What do you think?
Rate this book
Spellstruck
Not yet published
Expected 29 Sep 26From beloved author Martha Waters, a lightly magical, enemies-to-lovers rom-com about the owner of a speakeasy supplying magical drinks and an enforcer of the ban on magic who must team up when potions begin to go awry, proving that chemistry isn’t just for cocktails.
In an alternate version of 1920s London, vestiges of England’s magical past exist, but the use of magic has been outlawed, leading families still with powers to operate illegal speakeasies for a public still hungry for magic. Vesper Holloway runs her family club, where a dash of spell powder or an enchanted cocktail can add a little extra intrigue to the evening. But one night a man drinking a Flotation Fizz that should allow him to levitate a few inches finds himself bumping his head on the ceiling. Word among the magical elite is that such accidents have been happening more frequently, and the club owners are worried that the danger will spread.
Enter Maxwell Ashbridge, a onetime friend of Vesper’s brother, who has joined the government agency tasked with enforcing the ban, and who has a personal vendetta against the magical elite. But he does not have a vendetta against Vesper; in fact, he finds her rather enticing. He promises her immunity for her club, if she teams up with him to help gain entry to other establishments and find out who is responsible for the contaminated magic threatening her family business. But their investigation does little to quell the chemistry they share. As accidents continue and the fight to repeal the ban gains ground in Parliament, Vesper and Max will have to decide—is the magic between them worth fighting for?
In an alternate version of 1920s London, vestiges of England’s magical past exist, but the use of magic has been outlawed, leading families still with powers to operate illegal speakeasies for a public still hungry for magic. Vesper Holloway runs her family club, where a dash of spell powder or an enchanted cocktail can add a little extra intrigue to the evening. But one night a man drinking a Flotation Fizz that should allow him to levitate a few inches finds himself bumping his head on the ceiling. Word among the magical elite is that such accidents have been happening more frequently, and the club owners are worried that the danger will spread.
Enter Maxwell Ashbridge, a onetime friend of Vesper’s brother, who has joined the government agency tasked with enforcing the ban, and who has a personal vendetta against the magical elite. But he does not have a vendetta against Vesper; in fact, he finds her rather enticing. He promises her immunity for her club, if she teams up with him to help gain entry to other establishments and find out who is responsible for the contaminated magic threatening her family business. But their investigation does little to quell the chemistry they share. As accidents continue and the fight to repeal the ban gains ground in Parliament, Vesper and Max will have to decide—is the magic between them worth fighting for?
352 pages, Paperback
Expected publication September 29, 2026
About the author
Martha Waters
11 books1,728 followersMartha Waters is the author of To Have and to Hoax and To Love and to Loathe. She was born and raised in sunny South Florida and is a graduate of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. By day, she works as a children's librarian, and loves sundresses, gin cocktails, and traveling. Sign up for her newsletter for periodic book news and reading & travel recs: http://tinyletter.com/marthawaters
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 100 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Crossdressing to get inside a gentleman’s club? Fun!
Shagging inside a tiny cupboard? So hot!
Him finding any excuse to seek her out? Be still, my beating heart!!
✎ᝰ.┊My Thoughts:
As a first-time reader of this author, I wasn’t sure what to expect, but I absolutely loved reading about this world. The dynamic between Vesper and Max was definitely the highlight for me. Their chemistry felt natural and kept me hooked. For those who care about it, this is a moderate spice/open door read. There is one explicit scene, but it’s short.
Overall, the plot and the characters were so charming. Also, I really want a book about Freddie next!!
˖᯽ ݁˖┊What worked for me:
I love the forced proximity trope, so it’s not really a surprise that I swooned whenever they were forced to act coupley. Delicious stuff!
˖᯽ ݁˖┊What didn’t:
The constant use of dialogue tags for anything and everything sometimes pulled me out of the story.
✔ ┊Read this if:
You want a high-charm historical fantasy with a dash of mystery and a lot of heart.
─ ✦ ────
✎ᝰ.┊ pre-read: New author to me! I love the idea of a magical speakeasy in the 20s. Ready for some witty banter and enchanted drinks!
⬫ ⬪ ⬫
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the arc!
Shagging inside a tiny cupboard? So hot!
Him finding any excuse to seek her out? Be still, my beating heart!!
✎ᝰ.┊My Thoughts:
As a first-time reader of this author, I wasn’t sure what to expect, but I absolutely loved reading about this world. The dynamic between Vesper and Max was definitely the highlight for me. Their chemistry felt natural and kept me hooked. For those who care about it, this is a moderate spice/open door read. There is one explicit scene, but it’s short.
Overall, the plot and the characters were so charming. Also, I really want a book about Freddie next!!
˖᯽ ݁˖┊What worked for me:
I love the forced proximity trope, so it’s not really a surprise that I swooned whenever they were forced to act coupley. Delicious stuff!
˖᯽ ݁˖┊What didn’t:
The constant use of dialogue tags for anything and everything sometimes pulled me out of the story.
✔ ┊Read this if:
You want a high-charm historical fantasy with a dash of mystery and a lot of heart.
─ ✦ ────
✎ᝰ.┊ pre-read: New author to me! I love the idea of a magical speakeasy in the 20s. Ready for some witty banter and enchanted drinks!
⬫ ⬪ ⬫
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the arc!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
4⭐️
I've enjoyed all of Martha Water's romances thus far so it was no surprise that I loved this one as well! Spellstruck is a little different from her usual fare- it's a magical realism set in (I think) 1920s London. A world in which magical families run elite but illegal clubs to sell magical potions. When someone starts to tamper with those potions, Vesper, heiress of a magical family who runs their club, teams up with Max, who works for the government office in charge of enforcing the magical laws.
The plot here was a lot of fun. We got to go along with Vesper and Max to the different magical clubs and see the magic there. I particularly liked how different families had different magical specialties and how they were reflected in their menus.
The romance here was super cute. Vesper is unapologetically herself- vain and a little flighty, but also a suave business woman and more clever than anyone gives her credit for. I like how even when she was joking around with Max he took her seriously- he knew exactly who she was. And Max for his part struggled to let loose- he was described but his own friends and family as the fun police. But with Vesper he relaxed and let himself enjoy his surroundings. I also loved the banter between these two- how Vesper was constantly making Max smile and how he gave it back to her just as good.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishing team for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I've enjoyed all of Martha Water's romances thus far so it was no surprise that I loved this one as well! Spellstruck is a little different from her usual fare- it's a magical realism set in (I think) 1920s London. A world in which magical families run elite but illegal clubs to sell magical potions. When someone starts to tamper with those potions, Vesper, heiress of a magical family who runs their club, teams up with Max, who works for the government office in charge of enforcing the magical laws.
The plot here was a lot of fun. We got to go along with Vesper and Max to the different magical clubs and see the magic there. I particularly liked how different families had different magical specialties and how they were reflected in their menus.
The romance here was super cute. Vesper is unapologetically herself- vain and a little flighty, but also a suave business woman and more clever than anyone gives her credit for. I like how even when she was joking around with Max he took her seriously- he knew exactly who she was. And Max for his part struggled to let loose- he was described but his own friends and family as the fun police. But with Vesper he relaxed and let himself enjoy his surroundings. I also loved the banter between these two- how Vesper was constantly making Max smile and how he gave it back to her just as good.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishing team for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
June 14, 2026
Sparkling and witty and sure to appeal to fans of Freya Marske’s The Last Binding trilogy.
May 11, 2026
3.5⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley and to Atria Books for an early copy of this book! All thoughts and opinions are my own ❤️
This was really fun! It was cool to see Martha Waters branching out into incorporating fantasy elements into this book! I do think some parts were a bit dragged out and I feel like we could have expanded on the magical aspect of the potions that the families sell at these clubs. I really like our main female character because she was very fiery and always had a quip back to whatever another character said. The 1920s setting of it was interesting as well since Martha Waters usually writes in a historical time period (regency vows series, and then there was the one) Overall, I would highly recommend picking this one up when it comes out in September for a fun and cozy time that would be especially good for spooky season!
Thank you to NetGalley and to Atria Books for an early copy of this book! All thoughts and opinions are my own ❤️
This was really fun! It was cool to see Martha Waters branching out into incorporating fantasy elements into this book! I do think some parts were a bit dragged out and I feel like we could have expanded on the magical aspect of the potions that the families sell at these clubs. I really like our main female character because she was very fiery and always had a quip back to whatever another character said. The 1920s setting of it was interesting as well since Martha Waters usually writes in a historical time period (regency vows series, and then there was the one) Overall, I would highly recommend picking this one up when it comes out in September for a fun and cozy time that would be especially good for spooky season!
May 26, 2026
This had such a fun concept and setting. We’re in an alternate 1920s London where magic has basically gone through prohibition, and the magical elite run secret speakeasy-style clubs serving enchanted drinks and potions. The atmosphere was honestly my favorite part of the whole book. I loved the glamour, the private clubs, the cocktails, and the idea of underground magic hidden behind velvet curtains and social status.
That said, the magic itself felt surprisingly small for something so heavily outlawed. Since the entire society is built around banning magic, I expected bigger stakes or more impressive magical elements than what we actually got. The book is definitely lightly magical and that description is very accurate.
The romance also didn’t fully work for me. I never really felt the chemistry between the couple, and the grumpy/sunshine dynamic felt flat instead of tension-filled. Their history especially made it hard for me to buy into the emotional payoff later on. Because this is an ARC I won’t get into spoilers, but some of the backstory and character choices made the romance feel more forced than swoony for me.
I think readers looking for a cozy, light magical romance with a unique speakeasy setting may enjoy it more than I did, especially if you prefer atmosphere over heavier magic systems or intense romance development.
That said, the magic itself felt surprisingly small for something so heavily outlawed. Since the entire society is built around banning magic, I expected bigger stakes or more impressive magical elements than what we actually got. The book is definitely lightly magical and that description is very accurate.
The romance also didn’t fully work for me. I never really felt the chemistry between the couple, and the grumpy/sunshine dynamic felt flat instead of tension-filled. Their history especially made it hard for me to buy into the emotional payoff later on. Because this is an ARC I won’t get into spoilers, but some of the backstory and character choices made the romance feel more forced than swoony for me.
I think readers looking for a cozy, light magical romance with a unique speakeasy setting may enjoy it more than I did, especially if you prefer atmosphere over heavier magic systems or intense romance development.
June 15, 2026
Thank you to Atria books for the eARC!
Such a fun, magical book! Spellstruck follows Vesper as she teams up with Max to figure out who is tampering with magical potions at local establishments. Max, however, works for the local law enforcement who wants to shut down these establishments and is not a fan of magic.
I thoroughly enjoyed this lighthearted romance. The mystery and crime solving was super adorable and watching the characters fall for each other was the best. I think this will be a perfect fall book to get you in the witchy/magic spirit for Halloween.
Such a fun, magical book! Spellstruck follows Vesper as she teams up with Max to figure out who is tampering with magical potions at local establishments. Max, however, works for the local law enforcement who wants to shut down these establishments and is not a fan of magic.
I thoroughly enjoyed this lighthearted romance. The mystery and crime solving was super adorable and watching the characters fall for each other was the best. I think this will be a perfect fall book to get you in the witchy/magic spirit for Halloween.
April 19, 2026
This book was so unique! I loved that it brought a really interesting new take to the magic/witches genre that’s gained popularity, with this book being within a “magic prohibition” time period. I will say, it feels decidedly British, which I always find makes books take a little bit longer to get into as an American reader, but overall, very enjoyable.
April 21, 2026
4.25 stars. A cozy mystery set in the world of magical speakeasy’s in 1920’s London? Say less! I was utterly charmed by the world Waters created, in which Magical Prohibition has forced activities to be conducted in secret clubs run by the handful of magical families remaining. Our fiery, strong-willed FMC Vesper is confidently running the family business, but constantly feels the need to “prove herself” as capable. MMC Ashbridge is strait-laced, stoic, and unimpeachable. He has his work cut out for him when he’s tasked with investigating illegal activities on behalf of the government agency for which he works. It’s a quick, fun read filled with flirty banter and palpable chemistry, plus a dash of mystery. Key tropes: enemies-to-lovers, forced proximity, reluctant partners. Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the opportunity to review this advanced copy.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Spellstruck is a magical, romantic book that has me wishing that I, too, had a magical speakeasy near me that served fun and flirty mocktails for the sole purpose of a fun night out with my girls.
I adored Vesper Holloway. Truly. I think she might have made her way into one of my favorite female characters of this year. Smart, witty, and ultimately in tune with herself. I thought her character arc was extremely well-written. As the youngest of her siblings, she’s used to her family downplaying her abilities especially because of her past. But in this book we see her take running Holloway’s extremely seriously, as well as becoming more confident in who she is as a person. She recognizes her flaws and though she might brush them off with humor and wit, it was clear in this book that she was working on herself and I loved it.
And Maxwell Ashbridge. Oh, sweet sweet Max. I think he was the perfect complement for Vesper. They bounced off each other perfectly and I never tired of their banter. Never raised his voice, quite frankly didn’t resort to lies or manipulation, and was willing to reconsider his views on magic that had been tainted by his father. I also thought he had a good character arc and didn’t fall flat. Loved their tension and chemistry, and yeah. I would read more about them.
I thought the plot was fine, though predictable at times. I had worked out most of what it took them the entire book to work out so the reveal didn’t feel as surprising; nevertheless, it didn’t take away from my enjoyment of the book. This was my introduction to Martha’s writing style and I quite enjoyed it except for the replacement words for “said”, “murmured” being the most common. Lol. It’s okay to write “said” but I understand the desire for variety; unfortunately, it pulled me out of the story each time there was murmuring, whispering, and the like. I also found the pacing a bit weird. A good chunk at the beginning takes place over just a weekend. I personally thought more time had passed. And the entire story over the course of a couple of weeks… I also didn’t realize how short the book was? Before I realized it, we were at 90% of the way through and not a whole lot left to resolve the ending which led to it feeling a little rushed. And though we had been seeing Vesper and Max grow into loving each other, I wish we had more time with their romance on page.
Ultimately, I enjoyed this book and would be open to reading more in this universe. If Martha wants to write about Lucian, Amelia, and their magical family history, I would happily read it. If you’re a fan of witty banter, delicious tension, and building a friendship before any romantic advances, this will be the book for you!
Side note: I wonder if this is fantasy as much as it is magical realism :)
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria for a complimentary ARC. All opinions are my own!
I adored Vesper Holloway. Truly. I think she might have made her way into one of my favorite female characters of this year. Smart, witty, and ultimately in tune with herself. I thought her character arc was extremely well-written. As the youngest of her siblings, she’s used to her family downplaying her abilities especially because of her past. But in this book we see her take running Holloway’s extremely seriously, as well as becoming more confident in who she is as a person. She recognizes her flaws and though she might brush them off with humor and wit, it was clear in this book that she was working on herself and I loved it.
And Maxwell Ashbridge. Oh, sweet sweet Max. I think he was the perfect complement for Vesper. They bounced off each other perfectly and I never tired of their banter. Never raised his voice, quite frankly didn’t resort to lies or manipulation, and was willing to reconsider his views on magic that had been tainted by his father. I also thought he had a good character arc and didn’t fall flat. Loved their tension and chemistry, and yeah. I would read more about them.
I thought the plot was fine, though predictable at times. I had worked out most of what it took them the entire book to work out so the reveal didn’t feel as surprising; nevertheless, it didn’t take away from my enjoyment of the book. This was my introduction to Martha’s writing style and I quite enjoyed it except for the replacement words for “said”, “murmured” being the most common. Lol. It’s okay to write “said” but I understand the desire for variety; unfortunately, it pulled me out of the story each time there was murmuring, whispering, and the like. I also found the pacing a bit weird. A good chunk at the beginning takes place over just a weekend. I personally thought more time had passed. And the entire story over the course of a couple of weeks… I also didn’t realize how short the book was? Before I realized it, we were at 90% of the way through and not a whole lot left to resolve the ending which led to it feeling a little rushed. And though we had been seeing Vesper and Max grow into loving each other, I wish we had more time with their romance on page.
Ultimately, I enjoyed this book and would be open to reading more in this universe. If Martha wants to write about Lucian, Amelia, and their magical family history, I would happily read it. If you’re a fan of witty banter, delicious tension, and building a friendship before any romantic advances, this will be the book for you!
Side note: I wonder if this is fantasy as much as it is magical realism :)
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria for a complimentary ARC. All opinions are my own!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley, Atria Books, and Martha Waters for providing me with an ARC copy of Spellstruck in exchange for an honest review.
Spellstruck is a lightly magical historical rom-com set in an alternate 1920s London, which means we get speakeasies, outlawed magic, romantic tension, and people making deeply questionable choices in very good outfits. Honestly, an ideal use of everyone’s time.
This book follows Vesper, who runs a magical speakeasy, and Max, the very inconvenient man tasked with enforcing the ban on magic. Naturally, potions start going wrong, the two of them have to work together, and chemistry becomes a problem in more ways than one. Terrible for them. Delightful for me.
Martha Waters has such a charming voice, and this book has the same wit and sparkle I enjoy from her historical romances, just with a little more magic stirred in. The banter is quick, the world is fun, and the romance has that “I am absolutely not interested in you, please ignore my obvious interest” energy that always gets me. I am not immune to a competent woman and a buttoned-up man being forced into proximity. I have accepted this about myself.
This was not a perfect read for me, but it was a very enjoyable one. The magic system and mystery were fun, though I did sometimes want a little more depth from both. The world had so much potential that I occasionally wanted the book to slow down and let me snoop around more. Give me more magical speakeasy drama. Let me be nosy.
A few things I loved:
- Magical cocktails. Obviously.
- A heroine with bite.
- A hero who needs to unclench, professionally and emotionally.
- Forced teamwork. My favorite workplace violation.
- 1920s atmosphere with fantasy seasoning.
A few things that kept it at four stars:
- I wanted the magic and worldbuilding to go a little deeper.
- The mystery was entertaining, but not the part that fully hooked me.
- Some emotional beats could have used more room.
- I liked the romance, but I wanted a tiny bit more ache before the payoff. I am a simple woman. Make them suffer prettily.
Overall, Spellstruck is charming, clever, cozy, and very easy to enjoy. It has magical speakeasies, romantic friction, a fun mystery, and the kind of historical fantasy setup that makes you wonder why more people are not putting cocktails and forbidden magic in the same room.
Spellstruck is a lightly magical historical rom-com set in an alternate 1920s London, which means we get speakeasies, outlawed magic, romantic tension, and people making deeply questionable choices in very good outfits. Honestly, an ideal use of everyone’s time.
This book follows Vesper, who runs a magical speakeasy, and Max, the very inconvenient man tasked with enforcing the ban on magic. Naturally, potions start going wrong, the two of them have to work together, and chemistry becomes a problem in more ways than one. Terrible for them. Delightful for me.
Martha Waters has such a charming voice, and this book has the same wit and sparkle I enjoy from her historical romances, just with a little more magic stirred in. The banter is quick, the world is fun, and the romance has that “I am absolutely not interested in you, please ignore my obvious interest” energy that always gets me. I am not immune to a competent woman and a buttoned-up man being forced into proximity. I have accepted this about myself.
This was not a perfect read for me, but it was a very enjoyable one. The magic system and mystery were fun, though I did sometimes want a little more depth from both. The world had so much potential that I occasionally wanted the book to slow down and let me snoop around more. Give me more magical speakeasy drama. Let me be nosy.
A few things I loved:
- Magical cocktails. Obviously.
- A heroine with bite.
- A hero who needs to unclench, professionally and emotionally.
- Forced teamwork. My favorite workplace violation.
- 1920s atmosphere with fantasy seasoning.
A few things that kept it at four stars:
- I wanted the magic and worldbuilding to go a little deeper.
- The mystery was entertaining, but not the part that fully hooked me.
- Some emotional beats could have used more room.
- I liked the romance, but I wanted a tiny bit more ache before the payoff. I am a simple woman. Make them suffer prettily.
Overall, Spellstruck is charming, clever, cozy, and very easy to enjoy. It has magical speakeasies, romantic friction, a fun mystery, and the kind of historical fantasy setup that makes you wonder why more people are not putting cocktails and forbidden magic in the same room.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC read!
I went into Spellstruck by Martha Waters expecting a light, whimsical escape and in many ways, it absolutely delivered with that. This was a fun, entertaining read with a charming premise that blends a prohibition-era aesthetic with a magical twist, where magic itself is forbidden. The setting is easily one of the strongest aspects of the novel. Waters has a real talent for painting a vivid picture; the world feels textured, atmospheric, and immersive in that vintage, slightly glamorous, slightly dangerous way. It’s the kind of backdrop that immediately pulls you in and makes you want to linger.
The banter between Vesper and Max was another highlight. Their dynamic is playful, witty, and genuinely enjoyable to read. There’s a natural chemistry in their dialogue that keeps the story moving and adds a layer of charm that carries a lot of the book. Waters clearly excels at writing humor and light romantic tension. There were multiple moments that made me smile.
That said, where the book fell a bit short for me was in its emotional depth. While I liked both Vesper and Max, I never felt fully invested in them on a deeper level. Their connection, though fun on the surface, didn’t quite develop into something emotionally compelling. I found myself wishing for more quiet, vulnerable moments and scenes that would have allowed their relationship to breathe and feel more substantial rather than just clever and entertaining.
The same issue extends to the plot. While the premise is intriguing, the story itself felt somewhat flat and, at times, a bit predictable. I kept waiting for a stronger sense of momentum or a twist that would elevate the stakes, especially toward the end. The reveal didn’t land with the impact I was hoping for, which left the overall narrative feeling a little underwhelming despite its strong setup.
Overall, Spellstruck shines in its writing style, humor, and beautifully crafted setting. It’s an easy, enjoyable read that leans heavily into charm and atmosphere. However, if you’re looking for a story with deeper emotional resonance or a more gripping, layered plot, this one may feel like it’s missing that extra spark.
I went into Spellstruck by Martha Waters expecting a light, whimsical escape and in many ways, it absolutely delivered with that. This was a fun, entertaining read with a charming premise that blends a prohibition-era aesthetic with a magical twist, where magic itself is forbidden. The setting is easily one of the strongest aspects of the novel. Waters has a real talent for painting a vivid picture; the world feels textured, atmospheric, and immersive in that vintage, slightly glamorous, slightly dangerous way. It’s the kind of backdrop that immediately pulls you in and makes you want to linger.
The banter between Vesper and Max was another highlight. Their dynamic is playful, witty, and genuinely enjoyable to read. There’s a natural chemistry in their dialogue that keeps the story moving and adds a layer of charm that carries a lot of the book. Waters clearly excels at writing humor and light romantic tension. There were multiple moments that made me smile.
That said, where the book fell a bit short for me was in its emotional depth. While I liked both Vesper and Max, I never felt fully invested in them on a deeper level. Their connection, though fun on the surface, didn’t quite develop into something emotionally compelling. I found myself wishing for more quiet, vulnerable moments and scenes that would have allowed their relationship to breathe and feel more substantial rather than just clever and entertaining.
The same issue extends to the plot. While the premise is intriguing, the story itself felt somewhat flat and, at times, a bit predictable. I kept waiting for a stronger sense of momentum or a twist that would elevate the stakes, especially toward the end. The reveal didn’t land with the impact I was hoping for, which left the overall narrative feeling a little underwhelming despite its strong setup.
Overall, Spellstruck shines in its writing style, humor, and beautifully crafted setting. It’s an easy, enjoyable read that leans heavily into charm and atmosphere. However, if you’re looking for a story with deeper emotional resonance or a more gripping, layered plot, this one may feel like it’s missing that extra spark.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 3, 2026
I was lucky enough to receive an advanced copy of Spellstruck through a Goodreads giveaway. The following review is my immediate reaction upon finishing Spellstruck.
The time period is 1920s London - except in this reality, prohibition does not apply to alcohol, but instead to the consumption of magical substances. Magic was once prevalent throughout all aspects of life - magic wielders could light a fire with a snap of their fingers - but due to the co-mingling of magical people with “mundanes” (or nonmagical people) inherent magic has dwindled and weakened to the point that it can only be accessed through a sacred family Word and utilized through magically imbued powders and syrups. After a much alluded to war (I believe there was also a mention of a war between magical and mundane peoples, but I’m a bit fuzzier on that. Just take my word for it - there was a war. World War I, but with magic. Ok. Moving on.) prohibition is instated to control and police the use of said magical substances.
But as people are wont to do, they of course, shamelessly flout the rules and carry on with their magical merriment behind cleverly disguised doors, with the use of secret passwords, and other speakeasy-esque methods of evading the law. But when it becomes clear that someone is tampering with magic after multiple mishaps come to light, our protagonist, Vesper, daughter of a powerful and prestigious magical family who runs the famous club Holloway, teams up with Max Ashbridge, a straight laced civil worker who is dedicated to enforcing anti-magic laws (known as Forbiddance), to find who is behind the tainted substances.
The premise is promising, the banter is witty, and the story is cute with a fun, uncomplicated mystery. I had a gripe or two about the quick switch from a sweet budding romance that felt rather innocent that would suddenly be smashed with a sledgehammer with a reference to a “cock twitch” or “cock hardening”. Like really? That felt very out of nowhere compared to the rest of the book. I also think I would tighten up the war subplot so it serves the story better, but for what I assume is not the final version, it’s a great start and I enjoyed the read. All in all, I enjoyed this cozy little magical world, and our fiercely dependent heroine.
The time period is 1920s London - except in this reality, prohibition does not apply to alcohol, but instead to the consumption of magical substances. Magic was once prevalent throughout all aspects of life - magic wielders could light a fire with a snap of their fingers - but due to the co-mingling of magical people with “mundanes” (or nonmagical people) inherent magic has dwindled and weakened to the point that it can only be accessed through a sacred family Word and utilized through magically imbued powders and syrups. After a much alluded to war (I believe there was also a mention of a war between magical and mundane peoples, but I’m a bit fuzzier on that. Just take my word for it - there was a war. World War I, but with magic. Ok. Moving on.) prohibition is instated to control and police the use of said magical substances.
But as people are wont to do, they of course, shamelessly flout the rules and carry on with their magical merriment behind cleverly disguised doors, with the use of secret passwords, and other speakeasy-esque methods of evading the law. But when it becomes clear that someone is tampering with magic after multiple mishaps come to light, our protagonist, Vesper, daughter of a powerful and prestigious magical family who runs the famous club Holloway, teams up with Max Ashbridge, a straight laced civil worker who is dedicated to enforcing anti-magic laws (known as Forbiddance), to find who is behind the tainted substances.
The premise is promising, the banter is witty, and the story is cute with a fun, uncomplicated mystery. I had a gripe or two about the quick switch from a sweet budding romance that felt rather innocent that would suddenly be smashed with a sledgehammer with a reference to a “cock twitch” or “cock hardening”. Like really? That felt very out of nowhere compared to the rest of the book. I also think I would tighten up the war subplot so it serves the story better, but for what I assume is not the final version, it’s a great start and I enjoyed the read. All in all, I enjoyed this cozy little magical world, and our fiercely dependent heroine.
Review of advance copy
~~Reviewed by Toby Palevsky Smith of Toby's Nerd-Cave Library~~
Thank you to my sister, Ari, for lending me her paperback copy of the ARC for my review.
In an alternate 1920’s London, the secret speakeasies that the 20s are known for, cater to a different crowd than our own world - instead of hiding the illegal booze of the Prohibition era, these speakeasies hide illegal Magic. After the government outlaws all magic, those who partake in magic, now get their special drinks, cocktails, and potions, and powders in secret, and flock to the historically wealthy and magical families nightclubs. When something starts to go wrong with the magical drinks and cocktails served at the bars, it's up to Vesper, and her brother's old pal Max, who now works for the government agency that enforces those anti-magic laws, to figure out who is sabotaging the magical clubs, and why.
I’m really liking the sexually progressive FMC, Vesper. She is strong willed, confident, promiscuous, and clever. She knows exactly how she looks to others and uses it to her advantage, she sees what she wants and she goes for it. I am especially liking how progressive it is considering this takes place in the 1920’s.
The world building in this story is great, and gets fleshed out throughout the book instead of a giant info dumping scene. The sexual and romantic chemistry between Vesper and Max is astonishingly real and works really well for how they are supposed to interact - I believe the trope is ‘forced proximity’. The vulgar language also is really funny next to the posh English dialogue from most of the characters.
Overall, I think this is a fantastic Alternate Universe Historical Romantasy, with great well-rounded characters, a familiar yet magically altered setting, and fantastic LGBTQ+ representation. Make sure to get your copy of “Spellstruck” when the book is officially released in September 2026!
Thank you to my sister, Ari, for lending me her paperback copy of the ARC for my review.
In an alternate 1920’s London, the secret speakeasies that the 20s are known for, cater to a different crowd than our own world - instead of hiding the illegal booze of the Prohibition era, these speakeasies hide illegal Magic. After the government outlaws all magic, those who partake in magic, now get their special drinks, cocktails, and potions, and powders in secret, and flock to the historically wealthy and magical families nightclubs. When something starts to go wrong with the magical drinks and cocktails served at the bars, it's up to Vesper, and her brother's old pal Max, who now works for the government agency that enforces those anti-magic laws, to figure out who is sabotaging the magical clubs, and why.
I’m really liking the sexually progressive FMC, Vesper. She is strong willed, confident, promiscuous, and clever. She knows exactly how she looks to others and uses it to her advantage, she sees what she wants and she goes for it. I am especially liking how progressive it is considering this takes place in the 1920’s.
The world building in this story is great, and gets fleshed out throughout the book instead of a giant info dumping scene. The sexual and romantic chemistry between Vesper and Max is astonishingly real and works really well for how they are supposed to interact - I believe the trope is ‘forced proximity’. The vulgar language also is really funny next to the posh English dialogue from most of the characters.
Overall, I think this is a fantastic Alternate Universe Historical Romantasy, with great well-rounded characters, a familiar yet magically altered setting, and fantastic LGBTQ+ representation. Make sure to get your copy of “Spellstruck” when the book is officially released in September 2026!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thanks to NetGalley for this ARC.
This was an okay read overall. There were elements I really liked, and others that could have been executed better.
My favorite part are the 3 dimensional characters. Vesper defies many trope as the heroine. She’s privileged, a bit spoiled, flaunts her attractiveness, and was very messy and slutty in her previous relationships. Meanwhile, Max is Vesper’s foil. He’s uptight and a rule stickler. They could have easily been obnoxious characters, but the author makes them likable from the start. Despite them being opposites, their relationship makes a lot of sense at the end. I also like their families’ dynamics. I had a smile on my face reading Max’s family banter among themselves.
The world building was done well, but the beginning was a slog to get through due to all the exposition.
The mystery was the weakest part of the book. It wasn’t a compelling mystery and the culprit reveal was anticlimactic.
• Much of the story involves visiting different clubs, but the investigation doesn’t meaningfully deepen or evolve with each new location.
This was an okay read overall. There were elements I really liked, and others that could have been executed better.
My favorite part are the 3 dimensional characters. Vesper defies many trope as the heroine. She’s privileged, a bit spoiled, flaunts her attractiveness, and was very messy and slutty in her previous relationships. Meanwhile, Max is Vesper’s foil. He’s uptight and a rule stickler. They could have easily been obnoxious characters, but the author makes them likable from the start. Despite them being opposites, their relationship makes a lot of sense at the end. I also like their families’ dynamics. I had a smile on my face reading Max’s family banter among themselves.
The world building was done well, but the beginning was a slog to get through due to all the exposition.
The mystery was the weakest part of the book. It wasn’t a compelling mystery and the culprit reveal was anticlimactic.
• Much of the story involves visiting different clubs, but the investigation doesn’t meaningfully deepen or evolve with each new location.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Martha Waters' writing is gorgeous - it reads historical, a bit Austen-esque with quick-witted banter and surprising quips (mostly out of Max's shockingly not-uptight mouth). It's a quick read, but I would have given my kidney for an additional 100 pages to live in this world!! Light socio-economic criticism (no ethical aristocracy, y'all, and highlighting that the working class is often at the whims of the upper class), it's also a warm and cozy story, with two loving families for Max and Vesper, and a sweet set of friends. The love story and pacing doesn't feel as quick as the timeline probably indicates, as their intertwining histories fill out the underlying relationship, and there's a decidedly sweet and satisfying resolution. A bit of light spice at the end is a macaron for readers (the perfect two-bite dessert)!
Set in a post-WWI, Prohibition-era London, Spellstruck follows Vesper Holloway (youngest sibling of the legacy magical family the Holloways) as she runs their nightclub (members only, for magical folks), and Max Ashbridge (mundane Londoner and civil employee), working to enforce new laws restricting magic usage in such clubs (and former bestie of Vesper's older brother). When Max is tasked with investigating the Holloways' cub, he stumbles in as magical sabotage is taking place, and he and Vesper partner up to investigate the magical sabotage occurring all over London's magical clubs. Investigations lead to Vesper and Max discovering elements of each other (and magical and non-magical life, broadly)...and the feelings begin to turn. The investigation and their relationship heat up coincidentally. But Max is also hiding a BIG secret. And Vesper's nursing a long-broken heart and a vow to not open herself up again.
*Opinions and review are my own. I am grateful to Atria Books via NetGalley for an eARC of this book.
Set in a post-WWI, Prohibition-era London, Spellstruck follows Vesper Holloway (youngest sibling of the legacy magical family the Holloways) as she runs their nightclub (members only, for magical folks), and Max Ashbridge (mundane Londoner and civil employee), working to enforce new laws restricting magic usage in such clubs (and former bestie of Vesper's older brother). When Max is tasked with investigating the Holloways' cub, he stumbles in as magical sabotage is taking place, and he and Vesper partner up to investigate the magical sabotage occurring all over London's magical clubs. Investigations lead to Vesper and Max discovering elements of each other (and magical and non-magical life, broadly)...and the feelings begin to turn. The investigation and their relationship heat up coincidentally. But Max is also hiding a BIG secret. And Vesper's nursing a long-broken heart and a vow to not open herself up again.
*Opinions and review are my own. I am grateful to Atria Books via NetGalley for an eARC of this book.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Starstruck is an engaging novel that explores an alternate reality of London in the 1920's where traces of England’s magical past exist, but the use of magic has been outlawed. Prominent families still with magical powers to operate illegal speakeasies for a public still hungry for magic. Martha Walters creates a unputdownable story filled with interesting characters, emotional conflicts, and moments of self-discovery that keep readers invested from beginning to end - I read the entire novel in an afternoon.
One of the novel's greatest strengths is its protagonist, Vesper, a woman in her mid 20's who is beautiful, sexy, smart and promiscuous that has made some questionable life choices in the past. She manages her family's speakeasy but is not taken very seriously by her family. When someone starts to tamper with the potions in her club, Vesper teams up with Max, who works for the government office in charge of enforcing the magical laws. Her journey during the book feels believable. Walters captures the excitement of success while also highlighting the pressures, sacrifices, and personal struggles that often accompany it.
The pacing is generally strong, with enough twists and emotional moments to maintain interest. Walters's writing style is accessible and descriptive, making it easy to visualize the settings and become immersed in the narrative. Themes of identity, friendship, ambition, and staying true to oneself are woven effectively into the plot, giving the story depth beyond its glamorous surface.
Overall, Starstruck is an entertaining and uplifting read that will appeal to readers who enjoy paranormal romances about ambition, and personal
Thank you to NetGalley and to Atria Books for an advance copy of this book! All thoughts and opinions are my own
One of the novel's greatest strengths is its protagonist, Vesper, a woman in her mid 20's who is beautiful, sexy, smart and promiscuous that has made some questionable life choices in the past. She manages her family's speakeasy but is not taken very seriously by her family. When someone starts to tamper with the potions in her club, Vesper teams up with Max, who works for the government office in charge of enforcing the magical laws. Her journey during the book feels believable. Walters captures the excitement of success while also highlighting the pressures, sacrifices, and personal struggles that often accompany it.
The pacing is generally strong, with enough twists and emotional moments to maintain interest. Walters's writing style is accessible and descriptive, making it easy to visualize the settings and become immersed in the narrative. Themes of identity, friendship, ambition, and staying true to oneself are woven effectively into the plot, giving the story depth beyond its glamorous surface.
Overall, Starstruck is an entertaining and uplifting read that will appeal to readers who enjoy paranormal romances about ambition, and personal
Thank you to NetGalley and to Atria Books for an advance copy of this book! All thoughts and opinions are my own
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Spellstruck by Martha Waters
This was such a fun concept—1920s London, magical speakeasies, and prohibition but for magic instead of alcohol. The setting alone really carried the book for me.
The Holloway club and the idea of magic being regulated, hidden, and traded through secret spaces made for a really interesting backdrop, and I liked how much of the story took place in that underground nightlife atmosphere.
Vesper is very much the kind of FMC who feels responsible for everything. She’s running her family’s business, constantly trying to prove herself, and you can feel how much pressure she’s under even when she’s trying to act like she has it all together. Max contrasts her really well—very by-the-book, duty-focused, and not someone who expects to get pulled into the mess he ends up in.
Their dynamic works best when they’re forced to actually be around each other and figure things out on the fly. The romance builds gradually alongside the investigation, and I liked that it never fully took over the mystery side of the story.
The mystery itself is fairly straightforward, but it gives the plot enough structure to keep things moving through the speakeasy setting and magical mishaps. It felt more like a backdrop for character interactions than a deeply layered whodunnit, which worked fine for the tone.
One thing I did appreciate is that the book leans more into being light, readable, and slightly whimsical rather than trying to be overly serious or dense with lore. It’s an easy world to slip into and enjoy without needing to overthink it.
Overall, this was a solid cozy fantasy read with a strong setting and a romance that develops naturally within it. This is an easy, enjoyable pick when you want something atmospheric but not too heavy.
This was such a fun concept—1920s London, magical speakeasies, and prohibition but for magic instead of alcohol. The setting alone really carried the book for me.
The Holloway club and the idea of magic being regulated, hidden, and traded through secret spaces made for a really interesting backdrop, and I liked how much of the story took place in that underground nightlife atmosphere.
Vesper is very much the kind of FMC who feels responsible for everything. She’s running her family’s business, constantly trying to prove herself, and you can feel how much pressure she’s under even when she’s trying to act like she has it all together. Max contrasts her really well—very by-the-book, duty-focused, and not someone who expects to get pulled into the mess he ends up in.
Their dynamic works best when they’re forced to actually be around each other and figure things out on the fly. The romance builds gradually alongside the investigation, and I liked that it never fully took over the mystery side of the story.
The mystery itself is fairly straightforward, but it gives the plot enough structure to keep things moving through the speakeasy setting and magical mishaps. It felt more like a backdrop for character interactions than a deeply layered whodunnit, which worked fine for the tone.
One thing I did appreciate is that the book leans more into being light, readable, and slightly whimsical rather than trying to be overly serious or dense with lore. It’s an easy world to slip into and enjoy without needing to overthink it.
Overall, this was a solid cozy fantasy read with a strong setting and a romance that develops naturally within it. This is an easy, enjoyable pick when you want something atmospheric but not too heavy.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
When I saw “1920’s London” and “magic” in this book description, I just knew it was one I had to read. It was everything I hoped for and more. Martha Waters does a brilliant job of worldbuilding an alternate 1920s London, in which magic still exists amongst magical families, and in this world’s version of speakeasies… clubs serving magical cocktails. Our guide to this alternate reality is Vesper Holloway, privileged socialite tasked with running her family’s club amidst growing turmoil around magical mishaps happening at such clubs. Said mishaps have caught the eye of Maxwell Ashbridge, government man working for the agency in charge of enforcing the ban on magic.
In short, I loved this book. Beyond the world of alternate reality magical 1920s London, I thought our main characters were both fantastic. Vesper is every bit the spoiled and wealthy socialite, yet we can sympathize with her wanting her family to take her seriously and trust her judgement. She also is a formidable businesswoman, something that Max admires in her. Upon first look, Max seems every bit the uptight civil servant, unable to enjoy life. As we get to know him better, though, not only does he loosen up a bit, but we learn about why he is the way that he is. Together, the two of them are hilarious. The banter between them and the fantastic cast of supporting characters is endlessly entertaining, and I definitely found myself wanting to read more family scenes. Beyond the hilarity, though, it was also rewarding to see Vesper and Max bring out the best versions of each other.
I received an ARC from Atria via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
In short, I loved this book. Beyond the world of alternate reality magical 1920s London, I thought our main characters were both fantastic. Vesper is every bit the spoiled and wealthy socialite, yet we can sympathize with her wanting her family to take her seriously and trust her judgement. She also is a formidable businesswoman, something that Max admires in her. Upon first look, Max seems every bit the uptight civil servant, unable to enjoy life. As we get to know him better, though, not only does he loosen up a bit, but we learn about why he is the way that he is. Together, the two of them are hilarious. The banter between them and the fantastic cast of supporting characters is endlessly entertaining, and I definitely found myself wanting to read more family scenes. Beyond the hilarity, though, it was also rewarding to see Vesper and Max bring out the best versions of each other.
I received an ARC from Atria via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Two words: MAGICAL. SPEAKEASY.
That alone convinced me to read this book. Combined with the cute cover and the fact that it was written by Regency Vows author Martha Waters? I was absolutely, without a doubt, one hundred percent in.
This book was such a fun ride!! The magic system was unique and fun -- it was low stakes in a way that fit the romance-forward vibe of the story but still central enough to be a fantasy book as well. Vesper was the best kind of FMC because she was fun and sassy and just the slightest bit silly which made you just want to BE her. And watching Ashbridge, solemn and stoic government employee, fall so head over heels for her was so realistic because, honestly, I'm a little bit in love with her too.
I wish there was a little bit more explanation for some things regarding their past, but that was really the only thing that kept this from a 4-star rating in my head. I think it would have been nice to understand a little more about why Ashbridge and Vesper's brother had a falling out and also get a little bit more into his head about their past encounter. I think the mystery was also bit complicated in some moments, just because there were a lot of small background characters to keep in mind, but that was part of the fun!
But, honestly, this is exactly the kind of book you hope to get when you read the synopsis and see the adorable cover. Just a fun time from beginning to end.
--------------
Thank you to Netgalley and Atria for the ARC!
That alone convinced me to read this book. Combined with the cute cover and the fact that it was written by Regency Vows author Martha Waters? I was absolutely, without a doubt, one hundred percent in.
This book was such a fun ride!! The magic system was unique and fun -- it was low stakes in a way that fit the romance-forward vibe of the story but still central enough to be a fantasy book as well. Vesper was the best kind of FMC because she was fun and sassy and just the slightest bit silly which made you just want to BE her. And watching Ashbridge, solemn and stoic government employee, fall so head over heels for her was so realistic because, honestly, I'm a little bit in love with her too.
I wish there was a little bit more explanation for some things regarding their past, but that was really the only thing that kept this from a 4-star rating in my head. I think it would have been nice to understand a little more about why Ashbridge and Vesper's brother had a falling out and also get a little bit more into his head about their past encounter. I think the mystery was also bit complicated in some moments, just because there were a lot of small background characters to keep in mind, but that was part of the fun!
But, honestly, this is exactly the kind of book you hope to get when you read the synopsis and see the adorable cover. Just a fun time from beginning to end.
--------------
Thank you to Netgalley and Atria for the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to NetGalley for this advance copy!
I'm a sucker for Martha Waters. I have read (almost) everything she's written, and her charming characters and fantastic banter always have me coming back.
Spellstruck, Waters' first foray into fantasy, takes place in an alternate 1920s London, where magic is outlawed, but magical families act like prohibition-era bootleggers, selling potions and powders to anyone in the know. Vesper Holloway is the freespirited, fun-loving youngest of three siblings, and she has taken the mantle of running her family's magical club. Maxwell Ashbridge is a government official working to shut down these clubs that sell magic on the side. When he's assigned to try to infiltrate Vesper's club, Vesper makes him an alternative offer: team up to find out who's been making magic go awry at the other clubs. With a history they would rather not discuss and completely opposite views on magic, Vesper and Max clash on every ideal, but the more time they spend together, the more they can't stop thinking about the other, and the more they question their biases.
Like I said, few people do banter like Waters. She's great at wit and suggestive jokes. Her characters are always clever and deeper than they first appear (Vesper may be fun-loving, but she's serious about her family business!). I definitely felt the heat between the two characters. They had great chemistry. The setting was very fun; her descriptions of the different clubs made me feel like I could slide up to the bar and order a potion.
What fell a bit short was the worldbuilding. As a first attempt at fantasy, I think she did pretty well, but as someone who is well-versed in fantasy, I found some of it a bit tedious/not completely thought out. And perhaps I'm being too nit-picky as it's a "reimagined" 1920s London, but some things about the characters and their sentiments felt a bit anachonistic.
Overall, though, I enjoyed this little romp through the 1920s with Vesper and Max, and, as always, I will keep recommending her books and not so patiently awaiting her next book!
I'm a sucker for Martha Waters. I have read (almost) everything she's written, and her charming characters and fantastic banter always have me coming back.
Spellstruck, Waters' first foray into fantasy, takes place in an alternate 1920s London, where magic is outlawed, but magical families act like prohibition-era bootleggers, selling potions and powders to anyone in the know. Vesper Holloway is the freespirited, fun-loving youngest of three siblings, and she has taken the mantle of running her family's magical club. Maxwell Ashbridge is a government official working to shut down these clubs that sell magic on the side. When he's assigned to try to infiltrate Vesper's club, Vesper makes him an alternative offer: team up to find out who's been making magic go awry at the other clubs. With a history they would rather not discuss and completely opposite views on magic, Vesper and Max clash on every ideal, but the more time they spend together, the more they can't stop thinking about the other, and the more they question their biases.
Like I said, few people do banter like Waters. She's great at wit and suggestive jokes. Her characters are always clever and deeper than they first appear (Vesper may be fun-loving, but she's serious about her family business!). I definitely felt the heat between the two characters. They had great chemistry. The setting was very fun; her descriptions of the different clubs made me feel like I could slide up to the bar and order a potion.
What fell a bit short was the worldbuilding. As a first attempt at fantasy, I think she did pretty well, but as someone who is well-versed in fantasy, I found some of it a bit tedious/not completely thought out. And perhaps I'm being too nit-picky as it's a "reimagined" 1920s London, but some things about the characters and their sentiments felt a bit anachonistic.
Overall, though, I enjoyed this little romp through the 1920s with Vesper and Max, and, as always, I will keep recommending her books and not so patiently awaiting her next book!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I honestly didn’t expect to like this as much as I did.
Spellstruck ended up being such a fun read in a way that just felt really easy to get into. The whole alternate 1920s setting with magic being restricted gave it this cool edge, but it never felt too heavy or complicated. It stayed pretty light and easy to follow the whole way through.
The main thing that really worked for me was the dynamic between the two leads. It’s very much enemies-to-lovers / reluctant partnership / forced proximity vibes, with that constant bickering back-and-forth where they clearly don’t want to like each other… but also very obviously do. The tension between them is honestly what kept me hooked because you’re just waiting for them to stop fighting it.
I also really liked the world itself. The idea of magic being controlled and kind of pushed underground made everything feel a bit more interesting, even in the smaller moments. It gave the story this “hidden world” feel that I wasn’t expecting, and it fit really well with the overall vibe.
Tone-wise, it was just a really easy read. Fun, a bit playful at times, and romantic without taking itself too seriously. It had a nice balance where it never felt too heavy, but still had enough going on that it didn’t feel flat either.
If I had to be picky, I just wish there were a few more scenes between the main two because their dynamic was honestly the best part for me and I would’ve happily stayed in that tension longer.
But overall, I had a really good time with this. It’s one of those books that just works if you want something magical, romantic, and easy to get lost in.
Spellstruck ended up being such a fun read in a way that just felt really easy to get into. The whole alternate 1920s setting with magic being restricted gave it this cool edge, but it never felt too heavy or complicated. It stayed pretty light and easy to follow the whole way through.
The main thing that really worked for me was the dynamic between the two leads. It’s very much enemies-to-lovers / reluctant partnership / forced proximity vibes, with that constant bickering back-and-forth where they clearly don’t want to like each other… but also very obviously do. The tension between them is honestly what kept me hooked because you’re just waiting for them to stop fighting it.
I also really liked the world itself. The idea of magic being controlled and kind of pushed underground made everything feel a bit more interesting, even in the smaller moments. It gave the story this “hidden world” feel that I wasn’t expecting, and it fit really well with the overall vibe.
Tone-wise, it was just a really easy read. Fun, a bit playful at times, and romantic without taking itself too seriously. It had a nice balance where it never felt too heavy, but still had enough going on that it didn’t feel flat either.
If I had to be picky, I just wish there were a few more scenes between the main two because their dynamic was honestly the best part for me and I would’ve happily stayed in that tension longer.
But overall, I had a really good time with this. It’s one of those books that just works if you want something magical, romantic, and easy to get lost in.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
The 1920s setting mixed with the magical speakeasy concept was such a fun idea, and it never felt overly complicated. It was easy to fall into the world and just enjoy it for what it was. I especially liked the way magic was restricted and kept somewhat hidden—it added an interesting layer without weighing the story down.
The strongest part for me was definitely the dynamic between Vesper and Max. Their relationship had that classic reluctant partners/forced proximity feel, and their back-and-forth made it really engaging. The tension between them felt natural and was what kept me the most invested.
I also appreciated that the tone stayed fairly light overall. It had a nice balance of charm, romance, and a bit of mystery without trying to do too much.
If I had one complaint, I do wish there had been a few more scenes focused on the two of them, since their chemistry was the highlight. At times, the dialogue tags also felt a bit overused and pulled me out of the story here and there.
For those wondering, this is a moderate/open-door romance—there’s one explicit scene, but it’s fairly brief.
Overall, this was a charming, easy read with a fun concept and a strong central relationship. I’d recommend it if you’re looking for something light, romantic, and a little bit different.
The 1920s setting mixed with the magical speakeasy concept was such a fun idea, and it never felt overly complicated. It was easy to fall into the world and just enjoy it for what it was. I especially liked the way magic was restricted and kept somewhat hidden—it added an interesting layer without weighing the story down.
The strongest part for me was definitely the dynamic between Vesper and Max. Their relationship had that classic reluctant partners/forced proximity feel, and their back-and-forth made it really engaging. The tension between them felt natural and was what kept me the most invested.
I also appreciated that the tone stayed fairly light overall. It had a nice balance of charm, romance, and a bit of mystery without trying to do too much.
If I had one complaint, I do wish there had been a few more scenes focused on the two of them, since their chemistry was the highlight. At times, the dialogue tags also felt a bit overused and pulled me out of the story here and there.
For those wondering, this is a moderate/open-door romance—there’s one explicit scene, but it’s fairly brief.
Overall, this was a charming, easy read with a fun concept and a strong central relationship. I’d recommend it if you’re looking for something light, romantic, and a little bit different.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
If you’re walking into Spellstruck expecting a cozy sprinkle of magic, think again this book leans into emotional tension, complicated relationships, and a kind of enchantment that feels just as dangerous as it is alluring.
At its core, Spellstruck follows a protagonist caught between power and consequence, where magic isn’t just a gift it’s a liability. Walters builds a world where spells carry weight, not just in terms of cost but in how they reshape identity and relationships. The magic system feels grounded enough to be believable, but still whimsical enough to keep that “just one more chapter” energy alive.
What really stands out is the character work. The main character isn’t always likable and that’s intentional. Their decisions can be messy, impulsive, even frustrating at times, but it adds a layer of realism that elevates the story. Side characters aren’t just filler either; they each carry emotional stakes that intertwine with the central conflict, making the narrative feel fuller and more immersive.
Spellstruck is less about flashy magic and more about the fallout of using it. If you like character-driven fantasy with a slightly chaotic emotional core, this one’s worth picking up. It may not reinvent the genre, but it definitely casts a spell strong enough to keep you hooked.
At its core, Spellstruck follows a protagonist caught between power and consequence, where magic isn’t just a gift it’s a liability. Walters builds a world where spells carry weight, not just in terms of cost but in how they reshape identity and relationships. The magic system feels grounded enough to be believable, but still whimsical enough to keep that “just one more chapter” energy alive.
What really stands out is the character work. The main character isn’t always likable and that’s intentional. Their decisions can be messy, impulsive, even frustrating at times, but it adds a layer of realism that elevates the story. Side characters aren’t just filler either; they each carry emotional stakes that intertwine with the central conflict, making the narrative feel fuller and more immersive.
Spellstruck is less about flashy magic and more about the fallout of using it. If you like character-driven fantasy with a slightly chaotic emotional core, this one’s worth picking up. It may not reinvent the genre, but it definitely casts a spell strong enough to keep you hooked.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
We find ourselves in an alternate 1920's London where prohibition exists, only in this case it's magic that's been outlawed. Female lead Vesper comes from a magical family who run a club/speakeasy selling illegal magically enhanced drinks. Male lead Max belongs to the government agency tasked with shutting these illegal business down. Although the two exist on opposing sides of the magic ban they find themselves working together investigating a string of incidents with contaminated magic at the local speakeasys.
This is my first book by Martha Waters, so I went into Spellstruck unsure of what to expect. It turned out I was in for a treat. The setting is clever, the banter is sharp, the mystery interesting, and the romance between the protagonists checks off my "show, don't tell" box with flying colors. The leads clearly make each other better; flighty Vesper grows into her competency, while straight laced Max learns to how to bend. Throw in a cast of well developed side characters and you've got a winner.
This is an easy four star read for me. It loses one star because I found myself predicting parts of the plot/mystery ahead of time, but overall that wasn't a huge detraction. I may have been able to guess where things were going to end but I fully enjoyed my journey getting there.
Thank you to Netgalley for letting me read an ARC copy of this book
This is my first book by Martha Waters, so I went into Spellstruck unsure of what to expect. It turned out I was in for a treat. The setting is clever, the banter is sharp, the mystery interesting, and the romance between the protagonists checks off my "show, don't tell" box with flying colors. The leads clearly make each other better; flighty Vesper grows into her competency, while straight laced Max learns to how to bend. Throw in a cast of well developed side characters and you've got a winner.
This is an easy four star read for me. It loses one star because I found myself predicting parts of the plot/mystery ahead of time, but overall that wasn't a huge detraction. I may have been able to guess where things were going to end but I fully enjoyed my journey getting there.
Thank you to Netgalley for letting me read an ARC copy of this book
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC! The rating and all thoughts are my own :)
Spellstruck is an urban fantasy romance set in the 1920s with a confident and headstrong main character, Vesper. She soon finds a mystery surrounding the strange magical mishaps that have been occurring and stumbles upon an old acquaintance who now works for the government branch that hates magic. She convinces him to work with her to solve the mystery when they start getting closer and realize that maybe they aren't so different...
This book fully entertained me. I find Vesper and Max's relationship to be well-crafted and intriguing. I found the first two chapters to be a tad slow, but I managed to get past them. I also found the prose style to be very fun, and I like how it matches the time period and vibe of the story. I especially found the scenes where Vesper and Max went to the other clubs very interesting. We learned about the world and the magic naturally while they interacted together, and it was all really well thought out. The feel of this story is cozy and calm, which created an interesting change of pace for me.
While it isn't a perfect 5-star read for me, I still really enjoyed my time in this world. I would recommend it to those who enjoy light magic, cozy mystery vibes, and cute romance!
Spellstruck is an urban fantasy romance set in the 1920s with a confident and headstrong main character, Vesper. She soon finds a mystery surrounding the strange magical mishaps that have been occurring and stumbles upon an old acquaintance who now works for the government branch that hates magic. She convinces him to work with her to solve the mystery when they start getting closer and realize that maybe they aren't so different...
This book fully entertained me. I find Vesper and Max's relationship to be well-crafted and intriguing. I found the first two chapters to be a tad slow, but I managed to get past them. I also found the prose style to be very fun, and I like how it matches the time period and vibe of the story. I especially found the scenes where Vesper and Max went to the other clubs very interesting. We learned about the world and the magic naturally while they interacted together, and it was all really well thought out. The feel of this story is cozy and calm, which created an interesting change of pace for me.
While it isn't a perfect 5-star read for me, I still really enjoyed my time in this world. I would recommend it to those who enjoy light magic, cozy mystery vibes, and cute romance!
April 29, 2026
4/5 Stars
Vesper Holloway runs her family’s club at a time when magical speakeasies are forbidden. An abrupt stream of accidents caused by the consumption of enchanted cocktails puts all magical speakeasies in London on edge. Vesper masks her unease even in the face of an enforcer in her club. He isn’t just any magic ban enforcer; Maxwell Ashbridge used to be her brother’s best friend. An ex-friend who holds no ill will toward the Holloways, which initiates their partnership to find the person responsible for the magical mishaps.
Spellstruck is a cozy mystery book revolving around a privileged woman, and a jaded man who works for all he has. I find this an easy magical world to slip into with the aid of a swift pace. I read a majority of this story in one sitting.
Vesper is the good-time girl whose smile opens any door. Max is the bastard son of a man who had no qualm abandoning his child, and the woman he claimed to care for. Vesper charms her way through life, yet she struggles to understand how Max feels about her. One second she’s certain he despises her and all magic, then the next moment he’s defending her capability to run her family’s club.
There are two spicy scenes; one being mentioned and not explicitly detailed. This book is light-hearted and delightful. Sometimes all I need is a fluffy rom-com book with no gut-wrenching third act breakup.
A warm thanks to Martha Waters, Atria Books, and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Vesper Holloway runs her family’s club at a time when magical speakeasies are forbidden. An abrupt stream of accidents caused by the consumption of enchanted cocktails puts all magical speakeasies in London on edge. Vesper masks her unease even in the face of an enforcer in her club. He isn’t just any magic ban enforcer; Maxwell Ashbridge used to be her brother’s best friend. An ex-friend who holds no ill will toward the Holloways, which initiates their partnership to find the person responsible for the magical mishaps.
Spellstruck is a cozy mystery book revolving around a privileged woman, and a jaded man who works for all he has. I find this an easy magical world to slip into with the aid of a swift pace. I read a majority of this story in one sitting.
Vesper is the good-time girl whose smile opens any door. Max is the bastard son of a man who had no qualm abandoning his child, and the woman he claimed to care for. Vesper charms her way through life, yet she struggles to understand how Max feels about her. One second she’s certain he despises her and all magic, then the next moment he’s defending her capability to run her family’s club.
There are two spicy scenes; one being mentioned and not explicitly detailed. This book is light-hearted and delightful. Sometimes all I need is a fluffy rom-com book with no gut-wrenching third act breakup.
A warm thanks to Martha Waters, Atria Books, and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I had never read Martha Waters before and now I am completely hooked. Spellstruck was everything I wanted it to be and more.
The 1920s London speakeasy setting is so cool and unlike anything I have read before. The magic system feels genuinely original, and the world building is so vivid you feel like you are right there alongside Vesper and Max. Martha Waters has a gift for description that makes every scene feel alive.
I loved that the mystery at the center of the story is purely magical rather than a murder mystery. It keeps the tone fun and cozy throughout, and honestly, it was a refreshing change of pace. The chemistry between Vesper and Max is absolutely wonderful, and the romance is perfectly done without ever crossing into explicit territory, which I really appreciated.
I was grinning ear to ear at the end of this book, and when I finished, I immediately hoped this was the start of a series because I am not ready to leave this world or these characters.
If you love cozy magical romance with an atmospheric historical setting, this one is an absolute must. Martha Waters has a new devoted reader in me.
I received a copy via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The 1920s London speakeasy setting is so cool and unlike anything I have read before. The magic system feels genuinely original, and the world building is so vivid you feel like you are right there alongside Vesper and Max. Martha Waters has a gift for description that makes every scene feel alive.
I loved that the mystery at the center of the story is purely magical rather than a murder mystery. It keeps the tone fun and cozy throughout, and honestly, it was a refreshing change of pace. The chemistry between Vesper and Max is absolutely wonderful, and the romance is perfectly done without ever crossing into explicit territory, which I really appreciated.
I was grinning ear to ear at the end of this book, and when I finished, I immediately hoped this was the start of a series because I am not ready to leave this world or these characters.
If you love cozy magical romance with an atmospheric historical setting, this one is an absolute must. Martha Waters has a new devoted reader in me.
I received a copy via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Spellstruck takes place in London after World War 1. Vesper (FMC) has taken over day-to-day management of her family’s magical speakeasy. In this story, London did not have Prohibition laws against alcohol, like in the United States. Rather they had Forbiddance laws against magic. Max (MMC) is sent from a government agency to shut down the illegally operated clubs. He was friends with Vesper’s brother in university but had a falling out. Max has not spoken to the family until he sees Vesper at the club. While he is there something goes wrong with the magic and the Vesper and Max decide to work together to figure out why the magic isn’t working correctly.
Vesper is smart, sassy, and fearless. Max is proper, opinionated, and generally a good guy. They travel to the different clubs to figure out what is going on. It’s a cozy detective story, with good banter between the main characters. It’s also a fantasy book. Water spends a good amount of time explaining the magical system and rules. The plot twist was excellent and the last 100 pages or so flew by! It’s a fun read, very much in the style of Water’s other books.
Thank you Netgalley, Mather Water, and Atria Books for the ARC. This is my honest opinion.
Vesper is smart, sassy, and fearless. Max is proper, opinionated, and generally a good guy. They travel to the different clubs to figure out what is going on. It’s a cozy detective story, with good banter between the main characters. It’s also a fantasy book. Water spends a good amount of time explaining the magical system and rules. The plot twist was excellent and the last 100 pages or so flew by! It’s a fun read, very much in the style of Water’s other books.
Thank you Netgalley, Mather Water, and Atria Books for the ARC. This is my honest opinion.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for an advance copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
I needed a break from some heavy books, and Spellstruck fit the bill perfectly! It’s set in the 1920s during a sort of magical prohibition (“Forbiddance”). Vesper is a plucky, sassy woman who runs her family’s magical speakeasy, and when a series of accidents involving magically enhanced cocktails plagues the city’s magical establishments, the government sends in an investigator. Enter Max, said government’s investigator, who is a stickler for the rules, and decidedly not fun-loving.
I loved the mystery mixed with the rom-com, and was grateful that the stakes were low — no murder, just a bit of light political intrigue, lovely family dynamics, and a mystery neatly solved. The tension between Vesper and Max was uncomplicated. Instead of pining or yearning, they seem to realize pretty quickly that they enjoy one another's company; they just don’t know how to say it. Their banter was really enjoyable (I do love banter!), and how they seemed to balance one another out without overshadowing the other was a really nice touch.
This was the first time I’ve read anything by Martha Waters, but it won’t be the last!
I needed a break from some heavy books, and Spellstruck fit the bill perfectly! It’s set in the 1920s during a sort of magical prohibition (“Forbiddance”). Vesper is a plucky, sassy woman who runs her family’s magical speakeasy, and when a series of accidents involving magically enhanced cocktails plagues the city’s magical establishments, the government sends in an investigator. Enter Max, said government’s investigator, who is a stickler for the rules, and decidedly not fun-loving.
I loved the mystery mixed with the rom-com, and was grateful that the stakes were low — no murder, just a bit of light political intrigue, lovely family dynamics, and a mystery neatly solved. The tension between Vesper and Max was uncomplicated. Instead of pining or yearning, they seem to realize pretty quickly that they enjoy one another's company; they just don’t know how to say it. Their banter was really enjoyable (I do love banter!), and how they seemed to balance one another out without overshadowing the other was a really nice touch.
This was the first time I’ve read anything by Martha Waters, but it won’t be the last!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Read
May 6, 2026Hooray for advanced readers' copies 🥳
I have read this author before, although not exhaustively. The blend of fantasy, mystery and romance appealed to me.
The setting was my favorite part. 1920s London during 'Forbiddance' -- which is the magic version of Prohibition.
I was also fascinated by the construct of magic fading over time. This adds an element of tension to an already belabored magical community. While this explains why there isn't more magic, I still would have liked to see a bit more.
The mystery comes together a bit too conveniently, with the help of a twist broadcast fairly early on.
There is one explicit scene and fade to black/closed door after that. Max and Vesper do build their connection over the course of the book and have amusing banter. However, they never address a shared incident in their past adequately, imo. I appreciate that they aren't falling over one another at the end, but it does leave one feeling lukewarm about their feelings generally, (albeit optimistic). My rating reflects that it wasn't a stunner as a mystery, fantasy or romance.
Still, this will be an easy autumn read for those looking for something with non-scary, spooky vibes.
I have read this author before, although not exhaustively. The blend of fantasy, mystery and romance appealed to me.
The setting was my favorite part. 1920s London during 'Forbiddance' -- which is the magic version of Prohibition.
I was also fascinated by the construct of magic fading over time. This adds an element of tension to an already belabored magical community. While this explains why there isn't more magic, I still would have liked to see a bit more.
The mystery comes together a bit too conveniently, with the help of a twist broadcast fairly early on.
There is one explicit scene and fade to black/closed door after that. Max and Vesper do build their connection over the course of the book and have amusing banter. However, they never address a shared incident in their past adequately, imo. I appreciate that they aren't falling over one another at the end, but it does leave one feeling lukewarm about their feelings generally, (albeit optimistic). My rating reflects that it wasn't a stunner as a mystery, fantasy or romance.
Still, this will be an easy autumn read for those looking for something with non-scary, spooky vibes.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 100 reviews