For fans of Tusk Love and The Spellshop comes a romantic portal fantasy with a cosmic twist about a storybook chambermaid and an intergalactic bounty hunter whose worlds—and hearts—collide through a magical book, threatening to rewrite fate.
Della Farley has always known her place in the scrubbing floors, keeping her head down, and dreaming of something more. But when she stumbles upon a strange book that seems to be writing itself—a story about a man named Ansel Tulzok, a wanted fugitive traveling the stars—her quiet life turns extraordinary.
Light-years away, Ansel finds a mirror copy of the same book. Page by page, the story unfolds with details of a woman he’s never met—one whose words feel achingly familiar. As the two begin writing to each other through the mysterious pages, they open doors not just to each other’s worlds, but to their most vulnerable hopes and fears.
When Della takes an impossible leap of faith and writes herself into Ansel’s story, she soon finds herself aboard his ship, surrounded by stars, danger, and a crew of outlaws who might just become her family. Together, Della and Ansel strike a she’ll help him clear his name in exchange for passage to the planet that holds the cure for her mother’s deadly illness.
But every story has its price. And as their worlds entwine and their hearts collide, Della and Ansel must decide how far they’re willing to go to change the ending fate has written for them.
This was such a hard book to rate. The beginning was absolutely stunning and a completely addictive read. But then the middle dragged me through the mud and made me want to DNF. And then the ending had me in tears and wanting to read it all over again.
Let's first start with one of the highlights. The beginning. When Della finds Ansel's book and Ansel finds Della's book and they both start reading about each other...ohhhhh my GOD! Reading those parts of the book felt like having that first flirty text exchange with your crush. 😍 It was absolutely so addictive to read about and the chemistry was *flying.* I wanted them to meet so bad it was not even funny.
But when Della wrote herself into Ansel's book and teleported to him, that's where it started to go downhill. We immediately lost Ansel's perspective because she was no longer reading his book with all his day-to-day actions and thoughts. The story significantly slows down and I became less invested in the romance which made me less interested in the plot in general because it's mostly a romance plot. There was definitely a little mystery woven into the middle of the book, but I could not bring myself to care about it. I was getting exhausted with the nearly non-existent romance and the mystery plot that felt so random. I considered DNF'ing....however....the ending was SO WORTH IT!
After the middle that took me through the five stages of grief, the ending finally came to redeem the whole book. I can't talk about it too much without giving away spoilers, but it had me in literal tears. I was clutching my heart and my eyes were glued to the page. I would say that the ending alone is enough to make up for the lackluster middle. I love the concept of portal fantasy romances, so I'm happy this turned out worth it in the end.
This book is perfect for fans of time travel/portal romances, Devine Rivals, and endings that leave you speechless.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the eARC in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the opportunity to read this ARC!
3.75⭐️ Okay this might be niche, but if you’re a fan of Cress and Thorne from The Lunar Chronicles series, then you will probably LOVE this!
Our FMC, Della, is on the softer side, but I found her innocent and cheery nature very endearing. After a lifetime of invisibility, she carries this incredible passion for experiencing the world and making meaningful connections with others. Her wish for an epic love story is granted when she and our MMC, Ansel (a roguish captain), stumble upon magical books that allow them to communicate with, and eventually travel between, each other’s worlds.
Della and Ansel’s relationship was equally sweet and messy. Although their relationship is definitely NOT a slow burn, they kissed about a third of the way into the book and were already exchanging declarations of love by the two-thirds point, which felt way too soon for me. I definitely would have preferred more emotional build-up before jumping into physical intimacy and deep love confessions. Though the plot twists toward the end of the book provided important context that helped me better understand their connection.
Overall, while Written in Starlight might not have the intricate world-building or complex character development found in other Romantasy novels, it was still a fun and fast-paced read!
Really excited for this! Huge thanks to NetGalley & the publishers for a chance to review this arc 💘
When I saw this was recommended to Tusk love & The Spellshop fans ; I immediately needed to read this one. I’ve given both of those books 5 stars and I’m impatiently waiting for more books in those universes.
So I think it’s safe to say that my expectations were way too high, and that unfortunately impacted my read.
Written in Starlight is essentially about two characters who were dealt a bad hand in life, as they inadvertently find books in which in they can communicate.
My first issue with this novel was how this was written. The characters thought & behaved in some way, but the letters they wrote to each other were jarring in that setting. I just had the feeling that it didn’t quite fit together, especially how they were saying what they were writing.
The romance was the second issue I had with this. You couldn’t convince me that those two weren’t desperate for a way out of their situations. And for this reason, the romance didn’t felt genuine. It just felt like they were the only available person for them at that particular time, so it made it easier. It wasn’t natural and everything progressed at lightning speed. And I know that some readers could tell me that the ending sort of explained why that was but I would say that’s lazy. You can’t start something on insta love and hit me with that particular trope (I can’t specify without spoiling) later on to explain why it was that easy to begin with. It still didn’t make sense with the circumstances as they both had no idea.
My other issue was definitely the pacing. It was the most underwhelming read from 30-80% and I saw some reviewers saying it was worth it for the ending, but if you’re anything like me, you won’t find yourself agreeing with that. (I think I have to mention here that I do read a lot of books, it’s my favourite hobby so I can read up to 200 novels a year ; which means that I’ve seen this type of ending done a million times before and maybe I just find it lazy but that’s very subjective).
I also believe that losing access to the mmc’s thoughts/pov after they met clearly did this book a disservice. It was a bit embarrassing that the fmc kept trying and trying with her million letters and he just ignored her the whole time. And I think it all comes back to what I was saying about desperation. I do believe those two just wanted to be with someone so bad and it was just easy to pick the first one who showed interest.
Overall, I unfortunately didn’t fall head over heels for this one. I was underwhelmed & unsurprised but reading is subjective. It might be a good palate cleanser.
⋆˙⟡ — 2.75 stars ⌗ ┆started: aug 24th ● finished: oct 15th ⤿ arc review with no spoilers
৻ꪆ thank you so much atria books and sloane brooks for the arc!!
thoughts ⋆˚࿔
can i just say that i’m so sad that i didn’t end up enjoying this 🥲 when i first stopped reading it, i was loving it, but i had unfortunately fallen into a slump, and when i finally got to pick it back up, i was VERY excited. i honestly feel like my main issue with this was that we lost out on ansel’s pov once della had gone into his world 😔 from the first chapter, i was honestly addicted, and being able to see them write to each other was just such an interesting plot. though unfortunately, once we got to see the two in the same place, we immediately lost ansel’s pov, and in my opinion, i feel like it should’ve stayed 😕
characters ⋆˚࿔
⋆˚࿔ ― della + ansel
i’m not gonna lie, they were really cute in the beginning, but once we got towards the middle of the book, i kinda lost interest in the romance aspect 😕 i will say that i did enjoy the ending, so that definitely helped bump the rating up a bit, but honestly, i'm just so sad that i didn’t end up loving this when the tropes made this book sound like everything i wanted 💔
"I'll carry something of you with me now,across the stars,until the end of my days. Part of your world has collided with mine, and all because you and I met."
𝐏𝐥𝐨𝐭 ⤷ 🚀゛Regency mixed with guardians of the galaxy in this sci-fi romance. Della is a maid from a fairytale book and she finds a book about a man named Ansel who happens to be a wanted intergalactic bounty hunter. Light years away, Ansel finds a book about Della. Soon their fates and hearts collide when Della writes herself into his story and they create a bargain where Della will help clear his name up if he gives and finds her the medicine to heal her mother.
⊹.⋆🪐༘ ˖˚𝐌𝐲 𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬: The premise and cover is what caught my attention and i found the book to be a unique fantasy. I was hooked at the beginning of the chapters because of the dual POV. I found the pacing slow because I struggled to read in the middle of the book and towards the end since we lost Ansel's POV it felt like Ansel's character was only meant to be Della's lover when he could have been more than that and then the story became more focused on Della's dialogue which was more boring and slower and it felt repetitive. Now what i liked about the book was the fact that they can read each others mind through their story books and the atmosphere and Ansel's funny alien companions and that they can travel between stories. Overall this book has so much potential and I reccomend this if you like unique fun romantasy books with humorous alien companions and characters that can travel in different worlds! All thoughts are completely my own, thanks Netgalley and Atria books.
after my 2 month long streak of average and not so good books, i didn't have many expectations from this book. i actually started this without knowing anything about it and i'm so glad i did! this book actually came quite close to filling the academy 7 (by anne osterlund) shaped hole in my heart. with that being said, this book was SO unique. it was so fast paced- i read it in one sitting. i think it's best to start this book blindly. it was very immersive with very adorable characters. i wouldn't change anything in this book- well except i wish we could see more development in della and ansel's romance, and more backstory with della's mother- i hope we get a prequel- and yeah it was quite close to perfection imo. i also do wish we'd seen more of ansel's crew members in the last chapter and epilogue. but i think the ending was very open and there are chances of a sequel- tho everything was wrapped perfectly aswl lol. what i mean to say is that i wouldn't mind if we do get a sequel hehe.
*Many thanks to NetGalley for providing me an e-arc in exchange for an honest review!*
3.75 out of 5 stars!
Such a whimsical and unexpectedly lovely little adventure! I absolutely adored the concept of two people getting to know each other through a magical book, and the romance had some really sweet, swoon-worthy moments. The banter and found-family vibes were also a highlight! A few things could have been fleshed out a little more, but overall, this was such a fun and enchanting read. ___________ I received this book in my mail today, and i'm kinda sorta excited for this. The cover is so pretty and the synopsis sounds very interesting.
Della is a housemaid who dreams of a fairy tale life for herself. Maybe a duke will invite her to dinner at his house! Maybe her employer will encourage her to rise above her station! While she still dreams, her daily life doesn't seem to be going anywhere. And then one day, she finds a book about a renegade spaceship captain: Ansel. She's enjoying the story, even if the vocabulary confuses her a bit. Ansel shows a devil-may-care face to the world while hiding his soft interior from the world. And then, in his story, one day ... he finds Della's book. The two learn they can communicate through the book (since, while both of their books are written in third person, the narrator takes great pains to narrate their thoughts), and soon enough, they want to meet. But are they in the same universe? Are they even real people, or just characters in each other's books? This genre bending book combines a ton of stuff I love: historical romance, science fiction, fantasy ... and the integration of literary structure into the plot of the book. "The power of narrative" isn't a unique theme in literature, but I felt like the way Brooks handles it here is. For example, Della first meets Ansel through his interior life, and she knows that he hides his emotions from his closest friends. But even though she knows this about him, she's still taken aback when she meets him for real and has difficulty reading him. (If there's miscommunication in their relationship, it feels earned instead of like something the author falls back on!)
Yes, this is a romance; yes, it's open door, although sometimes the language is a little more vague than you might want. (I will say that I loved Della's seduction-via-book techniques!) It's also a bit more of a slow burn that you might expect based on the early emotional connection between the two main characters. But slow burn is fine with me as long as the rest of the book is cooking, and it certainly was: I absolutely devoured this book and never felt like picking something else up while I did.
TL;DR: this is a big win for me!
This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the novel.
[Edit: Increased my rating because I can’t stop thinking about how original this was!]
This is a smash hit for the pure romance girlies!! I went into this book totally blind, and if you’re not too familiar with the plot I highly recommend it. I ate this genre bending book up!
I did think I was having a stroke while reading chapter 2. Just know there’s a fun twist that is truly a mechanic of the plot, one I’d consider a new uncharted trope.
About halfway through I did have a bit of a snag reading. The characters are so dang cute it almost verged on cloying at parts. And our MMC and FMC have insight into each other’s thoughts on a very personal level, so truly there should be no miscommunication, right?? A little predictable at times, but overall so satisfying! The miscommunications-as-a-plot-device is ultimately my only gripe about the book and I thoroughly enjoyed every other aspect.
At this point in time it appears this is a standalone, which I truly have no qualms with. Although I could see opportunities for a sequel, this was a cute fun read, and I just enjoyed the ride as is! Thank you to Sloane Brooks, Atria Books and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review!
Written in Starlight by Sloane Brooks Book Blurb: a romantic portal fantasy with a cosmic twist about a storybook chambermaid and an intergalactic bounty hunter whose worlds—and hearts—collide through a magical book, threatening to rewrite fate.
Rating: **** Feels: Adventure, Interest, Fun, Satisfied Style: Fantasy, Romance, Romantasy, Fantasy Romance, Cozy Fantasy First published October 13, 2026: 384 pages
Themes & Setting: The way this mashes up fantasy and sci fi is just soooo fun and full of adventure. Two different time lines writing to each other that find a connection. Romance and finding the one you are meant to be with through everything. FMC: Della is a maid in a lady's house which is not her dream. Loved the fun of her finding the book she gets to read and discovering that she is part of an exciting story. She is full of fun and adventure !! Life is ready for her !! MMC: Ansel is a bounty hunter and a bit wild which is kinda fun. Loved seeing him interact with Della and fall for her. Conclusion: This was a super fun cozy spicy adventure !! I loved how this read was told through the lens of books and writing to start with and then the story literally leaped off the page. The flirting and getting to know each other through letter writing was just such fun !! A Library full of the stories of everyone's lives is such a fun concept and really pulled me in at the start. Totally recommend this for anyone who enjoys a good romantic adventure through time and space.
Favorite Quote: Behaving as a proper adult meant you had to appear totally disenchanted with the world around you.
Book Vibes: Found Family Portal Fantasy Sci Fi meets Fantasy Cozy Romance Letter Writing Fun
What happens when a fairytale meets a space opera, and two people who were never supposed to exist in the same world fall in love? Written in Starlight by Sloane Brooks is such an unusual and imaginative blend of fantasy, science fiction, romance, and a little bit of fairytale magic. I genuinely loved the concept of two characters discovering each other through mysterious books that reveal their lives, thoughts, and feelings. Della Farley is a chambermaid who has spent most of her life dreaming of something beyond her ordinary existence. Ansel Tulzok, meanwhile, is a fugitive traveling through space with a complicated past and plenty of emotional baggage. Their worlds couldn't be more different, yet somehow, a magical book brings them together. And that's where the adventure begins. One of my favorite aspects of this novel was the contrast between Della's fairytale-like world and Ansel's science-fiction universe. Watching Della discover spaceships, alien civilizations, and entirely unfamiliar technology was genuinely entertaining. There's something wonderfully charming about a heroine who approaches the impossible with curiosity rather than simply accepting the limitations of her world. I also really enjoyed the relationship between Della and Ansel. Their connection begins with words, curiosity, and an unexpected sense of intimacy. Before they even meet, they have already glimpsed parts of each other that most people would never willingly reveal. I loved how the story explored the vulnerability of being truly seen by another person. Ansel is exactly the kind of emotionally guarded, somewhat grumpy hero who makes a romance interesting. His reluctance to trust and his fear of emotional attachment create a lovely contrast with Della's determination and growing confidence. But what surprised me most was how much the book had to say about fate, free will, and the power of stories. Beneath the whimsical premise lies a surprisingly emotional exploration of whether our lives are predetermined or whether we can rewrite the endings we're given. The supporting cast also deserves some appreciation. The spaceship crew brings humor, warmth, and a delightful found-family atmosphere that makes the adventure even more enjoyable. My biggest criticism is that the pacing occasionally feels uneven. There are moments when the romantic tension and emotional uncertainty become a little repetitive, and some of the later revelations introduce so many new complications that I wished the story had given them more room to breathe. The combination of magical rules, timelines, and cosmic mysteries can also become quite complicated toward the end. Still, I appreciated the ambition behind the story. It isn't afraid to mix genres, embrace its whimsical side, or become unexpectedly emotional. Written in Starlight is ultimately a story about finding your own place in the universe, choosing love despite uncertainty, and refusing to let someone else decide how your story should end. If you enjoy whimsical romantasy, grumpy heroes, determined heroines, found families, magical books, and romances that literally transcend worlds, this one is absolutely worth checking out.
Thank you to NetGalley, Simon & Schuster, and Sloane Brooks for providing me with an advance digital copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
“I’ve read many stories with words that felt like they were being spoken directly into my heart. I never considered that my story could speak too, that I had the power to touch someone’s soul. I never felt significant enough, until today.”
Unfortunately, this story did not speak directly into my heart. I really wanted to love this book, the concept of it was very unique, and I was hoping for something that reminded me of Divine Rivals by Rebecca Ross.
This book had a long of really quotable passages. I found myself highlighting a lot of passages and dialogue. But everything in between was a lot of telling and not a lot of showing. The plot moved quickly, yet I found myself wanting to skim read due to how verbose the writing was. It kept taking me out of the story so much that I couldn’t focus on it. I think this book needs a bit of refinement.
It was a cute story and I loved the premise, but the execution didn’t work for me. I think many people will enjoy this, I just wish I did too.
Provided via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
I loved the concept of Written in Starlight, but I couldn’t connect with Della and needed more world building to pull me into the sci fi fantasy setting. The internal dialogue dragged, and the letters were difficult to follow on my Kindle.
Readers who enjoy slower, character focused stories with lots of internal dialogue may have a completely different experience.
Della is a miserable maid, just trying to make it through life her glum 1800s-set city. But one day she finds a book that intrigues her. It's a story about a man in space, which is hard for her to even fathom. Stranger still, the character in the book seems to be AWARE OF HER. What. Is. Happening?!?
Look, I could go on, but I can't. 🤣 I really want to...TRUST ME. I think that going into this novel knowing as little as possible is the best way to approach this book. Readers who enjoy historical romance and especially sci-fi romance will find this ridiculously compelling. Do I read sci-fi romance? Not really, 😆, but I didn't have any trouble at all in becoming fully invested in this world. Not only is this hilarious and jaw-droppingly refreshing, it's also incredibly deep. I highlighted so many lines and made notes to myself to read later. Do I have the eARC? Yes I do. Will I be buying a copy for myself? Also yes!
What else can I say without saying too much? The chemistry is top notch. We get some spice, but I'd say it's pretty mid-level. The vast majority of romance readers will feel very satisfied with the spice and be able to fill in a few blanks with their imagination (if they choose to). I adored the themes of love, not only romantic, but between a parent and child, and between friends as well. The only way this could have been any better, earning my rarely-given six stars, was if this book was twice as long. 🤣. Is it too much to ask to get a sequel? Ten sequels? Let's gooooooo.
Content Warnings: blood/bleeding, cutting into skin with a knife, shooting space blasters, threat of sexual assault, physical assault/beating, fighting, near-drowning, concerns over the health of one's mother's heart
I'd like to thank Atria Books and Netgalley for the eARC of this book. All opinions are my own.
i feel kind of conflicted with this one because i didnt love it but i didnt hate it, i unfortunately just never found myself truly invested in the plot or characters… i was lucky enough to be able to do an immersive read with this one which really helped me get through a lot of the middle sections when i felt like things hit a lull.
my biggest issue with this book is all the elements are there to make this massive unique world sloane created engaging and lush but it was unfortunately very surface level feeling to me, kind of like were standing on the outside of the world instead of being brought into it alongside the characters. theres a lot telling and not enough showing, i think this may be a product of it being in 3rd person but there were a lot of times i was left feeling confused and wanting by a scene instead of dying to know more.
lastly, locking us out of ansels point of view also really did a disservice to this story in my opinion… because of it the romance hits a weird road block that it truly never recovered from for me and paired with a “ive seen this a million times” type of ending kind of had me rushing to finish the book.
at the end of the day i think it just boils down to me not being the target audience for this book more than anything, maybe ive read too many stories like it by this point for it to stand out… i dont know.
Written In Starlight by Sloane Brooks, della is a maid in a time that looks like the Victorian era and she had to go to work because her mom has a heart problem and she needs to pay for her medicine. On the day she gets paid she goes to town to send her mom the money but someone robs her of her weeks pay and before going after the culprit she finds a package that she believed someone dropped when she opens the package it’s a book that recounts everything that just happened to her. Ansel pirate captain of a spaceship who finds a similar book in the cargo hold of his spaceship and has the same things happen to him. It isn’t until that night that they both realize there’s someone else this book is writing about and ssume they learned they can communicate with each other and before Adel knows it in a moment of quit thinking she writes herself into the book. at first Ansel it’s overwhelmed at seeing her for the first time and lets her know how he really is starting to feel for her but soon his more stubborn side pushes her away because he has loved before and it almost killed him. not to mention his best friend stabbs him in the back and is a reason he is trying to clear his name let me start by saying I like this book more than I didn’t and the things I didn’t like about it is one he wanted her to leave and go back to her time or to just leave the ship and she flat out refused,… Desperate much. The second thing is you would think she would’ve been more amazed at the technology that’s surrounded her, but no she wasn’t. Having said that to those of us who love fairytales an alien romances I would say would definitely like this book it really is a cute story a sweet romance I just wish he would’ve got on board a lot sooner but either way I love stories like this and can’t wait to read more I am definitely going to check out this author‘s Books and so whether I recommend it or not yes if you love fairytales an alien romance you will probably enjoy the story. #NetGalley, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview,
The vibes: - Star crossed romance - Space adventure - Whimsical - Found family - Open door (ish)- descriptions of sexual encounters written in letters but also experienced during the writing/reading. Not explicit by 60% but definitely spicier than I expected based on other reviews stating no spice / fade to black.
My thoughts: Ok. I really wanted to love this. I won’t be rating and reviewing it because I did not finish it, but I will be sharing my thoughts for the book up to 60%.
The vibes of this book are really fun. It almost feels like the MMC is Quill from Guardians of the Galaxy and the FMC is from a historical romance. They both stumble across magical books that allow them to read eachothers’ story. It was very much like the movie Stranger Than Fiction but for both characters. They begin writing back and forth to eachother with the magical notebooks and build a connection.
I love that idea so much. I also really liked seeing a very quirky and unique story. I’ve never read anything like this, and I thought that was a really cool concept. The humor was also spot on. I loved the side characters and the formation of found family bonds.
My issue with this was the lust-forward actions coming from Della- the FMC. At every turn she was throwing herself sexually at Ansel- the MMC. She was begging him to take her to bed for more than half of the book. I really struggle when the dynamic is “you’re so hot, let’s make out” with an added “I really like you and don’t need this to be permanent”. He kept saying he wanted their romance to be serious and she was insistent that they just have a sexual fling. She keeps trying to seduce him just for sex which was annoying to me.
I saw some early reviews saying this had no spice / was fade to black - which is my own personal comfort level when it comes to spice. When the FMC started writing out sexual fantasies for the MMC to read- I didn’t want to continue reading the book. While I wasn’t into the romance due to my own personal reading preferences - I can definitely see that this book will be loved by many. It was definitely a fun concept and well written.
Note / spice content: makeouts, innuendo, Open door (ish)- descriptions of sexual encounters written in letters but also experienced during the writing/reading. Not explicit by 60% but definitely more sexual than I expected based on other reviews stating no spice / fade to black ; Language ( a*hole, 25 f*, etc)
Release date: October 13, 2026.
Thank you so much to Sloane Brooks, Atria, and NetGalley for the gifted copy. I received this eARC from the author/publisher, but this honest review is voluntary.
I had really high hopes for this book. It sounded right up my alley and like a silly good time. Which honestly, it was! It was light, and silly, and an easy read. It was fast paced and I feel like we had quick progress through the adventure side of the story. You were on your toes often following along with this rag-tag crew on their mission.
However, while it was mostly a silly good time, I really struggled to connect to the characters and the romance. I love letter writing - it's one of my favorite micro tropes and actually a large part of why I initially reached for this story. Star crossed potential lovers across galaxies and timelines, communicating through writing? Sign me up. Butttt.... the main characters did not feel natural for me with their connection or even their interactions. It was SO rapid and really lacked any real depth for my preference.
I much preferred the adventure end of this story and seeing the interactions within the group as a whole on their missions. I'd say this is a vibey fun read for a good time, but definitely was lacking on the depth for me personally. Would still recommend for a fun read! I feel like those who enjoyed the vibe of Assistant to the Villain might also really enjoy this story!
Thank you Atria books for the e-arc!
*✧: ・゚: *✧・゚:*✧・゚: *✧・゚:*✧・゚: *✧・゚:*✧: ・゚:✧*
I just cannot refrain from requesting on NetGalley it seems. I LOVE portal fantasy and this sounds so fun.
Not to sound evil and incapable of love, but I do think this book would have turned out far more interesting with romance as the subplot and not main plot. There are some really fun potentials of this story, but it’s hidden behind a romance that feels forced, inorganic, and lacking in any real tension. The audience knows to much given the nature of how the story is centralized, and that is always one of my biggest critiques with romances.
The premise is interesting, but incredibly hard to pull off, and I don’t think it was managed nearly as deftly as it could have been. Something interesting lurks in the ideas, but fails in the execution.
A huge thank you to Atria Books for the advance copy of this book. All opinions are my own and freely given. What an absolute delight this book was to read! A regency romance crossed over with a scifi bounty hunter adventure story, this sounds like it should not work on paper. What could those two things possibly have space to share? It turns out, everything. Sloane Brooks knew what she was doing. This is the story of a story, and what happens when you have the power to choose your own.
Della, forced to be a maid in a lady’s home, is absolutely miserable. She longs for something, anything more than what she is. Treated as invisible, she starts to feel like she doesn’t belong anywhere. It isn’t until a chance encounter with a carriage, a mud puddle and a mysterious book does she discover that there might be something more for her in the world.
Ansel is the very definition of live by the seat of your pants. He’s an intergalactic bounty hunter with a bounty on his own head, and a drive for retribution. It isn’t until his last mission he finds his own mysterious book that he realizes there’s more to the story than he realizes.
Told through the pages of their individual books, the world plays out with exciting banter, close calls, lots of adrenaline and a yearning that is off the charts and delicious with its tension. You can’t help but fall in love with both characters, and when you see the pieces come together… you’ll finish this book with your jaw on the floor like I did.
Written in Starlight is available October 13 and I beg you, implore you even to get a copy for yourself. This is truly a wonderful story you can’t help but get lost in.
this book was just as beautiful and stunning as the cover makes it out to be, and i wish so badly that i could be rating this higher than a mediocre three stars, but i fear it did drag so bad in the middle. was so bored i wanted to cry. the ending tied everything up really nicely at least!! but this definitely didn't live up to the potential it had.
thank you netgalley & the publisher for an arc! all opinions are my own <3
This was a cute story, and I really liked the premise, but the pacing is what killed it for me. I was hoping for more of a slow-burn romance, and honestly, I think the story would have worked better that way. The execution just didn't quite do it for me, even though I still enjoyed the story overall. 🚀📚
Written in Starlight is a cross-genre romantic science fiction/fantasy that packs in loads of banter and sweetness along with a unique premise. Della labors as a maid in an abusive Victorian-style household, sending all of her money to her ill mother far away. Then she finds a book in the street about a roguish starship captain and his alien crew--and reads about him finding a book about her life. The two quickly begin to communicate, and sparks fly--and those only increase when Della writes herself into his world to save his life.
The banter is incredible fun. The author did a great job of handling the delicate matter of the invasive nature of reading each other's thoughts. I was a bit confused by brief bits about a special library that is mentioned from the start, but major twists at the end explain things and it all works out in a fun and surprising way.
This is a hard one for me to rate. I thought the beginning was cute, but the pacing in the middle was a struggle. I probably would have DNF’d, but I wanted to see if it was a book I could recommend to my teenage niece.
I thought the story was cute overall, but I think it was a bit too YA for me.
Enjoyed reading this book and was originally attracted by the unique communication from their own timelines (a la The Lake House). I am a sucker for these type of stories - the connection that's made via the written word. The story follows Della, a maid, who is living in a regency time period and Ansel, who is in a future timeline.
They communicate back and forth, lending advice and trying to make their lives (in their respective timelines) better, and then ultimately, Della ends up in the same timeline was Ansel (which was an interesting twist) when things don't go as expected. I thought the book was going a certain way, but the twists and turns made it interesting and the uncovering of all the secrets made the ending a page-turner.
While the book goes slowly as the world is being built, hang in there, the ending will make up for it and explain all the foundational work that was done at the beginning.
I genuinely didn’t know I needed an intergalactic, magical, letter-writing romance in my life until Written in Starlight came along and completely stole my heart. This was whimsical, adventurous, romantic, and SO much fun.
Della dreams of more, but she never expected that “more” would come in the form of a magical book connecting her to Ansel Tulzok, an intergalactic bounty hunter with a whole galaxy of problems. And then she basically goes, “welp, guess I’m going to space!” 😂
AND I LOVED HER FOR IT.
The crew. The space ports. The mismatched plans. The magic. Every ridiculous little adventure. I was completely along for the ride.
And then there’s Ansel and Della.
OH. MY. GOSH.
The letters. The flirting. THE FLIRTING. These two had me giggling at my book and yelling, “JUST KISS ALREADY!” The way their relationship slowly unfolded while Della uncovered pieces of her past was so beautiful.
And those spicy letters? 👀 DELICIOUS.
But that ending?!
My emotions went THROUGH IT.
First I was desperate. Then I was heartbroken. Then I was crying because WHY WOULD YOU DO THIS TO ME?! And just when I thought I was completely emotionally wrecked, my tears somehow turned into this overwhelming sense of relief and warmth that had me sitting there like… wait. WAIT. 😭
I need more. I need answers. I need these characters back in my life immediately. I am absolutely not ready to leave this world behind.
Written in Starlight was magical, romantic, adventurous, funny, and completely unexpected. I came for the romance and somehow left emotionally attached to an entire galaxy.
Sloane Brooks, WHAT HAVE YOU DONE TO ME?! I NEED MORE. 🚀
This was a very unique and interesting story. I really liked the mix of worlds as well as the magical book aspect. This novel had plenty of twists and action and just enough romance to keep it well balanced. Della and Ansel are really cute together and their story is sweet. I would probably consider this book a science fiction romance, which is a genre that is not written enough in my opinion. I love to see authors writing new books in this genre because I'm a huge fan and need more. This is a book I'll be recommending to anyone looking to branch out from typical romance into sci-fi romance.
Thank you NetGalley and Atria Books for access to the ARC in exchange for an honest review. Pub Date: 10/13/26
I’m not a guy who leaves a lot of reviews. I also don’t read a ton of romance novels. But every once in a while, a book comes along that’s so fricken good you can’t help but gush about it. And when that happens, you write a review.
Written in Starlight by Sloane Brooks is one of those books.
But dude. THIS WAS SO GOOD.
And honestly? I’m mostly just mad that I don’t get more of Della, Ansel, and the crew.
I WANT TO SEE THESE PEOPLE GO ON ADVENTURES.
Sloane absolutely nailed the found-family dynamic. This crew was cozy, hilarious, endearing, and just so damn easy to fall in love with. I wanted more time with them. More banter. More adventures. More of them just existing together. This could have been a kick-ass series, and I would happily read every single book.
Especially if Errol is involved. Almost every line out of their mouth had me dying. Absolute gold.
But Della. Holy hell, Della.
What an incredible character.
Her optimism and hopefulness were infectious in a way that felt genuinely refreshing. And Brooks does something I think is deceptively difficult: creating a character who is kind and hopeful without making her naive, foolish, or oblivious to the world around her.
Della is bold yet introverted. Innocent but wise. Vulnerable without being weak. She has this beautiful combination of qualities that makes her feel like a real person rather than a collection of character traits designed to make you like her.
And I absolutely loved her for it.
And then there's the way this story plays with love and storytelling itself.
In many ways, this is a love story told in reverse. We begin with love, vulnerability, and literally no walls between the characters, then work our way back toward that first meeting. It's such a clever way to approach a romance, and it gives the story a perspective that feels fresh and meaningful.
That willingness to play with tropes and reader expectations is one of my favorite things about Brooks's writing. There's a definite meta quality to these books, but it never feels cynical or like the author is simply winking at the audience. Instead, it's done with cleverness, affection, and a genuine love for the genre.
You can feel that love throughout this entire book.
The foreshadowing was fantastic, too. The way the threads come together, the connections that become clear, and the way everything ultimately pays off made for such a satisfying reading experience. Nothing felt like it was there by accident. And when the pieces finally fell into place, it was chef's kiss.
The prose deserves a shout-out as well. Beautiful and almost lyrical when it needed to be, snappy and quick when the story called for it. The writing knows when to slow down and let a moment breathe and when to get out of its own way and let the characters carry things.
But more than anything, this book felt like a love letter.
A love letter to books. To storytelling. To the journey of a story and all the possibilities contained within it. To the idea that a story can be more than its plot, more than its tropes, and more than the sum of its parts.
And I think that's why this might be the most hopeful story I've read from Brooks.
Hope is such an underrated ingredient in storytelling.
One of my longtime pet peeves with science fiction is how much of the genre seems to have drifted away from something I used to love about it: the idea that the future could be wonderful.
There was a time when science fiction was full of possibilities. Teleporters! Space travel! Incredible technology! A future where humanity might accomplish amazing things and the universe was full of adventures waiting to happen.
Somewhere along the way, so much of the genre became darker, grittier, and more concerned with what could go wrong. And while there's absolutely a place for those stories, I sometimes miss that sense of wonder. That feeling that the future could be something we look forward to rather than something we fear.
Maybe that's a reflection of the times we live in.
But Written in Starlight reminded me how wonderful it can be to read a story that chooses hope.
Not because it ignores vulnerability or pretends the world is perfect. But because it understands that hope, kindness, love, and the connections we make with other people are worth celebrating anyway.
And that's a beautiful thing.
So, Sloane Brooks, I'm impressed. Just genuinely, ridiculously impressed.
And it will be a goddamn tragedy if you don't write another book featuring a found-family team, party, crew, or whatever the hell you want to call them. You do this so effortlessly that I desperately need to see you do it again.
Give me more characters to fall in love with. More ridiculous banter. More adventures. More of that cozy, chaotic, wonderful feeling of watching a group of people become a family.
I don't care what the setting is. I'll be there.
Five stars. An absolute delight. And I can't wait for the next one.
This was my first Sloane Brooks novel, and I was blown away by it. The prose was gorgeous, and I was sincerely impressed with the generous use of figurative language. My writer's brain has been trying to puzzle out how the heck Sloane managed to cobble this story together. It was a layered narrative and whimsically meta—it's a book about a book within a book—and Brooks pulled it off like it was the easiest story to write in the world.
There's no better way of saying it: I drooled over the prose in this book. By the time I finished reading the novel, my ARC was more highlighted than not. The figurative language was masterfully done. It was emotionally invoking, fantastic at creating imagery, and was a true strength of this novel.
Della and Ansel's relationship was an absolute dream to experience. First, both characters were made for fantastic narrators early on. But I did enjoy the novel naturally falling away to focus on Della's perspective (and subsequent character arc). And the focus on one narrator did not detract from the romance unfolding between Della and Ansel. The yearning, the silent caring, the adoration these two had for each other—well, it was no surprise their romance gave this reader uncontrollable butterflies on numerous occasions.
For all the reasons why I adored this novel, there is also one reason why I dropped a star from the reader. I can't deny the prose, plotting, and characters were enchanting to read about. However, the third act plot arc was slightly baffling.
This novel was enchanting and the storytelling had me hooked from the very first line. I will be thinking about Della and Ansel for some time to come and can't wait to get my hands on more of Sloane's Brooks writing.
Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.