What do you think?
Rate this book
The Republic #1
A Question of Counsel
Life hasn't been easy for Aeley since she arrested her brother, and her role as a political leader leaves her feeling isolated and lonely. Days before her brother's trial, she meets Lira, a quiet and modest scribe who makes Aeley want more than just a professional relationship.
When she attends the trial and leaves with a marriage contract, Aeley doesn't know what to do. She must choose one of two brothers, marrying into a family she doesn't know. Then she discovers that Lira is part of the same family–a sister to Aeley's suitors and the family's disgrace. And not at all opposed to an intimate relationship.
Except random acts of violence against her people test Aeley's ability as a leader, and a web of lies and deceit threaten not only her chance at happiness, but her life...
When she attends the trial and leaves with a marriage contract, Aeley doesn't know what to do. She must choose one of two brothers, marrying into a family she doesn't know. Then she discovers that Lira is part of the same family–a sister to Aeley's suitors and the family's disgrace. And not at all opposed to an intimate relationship.
Except random acts of violence against her people test Aeley's ability as a leader, and a web of lies and deceit threaten not only her chance at happiness, but her life...
ebook
First published May 27, 2015
2 people are currently reading
703 people want to read
About the author
Archer Kay Leah
11 books119 followersArcher Kay Leah is an LGBTQA+ romance author that you'll often find getting lost in strange, fantastical worlds with characters who can't help but find trouble and shake things up. Fantasy and sci-fi romances are Archer's specialty, especially when they're complex and emotionally charged. But at the heart of Archer's stories are friendship, family, and there's always a happy ending–it might just take a whole lot of complications to get there!
When not reading and writing for work or play, Archer is a nerd of much geekery, loves music to depths that will never be contained, and is fascinated by behaviour, psychology, and ecology. Born and raised in Canada, Archer lives in London, Ontario with a non-binary partner who loves all things out there in the vast space of the universe.
To keep up with what Archer's up to, there's a Newsletter you can subscribe to @ https://eepurl.com/gNOSGH! Or, come visit Archer on social media, especially Twitter. And for anyone interested in reading works-in-progress as they're written in a monthly serial form, as well as hearing more about the books overall (with sneak peeks and early access to new materials, covers, and more), check out Archer's Patreon @ https://www.patreon.com/archerkayleah.
When not reading and writing for work or play, Archer is a nerd of much geekery, loves music to depths that will never be contained, and is fascinated by behaviour, psychology, and ecology. Born and raised in Canada, Archer lives in London, Ontario with a non-binary partner who loves all things out there in the vast space of the universe.
To keep up with what Archer's up to, there's a Newsletter you can subscribe to @ https://eepurl.com/gNOSGH! Or, come visit Archer on social media, especially Twitter. And for anyone interested in reading works-in-progress as they're written in a monthly serial form, as well as hearing more about the books overall (with sneak peeks and early access to new materials, covers, and more), check out Archer's Patreon @ https://www.patreon.com/archerkayleah.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
July 2, 2017
** free copy provided to me by Less Than Three Press in exchange for an honest review **
Not really sure what to rate this one.
It's a pretty cool concept. The fierce, warrior Tract Steward and the quiet yet very opinionated Scribe. This should be very interesting. Unfortunately, it kind of wasn't? In trying to pinpoint what didn't work for me, it comes down to:
1) The characters all seem to have basic, bare bones motivations. We get a few sentences to explain why anyone does anything and it all seems pretty shallow. I wanted more of the showing instead of the telling. For example, Aeley hates Allon and all of the reasons she gives are just told to us. It made me wish this took place much earlier in the game because how cool would it have been to actually see Allon's capture? To follow Aeley's story when her emotions are all fresh and vivid? Instead, we join the story months down the line where it's just told to us in expositional dialogue.
2) Side characters blended together. I sort of know who Mayr is because he's the most involved but other than Lira and Mayr, I found Emon, Ryler, Vant and other interchangeable. I couldn't really remember who each character was or why they were here.
3) Not enough description. The setting was interesting but I felt like there wasn't enough to description to fully immerse myself in it. I don't entirely understand what Aeley's job is.
4) The action scenes weren't enough to really keep my attention. I can't really say that I was interested and any scenes outside of the scenes between Aeley and Lira. Maybe that was the point? Still, I wanted to care about the random attacks and Aeley's goals here and I just didn't. It was a pretty big bummer.
That being said, I appreciate the effort here. It is an interesting setting, as I said above. I just felt like this book was pretty shallow and I wanted more detail and description. Part of me thinks a shift in time period (around Allon's capture) and maybe even a shift in POV (what if this was all from Lira's point of view?) would have made this more of a win for me.
So, this was kind of a bummer for me but I think I'll probably enjoy Four more.
Not really sure what to rate this one.
It's a pretty cool concept. The fierce, warrior Tract Steward and the quiet yet very opinionated Scribe. This should be very interesting. Unfortunately, it kind of wasn't? In trying to pinpoint what didn't work for me, it comes down to:
1) The characters all seem to have basic, bare bones motivations. We get a few sentences to explain why anyone does anything and it all seems pretty shallow. I wanted more of the showing instead of the telling. For example, Aeley hates Allon and all of the reasons she gives are just told to us. It made me wish this took place much earlier in the game because how cool would it have been to actually see Allon's capture? To follow Aeley's story when her emotions are all fresh and vivid? Instead, we join the story months down the line where it's just told to us in expositional dialogue.
2) Side characters blended together. I sort of know who Mayr is because he's the most involved but other than Lira and Mayr, I found Emon, Ryler, Vant and other interchangeable. I couldn't really remember who each character was or why they were here.
3) Not enough description. The setting was interesting but I felt like there wasn't enough to description to fully immerse myself in it. I don't entirely understand what Aeley's job is.
4) The action scenes weren't enough to really keep my attention. I can't really say that I was interested and any scenes outside of the scenes between Aeley and Lira. Maybe that was the point? Still, I wanted to care about the random attacks and Aeley's goals here and I just didn't. It was a pretty big bummer.
That being said, I appreciate the effort here. It is an interesting setting, as I said above. I just felt like this book was pretty shallow and I wanted more detail and description. Part of me thinks a shift in time period (around Allon's capture) and maybe even a shift in POV (what if this was all from Lira's point of view?) would have made this more of a win for me.
So, this was kind of a bummer for me but I think I'll probably enjoy Four more.
July 9, 2018
Aeley has a multiplicity of problems. Inheriting the local executive position ("Tract Steward") from her deceased father, she is immediately embroiled in the frustrated schemes of her insane brother. Aeley's shocky mental state and her shaky grip on authority both are threatened by the random crimes being committed throughout her district. Only her support system currently props her up - that is a mixture of loyal retainers, firm friends, potential suitors, and one attractive new scribe.
As far as it went, this is a serviceable little story. I say "little." It lies in that odd spot between full-sized novel and short-story. It is perfectly possible to read the entire length of this, unhurried, in an hour and a half or so.
The gravest concern with the work is the characterization. Aeley is presented as a local lording - trained, presumably, from birth and (we are told) given the actual work of the day-to-day management of the district even before her father's death. Unfortunately she doesn't act like it. Her default mood is a kind of teenaged irritation with everyone and everything. That is one thing; perhaps this book is simply aimed at that nebulous "young adult" market, in which case this might be fair enough. For someone supposedly versed in governance, however, she exercises her authority little, and appears to make no positive difference on her subjects. The one test of government she is given in-text (that of the crimes) she effectively fails to solve. The perpetrators get away scott-free until they fuck up and kidnap her without warning, revealing their nefarious plans..
That this is a first novel is commendable - it is certainly a credit to the author. It does, however, have certain problems that first novels tend towards. The plot lurches in places - the moods of the reader are prone to whiplash. At one point a rather juicy seed of doubt is planted . Aeley turns on this character with cool suspicion... for all of two pages. I emphasize that the accusation was perfectly plausible - probable even - and it had a whole lot of promise. Very odd.
I liked the book. I'm looking forward to the next one. Just bear in mind that it is a story with certain problems in its execution.
As far as it went, this is a serviceable little story. I say "little." It lies in that odd spot between full-sized novel and short-story. It is perfectly possible to read the entire length of this, unhurried, in an hour and a half or so.
The gravest concern with the work is the characterization. Aeley is presented as a local lording - trained, presumably, from birth and (we are told) given the actual work of the day-to-day management of the district even before her father's death. Unfortunately she doesn't act like it. Her default mood is a kind of teenaged irritation with everyone and everything. That is one thing; perhaps this book is simply aimed at that nebulous "young adult" market, in which case this might be fair enough. For someone supposedly versed in governance, however, she exercises her authority little, and appears to make no positive difference on her subjects. The one test of government she is given in-text (that of the crimes) she effectively fails to solve. The perpetrators get away scott-free until they fuck up and kidnap her without warning, revealing their nefarious plans..
That this is a first novel is commendable - it is certainly a credit to the author. It does, however, have certain problems that first novels tend towards. The plot lurches in places - the moods of the reader are prone to whiplash. At one point a rather juicy seed of doubt is planted . Aeley turns on this character with cool suspicion... for all of two pages. I emphasize that the accusation was perfectly plausible - probable even - and it had a whole lot of promise. Very odd.
I liked the book. I'm looking forward to the next one. Just bear in mind that it is a story with certain problems in its execution.
January 15, 2018
Great story by a local author!
I liked the characters though found some of the writing wasn't to my personal taste. Steamy bits were VERY steamy, loved it and loved that it was f/f!! I loved the complicated romance between Lira and Aeley. The plot was quite interesting!
I liked the characters though found some of the writing wasn't to my personal taste. Steamy bits were VERY steamy, loved it and loved that it was f/f!! I loved the complicated romance between Lira and Aeley. The plot was quite interesting!
November 7, 2016
This was...OK.
I quite liked the first half and I liked the character of Marys (I know he gets his own story next, which is actually why I read this one). BUT the whole mystery part wasn't really that mysterious, I mean I knew from practically the beginning what was going on, but none of the characters seemed to get what was going on until it was too late?!
Then the last third just seemed to drag and I skimmed the rest...I may still give Book #2 a go.
I quite liked the first half and I liked the character of Marys (I know he gets his own story next, which is actually why I read this one). BUT the whole mystery part wasn't really that mysterious, I mean I knew from practically the beginning what was going on, but none of the characters seemed to get what was going on until it was too late?!
Then the last third just seemed to drag and I skimmed the rest...I may still give Book #2 a go.
July 11, 2017
I recently received the third book in this series as an ARC for review and while it can be read as a standalone, I wanted to read the first two books first. If it weren’t for that, the very short length of this book, and the lesbian representation, I don’t think I would’ve read this book through. I had several problems with the book.
To start, the characters were pretty boring. Their motives and personalities were just foundations for characters and not developed beyond that. Aeley was especially annoying. I’m all for tough girl characters but Aeley was just said to be tough, there weren’t scenes that really proved what a great fighter she was or anything. She seemed to fall into the obstinate tough girl trope, as she would frequently act really stubborn and closed off but than paragraphs later she was pouring her heart out. Her descriptions didn’t fit her actions.
I did like Mayr even though all that was really shown is that he cares a lot about Aeley and is very sarcastic. I’m definitely psyched to read the next book since it follows him! The interactions between him and Aeley were just great. I loved how he teased her about her crush on Lira. He didn’t tease her because she was gay; he teased her because she had a crush and that was really great.
I hated all the brothers in this book. They all sucked. I don’t like manipulative characters and I like it even less when obviously manipulative characters aren’t seen as being obviously manipulative. Aeley even recognized that they were manipulative and yet didn’t proceed with caution.
The story was very trope-y and cliché. There was definitely unconditional insta-love, even if Lira and Aeley didn’t get together or hook up right away. Even when Aeley was frustrated with Lira and didn’t even know her very well, she was still super in love. The plot was trope-y as well and I predicted the twist early on – Aeley should’ve predicted it too. I think I rolled my eyes so hard they hurt when I read the line “…even if other women rarely enjoyed sharp weapons.” I’d appreciate if there weren’t ‘not like other girls’ quotes in my gay fiction, thanks. Or in any fiction.
I really wanted more from the setting of this story. All that was described was really intriguing but seemed contradictory. It’s not clear what women’s “roles” are in this society. There are a lot of women in positions of power, including the main character, yet there’s an arranged marriage where the woman had little to no say and underlying misogyny in the “not like other girls” quote. The acceptance of being gay was a bit contradictory as well. It seemed too convenient for the plot to have literally everyone accept people being gay except Lira’s family. I really wanted more from the world – even with things like the religion and Four Goddesses – because it was a great set-up.
I don’t read a lot of books with smut so I really don’t know how to judge sex scenes, but this one seemed mostly alright. The only thing that threw me off is that the clit was referred to as her “nub” which is just unnecessary.
Despite all my complaints, I didn’t hate the story. The best way to describe this is like guilty pleasure fanfiction. It really wasn’t the best story but it was still a fun read with a lot of clichés and predictable twists. It’s one of those junk food type reads. It’s not good for you, but you still want it.
The lesbian representation made my heart sing and kept me invested in the story. The romance between Lira and Aeley was cute.
So, not bad, but not great.
Check out this review on my blog!: https://loganetherealink.wordpress.co...
To start, the characters were pretty boring. Their motives and personalities were just foundations for characters and not developed beyond that. Aeley was especially annoying. I’m all for tough girl characters but Aeley was just said to be tough, there weren’t scenes that really proved what a great fighter she was or anything. She seemed to fall into the obstinate tough girl trope, as she would frequently act really stubborn and closed off but than paragraphs later she was pouring her heart out. Her descriptions didn’t fit her actions.
I did like Mayr even though all that was really shown is that he cares a lot about Aeley and is very sarcastic. I’m definitely psyched to read the next book since it follows him! The interactions between him and Aeley were just great. I loved how he teased her about her crush on Lira. He didn’t tease her because she was gay; he teased her because she had a crush and that was really great.
I hated all the brothers in this book. They all sucked. I don’t like manipulative characters and I like it even less when obviously manipulative characters aren’t seen as being obviously manipulative. Aeley even recognized that they were manipulative and yet didn’t proceed with caution.
The story was very trope-y and cliché. There was definitely unconditional insta-love, even if Lira and Aeley didn’t get together or hook up right away. Even when Aeley was frustrated with Lira and didn’t even know her very well, she was still super in love. The plot was trope-y as well and I predicted the twist early on – Aeley should’ve predicted it too. I think I rolled my eyes so hard they hurt when I read the line “…even if other women rarely enjoyed sharp weapons.” I’d appreciate if there weren’t ‘not like other girls’ quotes in my gay fiction, thanks. Or in any fiction.
I really wanted more from the setting of this story. All that was described was really intriguing but seemed contradictory. It’s not clear what women’s “roles” are in this society. There are a lot of women in positions of power, including the main character, yet there’s an arranged marriage where the woman had little to no say and underlying misogyny in the “not like other girls” quote. The acceptance of being gay was a bit contradictory as well. It seemed too convenient for the plot to have literally everyone accept people being gay except Lira’s family. I really wanted more from the world – even with things like the religion and Four Goddesses – because it was a great set-up.
I don’t read a lot of books with smut so I really don’t know how to judge sex scenes, but this one seemed mostly alright. The only thing that threw me off is that the clit was referred to as her “nub” which is just unnecessary.
Despite all my complaints, I didn’t hate the story. The best way to describe this is like guilty pleasure fanfiction. It really wasn’t the best story but it was still a fun read with a lot of clichés and predictable twists. It’s one of those junk food type reads. It’s not good for you, but you still want it.
The lesbian representation made my heart sing and kept me invested in the story. The romance between Lira and Aeley was cute.
So, not bad, but not great.
Check out this review on my blog!: https://loganetherealink.wordpress.co...
October 13, 2017
Link to the blog: https://dbsguidetothegalaxy.wordpress...
Received from the publishers (as I was approved for the 3rd book - Blood Borne).
All opinions expressed are my own.
3 and a half stars
The summary made the book out to be more interesting than the actual story. I mean I was expecting this adorable f/f romance and instead I get a story that's plot isn't fully developed, its dialogue felt a bit forced, and the action and subplot that should've been the main plot were half-formed. Which makes me upset. As now (as I'm writing this review, I'm about halfway through the second book, Four - which I was going to update on my Goodreads account, but then the onnosel thing decided to be down. And I stilll have the 3rd book to read).
I mean, sure, I liked the book, but I didn't really enjoy it, understand? It took me a while to get through it (ok, mostly because I was going through some things), but also because it was a case of me literally forcing myself to read the book. Like read a half of a chapter and then you can watch some Avatar: TLA. And I didn't want to dnf because it's the first in a trilogy, and who knows which characters are introduced will feature in the 2nd and 3rd and what background ontent will become important later on.
Although the characters were easy to like and hate, they could have done with a bit more fleshing out. It's like their hearts weren't in their motivations and it felt like they were just going through the motions. Yeah, they probably thought about what they were doing, and maybe why, but they didn't motivate me to want to them go through the motions.
I understand she's a Steward, which brings to mind Denethor, so I don't know how I feel about Aeley's job. And thinkin of Denethor makes me think of a certain gif, so I'm super glad that Aeley did not pull a Denethor.
It's not that there were too many characters, it's that not enough time was spent on them so I never really knew what their job was and their purpose in the story. I mean I barely remember any of the minor characters, or their jobs, or even their names.
So summed up, not that good as I thought it would be. Do I recommend it? Yes, as it gives you background information on several characters, but that's it.
Afrikaans:
onnosel - stupid
Received from the publishers (as I was approved for the 3rd book - Blood Borne).
All opinions expressed are my own.
3 and a half stars
The summary made the book out to be more interesting than the actual story. I mean I was expecting this adorable f/f romance and instead I get a story that's plot isn't fully developed, its dialogue felt a bit forced, and the action and subplot that should've been the main plot were half-formed. Which makes me upset. As now (as I'm writing this review, I'm about halfway through the second book, Four - which I was going to update on my Goodreads account, but then the onnosel thing decided to be down. And I stilll have the 3rd book to read).
I mean, sure, I liked the book, but I didn't really enjoy it, understand? It took me a while to get through it (ok, mostly because I was going through some things), but also because it was a case of me literally forcing myself to read the book. Like read a half of a chapter and then you can watch some Avatar: TLA. And I didn't want to dnf because it's the first in a trilogy, and who knows which characters are introduced will feature in the 2nd and 3rd and what background ontent will become important later on.
Although the characters were easy to like and hate, they could have done with a bit more fleshing out. It's like their hearts weren't in their motivations and it felt like they were just going through the motions. Yeah, they probably thought about what they were doing, and maybe why, but they didn't motivate me to want to them go through the motions.
I understand she's a Steward, which brings to mind Denethor, so I don't know how I feel about Aeley's job. And thinkin of Denethor makes me think of a certain gif, so I'm super glad that Aeley did not pull a Denethor.
It's not that there were too many characters, it's that not enough time was spent on them so I never really knew what their job was and their purpose in the story. I mean I barely remember any of the minor characters, or their jobs, or even their names.
So summed up, not that good as I thought it would be. Do I recommend it? Yes, as it gives you background information on several characters, but that's it.
Afrikaans:
onnosel - stupid
June 10, 2018
There's a few things that would have made for an okay-read: mostly that the romance (although insta-lust on the MC's part) is nice and supportive, with no unnecessary drama, (despite the MC 0-to-200-in-2-seconds-ing); also that the MC's entourage respect her and her abilities and her choices; and finally that it tries to make a comment on how women are expected to try and to accommodate and to coddle men, and how that can come across as acquiescence or complacency.
On the other hand: there's no other women in a very ironical twist for a wlw book; maybe related, the MC has some misogynistic opinions, which doesn't have to be a bad thing if the book doesn't condone it, which this one sadly does; I hated the happy ending of the MC complying with her father's promises, when he obviously was being paternalistic and condescending and disrespecting of his daughter's abilities and choices and disregarding of misogynistic views in other men (which does not speak well of his views on women, *cough*misogyny*cough*); and the worst, the whole manipulative scheme is so transparent that it feels like the author takes either her MC or the reader for stupid.
On the other hand: there's no other women in a very ironical twist for a wlw book; maybe related, the MC has some misogynistic opinions, which doesn't have to be a bad thing if the book doesn't condone it, which this one sadly does; I hated the happy ending of the MC complying with her father's promises, when he obviously was being paternalistic and condescending and disrespecting of his daughter's abilities and choices and disregarding of misogynistic views in other men (which does not speak well of his views on women, *cough*misogyny*cough*); and the worst, the whole manipulative scheme is so transparent that it feels like the author takes either her MC or the reader for stupid.
July 8, 2019
DNF'd
The plot such as it is can be summed up in a sentence. Also the dialogue is shudder inducing
The plot such as it is can be summed up in a sentence. Also the dialogue is shudder inducing
April 25, 2018
I'm not quite sure what to think about this book. This is a new author for me. For the most part, the book seemed alright as far as the plot and storyline, but it fell flat for me in a lot of spots. Maybe it seemed like there would be more action.
Aeley has become the new leader. She lost her father to death, and won against her traitorous brother in election. She doesn't want to be a more passive leader like her father, but doesn't know exactly how to change things. She's still having a hard time getting over her brother attacking villages and killing people and with having to attack him to put him in jail. When a message comes to her that she needs to attend her brother's trial, she dreads it. She knows his mouth and actions will be bad. And she's not wrong. She also finds out her father made her a marriage contract before he died. She has no desire to be with the two brothers. In fact, her gaze has been captured by Lira, her scribe. As time passes, Aeley learns of attacks in neighboring villages and is trying to fix the problem. She's also falling for Lira. When she herself is captured, she learns her brother's reach goes farther than she thought and so do the betrayals his actions have brought forth. Now she must figure out how to save her people and bring the criminals to justice. And maybe see if Lira is interested in more than just a night.
I felt for Aeley. Living in your parent's shadow, always feeling like you're not measuring up to them. Having your own sibling betray your people. Definitely makes for not good days. And I don't blame her for getting drunk most days either. Heck I'd want to as well. Being thrown into a marriage contract doesn't help either, especially when the object of her desire isn't even male. And the problems just keep adding up. It's one blow after another and Aeley doesn't even know if she can keep up anymore. I couldn't do it. Being a parent of one is enough for me lol. The one thing that keeps her sane is Lira. She's opinionated, mouthy, and perfect in Aeley’s eyes. The only thing she's having a hard time with, is that Lira is being secretive when it comes to certain things. And then she finds out why. And enemies use that against her. She seriously can't catch a break. But like anything in life, you have to keep getting up. Keep fighting. Keep moving forward. She has to learn some hard lessons, but when in life is anything ever easy.
Not a bad book. Like I said, the plot of the story was good. Give it a shot. Happy reading!
http://lovebytesreviews.com
Aeley has become the new leader. She lost her father to death, and won against her traitorous brother in election. She doesn't want to be a more passive leader like her father, but doesn't know exactly how to change things. She's still having a hard time getting over her brother attacking villages and killing people and with having to attack him to put him in jail. When a message comes to her that she needs to attend her brother's trial, she dreads it. She knows his mouth and actions will be bad. And she's not wrong. She also finds out her father made her a marriage contract before he died. She has no desire to be with the two brothers. In fact, her gaze has been captured by Lira, her scribe. As time passes, Aeley learns of attacks in neighboring villages and is trying to fix the problem. She's also falling for Lira. When she herself is captured, she learns her brother's reach goes farther than she thought and so do the betrayals his actions have brought forth. Now she must figure out how to save her people and bring the criminals to justice. And maybe see if Lira is interested in more than just a night.
I felt for Aeley. Living in your parent's shadow, always feeling like you're not measuring up to them. Having your own sibling betray your people. Definitely makes for not good days. And I don't blame her for getting drunk most days either. Heck I'd want to as well. Being thrown into a marriage contract doesn't help either, especially when the object of her desire isn't even male. And the problems just keep adding up. It's one blow after another and Aeley doesn't even know if she can keep up anymore. I couldn't do it. Being a parent of one is enough for me lol. The one thing that keeps her sane is Lira. She's opinionated, mouthy, and perfect in Aeley’s eyes. The only thing she's having a hard time with, is that Lira is being secretive when it comes to certain things. And then she finds out why. And enemies use that against her. She seriously can't catch a break. But like anything in life, you have to keep getting up. Keep fighting. Keep moving forward. She has to learn some hard lessons, but when in life is anything ever easy.
Not a bad book. Like I said, the plot of the story was good. Give it a shot. Happy reading!
http://lovebytesreviews.com
May 27, 2015
Check out my full review on Bookaholics Not-So-Anonymous.
Note: This ARC was provided by Less Than Three Press in exchange for an honest review.
A Question of Counsel is a fantasy romance novella by author Archer Kay Leah in The Republic series and is about Aeley and how she manages to create her own legacy as the leader of Kattal instead of merely living in the shadow left behind by her father, who was the leader prior to his death. Aeley knows that there are those who question her capabilities, but with the faith and support of her best friend and Head Guard Mayr and a handful of loyal supporters, she strives to prove her naysayers wrong. When Aeley notices Lira, her new scribe, there's something about her that gives Aeley pause and makes her want to know Lira on a more personal level. Learning, however, that her late father wanted her to marry a member of the Derossa family has Aeley trying to balance the wants of her father and her people and the needs that she, as a woman, also carries. Lira being a Derossa herself may give Aeley pause but Lira's brothers point out that Lira is nothing more than a disgrace. Adding to Aeley's worries are acts of violence against the people of Kattal and if she isn't able to find out if these are mere random events or something sinister and planned, she may lose her integrity as the Tract Steward or far worse.
This was a well-written and creatively original novella set in a world that may be different but one that can be easily understood by readers. The fact that the lead characters are two strong women makes this even more of a worthwhile read, neither of them needing to be saved or seeking validation from one another. There's also a bit of mystery that goes on and though I did figure out who was behind the attacks in Kattal, I was surprised by what happened after the reveal. I'll admit that, just like Aeley, there was a moment of doubt and the author getting me to question the motives of a character I like deserves bonus points. I liked the humor mixed in with the drama because it allowed the story to not be as heavy as you would expect with a subject matter as serious as the one here. As for the supporting cast of characters, Mayr was my absolute favorite, with my initial impression of him being this overly serious Head Guard being blown out of the water when his wicked but understated sense of humor and protective and brotherly nature toward Aeley coming to light. If you're looking for a fairly quick but substantial read, I recommend you check out A Question of Counsel. It gets 4.5 stars, rounded off to five stars! ♥
Note: This ARC was provided by Less Than Three Press in exchange for an honest review.
A Question of Counsel is a fantasy romance novella by author Archer Kay Leah in The Republic series and is about Aeley and how she manages to create her own legacy as the leader of Kattal instead of merely living in the shadow left behind by her father, who was the leader prior to his death. Aeley knows that there are those who question her capabilities, but with the faith and support of her best friend and Head Guard Mayr and a handful of loyal supporters, she strives to prove her naysayers wrong. When Aeley notices Lira, her new scribe, there's something about her that gives Aeley pause and makes her want to know Lira on a more personal level. Learning, however, that her late father wanted her to marry a member of the Derossa family has Aeley trying to balance the wants of her father and her people and the needs that she, as a woman, also carries. Lira being a Derossa herself may give Aeley pause but Lira's brothers point out that Lira is nothing more than a disgrace. Adding to Aeley's worries are acts of violence against the people of Kattal and if she isn't able to find out if these are mere random events or something sinister and planned, she may lose her integrity as the Tract Steward or far worse.
This was a well-written and creatively original novella set in a world that may be different but one that can be easily understood by readers. The fact that the lead characters are two strong women makes this even more of a worthwhile read, neither of them needing to be saved or seeking validation from one another. There's also a bit of mystery that goes on and though I did figure out who was behind the attacks in Kattal, I was surprised by what happened after the reveal. I'll admit that, just like Aeley, there was a moment of doubt and the author getting me to question the motives of a character I like deserves bonus points. I liked the humor mixed in with the drama because it allowed the story to not be as heavy as you would expect with a subject matter as serious as the one here. As for the supporting cast of characters, Mayr was my absolute favorite, with my initial impression of him being this overly serious Head Guard being blown out of the water when his wicked but understated sense of humor and protective and brotherly nature toward Aeley coming to light. If you're looking for a fairly quick but substantial read, I recommend you check out A Question of Counsel. It gets 4.5 stars, rounded off to five stars! ♥
Read
May 19, 2020** New edition available now at Amazon, Smashwords, Barnes & Noble, Apple Books, Kobo, Payhip, and other retailers!
Edition #2 is an extended edition with massive changes. Highlights: twice as long as the original, addressing several character-related and plot matters, several new chapters, extended scenes, rewritten scenes, and a general clean-up of the storytelling itself. Basically, an entirely new version.
The core remains the same, and so does the overall plot, but I've cleaned up and explored the rest of it, breathing new life into it and working out some of the other angles. This means characters that come from later points in the series are making an appearance, among other things, including details that tie it into the later books.
Note: This is an F/F romance set in a high fantasy world, and both main characters identify as lesbian.
* Please note this book comes with trigger warnings. To view them and other content notes and disclaimers, here you go:
Edition #2 is an extended edition with massive changes. Highlights: twice as long as the original, addressing several character-related and plot matters, several new chapters, extended scenes, rewritten scenes, and a general clean-up of the storytelling itself. Basically, an entirely new version.
The core remains the same, and so does the overall plot, but I've cleaned up and explored the rest of it, breathing new life into it and working out some of the other angles. This means characters that come from later points in the series are making an appearance, among other things, including details that tie it into the later books.
Note: This is an F/F romance set in a high fantasy world, and both main characters identify as lesbian.
* Please note this book comes with trigger warnings. To view them and other content notes and disclaimers, here you go:
August 1, 2015
See the full review here too
After the death of Aeley’s Father, she is now the elected Tract Steward that will be governing the people of her section. But getting where she is, isn’t pretty. Allon, her brother left their family’s name in dark shadow as he wreak havoc with his deeds. Now, because of Aeley, he is behind prison.
However it seems like Allon still has some control over some people even though he’s locked up.
Now, Aeley needs to uncover the mysterious attacks that leaves her reign with a dead body and several wounded. Throw in a distracting woman whom Aeley is extremely attracted to. Will she find
As what I’ve said from my previous reviews, I don’t check or read prior to reading a book. Yeah, I read it when I stumble upon it or when I request for a copy. But I always forget about it before I read a book for a review or tour. So I’m pretty surprised about the developments. It’s actually pretty fun though. I don’t know what to expect. I don’t even have a clue of its genre. Maybe a hint from the cover and title. Anyway, getting back to the review.
I completely loved this book. Bookworms, watch out for Archer Kay Leah because she is a wonderful author. The book isn’t what I expected it to be. It was much more. I also want to point out that this is my first book that the main character doesn’t prefer men. I must say it was fabulously well-written.
The story was exhilarating. It left me wanting to know more of the journey between Aeley and Lira. And to also see more of Mayr! Can we get a sequel with his POV? Lol. The characters have different personalities. The plot was vast. The only negative thing I have to say is that I could use a little more descriptive words with the places and characters. Also want to know more about the political rules and hierarchy. It would help to also have a clearer picture of the world Aeley lives in.
A Question of Counsel is definitely a diverse book to add to your to-read list. It’s a wonderful and exciting fantasy novel that is perfect any season.
After the death of Aeley’s Father, she is now the elected Tract Steward that will be governing the people of her section. But getting where she is, isn’t pretty. Allon, her brother left their family’s name in dark shadow as he wreak havoc with his deeds. Now, because of Aeley, he is behind prison.
However it seems like Allon still has some control over some people even though he’s locked up.
Now, Aeley needs to uncover the mysterious attacks that leaves her reign with a dead body and several wounded. Throw in a distracting woman whom Aeley is extremely attracted to. Will she find
As what I’ve said from my previous reviews, I don’t check or read prior to reading a book. Yeah, I read it when I stumble upon it or when I request for a copy. But I always forget about it before I read a book for a review or tour. So I’m pretty surprised about the developments. It’s actually pretty fun though. I don’t know what to expect. I don’t even have a clue of its genre. Maybe a hint from the cover and title. Anyway, getting back to the review.
I completely loved this book. Bookworms, watch out for Archer Kay Leah because she is a wonderful author. The book isn’t what I expected it to be. It was much more. I also want to point out that this is my first book that the main character doesn’t prefer men. I must say it was fabulously well-written.
The story was exhilarating. It left me wanting to know more of the journey between Aeley and Lira. And to also see more of Mayr! Can we get a sequel with his POV? Lol. The characters have different personalities. The plot was vast. The only negative thing I have to say is that I could use a little more descriptive words with the places and characters. Also want to know more about the political rules and hierarchy. It would help to also have a clearer picture of the world Aeley lives in.
A Question of Counsel is definitely a diverse book to add to your to-read list. It’s a wonderful and exciting fantasy novel that is perfect any season.
February 10, 2017
This book is a quick paced book and although I started to guess the ending.
I enjoyed this book and it's twist.
We meet Aeley who takes over being a Tract Steward after her father passes.
Aeley is fine with being single and surrounded by what friends she does have whom she considers like family.
Although her father thought she would need help with someone by her side. He left in his will that she had to marry and not just marry anyone, marry someone from a family that are considered foe.
See this family blames Aeley for all of their families trouble. But she gives it a try and meets with two brothers.
With the villages near by having trouble and Aeley's brother in prison for crimes against people in villages, she decides to allow the the two brothers stay in her estate. All the while she is falling hard for Lira, her new Scribe. But can Aeley trust her and the others with everything going on?
Will Aeley uncover the secrets surrounding her before it's to late?
I enjoyed this book and it's twist.
We meet Aeley who takes over being a Tract Steward after her father passes.
Aeley is fine with being single and surrounded by what friends she does have whom she considers like family.
Although her father thought she would need help with someone by her side. He left in his will that she had to marry and not just marry anyone, marry someone from a family that are considered foe.
See this family blames Aeley for all of their families trouble. But she gives it a try and meets with two brothers.
With the villages near by having trouble and Aeley's brother in prison for crimes against people in villages, she decides to allow the the two brothers stay in her estate. All the while she is falling hard for Lira, her new Scribe. But can Aeley trust her and the others with everything going on?
Will Aeley uncover the secrets surrounding her before it's to late?
June 10, 2015
Rating: 3.5/5
From the summary alone, this novel checked all of the right boxes for me: a strong female main character in a position of power; struggles between responsibility and desire; incredibly hot sex between two incredibly hot ladies; and a fantastic, supportive best friend who isn't afraid to tell the main character the truth.
Aeley Dahe has been elected Steward after her father passes away, but she's not content with the role. People expect her to be just like her father, and the shame brought on her family after her brother's unforgivable actions means she has to work twice as hard to keep everyone satisfied.
But from the moment she lays eyes on Lira, a scribe hired to assist her legal advisor, she starts to see a light in the darkness. Lira helps to banish the nightmares, and her forthright way of speaking is a breath of fresh air to Aeley, who's used to people watching what they say around her.
Aeley was a difficult character for me to like at first. She's suffering under the weight of her title and the nightmares left by her brother, so she turns to drinking every night. It's not an ideal trait for a political figure, and it's only Mayr, Aeley's best friend, who saves her from falling into the trap of using alcohol to forget.
Read the rest of the review on Just Love @ Wordpress!
From the summary alone, this novel checked all of the right boxes for me: a strong female main character in a position of power; struggles between responsibility and desire; incredibly hot sex between two incredibly hot ladies; and a fantastic, supportive best friend who isn't afraid to tell the main character the truth.
Aeley Dahe has been elected Steward after her father passes away, but she's not content with the role. People expect her to be just like her father, and the shame brought on her family after her brother's unforgivable actions means she has to work twice as hard to keep everyone satisfied.
But from the moment she lays eyes on Lira, a scribe hired to assist her legal advisor, she starts to see a light in the darkness. Lira helps to banish the nightmares, and her forthright way of speaking is a breath of fresh air to Aeley, who's used to people watching what they say around her.
Aeley was a difficult character for me to like at first. She's suffering under the weight of her title and the nightmares left by her brother, so she turns to drinking every night. It's not an ideal trait for a political figure, and it's only Mayr, Aeley's best friend, who saves her from falling into the trap of using alcohol to forget.
Read the rest of the review on Just Love @ Wordpress!
April 24, 2016
Independent reviewer for Archaeolibrarian, I was gifted my copy of this book.
Aeley arrested him r brother and now as political leader of her people, she left alone and is lonely. A scribe, Lira, sparks her interest and sets off a chain of events that leads to Aeley being kidnapped to decide who she will marry and Lira ends up being a pawn in a much bigger game.
Are there previous books set in this world?? Because I'm left feeling I'm missing something. Something important. Something about the people, the world, the history, the back story. Don't get me wrong, what's here is good, I'm just left missing......Something.
It's also told entirely from Aeley's POV, in the third person. So while I noticed the single POV, it didn't bother me too Mich, but just enough for me to mention it.
I really liked Lira, and Aeley, how they grew together, until Lira decided to push Aeley. And she pushed beautifully! I loved that, while hot and steamy, it's not too explicit, it has just the right amount for this book. I did think, at one point, it was gonna be clean, but it's not :-)
It is, history and single POV aside, a very well written and well delivered story. I would like to read something longer by this author, longer than the 149 pages we have here.
4 stars
**same worded review will appear on Goodreads, Amazon.co.uk and Amazon.com**
Aeley arrested him r brother and now as political leader of her people, she left alone and is lonely. A scribe, Lira, sparks her interest and sets off a chain of events that leads to Aeley being kidnapped to decide who she will marry and Lira ends up being a pawn in a much bigger game.
Are there previous books set in this world?? Because I'm left feeling I'm missing something. Something important. Something about the people, the world, the history, the back story. Don't get me wrong, what's here is good, I'm just left missing......Something.
It's also told entirely from Aeley's POV, in the third person. So while I noticed the single POV, it didn't bother me too Mich, but just enough for me to mention it.
I really liked Lira, and Aeley, how they grew together, until Lira decided to push Aeley. And she pushed beautifully! I loved that, while hot and steamy, it's not too explicit, it has just the right amount for this book. I did think, at one point, it was gonna be clean, but it's not :-)
It is, history and single POV aside, a very well written and well delivered story. I would like to read something longer by this author, longer than the 149 pages we have here.
4 stars
**same worded review will appear on Goodreads, Amazon.co.uk and Amazon.com**
December 30, 2016
http://i869.photobucket.com/albums/ab...
A Question of Counsel was a good 4 star read.
Following the death of her father, Aeley becomes the leader of Kattal and is determined to prove that she is capable to take on the role. Her brother Allon is nothing but trouble and once behind bars he is even worse.
As mysterious attacks start to happen, Aeley needs to find out who is responsible. Aeley’s new scribe Lira is rather intriguing and Aeley is finding herself attracted to her. Can Aeley get rid of her demons and be the leader that her people need?
I really liked the plot of the story and the characters added a great element to the story as well. I really liked her best friend Mayr. We also see Aeley struggle with how to deal with everything.
There is suspense, kidnapping, steamy sex and two very strong women. I wouldn’t mind seeing a little more from Archer Kay Leah. I want to know more of the history
I voluntarily reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. Reviewed by MAustin from Alpha Book Club
May 30, 2015
fourstars
I receive this book from Inked.Rainbow Reads in return for an honest review.
A very enjoyable well written book. Exciting situations, strong female leads and believable plots and sub plots.
Blood family relations at their worst, friend family relations at their most powerful and inspirational.
A novel that has both leading women with commendable traits and beliefs while still possessing human failings. In a time when sexuality between couples depended on breeding, valour, bravery, honour and in this case love rather on gender.
Both women have very different personalities and upbringing, however, both have their own strengths and each compliments the others mettle as well as combatting and protecting each others weaknesses.
A novel that shows strength of family does not necessarily come those we are related too but a novel which emphasis the potency and ultimately the effectiveness of true love.
Anyone wanting a rich love story combined with devious subterfuge, a little light comedy, and ultimately a richly deserved happy ending should enjoy this book.
I was given this in return for an honest review by Inked Rainbow Reads.
~Chris
I receive this book from Inked.Rainbow Reads in return for an honest review.
A very enjoyable well written book. Exciting situations, strong female leads and believable plots and sub plots.
Blood family relations at their worst, friend family relations at their most powerful and inspirational.
A novel that has both leading women with commendable traits and beliefs while still possessing human failings. In a time when sexuality between couples depended on breeding, valour, bravery, honour and in this case love rather on gender.
Both women have very different personalities and upbringing, however, both have their own strengths and each compliments the others mettle as well as combatting and protecting each others weaknesses.
A novel that shows strength of family does not necessarily come those we are related too but a novel which emphasis the potency and ultimately the effectiveness of true love.
Anyone wanting a rich love story combined with devious subterfuge, a little light comedy, and ultimately a richly deserved happy ending should enjoy this book.
I was given this in return for an honest review by Inked Rainbow Reads.
~Chris
February 11, 2017
Book 1 of this series and what a start. I really enjoyed this story line and the characters are really easy to relate to. Can't wait to see what happens in the next book.
May 11, 2015
I receive this book from Inked.Rainbow Reads in return for an honest review.
A very enjoyable well written book. Exciting situations, strong female leads and believable plots and sub plots.
Blood family relations at their worst, friend family relations at their most powerful and inspirational.
A novel that has both leading women with commendable traits and beliefs while still possessing human failings. In a time when sexuality between couples depended on breeding, valour, bravery, honour and in this case love rather on gender.
Both women have very different personalities and upbringing, however, both have their own strengths and each compliments the others mettle as well as combatting and protecting each others weaknesses.
A novel that shows strength of family does not necessarily come those we are related too but a novel which emphasis the potency and ultimately the effectiveness of true love.
Anyone wanting a rich love story combined with devious subterfuge, a little light comedy, and ultimately a richly deserved happy ending should enjoy this book
A very enjoyable well written book. Exciting situations, strong female leads and believable plots and sub plots.
Blood family relations at their worst, friend family relations at their most powerful and inspirational.
A novel that has both leading women with commendable traits and beliefs while still possessing human failings. In a time when sexuality between couples depended on breeding, valour, bravery, honour and in this case love rather on gender.
Both women have very different personalities and upbringing, however, both have their own strengths and each compliments the others mettle as well as combatting and protecting each others weaknesses.
A novel that shows strength of family does not necessarily come those we are related too but a novel which emphasis the potency and ultimately the effectiveness of true love.
Anyone wanting a rich love story combined with devious subterfuge, a little light comedy, and ultimately a richly deserved happy ending should enjoy this book
April 26, 2016
Aeley’s father dies and she is appointed as Leader. Because of her brother’s misdeeds, she is forced by the court to marry someone not of her choosing to save him. When she meets her potential spouse, she realizes that his sister is the one of her fantasies and that being married into that family won’t be such a bad thing. But, Lira is a disgrace to her family and they are embarrassed by her and her actions.
A Question of Counsel was not what I expected, but it did leave me wanting to know more about the backstory and what will happen in the future. Aeley and Lira are both so different, yet complement each other well. The suspenseful part of the story and kidnapping had me on the edge of my seat and wanting to know what was going to happen right away. It was well written with the two very strong women who stand up for themselves and don’t cower to anyone unless those they love are in danger. There are a few details that left me confused, but overall it was a good story with strong heroines and a well-built world.
*Copy provided for review.
A Question of Counsel was not what I expected, but it did leave me wanting to know more about the backstory and what will happen in the future. Aeley and Lira are both so different, yet complement each other well. The suspenseful part of the story and kidnapping had me on the edge of my seat and wanting to know what was going to happen right away. It was well written with the two very strong women who stand up for themselves and don’t cower to anyone unless those they love are in danger. There are a few details that left me confused, but overall it was a good story with strong heroines and a well-built world.
*Copy provided for review.
Read
July 19, 2016Thanks for reading, everyone! If you enjoyed the story, there's a short prequel novella that goes into the events that took place before this book. For more of Aeley, Gren, and why Allon's stuck in prison, check out RULE BREAKER in the Won't Back Down anthology. >> https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2...
And a quick note on book #2, especially for those asking for his story: Mayr's book is coming September 7th, 2016! >> https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3... This boy's got secrets... and so does his heart's desire. It's on the longer side and only the beginning of his story. ^_^
And a quick note on book #2, especially for those asking for his story: Mayr's book is coming September 7th, 2016! >> https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3... This boy's got secrets... and so does his heart's desire. It's on the longer side and only the beginning of his story. ^_^
October 2, 2015
I was given an ARC book for an honest review free of persuasion from the author or anyone else affiliated with this book.
CONTAINS SOME SPOILERS
This book was very difficult for me. I had an extremely hard time getting into the book. I was confused from the get go. The world wasn't explained enough for me. Within the first chapter you meet so many characters, but nothing is explained with any depth as to who they are and what part they play of the politics. Aeley had to her arrest her brother. Why? What is her job within this world? All we really find out is that Aeley falls in love with a girl. We have a lesbian romance fantasy novella that left a lot to be desired.
CONTAINS SOME SPOILERS
This book was very difficult for me. I had an extremely hard time getting into the book. I was confused from the get go. The world wasn't explained enough for me. Within the first chapter you meet so many characters, but nothing is explained with any depth as to who they are and what part they play of the politics. Aeley had to her arrest her brother. Why? What is her job within this world? All we really find out is that Aeley falls in love with a girl. We have a lesbian romance fantasy novella that left a lot to be desired.
July 16, 2015
I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review when I signed up to host the book tour. I made no guarantee of a favorable review.
This was a good read with not one, but two strong female leads who are strong willed and not afraid of saying what needs to be said or doing what needs to be done. This fantasy book is well written with believable characters and contains sexual situations. The only thing lacking in this novella is that I found it to be way too short. I look forward to reading more of this author's books.
This was a good read with not one, but two strong female leads who are strong willed and not afraid of saying what needs to be said or doing what needs to be done. This fantasy book is well written with believable characters and contains sexual situations. The only thing lacking in this novella is that I found it to be way too short. I look forward to reading more of this author's books.
December 28, 2015
I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
4.5/5 or maybe 5.5/5
Okay funny story: It's Sunday and I have to go to the church on Sundays. I was reading this book before we has to go to church but I was just halfway through when we had to. THIS BOOK IS SO OMFG NEGOJQSNQBCEGBFWP. I felt so so so so... Okay, I can't stop thinking about this book. And this is just so snxbcgrhpeewn. And simply put, this isn't the kind of book the church will really support on me reading but whatever, I love this book.
**full review by 15th**
4.5/5 or maybe 5.5/5
Okay funny story: It's Sunday and I have to go to the church on Sundays. I was reading this book before we has to go to church but I was just halfway through when we had to. THIS BOOK IS SO OMFG NEGOJQSNQBCEGBFWP. I felt so so so so... Okay, I can't stop thinking about this book. And this is just so snxbcgrhpeewn. And simply put, this isn't the kind of book the church will really support on me reading but whatever, I love this book.
**full review by 15th**
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews