A sizzling yet sweet festive rom-com about a small-town theatre director forced to put her faith in the woman who once shattered her heart, so they can save not only the show, but their whole community, too.
In Cedar Creek, Christmas is no joke, and the annual seasonal play is the centerpiece of the festivities. As director, Bo Amaratunga is not only filling the boots of her mother, but fulfilling her role as community organizer—bringing people together for a night of queer joy and merriment.
When a local landmark goes up for sale, and the town looks to Bo to save it, she does exactly what her mother would draws up plans to produce the loudest, most magical play to save the day—or at least bring in enough ticket sales to fend off any prospective buyers. To pull it all off, Bo needs a set builder who can bring her vision to life, but the only option seems to be the newly returned Val Morales, Bo’s long lost high school sweetheart. Sure, Val’s incredibly talented, more than willing to help, and still makes Bo’s pulse race, but how can she trust the girl who ghosted her and left her devastated ten years ago? And why did Val come back after all these years, anyway?
Val Morales didn’t think she’d ever find herself back in Cedar Creek. Freshly divorced, unemployed, and floundering, she was glad to take the lifeline when her demanding parents offered her a job helping out with their realtor business. When they ask her to find a buyer for their lucrative property in Cedar Creek, she jumps at the opportunity to escape their disappointment at her life’s recent downturn and hopefully even impress them. She wasn’t expecting to run into Bo, her first, most pivotal love, or for Bo to ask for her help designing the set for the annual holiday play. When Val realizes the property she’s trying to sell is the same one the play is trying to save, she is forced into an impossible place—will she break Bo’s heart all over again?
As the past and their longing for one another creeps up on them, Bo and Val must figure out a way to maneuver around their conflicting goals and pressures.
At once an utterly delightful holiday romcom and a tender exploration of past, present, and future selves, Tanya Boteju’s adult debut Setting the Stage For Christmas will warm hearts in any season.
TANYA BOTEJU lives on the unceded territories of the Musqueam, Squamish, and Tsleil-Waututh First Nations (Vancouver, BC). Part-time, she teaches English to clever and sassy young people. The rest of her time, she uses writing as an excuse to eat pastries. Her debut novel, KINGS, QUEENS, AND IN-BETWEENS, was named a Top Ten Indie Next Pick by the American Booksellers Association, as well as selected for the American Librarian Association 2020 Rainbow List. Her second novel, BRUISED, was selected as a Gold Standard book by the Junior Library Guild. Look for another YA novel, MESSY PERFECT, and a middle grade nonfiction book about allyship in 2025. In both her teaching and writing, Tanya hopes she’s bending the universe even the tiniest bit toward justice. Visit her at tanyaboteju.com.
This novel was a mixed bag for me. I definitely enjoyed it but also found it underwhelming. Great if your looking for an easy read, maybe not for you if your looking for something that will leave an impact.
I Liked: -The small town vibes and the Christmas spirit. -The characters and side characters, who were a lot of fun, and I wish we had gotten to see more of them (or them in different situations and settings). -The relationship had some delightfully supportive moments that were heartwarming. -The plotline wove a delightfully convoluted web without feeling forced or requiring a suspension of disbelief. -No plot points were pointlessly dragged out. -Happy vibes.
I Didn’t Love: -The whole thing was just kind of underwhelming? -The conflict was relatively weak. This works if you’re looking for something light and fluffy but I think I was hoping for more substance. -The conflict wasn’t reasonable. One of the protagonists was really expecting something from the other that I don’t think is realistic or fair. Somewhat of a case of bad plotting perhaps? -A little bit too cliché maybe? Which I realize is a bad criticism when I'm reading a Christmas Romance, but here we are I suppose.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing a free ARC. This honest review was left voluntarily.
Determined to fill the shoes of her late mother, Bo Amaratunga has taken on a variety of roles in the town of Cedar Creek including directing the annual play during the Christmas season. This year she is planning the biggest production ever as a fundraiser to save a local landmark which is rumoured to be up for sale. Bo has very ambitious plans but she needs a capable set builder and the only option appears to be Val Morales, the highschool sweetheart that Bo hasn't seen in more than a decade, who has recently returned to town. Val, freshly divorced and working for her realtor parents, has been sent to Cedar Creek to find a buyer for a lucrative property they own - the same one Bo is trying to save.
This is a sweet (and a bit spicy) second chance Christmas romcom set in a charming small town about two women who had a brief high school relationship and find themselves working together years later on a queer retelling of A Christmas Carol. The main romance and the plot itself is chaotic and messy in a fun way and there's also found family via a diverse group of secondary characters and a journey of emotional healing and self-discovery for both women - overall a fun and festive read for the holiday season!
Thank you to Simon & Schuster Canada for providing an ARC of this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
I was so excited for this adult debut from Canadian YA author, Tanya Boteju and the fact that it was a FF Christmas story just made it all the better! Heartfelt, feel-good, second chance festive romance that I couldn't put down! I loved that the story revolved around a queer Christmas Carol retelling and that there was a close-knit, small town community that band together to help save a small indie business in their midst. Lots of emotional depth, parental drama/neglect and grief over dead loved ones. I am hopeful for more adult love stories from this author and will be recommending this one all season long! Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early digital copy in exchange for my honest review.
Tanya Boteju continues to prove exactly why she deserves all the accolades she receives, and Setting the Stage for Christmas is a shining example of her talent. This release from Simon & Schuster is a magnificent 5-star read that brilliantly balances laugh-out-loud holiday chaos with genuine emotional depth.
The romance follows a delightfully messy "friends to lovers to disdain to lovers" trajectory. It is a dynamic that requires a careful hand to pull off, but the chemistry here makes every stage of their evolving relationship deeply compelling. What truly grounds the narrative, however, is the emotional weight both main characters carry. Both MCs are navigating significant past trauma, but from vastly different places. One is dealing with the impact of a wonderful mother, while the other is unpacking the heavy baggage of spiteful, ignorant child neglect and unrealistic parental expectations. Boteju handles this contrast beautifully, adding a rich layer of vulnerability to their eventual connection.
Beyond the central pairing, the book is elevated by a fantastic found family and an incredible, super diverse cast of side characters. They bring so much life, humor, and heart to the story that I am firmly keeping my fingers crossed for a Book #2 set in this universe!
If you are looking for a subtle, quiet read, look elsewhere. The ending—much like every other scene in the novel—is ridiculous, hilarious, and over-the-top in the absolute best way possible. It leans fully into its own theatricality, wrapping up an angst-tinged romance with pure, unadulterated joy. Highly recommended.
Thank you to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I read the blurb and a cute little holiday sapphic romance novel with both main characters being women of colour sounded good to me. I wish I loved it...
What I struggled the most with was believing that a 5-month-long teenage relationship ending abruptly when her girlfriend moved away traumatized this woman so much that she couldn't have any serious relationships afterward. I understand her teenage self being hurt, angry, and confused, but 10 years later, she should have matured enough to realize her girlfriend wouldn't have had a say in moving away and kids just don't stay in touch when they're not directly in each other's orbit. The hurt would have been easier to believe if they'd been friends/dating for years rather than less than 6 months.
The romance is... not good. There's a lot of telling, not enough showing, and the chemistry doesn't really feel present. Bo is overly prone to strong swings of emotion and somehow blames all her emotional trauma on Val. She's also annoyingly unself-aware and self-centred for someone who supposedly spends all her time giving to others and is made out to be the heart of the town. After Bo publicly humiliates Val, Bo plans a "grand romantic gesture" instead of having a normal adult conversation with Val when Bo is the one who said she needed space. It falls flat and feels cowardly and immature to use kids to apologize for her in public, and puts social pressure on Val to accept the apology in front of everyone or she'll look like a jerk. Bo also "outed" Val's barn plan to her parents without her consent, forcing Val to explain her sabotage to her parents - also in public. And somehow, instead of being outraged, Val finds it super touching and immediately wants to get in Bo's pants. Yay, happy ending!!! ...That was sarcastic.
Similarly, the sex scenes are forgettable. Nothing offensively bad, but nothing that stands out, either. I didn't have enough emotional investment for their first time to feel earned, and I couldn't pinpoint anything about the sex that felt unique to these characters and their relationship. They supposedly don't have much experience, but they're both apparently amazing at it. Adding in a little bit of fumbling awkwardness that they can giggle about together would've helped it feel more natural.
There's one particular scene where Val gets help from the townspeople for a project, but she's never shown to interact with said people prior to them helping her here (aside from Bo's 3 friends). It's meant to show how the community pulls together for their own and that Val is becoming part of that community, but it ends up coming out of nowhere because we don't see those relationships established beforehand. Especially with Val's socially awkward personality, we can't infer she's been making friends among the townsfolk during her stay or while working on the set. Then suddenly, she's orchestrating a project with a group of people?
I hate that I'm saying this, but this book mostly bored and then irritated me. Especially toward the end. Too much telling, not enough showing; main characters that are too emotionally immature for their age (if the author wanted them to act this way, age them down - they're acting like teenagers when they're almost 30); a cringe-worthy climax with unrealistic reactions to situations; and generic banter, flirting, and sex scenes that give no chemistry. The whole thing feels pretty bland except for it being sapphic and with a diverse cast. I wanted a cute little holiday romance with some steam, but it unfortunately fell flat.
This book was an absolute sapphic holiday delight! Small town with a compelling central relationship and a delightful cast of supporting characters, this one checks all the boxes. When we first meet Bo and Val, they’re both a little damaged, Bo still reeling from her mother’s passing and some self-imposed pressure to live up to the wonderful person her mother was in life, Val reeling from her divorce and pressure from her parents that place her into a box that doesn’t reflect who she truly is. The two of them do share a past from their high school days, and while this does play into their present-day relationship, I appreciated that this wasn’t overly drawn out, we didn’t dwell too much on the tiny details of the past, and are fairly quickly given enough of a glimpse to understand what happened. As we see Val grapple with standing up for who she truly is and what she truly wants, this almost has hints of coming of age, something that in Val’s case was delayed by her fear of not conforming to the expectations of others. It’s a rewarding journey to see. Overall, this was such a fun holiday read, with some spice and humour sprinkled in too.
I had a complicated time with this one. There were elements I genuinely enjoyed, particularly the character voices and some of the quieter moments of emotional development, but I often found myself frustrated by the writing choices.
I will be completely transparent; reading this novel was difficult at times. That’s why it took me so long to finish it.
One of my biggest issues was the way chapters ended. Many ended with a dramatic declaration seemingly intended to create suspense, but because this happened so frequently, the endings started to feel repetitive and manufactured rather than earned. I could sometimes predict that a chapter was about to end simply because the narration shifted into a “this time, things would be different” kind of statement. What made this particularly frustrating was that there were chapter endings that worked really well—especially when something actually changed within the scene or the author simply allowed a character’s uncertainty to linger. I wish there had been more trust in those quieter endings.
That was actually something I noticed throughout the book. Some of my favourite moments happened when the author trusted the scene to speak for itself. Val’s relationship with the woodstove, for example, initially seemed like an oddly specific detail, but eventually became one of the strongest ways the book communicated her internal struggle. Those scenes gave me a much clearer understanding of Val without needing to explicitly tell me how she felt.
In contrast, there were several emotional moments where the dialogue, description, or character actions had already communicated everything I needed, only for an additional quip or internal observation to be added afterward. Those additions sometimes undercut scenes that otherwise would have landed really well. I found myself repeatedly wishing the author would trust their instincts and let those moments breathe.
I also struggled somewhat with the pacing and character development, particularly earlier in the book. It took me quite a while to feel invested, and at certain points I understood Val more clearly than Bo despite Bo being such a central character. I wanted some of the family dynamics and motivations explored earlier or in greater depth.
That said, there were things I enjoyed. The characters had distinct voices, the relationship had moments that worked for me, and the stronger passages showed me exactly why I wanted more from the book. This wasn’t a case where I disliked everything about the writing; almost the opposite. There were moments that were genuinely effective, which made the inconsistency more noticeable.
Overall, 3.5 stars. There’s a lot here that I think will work for other readers, particularly those who enjoy holiday and second chance romance, but the pacing and some recurring stylistic choices kept me from connecting with it as much as I hoped.
A whole bunch of Christmas chaos was delivered in Setting the Stage for Christmas.
It's been years since Bo and Val were in high school together, they shared a few intimate moments, and then Val moved away without another word. This is the history that sets up the enemies to lovers trope when Val finds herself back in the small town where she met Bo so many years ago. I thought it made for a good start, but as I learned more about their initial time together it was a little difficult to believe it had such a substantial impact on their lives. I understand a first love to forever love, but these sense I was left with when reading was that they barely had a relationship in the past.
I thought it was an interesting setup why Val is back in town and it instantly pits her against a small, but fervent group within the community, especially Bo. I will say the ending was predictable from very early on in the book, not that I think it was meant to be a mystery, it's just by a third of the way through I was already thinking why doesn't this just happen. And that's what happened in the end.
The community spirit and found family were my favourite parts of the book, between the Christmas Market, the holiday play (with a gay twist on the original), and the holiday cocktails it was great to see people coming together and supporting one another. It was a positive version of a small town, yes everyone is in everyone's business, but only because they want the best for them.
I liked the characters, I liked the setting, but I would have liked a little bit more for communication between the lead characters because there were just too many misunderstandings for my liking.
Thank you to Simon and Schuster for providing me with an advanced readers copy, this is my honest review.
Bo and Val were in high school together, friends that could lead to potentially more. Val moved away without a word. Now, many years later, Val finds herself back in town to sell a property and comes head-to-head with Bo, who is organizing the Christmas play to collect enough funds for a down payment. When Val realizes she and Bo are at odds, she worries that she is going to break her heart again.
I loved the premise of the book. Val comes back to town, pitting her against a former crush, Bo, and her group of friends trying to save the barn. There were times I was enjoying the book and characters, and times when I was frustrated. It took me longer to feel invested in the characters and the book, which caused me to take a longer time with this read.
I thought the author did a good job with the characters’ voices, easily distinguishing between the two. I did wish that Val and Bo would have talked more to each other about how they were feeling, rather than to others in the community. There seemed to be too many misunderstandings and miscommunications between these two for my liking.
My favourite part of the book was the mishmash friend group who came together to create this little found family in this small town. Bo has a great group of friends, who are incredibly diverse side characters and add humour and heart to the story. I also thought the Christmas vibes were great in this small town, including a Christmas play and market.
Even though this book didn’t totally work for me, I think if you like holiday romances with a great found family and second chance at love, it is possible you will like this.
Thank you to Simon and Schuster Canada for a copy of this book. All opinions are 100% mine.
This was a light, easy read, but it took me quite a while to get through it because I couldn't get into the story. I liked the small-town setting and I liked Val's character, but it was so frustrating that she didn't stand up for herself more. I didn't really like Bo, which is too bad because she's basically the main character. It was frustrating that Bo held a grudge against Val for moving away when they were in high school, especially since it was her family's decision and not something Val had any control over while she was a teenager. It was ridiculous for her to hang onto that misdirected resentment for more than ten years. It was also hard to believe that these characters were 29-30 years old; they seemed way younger and really immature. They should've made decisions and handled situations in ways that fit with their ages. I liked the Canadian English spelling used throughout the book. This would be a good choice for anyone who enjoys a light holiday romance.
This was a great read to get you in the Christmas mood. The best Christmas theme books are the ones that make you feel joy.
The characters work so well together and you root for them the entire time to get their happy ending. There were parts that dragged but not enough to bore the reader.
Definitely a book I would revisit during the holidays.
Thanks to NetGallery and the publisher for this Arc in exchange for a honest review.
Bo is determined to create the best Cedar Creek Christmas play yet in order to save her friend's home and business. When Val returns to town to sell the property she has some doubts about her plan when she discovers her high school sweetheart Bo is creating a fundraiser to save it. This Young Adult holiday romance is a mature read, containing sexual content and profanity. It is also about two women who must face their past, forgive and give love a second chance.
Bo and Val met in high school and secretly fell in love, but Val left without saying a word. Now, about ten years later, she's back in town to sell a property that the locals aren't ready to let go of.
But things aren't always what they seem. Val truly wants to help the small town, and while working on the set of the Christmas show, she also starts finding herself again through carpentry. But will Bo be able to let go of the past and truly trust her?
I have mixed feelings about this one, as I sometimes felt like the main characters needed more depth. They also didn't really feel like they were in their 30s. However, I enjoyed the small-town vibes, how Christmas was everywhere, the friendships, and the diverse cast. All in all, it was a sweet holiday rom-com!