New York Times best-selling author Michael Dobbs reconstructs the thrilling inside story of the climactic nuclear crisis of the Cold War, revealing the tension between “the human in the loop” and the algorithms that could trigger World War III.
The year is 1983. Ronald Reagan is obsessed by biblical prophecies of Armageddon. A computer revolution is changing everything—from the way we track incoming ballistic missiles to how we share and consume information. And then, over just three months, a series of dramatic events encapsulates the president’s worst nightmares.
In rapid succession, a South Korean airliner is shot down over the Soviet Union after straying off course because of pilot-computer miscommunication. A glitchy Soviet early warning system mistakenly reports an incoming U.S. missile attack. The Kremlin puts its nuclear forces on high alert in response to a routine NATO nuclear release exercise. Reagan deploys missiles capable of destroying the Kremlin in six minutes from their launch positions in West Germany. Soviet nuclear submarines are stationed off Cape Hatteras, ready to obliterate the White House in the same amount of time.
“Six minutes to decide how to respond to a blip on a radar scope and decide whether to unleash Armageddon!” Reagan recalled many years later, in a little-noticed passage in his memoirs. “How could anyone apply reason at a time like that?”
In The Six Minute War, the former Moscow bureau chief for The Washington Post explores the challenge confronting fallible human leaders responding to ever-shrinking warning times of a nuclear attack. A nail-biting narrative of the Cold War crisis that heralded the fall of the Soviet Union, The Six Minute War poses an existential Can we trust the machines at such life-or-death moments—or will we be destroyed by our own technological hubris?
To distinguish myself from all the "presidential historians" out there, I have invented a new area of expertise: "presidential crisis historian." How a president confronts the gravest challenges of modern times, and how his decisions affect the rest of us, has been a recurring theme of my seven books.
One Minute to Midnight focused on possibly the gravest crisis ever, in October 1962, when John F. Kennedy stepped back from the nuclear brink at the last possible moment. The Unwanted looked at Franklin Roosevelt's handling of the Jewish refugee crisis that preceded the Holocaust. Six Months in 1945 examined how FDR and Truman negotiated the perilous transition from World War to Cold War. My latest book, King Richard: An American Tragedy, relates the Shakespearean tale of the self-made man who scrambled his way to the top only to see his dreams turn to nightmares because of tragic character flaws.
Before becoming an author, I was a journalist and foreign correspondent. After a stint in Rome as a correspondent for Reuters, and a tour of Africa, I lived in Yugoslavia during the twilight years of Marshal Tito. I moved to Poland for The Washington Post just in time to witness the extraordinary spectacle of workers rebelling against the "workers' state." I was the first western reporter to visit the Lenin shipyard in Gdansk in August 1980. As The Post's bureau chief in Moscow, I was standing in front of Boris Yeltsin in August 1991 when he climbed on a tank to face down Communist hardliners. In between these two events, I covered the imposition of martial law in Poland, the Chernobyl nuclear catastrophe, Gorbachev-Reagan summits, the Tiananmen uprising in China, and the 1989 revolution in Romania.
In addition to my work as a journalist and a historian, I have taught courses at the universities of Princeton, Michigan, and Georgetown, as well as American University. I also spent seven years at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum where I organized conferences on the genocides in Rwanda and Bosnia, and researched and wrote The Unwanted. King Richard is my seventh book.
A thoughtful, intelligent, and astute account of one of the most harrowing (and now generally forgotten) periods in history. In 1983 a confluence of events brought the world to the brink of nuclear war. A South Korean flight was shot down by the Soviet Union who were convinced it was an American surveillance plane that had encroached on their air space. The anti-Communist rhetoric coming from Washington -- particularly the Reagan White House -- was becoming more and more strident. In a political expression of Newton's Third Law of Motion (for every action in nature, there is an equal and opposite reaction) the Soviet Union became more and more convinced that a first strike attack was imminent. Both sides distrusted each other, both sides had very different understandings of what was happening. Early warning systems were generating false alarms of incoming missile attacks. Communication between the two countries was fraught at best. Large scale war games in Europe went ahead as planned. Hobbs captures in terrifying detail what was happening and why: the misunderstandings, locked-inane mistaken assumptions about motive, the beliefs some on both sides had that a nuclear war could be contained and "won," the simple errors that might easily have led to nuclear war. On top of it all, the movie "War Games" and the TV series "The Day After" captured millions of viewers.
More than a clearly written history of a not-so-recent past, "The Six Minute War" is an urgent and necessary alarm. When the nuclear age began the US alone had the bomb. Then the Soviet Union began to develop its own arsenal. The Cuban Missile Crisis took 13 days to be resolved, time that grew out of how long it took for weapons to be prepared and delivered, as well as memories of World War Two being recent enough in peoples' minds. In a short time the amount of time it took to deliver a nuclear strike grew shorter and shorter until what began as days or hours became minutes. Officials on both sides might believe -- rightly or wrongly, based on technological errors -- that they were under attack and had mere minutes to decide whether the attack was real, whether to launch and at how many targets.
In the past, Dobbs shows, a single individual on both sides -- in the "field," not at the highest levels -- had to make a decision about what was happening and what to do. We are now at the point where Artificial Intelligence will likely be integrated into the warning systems and perhaps even the decisions themselves. The events described in "Six Minute War" must be known and understood if we hope to prevent accidental nuclear war.
My thanks to Simon & Schuster and Edelweis+ for providing a digital ARC in return for an honest review.
Entertaining and page-turning read that rehashes the mishaps, espionage and foreign policy of the U.S and Soviet Union (not Russia) during the Cold War, leading up to Operation RYaN's defining event of 1983. The author’s calculated use of diaries and key primary sources gives a personal and immediate look of the key players, from Reagan and Andropov to those surrounding them. DNK Suzanne Massie, the wife of esteemed historian Robert Massie, had a fact-finding mission or that Rainer Rupp was the spy for East Germany during the ‘83 NATO exercises.
The organization is a bit disjointed at times, with the author hopping periods and perspectives (characters and countries) or dwelling too long IMO (KAL 007). And the conclusions seem overdetermined to a degree, with the author inserting himself into the events as well as marshalling his own sources. Were the leaders as one-dimensional as presented? Is leadership a performance art? Were we as close to Armageddon as given? Is AI the final slippery slope? Perhaps or perhaps not but the questions are worth asking regardless.
Some fact checks or typos that need addressing. Jimmy Carter never commanded a nuclear submarine, Mrs. Massie did not divorce her husband until 1990, and the Reagan-Gorbachev Red Square Walk took place in May 1988 not 1989 given in the photo caption. About those photos: a nice selection. Also, a good bibliography.
A solid 4 stars. A compelling, comprehensive, and engaging Cold War entry. Would read again. Looking forward to reading some of Mr. Dobbs’ other works.