Perfect for fans of Jo Segura and Rachel Grant, You, Me, & the Conspiracy is an academic adventure romance that finds two history professors trying to unmask a deadly secret society.
After a bruising book rejection, tenure-track history professor Jessica Wilson is scrambling for something new to publish to secure her spot at the top of the academic food chain. While researching in the archives, she discovers a coded message written by one of the founding fathers with the power to change her—and the world’s—understanding of American history forever. But first, she’s got to prove it’s real.
Desperate for answers, Jess searches out Calloway Morgan, a Harvard PhD student turned adjunct professor. Cal was forced to leave graduate school after presenting theories about a shadowy revolutionary organization. Jess heard his conference presentation and thought his findings were absurd, but now, she believes he was onto something.
With their fates intertwined by their discoveries, the two begin to work together, but danger lurks around every corner. The clandestine fraternity that they’ve uncovered still exists and is ready to kill. With it hot on their heels, the embers of Jess and Cal’s attraction grow. But unless they can make their findings public, they’ll soon become the conspiracy’s latest victims...
Emma Barry is a teacher, novelist, recovering academic, and former political staffer. She lives with her high school sweetheart and a menagerie of pets and children in Virginia, and she occasionally finds time to read and write.
This book is the first book I’ve read by Emma Barry. It’s a medium to fast-paced academic adventure romance with an investigation, some suspense, some romance, and some action scenes. Tenure-track history professor Jess Wilson is looking for something new to publish to get tenure after her book was rejected. While researching in the Massachusetts Historical Society archives, she discovers a coded message written by one of the United States’ founding fathers. It has the potential to change the world’s understanding of American history, but she needs to prove it’s real.
In desperation, Jess reaches out to Cal Morgan, a Harvard PhD student turned adjunct professor. He was forced to leave graduate school after presenting theories about a shadowy revolutionary organization. Can they prove what they found is real? How will it affect their lives? Will they even survive the investigation?
Jess is from a privileged family with an elite academic pedigree. She’s driven, skeptical, desperate, and resilient. She becomes flustered and clumsy as she deals with her intense and immediate attraction to Cal. Cal is a department outcast who has been shunned and blacklisted by mainstream academia. He’s cautious and slightly paranoid and he’s adaptable. Ellis is an eccentric hermit and conspiracy theorist who becomes their ally. Jess’s department chair, Patrick Holt, creates significant workplace pressure on Jess.
The novel uses several tropes such as rivals-to-partners, forced proximity, and a grumpy/sunshine dynamic. The romance part of the story has a couple of steamy scenes along with plenty of chemistry and banter. The author does a good job of combining a thriller plot, puzzle-solving, and secret societies with a contemporary romantic comedy. Her background as a college lecturer and former political staffer brings thought-provoking details to a fictional story. However, the book is heavy on historical facts and conspiracy lore at times which adversely affects the pacing, especially in the first half of the book. The ending is also abrupt and wraps up too quickly.
Overall, this was an enjoyable and entertaining novel that was a good change of pace.
Atria Books and Emma Barry provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for November 10, 2026. ---------------------------- My 3.43 rounded to 3.50 stars review is coming soon.
“Seeing the truth is like being the only sober person at a frat party. How do you handle it?”
The message as a whole is a valid one of how we should not allow history to dictate our actions and choices but rather learn from it to avoid repeating those same decisions and mistakes. But, as a supposed ode to National Treasure, I failed to find any relevance in that regard when much of Calloway and Jess' time was spent hiding out in the Minnie Winnie rather than actually doing some actual detective work in the line of action. 😟
True, Cal and Jess are history buffs on the road to tenure, not action buffs, so expecting them to suddenly turn cloak-and-dagger was highly unlikely, but rather than divulging in the apparent conspiracy theories surrounding America's forefathers, it was regaled with their obvious and failed to be blatantly aroused and scared and needing comfort and smitten feelings for each other. 🙄
“I’ll face down a revolutionary conspiracy that’s somehow still kicking with you.”
I didn't mind that by working together these two very sadly lonely souls were able to develop a meaningful connection, albeit a rather sudden romance with hungry and eager spicy times. 😏 But, I suppose, being confined for two weeks in an RV would do that; he had a partner. It was . . . nice. It was very much like understanding, like, especially when the hots for each other easily negate any other relevant sense.
That being that their lives were in danger, and they were on the brink of discovering long-buried secrets and coded reveals that sadly never made it beyond the many USBs in which all the information was stored away. I never got to experience the richness of U.S. history—moments were I was spellbound by its grandeur of austere ambience, or as the author put it 'legitimately ancient'. 😔
“Like Humpty Dumpty, no one was going to be able to put him back together again.”
I wasn't all too a fan of those tongue-in-cheek, sardonic quips poking fun at the idealization and idolization of the past. It failed to elicit a satisfaction of bringing the real truth behind the massive historical conspiracy that was the Ortu Solis. 😕 There was no joy or thrill of discovery; it was a flat search when so much felt more passive than aggressive.
I walked away feeling that You, Me was more at the forefront, & the Conspiracy never fleshed out into something of depth, other than inadvertently bringing them together of their shared theories. Not really fleshing out an all-too creative or intriguing premise of a backstory that would've made reading more of an adventure rather than a walk in the park - which, the plot wasn't entirely, but it never made me feel overly engaged or intrigued by what's to come. 😮💨
I won’t lie, the word “conspiracy” makes me sweat thinking someone’s gonna try to convert me to believing something wild, but this was a fun romance that I think people that wished “The DaVinci Code” had more of a romance-froward plot will eat up.
▹My ⭐ Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5) ▹Format: 📱 eReader I am providing my honest thoughts on this in exchange for an advanced e-copy from Atria Books and NetGalley. This book comes out November 10, 2026. ─────────────────────────
○★○ What to Expect from This Book: ○★○
– FMC: Jessica Wilson (aka “baby”). History professor who is on the search for something to write and publish to stay at the top of her field. – MMC: Calloway “Cal” Morgan. Adjunct history professor who became a laughing stock after sharing some “out of the box” theories on American History and the influence of a revolutionary organization. – Location: Boston, MA – POV: Multiple third-person (but mostly the FMC and MMC) – Spice: 3 open-door spicy scenes – Tropes: history professors, secret organization, reframing American History (using fictional examples for funsies), workplace romance, forced proximity, complex family dynamics, mystery and intrigue, murder – Representation: nothing noteworthy
─────────────────────────
🎯 My Thoughts:
This is a genre-bend that I hadn’t expected, but I really enjoyed it! It mixed murder and politics in a way that didn’t feel too direct, but used for the sake of a fictional adventure. I really enjoyed the secret organization and American History aspects (more than I even expected to), but I also really enjoyed the romance.
Cal and Jessica’s camaraderie made this feel like such a unique spin on workplace/forced proximity. It wasn’t academic rivals, per se, but it did feel like it started a little like that and ended with such a mesh of their characters.
While the author explicitly tells us that the theories presented in this book are entirely fictional, weaving in real American history—like the 1990 Boston museum heist—made it easy to get swept up in the intrigue without ever feeling like the book was pushing any particular ideas. The story also gets surprisingly dark at times, but the way the author handles those moments, paired with her prose, made them feel like a natural and compelling addition to the story rather than darkness added purely for shock value.
Would I Recommend?: This book won’t be for everyone considering the subject matter, but I enjoyed it a lot!
─────────────────────────
⍟»This or That«⍟
Character Driven—————✧——————Plot Driven Fast Burn——————✧—————Slow Burn Sweet———✧————————Spicy Light/Fluffy————————✧———Heavy/Emotional
•♥Consider following me on Instagram @kelseyreviewsbooks for more visual content and bookish discussions.♥•
I went back and forth on this one a lot. There were moments where I was completely pulled in and needed to know what was going to happen next, and others where I found myself struggling to stay engaged.
I loved the academic setting, the conversations around privilege and access, and the secret-society, behind-the-scenes power structures. It has that dark, institutional, conspiracy-driven energy that leans very Da Vinci Code, and I can absolutely see this working well as a TV series or movie. 🎓
The biggest sticking point for me was the amount of history woven into the plot. It often felt dense and assumed a level of knowledge I just didn’t have anymore, which slowed the pace down for me. I kept wanting to spend more time with the characters and less time trying to keep track of historical details.
Overall, this is a really interesting, idea-driven story that didn’t fully land for me, but I can absolutely see it working for readers who enjoy history-heavy conspiracies and academic settings.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I received a free copy of, You, Me, & the Conspiracy, by Emma Barry, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Jessica Wilson has to publish something good, to get her on top. I thought this was going to be a really interesting read, and it was not it was boring, and not very believable.
I DNFed this book at 46%. There will be spoilers for the book up to that point below. The star rating is for the section I did read—technically a 1.5 but rounded up since it’s a DNF.
First of all, thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for sending me a free eARC in exchange for an honest review. I’m sorry to be DNFing this, especially because it was one of the most requested books on NetGalley for awhile, but it’s just not written well and not a compelling story.
It starts off when the FMC Jessica finds something in an archive that reminds her of this conspiracy presentation this guy Calloway gave a few years ago. She goes to talk to him about it but he warns her off because it ruined his career and it’s “dangerous.” There’s no explanation (or any hints from previous sections from his POV) as to why it’s dangerous. Jessica decides she doesn’t believe him anyway, and later mentions the thing to her advisor over the phone. A week later, she’s told her advisor is dead. She goes to teach her class and comes back to her office to find it trashed. Despite there being no reason to think otherwise, she immediately runs to Cal and tells him people from the conspiracy are after her, which is a HUGE leap to make. I will say, they do find an AirTag in her jacket, but they don’t find it until after she and Cal have met up and are on the run. So again—to automatically assume your office being trashed=a secret group is out to get you does not make sense in the context of the story. Cal gave Jessica a USB drive with some info on it and she hasn’t even looked at it yet to determine if the conspiracy has merit.
So they go check out Cal’s apartment. It’s also trashed. They don’t even mention her apartment, like it’s a non-option. But not once have either of them felt like they’re being watched, no hints as to their phones being tapped, nothing! But Cal knows how to cover his tracks because he’s been super paranoid since his presentation—several years ago!—that he’s being watched. Again, no details as to how he knows that.
They go to a house of a friend of his and it’s literally that guy Murray from Stranger Things 😂 old dude conspiracy theorist, a million locks on his front door, a stash of guns in his living room.
He lets them sleep in his RV while they’re in hiding. No word to either of their families, their jobs, nothing. They’ve decided in a moment’s notice to just hide out undercover and then start tailing people who they think belong to the conspiracy group that’s after them because Cal, for some reason, doesn’t just have a list of people from the 1700s who were involved in this George Washington conspiracy. He also followed ALL of their family trees to the point that he has a list of people in the local area who he thinks are still in this mysterious group. And this is presented as normal. 🧐
The RV they’re sleeping in is in the friend’s garage. But there’s no description of any high tech security for the garage (which is a separate building in the backyard but is big enough to hold both an RV and a giant yellow corvette.) This doesn’t even go into the fact that if you want to run an RV off a generator, you have to have ventilation so you don’t get carbon monoxide poisoning. (I had to look that up cuz the whole scene just reads like you can flip a switch in the car and the power just comes on). So a ton of locks on the front door but no security anywhere else. Also, they decide to tail their first suspect in the giant yellow corvette. Because that’s not suspicious at all.
Honestly, this book is just incredibly frustrating. Jessica even mentions that her advisor dies and says, but that’s not connected to the rest of this stuff. Except 1) that means you think someone breaking into your office automatically means a secret cabal is out to get you and 2) we already know the advisor was killed because of the conspiracy because we get that scene from the killer’s pov!!! What??? Also, this author likes to randomly switch povs mid-section, when this book should just be dual 1st person pov. Her editor should have caught that and it’s already happened several times in the part of the book I did read. If I’m reading a section from Cal’s POV, for example, I shouldn’t be getting two sentences of Jessica’s POV before switching back to Cal. Jessica has her own sections for that.
Jessica herself was also a frustrating character. Her advisor, a close friend of hers, dies, and then later that day she makes out with Cal (her reason being people don’t like to look at couples kissing so if we kiss, the people following us won’t see us 🤨🙃) and she barely spares a thought later for either of those events. It just felt odd and not realistic at all. (She does spend quite some time thinking about how hot Cal is, but it was like the kiss was a sort of non-issue. I don’t know, It was odd.)
We also get some backstory on Cal’s family and how his biological father is from some rich family that wants nothing to do with him but it’s ok because Cal considers his stepfather his dad. Which is fine as far as backgrounds go—I’m assuming it’s all to set up the rich family also somehow being involved in this conspiracy—but I think it would’ve served the story’s purpose better to get more info on the conspiracy itself and the proof Cal had from his presentation. The only proof we get in the book comes in the form of three portraits of George Washington, which don’t actually prove anything, and a USB drive that Jessica STILL hasn’t looked at by the time they go into hiding. So she goes from not believing to believing all because her office got trashed. Riiiight.
This book could’ve been so much better.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Jessica Wilson has just had her book rejected, tenure is breathing down her neck, and academia has basically informed her that her continued employment depends on producing something shiny and publishable immediately. Then she finds a coded message tucked away in the archives that appears to connect to a secret organization buried in American history. And the only person who might understand it is Calloway Morgan, the guy Jess once watched give a conference presentation about this conspiracy and mentally filed under absolutely not. Unfortunately for Jess, the universe kept the receipt.
Cal, meanwhile, already destroyed his academic career over this thing. He went from Harvard PhD student to adjunct professor after suggesting that a shadow organization may have been manipulating American history since the Revolutionary era, which everyone naturally treated like he had shown up to the conference wearing a tinfoil mortarboard. Then Jess appears years later basically saying, “Remember that career-ending theory I thought was ridiculous? Tiny update.” And honestly, if I were Cal, I would have made her repeat that several times just for morale.
From there, Jess and Cal start following codes and historical connections while discovering that the secret society is not only still around, but apparently remains extremely committed to customer service when it comes to silencing historians. People start dying. Jess’s office gets ransacked. They go on the run. At one point these two academics are hiding out in an old Winnebago because apparently centuries of secret power can be defeated by two history nerds with research skills, sexual tension, and recreational-vehicle accommodations. This is the exact point where National Treasure energy entered the chat, except Nicolas Cage never had to negotiate forced proximity in a camper.
Jess and Cal together were where I had the most fun because neither one is remotely equipped to become an action hero. They know archives. They know citations. They know how academics can ruin each other’s careers over a footnote. Now people are actively trying to kill them and they’re still having conversations about historical evidence while also noticing that the other person is extremely hot. Priorities are difficult when your professional breakthrough and your crush are happening during the same felony.
I will say, there were moments when the conspiracy itself started handing me more historical names, organizations, theories, codes, and connections than my margarita was prepared to retain. Jess and Cal would make some enormous intellectual leap and I’d be sitting there like, yes, absolutely, Alexander Hamilton, clandestine fraternity, capitalism, USB drive, got it, please continue. I understood enough to stay with them, but there were stretches where I felt like I had accidentally audited an American history seminar and nobody had sent me the syllabus.
And weirdly, for two people being hunted by a murdery secret society, Jess and Cal spend a respectable amount of time staring at each other in that Winnebago. Which I understand. Near-death experiences probably do wonders for libido. But there were also points where I wanted to knock on the little camper door and remind them that THE CONSPIRACY IS STILL OUTSIDE. You can discuss whether this is lust, trauma bonding, or the beginning of something meaningful after somebody uploads the evidence.
The part underneath all the historical chaos that actually landed for me was how badly both of them need somebody to believe them. Jess has spent her entire career trying to prove she deserves her place in academia. Cal lost his place because he told the truth as he understood it and everyone laughed. Then these two find each other at exactly the moment when each person’s worst professional fear is becoming real. Being believed by one person does not fix everything, but sometimes it is the thing that keeps you standing.
By the end, I was still having fun, but I also felt like somebody had pressed fast-forward while several tabs were still open. There were things I wanted more time with, particularly once the conspiracy started coughing up its biggest answers. I came for secret societies and historical skulduggery, and sometimes Jess and Cal were already kissing while I was still in the previous room asking what happened to the evidence. Excuse me, professors, some of us are trying to finish the assignment.
Three stars for You, Me, & the Conspiracy. I had a good time with two hot historians making deeply questionable safety decisions in pursuit of an American-history conspiracy, even when the actual conspiracy occasionally required more brain space than I had budgeted and the romance did not fully drag me into the Winnebago with them. Still, academia rarely involves this much murder, which certainly livens up the tenure process.
Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for the ARC, and for reminding me that if I ever uncover a centuries-old coded message in an archive, I should quietly put it back where I found it and go get lunch. Jess chose tenure, danger, a disgraced historian, a camper, and a murderous secret society. I choose chips and guac.
Thank you, @simon.audio and @atriabooks for the gifted audiobook! #SimonAudioInfluencer
History professor Jessica Wilson is reeling from a stunning rejection of her book and is frantic to get a new piece in the publication pipeline because her tenure-track position depends on it. In the archives, she stumbles across a coded message written by one of the founding fathers. It could be the groundbreaking research she needs for tenure, but first she has to prove it is what she thinks it is. That’s when she remembers Calloway Morgan, a former Harvard PhD student turned adjunct instructor at a community college. He was dismissed from his PhD program after presenting on a powerful shadow group influencing our government. Now, Jessica might have the missing link to prove it. Cal is reluctant. His first time down this path cost him his education, career, reputation, and nearly his life. But Jess is intriguing…HER RESEARCH is intriguing. The deeper they go, the more danger they put themselves and their loved ones in, and not everyone makes it out alive.
If you love romance novels AND National Treasure, this one is for you! This nerdy academic adventure has surprisingly high stakes! It's full of inside baseball about the academic world and the “publish or perish” life of professors. There’s also a shared nerdy love of history and research. With found family, mentors, being on the run, hiding in a Winnebago, and piecing together a secret history of the United States, a lot is going on. At its core, this is a romance between Jessica and Cal, and their high-stakes, death-defying forced proximity amps up the attraction.
Audio Performance (9 hrs, 9 min): Anna Caputo and Tim Paige's dual narration had me inhaling this one over a single weekend.
As a huge fan of not only conspiracy theories but Indiana Jones meets Da Vinci Code, this was a no-brainer for me. Being a huge fan of mysteries and romance as well, pretty much made this a must-read for me.
And while this book did have all those elements, I would say it definitely leans more towards romance than anything else, which wasn't a bad thing but was a bit of a disappointment for someone who was expecting more mystery, more adventure, and more of a thrill.
Overall, this was a fun and engaging read that was a nice for a little bit of a weekend get away so to speak.
*ARC provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*
There really wasn’t a single thing I liked about this. Apologies in advance. I rarely DNF a rom com because there’s usually something that can redeem it even if it’s not a 5 star book. But alas I just couldn’t do it anymore with this book. I made it to 71% with high regrets that I won’t get those hours back.
If honest negative reviews are not for you, I’ll be as professional as possible but there won’t be any sugar coating. The writing is at the most basic it can be. This happened and then we went here and then I was shocked! There was no building, no showing, no nothing really. None of the characters have any personality. This line stuck out to me the most because I could t stop laughing at how pointless it was “i was going 8 miles an hour faster than I usually do” and she was like hoping not to get caught. First of all, oddly specific eh? And also wow what a bad ass? 8 milessss? Lol
I couldn’t really tell you much about the conspiracy because it sounded pretty fun at the beginning and then there was just multiple plot holes that were over shadowed by playing grab ass instead of figuring out the conspiracy…
The romance is non existent. 2 attractive people in each other’s orbit decide to bone. That’s all. No tension, no banter, barely any dialogue?? This was just I’m bored and you’re hot. Spice should be a plot device where 2 people are burning so bad for each other that it literally spills over into something physical. This was just shoved into the middle. She was more concerned about how many condoms were available than MAJOR PLOT SPOILER that she should have been more concerned/upset about?? Girl get it together.
Thank you to Netgalley and Atria Books for an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Sorry this wasn’t for me.
In theory this book was made in a lab for me. I love American history (in a widely-read, seen Hamilton many times, was a poli-sci major kind of way). Jess and Cal are both educators in college (neither are professors, but close). His career was torpedoed when he made assertions about a wide conspiracy within the government starting with the founding fathers. Hers is also struggling, as her book which she needs for tenure was rejected. While trying to land a new topic, Jess makes a similar find, "It was like pushing your hand through the back of the wardrobe and feeling snow," and they compare notes. Which leads to them both being on the run in the forced proximity of a winnebago trying to solve a vast conspiracy that's lasted centuries in weeks.
So these two have a sizzling attraction to each other from first meeting, and tingles whenever they touch (and certainly when they kiss, even the classic fake kiss to hide our faces from the camera kind of way). Barry does a great job of showing them getting to know one another and liking and respecting one another on top of wanting one another. I did feel that the romance very much took back seat to the larger mystery, sometimes forcibly so. These two are wildly attracted, and legitimately don't know if they will make it out of this investigation alive, but are constantly tabling the idea of more. "Everything about him worked for her, but the situation wasn't one that led itself to pursuing those feelings." Why?? We hear from their POV how they are bored with nothing to do for days on end, they have long hours of just lusting after the other and talking about how "one day" they'll go on a date. It just felt very "this is the adventure part, this is the romance part" instead of a skillful blend. By the 7th or 8th time my kindle notes started to be "they can walk and chew gum at the same time" and "Why not??" every time one of them mentioned they couldn't act. And of course they do eventually act, and you know what? No negative effect on their investigations.
Anyway, it all comes to a head, in a couple pretty exciting scenes. I enjoyed seeing all the pieces slot into place. Barry references "the moment with a jigsaw puzzle where after hours of effort, you can't seem to work fast enough to connect everything that belongs together" and it's exactly like that.
The wrap up was a little hasty, all told in an after action kind of way. Given the identity of one of the conspirators, I think the reader could have used a little more information on the consequences in many spheres of him being made public (purposefully vague). I'd love to have heard a little more about the resolution of the Big Set Piece at the end and how it shook out, because I don't *actually* think the way people and agencies acted rang super true, but we weren't given enough time on page to tell.
Readers who love a little intrigue or thriller action in their books will definitely enjoy this book. It was fun and entertaining, and was a great opportunity to stretch my brain trying to remember history classes from grad school.
Loved it immediately because it felt very National Treasure! Full of suspense. Totally recommend if you're a fan of Indiana Jones or National Treasure because this book will make you feel like you're right there all over again.
It was very history and academic forward, but I enjoyed every bit of it. The conspiracy and mystery were so well done. I did NOT expect a ton of the surprises, but it was super rewarding that there were a few I caught onto early on.
The MC's were super likeable. Cal is a good looking adjunct professor who initially believed in the conspiracy and was discredited for it. Jess is a prissy, incredibly privileged, legacy tenure track PhD. I thought I'd dislike her, but she was exactly what I'd expect from an academic without making her insufferable. They both were insta-attracted to each other, which made for fun spicy scenes when they were in danger. However, it did feel like the romance was a side quest, which I thought made sense because I stayed for the conspiracy.
If you're into academics who find themselves deep inside of a conspiracy against a cabal that has been around for hundreds of years, adventure and danger at every corner (LITERALLY!), unlikely allies, forced proximity, and multiple POVs, then this book is for you!
I had high hopes for this one and it just didn’t work for me. I checked reviews when I was struggling with it and saw people having similar issues (lots of mixed early reviews) and knew it just wouldn’t be getting better for me.
This is heavy on the academic setting, specifically history and looking back at a conspiracy in American history. It has a mystery blended in there, a secret society, people being murdered and threatened along the way, and a romance. Jess is a history professor who finds a coded message from a founding father (Alexander Hamilton actually), which leads her to track down Cal. Calloway is an adjunct professor who was forced to leave graduate school after having theories about a shadowy revolutionary organization/society. Jess takes the coded message to Cal who is able to decipher and finally has some proof for his overlooked theories. They start working together and end up in danger along the way too.
The writing just wasn’t for me, it was filled with so much info and descriptive language that made you forget how the sentence even began/what the message even was by the time you get to the end. The elements promised and the National Treasure vibes just weren’t there like I hoped either. All in all, not for me.
I love any kind of treasure-hunting adventurous romance and anything with vibes of National Treasure (one of my favorite movies) so I was really looking forward to reading this one. I love the idea of two people on the run, forced to work together to outsmart the villains and save the day.
This...was not that.
It felt like a badly done mashup of the STEMinist rom-coms of Ali Hazelwood and a Dan Brown book.
The "conspiracy" was not really explained until like 90 percent of the book (and the secret society's motivation, once I found it out, made me laugh out loud because it was so dumb and ridiculous!). The whole thing was very vague and I found it hard to believe that someone would kill to protect the knowledge that George Washington was not the hero of history books but a puppet of this secret society. Would people really care 250+ years later? And, because we're talking 250 years ago, the trail of clues was ice cold, but somehow Jess and Cal put everything together quickly and easily. There would be the barest hint and Jess would say "oh. we need to go to this town, to that building" or whatever. Miraculously, of course, all of these buildings are still standing after 250 years. Cal, who wrote a paper about this conspiracy years prior and was laughed out of academia, tells Jess that they're going to kill her and she just goes along with him based on the fact that her office was ransacked. Then they go on the run to live off the grid because of course Cal is friends with a doomsday prepper who has a place for them to stay. Also, despite the fact that this secret society would literally kill people to keep their secrets from getting out, they have almost no security? Cal and Jess infiltrated several places with no difficulty. We're talking a stronghold where there are missing Watergate tapes and everything! And they had TWO security guards?? That was absolutely ridiculous and the whole conspiracy thing ended up being a huge disappointment.
Also, the romance. UGH. I can't.
Both Cal and Jess were quite flat as characters. They were so similar that they felt like the same person too. Both academics, both struggling to find their place with their families, both loners, etc. I didn't feel a connection between them at all. it just felt like they were attracted to each other because he/she was the only guy/girl around. This book also has one of my least favorite romance tropes: when characters get all hot and bothered for each other at the worst possible time. This book had quite a few instances of that. The last third, which should have been ramping up the tension and excitement, turned into nothing more than a lust fest. Also, Cal came across as very juvenile for getting all hot and bothered over nothing more than seeing Jess's bra.
It didn't help that the writing (particularly the romantic parts) was not good either. Lines like "not now, crush. I have bad guys to dodge" or "the bandage looks good"/"then get the condoms" were very cringy and I really had a hard time taking this couple seriously.
Speaking of the writing, the perspective changes were random and happened sometimes mid-chapter. There’s even one passage from the killer’s perspective that was just thrown in there. The book did not move from narrator to narrator organically at all.
I also found Jess and Cal to be very judgy and preachy. Cal, who, thanks to his academic fall from grace, works as an adjunct professor at a community college, really looked down on it. Jess had a holier than thou personality as well. The book was very preachy about how awful capitalism is (and both Jess and Cal would go on and on about it, to the point that it would take me right out of the story) but then at the end, they pocket a cool $10 million dollars from a finder's fee. It made them come across as totally two-faced.
Sadly, this book did not work for me. I wanted more from the conspiracy and much less from the romance.
thank you to the publisher, Atria Books, for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
⁀➴ Overall: This is a fun, adventure-filled story with lots of historical and academic references!
⋆⟢ Tropes + Vibes: 🔍 The Da Vinci Code 🤍 forced proximity 🩵 opposites attract 💙 academic MCs 🩶 nerdy banter 🔍 decoding messages
⁀➴ Bookish Breakdown: The premise for this story is interesting and unique. I love the idea that there’s a conspiracy (and secret society) trying to stay hidden and that our MCs are trying to uncover it! I always appreciate nerdy MCs and the academia setting, too.
Academia has its challenges and usually presents a lot of opportunities for MCs to relate and build a relationship. That said, I didn’t really feel like Jess and Cal had any real sort of chemistry. They had an instant attraction, but we didn’t really see any chemistry or relationship building on page. There’s one scene where they really have a heart-to-heart, but only Cal shares, and the rest is just told not shown.
I struggled with the writing. It felt like it wanted to be playful and light, but it felt more like immaturity than flirty banter. The descriptions of people and retelling of stories doesn’t feel particularly deep, and that made it hard to connect to the characters. It was also difficult to keep up with the conspiracy because there are so many random things that I felt like I needed to know about American history, this particular conspiracy, and other secret societies to follow along.
It also feels like the author wanted to give a commentary about American history and politics while telling the story, but the moments talking about history and politics feel very out of place. They are often just dropped into the middle of conversations as internal monologue. This also made it hard to get into any sort of reading flow, because one moment you’re talking about an MC’s backstory and the next moment the other MC is having an internal crisis about how American history is taught and what people should believe or feel about it.
Thank you to Emma Barry, Atria Books, and NetGalley for this ARC. All opinions are my own.
Well, they had me at “for fans of Jo Segura,” so obviously I was all over this. 😂 And conspiracy is in the title?! ADD TO CART. Immediately.
Jessica is doing her best to find her place in a male-dominated world, but after a rejection she’s not sure she can bounce back from, she’s scrambling to find something that will help her land a more permanent position at work.
Then she makes a groundbreaking discovery and finds herself seeking help from Calloway, a Harvard PhD student turned adjunct professor after the academic world shuns some of his research. Together, these two have to uncover a shady revolutionary organization that has been lurking in the depths of history.
As they find themselves on the run and searching for answers, they also somehow manage to fall head over heels for each other. Because apparently solving centuries-old conspiracies while being chased isn’t enough, you also need to add romance to the chaos. 😂
These two history nerds basically put on their National Treasure adventure pants and set off to uncover the truth behind something that could change their lives forever. 🗺️🔎
I’ll be honest… I really wanted to be fully attached to Cal and Jess, but I just wasn’t. I tried. I really did. 😂 I’m also not a huge history person, BUT I am absolutely a weirdo for a good conspiracy, so that part definitely kept me going.
And the fact that the conspiracy was actually real, and that some of the people tied to it were literally right in front of their faces?! INSANE. There were definitely moments where I did NOT see things coming.
The ending was A LOT, but I was here for the chaos, even though some of it had me a little sad. 🥲
Overall, not a terrible read at all! It just had some parts that weren’t completely for me, and I think I went in wanting to love it more than I ultimately did.
But hey, give me a good conspiracy and two nerds falling in love, and apparently I’ll still show up. 😂
The premise of this sounded so fun, National Treasure as a rom-com? Love it! Unfortunately the execution wasn’t my favorite. The mystery itself was pretty fun, with Jess, a history professor, finding out that the US is run by a corrupt secret society called the Rising Sun and going on a quest to try to find evidence to tear them down. However, the rom-com aspect of this wasn’t really very romantic, it was just Jess and Cal lusting after each other. Sue me but I prefer romance to just spice.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the ARC!
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for a copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
I want to begin by saying that I really wanted to love this book! It was billed as being like National Treasure, which I absolutely loved, so I was super excited to read this. However, this book did not meet my expectations at all.
I felt that this book really jumped all over the place with little to no transition at times, and there was a complete lack of true explanation as to what the "conspiracy" was that our MCs were involved in exposing. We don't really even attempt understanding as to what the "conspiracy" really involved until around 92% + of the way through the novel. We are supposed to believe that there are life and death stakes at play here, but why? Throughout the majority of the text, we are just told that George Washington was a "bad guy", and that now the MCs lives are in danger because they have evidence to expose this supposed fact to the masses. (Um, alright. Why would that be life changing information for anyone 250 years later?) When you actually find out what has been going on with this shadowy cabal, it's difficult to understand why that would come as a shock to anyone. In all honesty, who doesn't believe that there's more going on with the government that we as citizens are told??
Aside from how much this book jumps around (which also makes it extremely difficult for me to form a more linear response as to how I felt about this book in a way that makes sense), everything just seemed to work out too smoothly for the MCs. If these villains had really been holding onto things like the missing Watergate tape, stolen multimillion dollar paintings, and documents proving that George Washington was bought and paid for by this group, you would assume that they would have far more security than they actually did, and that actually retrieving these items would be extremely difficult, if not impossible. Yet, our two college professor MCs have no issues breaking into one of their leader's homes, cracking his hidden safe, and strolling out of there with all kinds of USB drives containing information on their wrongdoings. Not to mention how easy it was for our MMC to scale a wall, break into their compound, use the combination he found on a Post-It note in the previous villain's home to open the door to their lair, and steal even more information. But wait, we aren't done yet!! They are also able to stroll right into a hidden bunker in which all of these priceless artifacts and damning documents are, and had they not taken 15 minutes instead of 5 inside, they'd have strolled out of there scott free. No alarms. No cameras. No real guards. Nothing. The believability was lost for me.
Now, for the thing that bothered me the most. I did not enjoy the current day political opinions that were constantly shoved down our throats. I have very low tolerance for hearing about how awful capitalism is, how privileged white people are, and for viewing an internal monologue that included our FMC wanting the MMC to rear end the vehicle in front of them for having a bumper sticker she viewed as supporting Republicans. To me, this felt disgusting and unnecessary, and it was done to death in this book. And yet, our MMCs had no issue accepting the 10-million-dollar reward for recovering a stolen painting for a museum. It seemed hypocritical. Every time something like this occurred on page, it made me want to put the book down and not pick it back up.
I wouldn't say this was my favorite Emma Barry book but fans of National Treasure will love this book. There is a lot of history in this book - it's a pretty big part of the plot and so, if you're not into that, then this book might not be for you. Luckily, I AM into history and I was into the whole revisiting the founding of this nation and thought the whole secret society using George Washington as a puppet was an interesting premise. However, that stuff takes over a lot of the book so the actual romance between Jessica and Cal do get overshadowed somewhat. yes, there's an only one winnebago scenario but for much of the book, Jessica's actions inadvertently put others in danger and even lead to someone dying. The action was well paced but I did think the final scene with Patrick and Robert was abruptly cut off too soon. Regardless, this was a mostly fun read.
ARC from publisher, review is all mine.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
You, Me, & the Conspiracy is a romantic historical conspiracy mystery
This story gave me National Treasure vibes, with this huge historical conspiracy, but one that was alive and thriving today. When Jess happens upon a coded message in the archives, and recalls a professor Calloway Morgan, who had given a speech related to this possible topic. She seeks him out, and finds he may be a bit of a conspiracy theorist, but is desperate enough to hear him out. As Cal shows Jess around to possible clues, she is not convinced....not until her office is ransacked. Realizing the deep trouble they are in, Cal and Jess go dark to either try and prove this secret society exists, or be permanently quieted in the process.
I loved this story, it has angst, mystery, romance, humor, all wrapped up in a secret society conspiracy. The problem with having to go dark, is the accommodations. Cal happens to have a prepper type friend, who lets him and Jess stay in a very tiny, but off the grid, Winnebago. When Jess describes the size, all I could do was simultaneously laugh, and feel a bit claustrophobic. Add into that the sexual tension the two are displaying, and it makes for some extremely tight quarters.
I really enjoyed reading along as Jess and Cal worked to unravel this not so secret society, I felt like I was right along with them, hunting for that solid piece of evidence to prove to the world they weren't crazy. When they get an unexpected huge lead, they finally are able to make a plan of action. I was on the edge of my seat every time they did one of their "missions" just waiting for something bad to happen!
With all the adrenaline of their situation, and their intense attraction for each other, it isn't long before Jess and Cal give into their desires.
I love the ending of this story too, it is perfect for both characters, who finally are able to choose how they live their lives.
Thank you so much to Atria Books, Netgalley, and the author for a copy of this story!!
Some fav quotes: "The road to tenure was paved with humiliations."
"In worn jeans and a cabled gray sweater that pulled over his biceps, Calloway Morgan had basically been made in a lab to destroy her common sense."
"Relief and terror spiraled in him. Because he had been right, they were both in profound danger."
"Of course the woman he needed to protect was this one. Of fucking course. Leave it to him to get gooey about a New England princess with the self-preservation instincts of a baby bunny."
"This situation sucked bad enough that Jess definitely didn’t need a brand-new and overprotective roommate who happened to look as if he ought to be in a glossy catalogue spread wearing incongruous designer items and chopping wood while a Labrador ran around."
"If Jess had to hide out in a decrepit RV in the woodshop of a prepper gun nut, did her partner have to be the hottest academic she had ever seen,..."
"The amount of violence required to maintain the system, in the past and in the present? How could you square those truths with the iconic America?"
"One fake make-out session followed by one accidental ass groping did not a relationship make."
"Close enough to kiss, but not close enough to . . . rut. And that was what she wanted to do. Jess wanted to rub herself over every inch of him."
"“I did dislike you that first day in my office. I’ve liked you . . . just fine since then.” “As in ‘I wish we were banging’ fine?”"
Sometimes I imagine the book I’m about to review as a cocktail. For Emma Barry’s You, Me & the Conspiracy there’s clearly a foundational pour of her own experience in academia, some Howard Zinn challenging historical naratives for flavor, and a hearty splash of National Treasure swashbuckling for sparkle. Her love of American history is in there. And then there are shots of “what if the hot guy who was shunned for conspiracy theories was right?” and “what happens when I’m stuck in a Winnebago with him because we’re on the run from *checks notes* my department chair?” Barry has added some very bad dads for garnish.
This is an honest review, but not an unbiased one. Emma Barry has written some of my favorite books, and they are the kinds of books the reward rereads. She writes characters who are incredibly competent and yet complete ding dongs when it comes to the person they have fallen in love with. In You, Me & the Conspiracy Jess and Cal are on the run from a secret organization. So maybe being romantic ding dongs isn’t unreasonable. They’ve got bigger things to figure out, like who is tracking them and what information do they need to keep themselves safe?
I love that I’m seeing more thriller romances, and that Barry is using that structure to look at the stories we invest in. The adventure kicks off when the history Jess wants to delve into is deemed unworthy of scholarship, forcing her to scramble for a more suitable topic. When she sees something curious in the archives, she remembers Cal, the hot guy who embarrassed himself and ruined his career talking about a secret cabal at an academic conference. She quickly finds out how far some people will go to keep their preferred version of history the only version that’s told. They hide out together, researching the conspiracy with occasional bouts of breaking and entering and espionage. In a small space, the sexual tension is thick. It’s amazing how much they accomplish with Cal distracted by Jess’s bra and Jess by Cal’s forearms.
You, Me & the Conspiracy was a fun and thought provoking read. I can’t talk about the part that had me lying on the floor, because it’s too much of a spoiler.
I received this as an advance reader copy from Atria Books and NetGalley. My opinions are my own, freely and honestly given.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the eARC.
This has a super interesting concept- a secret mastermind organization full or conspiracies and secrets is uncovered by the MCs and they have to save themselves from the unknown entities. But the constant heavy handed use of obscure historical events made it difficult to follow. I am not a history buff, so this was hard for me to get through.
If this had been half as history heavy and more focused on the mystery aspect, I think this would have worked better for me. The problem seemed too big to solve in the span of the book. At the 85% mark and the big event hadn't happened yet, I was wondering how this book was going to end. The ending felt a little too neat and everything just seemed to fall in line for the built up to be worth it. Everything happened so fast and there was so much going on, that it really didn't work for me. I honestly thought, at the pace we were going, that it would end on a cliff hanger and be part of a series.
This was definitely an interesting book and premise, but the execution fell flat for me. If you are a huge historian, you may appreciate the layers of history threaded in this book. If you are a casual fan, you will be lost and lose interest in parts of the book. If you are coming for a romance, it is there, but it is minor. The history is the lead trope in this one!
You, Me, and the Conspiracy follows history professor Jessica Wilson, who discovers a coded message that could change everything we know about American history. Desperate to prove her discovery is real, she teams up with Cal Morgan, an adjunct professor whose theories about a secret revolutionary organization were once dismissed. As they dig deeper, they uncover a dangerous conspiracy that still exists, putting their lives at risk while their attraction to each other grows. I enjoyed this book, and it reminded me a little of National Treasure, which I absolutely love! I loved how the author combined history and romance into one story! I loved all the characters and their quirkiness! I did expect a little more history and conspirac and the pacing felt a bit off at times. Even so, this was a fun read for a light hearted history rom-com!
Thank you to Atria books and Simon Audio for the gifted copy!
A cute romance about two academics uncovering a secret society and trying to find proof to take it down. Going into this expecting National Treasure meets romance, I was really missing the Riley energy and actual treasure-hunting expertise! Instead, it’s a love story about two academics who find themselves way over their heads, hiding out while trying to expose a secret society and its conspiracy. They’re surprisingly lucky and good at sleuthing for being novices.
My biggest issue was that the stakes never quite landed for me. The conspiracy felt more like an elite fraternity than a group with the influence the plot suggested, and the quick chain of events made some of the action feel over the top. I enjoyed the campy hiding-out moments, but wanted more depth behind the mystery. The history was interesting but the conspiracy was a bit convoluted.
I had a fun time reading but I think I was expecting more interesting treasure hunting.
You, Me and the Conspiracy drew me in immediately. I love historical adventure/ treasure hunt stories. It reminded me of the things I love about National Treasure, The Da Vinci Code, The Mummy, Indiana Jones and Uncharted; it's what got me excited to read this book!
The book kept me highly entertained and interested, it had a high energy pacing which I loved. I'll admit my history knowledge isn't the best, but I love it regardless. I found myself caught up in the history, action and possible romance between Jess & Cal. I was definitely rooting for them! Ellis, the doomsday conspiracy theory side character was amazing too.
This is the perfect book for someone like me, who would love to stumble onto a great adventure or find a secret message to decode. Thank you Atria, Simon & Schuster, and Netgalley for the ARC in return for an honest review!
You, Me & the Conspiracy by Emma Barry was a fun blend of historical conspiracies and romance!
The romance was definitely the highlight for me. Cal and Jessica were such a great match, balancing brains, witty banter, and just the right amount of flirting. I especially loved them sharing an old school Winnebago and hiding out in Cal’s friend Ellis's garage. Ellis was the perfect gruff but lovable conspiracy theorist and added some sneaky mischief to the story.
While I enjoyed the historical conspiracy and treasure hunt, I sometimes found it difficult to stay fully invested in that side of the plot. The ending also felt a little too convenient. I was hoping for more excitement during the final stretch of the hunt. Thankfully, Cal and Jessica's growing romance kept me turning the pages.
Thank you to Emma Barry, Atria Books, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this eARC!