Days after Allied forces invaded France on D-Day, June 6, 1944, the American 90th Infantry Division found itself in trouble. The inexperienced division ran up against fierce German resistance in the marshes and impenetrable hedgerows beyond Utah Beach. Gains came slowly, if at all, and with punishing casualties. First one commander, then another, was fired. High command considered breaking up the division. Then, in July, the 90th turned itself around. Seasoned by weeks of war, new leaders stepped up; once uncertain soldiers became tenacious fighting men. It had taken a month, but they were now the Tough ’Ombres, on their way to becoming one of the finest American infantry divisions of World War II. This story of battlefield transformation – of redemption and ultimately victory – is told by Richard C. Anderson Jr. in this inspiring new military history.
Elements of the 90th landed on Utah Beach on D-Day, and once the entire division came ashore over the following days, it was given the vital assignment of attacking west to link up with the 82nd Airborne and secure the Cotentin Peninsula. Stymied by its lack of experience, crack German troops, terrain that was not properly planned for, and just plain bad luck, the 90th made slow, costly progress. Impatient for success, U.S. high command sacked a series of commanders. One replacement – the legendary Gen. Theodore Roosevelt Jr. – died of a heart attack before he could assume command. The situation was bleak.
Then, almost miraculously, the 90th turned into a different division. As American forces drove south through Normandy’s maze of country roads and thick hedgerows, the 90th was assigned the task of clearing a hill and forest along one of the main southerly routes. After a week of seesawing attacks and counterattacks, the division took Hill 122 and laid the groundwork for the Allied breakout from Normandy – at a cost of nearly 5,000 casualties in a gritty, determined battle that earned them the nickname Tough ’Ombres (from the unit’s T and O insignia, for its origins in Texas and Oklahoma). The 90th was on the advance for the next month as a war of attrition became one of Périers, Le Mans, and finally the Falaise Pocket, where the division helped seal the Germans’ road out of Normandy.
By the end of the war, the Tough ’Ombres would see more days of combat than any other American division in Europe. Its soldiers would receive 4 Medals of Honor, 85 Distinguished Service Crosses, 311 Silver Stars, 5,057 Bronze Stars, and 21,371 Purple Hearts. While earning five battle stars, the 90th suffered more than 27,000 casualties – nearly 200 percent. At war’s end, Gen. George Patton told the “Sometimes I think you don’t know how good you are. You are the best soldiers in the world.” Anything but certain, this reputation was won at great cost – and it began with redemption in Normandy.
⭐⭐⭐⭐ From Struggling Division to Formidable Fighting Force
Tough ’Ombres In Normandy: The Rise of the 90th Infantry Division in World War II by Richard C. Anderson Jr. is a demanding but valuable work of military history. I have a strong interest in World War II, and I wanted to learn more about Normandy, the 90th Infantry Division, and how the campaign unfolded beyond the more familiar stories of D-Day. This book does that very well. It shows a division that struggled badly early on, then gradually developed into a far more effective fighting force through leadership, combat experience, and unit cohesion. That transformation was the most compelling part of the book for me.
The research here is excellent. Anderson provides an enormous amount of information about the division’s movements, leadership changes, battlefield actions, and progress across France and into Germany. I especially appreciated how the book showed the 90th being shaped by the fire of combat. They did not begin as an elite or polished unit. They had to learn under brutal conditions, and that made the story of their improvement feel meaningful. The photographs also added a great deal to the reading experience and helped the book stand out. They gave faces, places, and texture to a history that could otherwise become purely operational.
What affected me most, though, were the personal moments connected to the author’s father. Those sections brought a human dimension that I wish appeared even more often throughout the book. The operational history is clearly important, but the veteran stories made the war feel immediate in a different way. We already have many books about battles, movements, and commanders. What often stays with the reader are the personal experiences of the men who lived through it. I would have gladly traded some of the dense research detail for more of those memories from the author’s father or other veterans.
The main challenge is that this is a very dense book. There are many names, units, commanders, officers, locations, and movements to keep track of. At times, I found myself checking Google Maps just to understand where things were happening and how the battlefield connected geographically. Since I have some background in military history, I could follow the larger operational picture, but it still required effort. For a casual World War II reader, the amount of detail may become overwhelming. This is not really an introductory Normandy book. It is better suited for serious military-history readers who already have some understanding of the campaign.
The leadership element was one of the strongest parts of the book. Figures such as Generals McLain, Weaver, and Williams stood out as leaders who helped shape the division through example, pressure, and battlefield command. Patton’s Third Army also gives the later sections a larger operational frame. The book is ultimately about more than one division moving across a map. It is about leadership, adaptation, the cost of command, combat learning, and how a struggling unit can become formidable through experience and cohesion. I would recommend this to serious Normandy and World War II readers, especially those interested in operational history and lesser-discussed American divisions. It is not an easy read, but it is a worthwhile one.
Thank you to NetGalley, author Richard C. Anderson, Jr., Globe Pequot / Stackpole Books for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. #ToughOmbresinNormandy #NetGalley