A botanical illustrator in Victorian England uncovers a country garden’s secrets in a fantastical novel of dark enchantments by the author of Tea & Alchemy.
In 1850, Catherine Gray, a botanical illustrator from London, travels to a remote estate in the Lake District to catalog and paint the specimens thriving in a mysterious glasshouse garden. The most bewildering find is a water lily that somehow alters its appearance. Nearly as puzzling is Thomas Bane, the brooding groundskeeper, who closely guards the estate’s secrets—including the disappearance of Catherine’s predecessor.
The mystery deepens when Catherine discovers the diary of Prudence Bane, Thomas’s late mother, which contains revelations about the odd flora and its hold on a family touched by madness. The more she uncovers, the more the line between fantasy and reality—and superstition and fact—begins to blur.
Unable to trust her own thoughts, Catherine draws closer to Thomas, her only anchor in this strange place. But even he can’t fully protect her from the house and his otherworldly family. Only Catherine can break the Bane family’s cycle of heartbreak…but first she’ll have to confront her own.
Sharon Lynn Fisher writes mash-ups of fantasy, mystery, and slow-burn romance set in lush and atmospheric worlds. Her current series of stand-alone novels (which began with Salt & Broom) features cozy gothic fantasies set in Victorian England.
Sharon's other books include Grimm Curiosities, Tea & Alchemy, the Faery Rehistory historical romantasy series, and a trio of science fiction romances. Sharon is an Amazon bestselling author.
When Sharon's not writing, you'll mostly find her wandering the Pacific Northwest woods looking for fairies and mushrooms.
This was an okay fantasy romance with some mysterious fae folk but I don’t think it’s one that’s going to stick with me. The characters lacked chemistry and weren’t very compelling or memorable. I just finished it today, didn’t take notes and the details are already fuzzy. Might be my brain but it might be the book 😳
Audiobook. Both narrators did a fantastic job, and their voices really suited the story and its Victorian setting. I could genuinely imagine people from that period speaking this way, especially Thomas (which feels a little strange to say, but it's true!). My only small issue was that, toward the end, I would have liked Catherine's narration to reflect her character development a little more, with a more noticeable change in tone given everything she went through. Other than that, I have no complaints.
The book. I honestly don't think my vocabulary is enough to express just how much I enjoyed reading this book. Sharon Lynn Fisher has created such a beautiful, atmospheric story that completely pulled me in, and I loved almost every moment of it.
First of all, the writing. The author absolutely nailed the language and feel of the Victorian era. I struggled with some of the vocabulary along the way, but rather than taking away from my reading experience, it felt like a wonderful little exploration. Fisher managed to immerse me in the period through just a handful of settings, and the descriptions were so vivid that I often felt like I was standing in front of a painting by one of the great English landscape artists of the late 18th or mid-19th century. The atmosphere was honestly one of my favorite things about this book, and I could have spent so much more time wandering around its gardens and exploring its strange little corners.
The botanical aspect was another absolute highlight. From the glasshouse garden to the flowers and plants scattered throughout the story, and especially Cricket's illustrations, everything felt so carefully crafted. I could picture the plants and their peculiar characteristics so clearly, and the addition of folklore, fae, and plant spirits made the whole experience even more enchanting. Fisher did such a wonderful job blending botanical details with the fantastical elements that the line between the natural and supernatural felt wonderfully blurred.
And then there's Catherine, aka Cricket, who completely won me over. She's curious, observant, determined, and not afraid to pursue what she wants, even in a time when being a woman makes things considerably more difficult. Her dream of becoming part of the Society, and her willingness to use her botanical illustration skills to get there, made me root for her from the very beginning. I was genuinely excited when she secured her agreement with the Society, and I loved seeing her take the first steps toward the future she wanted for herself. She's also the kind of character who notices every little detail and asks a million questions, which made her interactions with Thomas particularly entertaining. She never lets him get away with avoiding a conversation, and I loved how she kept pushing him to open up, even when he clearly wanted to do the exact opposite.
Thomas, on the other hand, had me completely captivated. His POVs were few and far between, but every single one of them was so effective that I found myself wanting more. I felt for him and his backstory, especially knowing how much he had been left to deal with on his own, despite convincing himself that he was better off alone. I loved watching him gradually let his guard down around Cricket, and seeing that softer side of him emerge toward the end was incredibly satisfying.
And their romance? I absolutely devoured it. I'm not usually the biggest fan of romances that develop over such a short period, and this one takes place over roughly two weeks, but somehow, I was completely sold. The slow burn, the yearning, and all those little moments between them worked so well for me. I loved watching their connection grow, and when everything finally came to a head, I was more than ready for it.
Unfortunately, this is where the book falls just short of a five-star rating for me. While I loved the atmosphere, the characters, and the world Fisher created, I felt that the folkloric storyline and its central conflict needed a little more impact. Throughout the book, the strange occurrences and dangerous encounters involving the supernatural creatures build toward the eventual confrontation with the fae queen. However, when that moment finally arrived, it didn't quite deliver the intensity I had hoped for. After all the tension and mystery woven throughout the story, I wanted the climax to feel bigger and more consequential. Instead, it felt as though the story had spent so much time creating this beautiful, intricate tapestry that the final piece never quite came together.
Still, this was such a wonderful reading experience, and I think readers who enjoy classic literature will find a lot to appreciate in the writing and its beautiful, descriptive style. Those who are drawn to fantasy may also enjoy the woodland spirits and other fantastical creatures, but at its heart, this is a story that revolves around botany and the natural world. One thing worth mentioning, though, is that this is a very detail-oriented story. While there are moments of tension and conflict, the overall narrative is more focused on atmosphere, descriptions, and gradual discoveries than on delivering a strong, impactful storyline. As much as I enjoyed the experience, some of the conflicts didn't leave as lasting an impression as I would have hoped.
Thank you to 47North and Brilliance Audio for granting me access to both the eARC and ALC of this lovely story. The setting and writing completely captivated me! All opinions are my own.
Bane Bloom, set in Victorian England, introduces us to Catherine ‘Cricket’ Gray. As a means of supporting herself and her ailing artist father, Cricket has pitched herself as a botanical illustrator to the Apothecary’s guild. Ostensibly as a means of testing her skill, they send her to the rural countryside to catalogue the botanical collection of the Bane family - but Cricket arrives to discover the last person that they sent for this position disappeared without a trace, and that all may not be as it seems with the strange and unusual collection of plants in the estate’s glass house. Thomas Bane, the surly groundskeeper and last living descendent of the Bane family, doesn’t offer any answers, and as the days pass Cricket is left with more and more questions.
“This room, this house, was an unsettling blend of eerie, otherworldly and cosy, with its ghosts of the dead and disappeared, atmospheric glasshouse, and oddly behaving plants, and touches of faded but homey elegance.”
Despite the fairly tense premise, Bane Bloom is a meandering tale that unfolds at a leisurely pace. It includes many minutiae of Victorian life, which gives the tale historical credibility, but also left me very impatient for some action.
We spend a lot of time in Cricket’s head, as she churns her thoughts over and over. She is decidedly naive for a 30-year-old ‘spinster’, and the combination of these two things, combined with the somewhat prissy characterization by the audiobook narrator, made her quite an annoying main character at times.
Romance forms a major part of the plot, but unfortunately I found surly Thomas about as appealing as a fence post with abs. Sorry, but monosyllabic grunts and glowers and repressed feelings just don’t do it for me, no many how many wet shirt scenes are slipped in.
The storyline had such great potential, in particular with one Big Bad who waltzed in and out a couple of times, when she could have been a truly eerie source of tension and drama in the story.
The star of the show for me was the vibrant depictions of weird and wonderful botanics. I appreciate the author’s thorough research, and the medicinal, magical and folkloric aspects that were interwoven with their descriptions. I found myself longing to experience a bluebell wood - despite the otherworldly perils that may lurk there.
I listened to the audiobook version, which was narrated in duet by Bronwen Price and Will M Watt. I enjoyed Price’s depictions of the different dialects of northern England.
Vibes wise, Bane Bloom brings to mind a slightly more eerie Emily Wilde’s Encyclopedia of Faeries and Olivia Atwater’s The Witchwood Knot.
Based on the marketing, I think I was hoping for something a little darker and more compelling. Unfortunately this version wasn’t for me.
I’m so sad I’m not giving Bane Bloom a higher rating as Sharon Lynn Fisher is one of my favourite authors and I was so looking forward to reading this book. But I just didn’t really connect with the story as much as I wanted to. But this still had all the charm and cosiness of her previous work and I’ll look forward to the next!
This was a great low-stakes, light but also verged into dark at times, read for my super draining week. It has a lot of cozy mystery vibes, Some gothic romance vibes. There are some light horror elements and whimsy magic realism that made this a great October read too. I liked the mystery of what exactly is going on in this house, this garden, and the woods. It’s an extremely beautiful setting.
The H was an outcast and this romance had all those yummy reclusive, lonely H vibes. I really liked the grumpy sunshine dynamic in the beginning of the book. For me he was way too reluctant though. He is super protective but it got to be where he was too protective and that turned into self-sacrificing, which isn’t really my thing. He was kind of fine with just being lonely and miserable. The h has to do all the heavy lifting, like all of it. He did not fight for her, ever. Blah. There is some light OW and OM drama that brought in some angst and tension that wasn’t created by the H so that was massively appreciated.
I really enjoyed this! It was cozy and mysterious and fantastical. I loved the plant garden and all the little tidbits of botany and folklore. And I adored Thomas as a character and the past that haunts them.
I do feel like the romance was bit rushed and the conclusion happened really really fast, but overall I still had a great time!
I just love author Sharon Lynn Fisher's books. All her gothic stories have been five star reads for me. This one is about a poison garden, fae, magical plants that change shape, mystical creatures, and always a love story. Not a smutty story, just a gothic slow burn love. I'll read anything this author writes, she's never let me down. Absolutely give this book a read!
A mysterious and haunting historical fantasy set in 1850’s London, where Catherine Gray is determined to make her own way in the world. Her father is getting older and she is looking to help supplement an income to help him. She takes her illustrations to a prestigious society that requests one task of her — to take up the residence in a cottage. During her time there, she meets Thomas Bane, the caretaker and son of the man who built the cottage. Catherine is determined to make a name for herself and complete her assignment, but she’s starting to experience strange and unexpected things. Her entire world will shift and who knows if she’s ready for it.
The world building around this cottage, surrounding lands and town was rich and beautifully built. There was so much detail into descriptions from the cottage to the lake it sat next to, to different areas to feel more natural. I enjoyed the usage of the Elfhame name, and the Fae being more dark, disturbing and vicious. It was refreshing that all the strange and unnatural things still held the common folk by the throat and made them wary. I enjoyed the mystery of unraveling why this cottage made people lose their mind, and how it all connected with Thomas’ family. That was a good story to follow and how much of an impact it held on present day decisions for the characters.
Catherine Gray is supposedly trying to come off as a quirky and unconventional woman, but I kind of found her childish for most of the book. I hated her nickname, it was just presented at the weirdest of times like meeting a random stranger? Thomas was fine, if not, cliche for an mmc. He displayed every characteristic of the brooding, quiet but rude until he got to know the fmc. The relationship between them felt a little one-sided from Catherine’s perspective — and often she said “our relationship was on a whole new level” because he saved her life or he did something kind for her. It just felt like she was establishing a parasocial relationship with him when that phrase was mentioned. I didn’t think they had much in common, nor did they really have a romantic connection. It just seemed more like they shared the same space for a long time and it just happened to see one another as more.
Everything else was fine, the narrator did a good job but I think my issue came mostly from the characters and the relationship itself. I enjoyed the mystery, the magic and the descriptive scenery and even some of the dialogue.
Thank you NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for this advanced listeners copy. My review is my own.
I feel bamboozled. This was a cute, whimsical, low stakes romantic fantasy. Which caught me by complete surprise when it's marketed with words like "madness", "disappearance" and "dark gothic". For what it ACTUALLY is, it wasn't bad. 🤷🏽♀️ The beginning had a slow burn connection between Thomas and Catherine (Cricket when she's acting like a toddler) and there's some mysterious, fantastical things happening around the botanicals that were very interesting. And then about halfway through it lost me completely 🙃 This feels like it should be written and read as a YA romantasy. The romance (if you can call it that) was honestly childish, rushed and seemed like it bloomed from proximity and necessity rather than anything else. Thomas continued to call her “Lass” and a child throughout the entire book, making fun of her nickname, then suddenly she is sitting on his lap and they’re kissing?? What?? Did I miss a step? This is a little weird right? It seemed so misplaced and awkward going from them portraying a 30 year old as a child straight to spice. 😬 The mystery of what happened to her predecessor and what the flower is was solved about halfway through as well and I was genuinely confused what else there even was to cover. The stakes are so low fr. Even Catherine goes from acknoweding that the fae are trying to abduct the guy she likes and take his land and life's work, and she is like "What a great opportunity to draw fairies!” Like what?🤦🏽♀️ Then a ghost tries to play matchmaker on a relationship that is surface level AT BEST, the fae queen is jealous and wants him too, there is animal transformations and fae creatures running amok, and not an ounce of mystery, tension, buildup or intrigue to be found.🤷🏽♀️ There was no “will they won’t they” so most of the banter and potential other suiters was pointless. Most of the second half was just filler, pretending that they won’t get together. 🙄 Then the big reveal happened. And I laughed very hard 😂I might just leave my notes here real quick (slight spoilers):
Wut. Thomas is what. What??? .... WHAT??? Oh ok, and she's immediately perfectly fine with it. Oh she's calling him by his fae name. It's Thomas, Stop. Oh the fairy Queen wants him to be her consort. And the fairy Queen is jealous of Catherine? And Thomas can't leave because he's half fairy horse? ... Ok 🙄🙃😂
In the end they lived happily ever after and got everything they ever wanted. It was sweet and cute, but a bit undeserved and rushed, but a feel good ending. They get to keep the land, Thomas gets to keep being a horse and Catherine might give him little horse babies someday and show them her fairy drawings. Yay.
I got a bit bamboozled by this one because if there’s really a thing called cozy gothic then Sharon Lynn Fisher has mastered the art of it. From reading her Jane Eyre witchy retelling in Salt & Broom, homage to vampirism in Victorian gothic literature in Tea & Alchemy, and pastiche of Victorian Christmas ghost story in Grimm Curiosities, naturally i expected Bane & Bloom to deliver another excellence, based on its premise, maybe along the lines of T. Kingfisher’s Wolf Worm? with less grotesqueness and more coziness to it? Alas it turned out more in the line of historical cozy fantasy that is so popular these days. It wasn’t really my cup of tea especially as it was a bit heavy in the romance department but admittedly it was still a good read when i pushed through because the author as always, managed skillfully to blend historical accuracy in Victorian era, English folklores, gothic elements or at least its aesthetics (though in Bane & Bloom it was lacking) and wrapped it all up in a cozy vibes that makes all her book a pleasant autumnal/spooky read.
Sharon Lynn Fisher always writes the most beautifully constructed historical romances with just enough fantastical elements. I loved the folklore and slow burn of it all. It truly does feel like you get dropped into this world, surrounded by well realized worlds and characters.
I especially loved the magic included in this story, a tale of fae, kelpies, and a flower that can grant wishes. Another great tale from Sharon Lynn Fisher - she has very quickly become an auto-read author for me!
The nitty-gritty: Moody, dark and romantic, Bane Bloom combines intrigue and a bit of magic in an atmospheric setting, perfect for fans of Gothic romance.
Sharon Lynn Fisher’s latest fantasy romance is the perfect book to cozy up to as we slide into the Fall spooky season! Bane Bloom incorporates so many of my favorite elements, like folklore, witchcraft, faeries and a delicious slow burn romance that ties everything together.
The story takes place in 1850 England and follows thirty-year-old Catherine “Cricket” Gray, a botanical illustrator. Cricket lives with her father in London but she wants nothing more than to be accepted into the Society of Apothecaries, which is a difficult goal to achieve for a woman. Luckily, she’s able to meet with Society member Mr. Harding who agrees to send her on a month long assignment in Buttermere, taking notes and illustrating the many plants and flowers—many of them poisonous—at a small house called Pine Cottage.
When Cricket arrives, she’s greeted by the groundskeeper of the cottage, Thomas Bane, who is in charge of nurturing the plants housed in the glasshouse outside. Thomas is gruff and unfriendly and doesn’t want to answer her many questions at first. But Cricket is very curious and doesn’t give up, especially when odd things start happening to her. She’s particularly drawn to a beautiful, otherworldly flower in the glasshouse that she calls the Bane Bloom, a flower that seems to change appearance in the moonlight. She also senses a ghostly presence in the house that leads her to discover an old, secret diary written by Thomas’s mother Prudence.
But when the odd occurrences suddenly turn dangerous, Cricket knows she must get Thomas to trust her with the secrets of Pine Cottage. Because the apothecary who came before her, Charles Carroll, vanished from Pine Cottage and hasn’t been seen since, and Cricket does not want the same thing to happen to her.
Sharon does a brilliant job (as always!) of creating a wonderful Gothic vibe. The secluded cottage, the poison garden, the brooding love interest and talk of witches and faeries all add to the atmosphere, and I was immediately immersed in her world. I also loved that Cricket is interested in the science of botanical healing and remedies from folklore, which are explored in detail. I thought the combination of plant lore and art was so interesting, especially when Cricket explains that she is writing and illustrating a book for children that even incorporates faeries into the art.
There are several mysteries going: the disappearance of Carroll, the mysterious Bane Bloom, the diary Cricket finds that hints at even more mysteries surrounding Pine Cottage, and the biggest one of all—Thomas, who seems to be much more than he appears. Thanks to Cricket’s curiosity, all of these mysteries converge by the end of the book in some very satisfying ways.
And speaking of Cricket, I loved how “outside the box” her character was, especially for a woman in this time period. She’s more interested in educating herself than worrying about marrying, and at thirty she has no illusions about finding a husband. Once she discovers a mystery, she will do anything to solve it, although she comes across as a bit nosey at times. For the first time in her life, she’s away from her father, so the loneliness of the cottage is starting to affect her, and this eventually brings her closer to Thomas.
I enjoyed Thomas’s character as well. He’s a little harder to get a handle on, since you know right away he’s hiding something big, but it was fun trying to guess what that was (I did finally figure it out before the reveal!) At first the dynamics between the two are a little skewed. Cricket sees Thomas as the caretaker of the cottage, below her station, in other words, and it takes some time for her to get past this. But eventually their growing attraction to each other breaks down those barriers, and I ended up loving the way their slow burn romance played out.
There’s yet another subplot later in the story involving the fate of Pine Cottage, and by this time Cricket’s life has become entangled with the cottage and its history, as well as Thomas, so there’s quite a bit of tension. Of course, you can expect a happy ending, and the final pages were both romantic and satisfying.
If you’re already a fan of Sharon Lynn Fisher, you will absolutely love Bane Bloom, and for new readers, this is a great place to start with her work.
Big thanks to the author for providing a review copy.
Another lovely, cozy mystery by Sharon Lynn Fisher.
This one is about the FMC who is a botanical illustrator. She plans on creating a children’s book with the illustrations from a glass house that she received permission to visit.
When she arrives, she discovers the house and glass house are looked after by a very gruff and mysterious groundskeeper, our MMC.
There also is a very strange flower in the glass house that seems to go invisible. As she’s trying to find answers around this mysterious plant, the house seems to come alive and want to tell her things.
It ended up being unexpected and slightly different than the last three mysteries by this author. It didn’t interest me as much as the others, but I still enjoyed it.
I’d say that Tea and Alchemy, the vampire one, is probably my favorite book out of this bunch.
Also I loved the nod to Salt and Broom at the end. That made me happy.
This is one of those books that to me just felt familiar. Almost every aspect, plot point, character, etc. felt like it's been done before in a similar fashion. The magical realism was decently written as was the mystery surrounding what was going on with the location.
I didn't like Thomas' POV and felt like it didn't add that much to the story, and it sort of felt like his whole personality and their romance was built around him calling her "lass." There was no real chemistry between the two of them, and their relationship often felt one-sided for most of the book. I also really didn't like Catherine. She wasn't a compelling heroine nor protagonist and often felt childish and naive.
While this wasn't a bad read, it wasn't all that memorable either. The audiobook narrator did a good job though, so I do recommend listening to it if you're going to read this one. My thanks to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for allowing me to read this work. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
I was completely enchanted by this mysterious, darkly romantic, gothic tale! 🌿✨ The narrators were one of my favorite parts of the experience: their distinct voices brought the characters and their secrets to life, making the story feel intimate even as the world around Catherine grew stranger and more unsettling. I loved being drawn into the mystery through their performances and hearing the tension build as each new revelation came to light.
The atmosphere is absolutely delicious, misty, remote, and full of quiet unease. The Lake District estate feels like a world of its own, with its shadowy forest, old house, and mysterious glasshouse garden. I could practically feel the damp earth beneath my feet and imagine the strange plants thriving behind the glass. 🌲The botanical details are especially lovely, and the water lily that changes its appearance is such a captivating, uncanny touch.
And the magic! 🧚♀️ It’s woven through the story in a way that feels both beautiful and unsettling. The fairies and otherworldly family secrets add a delicate, eerie sparkle, while the book keeps blurring the line between fantasy and reality. Catherine herself is easy to root for: curious, observant, and determined to make sense of a place that seems intent on keeping its secrets. Her growing closeness with Thomas brings a tender thread to the darker story, while Prudence’s diary adds another fascinating layer of history, heartbreak, and family mystery. Beneath all the enchantment, this is also a story about grief, trust, and finding the courage to face the past. 💚📖
A beautifully atmospheric read for anyone who loves botanical curiosities, mysterious forests, gothic estates, complicated family secrets, and just the right touch of fairy magic. I adored getting lost in its strange, shadowy world! 🌸✨
Thanks to NetGalley, 47North and Sharon Lynn Fisher for this ARC. All opinions are my own.
BANE BLOOM is a simple story. A woman wants employment to ensure the survival of herself and her father, and a man wants to protect his house and its secrets from intruders. It just so happens that the people who employ her are the intruders in his house.
They say not to judge a book by its cover, but I did, and nearly did not read this. I try to go into a book with as little knowledge as possible, so I expected this to be a romance in a historical speculative setting, yet what I got was a beautiful story, gorgeous prose, and characters that came alive on page. Sharon Lynn Fisher has done something amazing here and I wish I could scream to the world about it.
BANE BLOOM sits somewhere between magical mystery and cosy fantasy, teetering on the edge of reality (this might make you chuckle if you've read this). The romance, which both is and isn't the centre of the story, is tentative and beautifully developed and tender and just about everything you could want from a story like this. What would you do to protect your world? For some it's a house, for others it's family, and Catherine and Thomas need to figure out how to get what they both want without having to give up each other.
This was a delight to read. I would recommend this to people who like THE MOONSINGERS by Robyn J Pritzker, and vice versa - it's the kind of fiction I just want to hold against my chest, sigh, and wish I could read again for the first time.
The blurb for this had me chomping at the bit to get a copy!
It’s the mid-19th century, and Catherine (Cricket) Gray is a thirty-year-old unmarried woman living with her aging father in London. Since her father will not be able to paint (and earn money) much longer, so Cricket (yeesh) impertinently asks to be a member of the Society of Apothecaries. Seeing as she is not in possession of male genitalia, this is a tall order, but she is ecstatic when offered a month-long trial to catalog flora in the wilds of England.
Upon arrival to the isolated Pine Cottage, Cricket learns that the Society has omitted important information—*extremely* important information. She is at a loss for what to do about the surly groundskeeper, Thomas, who always seems to appear at the most inopportune moments. Cricket is also extremely lonely, and the mysterious and spooky events that keep happening draw her closer and closer to the only other person on the property, as taciturn as he may be.
I loved the gothic setting, the spooky house/greenhouse, the lake, the yearning, all of it! Cricket is a superb & strong female character, especially in a time where women are expected to be seen and not heard. She’s smart and capable and doesn’t make herself small to appease the menfolk. Slay, Cricket…slay.
Pick this one up if you’re in the mood for mystery, moonlight and a bit of folklore!
4.25 stars, rounded down. OH, WAIT, WE CAN DO 1/2 STARS NOW!!! HOORAY!!
Thank you very much to NetGalley and 47North for gifting me an advance copy. I am writing this review entirely voluntarily.
First off, the narrators completely hit it out of the park! Phenomenal job from both of them! They really elevated the mood and were perfect for the gothic Victorian setting.
I was so pleasantly surprised with this book! I requested it from NetGalley solely on vibes, but it wound up being one of my top 5 reads of 2026 so far. It went in a slightly different direction than I expected at the beginning, but in a good way! It blends gothic Victorian England with classic Grimm fairytale lore.
The slow burn of the romance is done SO well. Truly some of the best pining I’ve read recently. I was also on the edge of my seat with the mystery. Somehow this book blends gothic with whimsy in the best possible way. Truly, I think I found my new favorite sub-genre.
I loved the entire cast of characters. Catherine was refreshingly tenacious and Thomas absolutely pulled at my heart. Even though his POV chapters were seldom and short, they were very impactful. I devoured their romance. Even though the timeframe of the story only takes place over a couple weeks, the slow burn and mutual pining makes it feel a lot longer.
I do feel like the ending was slightly rushed, but it didn’t detract from my enjoyment of the story.
I truly don’t feel like I have the adequate words to express how captivating this book was. I loved every moment of it and will absolutely return to this for several rereads. There were so many moments when I physically clutched my heart while reading.
This was the first book I’ve read by Sharon Lynn Fisher but it definitely will not be the last. Thank you to NetGalley and Brilliance Audio for the advanced listening copy. My opinions are my own. I thoroughly loved this book.
Bane Bloom combined elements I enjoy from several different genres - historical fiction, fantasy, gothic romance - into a story that was engaging and unique. The FMC, Catherine (nickname Cricket), is a botanical illustrator sent to help catalogue a poison garden in an old, run down cottage in the Lake District. As she explores the mysterious old house and gets to know its grumpy and taciturn groundskeeper Thomas, it becomes clear that all is not what it seems.
I enjoyed the grumpy-sunshine slow-burn relationship that develops between the main characters, the unique world building and plant lore, and the unfolding mystery. The romance was cleaner and the pacing was slower than I typically enjoy, but it was appropriate for the historical fiction genre.
The dual narration by Bronwen Price and Will M Watt was excellent, they really captured the characters and the vibe of the story.
Thanks to Brilliance Publishing for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
This was giving me major Pride & Prejudice meets Outlander vibes all swept inside a gothic glasshouse, and I was so down for it. More specifically, Thomas felt like Mr. Darcy with Jamie Fraser's knowledge of Scottish history and language. And I'm not sure who enjoyed Thomas calling Catherine “lass” more, Catherine or me.
“What had drawn her here? What is it she hungers for? Whatever it is, the house will find it out.”
This story gave me everything I was hoping for in a gothic historical romance: a gorgeous setting, secrets woven into an old house, a little bit of magic and folklore, and (most importantly) so much slow-burn longing...
I can always count on Sharon’s to be magical - full of folklore and whimsy. Somehow she also always seems to combine many of my favourite things in each of her books and gives them her own magical twist.
In Bane Bloom I was enchanted by Sharon’s prose, her creativity (a Herbal Fairy Compendium is the sweetest and needs to actually be published) and every single magical detail. There is soooo much botanical goodness here. I particularly loved the plant spirit medicine parts.
The characters will endear and delight you. Overall the book has a very cosy fantasy vibe and is perfect for curling up with on a drizzly day.
Note: Sharon always does so much research in her preparation. She doesn’t just guess things and this makes her books feel so much more immersive.
Thank you to NetGalley and the Publsher for my early review copy.
This books deserves five stars the setting the lake district with all it's beauty reminded me of Beatrix potter we follow cricket a nickname her father gave her when she was little other known as Caroline grey a botanical illustrator who is sent to study plants in a old country house in the lakes the man there Thomas bane is a grumpy garden man but over time he and Catherine warm to one another fairies plant spirits magical flowers a bit of eerie feeling vibe this book is magical the way the characters are written you really feel you know them .
Set in 1850 it has a classic old time feel a bit like a bronte novel the end was so beautiful .
“Find what is lost, remember what is forgotten, come back to me, love.”
Bane Bloom is set in the same Victorian era with a touch of magic as Sharon Lynn Fisher’s other novels. Where Tea and Alchemy was autumnal, Samhain, Vampires, divination and ancient forest creatures, Bane Bloom is its counterpoint in springtime, Beltane, malevolent fae, botany, and ghosts. Our main characters are two absolute green flag professional yearners which is a lovely break from the (albeit fun) morally grey characters currently abounding in fantasy. A cozy gothic (is that a thing?) atmospheric read with a compelling mystery and refreshingly pragmatic main characters (shoutout to the cameo from Dante Gabriel Rossetti)
3.5 stars rounded up. I recently returned from a trip to Scotland, so I loved reading a story about fairies and kelpies! This had a gothic feel. I did wish for more about the plants and garden, but it still lightly scratched my green thumb itch.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced release copy in exchange for a honest review.
I absolutely loved this. It's everything I want from a historical fantasy. There's another book I DNF'd recently that was quite similar, but didn't work for me. This one was perfect! I loved the focus on plants, the fairy vibes, the romance, the cosiness of it all. Highly recommend for those wanting what I can only describe as the perfect book to be made in a BBC period drama miniseries with a magical twist!
I don't think this book is being marketed correctly. It's being billed as a general adult fiction fantasy, but it's absolutely a romance first with a fantasy subplot. I felt like the entire story was about the romantic relationship and the fantasy aspect was merely the world that brought the two main characters together and occasionally presented an obstacle in the way. We actually barely saw any faeries or magic, and that was super disappointing.
The FMC is an illustrator and her entire purpose for visiting the cottage is to catalog the plants, but we barely saw Catherine drawing/painting or working, for that matter. She was entirely wrapped up in Thomas. It was lust at first sight when Catherine met Thomas, and she had lusty thoughts about him during a lot of their interactions throughout the entire story. I think the main story took place over a little more than a week's time, so the insta-lust to insta-love was too much for me.
I did think the writing was well done and I enjoyed the Gothic vibes. The glimpses at faerie lore were cool, but just not enough. I see lots of people are loving this one, but it just wasn't for me. I wanted more fantasy and less lust-forward romance.
Spice Level: 2/5 🌶️ - one multiple page open door scene
This is a cozy gothic-inspired fantasy romance, and I really wish more emphasis in the description was put on the romance and cozy, because between the use of “dark,” “disappearance,” and “madness” and the dark slightly menacing cover, I was expecting an entirely different book.
It is a sweet romance. It’s also a little bit annoying at times because Catherine (“Cricket” to literally everyone she meets because she makes sure to tell EVERYONE that is her nickname and doesn’t seem to get why they are confused), is emphasized repeatedly as being 30 but with no other indication that she isn’t much younger. There is no worldliness to Catherine. She comes across incredibly naive, which also was weird to me because she grew up with this circle of worldly artists. She gives pick-me vibes at times too with the amount of times she tells/thinks/implies that no man has ever been interested in her and it’s why she’s not married when it seems like literally every unmarried man is into her. I could not figure out whether she was motivated by independence, living a “typical” (for 1850) life, or whether she was motivated by her father. Thomas is fine. He wasn’t anything out there special, but if you like broody heroes, you’ll probably like him.
The disappearance is solved so quickly it’s barely worth mentioning as a major part of the plot. It’s why Catherine ends up at the cottage…but that’s pretty much it. And the wrap up of everything just didn’t really feel wrapped to me.
The plant and folklore details are well-researched and thorough, and I think that is what carries this book. If you’re into botanicals and fairy lore and want a low stakes read, this is for you. If you’re looking for a gothic novel of madness and family secrets and a missing man, this is NOT that book.
Thank you to NetGalley, 47North, and Sharon Lynn Fisher for the arc.
Thank you NatGalley and 47 North Press for this advanced reader’s copy of Sharon Lynn Fisher’s novel Bane Bloom in exchange for an honest review. My words are my own.
This book grew tendrils around my mind and imagination. Poisonous gardens, discontented fairies, parallel realms and metamorphic beings. All of this centers around a mansion that reveals secrets and communicates through objects, and a cryptic man whose brusque demeanor belies his altruistic intents. Catherine is sent by the London Society of Apothecary to catalog the botanical collection at Pine Cottage; however they are using her aspirations to commence the work of her missing predecessor. Thomas is the enigmatic groundskeeper whose inscrutable link to the house is entwined with the poisonous plants within the greenhouse - the most mysterious of which is the Bane’s Bloom.
All of the plants in the greenhouse are poisonous but have the ability to alter things as well. One of the most provocative lines from the novel is when Fisher says that in using poison, a thimble will cure but a cup will kill. This metaphor aptly described how all things medicinal ride the edge of what we need and what overwhelms us. Much like desire for another person, as Catherine finds out when her understanding of Thomas and the mysteries of the house begin to unravel. I was so enthralled by this book that I went on to read three more by this author. Outstanding.
Bummed about this one. I’ve been enjoying Sharon Lynn Fisher’s magical historical fiction, but this one just really fell flat for me. The characters and plot felt one dimensional, and I’m really tired of love interests getting their own POV narration for like two chapters just because.
Una fantasía cozy y oscura llena de hadas, plantas, y un romance dulce
Puntuación: 4.25 ⭐
Muchas gracias a la autora, 47North, y NetGalley por permitirme leer una copia adelantada de este libro. Las opiniones que leerán son mías y solo mías.
Este es el primer libro que leo de la autora, pero puedo asegurar que no será el último. Sus personajes, su forma de escribir, y esa mezcla de botánica y folkclore me atraparon totalmente.
Desde los primeros capítulos ya sabía que Catherine, la protagonista, iba a gustarme mucho y no me decepcionó. Es de esas mujeres capaces e inteligentes que hacen lo necesario para alcanzar sus metas. Tiene una mezcla entre romanticismo y pragmatismo que le da más profundidad a su personalidad. Aunque al inicio parece segura de sí misma, se van desvelando sus conflictos internos y cómo los va afrontando. En ese sentido, disfruté mucho la evolución de su percepción sobre su madre. Además, no duele ver a una protagonista de 30 años, "vieja" para los estándares de la época, moverse por la sociedad que, hasta cierto punto, la mantiene marginada.
La autora agregó capítulos cortos desde el punto de vista de Thomas, el interés amoroso de la novela. Las primeras apariciones de su POV me parecieron precipitadas, porque desvelaban desde muy temprano muchos aspectos sobre los misterios de la historia. Sin embargo, incluso así, la autora se guardó algunos ases bajo la manga para sorprendernos en algunos casos, y en otros, para dejar que el lector llegara a sus propias conclusiones antes de que se revelaran.
Disfruté mucho la forma de escribir de la autora. Su pluma se ajusta al período histórico que narra, lo que le da más vividez al ambiente por el que se mueve la protagonista. Además, sus descripciones de las partes más "salvajes" de Gran Bretaña, en especial de su flora y sus costumbres, acentúan aún más ese aspecto rústico pero cozy que predominan en la historia. Dicho esto, para alguien como yo que no tiene idea de plantas (y que ni siquiera puede salvar un cactus aunque su vida dependa de ello), las constantes referencias a flores y plantas pueden resultar demasiado.
La autora logra que lo oscuro se vuelva cómodo. Me imaginaba todo el tiempo paisajes etéreos y cargados de tensión donde lo real y lo fantástico confluyen. La unión de la botánica con el flokclore de las hadas, incluso la representación visual que la protagonista aporta con las descripciones de sus ilustraciones, crean una atmósfera increíble.
Todo el grueso de la historia sucede en el rango de unos días, tal vez una semana. En ese período suceden muchas cosas, incluyendo el desarrollo del romance y la revelación de secretos y misterios. Sin embargo, aunque poco creíble en la realidad, personalmente no me disgustó el poco tiempo en el que transcurre la historia con todo lo que sucede. Eso sí, el final me resultó un poco precipitado. Al menos a mí, una de las resoluciones del conflicto me pareció una suposición de los protagonistas, más que una confirmación explícita. Creo que al menos un capítulo más le hubiera venido bien para dar un cierre más redondo a la historia.
Bane Bloom es sin dudas el inicio de mi trayecto con esta autora y, si te gustan las historias de hadas un poco oscuras, pero también acogedoras, entonces te recomiendo seguir mi ejemplo. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ A cozy, dark fantasy filled with fairies, plants, and a sweet romance
Rating: 4.25 ⭐
Many thanks to the author, 47North, and NetGalley for allowing me to read an advance copy of this book. The opinions you’ll read are mine and mine alone.
This is the first book I’ve read by this author, but I can assure you it won’t be the last. Her characters, her writing style, and that blend of botany and folklore completely captivated me.
From the very first chapters, I knew I was going to really like Catherine, the protagonist, and she didn’t disappoint me. She’s one of those capable, intelligent women who does whatever it takes to achieve her goals. She has a blend of romanticism and pragmatism that adds depth to her personality. Although she seems self-assured at first, her internal conflicts are gradually revealed, along with how she deals with them. In that sense, I really enjoyed seeing how her perception of her mother evolved. Plus, it’s refreshing to see a 30-year-old protagonist—considered “old” by the standards of the time—navigate a society that, to a certain extent, marginalizes her.
The author included short chapters from the perspective of Thomas, the novel’s love interest. I found the first appearances of his POV to be rushed, because they revealed many aspects of the story’s mysteries too early on. However, even so, the author kept a few tricks up her sleeve to surprise us in some cases, and in others, to let the reader reach their own conclusions before they were revealed.
I really enjoyed the author’s writing style. Her prose fits the historical period she’s depicting, which brings the setting in which the protagonist moves to life. Furthermore, her descriptions of the “wildest” parts of Great Britain—especially its flora and customs—further accentuate that rustic yet cozy atmosphere that permeates the story. That said, for someone like me who knows nothing about plants (and who couldn’t even save a cactus if my life depended on it), the constant references to flowers and plants can be a bit much.
The author manages to make the dark feel comforting. I kept picturing ethereal, tension-filled landscapes where the real and the fantastical converge. The combination of botany and fairy folklore—including the visual imagery the protagonist brings to life through her descriptions of the illustrations—creates an incredible atmosphere.
The bulk of the story takes place over the course of a few days, perhaps a week. A lot happens during that time, including the development of the romance and the revelation of secrets and mysteries. However, although it’s not very believable in real life, I personally didn’t mind the short timeframe in which the story unfolds, given everything that happens. That said, I found the ending a bit rushed. At least to me, one of the resolutions to the conflict seemed more like an assumption on the part of the protagonists than an explicit confirmation. I think at least one more chapter would have been nice to give the story a more satisfying conclusion.
"Bane Bloom" is undoubtedly the start of my journey with this author, and if you like fairy tales that are a bit dark but also heartwarming, then I recommend following my lead.