What do you think?
Rate this book
Broken Plea: The Explosive Search for Truth Behind the Idaho Murders
Was there more than one killer? Had the crime scene been cleaned and sanitized before the police arrived? Was furniture staged to throw off detectives? In one of the most extraordinary true crime stories ever published, Broken Plea questions what really happened in the house on King Road—and the results of that investigation will astound you.
In the early morning hours of November 13, 2022, four lives were lost in a brutal crime in Moscow, Idaho—and a nation demanded answers. When a suspect accepted a plea bargain, the story seemed settled. Justice, many believed, had been served.
Broken Plea challenges that assumption.
Drawing on court records, investigative timelines, witness statements, and apparently overlooked inconsistencies, this meticulously researched exposé examines how a rush to judgment may have shaped one of the most closely watched murder cases in recent memory. As the official narrative hardened, critical leads went unexplored, contradictory evidence was minimized, and alternative explanations faded from view.
This book does not claim certainty where none exists. Instead, it asks the questions that were never fully What happens when pressure to close a case outweighs the search for truth? What evidence may have been sidelined, and why? And what are the consequences when a plea doesn’t end scrutiny but invites it?
Clear-eyed, unsparing, and deeply unsettling, Broken Plea reopens the case—and invites readers to look again at what justice demands when the truth remains unresolved.
In the early morning hours of November 13, 2022, four lives were lost in a brutal crime in Moscow, Idaho—and a nation demanded answers. When a suspect accepted a plea bargain, the story seemed settled. Justice, many believed, had been served.
Broken Plea challenges that assumption.
Drawing on court records, investigative timelines, witness statements, and apparently overlooked inconsistencies, this meticulously researched exposé examines how a rush to judgment may have shaped one of the most closely watched murder cases in recent memory. As the official narrative hardened, critical leads went unexplored, contradictory evidence was minimized, and alternative explanations faded from view.
This book does not claim certainty where none exists. Instead, it asks the questions that were never fully What happens when pressure to close a case outweighs the search for truth? What evidence may have been sidelined, and why? And what are the consequences when a plea doesn’t end scrutiny but invites it?
Clear-eyed, unsparing, and deeply unsettling, Broken Plea reopens the case—and invites readers to look again at what justice demands when the truth remains unresolved.
- GenresNonfictionTrue Crime
443 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 28, 2026
About the author
Christopher Whitcomb
12 books58 followersHis three books have been released by major publishers and well reviewed. You can find some details about him here:
http://www.bookreporter.com/authors/a...
http://www.bookreporter.com/authors/a...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews
April 29, 2026
Very compelling
This book makes a very disturbingly compelling argument that the prosecution had no case and knew it, so they railroaded Kohlberger into pleading guilty to a crime that was impossible for one man to commit.
It's disturbing that he pledged guilty when there was no evidence at all that he had anything to do with the crimes.
The prosecutions case fell to pieces and next thing you know, the suspect was pleading guilty.
It makes you wonder if we even have a system of justice anymore.
Maybe we do. Maybe this was a one time screwup. I hope so.
This book makes a very disturbingly compelling argument that the prosecution had no case and knew it, so they railroaded Kohlberger into pleading guilty to a crime that was impossible for one man to commit.
It's disturbing that he pledged guilty when there was no evidence at all that he had anything to do with the crimes.
The prosecutions case fell to pieces and next thing you know, the suspect was pleading guilty.
It makes you wonder if we even have a system of justice anymore.
Maybe we do. Maybe this was a one time screwup. I hope so.
May 2, 2026
great read
Interesting read. Provided some insight and another opinion to consider and dig into. I would recommend this to others to read to learn about parts of the case we haven’t seen or interpret differently
Interesting read. Provided some insight and another opinion to consider and dig into. I would recommend this to others to read to learn about parts of the case we haven’t seen or interpret differently
May 6, 2026
I truly cannot express how much this book changed my thought process. It will live free in my head for the rest of my life. Amazing is all I can say.
Read
May 2, 2026Shocking revelations
This author did an excellent job at telling the story without adding unnecessary extras. We were given facts, opinions and unknown surprises that had been locked away until now.
This author did an excellent job at telling the story without adding unnecessary extras. We were given facts, opinions and unknown surprises that had been locked away until now.
May 5, 2026
Not a fan at all of this one. Brought up a couple of interesting points but besides that spread a lot of false information, and got a lot of basic facts on the case/about the victims wrong.
May 6, 2026
Broken Plea is an Understatement
This book has laid out all the “evidence” or lack there of. If I were on the jury, based on the “evidence”, my decision would have been innocent. How on earth the prosecution, police department and FBI sleep at night is beyond me. There seems to be a major clean up of this horrific crime. From those in the home from 2am to noon to all law enforcement. I understand the university needed this to go away. Who in their right mind would keep their child at a University that produces four lost lives?
My opinion will always be for his innocence and the guilt on those that are obvious to all with a brain. This type of rage comes from hatred, jealousy, and disgust. The victims knew their monsters. It wasn’t random.
This book has laid out all the “evidence” or lack there of. If I were on the jury, based on the “evidence”, my decision would have been innocent. How on earth the prosecution, police department and FBI sleep at night is beyond me. There seems to be a major clean up of this horrific crime. From those in the home from 2am to noon to all law enforcement. I understand the university needed this to go away. Who in their right mind would keep their child at a University that produces four lost lives?
My opinion will always be for his innocence and the guilt on those that are obvious to all with a brain. This type of rage comes from hatred, jealousy, and disgust. The victims knew their monsters. It wasn’t random.
May 4, 2026
i’ve been following this book a long time and looking at both sides, idk, if i was on a jury idk if i would find him guilty beyond reasonable doubt. the scene being mishandled….and i just don’t get how none of his dna was found except on the button snap which was touch dna & not actual. this book brings a good argument to this table. hoping for justice for maddie, kaylee, ethan, and xana
April 30, 2026
I genuinely don’t know who keeps handing this man book deals, but hopefully this is the last time I waste even a fraction of my attention on one of his embarrassingly transparent cash grabs. At this point, his reputation is so consistently awful it should honestly be studied. It’s almost impressive how someone can repeatedly package absolute nonsense, slap a cover on it, and still find enablers willing to stand behind him like this is literary genius instead of opportunistic garbage.
This latest disaster, though? Easily the most pathetic yet. Not because it’s shocking, but because it reeks of desperation so intensely it’s practically dripping off the pages. Even worse, he appears willing to exploit people’s deaths for profit while shamelessly alluding that surviving victims are somehow complicit or involved, which is not only grotesque but an entirely new low, even for someone already scraping the bottom of public credibility. Apparently, his own personal drama wasn’t enough to keep people interested, so naturally, he resorted to exploiting the lives of others with fabricated narratives just to squeeze out a little more attention and money. How original.
It takes a truly remarkable lack of integrity to build relevance off distortion, manipulation, and outright fiction. But I suppose when talent and credibility are in short supply, manufacturing controversy is the next best option. Truly bottom-of-the-barrel behavior.
Harper’s Select lost credibility with this one
This latest disaster, though? Easily the most pathetic yet. Not because it’s shocking, but because it reeks of desperation so intensely it’s practically dripping off the pages. Even worse, he appears willing to exploit people’s deaths for profit while shamelessly alluding that surviving victims are somehow complicit or involved, which is not only grotesque but an entirely new low, even for someone already scraping the bottom of public credibility. Apparently, his own personal drama wasn’t enough to keep people interested, so naturally, he resorted to exploiting the lives of others with fabricated narratives just to squeeze out a little more attention and money. How original.
It takes a truly remarkable lack of integrity to build relevance off distortion, manipulation, and outright fiction. But I suppose when talent and credibility are in short supply, manufacturing controversy is the next best option. Truly bottom-of-the-barrel behavior.
Harper’s Select lost credibility with this one
April 29, 2026
A more comprehensive review is coming but just for now: bc I’ve been reading for the past 9 hrs and I’m tired.
Some serious issues with this book, but just WOW! I’ve seen (read) and heard (listened) to all the recent FOIA files (still waiting for the rest) so I already believe KB did not do this.. but this book is quite boring and technical .. I feel most will have a hard time understanding everything. Or just miss half the points because they’re so bored. If you heard the screams coming from that house from the cameras, you would know it was not a quiet night in Moscow. It was a horrific night. The states evidence doesn’t make any sense. But if you’re going to write a book about these victims LEARN TO PRONOUNCE their names. There was also several typing errors. But there’s important and accurate information in this book, facts that can’t be ignored. There’s also some wrong info too. Good book, wrong author.
51 tb of Brady disclosure 😱😳
There is some wrong information in this book - which is highly annoying because …. Jack WAS the one and ONLY SUSPECT from the official reports I’ve seen. Way before BK. So saying he was never a suspect is wrong. Unless your police reports are wrong … but yall did have him sitting in the back of that police car for a bit.
Some serious issues with this book, but just WOW! I’ve seen (read) and heard (listened) to all the recent FOIA files (still waiting for the rest) so I already believe KB did not do this.. but this book is quite boring and technical .. I feel most will have a hard time understanding everything. Or just miss half the points because they’re so bored. If you heard the screams coming from that house from the cameras, you would know it was not a quiet night in Moscow. It was a horrific night. The states evidence doesn’t make any sense. But if you’re going to write a book about these victims LEARN TO PRONOUNCE their names. There was also several typing errors. But there’s important and accurate information in this book, facts that can’t be ignored. There’s also some wrong info too. Good book, wrong author.
51 tb of Brady disclosure 😱😳
There is some wrong information in this book - which is highly annoying because …. Jack WAS the one and ONLY SUSPECT from the official reports I’ve seen. Way before BK. So saying he was never a suspect is wrong. Unless your police reports are wrong … but yall did have him sitting in the back of that police car for a bit.
May 1, 2026
🎧4.5🌟 I need to make it very clear I am not pro-Bryan but I am pro-justice for everyone involved and this case just doesn't make any sense.
I've followed this case from the beginning; it's like my JFK or another 9/11. I remember the early news reports of the neighbor clearly stating the front door was open. I remember the posted then 'quickly wiped from Internet' photos of the friend group huddling in blankets while the cops were first on scene.
There's way too many unanswered questions in this case for it to be swept under the rug with a plea deal. I have to admit the revelation from AT at the end was frustrating. I was hoping to get some answers but all I have are more questions including the huge WHY DID HE PLEA.
I've followed this case from the beginning; it's like my JFK or another 9/11. I remember the early news reports of the neighbor clearly stating the front door was open. I remember the posted then 'quickly wiped from Internet' photos of the friend group huddling in blankets while the cops were first on scene.
There's way too many unanswered questions in this case for it to be swept under the rug with a plea deal. I have to admit the revelation from AT at the end was frustrating. I was hoping to get some answers but all I have are more questions including the huge WHY DID HE PLEA.
April 28, 2026
Just finished, and it was a solid true crime read. It walks through the case in a clear way and keeps you interested without feeling overly complicated. I liked how it covered different angles and didn’t just stick to one perspective.
It does leave you with some unanswered questions, but that honestly adds to the realism. Not everything gets tied up perfectly in real life, and the book reflects that.
Overall, a good pick if you’re into true crime and want something engaging but easy to follow.
It does leave you with some unanswered questions, but that honestly adds to the realism. Not everything gets tied up perfectly in real life, and the book reflects that.
Overall, a good pick if you’re into true crime and want something engaging but easy to follow.
May 9, 2026
As an avid follower of this case I’m shocked in the amount of evidence that wasn’t brought forward or was but disregarded. I really wish this case would have gone to trial.
Rest in peace to Xana, Kaylee, Maddie, and Ethan. I hope the truth is revealed in time.
Thank you to the brave author and everyone who came forward with the discrepancies that filled this case.
Rest in peace to Xana, Kaylee, Maddie, and Ethan. I hope the truth is revealed in time.
Thank you to the brave author and everyone who came forward with the discrepancies that filled this case.
May 12, 2026
Obsessed with this case and this book. So interesting..
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews