actually cares about him beyond the surface level. The more time they spend together, the more impossible it becomes for either of them to stay away.
The tension between them was immediate, intense, and genuinely addictive. I flew through this book in a day because every chapter ended with me needing to know whether they were about to fight, kiss, or emotionally destroy each other.
Even though I still think book 3 is the strongest in the series, I had a really good time with Forbidden Little Game. It didn’t hit the same as “Reckless,” but it kept me invested.
Noah has been an interesting character since book 1, so I was happy to finally get to know more about him, his motivations, and see him grow, confront some of his toxic past habits, and make an effort to be better. It gave his arc more depth and made his story more engaging.
Torin, on the other hand, didn’t work for me nearly as well. I wanted to connect with him more than I did, but something about his storyline felt all over the place, and because of that, I never fully clicked with his POV. He wasn’t a bad character, but compared to Noah, he just didn’t feel as emotionally compelling to me.
I do have to say, I like the stepbrothers trope and it works here. The relationship feels believable enough within the world of the story, and the chemistry between them is very strong. There is a lot of tension, and the spicy scenes were probably some of the strongest parts of the book. That’s something this author does really well across the whole series.
My main issue is something I’ve felt with the previous books too: there’s just so much going on around the main story that it starts to feel noisy. There are a lot of side threads, extra conflicts, and little plot points fighting for attention, but not all of them feel fully developed or properly tied up by the end. Because of that, the central emotional arc loses some impact, and the book ends up feeling a little incomplete. The pacing was also an issue for me. A lot of it dragged in the middle, and then suddenly the last quarter picked up fast, which made the ending feel kind of rushed.
Overall, this was still an enjoyable read for me. If you’ve already been following the series, I think there’s a good chance you’ll have fun with this one too, especially if you are curious about Noah. It has some flaws, and I wish the plot had been tighter and a little more focused, but the character work, the chemistry, and the spice are nice enough to make it a fun read. Not my favorite in the series, but still a solid follow-up.
MY OPINION: I haven’t read any of the other books in this series, but the tropes here interested me enough to pick it up. There is some interaction and reference to the other books, but the story is not dependent on the prior books. As a Raleigh Ruebins fan, I was looking forward to what this book would bring. I was not disappointed.
There are a few great tropes that had me sold before I even started. Stepbrothers, enemies, hurt/comfort, golden retriever. These are all put in a blender, and you end up with this book. There is a good amount of angst, but it came in the form of them figuring things out together. The problem was that they found the best way for them to work through the hate was in the bedroom.
Finding feelings under the spice was something neither was prepared for, and they were convinced the other wouldn’t be interested. Noah is changing his life, trying to be better, and Torin is already going in the right direction. Not to mention they are step-brothers.
To be clear, they didn’t grow up together; they were seniors in high school when their parents met. The parents got married after both men were about to start their senior year in college. There was push and pull throughout the book, and it ended with them falling hard. It takes a bit for them to figure it out, but they get there. I wish I knew how it ends up a little more, but sometimes that's how it goes. In my head, they fulfill those dreams they shared.
Now this is framed as a mafia romance, so there is a bit of an underlying story there, and we find ourselves seeing how much Trion really cares for Noah. He is protective. The love story doesn’t get lost in the drama. The spice is right there on that line of really explicit and naughty. There is one steamy hot scene, though, that makes you sweat a little.
Overall, I enjoyed the book a lot. The characters are interesting, the friends are great, and the romance is hot. I would go back to read the other three most likely. We are left with a happily ever after, and we don’t think of them as brothers, that’s for sure.
ARC Review of Forbidden Little Game Book 4 in the Crimson College Series by Raleigh Ruebins. This book is part of an interconnected series but can be read as a full standalone. I love this book. It is definitely a 5 star read for me. I was hooked from the first page I didn’t want to put this book down. I loved all the suspense. I also love all the guys in Onyx and how they are a big family and always there for each other. This is Torin and Noah’s story. I love all the tension and back and forth between them. I love how territorial and protective Torin is over Noah even when he claims he doesn’t like him. This is a spicy, slow burn, MM, stepbrothers, forbidden, forced proximity, touch him and die, roommates, enemies to lovers, secret society, dark college romance. Noah attends Crimson College and is a member of Onyx Society, one of the three secret societies on campus. It’s the summer before Noah’s senior year and he’s staying on campus taking summer classes. Torin is taking summer classes at Crimson College as well and staying at Onyx Society for the summer. Torin volunteers with a bunch of different charities and is very skilled at woodworking. Torin's mom and Noah’s dad just got married and now they are stepbrothers but they can’t stand each other. They are completely different. Noah thinks Torin is an egotistical attention seeker and Torin thinks Noah is a spoiled rich kid who only wants to party. When Noah finds himself in danger Torin protects him. The tension between them boils over and they hook up. Noah is a hopeless romantic and wants to find his soulmate, while Torin only does casual hook ups he doesn’t want a relationship ever. Torin can’t fight the pull he feels towards Noah, he makes him feel and want things he hasn’t before. I love seeing Torin and Noah go from hating each other to hooking up to actually getting to know each other and finding some common ground. I love how Torin supports and encourages Noah’s dreams. I loved how protective Torin is over Noah he won’t let anyone hurt him. I absolutely loved this book and definitely recommend it.
Okay, so every single time I read another book in this series, I always think there’s no way it could possibly top the previous one — and yet here I am, saying that this was by far my absolute favorite so far. Even though this book completely sucked me in, I unfortunately couldn’t make as much progress with it as I wanted to because life got in the way… and not just a little.
I genuinely think Noah and Torin are the kind of people who were made for each other. The chemistry between them was insanely good, and every time they shared a scene, I kept wondering how it would end: were they going to kiss, passionately throw themselves at each other, or maybe kill each other? Okay, maybe not the murder part, but honestly, I would’ve taken all the rest :D
I loved every single moment of this book — watching the walls around them slowly come down and seeing them finally let each other in was everything.
Now let’s talk a little about the two main characters:
Noah is the definition of designer-clothed chaos — the classic playboy type — and it was so satisfying to finally get inside his head and discover the depth behind his character, which, let’s be honest, only made him even more attractive. And of course, the way Torin saw right through the act Noah put on to hide his insecurities and his constant struggle to live up to impossible family expectations added so much to both of their characters.
Meanwhile, Torin is responsible, grounded, and genuinely wants to help people, which makes him stand out quite a bit compared to the members of Noah’s frat house.
If I had to describe this book in just a few words, I’d say I loved every second of it, even if I had to read it much more slowly than I would’ve liked.
If you enjoy books like this, then this one was written for you.
And thank you for the opportunity to read an ARC copy of this book.