I chose to be the Primordial Dragon of Eternal Flames. They gave me a tadpole.
Kaito Mori was a programmer. He choked to death on an onigiri while reading an isekai. Classic.
When the reincarnation screen appeared, he picked the most powerful species in the Primordial Dragon of Eternal Flames. What nobody mentioned is that "primordial" means starting from zero. Half an ability, zero claws, and a 0.3% survival rate.
What he has going for a programmer's brain, enough sarcasm to irritate the universe, and 47 evolutionary stages ahead of him.
What he has going against everything else.
The Wrong Monster is a monster evolution LitRPG where the longest road is the one that goes furthest. For fans of Dungeon Crawler Carl, Chrysalis, and Systems that have way too many opinions about your life choices.
I was excited for the premise of this book and while the beginning was interesting, the whole book is very one note. I mostly skimmed the last third of the book. The MC was, allegedly, human in his last life, but reads like he was a computer, intelligent in a completely emotionless, inhuman way. I thought the emotionless bit would be an initial defense mechanism to the shock of his transition to his new species, but no, it persists throughout the whole book. There is no character development. The writing of the MC is very robotic in contrast to other human characters, so this is a stylistic choice, not the author's voice. The world is interesting, if a little generic. The System's presence is inconsistently present in the writing, which is a faux pax for the genre.
Overall, I love the idea behind this book. It’s fascinating in a way a lot of monster evolution litRPGs aren’t, but it was a struggle to read. I don’t know if the author used an LLM or not in the writing or maybe translation, but it reads as if he did. There are also a number of inconsistencies, like calling 10/47 one tenth, or forgetting the previous range of an ability was 20 and calling the previous range 10, things like that. A lot of repetition, as well, and it honestly reads like what you would get if you tried to edit together a series of prompts in ChatGPT. Not to mention once referring to the male main character with “her” instead of “his” which, unfortunately, lends credence to the possibility of this being written with heavy AI assistance at the least. I don’t believe I’ll be continuing with this series whenever the next book comes out.
This was a DNF for me unfortunately. I like the concept of where it was going, and the world building seemed interesting.
This one was the writing that left me unable to continue in the first third of the book It seemed like every other sentence reminded me that the MC was previous a programmer. This is fine for setting the scene originally, but eventually it would have been nice if the author just switched up how they referenced it? Instead of "...because I was a programmer" for why they did something logical, or wanted to collate data instead shifted eventually to "was nice to use my logic skills in a new way to figure out where best to hunt for *insert monster here*"
This probably works well for some, just wasn't for me.
Soooooooo friggintastic! Believe You/Me you hafta read this book!
I love ❤ this book! I'm always a sucker for when Kaito, the MC is Isekaied and Reborn into som'min that's not human. Whether it be an Ant 🐜, a Dragon🐉, or even a lowly Tadpole, a Null Spawn. It's som'min so foreign, far different from his day job as a computer programmer, and som'min Kaito has'ta deal with quickly if he wants to survive, to see the Dawning Sunrise tomorrow! 🌅 The class he chose had 47 evolutions before reaching It's final destination, The Primordial Dragon of the Eternal Flame. Who has time for reading the fine the fine print, it sounded strong so that's what grabbed... but 47 evolutions, that's a lotta grinding and fighting! Though it's som'min that his programming brains aren't afraid of doin. And that will require a lotta planning too. So yeah, grab the book, and you to can follow Kaito while he'sa grinding in this action-packed litRPG adventure.
Here's a quote:
"This is like choosing between Squirtle and Charmander. Except there's no save point.
This was an interesting read. The writer shows a lot of promise, the writing is fluid, and I got engrossed in reading the book, so I finished it in 1 day. Though it is clear that this is a novice writer, and he got himself locked into a single way of doing combat encounters - that while great the first 2-3 times, became repetitive to read after that.
I got the book for free from the writers' publicity post on reddit, where I and other LITRPG enthusiast had the chance to discuss improvements with him, which he seemed very receptive to. I look forward to his next book which I intend to buy based on this first one.
Nothing that hasn’t been done repeatedly in the genre already, the same stats change inexplicably from one page to the next without anything having changes, revelations from previous pages are brought up again as though they’re new revelations the MC didn’t just spend pages talking about, the MC’s narration/thoughts are as repetitive as someone trying to write a 20 page paper 10 minutes before it’s due, and the “programmer” flavor almost always feels extremely shoehorned.
A quick read, clever world building and a simple formula. No lengthy cultivation scenes, no insurmountable battles won with last minute skill evolutions or system assistances, no void steps or Scottish dwarves.
Just simple tenacious and well written scenes. CANT wait for book 2
A decent monster evolution type novel. More pros then cons, though you can definitely get a feel of the Author's flavor of Tism. Dude is obsessed with size descriptions and repeating those numbers. If the author can get a handle on his tendency towards repeating himself, then it could be a good series
Book was basically 5 chapters long. The rest of the book was him repeating the same basic information/programmer lines 9 different ways back to back. Lots of programmer jargon fluff. Take all of that out and you could have had a great first quarter of a novel. I don't think I'll be reading anymore in this series...
The first chapter is so awkwardly written and disconnected from the reality of the character's situation. Excessive and repeating prose to the point that there is more prose and rhetoric than actual events or writing in it. You can tell there's not much human writing here.
Good premise, but seems to be written by AI. Every paragraph ends with a climax, then the next starts and ends on the same pattern. The references to a developer's life are very shallow too, like the author felt obligted to add them, just because that's the book premise. Very sad
A fun and funny evolution read. This felt really short even though it is not,I blew through it in a weekend, the story just flows really well. Very light on the litrpg elements which is usually a bummer for me but it mostly works here. Looking forward to the next one!
Author changes events and is repetitive may be AI. Fell asleep while reading multiple times. If had an editor to fix events and remove repetitivness may be readable.
How clear the different steps were. The fear of a tadpole to the other sizes. This would be good for kids that would learn that life is not one size fits all. The writing style pleases me, explaining and being entertaining.
Very enjoyable read with good humor. I like the progression and the use of strategy rather than overpowered stats. I also appreciate a reincarnation where the mc doesn’t immediately forget their past and it’s never mentioned again except for food.
Ai generated, would I preferred if it was just an AI character at this point. It didn’t feel like a human or a dragon was narrating. It just felt like a robot.