Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Killer Isn't Alice

Rate this book
46,600 SUSPECTS. 18 CLUES. 1 KILLER. CAN YOU SOLVE THE CRIMETest your detective skills in the addictive murder mystery puzzle book sensation.

Alice Starling is missing. In her apartment, the police find three

A DEAD BODYA CRYPTIC NOTEA FOLDER OF NAMESAlice insists she is innocent – but she needs your help. . .

In a hastily written letter, Alice has left you with 18 specific clues and a list of 46,600 potential suspects. Somewhere in this sea of names hides a murderer.

YOUR MISSION IS SIMPLE BUT CHALLENGING

Analyse the Use the 18 pieces of evidence Alice entrusted to you.Eliminate the Methodically narrow down the list by stripping away those who do not fit the criteria.Identify the Find the one name that satisfies every single clue.A NEW GENRE OF INTERACTIVE MYSTERYForget everything you know about whodunnits. This first-of-its-kind, immersive logic puzzle is easy to grasp and impossible to put down. This is a pure test of logic, observation, and deduction.

Do you have what it takes to clear Alice’s name?

211 pages, Paperback

Published February 22, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Iris Starling

5 books24 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
373 (44%)
4 stars
256 (30%)
3 stars
127 (15%)
2 stars
41 (4%)
1 star
34 (4%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 201 reviews
Profile Image for Jayme C (Brunetteslikebookstoo).
1,724 reviews5,115 followers
October 7, 2026
From the Publisher’s blurb:

46,600 SUSPECTS. 18 CLUES. 1 KILLER. CAN YOU SOLVE THE CRIME?

Alice Starling is missing. In her apartment, the police find these things:

* A DEAD BODY
* A CRYPTIC NOTE
* A FOLDER OF NAMES

Alice insists she is innocent and she needs you to identify the culprit!

***

Yes, 46,000 names!
PAGE AFTER PAGE of NAMES
CHAPTER AFTER CHAPTER of NAMES

We have to read the clues, and go through each chapter CROSSING off NAMES as we eliminate SUSPECTS.

Until you are left with the ONE NAME-that satisfies EVERY.SINGLE.CLUE.

Then you send in the name of who you have identified as the CULPRIT online to see if you are correct! And, you get a reply telling you if you got it right!

I loved the IDEA of this but I had NO IDEA there would be endless pages of names. Although it’s FUN concept- it’s too hard on my OLD 👀 EYES so I don’t know if I will ever complete it.

But 🙌🏻 to anyone who solves it!

Thank You to Little Brown and Company and the NOVEL SUSPECTS program for sending me a gifted physical copy of this book!

It’s AVAILABLE now and might make a great Christmas gift 🎁 for the puzzle lover in your life!
Profile Image for Erin.
3,190 reviews465 followers
July 20, 2026
This isn’t a traditional book, more a bit of a logic game and I found it quite fun (although maybe I’ll like it less if my answer isn’t correct. Haven’t heard back yet.)

I can’t wait for the next one! Came across it here on GR.

UPDATE: I was INCORRECT and I am shamed. It’s cute. You submit what you think the solution is online and you’ll get an email in a few hours. And not only did it tell me I was wrong, it told me why I was wrong.

It’s because I can’t count. I was assured there would be no math.

So, back to it and I’ll have to update the “finish” date. Hopefully.
Profile Image for Nina.
234 reviews
April 24, 2026
I love love love love love this idea. Once you think you know who the killer is, there is a website you submit to and they will let you know if you are correct or incorrect. It took me about 5 days from doing it in the evening and I got it on my first try. But ugh, I hope she does more because this was wonderful.
Profile Image for Haley.
443 reviews
August 8, 2026
I completely screwed this up. I first found Zack and Anna’s page and then went page by page finding the 3 letter words and just crossing off the leading and following 10 names until I found only 1 not crossed off. Then I ensured that all clues were met… and you know what name I found… ALICE. But of course it isn’t fucking Alice. So I give up! I have completely marked the crap out of my book and I don’t want to start over to do it the right way. I will just tell myself it is Alice and never know who the real killer is. Sorry Alice you’ll be wrongly convicted. ✌🏼
Profile Image for Belles.
478 reviews27 followers
June 10, 2026
Good mystery puzzle book! Minus 1 star because it was very mentally taxing to read nothing but an endless list of names. Because of that I wish it was a bit shorter. But I did enjoy it. I will probably now look for other puzzle books like this in the future.
Profile Image for Connor Armitage.
17 reviews
October 26, 2026
Brought this over to my parents’ place and spent an entire weekend working through it with my mom. Her and I looooove logic puzzles, so this was an A+ bonding experience. We even ended the weekend by going to the bookstore to pick up more murder mystery puzzle books. We eagerly await the sequel!
1 review
July 3, 2026
This book had me intrigued when I saw it advertised on Insta. It was daunting, to be sure, but once I got into a rhythm, I felt it moved quickly. Good brain workout! Side note: I emailed the address in the book to ask a question about clue semantics, and the author personally reached out to clear it up for me. Loved that!
Profile Image for Liliana.
296 reviews
July 16, 2026
The perfect adjective: mind-blowing! (literally) It was so addictive that I was kept away from my normal daily reading. But it felt so good when I finally solved the mistery!

Update: I must’ve lost my marbles. I preordered the new edition.
Profile Image for Sabrina.
92 reviews
June 15, 2026
Liked it at first, but hated the ending. The concept is interesting, but the book is way too long. After reading hundreds of pages of names and details, missing a single page meant I couldn't solve the mystery. I had to look online to find out what I missed, and only then did the clues make sense. Clever idea, but overly drawn out and frustrating.
Profile Image for Стефани Витанова.
Author 1 book982 followers
August 22, 2026
За първи път в живота си връщам книга. По анотацията реших, че е крими загадка. Оказаха се 200 страници, пълни само с имена. 😳 Отговаряш на няколко въпроса, като търсиш букви в имената. Това е. Буквално.
Profile Image for Jess M.
997 reviews5 followers
October 15, 2026
OMG I FINALLY FINSIHED THIS!!!!!! I was not expecting it to take this long but also I felt like I was never going to solve this and then I just solved it randomly and I'm like ah okay. I think this was a interesting mind numbing puzzle book and I very much enjoyed it for most of the clues but once you get to the last more tedious clues like counting names etc this became torture on the eyeballs. I may need to get my eyes checked after this. Overall, interesting concept.
Profile Image for Ryann Barnash.
44 reviews1 follower
June 23, 2026
Title: The Killer Isn’t Alice
Author: Iris Starling
Genre: Puzzle Book
Length: 211 pgs.
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

This book was surprisingly more difficult than I originally thought it would be - crossing off names doesn’t sound all that hard until you’re on page 115 of 200 and all the words have started to blur together. I ended up using different colored highlighters for each clue which helped a lot and made for some pretty cool-looking pages.
I also didn’t do the clues in order, which was a big help because some of them would have taken forever to complete if I hadn’t narrowed down the options first. I’d also say to take full advantage of the website - there’s an FAQ page that was able to answer all of my questions (I guess my problems aren’t that original).
This puzzle book is perfect for staying busy on long car rides, plane flights, etc., slow days at work, or just for relaxing every night before bed. It’s great because, as long as you remember what clue you were on, you don’t have to hold a bunch of details and hints in your head between solving sessions. I was able to put it down for almost a week at one point and come back and pick it up exactly where I’d left off without any issues.
This book saved me on some long car rides and slow days working customer service, and I was really proud of myself when I finally figured out who the killer was!

This book is currently only available for purchase on Amazon.
113 reviews
Review of advance copy
August 7, 2026
This book is miserable and joyless. There is nothing creative in solving it. It's just scanning and rescanning tens of thousands of names, over and over again, combing through to find the names you're looking for.

Your eyes will go blurry. Your brain will shut off. I can't fathom the majority of these reviews being legitimate...this is the least fun puzzle book I've done out of hundreds in my life. Hundreds. This puzzle is just utterly numbing and miserable.
Profile Image for Anja Legermann-Schmitz.
3 reviews
May 1, 2026
If you enjoy huge Puzzles you will enjoy this too. It is not very rewarding in the beginning and given that you get absolutely no back story it couldn’t hold my attention.
Profile Image for Kimberly Heyming.
52 reviews1 follower
July 13, 2026
Perfect for camping. Makes you go insane at times. Normally wouldn’t count a book like this but the amount of hours I read name after name after name I could have read multiple novels.😂
Profile Image for Elizabeth Smith.
6 reviews
October 7, 2026
This was a fantastic puzzle book and I have to give it 5 stars although I haven't managed to solve it yet. My first guess was wrong yet I was positive I had it right. I didn't read any of the tips beforehand so I actually started out doing this puzzle the loooong way.
I do plan to pick this back up to give it another go once I get over the traumatic stress of my first try.
Profile Image for Sheryl Henschel.
26 reviews
May 30, 2026
Took me about 4 weeks to solve. There are 18 clues so get your highlighters ready. Go through the 200 pages and eliminate (highlight) the names that cannot be the killer. (Ie The killer’s name does not start with an “s”). After going through all 18 clues, you should be left with one name (out of 46,600). You submit your answer to a website and they will get back to you (within about an hour) with an answer if you are right or not. I solved it on my first attempt. 🎉
Profile Image for Carolyn Venne.
252 reviews12 followers
August 15, 2026
Completed the first edition and now on the second
Profile Image for Mariana Barbosa.
295 reviews12 followers
November 6, 2026
I loved this book and the way it was a great escape when I needed to distract my mind of the real world! I learned recently that I love these type of books but I also have to say that I am bummed that I didn't get the answer right although I have to say this was one of my favorite books of the year 🫶🏻❤️
Profile Image for Sophia.
129 reviews
July 28, 2026
A very fun puzzle book. Took me a few months to "read" through all the names. Highly recommend.
Profile Image for SuzannevHaaften.
277 reviews
November 1, 2026
Idee erg goed, uitvoering de hel. Ben vele maanden bezig geweest, levend in de constante angst dat ik over een belangrijke naam heb heengelezen. Ik zal nooit weten wie de moordenaar is en daarmee moet ik nu leren leven.
Profile Image for Colton Campbell.
174 reviews
July 2, 2026
A little daunting, but very cool how it rewires your brain to make things easier on yourself to solve.
Profile Image for burgundowezycie.
1,036 reviews17 followers
October 5, 2026
46 600 podejrzanych, 18 wskazówek i jeden morderca - podejmiecie wyzwanie?

Wyobraźcie sobie, że budzicie się w środku kryminalnej zagadki, której nikt inny nie rozwiąże za Was. Nie ma detektywa, który powie Wam, kto zabił. Nie ma narratora, który delikatnie poprowadzi nas za rękę. Jest tylko ciało, tajemnicza notatka i teczka zawierająca 46 600 imion oraz 18 wskazówek.

Alice Starling zniknęła. W jej mieszkaniu policja znalazła martwe ciało, kartkę z Waszym imieniem i listę tysięcy potencjalnych sprawców. Alice twierdzi, że jest niewinna. A my mamy teraz jedyne zadanie: udowodnić, że mówi prawdę… albo znaleźć tego, kto naprawdę zabił.

To nie jest klasyczna powieść kryminalna. To książka-łamigłówka, detektywistyczna gra, w której zamiast czytać o śledztwie — sami je prowadzimy. Każda wskazówka pozwala wykreślić kolejne setki, a potem dziesiątki nazwisk. Jedna mówi, że imię mordercy znajduje się w rozdziale, którego tytuł zawiera nazwę miasta. Inna — że w tym samym rozdziale muszą pojawić się imiona wszystkich Beatlesów. Brzmi prosto? Spróbuj. Lista 46 600 osób potrafi skutecznie ostudzić zapał… aż do momentu, gdy nagle zaczyna się kurczyć.

I wtedy pojawia się to uczucie. To przyjemne, lekko narkotyczne „oho… jestem coraz bliżej”. A potem kolejna wskazówka znów wszystko miesza.

„Mordercą nie jest Alice” nie rozpieszcza. Wymaga skupienia, cierpliwości i prawdziwej dedukcji. Nie da się jej „przeczytać jednym okiem”. Trzeba pracować z książką: wracać, notować, eliminować, sprawdzać. Ale właśnie dlatego satysfakcja, gdy wreszcie zostaje jedno jedyne imię, jest zupełnie inna niż po przeczytaniu tradycyjnego kryminału.

Jeśli lubicie sudoku, łamigłówki logiczne, zagadki detektywistyczne i moment, w którym mózg zaczyna pracować na najwyższych obrotach — to jest książka dla Was!

46 600 podejrzanych.
18 wskazówek.
Jeden morderca.

I tym razem to Wy musicie go znaleźć.
Gotowi?

Dziękuję za zaufanie i egzemplarz do recenzji od @zysk_wydawnictwo (współpraca reklamowa) 🩷.
Profile Image for Kulturowa.Anihilacja.
543 reviews14 followers
September 27, 2026
Książka, która pozwala zabawić mi się w Sherlocka zawsze zyskuje moje uznanie, a gdy rzuca mi wyzwanie typu, pokaż co potrafisz to już całkiem.

Alice znika, w jej mieszkaniu znalezione zostaje ciało, tajemnicza notka i listę pełną podejrzanych, początek niby banalny, a już od samego początku intryguje i daje ten tajemniczy vibe. Alice usilnie przekonuje o swojej niewinności, a ja wraz ze wskazówkami wyruszyłam na detektywistyczne polowanie.

Nie ma tu klasycznego śledztwa, na zasadzie Poirot, że spacerujemy od świadka do świadka, zbieramy poszlaki i brniemy do finału. Tym razem ze mną w roli sprytnej pani detektyw, a każda wskazówka ma olbrzymie znacznie, ponieważ każda zawęża krąg podejrzanych.
Ponad 46 tysięcy podejrzanych muszę przyznać, brzmi nieco absurdalnie i może jakoś odstraszyć, jednak autorka przekuła to w główny atut książki, bo liczba ta staje się głównym elementem zagadki.

Jeśli oczekujecie klasycznego kryminału z rozbudowanymi bohaterami i głębią psychologiczną sprawcy, to może poczuć rozczarowanie, jednak mi książka dała coś lepszego, a mianowicie możliwość dedukowania, rozwiązywania zagadek, co było bardziej wciągające niż się spodziewałam, bo interakcja w śledztwie mimo wszystko jest znacznie lepsza niż samo czytanie o śledztwie.

Trudno też nie krócic uwagi na to, jak książka pompuje ego czytelnika, bo można się poczuć jak hybryda Holmesa, Poirota, Colombo i Hasselhoff, ale tylko na chwilę, by za moment trafić na wskazówkę, która sprawia, że człowiek zaczyna rozumień, że przed momentem dokonał eliminacji podejrzanych według średnio dobrze zrozumianego kryterium.

„Mordercą nie jest Alice” to książka wymykająca się schemat, bo wrzucił mnie na głęboką wodę detektywistycznej pracy, dla mnie okazała się czymś niesamowicie odświeżającym. Podobało się to dla mnie.
Profile Image for bookfromdream_.
335 reviews9 followers
November 12, 2026
Już parę razy wspominałam tutaj, że ubóstwiam wszelkiego rodzaju łamigłówki i zagadki, więc jak tylko zobaczyłam tę książkę to widziałam, że to jest coś dla mnie.

Tym bardziej, że kolejną rzeczą którą uwielbiam jest tworzenie planu, wykreślenie punktów z listy i konkretnie wyznaczone etapy, które mogę pokonywać - a tutaj jest to kluczowym elementem.

Czułam ogromną satysfakcję jak małymi kroczkami mogłam wyeliminować kolejne wskazówki i w ten sposób zawężać liczbę podejrzanych imion.

Aczkolwiek muszę przyznać, że te imiona wyglądają niepozornie😆 jak zobaczyłam zapowiedź tej łamigłówki to byłam niesamowicie podekscytowana zamysłem i dalej jest to dla mnie ekstra pomysł! Jednak z każdą kolejną wskazówką i przeglądaniem tych imion coraz bardziej mieniło mi się od nich w oczach... Rozwiązywanie tego było jednocześnie irytujące, intrygujące i satysfakcjonujące.

Było to bardzo absorbujące zajęcie i uważam, że jest to bardzo dobra opcja na ponure, zimowe wieczory🤭
Displaying 1 - 30 of 201 reviews